Nitrogen fixation associated with grasses and cereals: Recent results and perspectives for future research

Over the last few years research in the area of biological nitrogen fixation (BNF) associated with cereals and grasses has become divided into two areas. On the one hand there have been a large number of reports of responses of field-grown plants to inoculation with N₂-fixing bacteria, principallyAzospirillum spp. On the other hand there have been several reports of significant contributions of associated BNF to the nutrition of several crops, including wetland rice, sugar cane and some forage grasses. However, where BNF contributions have definitely been established no certain information is available as to the diazotrophic organisms responsible. Furthermore, certain recent reports indicate that, at least in some cases, responses of plants to inoculation withAzospirillum spp. have been shown not to be due to BNF contributions. In this paper we review some recent progress in this field, particularly at our institute in Rio de Janeiro, concerning specificity of selected Azospirillum strains in the infection of cereal roots and the promotion of responses in the host plants. The possible mechanisms of plant response are discussed including the possibility that plant growth substances or bacterial nitrate reductase are involved. The application of¹⁵N and N balance techniques to the quantification of plant associated BNF are considered and the possible strategies that may be adopted to further the understanding of true N₂-fixing plant/diazotroph associations. The recent discovery of many more plant-associated N₂-fixing bacteria suggests that further research in this area may eventually lead to the development of such associations with applications for agricultural productivity.     

Biological nitrogen fixation associated with sugar cane and rice: Contributions and prospects for improvement

¹⁵N isotope and N balance studies performed over the last few years have shown that several Brazilian varieties of sugarcane are capable of obtaining over 60% of their nitrogen (<150 kg N ha^-1 year^-1) from biological nitrogen fixation (BNF). This may be due to the fact that this crop in Brazil has been systematically bred for high yields with low fertilizer N inputs. In the case of wetland rice, N balance experiments performed both in the field and in pots suggest that 30 to 60 N ha^-1 crop^-1 may be obtained from plant-associated BNF and that different varieties have different capacities to obtain N from this source. ¹⁵N₂ incorporation studies have proved that wetland rice can obtain at least some N from BNF and acetylene reduction (AR) assays also indicate differences in N₂-fixing ability between different rice varieties. However in situ AR field estimates suggest plant-associated BNF inputs to be less than 8 kg N ha^-1 crop^-1. The problems associated with the use of the ¹⁵N dilution technique for BNF quantification are discussed and illustrated with data from a recent study performed at EMBRAPA-CNPAB. Although many species of diazotrophs have been isolated from the rhizosphere of both sugarcane and wetland rice, the recent discovery of endophytic N₂-fixing bacteria within roots, shoots and leaves of both crops suggests, at least in the case of sugarcane, that these bacteria may be the most important contributors to the observed BNF contributions. In sugarcane both Acetobacter diazotrophicus and Herbaspirillum spp. have been found within roots and aerial tissues and these microorganisms, unlike Azospirillum spp. and other rhizospheric diazotrophs, have been shown to survive poorly in soil. Herbaspirillum spp. are found in many graminaceous crops, including rice (in roots and aerial tissue), and are able to survive and pass from crop to crop in the seeds. The physiology, ecology and infection of plants by these endophytes are fully discussed in this paper. The sugarcane/endophytic diazotroph association is the first efficient N₂-fixing system to be discovered associated with any member of the gramineae. As yet the individual roles of the different diazotrophs in this system have not been elucidated and far more work on the physiology and anatomy of this system is required. However, the understanding gained in these studies should serve as a foundation for the improvement/development of similar N₂-fixing systems in wetland rice and other cereal crops.     

