Biosynthetic preparation of selectively deuterated phosphatidylcholine in genetically modified <Emphasis Type="Italic">Escherichia coli</Emphasis>

Phosphatidylcholine (PC) is a major component of eukaryotic cell membranes and one of the most commonly used phospholipids for reconstitution of membrane proteins into carrier systems such as lipid vesicles, micelles and nanodiscs. Selectively deuterated versions of this lipid have many applications, especially in structural studies using techniques such as NMR, neutron reflectivity and small-angle neutron scattering. Here we present a comprehensive study of selective deuteration of phosphatidylcholine through biosynthesis in a genetically modified strain of Escherichia coli. By carefully tuning the deuteration level in E. coli growth media and varying the deuteration of supplemented carbon sources, we show that it is possible to achieve a controlled deuteration for three distinct parts of the PC lipid molecule, namely the (a) lipid head group, (b) glycerol backbone and (c) fatty acyl tail. This biosynthetic approach paves the way for the synthesis of specifically deuterated, physiologically relevant phospholipid species which remain difficult to obtain through standard chemical synthesis.     

Vesicle Adhesion and Fusion Studied by Small-Angle X-Ray Scattering

We have studied the adhesion state (also denoted by docking state) of lipid vesicles as induced by the divalent ions Ca²⁺ or Mg²⁺ at well-controlled ion concentration, lipid composition, and charge density. The bilayer structure and the interbilayer distance in the docking state were analyzed by small-angle x-ray scattering. A strong adhesion state was observed for DOPC:DOPS vesicles, indicating like-charge attraction resulting from ion correlations. The observed interbilayer separations of ～1.6 nm agree quantitatively with the predictions of electrostatics in the strong coupling regime. Although this phenomenon was observed when mixing anionic and zwitterionic (or neutral) lipids, pure anionic membranes (DOPS) with highest charge density σ resulted in a direct phase transition to a multilamellar state, which must be accompanied by rupture and fusion of vesicles. To extend the structural assay toward protein-controlled docking and fusion, we have characterized reconstituted N-ethylmaleimide-sensitive factor attachment protein receptors in controlled proteoliposome suspensions by small-angle x-ray scattering.     

Bending Rigidities and Interdomain Forces in Membranes with Coexisting Lipid Domains

To precisely quantify the fundamental interactions between heterogeneous lipid membranes with coexisting liquid-ordered (Lo) and liquid-disordered (Ld) domains, we performed detailed osmotic stress small-angle x-ray scattering experiments by exploiting the domain alignment in raft-mimicking lipid multibilayers. Performing a Monte Carlo-based analysis allowed us to determine with high reliability the magnitude and functional dependence of interdomain forces concurrently with the bending elasticity moduli. In contrast to previous methodologies, this approach enabled us to consider the entropic undulation repulsions on a fundamental level, without having to take recourse to crudely justified mean-field-like additivity assumptions. Our detailed Hamaker-coefficient calculations indicated only small differences in the van der Waals attractions of coexisting Lo and Ld phases. In contrast, the repulsive hydration and undulation interactions differed significantly, with the latter dominating the overall repulsions in the Ld phase. Thus, alignment of like domains in multibilayers appears to originate from both, hydration and undulation repulsions.     

Assessing the efficacy of vesicle fusion with planar membrane arrays using a mitochondrial porin as reporter

Reconstitution of functionally active membrane protein into artificially made lipid bilayers is a challenge that must be overcome to create a membrane-based biomimetic sensor and separation device. In this study we address the efficacy of proteoliposome fusion with planar membrane arrays. We establish a protein incorporation efficacy assay using the major non-specific porin of Fusobacterium nucleatum (FomA) as reporter. We use electrical conductance measurements and fluorescence microscopy to characterize proteoliposome fusion with an array of planar membranes. We show that protein reconstitution in biomimetic membrane arrays may be quantified using the developed FomA assay. Specifically, we show that FomA vesicles are inherently fusigenic. Optimal FomA incorporation is obtained with a proteoliposome lipid-to-protein molar ratio (LPR) = 50 more than 10⁵ FomA proteins could be incorporated in a bilayer array with a total membrane area of 2 mm² within 20 min. This novel assay for quantifying protein delivery into lipid bilayers may be a useful tool in developing biomimetic membrane applications.     

