Evolution of the synaptonemal complex in Helix aspersa spermatocytes

In spermatocytes of Helix aspersa, the structure of the synaptonemal complexes undergoes changes in the course of the pachytene, the lateral elements being transformed into wide bands of lesser density than the chromatin. By using the uranyl-EDTA-lead sequence, which preferentially stains RNA, the lateral elements can be made to appear positive in the early pachytene while the corresponding areas, which become wider and more diffuse, are positive during late pachytene. — Apparently, the lateral elements do not persist in the diplotene and remnants of the central element can occasionally be observed. Using the uranyl-EDTA-lead method reveals some positively stained material surrounding the chromatin, mostly granular in appearance, which is observed in late pachytene and attains its maximum amount during diplotene. Several aspects of these observations are here discussed.     

An ‘axis-like’ material in the centromeric region of metaphase-I chromosomes from mouse spermatocytes

This study reports the persistence of axis-like structures in the centromeric region of both homologues during the metaphase-I and anaphase-I stages of meiotic division of mouse spermatocytes. A novel type of silver argentaffin technique (NH₄–Ag) is employed. This technique includes the treatment of glutaraldehyde-fixed tissues with dilute ammonium hydroxide followed by a reduction of aldehyde groups with sodium borohydride. Staining is accomplished with ammoniacal silver nitrate in darkness followed by sulfite washing. The lateral elements of synaptonemal complexes and the single chromosomal axes of diplotene spermatocytes show a prominent reactivity with this technique. The pattern of very small grains over condensed chromatin is uniform and gives only a light opacity to the electron beam. The presence of an axis-like structure is seen in every centromeric end of meiotic chromosomes at metaphase I and anaphase I. The chromatin (heterochromatin) that surrounds the centromeric filament and some material distributed in irregular linear arrays along some of the homologues also showed a higher electron opacity than the bulk of deoxyribonucleoprotein. While the former is related to C+ heterochromatin, the latter could represent dispersed material of diplotene axes. It is suggested that the disposal of axial material is differentially delayed at the centromeric regions. The present evidence supports the hypothesis that axial fragments or lateral-element segments persisting at these regions contribute to the cohesiveness of centromeres of sister chromatids during normal disjunction.     

Ultrastructure and composition of the synaptonemal complex in spread and negatively stained spermatocytes of the golden hamster and the albino rat

The ultrastructure of the synaptonemal complex (SC) has been studied in spermatocytes of the golden hamster and the albino rat, spread on liquid surfaces and negatively stained with uranyl acetate. The conditions for a reproducible procedure for spreading the SC have been specified. Spreading on water causes large losses of material from the complex. Spreading on 0.45–0.9% NaCl in water results in good preservation of the SC. Ethanol dehydration introduces irreversible changes in the shape of the chromatin fibers and the components of the complex. Digestions with DNase and proteases, extraction with 2M NaCl and fixation in an aqueous solution of formaldehyde permit analysis of the components of the SC. The lateral elements of the SC are formed by three components: 1) the bulk material which is protease sensitive, DNase resistant, insoluble in 2M NaCl and partially soluble in water; 2) the axial attachment regions of the chromatin fiber; and 3) an axial and linear filament, 65 Å wide, which is DNase sensitive. It is suggested that this linear 65 Å filament contains a single linear DNA molecule to which the chromatin fibers are attached. The central element of the SC is made of fibrillar material, most of which is DNase resistant and protease sensitive. Fibrils 25 Å wide cross the central space and merge with the central element. The cross fibrils and the central element are labile in solutions containing less than 0.45% NaCl. — From the present results and previous data on diplotene axes (Solari, 1970), it is concluded that the lateral elements of the SC of hamster and rat spermatocytes are undivided during pachytene. It is suggested that the singleness of the axes in the lateral elements is based on the presence of a single DNA molecule axially located in the lateral elements, and that the chromatin fibers are symmetrically attached to this DNA molecule.     

Changes of the synaptonemal complex at the end of pachytene

Summary Observations on the changes of the synaptonemal complex at the end of pachytene and in diplotene are reported. The synaptonemal complex disintegrates in diplotene by progressive disjoining of the lateral arms. The structures of the pairing space disappear. A residual piece of the synaptonemal complex is interpreted as a transitional stage of the process of disintegration. The lateral arms form single threads which disappear at the end of diplotene. No doubleness of the lateral arms can be detected, except a splitting in 3–4 laminae in the region near the fixation points at the nuclear envelope. The lateral arms do not separate in subunits at the end of the meiotic prophase. Chiasmata can not be recognized.