Endophytic nitrogen fixation in sugarcane: present knowledge and future applications

In Brazil the long-term continuous cultivation of sugarcane with low N fertiliser inputs, without apparent depletion of soil-N reserves, led to the suggestion that N₂-fixing bacteria associated with the plants may be the source of agronomically significant N inputs to this crop. From the 1950s to 1970s, considerable numbers of N₂-fixing bacteria were found to be associated with the crop, but it was not until the late 1980s that evidence from N balance and ¹⁵N dilution experiments showed that some Brazilian varieties of sugarcane were able to obtain significant contributions from this source. The results of these studies renewed the efforts to search for N₂-fixing bacteria, but this time the emphasis was on those diazotrophs that infected the interior of the plants. Within a few years several species of such `endophytic diazotrophs' were discovered including Gluconacetobacter diazotrophicus, Herbaspirillum seropedicae, H. rubrisubalbicansand Burkholderia sp. Work has continued on these endophytes within sugarcane plants, but to date little success has been attained in elucidating which endophyte is responsible for the observed BNF and in what site, or sites, within the cane plants the N₂ fixation mainly occurs. Until such important questions are answered further developments or extension of this novel N₂-fixing system to other economically important non-legumes (e.g. cereals) will be seriously hindered. As far as application of present knowledge to maximise BNF with sugarcane is concerned, molybdenum is an essential micronutrient. An abundant water supply favours high BNF inputs, and the best medium term strategy to increase BNF would appear to be based on cultivar selection on irrigated N deficient soils fertilised with Mo.     

An assessment of soil enrichment by actinorhizal N2 fixation using δ15N values in a chronosequence of deglaciation at Glacier Bay,Alaska

The extent of transfer of fixed N between N₂-fixing and non-N₂-fixing plant species is largely unknown in successional studies. In order to redress this deficiency at a locale intensively studied ecologically, leaf tissue samples were collected from actinorhizal N₂-fixing (Alnus, Shepherdia, and Dryas) and two non-N₂-fixing (Salix) woody species within research plots located along a chronosequence of deglaciated fjord in Glacier Bay National Park, Alaska. The tissue samples were analyzed for ¹⁵N content, and the resulting data analyzed for trends in plant tissue N. Among the non-N₂-fixing Salix species, ¹⁵N values increased from the most recently deglaciated sites to converge with the temporally more-stable values for the symbiotic N₂-fixing species on sites at about 40 years after deglaciation. The lower ¹⁵N values of sequestered N in plant tissues suggested that N derived from N₂-fixing plants accounts for the major portion of N in associated plants up to 40 years after deglaciation. The ¹⁵N isotopic data also suggested that Shepherdia canadensis depends least on soil N, D. drummondii the most, and A. viridis ssp. sinuata somewhere between those two species. The presence of a sere dominated by dense thickets of A. viridis ssp. sinuata at the convergence of ¹⁵N values for the N₂-fixing and non-N₂-fixing species indicated that this species is most responsible for accumulation of fixed N in soil at Glacier Bay. This paper is dedicated to the memory of Steven J. Kohls who died prior to publication of this research.     

Molecular basis of the establishment and functioning of a N2-fixing root nodule

Compatible interactions between rhizobia and their leguminous host plant(s) culminate in the formation of a new plant organ, the root nodule. Within this structure, the bacteria reduce N₂ to NH₃ which is then assimilated by the plant. The formation of a N₂-fixing nodule requires a continuous process of two-way signalling and cellular recognition between the prokaryote and the plant. Such a process involves the sequential activation and/or repression of host plant- and bacteria-encoded genes. Finally, functioning of a legume-nodule necessitates not only the adaptation of plant and bacterial carbon, nitrogen and oxygen metabolism to an environment allowing N₂-fixation to occur, but also requires a tight co-ordination and integration of these plant and bacterial metabolic processes.     

Inoculation of forage grasses with N2-fixing Enterobacteriaceae

Summary Previous investigations indicated some forage grass roots in Texas are heavily colonized with N₂-fixing bacteria. The most numerous N₂-fixing bacteria were in the genera Klebsiella and Enterobacter. In the present investigation inoculation experiments were conducted using 18 isolates of these bacteria to determine if a N₂-fixing association could be established between the bacteria and the grassesCynodon dactylon andPanicum coloratum. Plants were grown in soil for approximately 5 months in a greenhouse and were measured periodically for dry matter, nitrogen accumulation, and acetylene reduction activity. Results of the investigation indicated that 25% of the plant-soil systems were active in acetylene reduction and the activity was high enough to indicate agronomically significant quantities of N₂ were being fixed (>8kg N ha⁻¹). However, plant systems extrapolated to fix>8 kg N ha⁻¹ contained less nitrogen and accumulated less dry matter than plants less active in acetylene reduction. Inocula could not be re-isolated from healthy grass roots indicating that the N₂-fixing activity may have not have been closely assiciated with plant roots. Future research is needed to determine factors limiting colonization of grass roots.     

