Escherichia coli tRNAs are resistant to the hyperprocessing reaction of homologous E. coli ribonuclease P ribozyme

Bacterial ribonuclease P RNA ribozyme can do the hyperprocessing reaction, the internal cleavage reaction of some floppy eukaryotic tRNAs. The hyperprocessing reaction can be used as a detection tool to examine the stability of the cloverleaf shape of tRNA. Until now, the hyperprocessing reaction has been observed in the heterologous combination of eukaryotic tRNAs and bacterial RNase P enzymes. In this paper, we examined the hyperprocessing reaction of Escherichia coli tRNAs by homologous E. coli RNase P, to find that these homologous tRNAs were resistant to the toxic hyperprocessing reaction. Our results display the evidence for molecular co-evolution between homologous tRNAs and RNase P in the bacterium E. coli.     

Escherichia coli tRNAs Are Resistant to the Hyperprocessing Reaction of Homologous E. coli Ribonuclease P Ribozyme

Bacterial ribonuclease P RNA ribozyme can do the hyperprocessing reaction, the internal cleavage reaction of some floppy eukaryotic tRNAs. The hyperprocessing reaction can be used as a detection tool to examine the stability of the cloverleaf shape of tRNA. Until now, the hyperprocessing reaction has been observed in the heterologous combination of eukaryotic tRNAs and bacterial RNase P enzymes. In this paper, we examined the hyperprocessing reaction of Escherichia coli tRNAs by homologous E. coli RNase P, to find that these homologous tRNAs were resistant to the toxic hyperprocessing reaction. Our results display the evidence for molecular co-evolution between homologous tRNAs and RNase P in the bacterium E. coli.     

Another cut for lysine tRNA: application of the hyperprocessing reaction reveals another stabilization strategy in metazoan lysine tRNAs

Recently, we revealed that the cloverleaf structure of some eukaryotic tRNAs is not always stable in vitro, and the denatured structures of these tRNAs are sometimes detected in bacterial RNase P reactions. We have designated the unusual internal cleavage reaction of these tRNAs as hyperprocessing. We have developed this hyperprocessing strategy as a useful tool for examining the stability of the tRNA cloverleaf structure. There are some common features in such unstable, hyperprocessible tRNAs, and the criteria for the hyperprocessing reaction of tRNA are extracted. Metazoan initiator methionine tRNAs and lysine tRNAs commonly fit the criteria, and are predicted to be hyperprocessible. The RNase P reactions of two metazoan lysine tRNAs from Homo sapiens and Caenorhabditis elegans, which fit the criteria, resulted in resistance to the internal cleavage reaction, while one bacterial lysine tRNA from Acholeplasma laidlawii, which also fits the criteria, was internally cleaved by the RNase P. The results showed that the metazoan lysine tRNAs examined are very stable without base modifications even under in vitro conditions. We also examined the 3'-half short construct of the human lysine tRNA, and the results showed that this RNA was internally cleaved by the enzyme. The results indicated that the human lysine tRNA has the ability to be hyperprocessed but is structurally stabilized in spite of lacking base modifications. A comparative study suggested, moreover, that the acceptor-stem bases should take part in the stabilization of metazoan lysine tRNAs. Our data strongly suggest that the cloverleaf shape of other metazoan lysine tRNAs should also be stabilized by means of similar strategies to in the case of human tRNA(Lys3).     

Kinetics of hyperprocessing reaction of human tyrosine tRNA by ribonuclease P ribozyme from Escherichia coli

Human tyrosine tRNA and fly alanine, histidine, and initiator methionine tRNAs are generally cleavable internally by bacterial ribonuclease P ribozyme. The unusual internal cleavage reaction of tRNA, called hyperprocessing, occurs when the cloverleaf structure of the tRNA molecule is denatured to form a double-hair-pin-like structure. The hyperprocessing reaction of these tRNAs requires magnesium ions. We analyzed details of this reaction using human tyrosine tRNA and Escherichia coli RNase P ribozyme. The usual processing reaction occurred efficiently with magnesium at 5 mM, but for the hyperprpocessing reaction, higher concentrations were needed. With such high concentrations, hyperprocessing cleaved both mature tRNA and tRNA precursor as substrates. When mature tRNA was the substrate, the apparent K(M) was almost the same as in the usual reaction, but k(cat) was smaller. These results indicated that the occurrence of hyperprocessing depends on the magnesium ion concentration, and suggested that magnesium ions contribute to the recognition of the shape of the substrate by bacterial RNase P enzymes.     

