Escherichia coli mutator (Delta)polA is defective in base mismatch correction: the nature of in vivo DNA replication errors

We constructed a set of Escherichia coli strains containing deletions in genes encoding three SOS polymerases, and defective in MutS and DNA polymerase I (PolI) mismatch repair, and estimated the rate and specificity of spontaneous endogenous tonB(+)-->tonB- mutations. The rate and specificity of mutations in strains proficient or deficient in three SOS polymerases was compared and found that there was no contribution of SOS polymerases to the chromosomal tonB mutations. MutS-deficient strains displayed elevated spontaneous mutation rates, consisting of dominantly minus frameshifts and transitions. Minus frameshifts are dominated by warm spots at run-bases. Among 57 transitions (both G:C-->A:T and A:T-->G:C), 35 occurred at two hotspot sites. PolI-deficient strains possessed an increased rate of deletions and frameshifts, because of a deficiency in postreplicative deletion and frameshift mismatch corrections. Frameshifts in PolI-deficient strains occurred within the entire tonB gene at non-run and run sequences. MutS and PolI double deficiency indicated a synergistic increase in the rate of deletions, frameshifts and transitions. In this case, mutS-specific hotspots for frameshifts and transitions disappeared. The results suggested that, unlike the case previously known pertaining to postreplicative MutS mismatch repair for frameshifts and transitions and PolI mismatch repair for frameshifts and deletions, PolI can recognize and correct transition mismatches. Possible mechanisms for distinct MutS and PolI mismatch repair are discussed. A strain containing deficiencies in three SOS polymerases, MutS mismatch repair and PolI mismatch repair was also constructed. The spectrum of spontaneous mutations in this strain is considered to represent the spectrum of in vivo DNA polymerase III replication errors. The mutation rate of this strain was 219x10(-8), about a 100-fold increase relative to the wild-type strain. Uncorrected polymerase III replication errors were predominantly frameshifts and base substitutions followed by deletions.     

Spontaneous Mutation at the Mtr Locus in Neurospora: The Molecular Spectrum in Wild-Type and a Mutator Strain

Sequence analysis of 34 mtr mutations has yielded the first molecular spectrum of spontaneous mutants in Neurospora crassa. The great majority of the mutations are base substitutions (48%) or deletions (35%). In addition, sequence analysis of the entire mtr region, including the 1472-base pair open reading frame and 1205 base pairs of flanking DNA, was performed in both the Oak Ridge and Mauriceville strains of Neurospora, which are known to be divergent at the DNA level. Sixteen sequence differences between these two strains have been found in the mtr region, with 13 of these in DNA flanking the open reading frame. The differences consisted of base substitutions and small frameshifts at monotonic runs. This set of sequence differences has allowed a comparison of mutations in unselected DNA to those mutations that produce a phenotypic signal. We have isolated a mutator strain (mut-1) of Neurospora in which the spontaneous mutation rate at various loci is as much as 80-fold higher than in the non-mutator (wild type). Twenty-one mtr mutations in the mutator background have been sequenced and compared to the non-mutator spectrum, revealing a striking increase in -1 frameshift mutations. These frameshifts occur exclusively within or adjacent to monotonic runs and can be explained by small slippage events during DNA replication. This argues for a role of the mut-1 gene in this process.     

Involvement of RecB-mediated (but not RecF-mediated) repair of DNA double-strand breaks in the gamma-radiation production of long deletions in Escherichia coli.

