Ion channel and toxin measurement using a high throughput lipid membrane platform

Measurements of ion channels are important for scientific, sensing and pharmaceutical applications. Reconstitution of ion channels into lipid vesicles and planar lipid bilayers for measurement at the single molecule level is a laborious and slow process incompatible with the high throughput methods and equipment used for sensing and drug discovery. A recently published method of lipid bilayer formation mechanically combines lipid monolayers self-assembled at the interfaces of aqueous and apolar phases. We have expanded on this method by vertically orienting these phases and using gravity as the driving force to combine the monolayers. As this method only requires fluid dispensation, it is trivially integrated with high throughput automated liquid-handling robotics. In a proof-of-concept demonstration, we created over 2200 lipid bilayers in 3h. We show single molecule measurements of technologically and physiologically relevant ion channels incorporated into lipid bilayers formed with this method.     

Bilayer lipid membranes supported on Teflon filters: a functional environment for ion channels

Many ion channel proteins have binding sites for toxins and pharmaceutical drugs and therefore have much promise as the sensing entity in high throughput technologies and biosensor devices. Measurement of ionic conductance changes through ion channels requires a robust biological membrane with sufficient longevity for practical applications. The conventional planar BLM is 100-300 μm in diameter and typically contains fewer than a dozen channels whereas pharmaceutical screening methods in cells use current recordings for many ion channels. We present a new, simple method for the fabrication of a disposable porous-supported bilayer lipid membrane (BLM) ion channel biosensor using hydrated Teflon (polytetrafluoroethylene, PTFE) filter material (pore size 5 μm, filter diameter=1 mm). The lipid layer was monitored for its thickness and mechanical stability by electrical impedance spectroscopy. The results showed membrane capacitances of 1.8±0.2 nF and membrane resistances of 25.9±4.1 GΩ, indicating the formation of lipid bilayers. The current level increased upon addition of the pore-forming peptide gramicidin. Following addition of liposomes containing voltage-gated sodium channels, small macroscopic sodium currents (1-80 pA) could be recorded. By preloading the porous Teflon with sodium channel proteoliposomes, prior to BLM formation, currents of 1-10 nA could be recorded in the presence of the activator veratridine that increased with time, and were inhibited by tetrodotoxin. A lack of rectification suggests that the channels incorporated in both orientations. This work demonstrates that PTFE filters can support BLMs that provide an environment in which ion channels can maintain their functional activity relevant for applications in drug discovery, toxin detection, and odour sensing.     

Discrete membrane arrays

This review describes various methods for the attachment of phospholipid bilayers to solid supports. The simplest approach involves vesicle unrolling onto a surface that has been previously modified with a continuous self-assembled monolayer (SAM). The choice of a suitable SAM can lead to the formation of attached bilayers that have the desired biomimetic properties and are suitable for studying transmembrane proteins. However, there are intrinsic problems associated with this approach if one is interested in studying ion transport phenomena. In particular, the relatively low resistance values found for such bilayers do not permit studies of single ion channels. For such studies to be carried out the background leakage through the lipid film must be greatly reduced. In an attempt to reduce the problems of leakage we have formed patterned SAMs in which a blocking, hydrophobic, layer covers 90% of the electrode surface. The remaining portion of the surface, which is hydrophilic, supports the formation of a bilayer. This approach has led to an improvement in the quality of the bilayers formed but has still not provided bilayers with sufficiently high specific resistances to study single ion channels. Finally, we describe new approaches based on the formation of bilayers suspended over small apertures. These 'suspended' bilayers are similar in structure to those used in black lipid membrane experiments and give rise to highly blocking bilayer membranes. Unfortunately, this approach requires the use of solvents to create the suspended bilayer and they are relatively fragile.     

Discrete membrane arrays

This review describes various methods for the attachment of phospholipid bilayers to solid supports. The simplest approach involves vesicle unrolling onto a surface that has been previously modified with a continuous self-assembled monolayer (SAM). The choice of a suitable SAM can lead to the formation of attached bilayers that have the desired biomimetic properties and are suitable for studying transmembrane proteins. However, there are intrinsic problems associated with this approach if one is interested in studying ion transport phenomena. In particular, the relatively low resistance values found for such bilayers do not permit studies of single ion channels. For such studies to be carried out the background leakage through the lipid film must be greatly reduced. In an attempt to reduce the problems of leakage we have formed patterned SAMs in which a blocking, hydrophobic, layer covers 90% of the electrode surface. The remaining portion of the surface, which is hydrophilic, supports the formation of a bilayer. This approach has led to an improvement in the quality of the bilayers formed but has still not provided bilayers with sufficiently high specific resistances to study single ion channels. Finally, we describe new approaches based on the formation of bilayers suspended over small apertures. These ‘suspended’ bilayers are similar in structure to those used in black lipid membrane experiments and give rise to highly blocking bilayer membranes. Unfortunately, this approach requires the use of solvents to create the suspended bilayer and they are relatively fragile.     