Substrate shape specificity of E coli RNase P ribozyme is dependent on the concentration of magnesium ion

The bacterial RNase P ribozyme can accept a hairpin RNA with CCA-3' tag sequence as well as a cloverleaf pre-tRNA as substrate in vitro, but the details are not known. By switching tRNA structure using an antisense guide DNA technique, we examined the Escherichia coli RNase P ribozyme specificity for substrate RNA of a given shape. Analysis of the RNase P reaction with various concentrations of magnesium ion revealed that the ribozyme cleaved only the cloverleaf RNA at below 10 mM magnesium ion. At 10 mM magnesium ion or more, the ribozyme also cleaved a hairpin RNA with a CCA-3' tag sequence. At above 20 mM magnesium ion, cleavage site wobbling by the enzyme in tRNA-derived hairpin occurred, and the substrate specificity of the enzyme became broader. Additional studies using another hairpin substrate demonstrated the same tendency. Our data strongly suggest that raising the concentration of metal ion induces a conformational change in the RNA enzyme.     

Intron excision from tRNA precursors by plant splicing endonuclease requires unique features of the mature tRNA domain.

It has been proposed that yeast and Xenopus splicing endonucleases initially recognize features in the mature tRNA domain common to all tRNA species and that the sequence and structure of the intron are only minor determinants of splice-site selection. In accordance with this postulation, we show that yeast endonuclease splices heterologous pre-tRNA(Tyr) species from vertebrates and plants which differ in their mature domains and intron secondary structures. In contrast, wheat germ splicing endonuclease displays a pronounced preference for homologous pre-tRNA species; an extensive study of heterologous substrates revealed that neither yeast pre-tRNA species specific for leucine, serine, phenylalanine and tyrosine nor human and Xenopus pre-tRNA(Tyr) species were spliced. In order to identify the elements essential for pre-tRNA splicing in plants, we constructed chimeric genes coding for tRNA precursors with a plant intron secondary structure and with mature tRNA(Tyr) domains from yeast and Xenopus, respectively. The chimeric pre-tRNA comprising the mature tRNA(Tyr) domain from Xenopus was spliced efficiently in wheat germ extract, whereas the chimeric construct containing the mature tRNA(Tyr) domain from yeast was not spliced at all. These data indicate that intron secondary structure contributes to the specificity of plant splicing endonuclease and that unique features of the mature tRNA domain play a dominant role in enzyme-substrate recognition. We further investigated the influence of specific nucleotides in the mature domain on splicing by generating a number of mutated pre-tRNA species. Our results suggest that nucleotides located in the D stem, i.e. in the center of the pre-tRNA molecule, are recognition points for plant splicing endonuclease.     

Human tyrosine tRNA is also internally cleavable by E. coli ribonuclease P RNA ribozyme in vitro

Transfer RNA is an essential molecule for biological system, and each tRNA molecule commonly has a cloverleaf structure. Previously, we experimentally showed that some Drosophila tRNA (tRNA(Ala), tRNA(His), and tRNA(iMet)) molecules fit to form another, non-cloverleaf, structure in which the 3'-half of the tRNA molecules forms an alternative hairpin, and that the tRNA molecules are internally cleaved by the catalytic RNA of bacterial ribonuclease P (RNase P). Until now, the hyperprocessing reaction of tRNA has only been reported with Drosophila tRNAs. This time, we applied the hyperprocessing reaction to one of human tRNAs, human tyrosine tRNA, and we showed that this tRNA was also hyperprocessed by E. coli RNase P RNA. This tRNA is the first example for hyperprocessed non-Drosophila tRNAs. The results suggest that the hyperprocessing reaction can be a useful tool detect destablized tRNA molecules from any species.     

Intron-dependent formation of pseudouridines in the anticodon of Saccharomyces cerevisiae minor tRNA(Ile).