Application of 15N natural abundance technique for evaluating biological nitrogen fixation in oil palm ecotypes at nursery stage in pot experiments and at mature plantation sites

A range of different species of diazotrophic bacteria has been found in tissues and the rhizosphere of oil palm plants, suggesting a potential to benefit from biological nitrogen fixation (BNF). A few studies have confirmed that plantlets at nursery stage can benefit significantly from BNF after inoculation with Azospirillum spp. but no data are available regarding the benefit from naturally-occurring diazotrophic bacteria in oil palm. The results described here were derived from two pot trials laid out under controlled conditions with plantlets from two important regions for palm oil production in Brazil, as well as from different field sites of mature oil palm plantations. The ¹⁵N natural abundance technique was employed to estimate plant dependence on BNF (%Ndfa) by the different ecotypes grown in soil and previously characterized as hosting diazotrophic bacteria. From both pot trials it was possible to identify some ecotypes of high potential for N₂-fixation that reached in some cases approximately 50%Ndfa. However, the accuracy of measurement still needs to be improved using more suitable reference plants for pot experiments. Values of δ ¹⁵N signals from oil palm and reference plants in the field were inconclusive concerning any benefit from BNF to oil palm, owing to apparently high temporal and spatial variability of δ ¹⁵N of the plant-available N in the heterogeneous soil matrix for the different palm and reference plant tested.     

Biological Nitrogen Fixation in Sugar Cane: A Key to Energetically Viable Biofuel Production

The advantages of producing biofuels to replace fossil energy sources are derived from the fact that the energy accumulated in the biomass is captured directly from photosynthesis and is thus renewable, and that the cycle of carbon dioxide fixation by the crop, followed by burning of the fuel makes no overall contribution to atmospheric CO₂ or, consequently, to global warming. However, these advantages are negated if large quantities of fossil fuels need to be used to grow or process the biofuel crop. In this regard, the Brazilian bioethanol program, based on the fermentation/distillation of sugar cane juice, is particularly favorable, not only because the crop is principally hand harvested, but also because of the low nitrogen fertilizer use on sugar cane in Brazil. Recent ¹⁵N and N balance studies have shown that in some Brazilian cane varieties, high yields are possible without N fertilization because the plants are able to obtain large contributions of nitrogen from plant-associated biological N₂ fixation (BNF). The N₂-fixing acid-tolerant bacterium Acetobacter diazotrophicus was first found to occur within roots, stems, and leaves of sugar cane. Subsequently, two species of Herbaspirillum also have been found to occur within the interior of all sugar cane tissues. The discovery of these, and other N₂-fixing bacteria that survive poorly in soil but thrive within plant tissue (endophytic bacteria), may account for the high BNF contributions observed in sugar cane. Further study of this system should allow the gradual elimination of N fertilizer use on sugar cane, at least in Brazil, and opens up the possibility of the extension of this efficient N₂-fixing system to cereal and other crops with consequent immense potential benefits to tropical agriculture.     

Nitrogen fixation in rice systems: state of knowledge and future prospects

Rice is the most important cereal crop. In the next three decades, the world will need to produce about 60% more rice than today's global production to feed the extra billion people. Nitrogen is the major nutrient limiting rice production. Development of fertilizer-responsive varieties in the Green Revolution, coupled with the realization by farmers of the importance of nitrogen, has led to high rates of N fertilizer use on rice. Increased future demand for rice will entail increased application of fertilizer N. Awareness is growing, however, that such an increase in agricultural production needs to be achieved without endangering the environment. To achieve food security through sustainable agriculture, the requirement for fixed nitrogen must increasingly met by biological nitrogen fixation (BNF) rather than by using nitrogen fixed industrially. It is thus imperative to improve existing BNF systems and develop N₂-fixing non-leguminous crops such as rice. Here we review the potentials and constraints of conventional BNF systems in rice agriculture, as well as the prospects of achieving in planta nitrogen fixation in rice.     

