On the evolution of protamines in bony Fish: Alternatives to the “Retroviral horizontal transmission” hypothesis

Fish protamines are highly specialized molecules which are responsible for chromatin condensation during the last stages of spermatogenesis (spermiogenesis). However, not all fish contain protamines in their sperm nuclei; rather, there seems to be a random distribution of protamines within this group. The origin of this sporadic presence of protamines in the sperm and its significance have not yet been precisely determined. In this paper we have conducted an exhaustive survey of the literature available on the different types of nuclear protein composition of the sperm of teleost fish in order to try to correlate these data with what is presently known about the taxonomy of this group. The results of this analysis have allowed us to make the following observations. The divergence between protamines and histones has occurred several times during the evolution of the bony fish. However, the relative frequency of this divergence is almost negligible during the differentiation of genera and species (intrafamily variation) and is very small during the differentiation of families (interfamily variation). Nevertheless, the divergence is very noticeable among the different orders. It is therefore possible to conclude from all this that the sporadic distribution of protamines in bony fish is not a random event as initially believed. Furthermore, such a heterogeneous distribution of protamines cannot be easily accounted for by a mechanism of horizontal retroviral transmission through repeated and independent acquisition of a prot amine gene as has been recently proposed (Jankowski, Stater, Dixon (1986) J Mol Evol 23:1–10). Rather, it could possibly be explained by a repeated and independent loss of the expression of the protamine gene (or loss of the gene itself) which mainly occurred during the diversification of the orders of this group.Correspondence to: J. Ausio     

The binding mode of a mammalian (boar) protamine to DNA

The binding modes of mammalian and fish protamines to DNA were studied by reconstitution experiments from dansylated protamines and DNA, using fluorescence spectroscopy, thermal denaturation and sedimentation. Both boar and fish protamines showed strong positive cooperativity in binding to DNA. Binding parameters of the protamines were determined in 0.1 M NaCl, 50 mM Tricine-HCl, pH 7.4, at 37 degrees C: in the boar protamine, the cooperative binding constant (Kc) = 3.4 X 10(6) M-1 and the cooperative factor (q) = 667, in the fish protamine, Kc = 1.8 X 10(7) M-1 and q = 304. The boar protamines bound to DNA with two functional domains, but the fish protamines bound directly to DNA as a single linear molecule.     

Protamine 3 shows evidence of weak, positive selection in mouse species (genus Mus)--but it is not a protamine

Protamines are short and highly basic sperm-specific nuclear proteins that replace somatic histones during spermiogenesis in a process that is crucial for sperm formation and function. Many mammals have two protamine genes (PRM1 and PRM2) located in a gene cluster, which appears to evolve fast. Another gene in this cluster (designated protamine 3 [PRM3]) encodes a protein that is conserved among mammals but that does not seem to be involved in chromatin condensation. We have compared protein sequences and amino acid compositions of protamines in this gene cluster, searched for evidence of positive selection of PRM3, and examined whether sexual selection (sperm competition) may drive the evolution of the PRM3 gene. Nucleotide and amino acid analyses of mouse sequences revealed that PRM3 was very different from PRM1 and from both the precursor and the mature sequences of PRM2. Among 10 mouse species, PRM3 showed weak evidence of positive selection in two species, but there was no clear association with levels of sperm competition. In analyses from among mammalian species, no evidence of positive selection was found in PRM3. We conclude that PRM3 exhibits several clear differences from other protamines and, furthermore, that it cannot be regarded as a true protamine.     

Sperm nuclear basic proteins of two closely related species of Scorpaeniform fish (Sebastes maliger, Sebastolobus sp.) with different sexual reproduction and the evolution of fish protamines

In this paper, we present a review of sperm nuclear basic proteins (SNBPs) in teleost fish. The distribution of the three basic groups of SNBPs [histone (H)-type, protamine-like (PL)-type and protamine (P)-type], their evolution and possible relation to the mode of fertilization are described. In this regard, we have characterized the SNBPs from two closely related species of Scorpaeniform fish: internally fertilizing Sebastes maliger and externally fertilizing Sebastolobus sp., both in the family Scorpaenidae. Despite the different reproductive behavior of these two closely related rockfish species, in both instances the SNBP consists of protamines. However, there is a significant increase in the arginine content of the protamine in the internally fertilizing rockfish. The relevance of this observation is discussed within the context of the P-type SNBP in teleosts. The rapid evolution of teleost protamines, including those in rockfish, has also allowed us to obtain a molecular phylogeny for this group of bony fish that is almost indistinguishable from that currently available from the use of conventional anatomical/paleontological markers.     

