Effects of Macromolecular Crowding on the Structure of a Protein Complex: A Small-Angle Scattering Study of Superoxide Dismutase

Macromolecular crowding can alter the structure and function of biological macromolecules. We used small-angle scattering to measure the effects of macromolecular crowding on the size of a protein complex, SOD (superoxide dismutase). Crowding was induced using 400 MW PEG (polyethylene glycol),TEG (triethylene glycol), α-MG (methyl-α-glucoside), and TMAO (trimethylamine n-oxide). Parallel small-angle neutron scattering and small-angle x-ray scattering allowed us to unambiguously attribute apparent changes in radius of gyration to changes in the structure of SOD. For a 40% PEG solution, we find that the volume of SOD was reduced by 9%. Considering the osmotic pressure due to PEG, this deformation corresponds to a highly compressible structure. Small-angle x-ray scattering done in the presence of TEG suggests that for further deformation—beyond a 9% decrease in volume—the resistance to deformation may increase dramatically.     

Effects of macromolecular crowding agents on protein folding in vitro and in silico

Proteins fold and function inside cells which are environments very different from that of dilute buffer solutions most often used in traditional experiments. The crowded milieu results in excluded-volume effects, increased bulk viscosity and amplified chances for inter-molecular interactions. These environmental factors have not been accounted for in most mechanistic studies of protein folding executed during the last decades. The question thus arises as to how these effects—present when polypeptides normally fold in vivo—modulate protein biophysics. To address excluded volume effects, we use synthetic macromolecular crowding agents, which take up significant volume but do not interact with proteins, in combination with strategically selected proteins and a range of equilibrium and time-resolved biophysical (spectroscopic and computational) methods. In this review, we describe key observations on macromolecular crowding effects on protein stability, folding and structure drawn from combined in vitro and in silico studies. As expected based on Minton’s early predictions, many proteins (apoflavodoxin, VlsE, cytochrome c, and S16) became more thermodynamically stable (magnitude depends inversely on protein stability in buffer) and, unexpectedly, for apoflavodoxin and VlsE, the folded states changed both secondary structure content and, for VlsE, overall shape in the presence of macromolecular crowding. For apoflavodoxin and cytochrome c, which have complex kinetic folding mechanisms, excluded volume effects made the folding energy landscapes smoother (i.e., less misfolding and/or kinetic heterogeneity) than in buffer.     

Soft interactions and crowding

The intracellular milieu is complex, heterogeneous and crowded—an environment vastly different from dilute solutions in which most biophysical studies are performed. The crowded cytoplasm excludes about a third of the volume available to macromolecules in dilute solution. This excluded volume is the sum of two parts: steric repulsions and chemical interactions, also called soft interactions. Until recently, most efforts to understand crowding have focused on steric repulsions. Here, we summarize the results and conclusions from recent studies on macromolecular crowding, emphasizing the contribution of soft interactions to the equilibrium thermodynamics of protein stability. Despite their non-specific and weak nature, the large number of soft interactions present under many crowded conditions can sometimes overcome the stabilizing steric, excluded volume effect.     

Macromolecular Crowding as a Suppressor of Human IAPP Fibril Formation and Cytotoxicity

The biological cell is known to exhibit a highly crowded milieu, which significantly influences protein aggregation and association processes. As several cell degenerative diseases are related to the self-association and fibrillation of amyloidogenic peptides, understanding of the impact of macromolecular crowding on these processes is of high biomedical importance. It is further of particular relevance as most in vitro studies on amyloid aggregation have been performed in diluted solution which does not reflect the complexity of their cellular surrounding. The study presented here focuses on the self-association of the type-2 diabetes mellitus related human islet amyloid polypeptide (hIAPP) in various crowded environments including network-forming macromolecular crowding reagents and protein crowders. It was possible to identify two competing processes: a crowder concentration and type dependent stabilization of globular off-pathway species and a – consequently - retarded or even inhibited hIAPP fibrillation reaction. The cause of these crowding effects was revealed to be mainly excluded volume in the polymeric crowders, whereas non-specific interactions seem to be most dominant in protein crowded environments. Specific hIAPP cytotoxicity assays on pancreatic β-cells reveal non-toxicity for the stabilized globular species, in contrast to the high cytotoxicity imposed by the normal fibrillation pathway. From these findings it can be concluded that cellular crowding is able to effectively stabilize the monomeric conformation of hIAPP, hence enabling the conduction of its normal physiological function and prevent this highly amyloidogenic peptide from cytotoxic aggregation and fibrillation.     

