Primary charge separation in Photosystem II

In this Minireview, we discuss a number of issues on the primary photosynthetic reactions of the green plant Photosystem II. We discuss the origin of the 683 and 679 nm absorption bands of the PS II RC complex and suggest that these forms may reflect the single-site spectrum with dominant contributions from the zero-phonon line and a pronounced ∼80 cm⁻¹ phonon side band, respectively. The couplings between the six central RC chlorins are probably very similar and, therefore, a `multimer' model arises in which there is no `special pair' and in which for each realization of the disorder the excitation may be dynamically localized on basically any combination of neighbouring chlorins. The key features of our model for the primary reactions in PS II include ultrafast (<500 fs) energy transfer processes within the multimer, `slow' (∼20 ps) energy transfer processes from peripheral RC chlorophylls to the RC multimer, ultrafast charge separation (<500 fs) with a low yield starting from the singlet-excited `accessory' chlorophyll of the active branch, cation transfer from this `accessory' chlorophyll to a `special pair' chlorophyll and/or charge separation starting from this `special pair' chlorophyll (∼8 ps), and slow relaxation (∼50 ps) of the radical pair by conformational changes of the protein. The charge separation in the PS II RC can probably not be described as a simple trap-limited or diffusion-limited process, while for the PS II core and larger complexes the transfer of the excitation energy to the PS II RC may be rate limiting. This revised version was published online in June 2006 with corrections to the Cover Date.     

Effect of the redox state of QB on electric field-induced charge recombination in Photosystem II

Electric field-induced charge recombination in Photosystem II (PS II) was studied in osmotically swollen spinach chloroplasts (blebs) by measurement of the concomitant chlorophyll luminescence emission (electroluminescence). A pronounced dependence on the redox state of the two-electron gate Q_B was observed and the earlier failure to detect it is explained. The influence of the Q_B/Q_B ^– oscillation on electroluminescence was dependent on the redox state of the oxygen evolving complex; at times around one millisecond after flash illumination a large effect was observed in the states S₂ and S₃, but not in the state S₄ (actually Z⁺S₃). The presence of the oxidized secondary electron donor, tyrosine Z⁺, appeared to prevent expression of the Q_B/Q_B ^– effect on electroluminescence, possibly because this effect is primarily due to a shift of the redox equilibrium between Z/Z⁺ and the oxygen evolving complex.Abbreviations BSA bovine serum albumin - EDTA ethylene-diaminetetraacetic acid - EL electroluminescence - FCCP carbonylcyanide p-trifluoromethyloxyphenyl-hydrazone - HEPESI 4-(2-hydroxyethyl)-1-piperazineethanesulfonic acid - I primary electron acceptor - MOPS 3-(N-morpholino) propane sulfonic acid - P680 primary electron donor of Photosystem II - P700 primary electron donor of Photosystem I - Q_A and Q_B secondary and tertiary electron acceptors of Photosystem II - Z secondary electron donor (D1 Tyr 161)     

Mechanism of photoinhibition: photochemical reaction center inactivation in system II of chloroplasts

Photoinhibition of photosynthesis is manifested at the level of the leaf as a loss of CO₂ fixation and at the level of the chloroplast thylakoid membrane as a loss of photosystem II electron-transport capacity. At the photosystem II level, photoinhibition is manifested by a lowered chlorophyll a variable fluorescence yield, by a lowered amplitude of the light-induced absorbance change at 320 nm (A₃₂₀) and 540-minus-550 nm (A_540–550), attributed to inhibition of the photoreduction of the primary plastoquinone Q_A molecule. A correlation of the kinetics of variable fluorescence yield loss with the inhibition of Q_A photoreduction suggested that photoinhibited reaction centers are incapable of generating a stable charge separation but are highly efficient in the trapping and non-photochemical dissipation of absorbed light. The direct effect of photoinhibition on primary photochemical parameters of photosystem II suggested a permanent reaction center modification the nature of which remains to be determined.Dedicated to Prof. L.N.M. Duysens on the occasion of his retirement     