Sugar beet and barley yields in relation to inoculation with N2-fixing and phosphate solubilizing bacteria

Recently, there has been a resurgence of interest in bioorganic fertilizers as part of sustainable agricultural practices to alleviate drawbacks of intensive farming practices. N₂-fixing and P-solubilizing bacteria are important in plant nutrition increasing N and P uptake by the plants, and playing a significant role as plant growth-promoting rhizobacteria in the biofertilization of crops. A study was conducted in order to investigate the effects of two N₂-fixing (OSU-140 and OSU-142) and a strain of P-solubilizing bacteria (M-13) in single, dual and three strains combinations on sugar beet and barley yields under field conditions in 2001 and 2002. The treatments included: (1) Control (no inoculation and fertilizer), (2) Bacillus OSU-140, (3) Bacillus OSU-142, (4) Bacillus M-13, (5) OSU-140 + OSU-142, (6) OSU-140 + M-13, (7) OSU-142 + M-13, (8) OSU-140 + OSU-142 + M-13, (9) N, (10) NP. N and NP plots were fertilized with 120 kg N ha^–1 and 120 kg N ha^–1 + 90 kg P ha^- for sugar beet and 80 kg N ha^–1 and 80 kg N ha^–1 + 60 kg P ha^–1 for barley. The experiments were conducted in a randomized block design with five replicates. All inoculations and fertilizer applications significantly increased leaf, root and sugar yield of sugar beet and grain and biomass yields of barley over the control. Single inoculations with N₂-fixing bacteria increased sugar beet root and barley yields by 5.6–11.0% depending on the species while P-solubilizing bacteria alone gave yield increases by 5.5–7.5% compared to control. Dual inoculation and mixture of three bacteria gave increases by 7.7–12.7% over control as compared with 20.7–25.9% yield increases by NP application. Mixture of all three strains, dual inoculation of N₂-fixing OSU-142 and P-solubilizing M-13, and/or dual inoculation N₂-fixing bacteria significantly increased root and sugar yields of sugar beet, compared with single inoculations with OSU-140 or M-13. Dual inoculation of N₂-fixing Bacillus OSU-140 and OSU-142, and/or mixed inoculations with three bacteria significantly increased grain yield of barley compared with single inoculations of OSU-142 and M-13. In contrast with other combinations, dual inoculation of N₂-fixing OSU-140 and P-solubilizing M-13 did not always significantly increase leaf, root and sugar yield of sugar beet, grain and biomass yield of barley compared to single applications both with N₂-fixing bacteria. The beneficial effects of the bacteria on plant growth varied significantly depending on environmental conditions, bacterial strains, and plant and soil conditions.     

Alder and lupine enhance nitrogen cycling in a degraded forest soil in Northern Sweden

Positive effects of legumes and actinorhizal plants on N-poor soils have been observed in many studies but few have been done at high latitudes, which was the location of our study. We measured N₂ fixation and several indices of soil N at a site near the Arctic Circle in northern Sweden. More than 20 years ago lupine (Lupinus nootkatensis Donn) and gray alder (Alnus incana L. Moench) were planted on this degraded forest site. We measured total soil N, net N mineralization and nitrification with a buried bag technique, and fluxes of NH⁺ ₄ and NO^– ₃ as collected on ion exchange membranes. We also estimated N₂ fixation activity of the N₂-fixing plants by the natural abundance of ¹⁵N of leaves with Betula pendula Roth. as reference species. Foliar nitrogen in the N₂-fixing plants was almost totally derived from N₂ fixation. Plots containing N₂-fixing species generally had significantly higher soil N and N availability than a control plot without N₂-fixing plants. Taken together, all measurements indicated that N₂-fixing plants can be used to effectively improve soil fertility at high latitudes in northern Sweden.     

Significance of nitrogen-fixing actinorhizal symbioses for restoration of depleted,degraded, and contaminated soil

Atmospheric nitrogen (N₂)-fixing legume trees are frequently used for the restoration of depleted, degraded, and contaminated soils. However, biological N₂ fixation (BNF) can also be performed by so-called actinorhizal plants. Actinorhizal plants include a high diversity of woody species and therefore can be applied in a broad spectrum of environments. In contrast to N₂-fixing legumes, the potential of actinorhizal plants for soil restoration remains largely unexplored. In this Opinion, we propose related basic research requirements for the characterization of environmental stress responses that determine the restoration potential of actinorhizal plants for depleted, degraded, and contaminated soils. We identify advantages and unexplored processes of actinorhizal plants and describe a mainly uncharted avenue of future research for this important group of plant species.     