---

Zusammenfassung Beobachtungen über die Veränderungen des synaptonemalen Komplexes am Ende des Pachytäus und im Diplotän werden mitgeteilt. Im Diplotän löst sich der synaptonemale Komplex durch fortschreitende Trennung der lateralen Arme. Die Strukturen des Paarungs-Raumes verschwinden. Ein Rest des synaptonemalen Komplexes wird als Übergangsstadium im Laufe des Desintegrations-Prozesses gedeutet. Die lateralen Arme bilden Einzelstränge, die am Ende des Diplotäns verschwinden. Eine Verdopplung des lateralen Armes kann nicht entdeckt werden; lediglich in der Nähe des Fixationspunktes an der Nuclearmembran findet sich eine Aufspaltung in 3–4 Lamellen. Am Ende der meiotischen Prophase trenne sich demnach die lateralen Arme nicht in Untereinheiten. Chiasmata sind nicht erkennbar.

---

---

This work was supported by the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft.     

Synaptonemal complex spreading in Allium

A surface-spreading technique for synaptonemal complexes was applied to triploid Allium sphaerocephalon L. (Liliaceae). In early pachytene two of the three axial elements of each set of three homologues are synapsed, the third is intimately aligned with and accompanies them throughout their whole length. The unsynapsed axis is attached to the synaptonemal complex of the other 2 at up to 50 association sites per trivalent. The distribution of these sites within the trivalents is not even; they are under-represented in the proximal regions. From nought to eight switches (pairing partner exchanges), where the accompanying axis joins in synapsis in exchange for one of the two other strands, occur per trivalent. Very often the telomeres of the aligned axes are attached to their synapsed counterparts by dense spherules, which makes this type of association different from the interstitial ones. Frequently the unsynapsed axes show a double structure along short distances. In late pachytene the intercalary associations are abolished, allowing the unsynapsed axes to engage in various types of non-homologous pairing. Since the association sites involve homologous chromosomes and are less abundant in the pericentric regions (which are usually the last to synapse), it is conceivable that similar structures are responsible for the pre-synaptic alignment of homologues and provide the initiation sites for synaptonemal complex formation in diploids.     

Synaptonemal Complex und Chromosomenstruktur in der achiasmatischen Spermatogenese vonPanorpa communis (Mecoptera)

Meiotic prophase in the spermatocytes ofPanorpa communis was studied. There is a proper sequence of meiotic stages in the testes. Therefore the temporal development of chromosome structure and the synaptonemal complex (SC) could be studied exactly. The structure and function of the SC are interpreted in a new model.—The chromosomes have a lambrush form from leptotene to diakinesis. At leptotene each chromatid produces an additional axis of basic protein and RNA. The axis becomes one of the lateral elements of the SC. At pachytene the DNA of the bivalents is separated into three regions: 1. Most of the DNA forms long loops outside the SC. 2. Smaller portions of the DNA filaments are twisted around the lateral elements of the SC. 3. Short DNA loops (called pairing loops) extend into the pairing space. InPanorpa the SC is composed of two lateral elements (chromosome axes), which are connected by equally spaced transverse filaments, a ladder-like central element in the middle of the pairing space and, on each side of the pairing space parallel to the lateral elements, two RNA containing strands. These are regarded as connected RNA copies of the pairing loops and are responsible for the exact pairing of homologous chromosome segments. At diplotene the axes of the sister chromatids separate to form “double complexes” with four lateral elements. The double complexes of the oocytes contain only transverse filaments between the axes of the homologous chromatids. After a short time they disappear again and the homologues separate to form the chiasmatic bivalents. In the spermatocytes all four chromatid axes are connected by transverse filaments. The pairing complex persists until diakinesis, thereby causing the suppression of the diplotene stage in the light microscope. This may be the only reason for the achiasmatic meiosis in the spermatocytes ofPanorpa.     