Entropic stabilization of the folded states of RNA due to macromolecular crowding

We review the effects of macromolecular crowding on the folding of RNA by considering the simplest scenario when excluded volume interactions between crowding particles and RNA dominate. Using human telomerase enzyme as an example, we discuss how crowding can alter the equilibrium between pseudoknot and hairpin states of the same RNA molecule—a key aspect of crowder–RNA interactions. We summarize data showing that the crowding effect is significant only if the size of the spherical crowding particle is smaller than the radius of gyration of the RNA in the absence of crowding particles. The implication for function of the wild type and mutants of human telomerase is outlined by using a relationship between enzyme activity and its conformational equilibrium. In addition, we discuss the interplay between macromolecular crowding and ionic strength of the RNA buffer. Finally, we briefly review recent experiments which illustrate the connection between excluded volume due to macromolecular crowding and the thermodynamics of RNA folding.     

Translational and rotational motions of proteins in a protein crowded environment

Fluorescence correlation spectroscopy (FCS) was used to measure the translational diffusion of labeled apomyoglobin (tracer) in concentrated solutions of ribonuclease A and human serum albumin (crowders), as a quantitative model system of protein diffusive motions in crowded physiological environments. The ratio of the diffusion coefficient of the tracer protein in the protein crowded solutions and its diffusion coefficient in aqueous solution has been interpreted in terms of local apparent viscosities, a molecular parameter characteristic for each tracer-crowder system. In all protein solutions studied in this work, local translational viscosity values were larger than the solution bulk viscosity, and larger than rotational viscosities estimated for apomyoglobin in the same crowding solutions. Here we propose a method to estimate local apparent viscosities for the tracer translational and rotational diffusion directly from the bulk viscosity of the concentrated protein solutions. As a result of this study, the identification of protein species and the study of hydrodynamic changes and interactions in model crowded protein solutions by means of FCS and time-resolved fluorescence depolarization techniques may be expected to be greatly simplified.     

Does Temporal Integration Occur for Unrecognizable Words in Visual Crowding?

Visual crowding—the inability to see an object when it is surrounded by flankers in the periphery—does not block semantic activation: unrecognizable words due to visual crowding still generated robust semantic priming in subsequent lexical decision tasks. Based on the previous finding, the current study further explored whether unrecognizable crowded words can be temporally integrated into a phrase. By showing one word at a time, we presented Chinese four-word idioms with either a congruent or incongruent ending word in order to examine whether the three preceding crowded words can be temporally integrated to form a semantic context so as to affect the processing of the ending word. Results from both behavioral (Experiment 1) and Event-Related Potential (Experiment 2 and 3) measures showed congruency effect in only the non-crowded condition, which does not support the existence of unconscious multi-word integration. Aside from four-word idioms, we also found that two-word (modifier + adjective combination) integration—the simplest kind of temporal semantic integration—did not occur in visual crowding (Experiment 4). Our findings suggest that integration of temporally separated words might require conscious awareness, at least under the timing conditions tested in the current study.     