Protein and DNA contents in sperm from an infertile human male possessing protamine defects that vary over time

Sperm from 2 semen samples collected 6 months apart from an infertile male and 3 semen samples collected over an 18-month period from a fertile human male volunteer have been analyzed for their protamine and DNA content. Hup1M and Hup2b antibodies were used to detect the presence of protamines and protamine precursors in western blots of nuclear proteins isolated from pools of sperm. Phosphorus and sulfur contents, which can be used to estimate the nuclear DNA and protamine contents of sperm from fertile males, were measured within individual sperm heads from each semen sample by particle induced x-ray emission (PIXE). The single-cell data reveal no significant differences in the phosphorus and sulfur contents of sperm heads in the three semen samples obtained from the fertile male. For the initial semen sample produced by the infertile male, Western blot data show a normal complement of protamine 1, small amounts of mature protamine 2, and reveal large amounts of anti-protamine 2 reactive proteins with electrophoretic mobilities similar to protamine 2 precursors. Data from PIXE show elevated levels of sulfur within sperm heads compared with sperm from the fertile male. Western blot data exhibit no evidence of protamines or protamine 2 precursors in the second semen sample produced by the infertile male. Data from PIXE suggest that these sperm are highly deficient in sulfur and protamines. These results show that the degree of maturation of sperm cells present in the semen of some infertile males can vary with time. Mol. Reprod. Dev. 50:345–353, 1998. Published 1998 Wiley-Liss, Inc.

1 This article is a US Government work and, as such, is in the public domain in the United States of America.

     

Primary structure of rabbit sperm protamine, the first protamine of its type with an aberrant N-terminal

Rabbit protamine was extracted from S-(pyridylethylated) sperm cell nuclei with hydrochloric acid and then isolated by reversed-phase HPLC. The primary structure was determined by amino acid sequence analysis of the total protein and of fragments obtained by digestion with endoproteinase Lys-C and thermolysin. The protamine contains 49 amino acid residues and is clearly homologous with mammalian type 1 protamines, 47% of the positions being invariant. Surprisingly, rabbit protamine possesses an N-terminal valine residue, whereas all mammalian and several non-mammalian protamine sequences of this type start with alanine, the N-terminal region being remarkably conserved during evolution.     

Vertebrate protamine gene evolution I. Sequence alignments and gene structure

Summary The availability of the amino acid sequence for nine different mammalian P1 family protamines and the revised amino acid sequence of the chicken protamine galline (Oliva and Dixon 1989) reveals a much close relationship between mammalian and avian protamines than was previously thought (Nakano et al. 1976). Dot matrix analysis of all protamine genes for which genomic DNA or cDNA sequence is available reveals both marked sequence similarities in the mammalian protamine gene family and internal repeated sequences in the chicken protamine gene. The detailed alignments of the cis-acting regulatory DNA sequences shows several consensus sequence patterns, particularly the conservation of a cAMP response element (CRE) in all the protamine genes and of the regions flanking the TATA box, CAP site, N-terminal coding region, and polyadenylation signal. In addition we have found a high frequency of the CA dinucleotide immediately adjacent to the CRE element of both the protamine genes and the testis transition proteins, a feature not present in other genes, which suggests the existence of an extended CRE motif involved in the coordinate expression of protamine and transition protein genes during spermatogenesis. Overall these findings suggest the existence of an avian-mammalian P1 protamine gene line and are discussed in the context of different hypotheses for protamine gene evolution and regulation.     

Identifying reproductive events using archival tags: egg‐laying behaviour of the small spotted catshark Scyliorhinus canicula

The use of archival depth telemetry as a means of remotely assessing the reproductive rates of free‐ranging fishes is explored. This is achieved by electronically tracking the vertical movements of individual female small spotted catsharks Scyliorhinus canicula in the natural environment, whilst simultaneously evaluating the temporal and vertical distributions of egg‐laying in this species. Distinctive patterns of short‐term (0·3–3·7 h), shallow‐water activity are documented in the time–depth profiles of female S. canicula that occur at an appropriate depth (1·0–2·3 m) and periodicity (every 10–12 days) to represent egg‐laying behaviour. Putative egg‐laying behaviour was exhibited simultaneously by two individually tracked female S. canicula during late‐spring and early‐summer. The results highlight that, provided species behaviour is suitable and complementary methods such as previous data, laboratory experiments and field surveys can be used to validate the patterns observed, archival depth telemetry offers an unobtrusive means by which egg production and egg‐laying behaviour of free‐living fishes can be estimated. As precise information regarding life‐history parameters is difficult to obtain for free‐ranging fish species, this technique could be used to improve the parameterization of species demographic models that are relevant to the management of wild fish populations.     