Purification and reconstitution of the bile acid transport system from hepatocyte sinusoidal plasma membranes

The taurocholic acid transport system from hepatocyte sinusoidal plasma membranes has been studied using proteoliposome reconstitution procedures. Membrane proteins were initially solubilized in Triton X-100. Following detergent removal, the resultant proteins were incorporated into lipid vesicles prepared from soybean phospholipids (asolectin) using sonication and freeze-thaw procedures. The resultant proteoliposomes demonstrated Na+-dependent transport of taurocholic acid which could be inhibited by bile acids. Greatly reduced amounts of taurocholic acid were associated with the phospholipid or membrane proteins alone prior to proteoliposome formation. Membrane proteins were fractionated on an anionic glycocholate-Sepharose 4B affinity column which was prepared by coupling (3 alpha,7 alpha,12 alpha-trihydroxy-5 beta-cholan-24-oyl)-N alpha-lysine to activated CH-Sepharose 4B via the epsilon-amino group of lysine resulting in the retention of a free carboxyl group. The adsorbed proteins enriched in components in the 54 kDa zone, which were originally identified by photoaffinity labeling to be components of the bile acid transport system, were also incorporated into liposomes. This vesicle system showed almost a 4-fold increase in Na+-dependent taurocholic acid uptake when compared to proteoliposomes formed from total membrane protein, as well as sensitivity to inhibition by bile acids. These results demonstrate that the bile acid carrier system can be reconstituted in proteoliposomes and that utilizing proteins in the 54 kDa zone leads to a significant enhancement in the transport capacity of the reconstituted system, consistent with the role of 54 kDa protein(s) as component(s) of the bile acid carrier system.     

Biomimetic design of nanopatterned membranes

The biomimetic approach copying the supramolecular building principle of many archaeal cell envelopes (i.e., a plasma membrane with associated S-layer proteins) has resulted in stable lipid membranes with excellent reconstitution properties for transmembrane proteins. This is a particular challenge as one-third of all proteins in an organism are membrane proteins like pores, ion channels, or receptors. At S-layer supported lipid membranes, spatial well-defined domains on the S-layer protein interact noncovalently with lipid head groups within the lipid membrane resulting in a nanopatterning of a few anchored and scores of diffusional free-lipid molecules. In addition, no impact on the hydrophobic core region and on the function of reconstituted integral proteins has been determined. Among others, particularly S-layer stabilized membranes can be used for structure-function studies on reconstituted integral proteins and also in the membrane protein-based molecular nanotechnology, e.g., in the design of biosensing devices (e.g., lipid chip or lab-on-a-chip), or for receptor or ion channel-based high-throughput screening.     

Reconstituted syntaxin1a/SNAP25 interacts with negatively charged lipids as measured by lateral diffusion in planar supported bilayers.

According to the soluble N-ethylmaleimide-sensitive factor (NSF)-attachment protein (SNAP) receptor hypothesis (SNARE hypothesis), interactions between target SNAREs and vesicle SNAREs (t- and v-SNAREs) are required for membrane fusion in intracellular vesicle transport and exocytosis. The precise role of the SNAREs in tethering, docking, and fusion is still disputed. Biophysical measurements of SNARE interactions in planar supported membranes could potentially resolve some of the key questions regarding the mechanism of SNARE-mediated membrane fusion. As a first step toward this goal, recombinant syntaxin1A/SNAP25 (t-SNARE) was reconstituted into polymer-supported planar lipid bilayers. Reconstituted t-SNAREs in supported bilayers bound soluble green fluorescent protein/vesicle-associated membrane protein (v-SNARE), and the SNARE complexes could be specifically dissociated by NSF/alpha-SNAP in the presence of ATP. The physiological activities of SNARE complex formation were thus well reproduced in this reconstituted planar model membrane system. A large fraction (~75%) of the reconstituted t-SNARE was laterally mobile with a lateral diffusion coefficient of 7.5 x 10(-9) cm(2)/s in a phosphatidylcholine lipid background. Negatively charged lipids reduced the mobile fraction of the t-SNARE and the lipids themselves. Phosphatidylinositol-4,5-bisphosphate was more effective than phosphatidylserine in reducing the lateral mobility of the complexes. A model of how acidic lipid-SNARE interactions might alter lipid fluidity is discussed.     

