RecFOR proteins load RecA protein onto gapped DNA to accelerate DNA strand exchange: a universal step of recombinational repair

Genetic evidence suggests that the RecF, RecO, and RecR (RecFOR) proteins participate in a common step of DNA recombination and repair, yet the biochemical event requiring collaboration of all three proteins is unknown. Here, we show that the concerted action of the RecFOR complex directs the loading of RecA protein specifically onto gapped DNA that is coated with single-stranded DNA binding (SSB) protein, thereby accelerating DNA strand exchange. The RecFOR complex recognizes the junction between the ssDNA and dsDNA regions and requires a base-paired 5' terminus at the junction. Thus, the RecFOR complex is a structure-specific mediator that targets recombinational repair to ssDNA-dsDNA junctions. This reaction reconstitutes the initial steps of recombinational gapped DNA repair and uncovers an event also common to the repair of ssDNA-tailed intermediates of dsDNA-break repair. We propose that the behavior of the RecFOR proteins is mimicked by functional counterparts that exist in all organisms.     

Concerted strand exchange and formation of Holliday structures by E. coli RecA protein

RecA protein makes stable joint molecules from fully duplex DNA and molecules that are partially single-stranded; the latter may be either duplex molecules with an internal gap in one strand or molecules with single-stranded ends. Stable joint molecules form only when the end of at least one strand is in a homologous region. When RecA protein pairs linear duplex molecules and tailed molecules that share the same sequence end to end, the joints, which are located away from the single-stranded tails in most instances, have the electron microscopic appearance associated with the Holliday structure resulting from the reciprocal exchange of strands. The reaction leading to reciprocal strand exchange involves the concerted displacement of a strand from the end of the duplex molecule. These observations support the view that RecA protein makes stable joint molecules only by transferring strands and not by the side-by-side pairing of duplex regions.     

Homologous recombination in real time: DNA strand exchange by RecA

Homologous recombination, the exchange of strands between different DNA molecules, is essential for proper maintenance and accurate duplication of the genome. Using magnetic tweezers, we monitor RecA-driven homologous recombination of individual DNA molecules in real time. We resolve several key aspects of DNA structure during and after strand exchange. Changes in DNA length and twist yield helical parameters for the protein-bound three-stranded structure in conditions in which ATP was not hydrolyzed. When strand exchange was completed under ATP hydrolysis conditions that allow protein dissociation, a "D wrap" structure formed. During homologous recombination, strand invasion at one end and RecA dissociation at the other end occurred at the same rate, and our single-molecule analysis indicated that a region of only about 80 bp is actively involved in the synapsis at any time during the entire reaction involving a long ( approximately 1 kb) region of homology.     

ADP-dependent DNA strand exchange by the mutant [P67G/E68A] RecA protein

We have prepared a mutant RecA protein in which proline 67 and glutamic acid 68 in the NTP binding site were replaced by a glycine and alanine residue, respectively. The [P67G/E68A]RecA protein catalyzes the single-stranded DNA-dependent hydrolysis of ATP and is able to promote the standard ATP-dependent three-strand exchange reaction between a circular bacteriophage phiX174 (phiX) single-stranded DNA molecule and a homologous linear phiX double-stranded (ds) DNA molecule (5.4 kilobase pairs). The strand exchange activity differs from that of the wild type RecA protein, however, in that it is (i) completely inhibited by an ATP regeneration system, and (ii) strongly stimulated by the addition of high concentrations of ADP to the reaction solution. These results indicate that the strand exchange activity of the [P67G/E68A]RecA protein is dependent on the presence of both ATP and ADP. The ADP dependence of the reaction is reduced or eliminated when (i) a shorter linear phiX dsDNA fragment (1.1 kilobase pairs) is substituted for the full-length linear phiX dsDNA substrate, or (ii) the Mg(2+) concentration is reduced to a level just sufficient to complex the ATP present in the reaction solution. These results indicate that it is the branch migration phase (and not the initial pairing step) of the [P67G/E68A]RecA protein-promoted strand exchange reaction that is dependent on ADP. It is likely that the [P67G/E68A]RecA mutation has revealed a requirement for ADP that also exists (but is not as readily apparent) in the strand exchange reaction of the wild type RecA protein.     

