Interactive signal transfer between host and pathogen during successful infection of barley leaves by Blumeria graminis and Bipolaris sorokiniana

Using ion-selective microprobes, interactive signalling between barley and Blumeria graminis or Bipolaris sorokiniana has been investigated. The question was raised whether a biotrophically growing fungus manipulates the electrical driving forces (membrane potential, transmembrane pH), required for H⁺ cotransport of energy-rich compounds. Electrodes were positioned in the substomatal cavity of open stomata or on the leaf surface, and pH was measured continuously up to several days during fungal development. We demonstrate that surface and apoplastic fluids are electrically coupled and respond in a similar manner to stimuli. Apoplastic pH, monitored from the moment of inoculation with conidia, reveals several phases: 2–4 h after inoculation of the barley leaf with either fungus, the host displays rapid transient responses after its first contact with the fungal cell wall; apoplastic pH and pCa increases, cytoplasmic pH and pCa decreases. About 1 day after inoculation, the apoplastic pH increases by up to 2 pH units, which is thought to reflect a resistance response against the intruder. Whereas barley leaf cells possess a membrane potential of −152±5 mV, hyphae of B. graminis yield −251±8 mV, indicative of a substantial driving force advantage for the fungus. Although the resting membrane potential of barley remains constant during the first days after inoculation, leaves infected with B. sorokiniana get confronted with an energy problem, indicated by a retarded repolarization following a “light-off” stimulus. Five days after inoculation, apoplastic pH has increased to 5.97±0.47 (n=11) and does no longer respond to “light-off” when measured within lesions. In contrast, it stays at near normal values outside the lesions and responds to “light-off”.It is concluded that biotrophically growing fungi do not manipulate the cotransport driving forces since (i) any change in apoplastic pH would be experienced by both partners; (ii) the resting membrane potential is not changed. It is suggested that measured pH changes reflect defence responses of the host against the fungus rather than fungal action to increase compatibility.     

Apoplastic pH signaling in barley leaves attacked by the powdery mildew fungus Blumeria graminis f. sp. hordei

To investigate apoplastic responses of barley (Hordeum vulgare L.) to the barley powdery mildew fungus Blumeria graminis f. sp. hordei, noninvasive microprobe techniques were employed. H(+)- and Ca(2+)-selective microprobes were inserted into open stomata of barley leaves inoculated with Blumeria graminis f. sp. hordei race A6 conidia. Resistance gene-mediated responses of barley genotype Ingrid (susceptible parent line) and the near-isogenic resistant Ingrid backcross lines (I-mlo5, I-Mla12, and I-Mlg) were continuously monitored from 20 min to 4 days after inoculation. The main events were categorized as short-term responses around 2 h after inoculation (hai), intermediate responses around 8 and 12 hai, and long-term responses starting between 21 and 24 hai. Short-term responses were rapid transient decreases of apoplastic H(+)- and Ca2+ activities that lasted minutes only. Kinetics were similar for all genotypes tested, and thus, these short-term responses were attributed as nonspecific first encounters of fungal surface material with the host plasma membrane. This is supported by the observation that a microinjected chitin oligomer (GlcNAc)8 yielded similar apoplastic alkalinization. Intermediate responses are trains of H+ (increase) spikes that, being different in susceptible Ingrid and penetration-resistant I-mlo5 (or I-Mlg), were interpreted as accompanying specific events of papillae formation. Long-term events were massive slow and long-lasting alkalinizations up to two pH units above control. Since these latter changes were only observed with near-isogenic hypersensitive reaction (HR)-mounting genotypes I-Mla12 and I-Mlg but not with I-mlo5 or, to a smaller extent, with susceptible Ingrid, both lacking significant rates of HR, they were rated as cell death specific. It is concluded that apoplastic pH changes are important indicators of host-pathogen interactions that correlate with both the different stages of fungal development and the different types of host defense response.     