Excitation trapping and charge separation in Photosystem II in the presence of an electrical field

To investigate the effects of a membrane potential on excitation trapping and charge separation in Photosystem II we have studied the chlorophyll fluorescence yield in osmotically swollen chloroplasts subjected to electrical field pulses. Significant effects were observed only in those membrane regions where a large membrane potential opposing the photochemical charge separation was built up. When the fluorescence yield was low, close to F₀, a much higher yield, up to F_max, was observed during the presence of the membrane potential. This is explained by an inhibition by the electrical field of electron transfer to the quinone acceptor Q, resulting in a decreased trapping of excitations. A field pulse applied when the fluorescence yield was high, Q and the donor side being in the reduced state, had the opposite effect: the fluorescence was quenched nearly to F₀. This field-induced fluorescence quenching is ascribed to reversed electron transfer from Q^? to the intermediate acceptor, pheophytin. Its field strength dependence suggests that the midpoint potential difference between pheophytin and Q is at most about 300 mV. Even then it must be assumed that electron transfer between pheophytin and Q spans 90% of the potential difference across the membrane.     

Thermodynamics of the charge recombination in photosystem II

The temperature dependence of the electric field-induced chlorophyll luminescence in photosystem II was studied in Tris-washed, osmotically swollen spinach chloroplasts (blebs). The system II reaction centers were brought in the state Z⁺P⁺-Q_A ^-Q_B ^- by preillumination and the charge recombination to the state Z⁺PQ_AQ_B ^- was measured at various temperatures and electrical field strengths. It was found that the activation enthalpy of this back reaction was 0.16 eV in the absence of an electrical field and diminished with increasing field strength. It is argued that this energy is the enthalpy difference between the states IQ_A ^- and I^-Q_A and accounts for about half of the free energy difference between these states. The redox state of Q_B does not influence this free energy difference within 150 s after the photoreduction of Q_A. The consequences for the interpretation of thermodynamic properties of Q_A are discussed.Abbreviations DCMU 3(3,4-dichlorophenyl)-1,1-dimethylurea - I intermediary electron acceptor - Mops 3-(N-morpholino)propanesulphonic acid - P (P₆₈₀) primary electron donor - PS II photosystem II - Q_A and Q_B first and second quinone electron acceptors - Tricine N-tris(hydroxymethyl)methylglycine - Tris tris-(hydroxymethyl)aminomethane - Z secondary electron donor Dedicated to Professor L.N.M. Duysens on the occasion of his retirement     

The isolated Photosystem II reaction center: first attempts to directly measure the kinetics of primary charge separation

Direct measurements of the intrinsic rate of primary charge separation in the isolated Photosystem II (PS II) reaction center complex had to await the availability of suitable, stabilized reaction center materials as well as sophisticated femtosecond transient absorption spectroscopic techniques. The events that led to the first direct measurements of the primary charge separation act in PS II and discussions of the results thereafter are chronicled in this brief historical review. This revised version was published online in August 2006 with corrections to the Cover Date.     

Reconstitution of photosynthetic charge accumulation and oxygen evolution in CaCl2-treated PS II particles: II: EPR evidence for reactivation of the S1 → S2 transition in CaCl2-treated PS II particles with the 17-, 23-, and 34-kDa proteins

Extraction of PS II particles with 1 M CaCl₂ caused complete disappearance of the light-induced signal of the possible Kok S₂ state of the water-splitting complex and total loss of the O₂, evolving activity, concomitant with perfect removal of the 17-, 23- and 34-kDa proteins from the particles. The recovery of the multiline signal in the CaCl₂-treated PS II was performed by reinserting the 34-kDa protein, when CI^? was present in the solution for the EPR measurement. However, in the absence of Cl^?, besides the 34-kDa protein, the 17- and 23-kDa proteins were required for the recovery of the signal. These results are compared with the results on the recovery of the O₂, evolution in the reconstituted PS II to examine the role of these three proteins on the water splitting.     

