A functional interaction of SmpB with tmRNA for determination of the resuming point of trans-translation

In trans-translation, transfer-messenger RNA (tmRNA), possessing a dual function as a tRNA and an mRNA, relieves a stalled translation on the ribosome with the help of SmpB. Here, we established an in vitro system using Escherichia coli translation and trans-translation factors to evaluate two steps of trans-translation, peptidyl transfer from peptidyl-tRNA to alanyl-tmRNA and translation of the resume codon on tmRNA. Using this system, the effects of several mutations upstream of the tag-encoding region on tmRNA were examined. These mutations affected translation of the resume codon rather than peptidyl transfer, and one of them, A84U/U85G, caused a shift of the resume codon by -1. We also found that U(85) is protected from chemical modification by SmpB. In the A84U/U85G mutant, the base of protection was shifted from 85 to 84. Another mutation, A86U, which caused a shift of the resume codon by +1, shifted the base of protection from 85 to 86. The protection at 85 was suppressed by a mutation in the tRNA-like domain critical to SmpB binding. These results suggest that SmpB serves to bridge two separate domains of tmRNA to determine the initial codon for tag-translation. A mutant SmpB with a truncation of the unstructured C-terminal tail failed to promote peptidyl transfer, although it still protected U(85) from chemical modification.     

tmRNA determinants required for facilitating nonstop mRNA decay

In bacteria, ribosomes stalled on nonstop mRNAs are rescued by tmRNA in a unique process called trans-translation. The two known tmRNA functions in trans-translation are (1) a tRNA-like function, which transfers the partially synthesized protein fragment to itself; and (2) an mRNA-like function, which enables ribosomes to resume and terminate translation on tmRNA as a surrogate template. We present evidence to demonstrate that tmRNA performs a third function, namely, facilitating the degradation of the causative defective mRNA. Our investigations have revealed the identity of key sequence determinants that promote the degradation of the nonstop mRNA. These sequence determinants are located in the distal part of the tmRNA open reading frame, encoding the ultimate, penultimate, and anti-penultimate amino acids of the peptide tag. We show that mutation of these tmRNA sequence elements has an adverse affect on the disposal of the nonstop mRNA, while leaving the tRNA and mRNA functions entirely unaffected. More significantly, specific mutations that change the nucleotide sequence of the peptide-reading frame without altering the nature or identity of the encoded amino acids still exhibit the characteristic defect in nonstop mRNA decay. In contrast, mutations in codons 3, 4, 5, and 6 of the tmRNA open reading frame do not have an adverse affect on degradation of defective mRNAs. Based on these results, we propose that tmRNA plays an important role in promoting the decay of nonstop mRNAs and that sequence elements in the distal segment of the peptide-reading frame make sequence-specific contributions that are crucial for this activity.     

Structure probing of tmRNA in distinct stages of trans-translation

Ribosomes stalled on problematic mRNAs in bacterial cells can be rescued by transfer-messenger RNA (tmRNA), its helper protein (small protein B, SmpB), and elongation factor Tu (EF-Tu) through a mechanism called trans-translation. In this work we used lead(II) footprinting to probe the interactions of tmRNA with SmpB and other components of the translation machinery at different steps of the trans-translation cycle. Ribosomes with a short nascent peptide stalled on a truncated mRNA were reacted with Ala-tmRNA*EF-Tu*GTP, SmpB, and other translation components to initiate and execute trans-translation. Free tmRNA was probed with lead(II) acetate with and without SmpB, and ribosome bound tmRNA was probed in one of four different trans-translation states stabilized by antibiotic addition or selective exclusion of translation components. For comparison, we also analyzed lead(II) cleavage patterns of tmRNA in vivo in a wild-type as well as in an SmpB-deficient Escherichia coli strain. We observed some specific cleavages/protections in tmRNA for the individual steps of trans-translation, but the overall tmRNA conformation appeared to be similar in the stages analyzed. Our findings suggest that, in vivo, a dominant fraction of tmRNA is in complex with SmpB and that, in vitro, SmpB remains tmRNA bound at the initial steps of trans-translation.     