bSUM: A bead-supported unilamellar membrane system facilitating unidirectional insertion of membrane proteins into giant vesicles

Fused or giant vesicles, planar lipid bilayers, a droplet membrane system, and planar-supported membranes have been developed to incorporate membrane proteins for the electrical and biophysical analysis of such proteins or the bilayer properties. However, it remains difficult to incorporate membrane proteins, including ion channels, into reconstituted membrane systems that allow easy control of operational dimensions, incorporation orientation of the membrane proteins, and lipid composition of membranes. Here, using a newly developed chemical engineering procedure, we report on a bead-supported unilamellar membrane (bSUM) system that allows good control over membrane dimension, protein orientation, and lipid composition. Our new system uses specific ligands to facilitate the unidirectional incorporation of membrane proteins into lipid bilayers. Cryo–electron microscopic imaging demonstrates the unilamellar nature of the bSUMs. Electrical recordings from voltage-gated ion channels in bSUMs of varying diameters demonstrate the versatility of the new system. Using KvAP as a model system, we show that compared with other in vitro membrane systems, the bSUMs have the following advantages: (a) a major fraction of channels are orientated in a controlled way; (b) the channels mediate the formation of the lipid bilayer; (c) there is one and only one bilayer membrane on each bead; (d) the lipid composition can be controlled and the bSUM size is also under experimental control over a range of 0.2–20 µm; (e) the channel activity can be recorded by patch clamp using a planar electrode; and (f) the voltage-clamp speed (0.2–0.5 ms) of the bSUM on a planar electrode is fast, making it suitable to study ion channels with fast gating kinetics. Our observations suggest that the chemically engineered bSUMs afford a novel platform for studying lipid–protein interactions in membranes of varying lipid composition and may be useful for other applications, such as targeted delivery and single-molecule imaging.     

Bilayer reconstitution of voltage-dependent ion channels using a microfabricated silicon chip

Painted bilayers containing reconstituted ion channels serve as a well defined model system for electrophysiological investigations of channel structure and function. Horizontally oriented bilayers with easy solution access to both sides were obtained by painting a phospholipid:decane mixture across a cylindrical pore etched into a 200-microm thick silicon wafer. Silanization of the SiO(2) layer produced a hydrophobic surface that promoted the adhesion of the lipid mixture. Standard lithographic techniques and anisotropic deep-reactive ion etching were used to create pores with diameters from 50 to 200 microm. The cylindrical structure of the pore in the partition and the surface treatment resulted in stable bilayers. These were used to reconstitute Maxi K channels in the 100- and 200-microm diameter pores. The electrophysiological characteristics of bilayers suspended in microchips were comparable with that of other bilayer preparations. The horizontal orientation and good voltage clamping properties make the microchip bilayer method an excellent system to study the electrical properties of reconstituted membrane proteins simultaneously with optical probes.     

Antibacterial peptide pleurocidin forms ion channels in planar lipid bilayers

Pleurocidin, a 25-residue alpha helical cationic peptide, isolated from skin mucous secretions of the winter flounder, displays a strong anti-microbial activity and appears to play a role in innate host defence. This peptide would be responsible for pore formation in the membrane of bacteria leading to lysis and therefore death. In this study, we investigated the behaviour of pleurocidin in different planar lipid bilayers to determine its mechanism of membrane permeabilisation. Macroscopic conductance experiments showed that pleurocidin did not display a pore-forming activity in neutral phosphatidylcholine/phosphatidylethanolamine (PC/PE) lipid bilayers. However, in 7:3:1 PC/PE/phosphatidylserine (PS) lipid bilayers, pleurocidin showed reproducible I/V curves at different peptide concentrations. This activity is confirmed by single-channel experiments since well-defined ion channels were obtained if the lipid mixture was containing an anionic lipid (PS). The ion channel characteristics such as-no voltage dependence, only one unitary conductance, linear relation ship current-voltage-, are not in favour of the membrane permeabilisation according to the barrel model but rather by the toroidal pore formation.     