A class III peroxidase specifically expressed in pathogen-attacked barley epidermis contributes to basal resistance

Higher plants possess large multigene families encoding secreted class III peroxidase (Prx) proteins. In barley, two Prx cDNAs encoding HvPrx07 and HvPrx08 have been isolated and characterized to some extent with respect to a resistance-mediating function upon attack by the powdery-mildew fungus Blumeria graminis f.sp. hordei ( Bgh ). Here we present evidence for the tissue-specific accumulation of a new Prx mRNA, HvPrx40 , in Bgh -attacked epidermis of barley ( Hordeum vulgare ). The encoded protein is predicted to be secreted into the apoplastic space of epidermal cells due to the absence of a C-terminal extension, which distinguishes it from other Prx proteins reported to accumulate in leaf epidermis. Transient overexpression of HvPrx40 enhanced the resistance of wheat ( Triticum aestivum ) and barley against Blumeria graminis f.sp. tritici (wheat powdery mildew) and Bgh , respectively. These findings were complemented by transient-induced gene silencing showing hypersusceptibility of barley leaf epidermal cells to Bgh . The local accumulation of oxidized 3,3-diaminobenzidine that reflects H₂O₂ production at sites of attempted fungal penetration was not reduced in HvPrx40 -silenced cells, suggesting a role of this peroxidase other than the production of reactive oxygen species.     

A small GTP-binding host protein is required for entry of powdery mildew fungus into epidermal cells of barley

Small GTP-binding proteins such as those from the RAC family are cytosolic signal transduction proteins that often are involved in processing of extracellular stimuli. Plant RAC proteins are implicated in regulation of plant cell architecture, secondary wall formation, meristem signaling, and defense against pathogens. We isolated a RacB homolog from barley (Hordeum vulgare) to study its role in resistance to the barley powdery mildew fungus (Blumeria graminis f.sp. hordei). RacB was constitutively expressed in the barley epidermis and its expression level was not strongly influenced by inoculation with B. graminis. However, after biolistic bombardment of barley leaf segments with RacB-double-stranded RNA, sequence-specific RNA interference with RacB function inhibited fungal haustorium establishment in a cell-autonomous and genotype-specific manner. Mutants compromised in function of the Mlo wild-type gene and the Ror1 gene (genotype mlo5 ror1) that are moderately susceptible to B. graminis showed no alteration in powdery mildew resistance upon RacB-specific RNA interference. Thus, the phenotype, induced by RacB-specific RNA interference, was apparently dependent on the same processes as mlo5-mediated broad resistance, which is suppressed by ror1. We conclude that an RAC small GTP-binding protein is required for successful fungal haustorium establishment and that this function may be linked to MLO-associated functions.     

Induction of beta-1,3-glucanase in barley in response to infection by fungal pathogens.

The sequence of a partial cDNA clone corresponding to an mRNA induced in leaves of barley (Hordeum vulgare) by infection with fungal pathogens matched almost perfectly with that of a cDNA clone coding for beta-1,-3-glucanase isolated from the scutellum of barley. Western blot analysis of intercellular proteins from near-isogenic barley lines inoculated with the powdery mildew fungus (Erysiphe graminis f. sp. hordei) showed a strong induction of glucanase in all inoculated lines but was most pronounced in two resistant lines. These data were confirmed by beta-1,3-glucanase assays. The barley cDNA was used as a hybridization probe to detect mRNAs in barley, wheat (Triticum aestivum), rice (oryza sativus), and sorghum (Sorghum bicolor), which are induced by infection with the necrotrophic pathogen Bipolaris sorokiniana. These results demonstrate that activation of beta-1,3-glucanase genes may be a general response of cereals to infection by fungal pathogens.     

