ATP synthesis driven by proton transport in F1F0-ATP synthase

Topical questions in ATP synthase research are: (1) how do protons cause subunit rotation and how does rotation generate ATP synthesis from ADP+Pi? (2) How does hydrolysis of ATP generate subunit rotation and how does rotation bring about uphill transport of protons? The finding that ATP synthase is not just an enzyme but rather a unique nanomotor is attracting a diverse group of researchers keen to find answers. Here we review the most recent work on rapidly developing areas within the field and present proposals for enzymatic and mechanoenzymatic mechanisms.     

ATP synthesis in Halobacterium saccharovorum: evidence that synthesis may be catalysed by an F0F1-ATP synthase

Halobacterium saccharovorum synthesized ATP in response to a pH shift from 8 to 6.2. Synthesis was inhibited by carbonyl cyanide m-chloro-phenylhydrazone, dicyclohexylcarbodiimide, and azide. Nitrate, an inhibitor of the membrane-bound ATPase previously isolated from this organism, did not inhibit ATP synthesis. N-Ethymaleimide, which also inhibited this ATPase, stimulated the production of ATP. These observations suggested that H. saccharovorum synthesized and hydrolysed ATP using different enzymes and that the vacuolar-like ATPase activity previously described in H. saccharovorum was an ATPase whose function is yet to be identified.     

Coupled rotation within single F0F1 enzyme complexes during ATP synthesis or hydrolysis

F0F1 ATP synthases are the smallest rotary motors in nature and work as ATP factories in bacteria, plants and animals. Here we report on the first observation of intersubunit rotation in fully coupled single F0F1 molecules during ATP synthesis or hydrolysis. We investigate the Na+-translocating ATP synthase of Propionigenium modestum specifically labeled by a single fluorophore at one c subunit using polarization-resolved confocal microscopy. Rotation during ATP synthesis was observed with the immobilized enzyme reconstituted into proteoliposomes after applying a diffusion potential, but not with a Na+ concentration gradient alone. During ATP hydrolysis, stepwise rotation of the labeled c subunit was found in the presence of 2 mM NaCl, but not without the addition of Na+ ions. Moreover, upon the incubation with the F0-specific inhibitor dicyclohexylcarbodiimide the rotation was severely inhibited.     

Effect of cetyltrimethylammonium on ATP hydrolysis and proton translocation in the F0-F1 H+-ATP synthase of mitochondria

The amphiphylic alkyl cation cetyltrimethylammonium inhibits the catalytic activity of soluble and membrane-bound F₁ in a noncompetitive fashion. In sonic submitochondrial particles the Dixon plot showed a peculiar pattern with upward deviation at cetyltrimethylammonium concentration higher than 80µM. In membrane-bound F₁ the inhibition by cetyltrimethylammonium was potentiated by the F₀ inhibitor ologomycin. Cetyltrimethylammonium also inhibited the oligomycin-sensitive proton conductivity in F₁-containing particles but was without any effect in F₁-depleted particles. Also this inhibitory effect was potentiated by oligomycin. These results indicate functional cooperative interactions between F₀ and F₁.     

Voltage-driven ATP synthesis by beef heart mitochondrial F0F1-ATPase

The F0F1-ATPase of the inner mitochondrial membrane catalyzes the conversion of a proton electrochemical energy into the chemical bond energy of ATP (Boyer, P.D., Chance, B., Ernster, L., Mitchell, P., Racker, E., and Slater, E.C. (1977) Annu. Rev. Biochem. 46, 955-1026). To assess the role of the membrane potential (delta psi) in this process and to study the effect of very short pulses on ATP synthesis, we employed a high voltage pulsation method (Kinosita, K., and Tsong, T.Y. (1977) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 74, 1923-1927) to induce a delta psi of controlled magnitude and duration in a suspension of submitochondrial particles and F0F1-ATPase vesicles. Cyanide-treated submitochondrial particles were exposed to electric pulses of 10-30 kV/cm of magnitude (generating a peak delta psi of 150-450 mV) and 1-100 microseconds duration. Net [32P]ATP synthesis from [32P]Pi and ADP was observed with maximal values of 410 pmol/mg X pulse for a 30 kV/cm-100-microseconds pulse. This corresponds to a yield of 10-12 mol of ATP per mol of F0F1 complex per pulse. As many as 4 nmol/mg were produced after pulsing the same sample 8 times. By varying the ionic strength of the suspending medium, and consequently the pulse width, it is clearly shown that the synthesis was electrically driven and did not correlate with Joule heating of the sample. Titrations using specific inhibitors and ionophores were performed. The voltage-induced ATP synthesis was 50% inhibited by 0.11 microgram/mg of oligomycin and 2.4 nmol/mg of N,N'-dicyclohexylcarbodiimide. Ionophores and uncouplers had varying degrees of inhibition. The dependence of ATP synthesis on pulse width was nonlinear, exhibiting a threshold at 10 microseconds and a biphasic behavior above this value. Isolated F0F1-ATPase reconstituted into asolectin vesicles also synthesized ATP when pulsed with electric fields. A 35 kV/cm pulse induced the synthesis of 115 pmol of ATP per mg of protein, which corresponds to approximately 0.34 mol of ATP per mol of F0F1-ATPase. This synthesis was also sensitive to oligomycin and dicyclohexylcarbodiimide. The possibility of turnover of the ATPase in microseconds is considered.     