Aggregation and porin-like channel activity of a beta sheet peptide

Beta sheet peptides (e.g., amyloid beta) are known to form ion channels in lipid bilayers possibly through aggregation, though the channel structure is not clear. We have recently reported that a short beta sheet peptide, (xSxG)(6), forms porin-like voltage-gated channels in lipid bilayers [Thundimadathil et al. (2005) Biochem. Biophys. Res. Commun. 330, 585-590]. To account for the porin-like activity, oligomerization of the peptide into a beta barrel-like structure was proposed. In this work, peptide aggregation in aqueous and membrane environments and a detailed study of channel properties were performed to gain insight into the mechanism of channel formation. The complex nature of the channel was revealed by kinetic analysis and the occurrence of interconverting multiple conductance states. Ion channels were inhibited by Congo red, suggesting that the peptide aggregates are the active channel species. Peptide aggregation and fibril formation in water were confirmed by electron microscopy (EM) and Congo red binding studies. Furthermore, oligomeric structures in association with lipid bilayers were detected. Circular dichroism of peptide-incorporated liposomes and peptide-lipid binding studies using EM suggest a lipid-induced beta sheet aggregation. Gel electrophoresis of peptide-incorporated liposomes showed dimeric and multimeric structures. Taken together, this work indicates insertion of (xSxG)(6) as oligomers into the lipid bilayer, followed by rearrangement into a beta barrel-like pore structure. A large peptide pore comprising several individual beta sheets or smaller beta sheet aggregates is expected to have a complex behavior in membranes. A dyad repeat sequence and the presence of glycine, serine, and hydrophobic residues in a repeated pattern in this peptide may be providing a favorable condition for the formation of a beta barrel-like structure in lipid bilayers.     

Antibacterial peptide pleurocidin forms ion channels in planar lipid bilayers

Pleurocidin, a 25-residue α helical cationic peptide, isolated from skin mucous secretions of the winter flounder, displays a strong anti-microbial activity and appears to play a role in innate host defence. This peptide would be responsible for pore formation in the membrane of bacteria leading to lysis and therefore death. In this study, we investigated the behaviour of pleurocidin in different planar lipid bilayers to determine its mechanism of membrane permeabilisation. Macroscopic conductance experiments showed that pleurocidin did not display a pore-forming activity in neutral phosphatidylcholine/phosphatidylethanolamine (PC/PE) lipid bilayers. However, in 7:3:1 PC/PE/phosphatidylserine (PS) lipid bilayers, pleurocidin showed reproducible I/V curves at different peptide concentrations. This activity is confirmed by single-channel experiments since well-defined ion channels were obtained if the lipid mixture was containing an anionic lipid (PS). The ion channel characteristics such as—no voltage dependence, only one unitary conductance, linear relation ship current-voltage—, are not in favour of the membrane permeabilisation according to the barrel model but rather by the toroidal pore formation.     

Refolded outer membrane protein A of Escherichia coli forms ion channels with two conductance states in planar lipid bilayers

Outer membrane protein A (OmpA), a major structural protein of the outer membrane of Escherichia coli, consists of an N-terminal 8-stranded beta-barrel transmembrane domain and a C-terminal periplasmic domain. OmpA has served as an excellent model for studying the mechanism of insertion, folding, and assembly of constitutive integral membrane proteins in vivo and in vitro. The function of OmpA is currently not well understood. Particularly, the question whether or not OmpA forms an ion channel and/or nonspecific pore for uncharged larger solutes, as some other porins do, has been controversial. We have incorporated detergent-purified OmpA into planar lipid bilayers and studied its permeability to ions by single channel conductance measurements. In 1 M KCl, OmpA formed small (50-80 pS) and large (260-320 pS) channels. These two conductance states were interconvertible, presumably corresponding to two different conformations of OmpA in the membrane. The smaller channels are associated with the N-terminal transmembrane domain, whereas both domains are required to form the larger channels. The two channel activities provide a new functional assay for the refolding in vitro of the two respective domains of OmpA. Wild-type and five single tryptophan mutants of urea-denatured OmpA are shown to refold into functional channels in lipid bilayers.     

Automatable production of shippable bilayer chips by pin tool deposition for an ion channel measurement platform

As a step towards an automated and operator-free ion channel measurement platform we have previously demonstrated a solution formulation for artificial lipid bilayers that enabled the indefinite storage and shipping of frozen bilayer precursors. In this work, the solutions were deposited by hand. Here, we have adapted pin tools to deposit the bilayer precursor solutions onto multi-element arrays, a popular method for microarray solution deposition. The pin tools have enabled the deposited volume to be applied highly repeatably and controllably, resulting in reduction of bilayer formation times to <1 h. The pin tools are also compatible with computerized motion control platforms, enabling automated and high throughput production. We discuss these results and the prospects of this technology to produce high density bilayer arrays for high throughput measurement of ion channels incorporated into artificial bilayers.     

