Fe-S clusters, fragile sentinels of the cell

Iron-sulfur (Fe-S) clusters are ubiquitous cofactors present in a myriad of proteins controlling processes as diverse as DNA replication, photosynthesis, respiration and gene regulation. Their assembly and delivery into apo-proteins are catalysed by different multi-protein systems conserved throughout prokaryotes and eukaryotes. Because so many cellular processes are dependent upon Fe-S proteins, alteration of the Fe-S clusters or of the systems that make them has profound impact on cellular physiology. The present review aims at covering and discussing those situations wherein these highly efficient redox sensitive cofactors turn from faithful sentinels into enfeebled assistants or, worse, into dangerous insiders.     

Thermodynamic influences on the fidelity of iron-sulphur cluster formation in proteins.

In an organism, two thermodynamic factors are important in ensuring that homometallic [4Fe-4S] cubane clusters are formed in preference to clusters containing heterometals such as Zn or Cu. These are the electronic resonance stabilisation, which boosts the binding of Fe(II) within an Fe-S cluster relative to its normally low position in the Irving-Williams order, and attenuation of the cytoplasmic concentrations of competing metals such as Zn or Cu by specific ligands.     

X-ray absorption spectroscopy of the [2Fe-2S] Rieske cluster in Pseudomonas cepacia phthalate dioxygenase. Determination of core dimensions and iron ligation

We have employed X-ray absorption spectroscopy to obtain structural information about the Rieske Fe/S center in the phthalate dioxygenase (PDO) from Pseudomonas cepacia. Native PDO contains a dinuclear Rieske Fe/S center and an additional mononuclear Fe site. In order to study selectively the Fe/S cluster, we measured data for samples in which the mononuclear site was either depleted of metal or reconstituted with Co or Zn. Our results demonstrate that the iron environment in the Rieske cluster is structurally indistinguishable from that found in other Fe/S clusters, thus strongly supporting the suggestion that the unusually high reduction potentials for Rieske clusters are due to electrostatic rather than structural effects. The average Fe-Fe distance is 2.68 (3) A for both oxidized and reduced Rieske clusters. The average Fe-S distance is 2.24 (2) A in the oxidized cluster and 2.28 (2) A in the reduced cluster. Careful analysis of the EXAFS Debye-Waller factors suggests that the bridging and terminal Fe-S distances for the oxidized cluster are 2.20 and 2.31 A, respectively. Taken together with recent ENDOR results, these studies provide a detailed structural model for the Rieske [2Fe-2S] centers.     

A vertebrate-type ferredoxin domain in the Na+-translocating NADH dehydrogenase from Vibrio cholerae

The Na(+)-translocating NADH:quinone oxidoreductase from Vibrio cholerae contains a single Fe-S cluster localized in subunit NqrF. Here we study the electronic properties of the Fe-S center in a truncated version of the NqrF subunit comprising only its ferredoxin-like Fe-S domain. M?ssbauer spectroscopy of the Fe-S domain in the oxidized state is consistent with a binuclear Fe-S cluster with tetrahedral sulfur coordination by the cysteine residues Cys(70), Cys(76), Cys(79), and Cys(111). Important sequence motifs surrounding these cysteines are conserved in the Fe-S domain and in vertebrate-type ferredoxins. The magnetic circular dichroism spectra of the photochemically reduced Fe-S domain exhibit a striking similarity to the magnetic circular dichroism spectra of vertebrate-type ferredoxins required for the in vivo assembly of iron-sulfur clusters. This study reveals a novel function for vertebrate-type [2Fe-2S] clusters as redox cofactors in respiratory dehydrogenases.     

SufE transfers sulfur from SufS to SufB for iron-sulfur cluster assembly

Iron-sulfur (Fe-S) clusters are key metal cofactors of metabolic, regulatory, and stress response proteins in most organisms. The unique properties of these clusters make them susceptible to disruption by iron starvation or oxidative stress. Both iron and sulfur can be perturbed under stress conditions, leading to Fe-S cluster defects. Bacteria and higher plants contain a specialized system for Fe-S cluster biosynthesis under stress, namely the Suf pathway. In Escherichia coli the Suf pathway consists of six proteins with functions that are only partially characterized. Here we describe how the SufS and SufE proteins interact with the SufBCD protein complex to facilitate sulfur liberation from cysteine and donation for Fe-S cluster assembly. It was previously shown that the cysteine desulfurase SufS donates sulfur to the sulfur transfer protein SufE. We have found here that SufE in turn interacts with the SufB protein for sulfur transfer to that protein. The interaction occurs only if SufC is present. Furthermore, SufB can act as a site for Fe-S cluster assembly in the Suf system. This provides the first evidence of a novel site for Fe-S cluster assembly in the SufBCD complex.     

The Mammalian Proteins MMS19, MIP18, and ANT2 Are Involved in Cytoplasmic Iron-Sulfur Cluster Protein Assembly

Iron-sulfur (Fe-S) clusters are essential cofactors of proteins with a wide range of biological functions. A dedicated cytosolic Fe-S cluster assembly (CIA) system is required to assemble Fe-S clusters into cytosolic and nuclear proteins. Here, we show that the mammalian nucleotide excision repair protein homolog MMS19 can simultaneously bind probable cytosolic iron-sulfur protein assembly protein CIAO1 and Fe-S proteins, confirming that MMS19 is a central protein of the CIA machinery that brings Fe-S cluster donor proteins and the receiving apoproteins into proximity. In addition, we show that mitotic spindle-associated MMXD complex subunit MIP18 also interacts with both CIAO1 and Fe-S proteins. Specifically, it binds the Fe-S cluster coordinating regions in Fe-S proteins. Furthermore, we show that ADP/ATP translocase 2 (ANT2) interacts with Fe-S apoproteins and MMS19 in the CIA complex but not with the individual proteins. Together, these results elucidate the composition and interactions within the late CIA complex.     