A barley ROP GTPase ACTIVATING PROTEIN associates with microtubules and regulates entry of the barley powdery mildew fungus into leaf epidermal cells

Little is known about the function of host factors involved in disease susceptibility. The barley (Hordeum vulgare) ROP (RHO of plants) G-protein RACB is required for full susceptibility of the leaf epidermis to invasion by the biotrophic fungus Blumeria graminis f. sp hordei. Stable transgenic knockdown of RACB reduced the ability of barley to accommodate haustoria of B. graminis in intact epidermal leaf cells and to form hairs on the root epidermis, suggesting that RACB is a common element of root hair outgrowth and ingrowth of haustoria in leaf epidermal cells. We further identified a barley MICROTUBULE-ASSOCIATED ROP-GTPASE ACTIVATING PROTEIN (MAGAP1) interacting with RACB in yeast and in planta. Fluorescent MAGAP1 decorated cortical microtubules and was recruited by activated RACB to the cell periphery. Under fungal attack, MAGAP1-labeled microtubules built a polarized network at sites of successful defense. By contrast, microtubules loosened where the fungus succeeded in penetration. Genetic evidence suggests a function of MAGAP1 in limiting susceptibility to penetration by B. graminis. Additionally, MAGAP1 influenced the polar organization of cortical microtubules. These results add to our understanding of how intact plant cells accommodate fungal infection structures and suggest that RACB and MAGAP1 might be antagonistic players in cytoskeleton organization for fungal entry.     

Root Colonization by Bipolaris sorokiniana in Different Cereals and Relations to Lesion Development and Natural Root Cortical Cell Death

A GUS-transformed strain of B. sorokiniana was used to study the relationship between fungal growth, lesion development and natural root cortical cell death (RCD) in roots of different cereals. Roots of 10-day-old seedlings, grown on filter paper, were inoculated with the fungus and at different time intervals lesion size and GUS-activity in the roots were determined. A significant, positive correlation was found between GUS-activity and ergosterol content in barley roots infected with this transformed strain and these results indicate that GUS can be used as a marker to study fungal growth in plant tissue. The fungus had a slower growth rate in resistant barley varieties, i.e., those producing smaller lesions, than in more susceptible varieties.
In wheat and triticale, the fungal growth was faster than in barley, despite the smaller and lighter coloured lesions in these species. This may be explained by the fact that wheat and triticale have a faster rate of root cortical senescence than barley. Presumably, dying cortex cells cannot respond to the fungal invasion by producing phenolic compounds that cause browning of the tissue. Among seven investigated cereal species, there was a positive correlation between the degree of RCD and fungal biomass increase in roots after inoculation.     

Heterologous expression of genes mediating enhanced fungal resistance in transgenic wheat.

Three cDNAs encoding the antifungal protein Ag-AFP from the fungus Aspergillus giganteus, a barley class II chitinase and a barley type I RIP, all regulated by the constitutive Ubiquitin1 promoter from maize, were expressed in transgenic wheat. In 17 wheat lines, stable integration and inheritance of one of the three transgenes has been demonstrated over four generations. The formation of powdery mildew (Erysiphe graminis f. sp. tritici) or leaf rust (Puccinia recondita f. sp. tritici) colonies was significantly reduced on leaves from afp or chitinase II- but not from rip I-expressing wheat lines compared with non-transgenic controls. The increased resistance of afp and chitinase II lines was dependent on the dose of fungal spores used for inoculation. Heterologous expression of the fungal afp gene and the barley chitinase II gene in wheat demonstrated that colony formation and, thereby, spreading of two important biotrophic fungal diseases is inhibited approximately 40 to 50% at an inoculum density of 80 to 100 spores per cm2.     

Root-to-shoot signalling: apoplastic alkalinization,a general stress response and defence factor in barley (<Emphasis Type="Italic">Hordeum vulgare</Emphasis>)