Experiments were designed to determine the association between the repair of gamma-radiation-induced DNA double-strand breaks (DSB) and the induction of 700-1000 bp long deletions (Lac(-)----Lac+), base substitutions (leuB19----Leu+), and frameshifts (trpE9777----Trp+) in Escherichia coli K-12. Over the range of 2.5-20 krad, deletions were induced with linear kinetics, as has been shown for the induction of DSB, while the induction kinetics of base substitutions and frameshifts were curvilinear. Like the repair of DSB, deletion induction showed an absolute requirement for an intact recB gene as well as a dependency on the type of preirradiation growth medium; these requirements were not seen for base substitutions or frameshifts. In addition, about 80% of the spontaneous deletions were absent in the recB21 strain. A recC1001 mutation, which confers a 'hyper-Rec' phenotype, increased the rate of gamma-radiation-induced deletions as well as the low-dose production of base substitutions and frameshifts. A recF143 mutation increased the yield of gamma-radiation-induced deletions without increasing base substitutions or frameshifts. A mutS mutation markedly enhanced the gamma-radiation induction of frameshifts, and had a slight effect on base substitutions, but did not affect the induction of deletions. Resistance to gamma-irradiation and the capacity to repair DSB (albeit at about half the normal rate) were restored to the radiosensitive recB21 strain by the addition of the sbcB21 and sbcC201 mutations. However, the radioresistant recB sbcBC strain, which is recombination proficient via the RecF pathway, was still grossly deficient in the ability to produce deletions. A model for deletion induction as a by-product of the recB-dependent (Chi-dependent) repair of gamma-radiation-induced DSB is discussed, as is the inability to detect deletions in cells that use only the recF-dependent (Chi-independent) mechanism to repair DSB.     

Mutagenic specificity of ultraviolet light

Genetic and sequencing studies of ultraviolet light (u.v.)-induced mutations in the lacI gene of Escherichia coli show the following: u.v. stimulates many types of mutations. In lacI, base substitutions account for 60 to 65% of the observed mutations, small frameshifts 30 to 35%, and deletions of more than several base-pairs approximately 5%. A comparison of the mutational spectrum of u.v.-induced mutations with those of other SOS-dependent mutagens and with the mutations produced by inducing the SOS system in the absence of mutagenic treatment indicates that most u.v.-induced base substitutions are "targeted", resulting from premutational lesions across from the site of the mutations. Among base substitutions, both transitions and transversions occur, although the most favored mutational sites involve G X C----A X T transitions. G X C----A X T transitions are induced preferentially at sites of adjacent pyrimidines. In one case the conversion of a site from -A-C-A- to -T-C-A- results in a 15-fold increase in u.v.-induced C----T transitions. Frameshifts at certain sites are well-induced by u.v., and the largest hotspot in the I gene involves the loss of an (sequence in text) base pair from a (sequence in text) sequence. Of 25 frameshifts detected by DNA sequencing, 23 mutations at seven different sites result from the elimination of a single base-pair, and two mutations result from the elimination of two base-pairs. No additions were detected. The use of a lacI-Z fusion system, which allows direct selection of frameshifts of either sign, reveals that throughout the entire gene frameshifts that eliminate a single base-pair (-1) predominate by a factor of 20 or more over frameshifts that add a single base-pair (+1). In one case a two-base-pair elimination occurs frequently, resulting in the loss of a -C-T- sequence (on one strand), or a -T-C- sequence, from a -C-T-C-T-C-T-C- sequence. For both frameshifts and base substitutions, some aspect of the larger surrounding sequence beyond the nearest neighbors can influence mutation rates by as much as 50-fold, thus determining which sites are seen as hotspots. The bearing of these and other data on the detailed mechanism of mutagenesis is considered in the Discussion.     

Role of the RuvAB protein in avoiding spontaneous formation of deletion mutations in the Escherichia coli K-12 endogenous tonB gene

The endogenous tonB gene of Escherichia coli was used as a target for spontaneous deletion mutations which were isolated from ruvAB-, recG-, and ruvC- cells. The rates of tonB mutation were essentially the same in ruv+, ruvAB-, recG-, and ruvC- cells. We analyzed tonB mutants by sequencing. In the ruv+, recG-, and ruvC- strains, the spectra were different from those obtained from the ruvAB- cells, where deletions dominated followed by IS insertions, base substitutions, and frameshifts, in that order. We then analyzed the tonB-trp large deletion, due to simultaneous mutations of the trp operon, and found that the frequency in ruvAB- was higher than those in ruv+, recG-, and ruvC- cells. To characterize deletion formation further, we analyzed all the tonB mutants from one colicin plate. Seven deletions were identified at five sites from the 45 tonB mutants of ruv+ cells and 24 deletions at 11 sites from the 43 tonB mutants of ruvAB- cells. Thus, the ruvAB- strain is a deletion mutator. We discuss the role of RuvAB in avoiding deletions.     

