Homology Search and Choice of Homologous Partner during Mitotic Recombination

Homologous recombination is an important DNA repair mechanism in vegetative cells. During the repair of double-strand breaks, genetic information is transferred between the interacting DNA sequences (gene conversion). This event is often accompanied by a reciprocal exchange between the homologous molecules, resulting in crossing over. The repair of DNA damage by homologous recombination with repeated sequences dispersed throughout the genome might result in chromosomal aberrations or in the inactivation of genes. It is therefore important to understand how the suitable homologous partner for recombination is chosen. We have developed a system in the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae that can monitor the fate of a chromosomal double-strand break without the need to select for recombinants. The broken chromosome is efficiently repaired by recombination with one of two potential partners located elsewhere in the genome. One of the partners has homology to the broken ends of the chromosome, whereas the other is homologous to sequences distant from the break. Surprisingly, a large proportion of the repair is carried out by recombination involving the sequences distant from the broken ends. This repair is very efficient, despite the fact that it requires the processing of a large chromosomal region flanking the break. Our results imply that the homology search involves extensive regions of the broken chromosome and is not carried out exclusively by sequences adjacent to the double-strand break. We show that the mechanism that governs the choice of homologous partners is affected by the length and sequence divergence of the interacting partners, as well as by mutations in the mismatch repair genes. We present a model to explain how the suitable homologous partner is chosen during recombinational repair. The model provides a mechanism that may guard the integrity of the genome by preventing recombination between dispersed repeated sequences.     

Recombination-Independent Recognition of DNA Homology for Repeat-Induced Point Mutation (RIP) Is Modulated by the Underlying Nucleotide Sequence

Haploid germline nuclei of many filamentous fungi have the capacity to detect homologous nucleotide sequences present on the same or different chromosomes. Once recognized, such sequences can undergo cytosine methylation or cytosine-to-thymine mutation specifically over the extent of shared homology. In Neurospora crassa this process is known as Repeat-Induced Point mutation (RIP). Previously, we showed that RIP did not require MEI-3, the only RecA homolog in Neurospora, and that it could detect homologous trinucleotides interspersed with a matching periodicity of 11 or 12 base-pairs along participating chromosomal segments. This pattern was consistent with a mechanism of homology recognition that involved direct interactions between co-aligned double-stranded (ds) DNA molecules, where sequence-specific dsDNA/dsDNA contacts could be established using no more than one triplet per turn. In the present study we have further explored the DNA sequence requirements for RIP. In our previous work, interspersed homologies were always examined in the context of a relatively long adjoining region of perfect homology. Using a new repeat system lacking this strong interaction, we now show that interspersed homologies with overall sequence identity of only 36% can be efficiently detected by RIP in the absence of any perfect homology. Furthermore, in this new system, where the total amount of homology is near the critical threshold required for RIP, the nucleotide composition of participating DNA molecules is identified as an important factor. Our results specifically pinpoint the triplet 5''-GAC-3'' as a particularly efficient unit of homology recognition. Finally, we present experimental evidence that the process of homology sensing can be uncoupled from the downstream mutation. Taken together, our results advance the notion that sequence information can be compared directly between double-stranded DNA molecules during RIP and, potentially, in other processes where homologous pairing of intact DNA molecules is observed.     

Gentle masking of low-complexity sequences improves homology search

Detection of sequences that are homologous, i.e. descended from a common ancestor, is a fundamental task in computational biology. This task is confounded by low-complexity tracts (such as atatatatatat), which arise frequently and independently, causing strong similarities that are not homologies. There has been much research on identifying low-complexity tracts, but little research on how to treat them during homology search. We propose to find homologies by aligning sequences with "gentle" masking of low-complexity tracts. Gentle masking means that the match score involving a masked letter is min(0,S), where S is the unmasked score. Gentle masking slightly but noticeably improves the sensitivity of homology search (compared to "harsh" masking), without harming specificity. We show examples in three useful homology search problems: detection of NUMTs (nuclear copies of mitochondrial DNA), recruitment of metagenomic DNA reads to reference genomes, and pseudogene detection. Gentle masking is currently the best way to treat low-complexity tracts during homology search.     