反式翻译模型

反式翻译是细菌体内一种修复翻译水平上受阻的遗传信息表达过程的机制。tmRNA是反式翻译的核心分子,它兼具tRNA和mRNA的特点,在SmpB蛋白的帮助下特异性识别携带mRNA缺失体的核糖体,在核糖体蛋白S1的传递作用下结合在A位点上,一方面延续被中断的mRNA上的遗传信息,一方面终止蛋白质的合成,释放被束缚的核糖体和tRNA进入新的翻译过程。本文对近年来关于反式翻译模型的研究进行综述。     

Analysis of the role of trans-translation in the requirement of tmRNA for lambdaimmP22 growth in Escherichia coli

The small, stable RNA molecule encoded by ssrA, known as tmRNA or 10Sa RNA, is required for the growth of certain hybrid lambdaimmP22 phages in Escherichia coli. tmRNA has been shown to tag partially synthesized proteins for degradation in vivo by attaching a short peptide sequence, encoded by tmRNA, to the carboxyl termini of these proteins. This tag sequence contains, at its C terminus, an amino acid sequence that is recognized by cellular proteases and leads to degradation of tagged proteins. A model describing this function of tmRNA, the trans-translation model (K. C. Keiler, P. R. Waller, and R. T. Sauer, Science 271:990-993, 1996), proposes that tmRNA acts first as a tRNA and then as a mRNA, resulting in release of the original mRNA template from the ribosome and translocation of the nascent peptide to tmRNA. Previous work from this laboratory suggested that tmRNA may also interact specifically with DNA-binding proteins, modulating their activity. However, more recent results indicate that interactions between tmRNA and DNA-binding proteins are likely nonspecific. In light of this new information, we examine the effects on lambdaimmP22 growth of mutations eliminating activities postulated to be important for two different steps in the trans-translation model, alanine charging of tmRNA and degradation of tagged proteins. This mutational analysis suggests that, while charging of tmRNA with alanine is essential for lambdaimmP22 growth in E. coli, degradation of proteins tagged by tmRNA is required only to achieve optimal levels of phage growth. Based on these results, we propose that trans-translation may have two roles, the primary role being the release of stalled ribosomes from their mRNA template and the secondary role being the tagging of truncated proteins for degradation.     

Functional and structural analysis of a pseudoknot upstream of the tag-encoded sequence in E. coli tmRNA

Escherichia coli tmRNA (transfer-messenger RNA) facilitates a trans-translation reaction in which a stalled ribosome on a terminatorless mRNA switches to an internal coding sequence in tmRNA, resulting in the addition of an 11 amino acid residue tag to the truncated protein that is a signal for degradation and in recycling of the stalled ribosome. A tmRNA secondary structure model with a partial tRNA-like structure and several pseudoknots was recently proposed. This report describes an extensive mutational analysis of one predicted pseudoknot (PK1) located upstream of the E. coli tmRNA tag-encoded sequence. Both the extent of aminoacylation and the alanine incorporation into the tag sequence, reflecting the two functions of tmRNA, were measured in vitro for all the engineered RNA variants. To characterize structure-function relationships for the tmRNA mutants, their solution conformations were investigated by using structural probes and by measuring the temperature dependence of their UV absorbance. This analysis strongly supports the presence of a pseudoknot in E. coli tmRNA, and its involvement in trans-translation. Mutations disrupting the first stem of the pseudoknot inactivate function and promote stable alternative conformations. Mutations of the second stem of the pseudoknot also effect both functions. The nucleotide stretch between the two stems (loop 2) is required for efficient trans-translation, and nucleotides at positions 61 and 62 must be guanine residues. The probing data suggest the presence of magnesium ion(s) interacting with loop 2. The loops crossing the minor and major grooves can be mutated without significant effects on tmRNA function. Nucleotide insertion or deletion between the pseudoknot and the coding sequence do not change the mRNA frame of the tag-peptide sequence, suggesting that the pseudoknot structure is not a determinant for the resumption of translation.     

Contributions of pseudoknots and protein SmpB to the structure and function of tmRNA in trans-translation

Bacteria contain transfer-messenger RNA (tmRNA), a molecule that during trans-translation tags incompletely translated proteins with a small peptide to signal the proteolytic destruction of defective polypeptides. TmRNA is composed of tRNA- and mRNA-like domains connected by several pseudoknots. Using truncated ribosomal protein L27 as a reporter for tagging in vitro and in vivo, we have developed exceptionally sensitive assays to study the role of Escherichia coli tmRNA in trans-translation. Site-directed mutagenesis experiments showed that pseudoknot 2 and the abutting helix 5 were particularly important for the binding of ribosomal protein S1 to tmRNA. Pseudoknot 4 not only facilitated tmRNA maturation but also promoted tagging. In addition, the three pseudoknots (pk2 to pk4) were shown to play a significant role in the proper folding of the tRNA-like domain. Protein SmpB enhanced tmRNA processing, suggesting a new role for SmpB in trans-translation. Taken together, these results provide unanticipated insights into the functions of the pseudoknots and protein SmpB during tmRNA folding, maturation, and protein synthesis.     

