The Species Problem in a Ciliate with a High Multiple Mating Type System, Euplotes crassus

ABSTRACT. One hundred twenty non-autogamous wild-type strains of Euplotes crassus , collected over seven years, mainly from the Mediterranean coasts, were investigated for their mating interactions. The strains were mixed pair-wise and data from mating reactions were evaluated and organized by means of a specially constructed computer program. The program identified 38 strains with distinctive mating patterns which could be clustered in nine clumps, all of which were connected either directly or indirectly. Thus, all these strains appeared to be components of the same gene pool, even though direct genetic exchange between strains was not possible in every combination. Subsequently, the 38 strains were subjected to cytometric analysis and scored for zymic variations resulting from electrophoretic patterns of five enzyme systems (acid phosphatases, amylases, malic dehydrogenase, malic enzyme, and tetrazolium oxidases) of proved diagnostic value in the identification of Euplotes species. No significant discontinuities correlated with mating patterns was apparent from these analyses. It was concluded that the E. crassus strains analyzed are not properly divided in sibling species and it was consistently suggested to avoid a genetic partitioning of ciliate species endowed with high multiple mating type systems, in which the sets of wild strains brought under investigation with difficulty represent the natural dimensions of the species.     

The Secondary Metabolite Euplotin C Induces Apoptosis-Like Death in the Marine Ciliated Protist Euplotes vannus

ABSTRACT. The sesquiterpenoid euplotin C is a secondary metabolite produced by the ciliated protist Euplotes crassus and provides a mechanism for damping populations of potential competitors. Indeed, E. crassus is virtually resistant to its own product while different non-producer species representing an unbiased sample of the marine, interstitial, ciliate diversity are sensitive. For instance, euplotin C exerts a marked disruption of different homeostatic mechanisms in Euplotes vannus . We demonstrate by 3-(4,5-dimethylthiazol-2-yl)-2,5-diphenyltetrazolium bromide assay that euplotin C quickly decreases viability and mitochondrial function of E. vannus with a very high efficacy and at micromolar potency. In addition, euplotin C induces apoptosis in E. vannus as 4,6-diamino-2-phenylindole and terminal transferase dUTP nick end labeling staining show the rapid condensation and fragmentation of nuclear material in cells treated with euplotin C. These effects occur without detectable permeabilisation or rupture of cell membranes and with no major changes in the overall morphology, although some traits, such as vacuolisation and disorganized microtubules, can be observed by transmission electron microscopy. In particular, E. vannus show profound changes of the mitochondrial ultrastructure. Finally, we also show that caspase activity in E. vannus is increased by euplotin C. These data elucidate the pro-apoptotic role of euplotin C and suggest a mechanism for its impact on natural selection.     

Species Structure in Euplotes crassus (Ciliophora, Hypotrichida)

ABSTRACT. We observed different low salinity tolerances between two groups of populations of Euplotes crassus. After mating analysis, the less tolerant populations could be assigned to three mating groups. Two of them were separated by preconjugative barriers but both conjugated with a third one. A breeding test showed evidence of (potential) introgression mediated by this "bridging" group. On the other hand, the more tolerant populations formed a fourth mating group unable to conjugate with the others and characterized by distinct zymogram patterns. We conclude that natural introgression among the studied populations is not complete and that the species structure of E. crassus comprises intrafertile sets of populations among which gene flow may be difficult or virtually absent.     

A Morphometric Study of Euryhalinity in Marine Populations of the Ciliate Genus Euplotes

ABSTRACT. Twenty different clonal strains of marine and brackish Euplotes , representing four morphotypes, were tested for hyposalinity tolerance by a method which gradually acclimated the cells to lower salinity medium. The lowest salinities in which the strains could thrive ranged from 60% of normal seawater to complete freshwater. The morphological effects of culture medium salinity were also examined for two strains of a small "Euplotes charon" morphotype, as well as for two mating compatible "Euplotes vannus" strains and several of their exconjugates. There were no differences between the euryhaline strains grown in fresh or saltwater, except for a slight increase in overall cell size in one strain when cultured in freshwater medium. E. vannus strains increased in overall cell size with decreased salinity; also, the dorsal surface of the cells can become disorganized when the cells are cultured in 30% normal seawater.     