Topological testing of the mechanism of homology search promoted by RecA protein

To initiate homologous recombination, sequence similarity between two DNA molecules must be searched for and homology recognized. How the search for and recognition of homology occurs remains unproven. We have examined the influences of DNA topology and the polarity of RecA–single-stranded (ss)DNA filaments on the formation of synaptic complexes promoted by RecA. Using two complementary methods and various ssDNA and duplex DNA molecules as substrates, we demonstrate that topological constraints on a small circular RecA–ssDNA filament prevent it from interwinding with its duplex DNA target at the homologous region. We were unable to detect homologous pairing between a circular RecA–ssDNA filament and its relaxed or supercoiled circular duplex DNA targets. However, the formation of synaptic complexes between an invading linear RecA–ssDNA filament and covalently closed circular duplex DNAs is promoted by supercoiling of the duplex DNA. The results imply that a triplex structure formed by non-Watson–Crick hydrogen bonding is unlikely to be an intermediate in homology searching promoted by RecA. Rather, a model in which RecA-mediated homology searching requires unwinding of the duplex DNA coupled with local strand exchange is the likely mechanism. Furthermore, we show that polarity of the invading RecA–ssDNA does not affect its ability to pair and interwind with its circular target duplex DNA.     

Efficient Detection of Unpaired DNA Requires a Member of the Rad54-Like Family of Homologous Recombination Proteins

Meiotic silencing by unpaired DNA (MSUD) is a process that detects unpaired regions between homologous chromosomes and silences them for the duration of sexual development. While the phenomenon of MSUD is well recognized, the process that detects unpaired DNA is poorly understood. In this report, we provide two lines of evidence linking unpaired DNA detection to a physical search for DNA homology. First, we have found that a putative SNF2-family protein (SAD-6) is required for efficient MSUD in Neurospora crassa. SAD-6 is closely related to Rad54, a protein known to facilitate key steps in the repair of double-strand breaks by homologous recombination. Second, we have successfully masked unpaired DNA by placing identical transgenes at slightly different locations on homologous chromosomes. This masking falls apart when the distance between the transgenes is increased. We propose a model where unpaired DNA detection during MSUD is achieved through a spatially constrained search for DNA homology. The identity of SAD-6 as a Rad54 paralog suggests that this process may be similar to the searching mechanism used during homologous recombination.     

BLASTing proteomes,yielding phylogenies

We develop a procedure called RiPE (Retrieval-induced Phylogeny Environment) that automatically performs an evolutionary analysis of a protein (sub)family, (i) by retrieving the relevant sequences via a homology search, (ii) by using the search report to construct the alignment using only homologous subsequences (taking into account their neighborhood with a low chance of homology), (iii) by realigning, and (iv) by generating phylogenetic trees based on the alignment. In a first implementation of our scheme, we start with the available proteome data of model organisms, perform a PSI-BLAST search, use MView to convert hits into a multiple alignment, and perform realignment and tree building. As a test case, we have investigated the human ABC transporters of the subfamily G, starting with the five known human ABCG transporters. Our method retrieved homologous sequences not previously analyzed, generating a tree that is more plausible and better supported than previously published trees. The RiPE 0.1 prototype is available at the RiPE website, http://ifg-izkf.uni-muenster.de/fuellen/RiPE/ripe.html.     

A Sister-Strand Exchange Mechanism for Reca-Independent Deletion of Repeated DNA Sequences in Escherichia Coli

In the genomes of many organisms, deletions arise between tandemly repeated DNA sequences of lengths ranging from several kilobases to only a few nucleotides. Using a plasmid-based assay for deletion of a 787-bp tandem repeat, we have found that a recA-independent mechanism contributes substantially to the deletion process of even this large region of homology. No Escherichia coli recombination gene tested, including recA, had greater than a fivefold effect on deletion rates. The recA-independence of deletion formation is also observed with constructions present on the chromosome. RecA promotes synapsis and transfer of homologous DNA strands in vitro and is indispensable for intermolecular recombination events in vivo measured after conjugation. Because deletion formation in E. coli shows little or no dependence on recA, it has been assumed that homologous recombination contributes little to the deletion process. However, we have found recA-independent deletion products suggestive of reciprocal crossovers when branch migration in the cell is inhibited by a ruvA mutation. We propose a model for recA-independent crossovers between replicating sister strands, which can also explain deletion or amplification of repeated sequences. We suggest that this process may be initiated as post-replicational DNA repair; subsequent strand misalignment at repeated sequences leads to genetic rearrangements.     