Presteady-state kinetics of ATP hydrolysis by chloroplast CF1-ATPASE

The kinetics of reversible inactivation of chloroplast CF1-ATPase by Mg2+ and ADP was studied. The rate of inactivation obeys the first-order equation and is independent of ADP concentration. An analysis of the dependence of the inactivation rate on Mg2+ concentration demonstrated that the limiting step of inactivation is other than Mg2+ binding, i.e. the subsequent steps which include, in all probability, the conformational changes of the enzyme. The original Mg2+-dependent activity of CF1-ATPase is close to that observed under steady-state conditions in the presence of sulphate and methanol and exceeds the Ca2+-dependent activity approximately 6-fold. Preincubation of CF1-ATPase with Mg2+ results in inhibition of the original activity of the enzyme. This effect is not removed by addition of the ATP-regenerating system (pyruvate kinase + phosphoenol pyruvate) to the preincubation medium but is diminished by sulphite and the non-hydrolyzed analog of ATP--beta, gamma-methyladenosine-5-triphosphate. After addition of AMPPCP to the reaction mixture the initial reaction rate is decreased, while the steady-state rate is increased. It may be concluded that the Mg2+-dependent inactivation of CF1-ATPase is induced by the tightly bound ADP. The latter can be replaced by ATP, which in contrast to ADP does not form an inactive complex with the enzyme. A comparison of experimental results with literature data suggests that the mechanism of "alternating sites" proposed by Boyer et al. for ATP hydrolysis by soluble CF1-ATPase is not realized under the given experimental conditions.     

The molecular mechanism of ATP synthesis by F1F0-ATP synthase

ATP synthesis by oxidative phosphorylation and photophosphorylation, catalyzed by F1F0-ATP synthase, is the fundamental means of cell energy production. Earlier mutagenesis studies had gone some way to describing the mechanism. More recently, several X-ray structures at atomic resolution have pictured the catalytic sites, and real-time video recordings of subunit rotation have left no doubt of the nature of energy coupling between the transmembrane proton gradient and the catalytic sites in this extraordinary molecular motor. Nonetheless, the molecular events that are required to accomplish the chemical synthesis of ATP remain undefined. In this review we summarize current state of knowledge and present a hypothesis for the molecular mechanism of ATP synthesis.     

Kinetics of ATP hydrolysis catalyzed by isolated TF1 and reconstituted TF0F1 ATPase

The rate of ATP hydrolysis catalyzed by isolated TF1 and reconstituted TF0F1 was measured as a function of the ATP concentration in the presence of inhibitors [ADP, Pi and 3'-O-(1-naphthoyl)ATP]. ATP hydrolysis can be described by Michaelis-Menten kinetics with Km(TF1) = 390 microM and Km (TF0F1) = 180 microM. The inhibition constants are for ADP Ki(TF1) = 20 microM and Ki(TF0F1) = 100 microM, for 3'-O-(1-naphthoyl)ATP Ki(TF1) = 150 microM and Ki(TF0F1) = 3 microM, and for Pi Ki(TF1) = 60 mM. From these results it is concluded that upon binding of TF0 to TF1 the mechanism of ATP hydrolysis catalyzed by TF1 is not changed qualitatively; however, the kinetic constants differ quantitatively.     