Integration and Oligomerization of Bax Protein in Lipid Bilayers Characterized by Single Molecule Fluorescence Study

Bax is a pro-apoptotic Bcl-2 family protein. The activated Bax translocates to mitochondria, where it forms pore and permeabilizes the mitochondrial outer membrane. This process requires the BH3-only activator protein (i.e. tBid) and can be inhibited by anti-apoptotic Bcl-2 family proteins such as Bcl-x_L. Here by using single molecule fluorescence techniques, we studied the integration and oligomerization of Bax in lipid bilayers. Our study revealed that Bax can bind to lipid membrane spontaneously in the absence of tBid. The Bax pore formation undergoes at least two steps: pre-pore formation and membrane insertion. The activated Bax triggered by tBid or BH3 domain peptide integrates on bilayers and tends to form tetramers, which are termed as pre-pore. Subsequent insertion of the pre-pore into membrane is highly dependent on the composition of cardiolipin in lipid bilayers. Bcl-x_L can translocate Bax from membrane to solution and inhibit the pore formation. The study of Bax integration and oligomerization at the single molecule level provides new evidences that may help elucidate the pore formation of Bax and its regulatory mechanism in apoptosis.     

Storable droplet interface lipid bilayers for cell-free ion channel studies

An artificially created lipid bilayer is an important platform in studying ion channels and engineered biosensor applications. However, a lipid bilayer created using conventional techniques is fragile and short-lived, and the measurement of ion channels requires expertise and laborious procedures, precluding practical applications. Here, we demonstrate a storable droplet lipid bilayer precursor frozen with ion channels, resulting in a droplet interface bilayer upon thawing. A small vial with an aqueous droplet in organic solution was flash frozen in -80 °C methanol immediately after an aqueous droplet was introduced into the organic solution and gravity draws the droplet down to the interface upon thawing. A lipid bilayer created along the interface using this method had giga-ohm resistance and typical specific capacitance values. The noise level of this system is favorably comparable to the conventional system. The subsequent incorporation of ion channels, alpha-hemolysin and gramicidin A, showed typical conductance values consistent with those in previous literatures. This novel system to create a lipid bilayer as a whole can be automated from its manufacture to use and indefinitely stored when frozen. As a result, ion channel measurements can be carried out in any place, increasing the accessibility of ion channel studies as well as a number of applications, such as biosensors, ion channel drug screening, and biophysical studies.     

Pore formation by Staphylococcus aureus alpha-toxin in lipid bilayers

Staphylococcus aureus -toxin forms ionic channels of large size in lipid bilayer membranes. We have developed two methods for studying the mechanism of pore formation. One is based on measurement of the ionic current flowing through a planar lipid membrane after exposure to the toxin; the other is based on measuring the release of the fluorescent complex Tb-Dipicolinic acid from large unilamellar vesicles under similar conditions.Both methods indicate that the pore formation process is complex, showing an initial delay followed by non-linear kinetics. The power dependence of the pore formation rate on the toxin concentration in planar bilayers indicates that an aggregation mechanism underlies the channel assembly. Arrhenius plots, obtained with both techniques, show no deviation from linearity up to 50°C and the derived activation energies are found to be comparable to those for the binding and the lysis of rabbit erythrocytes by the same toxin.The temperature dependence of the conductance induced in planar bilayers by a large number of toxin channels indicates that the pores are filled with aqueous solution. The analysis of single conductance events shows that a heterogeneous population of pores exist and that smaller channels are preferred at low temperature. We attribute this heterogeneity to the existence of pores resulting from the aggregation of different numbers of monomers.     

Simulations of skin barrier function: free energies of hydrophobic and hydrophilic transmembrane pores in ceramide bilayers

Transmembrane pore formation is central to many biological processes such as ion transport, cell fusion, and viral infection. Furthermore, pore formation in the ceramide bilayers of the stratum corneum may be an important mechanism by which penetration enhancers such as dimethylsulfoxide (DMSO) weaken the barrier function of the skin. We have used the potential of mean constraint force (PMCF) method to calculate the free energy of pore formation in ceramide bilayers in both the innate gel phase and in the DMSO-induced fluidized state. Our simulations show that the fluid phase bilayers form archetypal water-filled hydrophilic pores similar to those observed in phospholipid bilayers. In contrast, the rigid gel-phase bilayers develop hydrophobic pores. At the relatively small pore diameters studied here, the hydrophobic pores are empty rather than filled with bulk water, suggesting that they do not compromise the barrier function of ceramide membranes. A phenomenological analysis suggests that these vapor pores are stable, below a critical radius, because the penalty of creating water-vapor and tail-vapor interfaces is lower than that of directly exposing the strongly hydrophobic tails to water. The PMCF free energy profile of the vapor pore supports this analysis. The simulations indicate that high DMSO concentrations drastically impair the barrier function of the skin by strongly reducing the free energy required for pore opening.     