Reconstitution of liver endoplasmic reticulum membranes from solubilized proteins and lipids by removal of detergent]

A method for membrane reconstitution from cholate-solubilized microsomal proteins and lipids by a removal of the detergent on a column with charcoal has been developed. A comparative study showed that the membranes reconstituted by a dialysis or absorption do not differ from each other in terms of membrane proteins incorporation into lipid vesicles and cytochrome P-450 reconversion into cytochrome P-450. A possibility of biomembrane reconstitution from membrane proteins and lipids solubilized by a non-ionic detergent Triton X-100 was shown. A removal of the detergent results in a formation of membranes, which are chemically close to the original ones but ultrastructurally very different from the latter. On the other hand, absorption or dialysis of cholate-solubilized proteins and lipids results in reconstituted membranes with asymmetrically arranged intramembrane particles located on the hydrophobic surfaces of the membrane halves. The number and size of these particles are similar to those of the original microsomal membranes.     

Reconstitution of membrane proteins into giant unilamellar vesicles via peptide-induced fusion

In this work, we present a protocol to reconstitute membrane proteins into giant unilamellar vesicles (GUV) via peptide-induced fusion. In principle, GUV provide a well-defined lipid matrix, resembling a close-to-native state for biophysical studies, including optical microspectroscopy, of transmembrane proteins at the molecular level. Furthermore, reconstitution in this manner would also eliminate potential artifacts arising from secondary interactions of proteins, when reconstituted in planar membranes supported on solid surfaces. However, assembly procedures of GUV preclude direct reconstitution. Here, for the first time, a method is described that allows the controlled incorporation of membrane proteins into GUV. We demonstrate that large unilamellar vesicles (LUV, diameter 0.1 microm), to which the small fusogenic peptide WAE has been covalently attached, readily fuse with GUV, as revealed by monitoring lipid and contents mixing by fluorescence microscopy. To monitor contents mixing, a new fluorescence-based enzymatic assay was devised. Fusion does not introduce changes in the membrane morphology, as shown by fluorescence correlation spectroscopy. Analysis of fluorescence confocal imaging intensity revealed that approximately 6 to 10 LUV fused per microm(2) of GUV surface. As a model protein, bacteriorhodopsin (BR) was reconstituted into GUV, using LUV into which BR was incorporated via detergent dialysis. BR did not affect GUV-LUV fusion and the protein was stably inserted into the GUV and functionally active. Fluorescence correlation spectroscopy experiments show that BR inserted into GUV undergoes unrestricted Brownian motion with a diffusion coefficient of 1.2 microm(2)/s. The current procedure offers new opportunities to address issues related to membrane-protein structure and dynamics in a close-to-native state.     

Nanoscale structural and mechanical effects of beta-amyloid (1-42) on polymer cushioned membranes: a combined study by neutron reflectometry and AFM Force Spectroscopy

The interaction of beta-amyloid peptides with lipid membranes is widely studied as trigger agents in Alzheimer's disease. Their mechanism of action at the molecular level is unknown and their interaction with the neural membrane is crucial to elucidate the onset of the disease. In this study we have investigated the interaction of water soluble forms of beta-amyloid Aβ(1-42) with lipid bilayers supported by polymer cushion. A reproducible protocol for the preparation of a supported phospholipid membrane with composition mimicking the neural membrane and in physiological condition (PBS buffer, pH=7.4) was refined by neutron reflectivity. The change in structure and local mechanical properties of the membrane in the presence of Aβ(1-42) was investigated by neutron reflectivity and Atomic Force Microscopy (AFM) Force Spectroscopy. Neutron reflectivity evidenced that Aβ(1-42) interacts strongly with the supported membrane, causing a change in the scattering length density profile of the lipid bilayer, and penetrates into the membrane. Concomitantly, the local mechanical properties of the bilayer are deeply modified by the interaction with the peptide as seen by AFM Force Spectroscopy. These results may be of great importance for the onset of the Alzheimer's disease, since a simultaneous change in the structural and mechanical properties of the lipid matrix could influence all membrane based signal cascades.     