Sperm Nuclear Basic Proteins (SNBPs) of Agnathans and Chondrichthyans: Variability and Evolution of Sperm Proteins in Fish

We have characterized for the first time SNBPs from the hagfish Eptatratus stouti (Myxini) and the lamprey Lampetra tridentatus (Cephalaspidomorphi) and have found that histones are the major protein components of the sperm of these agnathans. We have also conducted a systematic analysis of SNBPs from different groups of chondrichthyan fishes, including the skate Raja rhina and seven species of sharks. Together with our previous data showing the sporadic nature of SNBP evolution in bony fish (Saperas, N., Ausio, J., Lloris, D. and Chiva, M. [1994] J. Mol. Evol. 39: 282–295), the present study provides a unique insight into the overall evolutionary complexity and variability of the nuclear sperm proteins of fishes. It would appear that despite the discontinuous evolution of these proteins, the macroevolutionary pattern of histone (H type) → protamine-like (PL type) → protamine (P type) has been conserved in fish evolution, as it has in the evolution of other Deuterostomes. Received: 11 June 1996 / Accepted: 6 August 1996     

Secondary structure of protamine in sperm nuclei: an infrared spectroscopy study

Background  

Protamines are small basic proteins that condense the DNA in mature spermatozoa. Typical protamines are of simple composition and very arginine-rich, usually in the range of 60-80%. Arginine residues are distributed in a number of stretches separated by neutral amino acids. We have used Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy (FTIR) to gain access for the first time to the secondary structure of protamines in sperm nuclei. This technique is particularly well suited to the study of DNA-bound protamine in whole nuclei since it is not affected by turbidity.     

Sexual selection halts the relaxation of protamine 2 among rodents

Sexual selection has been proposed as the driving force promoting the rapid evolutionary changes observed in some reproductive genes including protamines. We test this hypothesis in a group of rodents which show marked differences in the intensity of sexual selection. Levels of sperm competition were not associated with the evolutionary rates of protamine 1 but, contrary to expectations, were negatively related to the evolutionary rate of cleaved- and mature-protamine 2. Since both domains were found to be under relaxation, our findings reveal an unforeseen role of sexual selection: to halt the degree of degeneration that proteins within families may experience due to functional redundancy. The degree of relaxation of protamine 2 in this group of rodents is such that in some species it has become dysfunctional and it is not expressed in mature spermatozoa. In contrast, protamine 1 is functionally conserved but shows directed positive selection on specific sites which are functionally relevant such as DNA-anchoring domains and phosphorylation sites. We conclude that in rodents protamine 2 is under relaxation and that sexual selection removes deleterious mutations among species with high levels of sperm competition to maintain the protein functional and the spermatozoa competitive.     

The evolution of protamine P1 genes in dasyurid marsupials

We report the complete DNA sequences of the protamine P1 gene and flanking regions for 13 species of the marsupial family Dasyuridae. The structure of the protamine locus is conserved in dasyurids and consists of two exons (of lengths 142–151 and 47 bp) separated by an intron (208–240 bp). A key feature of the dasyund intron is a 38–40 by duplication found in all species examined to date. This duplication apparently predates the radiation of modern dasyurid lineages and may be homologous to a similar feature in the marsupial mole (Notoryctes). Sequences from a species of Planigale demonstrate that this genus is unique among marsupials in possessing cysteine residues in its protamine P1 molecules. Cysteines may provide enhanced chemical stability for condensed sperm nuclei, a physiological feature that would converge on the common eutherian pattern. Phylogenetic analysis of the protamine genes yields a tree that is largely congruent with previous molecular systematic studies in two areas: (1) There are three main dasyurid lineages corresponding to the Sminthopsinae, Dasyurinae, and Phascogalinae; (2) Dasyurinae and Phascogalinae are sister groups. This study is the first estimate of dasyurid relationships based on a nuclear DNA sequence. Correspondence to: J.D. Retief     

Sequence analysis and structural features of the largest known protamine isolated from the sperm of the archaeogastropod Monodonta turbinata

Protamine of the archaeogastropod mollusc Monodonta turbinata has been isolated and characterized. With a mass of 13,476 Da, it is the largest known prolamine. Amino acid sequence of this protamine (106 residues) was established from data provided by automated sequence analysis and mass spectrometry of the protein and of its fragments. The primary structure of the NH₂-terminal region exhibits repetitive sequence motifs Basic-Ser (mainly R-S) and both central and COOH-terminal regions are composed by arginine clusters. The amino acid sequence of Monodonta turbinata protamine shows structural similarities with other protamines from invertebrates and from birds and mammals.     

Electrophoretic analysis of nuclear proteins isolated from sperm of the black abalone Haliotis crackeroidii

Nuclear proteins isolated from spermatozoa of the abalone, Haliotis crackeroidii, after sonication and CTAB treatment were characterized electrophoretically. Mature, sonication-resistant sperm nuclei contain only protamine and lack detectable levels of somatic histone. The amino acid composition and size of this protamine suggests that its structure must be intermediate between fish and mammalian protamines.     