Involvement of synaptonemal complex proteins in sex chromosome segregation during marsupial male meiosis

Marsupial sex chromosomes break the rule that recombination during first meiotic prophase is necessary to ensure reductional segregation during first meiotic division. It is widely accepted that in marsupials X and Y chromosomes do not share homologous regions, and during male first meiotic prophase the synaptonemal complex is absent between them. Although these sex chromosomes do not recombine, they segregate reductionally in anaphase I. We have investigated the nature of sex chromosome association in spermatocytes of the marsupial Thylamys elegans, in order to discern the mechanisms involved in ensuring their proper segregation. We focused on the localization of the axial/lateral element protein SCP3 and the cohesin subunit STAG3. Our results show that X and Y chromosomes never appear as univalents in metaphase I, but they remain associated until they orientate and segregate to opposite poles. However, they must not be tied by a chiasma since their separation precedes the release of the sister chromatid cohesion. Instead, we show they are associated by the dense plate, a SCP3-rich structure that is organized during the first meiotic prophase and that is still present at metaphase I. Surprisingly, the dense plate incorporates SCP1, the main protein of the central element of the synaptonemal complex, from diplotene until telophase I. Once sex chromosomes are under spindle tension, they move to opposite poles losing contact with the dense plate and undergoing early segregation. Thus, the segregation of the achiasmatic T. elegans sex chromosomes seems to be ensured by the presence in metaphase I of a synaptonemal complex-derived structure. This feature, unique among vertebrates, indicates that synaptonemal complex elements may play a role in chromosome segregation.     

Synaptonemal polycomplexes in spermatocytes of the gooseneck barnacle,Pollicipes polymerus Sowerby (Crustacea: Cirripedia)

Polycomplexes are described for the first time in spermatocytes of a cirripede crustacean, Pollicipes polymerus Sowerby. Synaptonemal complexes of regular tripartite construction are seen from zygotene to mid-pachytene. Although some of the synaptonemal complexes are disrupted at late pachytene and may degenerate at this stage, some persist and by diplotene may form polycomplexes by the bending and self-fusion of their lateral elements. These polycomplexes are still encompassed by chromosomes and consist of four dense plates and intercalated central elements and transverse fibers. Other polycomplexes with five or six dense plates, all of which are considerably wider than lateral elements of mid-pachytene synaptonemal complexes, are also seen in diplotene nuclei. These may be attached to a chromosome at only one end or may be in the nucleoplasm, free of chromosomal involvement except for fine fibrous connectives. No polycomplexes are seen in meiotic cells after diplotene and their fate is unknown. It is suggested that poly-complexes serve as sequestra for synaptonemal material which could prevent normal chromosomal disjunction.     

The relationship between chromosomes and axes in the chiasmatic XY pair of the Armenian hamster (Cricetulus migratorius)

The XY pair of the Armenian hamster has been studied in spreads and in three-dimensional reconstructions during the main stages of first meiotic prophase and metaphase I. The general pattern of the axes is similar to that of other mammals. There is a differential and a common region. In the latter a synaptonemal complex (SC) is formed by the pairing of the axes. This SC is longer than in other mammals. Heteropycnosis in the differential region is mirrored by differential chromatin packing at the ultrastructural level. The differential regions of the X and Y chromosomes can be identified both at the light and at the electron microscope level. The location of the axes at the interchromatid space in the differential region has been established. The visualization of the axes with the light microscope is facilitated by their bulgings at the beginning of mid-pachytene. These intermittent deformities change into a coiled and thinner axis during mid-pachytene. A chiasma originates in the common region of the XY body and it is seen near the ends of the sex chromosomes at diakinesis and metaphase I. The ultrastructure of this chiasmatic region is similar to that of autosomal chiasmata in the mouse. The axes separate from each other and leave a remaining piece of SC in which the central space is replaced by dense fibrillar material. During metaphase I the ultrastructure of this chiasmatic region cannot be identified because of the partial loss of the marker axes.     

The meiotic behaviour of the XY pair in Lutreolina crassicaudata (Marsupialia: Didelphoidea)

The meiotic behaviour of the XY pair of the didelphid Lutreolina crassicaudata is analyzed by microspreading of spermatocytes for visualization of chromosomal axes and by three-dimensional reconstruction of spermatocyte nuclei from EM thin sections. The delay in pairing of sex chromosomes compared to autosomes and the absence of a synaptonemal complex between the axes of the X and Y chromosomes, already described for South American marsupials by three-dimensional reconstruction and for Australian species with synaptonemal complex microspreadings, is confirmed for this species. Sections demonstrate that at the diffuse stage and diplotene the dense plate occupies the region of the inner face of the nuclear envelope in contact with the XY body. Spreads show an structure similar in staining to the axes that becomes apparent simultaneously with the dense plate, called a balloon. The mechanism of XY pairing during meiotic prophase appears to be common to American and Australian marsupials as the same morphological pattern is found in all the species described. This mechanism is different from the way of pairing and segregation known for eutherian sex chromosomes.     