Various effects of paromomycin on tmRNA-directed trans-translation

trans-Translation is an unusual translation in which tmRNA plays a dual function as a tRNA and an mRNA to relieve the stalled translation on the ribosome. In this study, we examined the effects of an aminoglycoside antibiotic, paromomycin, on several tmRNA-related events in vitro. The results of a chemical footprinting study indicated that paromomycin molecules bind tmRNA at G332/G333 in the tRNA domain and A316 in the middle of the long helix between tRNA and mRNA domains. Paromomycin bound at G332/G333 inhibited aminoacylation, and the inhibition was suppressed by the addition of SmpB, a tmRNA-binding protein. It was also found that paromomycin causes a shift of the translation resuming point on tmRNA by -1. The effect on initiation shift was canceled by a mutation at the paromomycin-binding site in 16 S rRNA but not by mutations in tmRNA. A high concentration of paromomycin inhibited trans-translation, whereas it enhanced the initiation-shifted trans-translation when SmpB was exogenously added or a mutation was introduced at 333. The effect of paromomycin on trans-translation differs substantially from that on canonical translation, in which it induces miscoding by modulating the A site of the decoding helix of the small subunit RNA of the ribosome.     

Inhibition of transfer messenger RNA aminoacylation and trans-translation by aminoglycoside antibiotics

Transfer messenger RNA (tmRNA) directs the modification of proteins of which the biosynthesis has stalled or has been interrupted. Here, we report that aminoglycosides can interfere with this quality control system in bacteria, termed trans-translation. Neomycin B is the strongest inhibitor of tmRNA aminoacylation with alanine (K(i) value of approximately 35 micro m), an essential step during trans-translation. The binding sites of neomycin B do not overlap with the identity determinants for alanylation, but the aminoglycoside perturbs the conformation of the acceptor stem that contains the aminoacylation signals. Aminoglycosides reduce the conformational freedom of the transfer RNA-like domain of tmRNA. Additional contacts between aminoglycosides and tmRNA are within the tag reading frame, probably also disturbing reprogramming of the stalled ribosomes prior protein tagging. Aminoglycosides impair tmRNA aminoacylation in the presence of all of the transfer RNAs from Escherichia coli, small protein B, and elongation factor Tu, but when both proteins are present, the inhibition constant is 1 order of magnitude higher. SmpB and elongation factor Tu have RNA chaperone activities, ensuring that tmRNA adopts an optimal conformation during aminoacylation.     

tmRNA and associated ligands: a puzzling relationship

Translation is an efficient and accurate mechanism, needing thorough systems of control-quality to ensure the correspondence between the information carried by the messenger RNA (mRNA) and the newly synthesized protein. Among them, trans-translation ensures delivering of stalled ribosomes when translation occurs on truncated mRNAs in bacteria, followed by the degradation of the incomplete nascent proteins. This process requires transfer-messenger RNA (tmRNA), an original molecule acting as both a tRNA and an mRNA. tmRNA first enters the decoding site of stuck ribosomes and, despite the lack of any codon-anticodon interaction, acts as a tRNA by transferring its alanine to the incomplete protein. Translation then switches to a small internal coding sequence (mRNA domain), which encodes a tag directing the incomplete protein towards degradation. Although playing a central role during trans-translation, tmRNA function depends on associated proteins. Genetic, biochemical and recent structural data are starting to unravel how the process takes place, by involving three main protein partners. Small protein B (SmpB) interacts with the tRNA-like domain (TLD) of tmRNA and is indispensable and specific to the process. Elongation factor Tu (EF-Tu) binds simultaneously the TLD and brings aminoacylated tmRNA to the ribosome, as for canonical tRNAs. Ribosomal protein S1 forms complexes with tmRNA, facilitating its recruitment by the stalled ribosomes. The chronology of events, however, is poorly understood and recent data shed light on the functions attributed to the proteins involved in trans-translation. This review focuses on the puzzling relationship that tmRNA has with these three protein ligands, putting forward trans-translation as a highly dynamical process.     

Ribosomal protein S1 is not essential for the trans-translation machinery

In eubacteria, ribosome stalling during protein synthesis is rescued by a tmRNA-derived trans-translation system. Because ribosomal protein S1 specifically binds to tmRNA with high affinity, it is considered to be involved in the trans-translation system. However, the role of S1 in trans-translation is still unclear. To study the function of S1 in the trans-translation system, we constructed an S1-free cell-free translation system. We found that trans-translation proceeded even in the absence of S1. Addition of S1 into the S1-free system did not affect trans-translation efficiency. These results suggest that S1 does not play a role in the trans-translation machinery.     