Kinetics of ATP synthesis catalyzed by the H(+)-ATPase from chloroplasts (CF0F1) reconstituted into liposomes and coreconstituted with bacteriorhodopsin.

The H(+)-ATPase from chloroplasts (CF0F1) was isolated, purified and reconstituted into liposomes from phosphatidylcholine/phosphatidic acid. A transmembrane pH difference, delta pH, and a transmembrane electric potential difference, delta psi, were generated by an acid/base transition. The rate of ATP synthesis was measured at constant delta pH and constant delta psi as a function of temperature between 5 degrees C and 45 degrees C. The activation energy was 55 kJ mol-1. CF0F1 was coreconstituted with bacteriorhodopsin at a molar ratio of approximately 1:170 in the same type of liposomes. Illumination of the proteoliposomes leads to proton transport into the vesicles generating a constant delta pH = 1.8. The dependence of the rate of ATP synthesis on ADP concentration was measured with CF0F1 in the oxidized state, E(ox), and in the reduced state, E(red). The results can be described by Michaelis-Menten kinetics with the following parameters: Vmax = 0.5 s-1, Km = 8 microM for E(ox) and Vmax = 2.0 s-1, Km = 8 microM for E(red).     

ATP hydrolysis catalyzed by a beta subunit preparation purified from the chloroplast energy transducing complex CF1.CF0

Washing thylakoid membranes with 1 M LiCl causes the release of the beta subunit from the chloroplast energy transducing complex (CF1.CF0) in spinach chloroplasts. This protein purifies by size exclusion chromatography as a 180-kDa aggregate and, thus, is probably composed of a trimer of beta polypeptides. The purified aggregate binds ADP to a high and a low affinity site with dissociation constants of 15 and 202 microM, respectively. Mg2+ is required for ADP to bind to both sites. Manganese binds to the protein in a cooperative manner to at least two sites with high affinity. The beta subunit preparation catalyzes Mg2+-dependent ATP hydrolysis at rates which are comparable to other subunit-deficient CF1 preparations and is increased by treatments known to activate the Mg2+-ATPase activity of CF1. However, Ca2+ is not an effective cofactor for this reaction and treatments which activate the Ca2+-ATPase of CF1 are either ineffective or inhibitory.     

A structure-based model for the synthesis and hydrolysis of ATP by F1-ATPase

Many essential functions of living cells are performed by nanoscale protein motors. The best characterized of these is F(o)F1-ATP synthase, the smallest rotary motor. This rotary motor catalyzes the synthesis of ATP with high efficiency under conditions where the reactants (ADP, H2PO4(-)) and the product (ATP) are present in the cell at similar concentrations. We present a detailed structure-based kinetic model for the mechanism of action of F1-ATPase and demonstrate the role of different protein conformations for substrate binding during ATP synthesis and ATP hydrolysis. The model shows that the pathway for ATP hydrolysis is not simply the pathway for ATP synthesis in reverse. The findings of the model also explain why the cellular concentration of ATP does not inhibit ATP synthesis.     

Energy-linked binding of Pi is required for continuous steady-state proton-translocating ATP hydrolysis catalyzed by F0.F1 ATP synthase

The presence of medium Pi (half-maximal concentration of 20 microM at pH 8.0) was found to be required for the prevention of the rapid decline in the rate of proton-motive force (pmf)-induced ATP hydrolysis by Fo.F1 ATP synthase in coupled vesicles derived from Paracoccus denitrificans. The initial rate of the reaction was independent of Pi. The apparent affinity of Pi for its "ATPase-protecting" site was strongly decreased with partial uncoupling of the vesicles. Pi did not reactivate ATPase when added after complete time-dependent deactivation during the enzyme turnover. Arsenate and sulfate, which was shown to compete with Pi when Fo.F1 catalyzed oxidative phosphorylation, substituted for Pi as the protectors of ATPase against the turnover-dependent deactivation. Under conditions where the enzyme turnover was not permitted (no ATP was present), Pi was not required for the pmf-induced activation of ATPase, whereas the presence of medium Pi (or sulfate) delayed the spontaneous deactivation of the enzyme which was induced by the membrane de-energization. The data are interpreted to suggest that coupled and uncoupled ATP hydrolysis catalyzed by Fo.F1 ATP synthases proceeds via different intermediates. Pi dissociates after ADP if the coupling membrane is energized (no E.ADP intermediate exists). Pi dissociates before ADP during uncoupled ATP hydrolysis, leaving the E.ADP intermediate which is transformed into the inactive ADP(Mg2+)-inhibited form of the enzyme (latent ATPase).     