We have isolated and sequenced the minor species of tRNA(Ile) from Saccharomyces cerevisiae. This tRNA contains two unusual pseudouridines (psi s) in the first and third positions of the anticodon. As shown earlier by others, this tRNA derives from two genes having an identical 60 nt intron. We used in vitro procedures to study the structural requirements for the conversion of the anticodon uridines to psi 34 and psi 36. We show here that psi 34/psi 36 modifications require the presence of the pre-tRNA(Ile) intron but are not dependent upon the particular base at any single position of the anticodon. The conversion of U34 to psi 34 occurs independently from psi 36 synthesis and vice versa. However, psi 34 is not formed when the middle and the third anticodon bases of pre-tRNA(Ile) are both substituted to yield ochre anticodon UUA. This ochre pre-tRNA(Ile) mutant has the central anticodon uridine modified to psi 35 as is the case for S.cerevisiae SUP6 tyrosine-inserting ochre suppressor tRNA. In contrast, neither the first nor the third anticodon pseudouridine is formed, when the ochre (UUA) anticodon in the pre-tRNA(Tyr) is substituted with the isoleucine UAU anticodon. A synthetic mini-substrate consisting of the anticodon stem and loop and the wild-type intron of pre-tRNA(Ile) is sufficient to fully modify the anticodon U34 and U36 into psi s. This is the first example of the tRNA intron sequence, rather than the whole tRNA or pre-tRNA domain, being the main determinant of nucleoside modification.     

Human Tyrosine tRNA Is Also Internally Cleavable by E. coli Ribonuclease P RNA Ribozyme in Vitro

Transfer RNA is an essential molecule for biological system, and each tRNA molecule commonly has a cloverleaf structure. Previously, we experimentally showed that some Drosophila tRNA (tRNA^Ala, tRNA^His, and tRNA_i ^Met) molecules fit to form another, non-cloverleaf, structure in which the 3'-half of the tRNA molecules forms an alternative hairpin, and that the tRNA molecules are internally cleaved by the catalytic RNA of bacterial ribonuclease P (RNase P). Until now, the hyperprocessing reaction of tRNA has only been reported with Drosophila tRNAs. This time, we applied the hyperprocessing reaction to one of human tRNAs, human tyrosine tRNA, and we showed that this tRNA was also hyperprocessed by E. coli RNase P RNA. This tRNA is the first example for hyperprocessed non-Drosophila tRNAs. The results suggest that the hyperprocessing reaction can be a useful tool to detect destablized tRNA molecules from any species.     

Sequential 2'-O-methylation of archaeal pre-tRNATrp nucleotides is guided by the intron-encoded but trans-acting box C/D ribonucleoprotein of pre-tRNA

Haloferax volcanii pre-tRNA(Trp) processing requires box C/D ribonucleoprotein (RNP)-guided 2'-O-methylation of nucleotides C34 and U39 followed by intron excision. Positioning of the box C/D guide RNA within the intron of this pre-tRNA led to the assumption that nucleotide methylation is guided by the cis-positioned box C/D RNPs. We have now investigated the mechanism of 2'-O-methylation for the H. volcanii pre-tRNA(Trp) in vitro by assembling methylation-competent box C/D RNPs on both the pre-tRNA and the excised intron (both linear and circular forms) using Methanocaldococcus jannaschii box C/D RNP core proteins. With both kinetic studies and single nucleotide substitutions of target and guide nucleotides, we now demonstrate that pre-tRNA methylation is guided in trans by the intron-encoded box C/D RNPs positioned in either another pre-tRNA(Trp) or in the excised intron. Methylation by in vitro assembled RNPs prefers but does not absolutely require Watson-Crick pairing between the guide and target nucleotides. We also demonstrate for the first time that methylation of two nucleotides guided by a single box C/D RNA is sequential, that is, box C'/D' RNP-guided U39 methylation first requires box C/D RNP-guided methylation of C34. Methylation of the two nucleotides of exogenous pre-tRNA(Trp) added to an H. volcanii cell extract also occurs sequentially and is also accomplished in trans using RNPs that pre-exist in the extract. Thus, this trans mechanism is analogous to eukaryal pre-rRNA 2'-O-methylation guided by intron-encoded but trans-acting box C/D small nucleolar RNPs. This trans mechanism could explain the observed accumulation of the excised H. volcanii pre-tRNA(Trp) intron in vivo. A trans mechanism would also eliminate the obligatory refolding of the pre-tRNA that would be required to carry out two cis-methylation reactions before pre-tRNA splicing.     