Phylogenetic analysis of tmRNA secondary structure.

The bacterial tmRNA acts with dual tRNA-like and mRNA-like character to tag incomplete translation products for degradation. Comparative analysis of 17 tmRNA genes (including eight new sequences) has allowed us to deduce conserved features of the tmRNA secondary structure. Except in a segment that includes the first codon of the tag reading frame, tmRNA is highly structured, with four pseudoknots and a total of 11 conserved base pairing regions. The previously identified tRNA minihelix structure is connected by a long base paired region to a large structured domain composed of a pseudoknot, followed by the tag reading frame and a string of three rather similar pseudoknots. The conservation of numerous structural elements among diverse eubacterial species indicates that these elements have important function beyond simply forming an endonuclease-resistant link between the reading frame and the tRNA-like domain.     

Binding and cross-linking of tmRNA to ribosomal protein S1, on and off the Escherichia coli ribosome

UV irradiation of an in vitro translation mixture induced cross-linking of 4-thioU-substituted tmRNA to Escherichia coli ribosomes by forming covalent complexes with ribosomal protein S1 and 16S rRNA. In the absence of S1, tmRNA was unable to bind and label ribosomal components. Mobility assays on native gels demonstrated that protein S1 bound to tmRNA with an apparent binding constant of 1 x 10(8) M(-1). A mutant tmRNA, lacking the tag coding region and pseudoknots pk2, pk3 and pk4, did not compete with full-length tmRNA, indicating that this region is required for S1 binding. This was confirmed by identification of eight cross-linked nucleotides: U85, located before the resume codon of tmRNA; U105, in the mRNA portion of tmRNA; U172 in pK2; U198, U212, U230 and U240 in pk3; and U246, in the junction between pk3 and pk4. We concluded that ribosomal protein S1, in concert with the previously identified elongation factor EF-Tu and protein SmpB, plays an important role in tmRNA-mediated trans-translation by facilitating the binding of tmRNA to ribosomes and forming complexes with free tmRNA.     

Trans-translation mediated by Bacillus subtilis tmRNA

Trans-translation, in which a ribosome switches between translation of an mRNA and a tmRNA, produces a chimera polypeptide of an N-terminal truncated polypeptide and a C-terminal tag-peptide encoded by tmRNA. One of the tmRNA binding proteins, a ribosomal protein S1, has not been found in a group of Gram-positive bacteria. In this study, the trans-translation reaction with tmRNA from Bacillus subtilis belonging to this group was examined. When a truncated gene lacking a termination codon was expressed in B. subtilis, a 15-amino acid tag-peptide derived from tmRNA was identified in the C-termini of the trans-translation products. An identical tag-peptide was also found at the C-termini of the products from a truncated gene, when it was coexpressed with B. subtilis tmRNA in Escherichia coli. B. subtilis tmRNA was functional, although much less efficiently, in the in vitro poly(U)-dependent tag-peptide synthesis system of E. coli. A comparison of two bacterial tmRNAs suggests that the rule for determining the tag-initiation point on tmRNA may be the same in Gram-positive and Gram-negative bacteria.     

Simultaneous and functional binding of SmpB and EF-Tu-TP to the alanyl acceptor arm of tmRNA.

Transfer-messenger RNA (tmRNA) mimics functions of aminoacyl-tRNA and mRNA, subsequently, when rescuing stalled ribosomes on a 3' truncated mRNA without stop codon in bacteria. In addition, this mechanism marks prematurely terminated proteins by a C-terminal peptide tag as a signal for degradation by specific cellular proteases. For Escherichia coli, previous studies on initial steps of this "trans-translation" mechanism revealed that tmRNA alanylation by Ala-tRNA synthetase and binding of Ala-tmRNA by EF-Tu-GTP for subsequent delivery to stalled ribosomes are inefficient when compared to analogous reactions with canonical tRNA(Ala). In other studies, protein SmpB and ribosomal protein S1 appeared to bind directly to tmRNA and to be indispensable for trans-translation. Here, we have searched for additional and synergistic effects of the latter two on tmRNA alanylation and its subsequent binding to EF-Tu-GTP. Kinetic analysis of functioning combined with band-shift experiments and structural probing demonstrate, that tmRNA may indeed form a multimeric complex with SmpB, S1 and EF-Tu-GTP, which leads to a considerably enhanced efficiency of the initial steps of trans-translation. Whereas S1 binds to the mRNA region of tmRNA, we have found that SmpB and EF-Tu both interact with its acceptor arm region. Interaction with SmpB and EF-Tu was also observed at the acceptor arm of Ala-tRNA(Ala), but there the alanylation efficiency was inhibited rather than stimulated by SmpB. Therefore, SmpB may function as an essential modulator of the tRNA-like acceptor arm of tmRNA during its successive steps in trans-translation.     