Structural characterization of apomyoglobin self-associated species in aqueous buffer and urea solution

The biophysical characterization of nonfunctional protein aggregates at physiologically relevant temperatures is much needed to gain deeper insights into the kinetic and thermodynamic relationships between protein folding and misfolding. Dynamic and static laser light scattering have been employed for the detection and detailed characterization of apomyoglobin (apoMb) soluble aggregates populated at room temperature upon dissolving the purified protein in buffer at pH 6.0, both in the presence and absence of high concentrations of urea. Unlike the beta-sheet self-associated aggregates previously reported for this protein at high temperatures, the soluble aggregates detected here have either alpha-helical or random coil secondary structure, depending on solvent and solution conditions. Hydrodynamic diameters range from 80 to 130 nm, with semiflexible chain-like morphology. The combined use of low pH and high urea concentration leads to structural unfolding and complete elimination of the large aggregates. Even upon starting from this virtually monomeric unfolded state, however, protein refolding leads to the formation of severely self-associated species with native-like secondary structure. Under these conditions, kinetic apoMb refolding proceeds via two parallel routes: one leading to native monomer, and the other leading to a misfolded and heavily self-associated state bearing native-like secondary structure.     

The crowd you're in with: Effects of different types of crowding agents on protein aggregation

The intracellular environment contains high concentrations of macromolecules occupying up to 30% of the total cellular volume. Presence of these macromolecules decreases the effective volume available for the proteins in the cell and thus increases the effective protein concentrations and stabilizes the compact protein conformations. Macromolecular crowding created by various macromolecules such as proteins, nucleic acids, and carbohydrates has been shown to have a significant effect on a variety of cellular processes including protein aggregation. Most studies of macromolecular crowding have used neutral, flexible polysaccharides that function primarily via excluded volume effect as model crowding agents. Here we have examined the effects of more rigid polysaccharides on protein structure and aggregation. Our results indicate that rigid and flexible polysaccharides influence protein aggregation via different mechanisms and suggest that, in addition to excluded volume effect, changes in solution viscosity and non-specific protein–polymer interactions influence the structure and dynamics of proteins in crowded environments.     

Non-ideal tracer sedimentation equilibrium: a powerful tool for the characterization of macromolecular interactions in crowded solutions

Non-ideal tracer sedimentation equilibrium is a technique devised to quantify the effect of high concentrations of unrelated macromolecules on the self- or hetero-associations of dilute macromolecules. Principles and experimental techniques are reviewed, and previous experimental work summarized. A new analysis of experimental data is presented that requires no a priori assumptions regarding the nature of weak repulsive interactions between solute species and the concentrated (crowding) species.     

Protein self-association in crowded protein solutions: a time-resolved fluorescence polarization study

The self-association equilibrium of a tracer protein, apomyoglobin (apoMb), in highly concentrated crowded solutions of ribonuclease A (RNase A) and human serum albumin (HSA), has been studied as a model system of protein interactions that occur in crowded macromolecular environments. The rotational diffusion of the tracer protein labeled with two different fluorescent dyes, 8-anilinonaphthalene-1-sulfonate and fluorescein isothiocyanate, was successfully recorded as a function of the two crowder concentrations in the 50-200 mg/mL range, using picosecond-resolved fluorescence anisotropy methods. It was found that apoMb molecules self-associate at high RNase A concentration to yield a flexible dimer. The apparent dimerization constant, which increases with RNase A concentration, could also be estimated from the fractional contribution of monomeric and dimeric species to the total fluorescence anisotropy of the samples. In contrast, an equivalent mass concentration of HSA does not result in tracer dimerization. This different effect of RNase A and HSA is much larger than that predicted from simple models based only on the free volume available to apoMb, indicating that additional, nonspecific interactions between tracer and crowder should come into play. The time-resolved fluorescence polarization methods described here are expected to be of general applicability to the detection and quantification of crowding effects in a variety of macromolecules of biological relevance.     