Meiotic configurations in female trisomy 21 foetuses

Summary Analysis of the meiotic configurations formed by the three No 21 chromosomes in oocytes from two trisomy 21 foetuses was undertaken using a spreading technique. Light microscope analysis of the first gave limited resolving power, such that over half the oocytes could not be classified as to presence or absence of trivalent or bivalent plusunivalent. In the second, investigated at the electron microscope level, all 65 cells analysed were informative and precise detail of meiotic pairing in trivalents could be obtained. Two principal forms of trivalent occurred, one in which pairing was initiated at opposite ends of the three No 21's, each initiation point involving only two of the three homologous lateral elements; the other in which pairing was initiated by all three elements at the same end, a triple synaptonemal complex being formed. Only in one oocyte out of the 65 analysed at EM level, however, did triple pairing occur along the entire length of the No 21 trivalent. All others showed splitting into bivalent and univalent at some point along the structure. Unpaired regions within trivalents and all univalents were consistently seen to be thickened and dark staining with silver over the whole period from pachytene to diplotene. This contrasted with the desynapsing lateral elements of previously paired synaptonemal complexes which appeared thin by comparison at diplotene. The significance of the thickening remains, as yet, obscure.     

Whole mount electron microscopy of meiotic chromosomes and the synaptonemal complex

The mechanism by which homologous chromosomes pair and crossover has been a major unsolved problem in genetics. Thin section electron microscopy of the synaptonemal complex has not provided enough details to allow any significant insight into this problem. Whole mount preparations of the testis of mice, quail, crayfish, and frogs provided a striking improvement in visualization of the morphological features of meiotic chromosomes. These studies, when combined with the use of deoxyribonuclease and trypsin allowed the following conclusions. 1. The synaptonemal complex (lateral and central elements with connecting L-C fibers) is composed of protein. 2. Contrary to common speculation the central element is not the pairing surface of homologous chromosomes. 3. The L-C fibers, averaging 75–100 Å in width, extend from the lateral elements and meet to form the central element which is usually composed of four fibers. 4. During leptotene, homologous axial elements, although unpaired for most of their length, attach next to each other at the nuclear membrane. 5. Short segments of the chromatin fibers attach to the lateral elements. These points of attachment are clustered, producing the chromomeres seen by light microscopy. 6. The chromatin fibers extend out from the lateral element as loops. Lampbrush chromosomes are thus not restricted to oogenesis but are common to all meiotic chromosomes.Since the morphological features of the central element of the synaptonemal complex persist despite extensive deoxyribonuclease digestion, pairing is perhaps best visualized as a two-step process consisting of a) chromosomal pairing during which the proteinaceous synaptonemal complex pulls homologous chromosomes into approximate association with each other, and b) molecular pairing, which probably takes place in the area around the synaptonemal complex.Supported by NIH Grants GM-15886 and C-2568, and The Charles and Henrietta Detoy Research Fellowship.     

A light microscopic study of the development and behaviour of the synaptonemal complex in spermatocytes of the mouse

A method is presented for the sequential analysis of male meiosis using hydroxyurea (HU). HU produces a gap in the spermatogenic line. The front of surviving cells behind the gap was examined day by day using silverstained whole mount spreads on glass slides. With this method it was possible to study the development and behaviour of the synaptonemal complex (SC) in mouse spermatocytes by the light microscope. At zygotene no unpaired axial elements could be seen. Unpaired axial elements were found to be specific for the diplotene stage. The axes of the XY pair could be recognized from late zygotene up to diplotene.     

Sequential analysis of synaptonemal complexes in the repopulating spermatocytes of Rattus norvegicus after restricting the germ cell population to spermatogonia by gossypol treatment

Synaptonemal complexes of the repopulating spermatocytes of male rats were analyzed day by day using silver-stained surface spread nuclei between 8 and 25 days after restricting the germ cell population to spermatogonia by treatment of gossypol acetic acid at 30 mg/kg body weight/day for 70 days. The method allowed sequential analysis of male meiotic prophase on successive days after the last day of treatment. The leptotene cells appeared on day 11 and were characterized by a network of lateral elements and large nucleolar bodies in a diffuse mass. On day 13 the unpaired lateral elements and short stretches of synaptonemal complexes characteristic for zygotene could be seen. Pachytene nuclei showing 20 autosomal synaptonemal complexes and XY axes appeared on day 15. The diplotene cells were defined on day 22 by the loss of a complete synaptonemal complex set and by the appearance of disjoined lateral elements and persistent segments of synaptonemal complexes.     