Deoxyuridine misincorporation causes site-specific mutational lesions in the lacI gene of Escherichia coli

Spontaneous forward mutation in lacI was analyzed by DNA sequencing in a Dut- strain of E. coli. Hyperuracil incorporation into DNA due to the defect in deoxyuridinetriphosphatase caused a 5-fold increase in mutation frequency. Deletion, duplication and base-substitution frequencies were all enhanced in the Dut- strain. However, the analysis of the specificity of mutation revealed a remarkable site- and class-specificity. For example, base substitutions at a single site, a G:C = greater than A:T transition (Ochre 34) accounted for 55% of the base substitutions recovered. The spontaneous A:T = greater than G:C hotspot at position +6 at the lac operator was also recovered at an enhanced frequency in the Dut- strain where it accounted for 25% of the base substitutions. Many of the deletion and duplication events were recovered more than once; most had endpoints in A/T rich regions. The spontaneous frameshift hotspot involving the gain or loss of 5'-CTGG-3' in a region where this tetramer is tandemly repeated 3 times, was also greatly enhanced. No frameshifts involving a single base pair nor IS1 insertions were identified among the 86 lacI mutants sequenced. The analysis of these events reveals them to be generally consistent with a mechanism involving AP sites generated by the removal of misincorporated uracil by uracil-N-glycosylase. Considering the number of potential AP sites (approximately 1 per 170 base pairs) E. coli is remarkably refractory to mutational consequences of deoxyuridine misincorporation in place of thymidine.     

Spontaneous mutagenesis in haploid and diploid Saccharomyces cerevisiae

To obtain insights into the mechanisms of spontaneous mutations in Saccharomyces cerevisiae, we have characterized the genetic alterations that inactivate either the CAN1 gene in haploid cells or heterozygously situated in diploid cells. The mutation rate in haploid cells was 9.08 x 10(-7), 100-fold lower than that in diploid cells (1.03 x 10(-4)). In haploid cells, among 69 independent CAN1 mutations, 75% were base substitutions and 22% frameshifts. The base substitutions were both transitions (33%) and transversions (42%), with G:C-->A:T and G:C-->T:A dominating. Minus frameshifts (12%) and plus frameshifts (10%) were also observed at run and non-run bases, and at A:T and G:C pairs with almost equal efficiency. An analysis of chromosome structure in diploid yeast cells indicated that allelic crossover was the predominant event followed by gene conversion and chromosome loss. We argued that genetic alterations leading to spontaneous phenotypic changes in wild-type diploid yeast cells occurred through two steps; replication-dependent alterations of bases in either allele then recombination-dependent transfer of the mutated allele to the intact one.     

Mechanisms of spontaneous mutagenesis: an analysis of the spectrum of spontaneous mutation in the Escherichia coli lacI gene

We have obtained via DNA sequence analysis a spectrum of 174 spontaneous mutations occurring in the lac I gene of Escherichia coli. The spectrum comprised base substitution, frameshift, deletion, duplication and insertion mutations, of which the relative contributions to spontaneous mutation could be estimated. Two thirds of all lacI mutations occurred in the frameshift hotspot site. An analysis of the local DNA sequence suggested that the intensity of this hotspot may depend on structural features of the DNA that extend beyond those permitted by the repeated tetramer at this site. Deletions comprised the largest non-hotspot class (37%). They could be divided into two subclasses, depending on whether they included the lac operator sequence; the latter was found to be a preferred site for deletion endpoints. Most of the deletions internal to the lacI gene were associated with the presence of directly or invertedly repeated sequences capable of accounting for their endpoints. Base substitutions comprised 34% of the non-hotspot events. Unlike the base substitution spectrum obtained via nonsense mutations, G . C----A . T transitions do not predominate. A new base substitution hotspot was discovered at position +6 in the lac operator; its intensity may reflect specific features of the operator DNA. IS1 insertion mutations contributed 12% of the non-hotspot mutations and occurred dispersed throughout the gene in both orientations. Since the lacI gene is not A + T-rich, the contribution of IS1 insertion to spontaneous mutation in general might be underestimated. Single-base frameshift mutations were found only infrequently. In general, they did not occur in runs of a common base. Instead, their occurrence seemed based on the "perfection" of direct or inverted repeats in the local DNA sequence. Three (tandem) duplication events were recovered. No repeated sequences were found that might have determined their endpoints.     