Nucleotide sequence of circular DNA molecules homologous to the 240 bp tandem repeats of the intergenic spacer of Drosophila melanogaster ribosomal DNA

We have determined the nucleotide sequence of ten 240 bp repeated sequences of the DNA intergenic spacer present in circular DNA molecules purified from D melanogaster embryos. No significant difference was found with the sequence of the chromosomal units. This suggests that most of the circular molecules homologous to the 240 bp repeats are generated by homologous recombination between adjacent chromosomal units.     

The Search for Homology Does Not Limit the Rate of Extrachromosomal Homologous Recombination in Mammalian Cells

Mouse LTK(-) cells were transfected with a pair of defective Herpes simplex virus thymidine kinase (tk) genes. One tk gene had an 8-bp insertion mutation while the second gene had a 100-bp inversion. Extrachromosomal homologous recombination leading to the reconstruction of a functional tk gene was monitored by selecting for tk positive cells using medium supplemented with hypoxanthine/aminopterin/thymidine. To assess whether the search for homology may be a rate-limiting step of recombination, we asked whether the presence of an excess number of copies of a tk gene possessing both the insertion and inversion mutations could inhibit recombination between the singly mutated tk genes. Effective competitive inhibition would require that homology searching (homologous pairing) occur rapidly and efficiently. We cotransfected plasmid constructs containing the singly mutated genes in the presence or absence of competitor sequences in various combinations of linear or circular forms. We observed effective inhibition by the competitor DNA in six of the seven combinations studied. A lack of inhibition was observed only when the insertion mutant gene was cleaved within the insertion mutation and cotransfected with the two other molecules in circular form. Additional experiments suggested that homologous interactions between two DNA sequences may compete in trans with recombination between two other sequences. We conclude that homology searching is not a rate-limiting step of extrachromosomal recombination in mammalian cells. Additionally, we speculate that a limiting factor is involved in a recombination step following homologous pairing and has a high affinity for DNA termini.     

Circular and linear plasmids of Lyme disease spirochetes have extensive homology: characterization of a repeated DNA element.

We have cloned three copies of a repeated DNA segment from Borrelia burgdorferi sensu stricto strain B31, present on both circular and linear plasmids of this and other B. burgdorferi sensu lato strains. The DNA sequences are characterized by a highly homologous segment containing two open reading frames (ORFs), ORF-A and ORF-B. Five additional ORFs can be found on the slightly less homologous flanking sequences: ORF-G on the opposite strand upstream of ORF-A, and ORF-C, ORF-D, ORF-E, and ORF-F downstream of ORF-B. The 4.6-kb-long element containing ORF-A through ORF-E is flanked by approximately 180-bp-long imperfect inverted repeats (IRs). The putative gene product of ORF-C displays homology to proteins involved in plasmid maintenance in a number of gram-positive and gram-negative bacteria. ORF-E features several short, highly homologous direct repeats. ORF-A, ORF-B, and ORF-D are homologous to three ORFs on a recently described 8.3-kb circular plasmid of Borrelia afzelii Ip21 that are flanked by similar IRs (J. J. Dunn, S. R. Buchstein, L.-L. Butler, S. Fisenne, D. S. Polin, B. N. Lade, and B. J. Luft, J. Bacteriol. 176:2706-2717,1994). ORF-C and ORF-E, however, are missing from this region on the Ip21 plasmid. Furthermore, the repeated DNA element as defined by the IRs is present in opposite orientations relative to the flanking sequences on the B31 and Ip21 plasmids.     

Finding a match: how do homologous sequences get together for recombination?

Decades of research into homologous recombination have unravelled many of the details concerning the transfer of information between two homologous sequences. By contrast, the processes by which the interacting molecules initially colocalize are largely unknown. How can two homologous needles find each other in the genomic haystack? Is homologous pairing the result of a damage-induced homology search, or is it an enduring and general feature of the genomic architecture that facilitates homologous recombination whenever and wherever damage occurs? This Review presents the homologous-pairing enigma, delineates our current understanding of the process and offers guidelines for future research.     