The synaptic complex of RecA protein participates in hybridization and inverse strand exchange reactions

RecA protein catalyzes strand exchange between homologous single-stranded and double-stranded DNAs. In the presence of ATPgammaS, the post-strand exchange synaptic complex is a stable end product that can be studied. Here we ask whether such complexes can hybridize to or exchange with DNA, 2'-OMe RNA, PNA, or LNA oligonucleotides. Using a gel mobility shift assay, we show that the displaced strand of a 45 bp synaptic complex can hybridize to complementary oligonucleotides with different backbones to form a four-stranded (double D-loop) joint that survives removal of the RecA protein. This hybridization reaction, which confirms the single-stranded character of the displaced strand in a synaptic complex, might initiate recombination-dependent DNA replication if it occurs in vivo. We also show that either strand of the heteroduplex in a 30 bp synaptic complex can be replaced with a homologous DNA oligonucleotide in a strand exchange reaction that is mediated by the RecA filament. Consistent with the important role that deoxyribose plays in strand exchange, oligonucleotides with non-DNA backbones did not participate in this reaction. The hybridization and strand exchange reactions reported here demonstrate that short synaptic complexes are dynamic structures even in the presence of ATPgammaS.     

RecA protein reinitiates strand exchange on isolated protein-free DNA intermediates. An ADP-resistant process

Efficient homologous pairing de novo of linear duplex DNA with a circular single strand (plus strand) coated with RecA protein requires saturation and extension of the single strand by the protein. However, strand exchange, the transfer of a strand from duplex DNA to the nucleoprotein filament, which follows homologous pairing, does not require the stable binding of RecA protein to single-stranded DNA. When RecA protein was added back to isolated protein-free DNA intermediates in the presence of sufficient ADP to inhibit strongly the binding of RecA protein to single-stranded DNA, strand exchange nonetheless resumed at the original rate and went to completion. Characterization of the protein-free DNA intermediate suggested that it has a special site or region to which RecA protein binds. Part of the nascent displaced plus strand of the deproteinized intermediate was unavailable as a cofactor for the ATPase activity of RecA protein, and about 30% resisted digestion by P1 endonuclease, which acts preferentially on single-stranded DNA. At the completion of strand exchange, when the distal 5' end of the linear minus strand had been fully incorporated into heteroduplex DNA, a nucleoprotein complex remained that contained all three strands of DNA from which the nascent displaced strand dissociated only over the next 50 to 60 minutes. Deproteinization of this intermediate yielded a complex that also contained three strands of DNA in which the nascent displaced strand was partially resistant to both Escherichia coli exonuclease I and P1 endonuclease. The deproteinized complex showed a broad melting transition between 37 degrees C and temperatures high enough to melt duplex DNA. These results show that strand exchange can be subdivided into two stages: (1) the exchange of base-pairs, which creates a new heteroduplex pair in place of a parental pair; and (2) strand separation, which is the physical displacement of the unpaired strand from the nucleoprotein filament. Between the creation of new heteroduplex DNA and the eventual separation of a third strand, there exists an unusual DNA intermediate that may contain three-stranded regions of natural DNA that are several thousand bases in length.     

The function of the secondary DNA-binding site of RecA protein during DNA strand exchange.