Substrate recognition and splice site determination in yeast tRNA splicing

S. cerevisae tRNA introns interrupt the gene at a constant position in the anticodon loop. Pre-tRNAs are matured by an endonuclease and a ligase. The endonuclease alone can accurately release the intron from the pre-tRNA. Here, we investigate the mechanism of splice site selection by the endonuclease. We propose that it initially recognizes features in the mature domain common to all tRNAs. Once positioned on the enzyme, the splice sites are recognizable because they are a fixed distance from the mature domain. To test this hypothesis, we developed a system for synthesizing pre-tRNA by bacteriophage T7 RNA polymerase. To search for recognition sites, we made several mutations. Mutations of C56 and U8 strongly affect endonuclease recognition of pre-tRNA. With insertion and deletion mutations, we show that the anticodon stem determines splicing specificity. The sequence and structure of the intron are not strong determinants of splice site selection.     

Splicing of mRNA mediated by tRNA sequences in mouse cells

tRNA splicing is essential for the formation of tRNAs and therefore for gene expression. A circularly permuted sequence of an amber-suppressor pre-tRNA gene was inserted into the sequence encoding the mouse NEMO protein. We demonstrated that, in mouse cells, the hybrid pre-tRNA/pre-mRNAs can be spliced precisely at the sites of the pre-tRNA intron. This splicing reaction produces functional tRNAs that suppress amber codons as well as translatable mRNAs that sustain the NF-κB activation pathway. The RNA molecules extracted from mouse cells were amplified by RT-PCR, and their sequences were determined, confirming the identity of the splice junctions. We then applied the Archaea-express technology, in which an archaeal RNA endonuclease is expressed in mouse cells. We show that both the endogenous eukaryal endonuclease and the archaeal one cleave the hybrid pre-tRNA/pre-mRNAs in the same manner with an additive effect.     

Splicing of a yeast proline tRNA containing a novel suppressor mutation in the anticodon stem

The intron-containing proline tRNAUGG genes in Saccharomyces cerevisiae can mutate to suppress +1 frameshift mutations in proline codons via a G to U base substitution mutation at position 39. The mutation alters the 3' splice junction and disrupts the bottom base-pair of the anticodon stem which presumably allows the tRNA to read a four-base codon. In order to understand the mechanism of suppression and to study the splicing of suppressor pre-tRNA, we determined the sequences of the mature wild-type and mutant suppressor gene products in vivo and analyzed splicing of the corresponding pre-tRNAs in vitro. We show that a novel tRNA isolated from suppressor strains is the product of frameshift suppressor genes. Sequence analysis indicated that suppressor pre-tRNA is spliced at the same sites as wild-type pre-tRNA. The tRNA therefore contains a four-base anticodon stem and nine-base anticodon loop. Analysis of suppressor pre-tRNA in vitro revealed that endonuclease cleavage at the 3' splice junction occurred with reduced efficiency compared to wild-type. In addition, reduced accumulation of mature suppressor tRNA was observed in a combined cleavage and ligation reaction. These results suggest that cleavage at the 3' splice junction is inefficient but not abolished. The novel tRNA from suppressor strains was shown to be the functional agent of suppression by deleting the intron from a suppressor gene. The tRNA produced in vivo from this gene is identical to that of the product of an intron+ gene, indicating that the intron is not required for proper base modification. The product of the intron- gene is a more efficient suppressor than the product of an intron+ gene. One interpretation of this result is that inefficient splicing in vivo may be limiting the steady-state level of mature suppressor tRNA.     

Architecture and folding mechanism of the Azoarcus Group I Pre-tRNA

Self-splicing RNAs must evolve to function in their specific exon context. The conformation of a group I pre-tRNA(ile) from the bacterium Azoarcus was probed by ribonuclease T(1) and hydroxyl radical cleavage, and by native gel electrophoresis. Biochemical data and three-dimensional models of the pre-tRNA showed that the tRNA is folded, and that the tRNA and intron sequences form separate tertiary domains. Models of the active site before steps 1 and 2 of the splicing reaction predict that exchange of the external G-cofactor and the 3'-terminal G is accomplished by a slight conformational change in P9.0 of the Azoarcus group I intron. Kinetic assays showed that the pre-tRNA folds in minutes, much more slowly than the intron alone. The dependence of the folding kinetics on Mg(2+) and the concentration of urea, and RNase T(1) experiments showed that formation of native pre-tRNA is delayed by misfolding of P3-P9, including mispairing between residues in P9 and the tRNA. Thus, although the intron and tRNA sequences form separate domains in the native pre-tRNA, their folding is coupled via metastable non-native base-pairs. This could help prevent premature processing of the 5' and 3' ends of unspliced pre-tRNA.     