Growth Rates of Marine Ciliates on Diverse Organisms Reveal Ecological Specializations within Morphospecies

Abstract The growth rate of 31 stocks of Euplotes, a cosmopolitan, marine, unicellular protist, on six food species representing two different food types, microalgae and bacteria, has been determined. The 31 stocks represented nine reproductively isolated groups (biological species?) based on breeding relationships. Three morphospecies, E. vannus, E. crassus, and E. minuta, each with both autogamous and cross-breeding breeding groups, were included. The mean number of fissions completed in 5 days of a breeding group growing on one of the six food species varied from zero to 17.06. There is a strong interaction between morphospecies and food type. The largest morphospecies, E. vannus, translates the nutritional content of algae into growth better than it translates that of bacteria, while the reverse is true for E. minuta, the smallest morphospecies. Autogamous breeding groups grow more rapidly on algae than on bacteria when compared to cross-breeding groups in the same morphospecies. Two breeding groups cannot grow on Escherichia coli. ANOVA of fissions completed in 5 days revealed significant main effects and interactions between many hierarchical levels of stocks and food species. These significant interactions indicate that genetically determined ecologically important information is present at all taxonomic levels—morphospecies, breeding system, breeding group, and stock. As all these levels are biologically meaningful, measuring biodiversity in the E. vannus–crassus–minuta complex solely on morphospecies will inadequately represent the ecological diversity present in the organisms and their environment. Received: 11 May 1998; Accepted: 31 July 1998     

Genetic relationship of 32 cell lines of the euplotes octocarinatus species complex revealed by random amplified polymorphic DNA (RAPD) fingerprinting

Random amplified polymorphic DNA (RAPD) fingerprinting was used in this study to determine the genetic relationship of different cell lines of the hypotrichous ciliate Euplotes octocarinatus. Stocks isolated from different habitats in the USA, and from a group of genetically recombined laboratory strains, were characterized. Band-sharing indices (D) for all possible pairwise comparisons revealed a remarkable genetic diversity between the different cell lines. Investigation of the genetic structure in natural populations found diversity--although to a different extent--in all populations investigated. No clonal structure could be observed, as proposed for several protozoa and recently shown for E. daidaleos. These findings suggest frequent conjugation in the population of E. octocarinatus. No correlation between the genetic relationship of cell lines from different habitats and the distance between the corresponding sampling locations was found. Once separated geographically, the exchange of genetic material between populations appears to be nearly impossible. Therefore, these groups tend to separate into sibling species. The data generally support the occurrence of different syngens in the E. octocarinatus species complex. This finding is in accordance with our observation that the morphological 'species' of E. octocarinatus consists of several syngens or sibling species, similar to findings for the Paramecium aurelia-, Tetrahymena pyriformis- and E. vannus- species complexes.     

Relationships between Cell Cycle and Conjugation in 3 Hypotrichs*

SYNOPSIS. Relationships between the cell cycle and the beginning of conjugation were analyzed for 3 hypotrichs: Diophrys scutum, Oxytricha bifaria, and Euplotes crassus. The first 2 species enter conjugation with micronuclei in G₁; the latter species with a micronucleus in G₂. The 1st micronuclear division of conjugating E. crassus is mitotic. Thus meiotic DNA replication occurs when the cells of each species have already entered the mating process. Cells from asynchronous populations start conjugation with their macronuclei primarily in G₁ or more rarely at the beginning of the S stage in a percentage significantly different from that expected on the basis of random mating among all cells in the population. Also, macronuclear replication, when already begun, was blocked in cells undergoing conjugation. Therefore only the G₁ or the very early S stages of the cell cycle are compatible with conjugation in the 3 analyzed species.     