Powerful mutator activity of the polA1 mutation within the histidine region of Escherichia coli K-12.

We examined 122 spontaneous histidine auxotrophs accumulated in overnight cultures of polA1 strains of Escherichia coli K-12 at approximate frequencies of 10(-3). One hundred and thirteen appeared to be minus frameshifts, and nine appeared to be deletions. Of the frameshift mutations, 109 affected the hisC gene, and 4 affected genes hisD, hisH, hisA, and hisI. The lack of base substitutions supported the idea that polymerase-defective polA is a minus frameshift- and deletion-type mutator. Contrary to a previous report, we did not observe superior growth of PolA auxotrophs over their prototrophic progenitors (15 auxotrophs tested). We conclude that the polA1 mutation exerts a powerful mutator activity in this specific genetic context.     

Mutation spectrum following transfection of ultraviolet-irradiated single-stranded or double-stranded shuttle vector DNA into monkey cells

We designed a shuttle vector system that allowed a comparison of the mutation spectrum on the supF target gene after transfection of single-stranded or double-stranded DNA into monkey cells. Single-strand-derived plasmids exhibited a spontaneous mutation frequency tenfold higher than double-strand-derived ones. These spontaneous mutations comprised deletions and point substitutions. This system was applied to the study of ultraviolet-induced mutagenesis. Single-stranded DNA exhibited a lower survival and a higher mutation frequency than double-stranded DNA after identical ultraviolet-irradiation. The use of single-stranded DNA allowed us to confirm and complete the data about the targeting of ultraviolet-induced mutations and the exact nature of the base changes involved. One class of mutations was more frequent after transfection of ultraviolet-irradiated single-stranded DNA than for double-stranded DNA: frameshifts represented 10% of the mutants. Multiple mutations, attributed by some authors to an error-prone excision repair process, have also been observed in the spontaneous and ultraviolet-induced mutation spectra following single-stranded DNA transfection, although it cannot be a direct substrate for excision repair.     

Spontaneous mutations affecting glycerol-3-phosphate dehydrogenase enzyme activity in Drosophila melanogaster.

Significant genetic variance in glycerol-3-phosphate dehydrogenase (GPDH) activity was observed between chromosome lines of Drosophila melanogaster that had each accumulated spontaneous mutations for approximately 300 generations. No restriction map variation was found in a 26-kb region surrounding the entire Gpdh gene. The restriction analysis used is capable of detecting insertions/deletions larger than 0.05 kb. The survey would also detect chromosomal recombinations that include the entire Gpdh coding region. Therefore, if the spontaneous mutations that affected the enzyme activity are located inside the Gpdh gene region, then they are base pair substitutions or structural changes that are smaller than the limit in resolution described above.     

Spontaneous mutagenesis: the roles of DNA repair, replication, and recombination

There appears to be no dearth of mechanisms to explain spontaneous mutagenesis. In the case of base substitutions, data for bacteriophage T4 and especially for E. coli and S. cerevisiae suggest important roles in spontaneous mutagenesis for the error-prone repair of DNA damage (to produce mutations) and for error-free repair of DNA damage (to avoid mutagenesis). Data from the very limited number of studies on the subject suggest that about 50% of the spontaneous base substitutions in E. coli, and perhaps 90% in S. cerevisiae are due to error-prone DNA repair. On the other hand, spontaneous frameshifts and deletions seem to result from mechanisms involving recombination and replication. Spontaneous insertions have been shown to be important in the strongly polar inactivation of certain loci, but it is less important at other loci. Perhaps with continued study, the term "spontaneous mutagenesis" will be replaced by more specific terms such as 5-methylcytosine deamination mutagenesis, fatty acid oxidation mutagenesis, phenylalanine mutagenesis, and imprecise-recombination mutagenesis. While most studies have concentrated on mutator mutations, the most conclusive data for the actual source of spontaneous mutations have come from the study of antimutator mutations. Further study in this area, perhaps along with an understanding of chemical antimutagens, should be invaluable in clarifying the bases of spontaneous mutagenesis.     