Chromatographic purification of the chloroplast ATP synthase (CF0-CF1) and the role of CF0 subunit IV in proton conduction

Chromatographic procedures were developed to purify chloroplast ATP synthase (CF0-CF1) in large amounts and to resolve subunits from this enzyme. The ATP synthase thus obtained has high ATP-Pi exchange and Mg2(+)-ATPase activities upon incorporation into asolectin liposomes. The purity of this preparation was about 95%. By modifications of this chromatographic procedure, we purified subunit IV-deficient CF0-CF1, subunit IV-deficient CF0, and subunit IV. Both ATP-Pi exchange and Mg2(+)-ATPase activities were impaired by depletion of subunit IV from CF0-CF1. Partial restoration of these activities was obtained by reconstituting subunit IV-deficient CF0-CF1 with subunit IV. The impairment of these activities was likely caused by a loss in proton conductivity of CF0 upon removal of subunit IV. The dicyclohexylcarbodiimide-sensitive Mg2(+)-ATPase of subunit IV-deficient CF0-CF1 was not as sensitive to the depletion of subunit IV as ATP-Pi exchange. Nearly 90% of subunit IV could be removed, but Mg2(+)-ATPase activity was inhibited by only 40-60%. Thus subunit IV of CF0-CF1 may not participate directly in proton transfer but may have a role in organizing and/or stabilizing CF0 structure.     

H+/ATP stoichiometry of proton pump of turtle urinary bladder

Urinary acidification in the turtle urinary bladder is due to a reversible proton-translocating ATPase. To estimate the H+/ATP stoichiometry of this pump, we measured the delta G'ATP in the epithelial cells and the maximum e.m.f. generated by the pump. The latter is the maximal transepithelial electrochemical gradient for protons placed across the epithelium that is needed to nullify the rate of transport and averaged 179 +/- 7 mV. The delta G'ATP averaged 50.1 kJ/mol. The H+/ATP stoichiometry of these bladders was 2.92 +/- 0.1. In other experiments, the bladders were poisoned by iodoacetate and cyanide and a variable transepithelial electrochemical gradient for protons was placed across them. It was noted that ATP synthesis occurred at a transepithelial electrochemical gradient for protons greater than 120 mV. The delta G'ATP in other bladders treated identically averaged 40.0 kJ/mol, giving a H+/ATP stoichiometry of 3.4 +/- 0.1. We conclude that the H+/ATP stoichiometry of the proton pump of turtle urinary bladder is approximately 3.     

Introduction of a carboxyl group in the loop of the F0 c-subunit affects the H+/ATP coupling ratio of the ATP synthase from Synechocystis 6803

The proton translocation stoichiometry (H⁺/ATP ratio) was investigated in membrane vesicles from a Synechocystis 6803 mutant in which the serine at position 37 in the hydrophilic loop of the c-subunit from the wild type was replaced by a negatively charged glutamic acid residue (strain plc37). At this position the c-subunit of chloroplasts and the cyanobacterium Synechococcus 6716 already contains glutamic acid. H⁺/ATP ratios were determined with active ATP synthase in thermodynamic equilibrium between phosphate potential (G _p ) and the proton gradient ( _H ⁺) induced by acid–base transition. The mutant displayed a significantly higher H⁺/ATP ratio than the control strain (wild type with kanamycin resistance) at pH 8 (4.3 vs. 3.3); the higher ratio also being observed in chloroplasts and Synechococcus 6716. Furthermore, the pH dependence of the H⁺/ATP of strain plc37 resembles that of Synechococcus 6716. When the pH was increased from 7.6 to 8.4, the H⁺/ATP of the mutant increased from 4.2 to 4.6 whereas in the control strain the ratio decreased from 3.8 to 2.8. Differences in H⁺/ATP between the mutant and the control strain were confirmed by measuring the light-induced phosphorylation efficiency (P/2e), which changed as expected, i.e., the P/2e ratio in the mutant was significantly less than that in the wild type. The need for more H⁺ ions used per ATP in the mutant was also reflected by the significantly lower growth rate of the mutant strain. The results are discussed against the background of the present structural and functional models of proton translocation coupled to catalytic activity of the ATP synthase.     