RecA protein features two distinct DNA-binding sites. During DNA strand exchange, the primary site binds to single-stranded DNA (ssDNA), forming the helical RecA nucleoprotein filament. The weaker secondary site binds double-stranded DNA (dsDNA) during the homology search process. Here we demonstrate that this site has a second important function. It binds the ssDNA strand that is displaced from homologous duplex DNA during DNA strand exchange, stabilizing the initial heteroduplex DNA product. Although the high affinity of the secondary site for ssDNA is essential for DNA strand exchange, it renders DNA strand exchange sensitive to an excess of ssDNA which competes with dsDNA for binding. We further demonstrate that single-stranded DNA-binding protein can sequester ssDNA, preventing its binding to the secondary site and thereby assisting at two levels: it averts the inhibition caused by an excess of ssDNA and prevents the reversal of DNA strand exchange by removing the displaced strand from the secondary site.     

RNA-DNA hybridization promoted by E. coli RecA protein.

RecA protein of E. coli plays a central regulatory role that is induced by damage to DNA and results in the inactivation of LexA repressor. In vitro, RecA protein binds preferentially to single-stranded DNA to form a nucleoprotein filament that can recognize homology in naked duplex DNA and promote extensive strand exchange. Although RecA protein shows little tendency at neutral pH to bind to RNA, we found that it nonetheless catalyzed at 37 degrees C the hybridization of complementary RNA and single-stranded DNA sequences. Hybrids made by RecA protein at 37 degrees C appeared indistinguishable from ones prepared by thermal annealing. RNA-DNA hybridization by RecA protein at neutral pH required, as does RecA-promoted homologous pairing, optimal conditions for the formation of RecA nucleoprotein filaments. The cosedimentation of RNA with those filaments further paralleled observations made on the formation of networks of nucleoprotein filaments with double-stranded DNA, an instrumental intermediate in homologous pairing in vitro. These similarities with the pairing reaction support the view that RecA protein acts specifically in the hybridization reaction.     

RecA protein-facilitated DNA strand breaks. A mechanism for bypassing DNA structural barriers during strand exchange

RecA protein promotes an unexpectedly efficient DNA strand exchange between circular single-stranded DNA and duplex DNAs containing short (50-400-base pair) heterologous sequences at the 5' (initiating) end. The major mechanism by which this topological barrier is bypassed involves DNA strand breakage. Breakage is both strand and position specific, occurring almost exclusively in the displaced (+) strand of the duplex within a 15-base pair region of the heterology/homology junction. Breakage also requires recA protein, ATP hydrolysis, and homologous sequences 3' to the heterology. Although the location of the breaks and the observed requirements clearly indicate a major role for recA protein in this phenomenon, the molecular mechanism is not yet clear. The breakage may reflect a DNA structure and/or some form of structural stress within the DNA during recA protein-mediated DNA pairing which either exposes the DNA at this precise position to the action of a contaminating nuclease or induces a direct mechanical break. We also find that when heterology is located at the 3' end of the linear duplex, strand exchange is halted (without DNA breakage) about 500 base pairs from the homology/heterology junction.     

Mechanistic insight from chaos: how RecA mediates DNA strand exchange

Cleverly designed single-molecule FRET experiments reported in this issue of Structure by Ragunathan et?al. coax RecA to reveal some of its secrets. Observing individual events identifies intermediate steps and provides clues for how to drive strand exchange forward.     

Escherichia coli RecA promotes strand invasion with cisplatin-damaged DNA

The antitumor drug cisplatin causes intrastrand cross-linking of adjacent guanine residues that severely distorts the DNA backbone. These DNA adducts impede the progress of the replisome and may result in replication fork arrest. In Escherichia coli, the response to cisplatin involves the action of the prototypic recombinase RecA. Here we show that RecA can utilize, albeit at reduced levels, oligonucleotides that bear site-specific cisplatin-induced 1,2 d(GpG) intrastrand cross-links in strand invasion reactions. Binding of RecA to cisplatin-damaged oligonucleotides was not affected, indicating that the impediment was in the pairing step. The cognate E. coli single-strand DNA-binding protein specifically stimulated strand invasion particularly with cisplatin-damaged DNA. These results indicate that RecA is capable of processing the major cisplatin-induced lesion via a recombination mechanism.     