Trials to create artificial nitrogen-fixing symbioses and associations using in vitro methods: An outlook

Summary Biological nitrogen fixation is the most important process in which some prokaryotic organisms fix N₂ into ammonium. From an agricultural standpoint, biological nitrogen fixation (BNF) is critical because industrial production of nitrogen fertilizers seldom meets agricultural demands. To increase the BNF is one of the main challenges for the future. There are different possibilities for extending biological nitrogen fixation to the economically important plants. One of the possibilities is to create new artificial systems between diazotrophic bacteria and different higher plants. This is the main topic of the present review article which discusses the establishment of new associative and/or symbiotic systems, via introduction of diazotrophic bacteria into the roots by different methods; and incorporation of nitrogen-fixing bacteria in the entire plant by in vitro methods, through the establishment of intracellular endosymbioses via induced uptake of bacteria by plant protoplasts (endocytobiosis), and establishment of intercellular associations by forced introduction of bacteria into the plant tissues (exocytobiosis). The common characteristic of the methods to create artificial plant-microbe systems for atmospheric nitrogen fixation is the use of in vitro plant systems: cells, tissues and organ cultures. The review pays particular attention to new bacterial inoculation procedures for introduction of the diazotrophic bacteria inside the plant tissues.     

Fixation of Dinitrogen-15 Associated with Rice Plants

Rice plants (IR26 and Latisail) obtained at near heading stage from a wetland field were transferred to water culture and exposed to ¹⁵N₂ in a gas-tight growth chamber for 7 days to measure N₂-fixing activities associated with the rice. The activities measured varied from 6.5 to 11.6 μmol of N₂ fixed per hill per day. The outer leaf sheath had about 2.5 times higher N₂-fixing activities per unit weight than the root. Slight activities were also found in the basal node and inner leaf sheath. Wrapping basal parts of the stem with aluminum foil did not decrease the activities of N₂ fixation in these parts. Thus, the outer leaf sheath as well as the root are N₂-fixing sites in rice plants. N₂ fixation found in above-ground parts is not due to photoautotrophic organisms. Less than 10% of the fixed nitrogen was translocated from the fixing sites to the leaf blades and the young panicles.     

Natural 15N abundance of presumed N2-fixing and non-N2-fixing plants from selected ecosystems

Summary The ¹⁵N/¹⁴N ratios of plant and soil samples from Northern California ecosystems were determined by mass spectrometry. The ¹⁵N abundance of 176 plant foliar samples averaged 0.0008 atom % ¹⁵N excess relative to atmospheric N₂ and ranged from-0.0028 to 0.0064 atom % ¹⁵N excess relative to atmospheric N₂. Foliage from reported N₂-fixing species had significantly lower mean ¹⁵N abundance (relative to atmospheric N₂ and total soil N) and significantly higher N concentration (% N dry wt.) than did presumed non-N₂-fixing plants growing on the same sites. The mean difference between N₂-fixing species and other plants was 0.0007 atom % ¹⁵N. N₂-fixing species had lower ¹⁵N abundance than the other plants on most sites examined despite large differences between sites in vegetation, soil, and climate. The mean ¹⁵N abundance of N₂-fixing plants varied little between sites and was close to that of atmospheric N₂. The ¹⁵N abundance of presumed non-N₂-fixing species was highest at coastal sites and may reflect an input of marine spray N having relatively high ¹⁵N abundance. The ¹⁵N abundance of N₂-fixing species was not related to growth form but was for other plants. Annual herbaceous plants had highest ¹⁵N abundance followed in decreasing order by perennial herbs, shrubs, and trees. Several terrestrial ferns (Pteridaceae) had ¹⁵N abundances comparable to N₂-fixing legumes suggesting N₂-fixation by these ferns. On sites where the ¹⁵N abundance of soil N differs from that of the atmosphere, N₂-fixing plants can be identified by the natural ¹⁵N abundance of their foliage. This approach can be useful in detecting and perhaps measuring N₂-fixation on sites where direct recovery of nodules is not possible.     