A thermoluminescence study of the effects of nitrite on photosystem II in spinach thylakoids.

The site of action of nitrite on PS II was investigated by measuring the TL profile of nitrite-treated spinach thylakoid membranes. Three bands were observed in control, which were identified as the Q band (7 degrees C), the B band (24 degrees C) and the C band (57 degrees C). In the presence of 20 mmol/L nitrite, the intensity of the Q band decreased, the B band upshifted to 46 degrees C but the C band disappeared. The suppression of the Q band and the upshift of the B band suggested that nitrite caused inhibition at the water oxidizing complex. The effects of nitrite also remained the same in the presence of chloride. In case of ion-sufficient thylakoid membranes, nitrite decreased the Q band peak intensity and caused an upshift in the B band peak temperature. Nitrite showed similar effects in the presence of DCMU. This suggested that the site of action of nitrite is not at the acceptor side but at the donor side of PS II. The inhibition shown by nitrite has been found to be specific for nitrite anion. No other anions such as formate, fluoride or nitrate, were effective.     

Fluorescence induction of Photosystem II membranes shows the steps till reduction and protonation of the quinone pool

Chlorophyll fluorescence induction (Chl-F) was investigated in Photosystem II (PSII)-enriched membranes, which predominantly include active (Q_B reducing) PSII reaction centres (RCs) and lack Photosystem I (PSI). The Chl-F curve of these preparations show a polyphasic rise from F₀, the minimal fluorescence, to F_P, the maximal fluorescence, with several intermediate transitions. Analyses of these transitions revealed three exponential rise components with lifetimes of 18 ms, 400 ms and 800 ms. The 18 ms component was assigned to the photoaccumulation of reduced Q_A. The two slowest components, of 400 ms and 800 ms, were assigned to Q_B reduction (Q_B⁻ and Q_B⁼) and further Q_B⁼ protonation (till Q_BH₂), respectively. These assignments were based on the observation of specific quenching of the phases by DCMU or by different oxidized, reduced and protonated quinones. The work is done in low light conditions which are saturating to avoid photoinhibition or PSII inactivation effects. The results suggest that the Chl-F curve observed in PSII-enriched membranes can be attributed to the sequential steps till the photoaccumulation (reduction and protonation) of plastoquinone (PQ) by PSII. These results are in good agreement with the molecular models that show a correspondence between Chl-F and PQ reduction steps, like the models that propose and explain the O-J-I-P transients.     

Evidence that the variable chlorophyll fluorescence in Chlamydomonas reinhardtii is not recombination luminescence

Room temperature single photon timing measurements on intact, Chlamydomonas reinhardtii cells at low excitation energies have been analysed using a four exponential kinetic model. Closing the PSII reaction centres produced two major variable lifetime and two minor constant lifetime components. The yield of each component mirrored the changes in lifetime. Such observations indicate the presence of well-connected PSII centres favoring excitation energy transfer. A Chlamydomonas mutant lacking PSII reaction centre proteins exhibited decay components equivalent to those seen at F_M in the wild-type. A titration of in vivo fluorescence, in both the mutant and wild-type algae, using DNB, produced decay components similar to those seen on opening PSII reaction centres. Such observations indicate that the luminescence hypothesis for the origin of the long-lived lifetime component is not the case.Abbreviations DCMU 3-(3,4-dichlorophenyl)-1, 1-dimethyl urea - DNB m,Dinitrobenzene - PSII photosystem II - RCII PSII recation centre - I^- reduced pheophytin - Q_A primary stable electron ecceptor of PSII - Ch1 chlorophyl1 - LHCII light harvesting Ch1a/b protein complex of PSII - F_O initial fluorescence level - F_M maximum fluorescence level - F_V variable fluorescence (F_M-F_O) - ps picosecond - ns nanosecond     

The involvement of lipids in light-induced charge separation in the reaction center of photosystem II