RecA protein promotes strand exchange with DNA substrates containing isoguanine and 5-methyl isocytosine

The Escherichia coli RecA protein pairs homologous DNA molecules and promotes DNA strand exchange in vitro. We have examined DNA strand exchange between a 70 nucleotide ssDNA fragment and a 40 bp duplex, in which all G and C residues (at 18 positions distributed throughout the 40 bp exchanged region) were replaced with the nonstandard nucleosides 2'-deoxyisoguanosine (iG) and 2'-deoxy-5-methylisocytidine (MiC), respectively. We demonstrate that the nonstandard oligonucleotides are substrates for the RecA protein, permitting DNA strand exchange in vitro at a rate and efficiency comparable to exchange with normal DNA substrates. This observation provides an expanded experimental basis for discussions of potential roles for iG and MiC in a genetic code. Experiments of this type also provide another avenue for exploring RecA-facilitated DNA pairing mechanisms.     

Postreplication repair of deoxyribonucleic acid and daughter strand exchange in uvr- mutants of Bacillus subtilis

The fate of pyrimidine dimers in deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA) newly synthesized by Bacillus subtilis after ultraviolet irradiation was monitored by use of a damage-specific endonuclease that introduces single-strand breaks adjacent to nearly all of the dimer sites. Two Uvr- strains, one defective in the initiation of dimer excision and the other defective in a function required for efficient dimer excision, were found to be similar to their wild-type parent in the kinetics and extent of converting low-molecular-weight DNA newly synthesized after ultraviolet irradiation to high molecular weight. In the Uvr- strains large molecules of newly synthesized DNA remained susceptible to nicking by the damage-specific endonuclease even after extended incubation in growth medium, whereas the enzyme-sensitive sites were rapidly removed from both preexisting and newly synthesized DNA in Uvr+ cells. Our results support the hypothesis that postreplication repair in bacteria includes recombination between dimer-containing parental DNA strands and newly synthesized strands.     

RecA protein of Mycobacterium tuberculosis possesses pH-dependent homologous DNA pairing and strand exchange activities: implications for allele exchange in mycobacteria

To gain insights into inefficient allele exchange in mycobacteria, we compared homologous pairing and strand exchange reactions promoted by RecA protein of Mycobacterium tuberculosis to those of Escherichia coli RecA protein. The extent of single-stranded binding protein (SSB)-stimulated formation of joint molecules by MtRecA was similar to that of EcRecA over a wide range of pH values. In contrast, strand exchange promoted by MtRecA was inhibited around neutral pH due to the formation of DNA networks. At higher pH, MtRecA was able to overcome this constraint and, consequently, displayed optimal strand exchange activity. Order of addition experiments suggested that SSB, when added after MtRecA, was vital for strand exchange. Significantly, with shorter duplex DNA, MtRecA promoted efficient strand exchange without network formation in a pH-independent fashion. Increase in the length of duplex DNA led to incomplete strand exchange with concomitant rise in the formation of intermediates and networks in a pH-dependent manner. Treatment of purified networks with S1 nuclease liberated linear duplex DNA and products, consistent with a model in which the networks are formed by the invasion of hybrid DNA by the displaced linear single-stranded DNA. Titration of strand exchange reactions with ATP or salt distinguished a condition under which the formation of networks was blocked, but strand exchange was not significantly affected. We discuss how these results relate to inefficient allele exchange in mycobacteria.     