Free-standing lipid films stabilized by Annexin-A5

Free-standing lipid bilayers in nano- and micro-pores are interesting membrane models and attractive for biotechnological applications. We describe here the controlled preparation of proteo-lipid mono- and bilayers using the Langmuir–Schaefer transfer or Langmuir–Blodgett technique, respectively on hydrophobic and hydrophilic surfaces. We demonstrate the formation of suspended proteo-lipid layers by Transmission Electron Microscopy (TEM) and in situ Atomic Force Microscopy (AFM) imaging. Using Annexin-A5 as a membrane-associated protein, continuous proteo-lipid mono- and bilayers were formed, which span pore arrays over areas of several square-micrometers. The 2D organization of proteins associated to lipid monolayer is well preserved during the transfer process and the protein association is Ca²⁺-dependent and therefore reversible. The simple formation and reliable transfer of stabilized free-standing lipid films is a first crucial step to create biomimetic membranes for biotechnological applications and membrane protein research.     

Peptides derived from apoptotic Bax and Bid reproduce the poration activity of the parent full-length proteins

Bax and Bid are proapoptotic proteins of the Bcl-2 family that regulate the release of apoptogenic factors from mitochondria. Although they localize constitutively in the cytoplasm, their apoptotic function is exerted at the mitochondrial outer membrane, and is related to their ability to form transbilayer pores. Here we report the poration activity of fragments from these two proteins, containing the first alpha-helix of a colicinlike hydrophobic hairpin (alpha-helix 5 of Bax and alpha-helix 6 of Bid). Both peptides readily bind to synthetic lipid vesicles, where they adopt predominantly alpha-helical structures and induce the release of entrapped calcein. In planar lipid membranes they form ion conducting channels, which in the case of the Bax-derived peptide are characterized by a two-stage pattern, a large conductivity and lipid-charge-dependent ionic selectivity. These features, together with the influence of intrinsic lipid curvature on the poration activity and the existence of two helical stretches of different orientations for the membrane-bound peptide, suggest that it forms mixed lipidic/peptidic pores of toroidal structure. In contrast, the assayed Bid fragment shows a markedly different behavior, characterized by the formation of discrete, steplike channels in planar lipid bilayers, as expected for a peptidic pore lined by a bundle of helices.     

Patch clamp studies of single intact secretory granules.

The membrane of secretory granules is involved in the molecular events that cause exocytotic fusion. Several of the proteins that have been purified from the membrane of secretory granules form ion channels when they are reconstituted in lipid bilayers and, therefore, have been thought to form part of the molecular structure of the exocytotic fusion pore. We have used the patch clamp technique to study ion conductances in single isolated secretory granules from beige mouse mast cells. We found that the membrane of the intact granule had a conductance of < 50 pS. No abrupt changes in current corresponding to the opening and closing of ion channels were observed, even under conditions where exocytotic fusion occurred. However, mechanical tension or a large voltage pulse caused the breakdown of the granule membrane resulting in the abrupt opening of a pore with an ion conductance of about 1 nS that fluctuated rapidly and could expand to an immeasurably large conductance or close completely. Surprisingly, the behavior of these pores resembled the pattern of conductance changes of exocytotic fusion pores observed in degranulating beige mast cells. This similarity supports the view that the earliest fusion pore is formed upon the breakdown of a bilayer such as that formed during hemifusion.     

Do Lipids Show State-dependent Affinity to the Voltage-gated Potassium Channel KvAP?

As all integral membrane proteins, voltage-gated ion channels are embedded in a lipid matrix that regulates their channel behavior either by physicochemical properties or by direct binding. Because manipulation of the lipid composition in cells is difficult, we investigated the influence of different lipids on purified KvAP channels reconstituted in planar lipid bilayers of known composition. Lipids developed two distinct and independent effects on the KvAP channels; lipids interacting with the pore lowered the energy barriers for the final transitions, whereas voltage sensor-bound lipids shifted the midpoint of activation dependent on their electrostatic charge. Above all, the midpoint of activation was determined only by those lipids the channels came in contact with first after purification and can seemingly only be exchanged if the channel resides in the open state. The high affinity of the bound lipids to the binding site has implications not only on our understanding of the gating mechanism but also on the general experimental design of any lipid dependence study.