Novel factor rescues ribosomes trapped on non-stop mRNAs

Ribosomes are trapped at the 3′ ends of mRNAs that lack a natural stop codon. In bacteria, a reaction called trans-translation recycles ribosomes entrapped at such ‘non-stop’ mRNAs. The main player in trans-translation is tmRNA (SsrA-RNA), a bi-functional RNA that acts as both a tRNA and an mRNA. In the trans-translation reaction, alanine-charged tmRNA loads at the ribosomal A-site and translation shifts to the resume codon in tmRNA. Translation of tmRNA stops at a natural stop codon at the end of the small reading frame of tmRNA. In this way, the reaction simultaneously adds a peptide tag to the end of the nascent, incomplete polypeptide and recycles the stalled ribosomes. The peptide tag is recognized by cellular proteases that rapidly degrade the incomplete, potentially harmful polypeptides. The trans-translation reaction is not essential in most bacteria, raising the possibility that ribosomes stalled at non-stop mRNAs can be rescued by alternative routes. In this issue of Molecular Microbiology, Chadani et al. show that a novel translation factor, ArfA, can recycle a ribosome trapped at the 3′ end of a non-stop mRNA in the absence of trans-translation. AfrA is essential in the absence of tmRNA, showing that the two systems work in parallel to resolve stalled ribosomes.     

The role of SmpB protein in trans-translation

The function of SmpB protein in the trans-translation system was evaluated using the well-defined cell-free translation system consisting of purified ribosome, alanyl-tRNA synthetase and elongation factors. The analysis showed that SmpB protein enhances alanine-accepting activity of tmRNA and that SmpB protein and tmRNA are sufficient to complete the trans-translation process in the presence of translational components. Moreover, SmpB is indispensable in the addition of tag-peptide onto ribosomes by tmRNA. In particular, the A-site binding of tmRNA is inhibited in the absence of SmpB.     

A minimum structure of aminoglycosides that causes an initiation shift of trans-translation

Trans-translation is an unusual translation in which transfer-messenger RNA plays a dual function--as a tRNA and an mRNA--to relieve the stalled translation on the ribosome. It has been shown that paromomycin, a typical member of a 4,5-disubstituted class of aminoglycosides, causes a shift of the translation-resuming point on the tmRNA by -1 during trans-translation. To address the molecular basis of this novel effect, we examined the effects of various aminoglycosides that can bind around the A site of the small subunit of the ribosome on trans-translation in vitro. Tobramycin and gentamicin, belonging to the 4,6-disubstituted class of aminoglycosides having rings I and II similar to those in the 4,5-disubstituted class, possess similar effects. Neamine, which has only rings I and II, a common structure shared by 4,5- and 4,6-disubstituted classes of aminoglycosides, was sufficient to cause an initiation shift of trans-translation. In contrast, streptomycin or hygromycin B, lacking ring I, did not cause an initiation shift. The effect of each aminoglycoside on trans-translation coincides with that on conformational change in the A site of the small subunit of the ribosome revealed by recent structural studies: paromomycin, tobramycin and geneticin which is categorized into the gentamicin subclass, but not streptomycin and hygromycin B, flip out two conserved adenine bases at 1492 and 1493 from the A site helix. The pattern of initiation shifts by paromomycin fluctuates with variation of mutations introduced into a region upstream of the initiation point.     

Minimal translation of the tmRNA tag-coding region is required for ribosome release

The trans-translation system in bacteria promotes recycling of stalled ribosomes and targets incomplete peptides for proteolysis. In Escherichia coli, loss of trans-translation function has little effect on growth under normal laboratory conditions. Among the subtle phenotypes of tmRNA-deficient mutants is the inability to plate certain lambda imm(P22) phages. This phenotype is dependent on the ribosome recycling functions of the trans-translation system but is independent of its proteolysis-targeting activity. The experiments described here show that translation of the first (resume) codon of the tmRNA open reading frame by a tRNA is both necessary and sufficient for ribosome recycling. While a variety of sense codons can replace the naturally-occurring GCA alanine codon as the resume codon, both AAA and AAG lysine codons are non-functional resume codons. These results suggest that the main function of tmRNA in releasing stalled ribosomes is to supply a stop codon and so facilitate termination and subsequent ribosome recycling.