Summary. We used a noninvasive microprobe technique to record in substomatal cavities of barley leaves the apoplastic pH response to different stress situations. When K⁺ (or Na⁺) activity at the roots of intact plants was increased from 1 to 50 mM, the leaf apoplastic pH increased by 0.4 to 0.6 units within 8 to 12 min when stomata were open, and within 15 to 20 min when stomata were closed. This reaction was accompanied by a correlative increase in K⁺ activity. Addition of 1 μM abscisic acid caused an apoplastic alkalinization of 0.5 to 0.8 units, and low temperatures (4 °C) increased pH by 0.2 to 0.3 units. Addition of 100 mM sorbitol or pH changes in the range 4.0 to 7.9 had no effect, ruling out that osmotic potential and/or pH is the carried signal. On detached leaves, the same treatments yielded qualitatively similar results, suggesting that the xylem is the most likely signal path. Following the attack of powdery mildew, the apoplastic pH of barley leaves substantially increases. We demonstrate that in susceptible barley, pretreatment (soil drench) with the resistance-inducing chemical benzo- (1,2,3)thiadiazole-7-carbothioic acid S-methyl ester markedly enhances this pH response. This is consistent with previous finding that apoplastic alkalinization is related to the degree of resistance towards this fungus. Correspondence and reprints: Botanisches Institut I, Justus-Liebig-Universit?t, Senckenbergstra?e 17, 35390 Gie?en, Federal Republic of Germany.     

Dissection of heat-induced systemic signals: superiority of ion fluxes to voltage changes in substomatal cavities

Using non-invasive ion-selective microprobes, that were placed in substomatal cavities, long-distance signalling has been investigated in intact Hordeum vulgare and Vicia faba seedlings. Heat (flame), applied to one leaf (S-leaf), triggers apoplastic ion activity (pH, pCa, pCl) transients in a distant leaf (T-leaf), all largely independent of simultaneously occurring action potential-like voltage changes. While apoplastic pCa and pH increase (Ca²⁺-, H⁺-activities decrease), pCl decreases (Cl⁻-activity increases). As the signal transfer from the S- to the T-leaf is too fast to account for mass flow, the heat-induced pressure change is primarily responsible for changes in voltage (H⁺ pump deactivation) as well as for the ion fluxes. The pCa transient precedes the pCl- and pH responses, but not the voltage change. Since the apoplastic pCl decrease (Cl⁻ increase) occurs after the pCa increase (Ca²⁺ decrease) and after the depolarization, we argue that the Cl⁻ efflux is a consequence of the Ca²⁺ response, but has no part in the depolarization. Kinetic analysis reveals that pH- and pCl changes are interrelated, indicated by the action of the anion channel antagonist NPPB, which inhibits both pCl- and pH changes. It is suggested that efflux of organic anions into the apoplast causes the pH increase rather than the deactivation of the plasma membrane H⁺ pump. Since there is considerably more information in ion activity changes than in a single action- or variation potential and heat-induced ion fluxes occur more reliably than voltage changes, released by milder stimuli, they are considered systemic signalling components superior to voltage.     

Apoplastic pH and Fe(3+) reduction in intact sunflower leaves

It has been hypothesized that under NO(3)(-) nutrition a high apoplastic pH in leaves depresses Fe(3+) reductase activity and thus the subsequent Fe(2+) transport across the plasmalemma, inducing Fe chlorosis. The apoplastic pH in young green leaves of sunflower (Helianthus annuus L.) was measured by fluorescence ratio after xylem sap infiltration. It was shown that NO(3)(-) nutrition significantly increased apoplastic pH at distinct interveinal sites (pH >/= 6.3) and was confined to about 10% of the whole interveinal leaf apoplast. These apoplastic pH increases presumably derive from NO(3)(-)/proton cotransport and are supposed to be related to growing cells of a young leaf; they were not found in the case of sole NH(4)(+) or NH(4)NO(3) nutrition. Complementary to pH measurements, the formation of Fe(2+)-ferrozine from Fe(3+)-citrate was monitored in the xylem apoplast of intact leaves in the presence of buffers at different xylem apoplastic pH by means of image analysis. This analysis revealed that Fe(3+) reduction increased with decreasing apoplastic pH, with the highest rates at around pH 5. 0. In analogy to the monitoring of Fe(3+) reduction in the leaf xylem, we suggest that under alkaline nutritional conditions at interveinal microsites of increased apoplastic pH, Fe(3+) reduction is depressed, inducing leaf chlorosis. The apoplastic pH in the xylem vessels remained low in the still-green veins of leaves with intercostal chlorosis.     