Extraction of PS II particles with 50 mM cholate and 1 M NaCl releases several proteins (33-, 23-, 17- and 13 kDa) and lipids from the thylakoid membrane which are essential for O₂ evolution, dichlorophenolindophenol (DCIP) reduction and for stable charge separation between P680⁺ and Q_A ^-. This work correlates the results on the loss of steady-state rates for O₂ evolution and PS II mediated DCIP photo-reduction with flash absorption changes directly monitoring the reaction center charge separation at 830 nm due to P680⁺, the chlorophyll a donor. Reconstitution of the extracted lipids to the depleted membrane restores the ability to photo-oxidize P680 reversibly and to reduce DCIP, while stimulating O₂ evolution minimally. Addition of the extracted proteins of masses 33-, 23- and 17- kDa produces no further stimulation of DCIP reduction in the presence of an exogenous donor like DPC, but does enhance this rate in the absence of exogenous donors while also stimulating O₂ evolution. The proteins alone in the absence of lipids have little influence on charge separation in the reaction center. Thus lipids are essential for stable charge separation within the reaction center, involving formation of P680⁺ and Q_A ^-.Abbreviations A₈₃₀ Absorption change at 830 nm - Chl Chlorophyll - D₁ primary electron donor to P680 - DCIP 2,6-dichlorophenolindophenol - DPC 1,5-diphenylcarbazide - MOPS 3-(N-morpholino)propanesulfonic acid - P680 reaction center chlorophyll a molecule of photosystem II - PPBQ Phenyl-p-benzoquinone - PS II Photosystem II - Q_A, Q_B first and second quinone acceptors in PS II - V-DCIP rate of DCIP reduction - V-O₂ rate of oxygen evolution - Y water-oxidizing enzyme system - CHAPS 3-Cyclohexylamino-propanesulfonic acid     

Acceptor side photoinhibition in PS II: On the possible effects of the functional integrity of the PS II donor side on photoinhibition of stable charge separation

Photoinhibition under aerobic and anaerobic conditions was analyzed in O₂-evolving and in Tris-treated PS II-membrane fragments from spinach by measuring laser-flash-induced absorption changes at 826 nm reflecting the transient P680⁺ formation and the chlorophyll fluorescence lifetime. It was found that anaerobic photoinhibitory treatment leads in both types of samples to the appearence of two long-lived fluorescence components with lifetimes of 7 ns and 16 ns, respectively. The extent of these fluorescence kinetics depends on the state of the reaction center (open/closed) during the fluorescence measurements: it is drastically higher in the closed state. It is concluded that this long-lived fluorescence is mainly emitted from modified reaction centers with singly reduced Q_A(Q_A ^-). This suggests that the observation of long-lived fluorescence components cannot necessarily be taken as an indicator for reaction centers with missing or doubly reduced and protonated Q_A (Q_AH₂). Time-resolved measurements of 826 nm absorption changes show that the rate of photoinhibition of the stable charge separation (P680^*Q_A P680⁺Q_A ^-), is nearly the same in O₂-evolving and in Tris-treated PS II-membrane fragments. This finding is difficult to understand within the framework of the Q_AH₂-mechanism for photoinhibition of stable charge separation because in that case the rate of photoinhibition should strongly depend on the functional integrity of the donor side of PS II. Based on the results of this study it is inferred, that several processes contribute to photoinhibition within the PS II reaction center and that a mechanism which comprises double reduction and protonation of Q_A leading to Q_AH₂ formation is only of marginal – if any – relevance for photoinhibition of PS II under both, aerobic and anaerobic, conditions.     