Mimetic Membrane System to Carry Multiple Antigenic Proteins from Leishmania amazonensis

Liposomes have long been used as models for lipid membranes and for the reconstitution of a single or multiple proteins. Also, liposomes have adjuvant activity in vaccines against several protozoan or bacterial organisms. Thus, the main objective of the present study was to obtain a crude extract of detergent-solubilized proteins of Leishmania amazonensis amastigotes and reconstitute them into liposomes. Neutral and zwiterionic detergents were less efficient than an ionic detergent. In order to obtain efficient solubilization using only sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS), the effects of detergent and protein concentration and incubation time were studied. The maximum of solubilized proteins was obtained instantaneously using a ratio of 0.5 mg/ml of protein to 0.1% (w/v) detergent at 4°C. Dipalmitoylphosphatidylcholine (DPPC), dipalmitoylphosphatidylserine (DPPS) and cholesterol in a weight ratio of 5:1:4 were used for protein reconstitution into liposomes using the cosolubilization method, yielding 60% of incorporation. The incorporation of multiple parasite proteins results in a vesicular diameter of proteoliposomes of about 140 nm, presenting a final lipid weight ratio for DPPC, DPPS and cholesterol of 1:1:5, with high stability. The detergent-solubilized proteins of L. amazonensis amastigotes present in the proteoliposome, when analyzed by SDS-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis, include a wide range of parasite-incorporated proteins. BALB/c mice inoculated with these proteoliposomes were able to produce antibodies against the proteins reconstituted in DPPC:DPPS:cholesterol liposomes and were partially resistant to infection with L. amazonensis promastigotes. These results indicate that this system can be used as a possible vaccine against L. amazonensis.     

Protein Determinants of SNARE-Mediated Lipid Mixing

Soluble N-ethylmaleimide sensitive factor attachment protein receptor (SNARE)-mediated lipid mixing can be efficiently recapitulated in vitro by the incorporation of purified vesicle membrane (-v) SNARE and target membrane (t-) SNARE proteins into separate liposome populations. Despite the strong correlation between the observed activities in this system and the known SNARE physiology, some recent works have suggested that SNARE-mediated lipid mixing may be limited to circumstances where membrane defects arise from artifactual reconstitution conditions (such as nonphysiological high-protein concentrations or unrealistically small liposome populations). Here, we show that the previously published strategies used to reconstitute SNAREs into liposomes do not significantly affect either the physical parameters of the proteoliposomes or the ability of SNAREs to drive lipid mixing in vitro. The surface density of SNARE proteins turns out to be the most critical parameter, which controls both the rate and the extent of SNARE-mediated liposome fusion. In addition, the specific activity of the t-SNARE complex is significantly influenced by expression and reconstitution protocols, such that we only observe optimal lipid mixing when the t-SNARE proteins are coexpressed before purification.     

Composite S-layer lipid structures

Designing and utilization of biomimetic membrane systems generated by bottom-up processes is a rapidly growing scientific and engineering field. Elucidation of the supramolecular construction principle of archaeal cell envelopes composed of S-layer stabilized lipid membranes led to new strategies for generating highly stable functional lipid membranes at meso- and macroscopic scale. In this review, we provide a state of the art survey how S-layer proteins, lipids, and polysaccharides may be used as basic building blocks for the assembly of S-layer supported lipid membranes. These biomimetic membrane systems are distinguished by a nanopatterned fluidity, enhanced stability and longevity and thus, provide a dedicated reconstitution matrix for membrane-active peptides and transmembrane proteins. Exciting areas for application of composite S-layer membrane systems concern sensor systems involving specific membrane functions.     

A partially zipped SNARE complex stabilized by the membrane

The SNARE complex acts centrally for intracellular membrane fusion, an essential process for vesicular transport in cells. Association between vesicle-associated (v-) SNARE and target membrane (t-) SNARE results in the coiled coil core that bridges two membranes. Here, the structure of the SNARE complex assembled by recombinant t-SNARE Sso1p/Sec9 and v-SNARE Snc2p, which are involved in post-Golgi trafficking in yeast, was investigated using EPR. In detergent solutions, SNAREs formed a fully assembled core. However, when t-SNAREs were reconstituted into the proteoliposome and mixed with the soluble SNARE motif of Snc2p, a partially zipped core in which the N-terminal region is structured, whereas the C-terminal region is frayed, was detected. The partially zipped and fully assembled complexes coexisted with little free energy difference between them. Thus, the core complex formation of yeast SNAREs might not serve as the energy source for the fusion, which is different from what has been known for neuronal SNAREs. On the other hand, the results from the proteoliposome fusion assay, employing cysteine- and nitroxide-scanning mutants of Sso1p, suggested that the formation of the complete core is required for membrane fusion. This implies that core SNARE assembly plays an essential role in setting up the proper geometry of the lipid-protein complex for the successful fusion.     