Interaction Between Root and Leaf Disease Development in Barley Cultivars after Inoculation with Different Isolates of Bipolaris sorokiniana

The relationship between root and leaf infection in 11 cultivars of barley ( Hordeum vulgare ) by different isolates of Bipolaris sorokiniana was investigated in young plants. Roots of 10-day-old seedlings, grown in filterpaper rolls, and the third leaf of 17-day-old seedlings were inoculated with the different isolates and a Disease Development Index (DDI) was calculated.
The rate of lesion development in leaves was higher than in roots, indicated by generally higher DDI after leaf inoculation than after root inoculation. Significant differences in resistance were found among the barley cultivars. Inoculation with different isolates of B. sorokiniana caused significant differences in DDI for both roots and leaves. In the leaves, but not in the roots, a significant cultivar–isolate interaction was found. No significant correlations, neither in isolate aggressiveness nor in cultivar reaction between root and leaf, were observed.     

Histological and molecular analysis of Rdg2a barley resistance to leaf stripe

Barley (Hordeum vulgare L.) leaf stripe is caused by the seed-borne fungus Pyrenophora graminea. We investigated microscopically and molecularly the reaction of barley embryos to leaf stripe inoculation. In the resistant genotype NIL3876-Rdg2a, fungal growth ceased at the scutellar node of the embryo, while in the susceptible near-isogenic line (NIL) Mirco-rdg2a fungal growth continued past the scutellar node and into the embryo. Pathogen-challenged embryos of resistant and susceptible NILs showed different levels of UV autofluorescence and toluidine blue staining, indicating differential accumulation of phenolic compounds. Suppression subtractive hybridization and cDNA amplified fragment-length polymorphism (AFLP) analyses of embryos identified P. graminea-induced and P. graminea-repressed barley genes. In addition, cDNA-AFLP analysis identified six pathogenicity-associated fungal genes expressed during barley infection but at low to undetectable levels during growth on artificial media. Microarrays representing the entire set of differentially expressed cDNA-AFLP fragments and 100 barley homologues of previously described defence-related genes were used to study gene expression changes at 7 and 14 days after inoculation in the resistant and susceptible NILs. A total of 171 significantly modulated barley genes were identified and assigned to four groups based on timing and genotype dependence of expression. Analysis of the changes in gene expression during the barley resistance response to leaf stripe suggests that the Rdg2a-mediated response includes cell-wall reinforcement, signal transduction, generation of reactive oxygen species, cell protection, jasmonate signalling and expression of plant effector genes. The identification of genes showing leaf stripe inoculation or resistance-dependent expression sets the stage for further dissection of the resistance response of barley embryo cells to leaf stripe.     

The receptor-like MLO protein and the RAC/ROP family G-protein RACB modulate actin reorganization in barley attacked by the biotrophic powdery mildew fungus Blumeria graminis f.sp. hordei

Cytoskeleton remodelling is a crucial process in determining the polarity of dividing and growing plant cells, as well as during interactions with the environment. Nothing is currently known about the proteins, which regulate actin remodelling during interactions with invading pathogens. The biotrophic powdery mildew fungus Blumeria graminis f.sp. hordei (Bgh) invades susceptible barley (Hordeum vulgare L.) by penetrating epidermal cells, which remain intact during fungal development. In contrast, resistant host plants prevent infection by inhibiting penetration through apoplastic mechanisms, which require focusing defence reactions on the site of attack. We stained actin filaments in a susceptible Mlo-genotype and a near-isogenic race-non-specifically resistant barley mlo5-mutant genotype using fluorescence-labelled phalloidin after chemical fixation. This revealed that the actin cytoskeleton is differentially reorganized in susceptible and resistant hosts challenged by Bgh. Actin filaments were polarized towards the sites of attempted penetration in the resistant host, whereas when susceptible hosts were penetrated, a more subtle reorganization took place around fungal haustoria. Strong actin filament focusing towards sites of fungal attack was closely associated with successful prevention of penetration. Actin focusing was less frequent and seemingly delayed in susceptible wild-type barley expressing the susceptibility factor MLO. Additionally, single cell overexpression of a constitutively activated RAC/ROP G-protein, CA RACB, another potential host susceptibility factor and hypothetical actin cytoskeleton regulator, partly inhibited actin reorganization when under attack from Bgh, whereas knockdown of RACB promoted actin focusing. We conclude that RACB and, potentially, MLO are host proteins involved in the modulation of actin reorganization and cell polarity in the interaction of barley with Bgh.     