Coupling of exciton motion in the core antenna and primary charge separation in the reaction center

The relation between exciton motion in the LH1 antenna and primary charge separation in the reaction center of purple bacteria is briefly reviewed. It is argued that in models based on hopping excitons described strictly by Förster theory, transfer-to-trap-limited kinetics is quite unlikely according to the relation between the exciton trapping kinetics and N, the size of the photosynthetic unit in such models. Because the results of several recent experiments have been interpreted in terms of transfer-to-trap limited kinetics, this presents a conflict between these experimental interpretations and strictly Förster-based theoretical models. Two possible resolutions are proposed. One arises from the random phase-redistribution trapping kinetics of partially coherent excitons, a kinetics uniquely independent of both N and the rate constant for primary charge separation in the reaction center. The other comes from multiple-pathways models of the multipicosecond nonexponentiality of the decay of P^*, the electronically excited primary electron donor in the reaction center. In these models, because it depends only on a certain averaged electron-transfer time constant, the exciton lifetime may be relatively insensivive to variations of individual electrontransfer rate constants-thereby undercutting the argument appearing in recent literature that by default the exciton kinetics must be transfer-to-trap limited.     

Characterization of the photosystem II centers inactive in plastoquinone reduction by fluorescence induction

In order to characterize the photosystem II (PS II) centers which are inactive in plastoquinone reduction, the initial variable fluorescence rise from the non-variable fluorescence level F_o to an intermediate plateau level F_i has been studied. We find that the initial fluorescence rise is a monophasic exponential function of time. Its rate constant is similar to the initial rate of the fastest phase (-phase) of the fluorescence induction curve from DCMU-poisoned chloroplasts. In addition, the initial fluorescence rise and the -phase have the following common properties: their rate constants vary linearly with excitation light intensity and their fluorescence yields are lowered by removal of Mg⁺⁺ from the suspension medium. We suggest that the inactive PS II centers, which give rise to the fluorescence rise from F_o to F_i, belong to the -type PS II centers. However, since these inactive centers do not display sigmoidicity in fluorescence, they thus do not allow energy transfer between PS II units like PS II.Abbreviations DCMU 3-(3,4-dichlorophenyl)-1,1-dimethyl urea - DMQ 2,5-dimethyl-p-benzoquinone - F_o initial non-variable fluorescence yield - F_m maximum fluorescence yield - F_i intermediate fluorescence yield - PS II photosystem II - Q_A primary quinone acceptor of PS II - Q_B secondary quinone acceptor of PS II     

Influence of stray capacitance and sample resistance on the kinetics of fast photovoltages from oriented purple membranes

Flash-induced photovoltages were measured with metal electrodes in two experimental systems of purple membranes oriented by an electric field. One system consisted of a suspension of purple membranes cooled to 80 K. The photovoltage evoked by a xenon flash lamp displayed a single phase with a fast rise and a slow RC-decay. The signal shape is consistent with a fast charge separation occurring before the decay of the K-intermediate. The other system consisted of purple membranes embedded and stabilized in polyacrylamide gel. At room temperature, the photovoltage, evoked by a 10 ns laser flash, displayed a negative phase in the submicrosecond range and a slower positive one. The shape of the signals were altered in a complex manner by the stray capacitance and the ionic strength. The rise-time of the negative phase was approx. 14 and approx. 40 ns at ionic strengths of 10 and 1 mM, respectively. The initial peak amplitudes of the photovoltage from both experimental systems depended on the external capacitance in an inverse manner, indicating that both experimental systems were not impedance-matched. The evaluation of kinetic data of molecular reactions from measurements of the photovoltage is discussed.     

植物光系统II放氧复合体外周蛋白结构和功能的研究进展

光合放氧是植物光系统II(PSII)的重要功能之一。PSII的放氧反应主要是由PSII氧化侧的 4个锰原子组成的锰簇催化的。在类囊体膜的囊腔侧还结合有若干个外周蛋白 ,对放氧反应起着重要作用。文章总结了植物光系统II外周蛋白的结构和功能研究方面的最新进展     

On the involvement of the water-polaron mechanism in energy trapping by reaction centers of purple bacteria

A locus for binding a mobile water molecule was searched for in the immediate vicinity of the special pair in the reaction center. Using the PROTEUS PC-program (a part of the GRASP package) atomic structures of the reaction centers were analyzed in purple bacteria Rhodopseudomonas viridis and Rhodobacter sphaeroides. In both structures the loci for binding mobile water molecules were found at the distance of about 4.5 Å from the middle of the special pair in the reaction center. The reorientation of a hydrogen atom of this water molecule in the electric field of the excited special pair required energy of no less than 40 MeV that corresponded to predictions of the water-polarization model of trapping of electron excitation which was developed by M. V. Fok and one of the authors of this article.     