Studies of effects of macromolecular crowding and confinement on protein folding and protein stability

In cells, proteins execute specific tasks in crowded environments; these environments influence their stability and dynamics. Similarly, for an enzyme molecule encapsulated in an inorganic cavity as in biosensors or biocatalysts, confinement or excluded volume plays an important role in its stability and dynamics. In this article we present results of our experimental and theoretical investigations of the confinement and macromolecular crowding effects on protein. On the experimental side we study the stability of encapsulated cytochrome c against unfolding induced by the presence of denaturants, such as urea. Results show that, as the pore size in which protein is trapped is reduced, protein shows higher stability against denaturant-induced unfolding. On the theoretical side, after reviewing our previous study of the confinement effects on the equilibrium and dynamic properties of protein using a minimalist (two-dimensional lattice, Monte Carlo, Brownian dynamics) model, we have extended the model so that the effects of macromolecular crowding on such properties can be studied. Our simulations show that both folding and unfolding times increase with the number of crowders in solution, however, the equilibrium constant is affected such that the equilibrium is shifted towards the folded state. Furthermore, our results show that, for a fixed number of crowders as the size of crowder (or excluded volume) increases, the average size of protein at equilibrium decreases.     

Inferring Diffusion Dynamics from FCS in Heterogeneous Nuclear Environments

Fluorescence correlation spectroscopy (FCS) is a noninvasive technique that probes the diffusion dynamics of proteins down to single-molecule sensitivity in living cells. Critical mechanistic insight is often drawn from FCS experiments by fitting the resulting time-intensity correlation function, G(t), to known diffusion models. When simple models fail, the complex diffusion dynamics of proteins within heterogeneous cellular environments can be fit to anomalous diffusion models with adjustable anomalous exponents. Here, we take a different approach. We use the maximum entropy method to show—first using synthetic data—that a model for proteins diffusing while stochastically binding/unbinding to various affinity sites in living cells gives rise to a G(t) that could otherwise be equally well fit using anomalous diffusion models. We explain the mechanistic insight derived from our method. In particular, using real FCS data, we describe how the effects of cell crowding and binding to affinity sites manifest themselves in the behavior of G(t). Our focus is on the diffusive behavior of an engineered protein in 1) the heterochromatin region of the cell’s nucleus as well as 2) in the cell’s cytoplasm and 3) in solution. The protein consists of the basic region-leucine zipper (BZip) domain of the CCAAT/enhancer-binding protein (C/EBP) fused to fluorescent proteins.     

Effect of mixed macromolecular crowding agents on protein folding

In cells, proteins fold and unfold in the presence of macromolecules with various sizes and shapes. Recent experiments by Liang and coworkers (J Biol Chem 2004;279:55109-55116; J Mol Biol 2006;364:469-482) show that protein refolding is enhanced by a mixture of two different crowding agents relative to the individual crowding agents and an optimal mixing ratio exists. Here, we present a theory that predicts the existence of an optimal mixing ratio. The theory is based on models for calculating the changes in the chemical potentials of the folded and unfolded states by a mixture of crowders. The existence of an optimal mixing ratio results from the dependences of these chemical-potential changes on crowder sizes and concentrations, which can be argued to be quite general. We further predict that, for any crowding agent, the stabilizing effect can be optimized both by varying the molecular weight and the mixing ratio of two species with different molecular weights.     

Synthetic crowding agent dextran causes excluded volume interactions exclusively to tracer protein apoazurin

To understand protein biophysics in crowded cellular environments, researchers often use synthetic polymers as ‘crowding agents’ in vitro. The idea is that these agents will occupy space and reproduce the in vivo scenario in terms of excluded volume. However, recent work has challenged this concept and pointed out that attractive interactions between protein and crowding agent will provide an enthalpic contribution to the overall effect on protein thermodynamics. Here we use a typical synthetic crowding agent and a well-studied model protein to demonstrate in a window of 50 K that the presence of dextran 20 affects apoazurin by steric repulsion.     