Structure and stability of the spinach aquaporin SoPIP2;1 in detergent micelles and lipid membranes

Background

SoPIP2;1 constitutes one of the major integral proteins in spinach leaf plasma membranes and belongs to the aquaporin family. SoPIP2;1 is a highly permeable and selective water channel that has been successfully overexpressed and purified with high yields. In order to optimize reconstitution of the purified protein into biomimetic systems, we have here for the first time characterized the structural stability of SoPIP2;1.

Methodology/Principal Finding

We have characterized the protein structural stability after purification and after reconstitution into detergent micelles and proteoliposomes using circular dichroism and fluorescence spectroscopy techniques. The structure of SoPIP2;1 was analyzed either with the protein solubilized with octyl-β-D-glucopyranoside (OG) or reconstituted into lipid membranes formed by E. coli lipids, diphytanoylphosphatidylcholine (DPhPC), or reconstituted into lipid membranes formed from mixtures of 1-palmitoyl-2-oleoyl-phosphatidylcholine (POPE), 1-palmitoyl-2oleoyl-phosphatidylethanolamine (POPE), 1-palmitoyl-2-oleoyl-phosphatidylserine (POPS), and ergosterol. Generally, SoPIP2;1 secondary structure was found to be predominantly α-helical in accordance with crystallographic data. The protein has a high thermal structural stability in detergent solutions, with an irreversible thermal unfolding occurring at a melting temperature of 58°C. Incorporation of the protein into lipid membranes increases the structural stability as evidenced by an increased melting temperature of up to 70°C.

Conclusion/Significance

The results of this study provide insights into SoPIP2;1 stability in various host membranes and suggest suitable choices of detergent and lipid composition for reconstitution of SoPIP2;1 into biomimetic membranes for biotechnological applications.     

Interaction of tau protein with model lipid membranes induces tau structural compaction and membrane disruption

The misfolding and aggregation of the intrinsically disordered, microtubule-associated tau protein into neurofibrillary tangles is implicated in the pathogenesis of Alzheimer's disease. However, the mechanisms of tau aggregation and toxicity remain unknown. Recent work has shown that anionic lipid membranes can induce tau aggregation and that membrane permeabilization may serve as a pathway by which protein aggregates exert toxicity, suggesting that the plasma membrane may play dual roles in tau pathology. This prompted our investigation to assess tau's propensity to interact with membranes and to elucidate the mutually disruptive structural perturbations the interactions induce in both tau and the membrane. We show that although highly charged and soluble, the full-length tau (hTau40) is also highly surface active, selectively inserts into anionic DMPG lipid monolayers and induces membrane morphological changes. To resolve molecular-scale structural details of hTau40 associated with lipid membranes, X-ray and neutron scattering techniques are utilized. X-ray reflectivity indicates hTau40s presence underneath a DMPG monolayer and penetration into the lipid headgroups and tailgroups, whereas grazing incidence X-ray diffraction shows that hTau40 insertion disrupts lipid packing. Moreover, both air/water and DMPG lipid membrane interfaces induce the disordered hTau40 to partially adopt a more compact conformation with density similar to that of a folded protein. Neutron reflectivity shows that tau completely disrupts supported DMPG bilayers while leaving the neutral DPPC bilayer intact. Our results show that hTau40s strong interaction with anionic lipids induces tau structural compaction and membrane disruption, suggesting possible membrane-based mechanisms of tau aggregation and toxicity in neurodegenerative diseases.     