Enhancement of transfection efficiency by protamine in DDAB lipid vesicle-mediated gene transfer.

We have previously developed a simple gene transfection procedure mediated by cationic lipid vesicles for animal cells, in which a commercially available cationic surfactant, dimethyldioctadecyl ammonium bromide (DDAB), was used for making lipid vesicles. In the present study, we examined enhancement of transfection efficiency for this method by adding protamine to plasmid DNA solution before the formation of DNA/lipid vesicle complexes. Both free-base protamine and protamine sulfate provided enhanced transfection efficiency and expression level, but the optimal amount of the two protamines was different. The enhancement in transfection efficiency and expression level by protamines was observed in all the cell lines (COS-7, Hela, NIH3T3, MDCK, and BHK-21C13) and all the plasmids (pCMVbeta, pmiwZ, and pCH110) tested. The enhancement in both transfection efficiency and expression level was at most 20-fold compared with that using only DDAB lipid vesicles. Protamines seemed to protect DNA from degradation by DNase and promote DNA delivery into a nucleus.     

Sexual selection drives weak positive selection in protamine genes and high promoter divergence,enhancing sperm competitiveness

Phenotypic adaptations may be the result of changes in gene structure or gene regulation, but little is known about the evolution of gene expression. In addition, it is unclear whether the same selective forces may operate at both levels simultaneously. Reproductive proteins evolve rapidly, but the underlying selective forces promoting such rapid changes are still a matter of debate. In particular, the role of sexual selection in driving positive selection among reproductive proteins remains controversial, whereas its potential influence on changes in promoter regions has not been explored. Protamines are responsible for maintaining DNA in a compacted form in chromosomes in sperm and the available evidence suggests that they evolve rapidly. Because protamines condense DNA within the sperm nucleus, they influence sperm head shape. Here, we examine the influence of sperm competition upon protamine 1 and protamine 2 genes and their promoters, by comparing closely related species of Mus that differ in relative testes size, a reliable indicator of levels of sperm competition. We find evidence of positive selection in the protamine 2 gene in the species with the highest inferred levels of sperm competition. In addition, sperm competition levels across all species are strongly associated with high divergence in protamine 2 promoters that, in turn, are associated with sperm swimming speed. We suggest that changes in protamine 2 promoters are likely to enhance sperm swimming speed by making sperm heads more hydrodynamic. Such phenotypic changes are adaptive because sperm swimming speed may be a major determinant of fertilization success under sperm competition. Thus, when species have diverged recently, few changes in gene-coding sequences are found, while high divergence in promoters seems to be associated with the intensity of sexual selection.     

Convergent evolution of cysteine residues in sperm protamines of one genus of marsupials, the Planigales

A characteristic feature of the sperm P1 protamines of eutherian mammals is the constant presence of six to nine cysteine residues per molecule. During spermiogenesis these residues become oxidized to form a three-dimensional network of disulfide bridges between, and within, protamine molecules in the sperm chromatin. This covalent cross linking strongly stabilizes eutherian sperm nuclei. In contrast, protamines sequenced from teleost fish, birds, monotremes, and marsupials all lack cysteine residues and their sperm nuclei, without the stabilizing cross links, are easily decondensed in vitro. We have now found that one genus of tiny, shrewlike dasyurid marsupials, the Planigales, possess P1 protamines containing five to six cysteine residues. These residues appear to have evolved since the divergence of Planigales from other members of the family Dasyuridae, such as the marsupial mouse, Sminthopsis crassicaudata. We believe this constitutes a case of convergent evolution in a subfamily of dasyurid marsupials toward the cysteine-rich eutherian form of sperm protamine P1.      

Sexual dimorphisms in the dermal structure of the lesser‐spotted catshark,Scyliorhinus canicula (Linnaeus, 1758)

Sexual dimorphisms in the dermal structures of two elasmobranch species have previously been reported and it has been linked to the use of the mouth by males during copulation. Until relatively recently, the fact, that male Scyliorhinus canicula use their mouths for grasping and biting females during copulation was unknown. This study reveals that not only do adult (M ≥ 525 mm, F ≥ 550 mm) S. canicula show a sexual dimorphism in the epidermis and dermis, but that hatchling S. canicula are born with a sexually dimorphic epidermal layer and this persists into the juvenile stage (M < 525 mm, F < 550 mm). A sexual dimorphism was found in all size classes with both hatchling and juvenile female S. canicula having significantly thicker epidermal layers than hatchling and juvenile male S. canicula. Adult female S. canicula were found to possess both a significantly thicker epidermal and dermal layer than adult male S. canicula. The presence of a sexual dimorphism in the epidermal and dermal layers of adult S. canicula could be directly related to reproductive behaviour in response to the male biting the female prior to copulation.