Investigation of the plastoquinone pool size and fluorescence quenching in thylakoid membranes and Photosystem II (PS II) membrane fragments

The efficiency of oxidized endogenous plastoquinone-9 (PQ-9) as a non-photochemical quencher of chlorophyll fluorescence has been analyzed in spinach thylakoids and PS II membrane fragments isolated by Triton X-100 fractionation of grana stacks. The following results were obtained: (a) After subjection of PS II membrane fragments to ultrasonic treatment in the presence of PQ-9, the area over the induction curve of chlorophyll fluorescence owing to actinic cw light increases linearly with the PQ-9/PS II ratio in the reconstitution assay medium; (b) the difference of the maximum fluorescence levels, F_max, of the induction curves, measured in the absence and presence of DCMU, is much more pronounced in PS II membrane fragments than in thylakoids; (c) the ratio F_max(-DCMU)/F_max(+DCMU) increases linearly with the content of oxidized PQ-9 that is varied in the thylakoids by reoxidation of the pool after preillumination and in PS II membrane fragments by the PQ-9/PS II ratio in the reconstitution assay; (d) the reconstitution procedure leads to tight binding of PQ-9 to PS II membrane fragments, and PQ-9 cannot be replaced by other quinones; (e) the fluorescence quenching by oxidized PQ-9 persists at low temperatures, and (f) oxidized PQ-9 preferentially affects the F695 of the fluorescence emission spectrum at 77 K. Based on the results of this study the oxidized PQ-9 is inferred to act as a non-photochemical quencher via a static mechanism. Possible implications for the nature of the quenching complex are discussed. This revised version was published online in June 2006 with corrections to the Cover Date.     

Two sites of photoinhibition of the electron transfer in oxygen evolving and Tris-treated PS II membrane fragments from spinach

Photoinhibition was analyzed in O₂-evolving and in Tris-treated PS II membrane fragments by measuring flash-induced absorption changes at 830 nm reflecting the transient P680⁺ formation and oxygen evolution. Irradiation by visible light affects the PS II electron transfer at two different sites: a) photoinhibition of site I eliminates the capability to perform a stable charge separation between P680⁺ and Q_A ^- within the reaction center (RC) and b) photoinhibition of site II blocks the electron transfer from Y_Z to P680⁺. The quantum yield of site I photoinhibition (2–3×10^-7 inhibited RC/quantum) is independent of the functional integrity of the water oxidizing system. In contrast, the quantum yield of photoinhibition at site II depends strongly on the oxygen evolution capacity. In O₂-evolving samples, the quantum yield of site II photoinhibition is about 10^-7 inhibited RC/quantum. After selective elimination of the O₂-evolving capacity by Tris-treatment, the quantum yield of photoinhibition at site II depends on the light intensity. At low intensity (<3 W/m²), the quantum yield is 10^-4 inhibited RC/quantum (about 1000 times higher than in oxygen evolving samples). Based on these results it is inferred that the dominating deleterious effect of photoinhibition cannot be ascribed to an unique target site or a single mechanism because it depends on different experimental conditions (e.g., light intensity) and the functional status of the PS II complex.Abbreviations A₈₃₀ absorption change at 830 nm - P680 primary electron donor of PS II - PS II photosystem II - Mes 2(N-morpholino)ethansulfonic acid - Q_A, Q_B primary and secondary acceptors of PS II - DCIP 2,6-dichlorophenolindophenol - DPC 1,5-diphenylcarbohydrazide - FWHM fullwidth at half maximum - Ph-p-BQ phenyl-p-benzoquinone - PFR photon fluence rate - Pheo pheophytin - RC reaction center