Stairway to Asymmetry: Five Steps to Lipid-Asymmetric Proteoliposomes

Membrane proteins are embedded in a complex lipid environment that influences their structure and function. One key feature of nearly all biological membranes is a distinct lipid asymmetry. However, the influence of membrane asymmetry on proteins is poorly understood, and novel asymmetric proteoliposome systems are beneficial. To our knowledge, we present the first study on a multispanning protein incorporated in large unilamellar liposomes showing a stable lipid asymmetry. These asymmetric proteoliposomes contain the Na⁺/H⁺ antiporter NhaA from Salmonella Typhimurium. Asymmetry was introduced by partial, outside-only exchange of anionic phosphatidylglycerol (PG), mimicking this key asymmetry of bacterial membranes. Outer-leaflet and total fractions of PG were determined via ζ-potential (ζ) measurements after lipid exchange and after scrambling of asymmetry. ζ-Values were in good agreement with exclusive outside localization of PG. The electrogenic Na⁺/H⁺ antiporter was active in asymmetric liposomes, and it can be concluded that reconstitution and generation of asymmetry were successful. Lipid asymmetry was stable for more than 7 days at 23°C and thus enabled characterization of the Na⁺/H⁺ antiporter in an asymmetric lipid environment. We present and validate a simple five-step protocol that addresses key steps to be taken and pitfalls to be avoided for the preparation of asymmetric proteoliposomes: 1) optimization of desired lipid composition, 2) detergent-mediated protein reconstitution with subsequent detergent removal, 3) generation of lipid asymmetry by partial exchange of outer-leaflet lipid, 4) verification of lipid asymmetry and stability, and 5) determination of protein activity in the asymmetric lipid environment. This work offers guidance in designing asymmetric proteoliposomes that will enable researchers to compare functional and structural properties of membrane proteins in symmetric and asymmetric lipid environments.     

Effect of antibiotic amphotericin B on structural and dynamic properties of lipid membranes formed with egg yolk phosphatidylcholine

Amphotericin B (AmB) is a popular antibiotic applied in treatment of deep-seated mycotic infections. The mode of action of AmB is based upon interactions with biomembranes but exact binding properties of the antibiotic to the lipid membranes still remain obscure. Effect of incorporation of AmB into egg yolk phosphatidylcholine membranes in the concentration range from 0.01 to 5 mol% on structural and dynamic properties of lipid bilayers was studied with application of small-angle neutron scattering, X-ray diffractometry and Fourier-transform infrared spectroscopy (FTIR). The results of the experiments show that AmB is located predominantly in the headgroup region of the membranes at concentrations below 1 mol%. The process of AmB aggregation, at concentrations above 1 mol%, is associated with ordering effect within the acyl chain region and therefore indicates incorporation of AmB into the hydrophobic membrane core.     

The reconstitution and activity of the small multidrug transporter EmrE is modulated by non-bilayer lipid composition

The ability of multidrug transport proteins within biological membranes to recognise a diverse array of substrates is a fundamental aspect of antibiotic resistance. Detailed information on the mechanisms of recognition and transport can be provided only by in vitro studies in reconstituted bilayer systems. We describe the controlled, efficient reconstitution of the small multidrug transporter EmrE in a simple model membrane and investigate the effect of non-bilayer lipids on this process. Transport activity is impaired, in line with an increase in the lateral pressure within the bilayer. We demonstrate the potential of this lateral pressure modulation method as a general approach to the folding and assembly of membrane proteins in vitro, by recovering functional transporter from a partly denatured state. Our results highlight the importance of optimising reconstitution procedures and bilayer lipid composition in studies of membrane transporters. This is particularly pertinent for multidrug proteins, and we show that the use of a sub-optimal lipid bilayer environment or reconstitution method could lead to incorrect information on protein activity.     

SNARE-mediated lipid mixing depends on the physical state of the vesicles

Reconstitution experiments have suggested that N-ethylmaleimide sensitive factor attachment protein receptor (SNARE) proteins constitute a minimal membrane fusion machinery but have yielded contradictory results, and it is unclear whether the mechanism of membrane merger is related to the stalk mechanism that underlies physiological membrane fusion. Here we show that reconstitution of solubilized neuronal SNAREs into preformed 100 nm liposomes (direct method) yields proteoliposomes with more homogeneous sizes and protein densities than the standard reconstitution method involving detergent cosolubilization of proteins and lipids. Standard reconstitutions yield slow but efficient lipid mixing at high protein densities and variable amounts of lipid mixing at moderate protein densities. However, the larger, more homogenous proteoliposomes prepared by the direct method yield almost no lipid mixing at moderate protein densities. These results suggest that the lipid mixing observed for standard reconstitutions is dominated by the physical state of the membrane, perhaps due to populations of small vesicles (or micelles) with high protein densities and curvature stress created upon reconstitution. Accordingly, changing membrane spontaneous curvature by adding lysophospholipids inhibits the lipid mixing observed for standard reconstitutions. Our data indicate that the lipid mixing caused by high SNARE densities and/or curvature stress occurs by a stalk mechanism resembling the mechanism of fusion between biological membranes, but the neuronal SNAREs are largely unable to induce lipid mixing at physiological protein densities and limited curvature stress.