Utilization of amino acids by Frankia sp. strain CpI1

The utilization of some amino acids, added at 1 mM and 10 mM concentrations, as the sole combined nitrogen sources by Frankia sp. strain CpI1, has been investigated. Glutamine, like NH ₄ ⁺ , provided rapid growth without N₂ fixation. Histidine at 1 mM yielded poor N₂-fixing activity but better cell growth than N₂. Aspartate, glutamate, alanine, proline, each at 1 mM concentration, supported similar levels of N₂ fixation and growth. Growth on 10 mM glutamate, proline, or histidine resulted in poor N₂-fixing activity and poor cell growth. Cells grown on 10 mM alanine had about half the N₂-fixing activity of cells grown on N₂ but growth was good. Aspartate at 10 mM concentration, however, stimulated N₂-fixing activity dramatically and promoted faster growth. Enzyme analysis suggested that asparate is catabolized by glutamate-oxaloacetate transaminase (GOT), since GOT specific activity was induced, and aspartase activity was not detected, in cells grown on aspartate as the sole combined nitrogen source. Thinlayer chromatography (TLC) of metabolites extracted from N₂-grown cells fed with [¹⁴C]-aspartate showed that label was rapidly accumulated mainly on aspartate and/or glutamate, depending on the cells' physiological state, without detectable labeling on fumarate or oxaloacetate (OAA). These findings provide evidence that aspartate is catabolized by GOT to OAA which, in turn, is rapidly converted to -ketoglutarate through the TCA cycle and then to glutamate by GOT or by glutamate synthase (GOGAT). The stimulation of N₂ fixation and growth by aspartate is probably caused by an increased intracellular glutamate pool.     

Root-based N2-fixing Symbioses: Legumes, Actinorhizal Plants, Parasponia sp. and Cycads

In the mutualistic symbioses between legumes and rhizobia, actinorhizal plants and Frankia, Parasponia sp. and rhizobia, and cycads and cyanobacteria, the N₂-fixing microsymbionts exist in specialized structures (nodules or cyanobacterial zones) within the roots of their host plants. Despite the phylogenetic diversity among both the hosts and the microsymbionts of these symbioses, certain developmental and physiological imperatives must be met for successful mutualisms. In this review, phylogenetic and ecological aspects of the four symbioses are first addressed, and then the symbioses are contrasted and compared in regard to infection and symbio-organ development, supply of carbon to the microsymbionts, regulation of O₂ flux to the microsymbionts, and transfer of fixed-N to the hosts. Although similarities exist in the genetics, development, and functioning of the symbioses, it is evident that there is great diversity in many aspects of these root-based N₂-fixing symbioses. Each symbiosis can be admired for the elegant means by which the host plant and microsymbiont integrate to form the mutualistic relationships so important to the functioning of the biosphere.     