Apoplastic Sugar Concentration and pH in Barley Leaves Infected with Brown Rust

Soluble sugars were extracted by low speed centrifugation fromthe apoplast of leaves of barley (Hordeum distichum L.) infiltratedwith water. Infection of the leaf with the brown rust fungus(Puccinia hordeii) resulted in a reduction in the concentrationof sucrose, glucose and fructose in the apoplast. Sugars werepresent in an apoplastic space occupying 12 and 17 cm³ m^–2of leaf area in healthy and infected tissue, respectively. Uptakeof hexoses by intercellular hyphae is suggested as a cause ofthis reduction. The pH of apoplastic sap extracted from rust-infectedleaves was increased to pH 7·3 from pH 6·6 incontrols. The effect of a reduced apoplastic sugar pool andincreased pH on export from infected leaves is discussed. Key words: Apoplast, barley (Hordeum distichum L.), brown rust (Puccinia hordeii Otth.), pH, sucrose, hexose     

Resistance induction in barley coleoptile cells by intracellular pH decline

Cytoplasmic acidification in suspension-cultured plant cells has been characterized as a common intracellular response of some kinds of plant cells to elicitors. Expression of various defense genes in these cells has been increased by the cytoplasmic acidification itself without treatment by elicitors. It is not evident, however, whether or not cells with acidified cytoplasm actually exhibit resistance to the pathogen because of the lack of an adequate infection system between cultured plant cells and some pathogens. Using barley coleoptiles rather than suspension-cultured cells, we demonstrated both detection of cellular pH decline and increased resistance to Blumeria graminis. The cytoplasmic pH of barley coleoptile cells floated on 1 mM citrate buffer (CB), pH 4.0, became 0.5 unit lower than that of cells floated on 1 mM CB, pH 8.0, within 30 min after treatment. The penetration efficiency of B. graminis into the coleoptile was decreased in a pH-dependent manner; that is, when the coleoptiles were floated on 1 mM CB, pH 8.0, the penetration efficiency of the fungi was about 80%. In contrast, when the coleoptiles were floated on acidic buffers, the penetration efficiency decreased in parallel the decline of pH and the penetration efficiency reached 0% when coleoptiles were floated on 1 mM CB, pH 4.0. Morphogenesis of appressoria on the coleoptiles floating on CB was not influenced. The lowered penetration efficiency at lower pH was partially cancelled when the barley coleoptiles were irradiated with UV for 5 min prior to B. graminis inoculation. These findings suggest that the decline in cytoplasmic pH in barley coleoptile cells increases resistance to the pathogenic fungus B. graminis.     

The Ability of Barley Powdery Mildew to Grow in vitro

A technique was developed for the in vitro culture of Blumeria graminis f. sp. hordei , an obligate biotrophic pathogen of barley. Optimal growth occurred at pH 5.6 on a medium containing 39 gl^–1 potato dextrose agar, 40 gl^–1 shredded fresh barley leaves, 20 gl^–1 sucrose, 13 mgl^–1 kanamycin and 80 mgl^–1 benzimidazole. At 20°C (90% relative humidity), conidia germinated 48 h after inoculation, producing an average colony diameter of 1 cm after 10 days. However, numerous colonies were present on the medium after 15 days. Light microscopy showed that there was a positive relationship between the amount of leaf in the medium and fungus growth. The fungus retained its virulence during 60 days of storage in vitro , and was able to infect barley. This is a useful and novel technique that could be beneficial in barley pathology breeding programs.