Expanding to fill the gap: a possible role for inert biopolymers in regulating the extent of the 'macromolecular crowding' effect

We discuss the potential for inert biopolymers existing in cells to play a role in regulating the macromolecular crowding effect via their ability to undergo shape changing structural transitions. We have explored this possibility by the use of theory and experiment. The theoretical component utilized Monte-Carlo based simulations to examine the folding of a hypothetical protein in a concentrated environment of hard spheres which are themselves capable of reversible expansion and contraction. The experimental component of the study involved examination of the effect of different sized crowding agents on the thermally induced denaturation of cytochrome c [in phosphate buffered saline solution containing 1.0M guanidinium hydrochloride at pH 7.0]. On the basis of our findings we suggest that in a crowded solution environment the presence of a non-reactive polymer capable of reversible expansion/contraction via folding and unfolding may alter the excluded volume component of the solution. This ability would confer on the non-reactive polymer a novel role in influencing other processes in solution affected by macromolecular crowding.     

Effects of inert volume-excluding macromolecules on protein fiber formation. I. Equilibrium models

The equilibrium Oosawa-Asakura model for nucleated assembly of rod-like protein fibers is recast in terms of dimensionless (scaled) quantities. The model is then generalized to treat arbitrarily large deviations from thermodynamic ideality arising from high fractional volume occupancy by an inert protein or polymer. Each state of association of the self-associating protein is modeled as an equivalent rigid convex particle (sphere or spherocylinder) and the crowding species is modeled either as an equivalent sphere or cylindrical rod. The resulting conservation of mass relation is readily solved to yield the fractional abundance of monomer, from which the entire equilibrium distribution of oligomeric species can be calculated, either directly or through the use of an additional scaling relationship. Results indicating the potential effect of volume occupancy on the equilibrium solubility of the self-associating protein and upon the equilibrium distribution of polymer size are presented. It is found that the fractional (logarithmic) change in both solubility and in the breadth of the polymer size distribution scale almost linearly with the fractional (logarithmic) change in the thermodynamic activity of monomer.     

Adsorption of globular proteins on locally planar surfaces: models for the effect of excluded surface area and aggregation of adsorbed protein on adsorption equilibria.

Equilibrium statistical-thermodynamic models are presented for the surface adsorption of proteins modeled as regular convex hard particles. The adsorbed phase is treated as a two-dimensional fluid, and the chemical potential of adsorbed protein is obtained from scaled particle theory. Adsorption isotherms are calculated for nonassociating and self-associating adsorbing proteins. Area exclusion broadens adsorption isotherms relative to the Langmuir isotherm (negative cooperativity), whereas self-association steepens them (positive cooperativity). The calculated isotherm for adsorption of hard spheres using scaled particle theory for hard discs agrees well with that calculated from the hard disc virial expansion. As the cross section of the adsorbing protein in the plane of the surface becomes less discoidal, the apparent negative cooperativity manifested in the isotherm becomes more pronounced. The model is extended to the case of simultaneous adsorption of a tracer protein at low saturation and a competitor protein with a different size and/or shape at arbitrary fractional saturation. Area exclusion by competitor for tracer (and vice versa) is shown to substantially enhance the displacement of tracer by competitor and to qualitatively invalidate the standard interpretation of ligand competition experiments, according to which the fractional displacement of tracer by competitor is equal to the fractional saturation by competitor.     

Salt-independent adsorption of human serum proteins on cyanocarbon gels

Electron donor acceptor gels based on cyanocarbons have been tested for human serum protein adsorption in the absence of salt-promotion by water-structuring salt. This phenomenon was compared with a normal adsorption process in the presence of salt. The tricyanoaminopropene–divinyl sulfone–agarose displayed unusual protein adsorption properties as binding could occur both independently or dependently of the salt-promotion. The absence of hydrophobic or ionic character of the salt-independent interaction suggests an electron donor acceptor adsorption mechanism which is shown, for the first time, to occur independently of salt-promotion in aqueous solution. Study of the protein adsorption specificity showed similar protein selectivity for the fractions adsorbed in both conditions.