The direction of RecA protein assembly onto single strand DNA is the same as the direction of strand assimilation during strand exchange

The RecA protein of Escherichia coli optimally promotes DNA strand exchange reactions in the presence of the single strand DNA-binding protein of E. coli (SSB protein). Under these conditions, assembly of RecA protein onto single-stranded DNA (ssDNA) occurs in three steps. First, the ssDNA is rapidly covered by SSB protein. The binding of RecA protein is then initiated by nucleation of a short tract of RecA protein onto the ssDNA. Finally, cooperative polymerization of additional RecA protein accompanied by displacement of SSB protein results in a ssDNA-RecA protein filament (Griffith, J. D., Harris, L. D., and Register, J. C. (1984) Cold Spring Harbor Symp. Quant. Biol. 49, 553-559). We report here that RecA protein assembly onto circular ssDNA yields RecA protein-covered circles in which greater than 85% are completely covered by RecA protein with no remaining SSB protein-covered segments (as detected by electron microscopy). However, when linear ssDNA is used, 90% of the filaments contain a short segment at one end complexed with SSB protein. This suggests that RecA protein assembly is unidirectional. Visualization of the assembly of RecA protein onto either long ssDNA tails (containing either 5' or 3' termini) or ssDNA gaps generated in double strand DNA allowed us to determine that the RecA protein polymerizes in the 5' to 3' direction on ssDNA and preferentially nucleates at ssDNA-double strand DNA junctions containing 5' termini.     

Postreplication repair mechanisms in the presence of DNA adducts in Escherichia coli

During bacterial replication, DNA polymerases may encounter DNA lesions that block processive DNA synthesis. Uncoupling the replicative helicase from the stalled DNA polymerase results in the formation of single-stranded DNA (ssDNA) gaps, which are repaired by postreplication repair (PRR), a process that involves at least three mechanisms that collectively remove, circumvent or bypass lesions. RecA mediated excision repair (RAMER) and homologous recombination (HR) are strand-exchange mechanisms that appear to be the predominant strategies for gap repair in the absence of prolonged SOS induction. During RAMER, RecA mediates pairing of damaged ssDNA with an undamaged homologous duplex and subsequent exchange of strands between the damaged and undamaged DNA. Repair of the lesion occurs in the context of the strand-exchange product and is initiated by UvrABC excinuclease; the resulting patch is filled by DNA synthesis using the complementary strand of the homologous duplex as a template. HR uses a complementary strand of an undamaged homologous duplex as a transient template for DNA synthesis. HR requires the formation and resolution of Holliday junctions, and is a mechanism to circumvent the lesion; lesions persisting in one of the daughter DNA duplexes will normally be repaired prior to subsequent rounds of replication/cell division. Translesion DNA Synthesis (TLS) does not involve strand-exchange mechanisms; it is carried out by specialized DNA polymerases that are able to catalyze nucleotide incorporation opposite lesions that cannot be bypassed by high-fidelity replicative polymerases. Maximum levels of TLS occur during prolonged SOS induction generally associated with increased mutagenesis. RAMER, HR and TLS are alternative mechanisms for processing a common intermediate-the ssDNA gap containing a RecA nucleofilament. The actual pathway that is utilized will be strongly influenced by multiple factors, including the blocking/coding capacity of the lesion, the nature of the gene products that can be assembled at the ssDNA gap, the availability of a homologous partner for RAMER and HR, and protein:protein interactions and post-translational modifications that modulate the mutagenic activity of Pol-IV and Pol-V.     

Assembly and disassembly of RecA protein filaments occur at opposite filament ends. Relationship to DNA strand exchange

RecA protein primarily associates with and dissociates from opposite ends of nucleoprotein filaments formed on linear duplex DNA. RecA nucleoprotein filaments that are hydrolyzing ATP therefore engage in a dynamic process under some conditions that has some of the properties of treadmilling. We have also investigated whether the net polymerization of recA protein at one end of the filament and/or a net depolymerization at the other end drives unidirectional strand exchange. There is no demonstrable correlation between recA protein association/dissociation and the strand exchange reaction. RecA protein-mediated DNA strand exchange is affected minimally by changes in reaction conditions (dilution, pH shift, or addition of small amounts of adenosine-5'-O-(3-thiotriphosphate) that have large and demonstrable effects on recA protein association, dissociation, or both. Rather than driving strand exchange, these assembly and disassembly processes may simply represent the mechanism by which recA nucleoprotein filaments are recycled in the cell.