In Situ Identification by Fluorescently Labeled Oligonucleotide Probes of Morphologically Similar,Closely Related Ciliate Species

Ciliate protozoa are important members of microbial communities in which they play specific ecological roles. The determination of single species distribution is fundamental for food web analysis, but species recognition, which is mainly based on morphological characters, is often difficult between closely related species. The use of species-specific, purposely designed, fluorescently labeled probes for in situ hybridization is here presented as an easy and fast identification method for three closely related species belonging to the widespread genus Euplotes, namely E. crassus, E. vannus, and E. minuta, that in spite of their remarkable morphological similarity have significant metabolic and ecological differences. These three species can be detected simultaneously, provided the probes employed are bound to different fluorescent dyes: in this way their relative abundance and their population dynamics in the natural environment can be evaluated. As more ciliate sequences become available in databases, species-specific probes can be designed for other ciliates, thus rendering the application of the method of more general importance. The probes used in this study may also provide a tool to prevent erroneous species identification in future studies.     

Phylogeographical pattern of Euplotes nobilii,a protist ciliate with a bipolar biogeographical distribution

Nuclear (18S and ITS) and mitochondrial (16S) ribosomal RNA gene sequences were determined from genetically distinct wild‐type strains of Antarctic (nine strains), Fuegian (four strains), Greenland (nine strains) and Svalbard (three strains) populations of the marine ciliate, Euplotes nobilii, and analysed for their nucleotide polymorphisms. A close genetic homogeneity was found within and between the Antarctic and Fuegian populations, while more significant levels of genetic differentiation were detected within and between the two Arctic populations, as well as between these populations and the Antarctic/Fuegian ones. The phylogeographical pattern that was derived from these data indicates that gene flow is not limited among Arctic populations; it equally connects the Arctic and Antarctic populations either directly, or through the Fuegian population. This indication reinforces previous evidence from laboratory assays of mating interactions between some of the strains analysed in this work that Southern and Northern polar populations of E. nobilii belong to a unique, panmictic population that substantially share the same gene pool.     

Genetic Variation Segregating in Natural Populations of Tribolium Castaneum Affecting Traits Observed in Hybrids with T. Freemani

We investigated patterns of within-species genetic variation for traits observed in hybrids (hybrid numbers, hybrid sex ratios, and hybrid male deformities) between two species of flour beetles, Tribolium castaneum and T. freemani. We found genetic variation segregating among four natural populations of T. castaneum as well as within these populations. For some hybrid traits, we observed as much variation among populations 750 km apart as between populations on different continents, suggesting genetic differentiation at a local scale. Within natural populations, the variation segregating among sires is greater than that found in an earlier study for an outbred laboratory population and comparable to that observed between inbred lines derived from the outbred stock by eight generations of brother-sister mating. When sires from T. castaneum are mated to conspecific and heterospecific females, we do not observe a significant correlation at the level of the family mean between the intraspecific and interspecific phenotypes, suggesting the independence of the hybrid traits from comparable traits within species. We discuss our findings in relation to the evolutionary genetics of speciation and the expression of epistatic genetic variance in interspecific crosses.     

Adolescence and the Reversibility of Maturity in Euplotes crassus

ABSTRACT. The clonal life history of ciliated protists is characterized by a sequence of phenotypes; sexual immaturity, maturity, and senescence. The distinctiveness of immaturity and maturity has been investigated. Standard assays of the onset of maturity of progeny clones from a cross between stocks EC1 and EC2 of Euplotes crassus demonstrated significant differences among clones and among testers within clones. They also revealed that the first positive test(s) of a progeny subclone were typically followed by at least one negative test. Special protocols were devised to investigate if maturity was reversible at the cellular level. In these experiments, the first mating pair of a progeny subclone was split before the consummation of mating. From these two cells as well as from control progeny and tester cells, subclones were established and every leftover cell was tested for maturity after each transfer. Both standard and split-pair progeny subclones had immature and slow- to-mate cells. The number of fissions before progeny exhibited sexual behavior indistinguishable from the testers was more than twice that to the first mating reaction of a subclone. At the first sign of maturity, progeny lines are a heterogeneous population of cells able and not able to mate, but remarkably, clonal descendants of those able to mate may become unable to mate. The development of maturity is progressive, quantitative and non-monotonic rather than an instantaneous switch.     