Reassociation and dissociation of cytoplasmic membrane-associated DNA

The relationship between nuclear DNA and cytoplasmic membrane-associated DNA, extracted from a human lymphocyte cell line, was examined by DNA-DNA reannealing and by dissociation of renatured molecules. Up to 2% of the total cellular DNA is found in the cytoplasm as cytoplasmic membrane-associated DNA and of this 2%, approximately 70% is comprised of repeated sequences. These sequences are homologous to only about 4% of the repeated sequences of nuclear DNA. The repeat fraction of cytoplasmic membrane-associated DNA consists of sequences which are only moderately repeated. The number of copies in the average “family” could range from about 1500 copies to as few as 25 copies. A small rapidly reannealing portion of cytoplasmic membrane-associated DNA (C₀t < 4 × 10^?3) appears to consist of sequences derived from a single “family”.About 30% of cytoplasmic membrane-associated DNA reassociates slowly with a $\text{C}{}_0\text{t}\text{1}\text{2}$ value of 223 (unique cytoplasmic membrane-associated DNA). This fraction has homology with about 11% of the unique sequences of nuclear DNA. However, unique cytoplasmic membrane-associated DNA comprises only about 0·6% of the total cellular DNA. If it is assumed that each cell has the same amount of cytoplasmic membrane-associated DNA, homology with 11% of the unique sequences of nuclear DNA suggests that different cells may have different unique nucleotide sequences in the cytoplasm.     

Caught in the act: the lifetime of synaptic intermediates during the search for homology on DNA

Homologous recombination plays pivotal roles in DNA repair and in the generation of genetic diversity. To locate homologous target sequences at which strand exchange can occur within a timescale that a cell’s biology demands, a single-stranded DNA-recombinase complex must search among a large number of sequences on a genome by forming synapses with chromosomal segments of DNA. A key element in the search is the time it takes for the two sequences of DNA to be compared, i.e. the synapse lifetime. Here, we visualize for the first time fluorescently tagged individual synapses formed by RecA, a prokaryotic recombinase, and measure their lifetime as a function of synapse length and differences in sequence between the participating DNAs. Surprisingly, lifetimes can be ∼10 s long when the DNAs are fully heterologous, and much longer for partial homology, consistently with ensemble FRET measurements. Synapse lifetime increases rapidly as the length of a region of full homology at either the 3′- or 5′-ends of the invading single-stranded DNA increases above 30 bases. A few mismatches can reduce dramatically the lifetime of synapses formed with nearly homologous DNAs. These results suggest the need for facilitated homology search mechanisms to locate homology successfully within the timescales observed in vivo.     

Isolation and structure of a rat cytochrome c gene

We screened a Charon 4A-rat genomic library using the cloned iso-1 cytochrome c gene from Saccharomyces cerevisiae as a specific hybridization probe. Eight different recombinant phages homologous to a coding region subfragment of the yeast gene were isolated. Nucleotide sequence analysis of a 0.96-kilobase portion of one of these established the existence of a gene coding for a cytochrome c identical in amino acid sequence with that of mouse. The rat polypeptide chain sequence had not previously been determined. In contrast to the yeast iso-1 and iso-2 cytochrome c genes, neither of which have introns, the rat gene contains a single 105-base pair intervening sequence interrupting glycine codon 56. The overall nucleotide sequence homology between cytochrome c genes of yeast and rat is about 62%, with areas of greater homology coinciding with four regions of functionally constrained amino acid sequences. Two of these regions displayed 85-90% DNA sequence homology, including the longest consecutive homologous stretch of 14 nucleotides, corresponding to amino acids 47-52 of the rat protein. Somewhat less homology was observed in the DNA-specifying amino acids 70-80, which are invariant residues in most known cytochrome c molecules. Thermal dissociation of the yeast probe from the homologous rat DNA was at about 58 degrees C in 0.39 M Na+. These results establish that cytochrome c genes may be isolated by interspecies hybridization between widely divergent organisms.     

Cloning and sequencing of viral integration site in human fibroblasts immortalized by simian virus 40.