Spontaneous Mutation in the Escherichia Coli Laci Gene

To gain more detailed insight into the nature and mechanisms of spontaneous mutations, we undertook a DNA sequence analysis of a large collection of spontaneous mutations in the N-terminal region of the Escherichia coli lacI gene. This region of circa 210 base pairs is the target for dominant lacI mutations (i-d) and is suitable for studies of mutational specificity since it contains a relatively high density of detectable mutable sites. Among 414 independent i-d mutants, 70.8% were base substitutions, 17.2% deletions, 7.7% additions and 4.3% single-base frameshifts. The base substitutions were both transitions (60%) and transversions (40%), the largest single group being G.C----A.T (47% of base substitutions). All four transversions were observed. Among the 71 deletions, a hotspot (37 mutants) was present: an 87-bp deletion presumably directed by an 8-bp repeated sequence at its endpoints. The remaining 34 deletions were distributed among 29 different mutations, either flanked (13/34) or not flanked (21/34) by repeated sequences. The 32 additions comprised 29 different events, with only two containing a direct repeat at the endpoints. The single-base frameshifts were the loss of a single base from either repeated (67%) or nonrepeated (33%) bases. A comparison with the spectrum obtained previously in strains defective in DNA mismatch correction (mutH, mutL, mutS strains) yielded information about the apparent efficiency of mismatch repair. The overall effect was 260-fold but varied substantially among different classes of mutations. An interesting asymmetry was uncovered for the two types of transitions, A.T----G.C and G.C----A.T being reduced by mismatch repair 1340- and 190-fold, respectively. Explanations for this asymmetry and its possible implications for the origins of spontaneous mutations are discussed.     

Specificity of spontaneous mutation in the lacI gene cloned into bacteriophage M13

We have studied the specificity of spontaneous mutation in the lacI gene of Escherichia coli cloned into bacteriophage M13. The comparison of the spectrum of 85 spontaneous mutations with that of the lacI gene carried on an E. coli F' episone revealed the following characteristics: (i) base substitution was predominant, accounting for 80% of spontaneous events compared with only 11% on the F' episome; (ii) among the base substitutions, the majority were G:C----A:T transitions (86%); (iii) not one mutation recovered on M13 corresponded to a mutation at the spontaneous hotspots seen in the F' spectrum (i.e., neither the addition or deletion of the tetramer 5'-CTGG-3' at position 620-631 nor the A:T----G:C transition at position +6 of lacO were recovered). The enhanced rate of cytosine deamination in single-stranded DNA, the unique replication mechanism and the refractory nature of single-stranded DNA to excision-repair processes present likely explanations for the observed mutational spectrum.     

Specificity of mutational DNA sequence changes induced by X-rays in the cloned Escherichia coli crp gene.

Plasmid DNA carrying the adenosine 3',5'-cyclic monophosphate receptor protein (crp) gene of Escherichia coli was irradiated, in solution, with X-rays, and the mutations produced in the crp gene were assayed by transforming the recipient E. coli cells. Ninety-six mutant clones were isolated, and mutational changes were determined by DNA sequencing. Of the 92 mutations thus detected, 74 represented base substitution mutations and the remaining 18 were frameshifts. The base substitutions included 56 G:C to A:T transitions, 10 G:C to T:A transversions and 7 G:C to C:G transversions. An A:T to G:C transition was found only once, and neither an A:T to T:A nor an A:T to C:G transversion was detected. The frameshift mutations consisted of 11 one-base deletions and 7 one-base insertions. Accordingly, G:C to A:T transition was the predominant type of mutation, which constituted 76% (56/74) of the total base substitutions and 60% (56/92) of all detected mutations. Furthermore, of the 56 transitions, about three-quarters (41 clones) clustered at an identical site, a cytosine residue at the 706 position, demonstrating that this site is a distinct hot spot for X-ray mutagenesis. These results raise the possibility that radiation-induced mutations may not necessarily occur randomly, at least in certain cases.     