Spontaneous Selfing (Intraclonal Conjugation) in the Ciliate Euplotes patella Syngen 2 Takes Place without a Change in Mating Type Expression

ABSTRACT. Cells of Euplotes patella syngen 2 have been found to excrete mating-type-specific gamones (mating-inducing factors) into the surrounding medium. In strains of E. patella syngen 2, intraclonal conjugation (selfing) sometimes occurred spontaneously. Cell-free fluids of clonal cultures in which spontaneous selfing occurred were not effective in inducing homotypic pair formation in other cultures of the same mating type as the culture from which the cell-free fluids were derived. This indicates that selfing cultures produce only those gamones expected of their own mating types. This result suggests that spontaneous selling in E. patella syngen 2 is not due to change of mating type expression. The possible mechanisms for spontaneous selfing in E. patella syngen 2 are discussed.     

RAPD Evidence for Apomixis and Clonal Populations in Eriotheca (Bombacaceae)

Abstract: Two woody species of Eriotheca (Bombacaceae) of the Central Brazilian Cerrados were submitted to RAPD analyses. Both species are bee pollinated and have a similar flower structure, but E. pubescens presents adventitious embryony and apomixis, while E. gracilipes is self-incompatible. The RAPD screening reflects these differences in breeding systems, with very low genetic variation in the apomictic species, while the sexual species presented much higher variability with no similar genotypes among the sampled trees. The results suggest that adventitious embryony in E. pubescens effectively results in clonal populations or population mosaics of clonal individuals. Since recent studies have indicated poly-embryony and possibly apomixis in a number of Cerrado woody species otherwise considered obligatorily allogamous, the RAPD results presented here indicate the technique will be a useful tool to detect clonal populations of apomictic origin among Cerrado woody species with mixed mating systems and will help to assess the importance of apomixis as a breeding system for the Cerrado flora.     

An Integrated Study of the Species Problem in the Euplotes crassus-minuta-vannus Group1

ABSTRACT. In an attempt to solve the ambiguity in the taxonomy of the Euplotes crassus, minuta, and vannus group, 19 strains were tested for mating interactions, electrophoresed for isozymic variations, and analyzed by multivariate morphometrics of the conventional diagnostic traits. The overall results supported the validity of the three named species. Inter-specific mating occurred only in a few crassus x vannus strain combinations and was usually inviable. Isozymic variations, in particular of amylases, malic enzyme, and malic dehydrogenase, were very restricted within conspecific strains and were great between non-conspecifics. The species ascertainment of the strains was possible on the basis of clustering and principal component analyses of morphological measures.     

Development of microsatellite primers of the largest seagrass, Enhalus acoroides (Hydrocharitaceae)

? Premise of the study: Microsatellite primers were developed for the seagrass Enhalus acoroides to investigate genetic variation and identify clonal structure. ? Methods and Results: Four polymorphic loci and 32 monomorphic loci were developed in E. acoroides. Two to four alleles per locus were observed at the polymorphic loci across 60 individuals of two E. acoroides populations. The observed and expected heterozygosities within populations ranged from 0.100 to 0.5667 and from 0.0977 to 0.5079, respectively. ? Conclusions: Our study revealed very low polymorphism in E. acoroides, even at the polymorphic loci. Nevertheless, these primers are a useful tool to study genetic variation, clonal structure, and mating system.     

Genetic characterization and use of a restriction fragment length variant in the hypotrichous ciliate Euplotes crassus

Two forms of a macronuclear DNA molecule differing in the presence or absence of a restriction endonuclease recognition site have been detected in the hypotrichous ciliate Euplotes crassus. Through a series of genetic crosses the two forms were shown to be allelic, being derived from a single micronuclear genetic locus. This restriction fragment length variant (RFLV) was used as a genetic marker to determine that the migratory and stationary pronuclei generated during mating can be genetically non-identical. In addition, the RFLV was used to investigate the efficiency of processing of the alternate alleles during macronuclear development and their subsequent transmission during vegetative growth. Little or no bias in the processing and/or amplification of the two alleles was observed during macronuclear development. During vegetative growth, however, changes in the relative amounts of the two alleles were observed.