Crossing over is coupled to late meiotic prophase bivalent differentiation through asymmetric disassembly of the SC

Homologous chromosome pairs (bivalents) undergo restructuring during meiotic prophase to convert a configuration that promotes crossover recombination into one that promotes bipolar spindle attachment and localized cohesion loss. We have imaged remodeling of meiotic chromosome structures after pachytene exit in Caenorhabditis elegans. Chromosome shortening during diplonema is accompanied by coiling of chromosome axes and highly asymmetric departure of synaptonemal complex (SC) central region proteins SYP-1 and SYP-2, which diminish over most of the length of each desynapsing bivalent while becoming concentrated on axis segments distal to the single emerging chiasma. This and other manifestations of asymmetry along chromosomes are lost in synapsis-proficient crossover-defective mutants, which often retain SYP-1,2 along the full lengths of coiled diplotene axes. Moreover, a gamma-irradiation treatment that restores crossovers in the spo-11 mutant also restores asymmetry of SYP-1 localization. We propose that crossovers or crossover precursors serve as symmetry-breaking events that promote differentiation of subregions of the bivalent by triggering asymmetric disassembly of the SC.     

Anti-topoisomerase II recognizes meiotic chromosome cores

At meiotic prophase the chromatin becomes arranged in loops on newly formed chromosome cores. The cores of homologous chromosomes become aligned in parallel and thus form the synaptonemal complex (SC), a structure found in the meiocytes of nearly all recombinationally competent, sexually reproducing organisms. We report that two polyclonal antibodies against topoisomerase II (topo II), which recognize the mitotic metaphase chromosome scaffold give, at pachytene, a positive immunocytological reaction with the chromatin and, predominantly, with the cores and centromeric regions of the paired chromosomes. It therefore appears that during meiotic prophase, topo II — a DNA-binding enzyme implicated in transient double-strand breaks, chromosome condensation, and anaphase separation — is associated with the chromatin and SCs of the pachytene and diplotene chromosomes.     

Presence of abnormal synaptonemal complexes in heterothallic species of Neurospora

Synaptonemal complex abnormalities are frequent in reconstructed meiotic prophase nuclei of Neurospora crassa and Neurospora intermedia. Three kinds of synaptonemal complex anomalies were seen: lateral component splits, lateral component junctions, and multiple complexes. The anomalies apparently are formed during or after the pairing process, as they were not seen in the largely unpaired early zygotene chromosomes. Their presence at all the other substages from mid-zygotene to late pachytene indicates that they are not eliminated before the synaptonemal complex decomposes at diplotene. Abnormal synaptonemal complexes were seen in all 19 crosses of N. crassa and N. intermedia that were examined, including matings between standard laboratory strains, inversions, Spore killers, and strains collected from nature. The frequency of affected nuclei and degree of abnormality within a nucleus varied in different matings. No abnormalities were present in the homothallic species Neurospora africana and Neurospora terricola. Structural chromosome aberrations, introgression, and heterozygosity have been eliminated as causes for pairing disorder. The abnormal synaptonemal complexes seemingly do not interfere with normal ascus development and ascospore formation. The affected nuclei are not aborted during meiotic prophase, nor are they eliminated by abortion of mature asci. The abnormal meiocytes do not lead to aneuploidy, as judged by the low frequency of white ascospores in crosses between wild type strains that have many abnormalities. Thus, the abnormal synatonemal complexes do not appear to prevent chiasma formation between homologues.     

Sex chromosome pairing during male meiosis in marsupials

The pairing of the sex chromosomes at pachytene has been examined in twenty-two species of Australian marsupials, including four with complex sex chromosome systems. The axial elements of the sex chromosomes associate in all but one species. However, no synaptonemal complex has been observed between the axes of the X and Y chromosome in any of the examined species. Both the type of association between the sex chromosome axes, and the structural modifications of these axes are conserved within taxonomic groupings. In three species with complex sex chromosome systems, the t(XA), Y, A trivalents do not have a favoured relative orientation of the axes of the Y and A chromosomes, whereas in a fourth species with a t(XA₁), t(A₂YA₂), A₂ system the t(XA₁) and A₂ axes are in a cis arrangement with each other.