The Spontaneous Mutation Rate in the Fission Yeast Schizosaccharomyces pombe

The rate at which new mutations arise in the genome is a key factor in the evolution and adaptation of species. Here we describe the rate and spectrum of spontaneous mutations for the fission yeast Schizosaccharomyces pombe, a key model organism with many similarities to higher eukaryotes. We undertook an ∼1700-generation mutation accumulation (MA) experiment with a haploid S. pombe, generating 422 single-base substitutions and 119 insertion-deletion mutations (indels) across the 96 replicates. This equates to a base-substitution mutation rate of 2.00 × 10⁻¹⁰ mutations per site per generation, similar to that reported for the distantly related budding yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae. However, these two yeast species differ dramatically in their spectrum of base substitutions, the types of indels (S. pombe is more prone to insertions), and the pattern of selection required to counteract a strong AT-biased mutation rate. Overall, our results indicate that GC-biased gene conversion does not play a major role in shaping the nucleotide composition of the S. pombe genome and suggest that the mechanisms of DNA maintenance may have diverged significantly between fission and budding yeasts. Unexpectedly, CpG sites appear to be excessively liable to mutation in both species despite the likely absence of DNA methylation.     

Mutagenesis by 8-methoxypsoralen plus near-UV treatment: analysis of specificity in the lacI gene of Escherichia coli

We have studied the specificity of mutation induced by PUVA treatment in the lacI gene of E. coli. Cells were exposed to near UV (≈365 nm) in the presence of 8-methoxypsoralen under conditions yielding about 7% survival and a 10-fold increase in mutation frequency. The cloning and sequencing of 131 mutants recovered following PUVA treatment revealed that almost all classes of mutation including base substitutions, frameshifts and deletions were induced. The distribution of mutations was non-random and a region of the lacI gene was found to be virtually silent for all classes of mutation. Intriguingly, the broad spectrum of mutation is accompanied by the recovery of mutation at two spontaneous hotspots. We observed a 7-fold increase at a frameshift hotspot involving the gain or loss of a tetramer tandemly repeated 3 times at this site and a 23-fold increase at an A:T→G:C transition hotspot located at the +6 position in the lac operator region. However, despite the presence of these spontaneous hotspots, the mutational spectrum recovered following PUVA treatment was unique and a detailed analysis of the different classes of mutations indicates a role for DNA repair of both monoadducts and cross-links in the production of mutation.     

Spectrum of spontaneous frameshift mutations. Sequences of bacteriophage T4 rII gene frameshifts

The DNA sequences of 185 independent spontaneous frameshift mutations in the rIIB gene of bacteriophage T4 are described. Approximately half of the frameshifts, including those at hot spot sites, are fully consistent with classical proposals that frameshift mutations are produced by a mechanism involving the misaligned pairing of repeated DNA sequences. However, the remaining frameshifts are inconsistent with this model. Correlations between the positions of two base-pair frameshifts and the bases of DNA hairpins suggest that local DNA topology might influence frameshift mutation. Warm spots for larger deletions share the property of having endpoints adjacent to DNA sequences whose complementarity to sequences a few base-pairs away suggest that non-classical DNA misalignments may participate in deletion mutation. A model for duplication mutation as a consequence of strand displacement synthesis is discussed. In all, 15 frameshifts were complex combinations of frameshifts and base substitutions. Three of these were identical, and have extended homology to a sequence 256 base-pairs away that is likely to participate in the mutational event; the remainder are unique combinations of frameshifts and transversions. The frequency and diversity of complex mutants suggest a challenge to the assumption that the molecular evolution of DNA must depend primarily upon the accumulation of single nucleotide changes.