Activity and thermostability of the small self-splicing group I intron in the pre-tRNA(lle) of the purple bacterium Azoarcus.

The 205-nt group I intron located in the pre-tRNA(lle) from the bacterium Azoarcus sp.BH72 is the smallest self-splicing group I intron identified to date. Comparative sequence analysis has placed this intron and the Anabaena pre-tRNA(Leu) intron into the same subgroup, IC3; we now compare their activity and stability. Unlike the Anabaena intron, the Azoarcus intron has two transitions in the kinetics of the first step of splicing. The faster transition occurs with a larger k(cat)/K(m) than that of the Anabaena or other group I introns, due to a rapid K(cat) (5 min(-1) at 32 degrees C) and a low K(m) for guanosine (17 microM). The excised intron circularizes by releasing a trinucleotide from the 5' end of the intron, another property unlike the Anabaena intron. Although it is smaller in size, the Azoarcus intron retains activity at higher temperatures, higher concentrations of urea, and higher pH than the Anabaena intron. Melting curves show that tertiary structure is disrupted at a lower temperature in the Anabaena intron. Some structural features that may explain the unusual stability of the Azoarcus intron include a G-C rich secondary structure and the presence of two 11-nt motifs, which are known to interact strongly with GAAA loops in group I and group II introns. The disruption of one of these interactions by substituting the Anabaena structural element in fact lowered the thermal stability of the Azoarcus intron. Thus, even superficially similar group I introns from the same structural subgroup can differ significantly in activity and stability.     

Non-enzymatic excision of pre-tRNA introns?

We used human tRNA(Tyr) precursor as a substrate to study self-excision of a pre-tRNA intron. This RNA was synthesized in vitro in a HeLa cell extract. It contains a 5' leader, an intron of 20 nucleotides and a 3' trailer. Self-cleavage of pre-tRNA(Tyr) occurs in 100 mM NH4OAc at a pH ranging from 6 to 8.5 in the presence of spermine, MgCl2 and Triton X-100 under conditions very similar to enzymatic intron excision. The reaction is temperature-dependent, relatively fast as compared to the enzyme-catalysed reaction and leads to fragments which resist further degradation. The detailed structure of all major and minor cleavage products was established by fingerprint analyses. Non-enzymatic cleavage occurs predominantly at the 3' splice site and to a minor extent at the 5' splice site. Other minor cleavage sites are located within the intron and in the 3' trailer. Putative 5' and 3' tRNA halves resulting from pre-tRNA(Tyr) self-cleavage are substrates for wheat germ RNA ligase, suggesting that the cleavage reaction yields 2',3'-cyclic phosphate and 5'-hydroxyl termini. Pre-tRNA splicing endonuclease is believed to cleave both the 5' and the 3' splice site. However, on the basis of our results we propose that this enzyme may support the formation of a pre-tRNA tertiary structure favourable for autocatalytic intron excision and impair unspecific self-cleavage.     

Wheat germ splicing endonuclease is highly specific for plant pre-tRNAs.

Intron-containing pre-tRNAs from organisms as different as yeast, Nicotiana, Xenopus and man are efficiently spliced and processed in a HeLa cell extract. They are also correctly processed in a wheat germ extract; however, the intron is removed only from the tobacco pre-tRNA. To determine whether plant pre-tRNA introns have any specific structural and/or sequence feature we have cloned two intron-containing tRNATyr genes from the plant Arabidopsis. Comparison of these genes, of the Nicotiana tRNATyr gene and of a Glycine max tRNAMet gene reveals that plant introns from three different species have no sequence homology and are only 11 to 13 nucleotides long. Thus, short length may be one important feature of plant introns. Furthermore, the 5' and 3' splice sites are separated by 4 bp in the extended anticodon stems of these pre-tRNA structures. In contrast, yeast and vertebrate introns are rather variable in length and the splice sites are separated by 5 or 6 bp. These differences in distance and relative helical orientation of the splice sites in plant pre-tRNAs versus pre-tRNAs from other organisms are obviously tolerated by the vertebrate splicing endonuclease, but not at all by the plant enzyme.