The Escherichia coli F1F0 ATP synthase displays biphasic synthesis kinetics

The F1F0 proton-translocating ATPase/synthase is the primary generator of ATP in most organisms growing aerobically. Kinetic assays of ATP synthesis have been conducted using enzymes from mitochondria and chloroplasts. However, limited data on ATP synthesis by the model Escherichia coli enzyme are available, mostly because of the lack of an efficient and reproducible assay. We have developed an optimized assay and have collected synthase kinetic data over a substrate concentration range of 2 orders of magnitude for both ADP and Pi from the synthase enzyme of E. coli. Negative and positive cooperativity of substrate binding and positive catalytic cooperativity were all observed. ATP synthesis displayed biphasic kinetics for ADP indicating that 1) the enzyme is capable of catalyzing efficient ATP synthesis when only two of three catalytic sites are occupied by ADP; and 2) occupation of the third site further activates the rate of catalysis.     

CF0, the proton channel of chloroplast ATP synthase. After removal of CF1 it appears in two forms with highly different proton conductance

The discharge of the flash-induced transmembrane voltage through the exposed proton channel, CF0, of the chloroplast ATP synthase, CF0CF1 was investigated. EDTA treatment of thylakoid membranes exposed approximately 50% of total CF0 by removal of the CF1 counterparts. This greatly accelerated the decay of the transmembrane voltage, as was apparent from electrochromic-absorption changes of intrinsic pigments and by pH-indicating-absorption changes of added dyes. Two decay processes were discernible, one rapid with a typical half-decay time of 2 ms, and a slower one with a half-decay time variable between 20-100 ms. Both were sensitive to CF0 inhibitors, but only the rapid decay process was also inhibited by added CF1. CF1 was effective in surprisingly small amounts, which were significantly lower than those previously removed by EDTA treatment. This finding corroborated our previous conclusion that the rapid decay of the transmembrane voltage was attributable to only a few high-conductance channels among many CF0 molecules, typically in the order of one channel/CF1-depleted EDTA vesicle. Inhibition of photophosphorylation in control thylakoids was measured as function of the concentration of CF0 inhibitors. It was compared with the inhibition of proton conduction through exposed CF0 in EDTA vesicles. Photophosphorylation and proton conduction by the high-conductance form of CF0 were inhibited by the same low inhibitor concentrations. This suggested that the high-conducting form of CF0 with a time-averaged single-channel conductance of 1 pS [Lill, H., Althoff, G. & Junge, W. (1987) J. Membrane Biol. 98, 69-78] represented the proton channel in the integral enzyme, which acted as a low-impedance access from the thylakoid lumen to the coupling site in CF0CF1. The slow decay process was attributed to a majority of low-conductance CF0 channels, i.e. about 50 molecules/vesicle. The conductance of these channels was more than 100-fold lower and they did not compete with the very few highly conducting channels for rebinding of added CF1. The low proton conduction of the majority of exposed CF0 molecules, possibly due to a structural rearrangement, may be protecting the thylakoid membrane against rapid energy dissipation caused by accidental loss of CF1. It may also explain the low single-channel conductance of bacterial F0 reported in the literature.     

ATP-synthase of Rhodobacter capsulatus: coupling of proton flow through F0 to reactions in F1 under the ATP synthesis and slip conditions

A stepwise increasing membrane potential was generated in chromatophores of the phototrophic bacterium Rhodobacter capsulatus by illumination with short flashes of light. Proton transfer through ATP-synthase (measured by electrochromic carotenoid bandshift and by pH-indicators) and ATP release (measured by luminescence of luciferin-luciferase) were monitored. The ratio between the amount of protons translocated by F0F1 and the ATP yield decreased with the flash number from an apparent value of 13 after the first flash to about 5 when averaged over three flashes. In the absence of ADP, protons slipped through F0F1. The proton transfer through F0F1 after the first flash contained two kinetic components, of about 6 ms and 20 ms both under the ATP synthesis conditions and under slip. The slower component of proton transfer was substantially suppressed in the absence of ADP. We attribute our observations to the mechanism of energy storage in the ATP-synthase needed to couple the transfer of four protons with the synthesis of one molecule of ATP. Most probably, the transfer of initial protons of each tetrad creates a strain in the enzyme that slows the translocation of the following protons.