We have analyzed cellular DNA sequences at the viral genome integration site in a human fibroblast cell line VA13 immortalized by simian virus 40 (SV40). The computer analysis of the junctional cellular DNA sequences did not show any homology to the DNA sequences previously reported. This suggests that immortalization by SV40 was not induced by the destruction of any known oncogene or anti-oncogene at the integration site. We did not find the precise substantial sequence homology at the junctional site between the cellular DNA and SV40 DNA, indicating that the recombination mechanism involved does not require precise sequence homology and therefore, SV40 genome was probably not integrated by homologous recombination. Short direct and inverted repeats of 5 to 29 nucleotides were found in the junctional cellular and SV40 DNA. Cellular DNA abutting SV40 DNA was found by the Northern blot analysis to be expressed in diploid human fibroblasts and SV40-transformed cells. The nature of this RNA is now under study.     

Identification of functional open reading frames in chloroplast genomes

We have used a rapid computer dot-matrix comparison method to identify all DNA regions which have been evolutionarily conserved between the completely sequenced chloroplast genomes of tobacco and a liverwort. Analysis of these regions reveals 74 homologous open reading frames (ORFs) which have been conserved as to length and amino acid sequence; these ORFs also have an excess of nucleotide substitutions at silent sites of codons. Since the nonfunctional parts of these genomes have become saturated with mutations and show no sequence similarity whatsoever, the homologous ORFs are almost certainly functional. A further four pairs of ORFs show homology limited to only a short part of their putative gene products. Amino acid sequence identities range between 50 and 99%; some chloroplast proteins are seen to be among the most slowly evolving of all known proteins. A search of the nucleotide and amino acid sequence databanks has revealed several previously unidentified genes in chloroplast sequences from other species, but no new homologies to prokaryotic genes.     

Illegitimate recombination in the histone multigenic family generates circular DNAs in Drosophila embryos.

From extrachromosomal covalently closed circular DNA molecules purified from Drosophila melanogaster embryos, we have isolated 24 clones homologous to the histone tandemly repeated gene family. Some of the clones harbor one of the two main types of genomic repeated units of 4.8 and 5.0 kb. and probably result from homologous recombination. The remaining clones have a size ranging from 0.2 to 2.5 kb. and most of them carry a single fragment of the repeated unit. Nucleotide sequences of the junction region of six of these clones indicate they are generated by illegitimate recombination between short (8-15 bp.) imperfect direct repeats. The data suggest that most of the histone homologous circular DNA molecules are deleted histone units.     

Stimulation of D-loop formation by polypurine/polypyrimidine sequences

Most of the approaches used to correct gene mutations in mammalian cells involve the targeting of short nucleotide molecules to homologous chromosomal sequences and the replacement of resident sequences via homologous recombination and mismatch repair. The limited efficiency and inconsistent reproducibility of these techniques are major constraints to their use in gene therapy. One of the main problems is that it is impossible to obtain reproducible results when the targeted gene loci differ. We investigated the effects of flanking sequences on homologous recombination by means of an in vitro assay of the efficiency of oligonucleotide targeting to its homologous sequence on a large duplex molecule in a reaction catalysed by the Escherichia coli RecA protein. We demonstrated that polypurine·polypyrimidine tracts (PPTs) in duplex DNA strongly stimulate the formation of D-loops with short oligodeoxynucleotides. This result was reproduced with various PPT sequences and oligonucleotides. The stimulatory effect was observed at loci as far as 4000 bp from the PPT. The formation of complexes between the oligonucleotide and the duplex molecule depended on the extent of sequence similarity between the two DNAs and the presence of the RecA protein. The stimulatory effect was inhibited by excess RecA and restored by adding heterologous DNA. We suggest that PPT sequences induce conformational changes in duplex DNA, leading to the aggregation of molecules, facilitating homology searches. We com pared, in vivo, the efficiency of the oligonucleotide-mediated correction of a URA3 chromosomal mutation for sequences with and without a PPT sequence in the vicinity. Consistent with our in vitro results, the efficiency of correction was eight times higher in the presence of the PPT sequence.     

A new repeat-masking method enables specific detection of homologous sequences

Biological sequences are often analyzed by detecting homologous regions between them. Homology search is confounded by simple repeats, which give rise to strong similarities that are not homologies. Standard repeat-masking methods fail to eliminate this problem, and they are especially ill-suited to AT-rich DNA such as malaria and slime-mould genomes. We present a new repeat-masking method, tantan, which is motivated by the mechanisms that create simple repeats. This method thoroughly eliminates spurious homology predictions for DNA–DNA, protein–protein and DNA–protein comparisons. Moreover, it enables accurate homology search for non-coding DNA with extreme A + T composition.