Photosynthate metabolism in the source leaves of n(2)-fixing soybean plants

Soybean plants (Glycine max [L.] Merr. cv Williams), which were symbiotic with Bradyrhizobium japonicum, and which grew well upon reduced nitrogen supplied solely through N₂ fixation processes, often exhibited excess accumulation of starch and sucrose and diminished soluble protein in their source leaves. Nitrate and ammonia, when supplied to the nodulated roots of N₂-fixing plants, mediated a reduction of foliar starch accumulation and a corresponding increase in soluble protein in the source leaves. This provided an opportunity to examine the potential metabolic adjustments by which NO₃⁻ and NH₄⁺ (N) sufficiency or deficiency exerted an influence upon soybean leaf starch synthesis. When compared with soybean plants supplied with N, elevated starch accumulation was focused in leaf palisade parenchyma tissue of N₂-fixing plants. Foliar activities of starch synthesis pathway enzymes including fructose-1,6-bisphosphate phosphatase, phosphohexoisomerase, phosphoglucomutase (PGM), as well as adenosine diphosphate glucose pyrophosphorylase (in some leaves) exhibited highest activities in leaf extracts of N₂-fixing plants when expressed on a leaf protein basis. This was interpreted to mean that there was an adaptation of these enzyme activities in the leaves of N₂-fixing plants, and this contributed to an increase in starch accumulation. Another major causal factor associated with increased starch accumulation was the elevation in foliar levels of fructose-6-phosphate, glucose-6-phosphate, and glucose-1-phosphate (G1P), which had risen to chloroplast concentrations considerably in excess of the K_m values for their respective target enzymes associated with starch synthesis, e.g. elevated G1P with respect to adenosine diphosphate glucose pyrophosphorylase (ADPG-PPiase) binding sites. The cofactor glucose-1,6-bisphosphate (G1,6BP) was found to be obligate for maximal PGM activity in soybean leaf extracts of N₂-fixing as well as N-supplemented plants, and G1,6BP levels in N₂-fixing plant leaves was twice that of levels in N-supplied treatments. However the concentration of chloroplastic G1,6BP in illuminated leaves was computed to be saturating with respect to PGM in both N₂-fixing and N-supplemented plants. This suggested that the higher level of this cofactor in N₂-fixing plant leaves did not confer any higher PGM activation and was not a factor in higher starch synthesis rates. Relative to plants supplied with NO₃⁻ and NH₄⁺, the source leaf glycerate-3-phosphate (3-PGA) and orthophosphate (Pi) concentrations in leaves of N₂-fixing plants were two to four times higher. Although Pi is a physiological competitive inhibitor of leaf chloroplast ADPG-PPiase, and hence, starch synthesis, elevated chloroplast 3-PGA levels in N₂-fixing plant leaves apparently prevented interference of Pi with ADPG-PPiase catalysis and starch synthesis.     

Efficiency of Nitrogen Assimilation by N(2)-Fixing and Nitrate-Grown Soybean Plants (Glycine max [L.] Merr.)

Nodulated and non-nodulated (not inoculated) soybeans (Glycine max [L.] Merr. cv Wells) were grown in controlled environments with N₂ or nonlimiting levels of NO₃⁻, respectively, serving as sole source of nitrogen. The efficiency of the N₂-fixing plants was compared with that of the nitrate-supplied plants on the basis of both plant age and plant size. Efficiency evaluations of the plants were expressed as the ratio of moles of carbon respired by the whole plant to the moles of nitrogen incorporated into plant material.

Continuous 24-hour CO₂ exchange measurements on shoot and root systems made at the beginning of flowering (28 days after planting) indicated that N₂-fixing plants respired 8.28 moles of carbon per mole of N, fixed from dinitrogen, while nitrate-supplied plants respired only 4.99 moles of carbon per mole of nitrate reduced. Twenty-one-day-old nitrate-supplied plants were even more efficient, respiring only 3.18 moles of carbon per mole of nitrate reduced. The decreased efficiency of the N₂-fixing plants was not due to plant size since, on a dry weight basis, the 28-day-old N₂-fixing plants were intermediate between the 28- and 21-day-old nitrate-supplied plants.

The calculated efficiencies were predominantly a reflection of root-system respiration. N₂-fixing plants lost 25% of their daily net photosynthetic input of carbon through root-system respiration, compared with 16% for 28-day-old nitrate-supplied plants and 12% for 21-day-old nitrate-supplied plants. Shoot dark respiration was similar for all three plant groups, varying between 7.9% and 9.0% of the apparent photosynthate.

The increased respiratory loss by the roots of the N₂-fixing plants was not compensated for by increased net photosynthetic effectiveness. Canopy photosynthesis expressed on a leaf area basis was similar for 28-day-old N₂-fixing plants (15.5 milligrams CO₂ square decimeter per hour) and 21-day-old nitrate-supplied plants (14.5 milligrams CO₂ square decimeter per hour). Both were similar in total canopy leaf area. The larger nitrate-supplied plants (28-day-old) had lower photosynthetic rates (12.5 milligrams CO₂ square decimeter per hour), presumably due to self-shading of the leaves.

These data indicate that, during the early stages of plant development, dependence solely on N₂-fixation is an expensive process compared to nitrate reduction in nitrate-supplied plants, since the N₂-fixing plants retained 8% to 12% less of their photosynthate as dry matter.