Distinct iron-sulfur cluster assembly complexes exist in the cytosol and mitochondria of human cells

Iron-sulfur (Fe-S) clusters are cofactors found in many proteins that have important redox, catalytic or regulatory functions. In mammalian cells, almost all known Fe-S proteins are found in the mitochondria, but at least one is found in the cytosol. Here we report cloning of the human homologs to IscU and NifU, iron-binding proteins that play a critical role in Fe-S cluster assembly in bacteria. In human cells, alternative splicing of a common pre-mRNA results in synthesis of two proteins that differ at the N-terminus and localize either to the cytosol (IscU1) or to the mitochondria (IscU2). Biochemical analyses demonstrate that IscU proteins specifically associate with IscS, a cysteine desulfurase that is proposed to sequester inorganic sulfur for Fe-S cluster assembly. Protein complexes containing IscU and IscS can be found in the mitochondria as well as in the cytosol, implying that Fe-S cluster assembly takes place in multiple subcellular compartments in mammalian cells. The possible roles of the IscU proteins in mammalian cells and the potential implications of compartmentalization of Fe-S cluster assembly are discussed.     

光谱技术研究固氮酶铁硫簇的理化特性

Ｎ－甲基甲酰胺碱度是提取高质量固氮酶铁钼辅基的关键因素之一。过量的亚甲蓝能氧化并分解铁铜铺基为含双相铁硫簇和铁硫簇固氮酶铁钼辅基和在紫外可见光谱区中均无特征吸收峰,而在３２０ｎｍ处却呈弱吸收峰,棕色固氮菌固氮酶和该菌的突变菌侏ＵＷ４５固氮酶（缺铁钼辅基）中的非含钼的铁硫簇在紫外可见光谱区３２０ｎｍ和４０５ｎｍ处均含有特征吸收峰．     

NifS-mediated assembly of [4Fe-4S] clusters in the N- and C-terminal domains of the NifU scaffold protein

NifU is a homodimeric modular protein comprising N- and C-terminal domains and a central domain with a redox-active [2Fe-2S](2+,+) cluster. It plays a crucial role as a scaffold protein for the assembly of the Fe-S clusters required for the maturation of nif-specific Fe-S proteins. In this work, the time course and products of in vitro NifS-mediated iron-sulfur cluster assembly on full-length NifU and truncated forms involving only the N-terminal domain or the central and C-terminal domains have been investigated using UV-vis absorption and M?ssbauer spectroscopies, coupled with analytical studies. The results demonstrate sequential assembly of labile [2Fe-2S](2+) and [4Fe-4S](2+) clusters in the U-type N-terminal scaffolding domain and the assembly of [4Fe-4S](2+) clusters in the Nfu-type C-terminal scaffolding domain. Both scaffolding domains of NifU are shown to be competent for in vitro maturation of nitrogenase component proteins, as evidenced by rapid transfer of [4Fe-4S](2+) clusters preassembled on either the N- or C-terminal domains to the apo nitrogenase Fe protein. Mutagenesis studies indicate that a conserved aspartate (Asp37) plays a critical role in mediating cluster transfer. The assembly and transfer of clusters on NifU are compared with results reported for U- and Nfu-type scaffold proteins, and the need for two functional Fe-S cluster scaffolding domains on NifU is discussed.     

Identification of Iron-Sulfur (Fe-S) Cluster and Zinc (Zn) Binding Sites Within Proteomes Predicted by DeepMind’s AlphaFold2 Program Dramatically Expands the Metalloproteome

DeepMind’s AlphaFold2 software has ushered in a revolution in high quality, 3D protein structure prediction. In very recent work by the DeepMind team, structure predictions have been made for entire proteomes of twenty-one organisms, with >360,000 structures made available for download. Here we show that thousands of novel binding sites for iron-sulfur (Fe-S) clusters and zinc (Zn) ions can be identified within these predicted structures by exhaustive enumeration of all potential ligand-binding orientations. We demonstrate that AlphaFold2 routinely makes highly specific predictions of ligand binding sites: for example, binding sites that are comprised exclusively of four cysteine sidechains fall into three clusters, representing binding sites for 4Fe-4S clusters, 2Fe-2S clusters, or individual Zn ions. We show further: (a) that the majority of known Fe-S cluster and Zn binding sites documented in UniProt are recovered by the AlphaFold2 structures, (b) that there are occasional disputes between AlphaFold2 and UniProt with AlphaFold2 predicting highly plausible alternative binding sites, (c) that the Fe-S cluster binding sites that we identify in E. coli agree well with previous bioinformatics predictions, (d) that cysteines predicted here to be part of ligand binding sites show little overlap with those shown via chemoproteomics techniques to be highly reactive, and (e) that AlphaFold2 occasionally appears to build erroneous disulfide bonds between cysteines that should instead coordinate a ligand. These results suggest that AlphaFold2 could be an important tool for the functional annotation of proteomes, and the methodology presented here is likely to be useful for predicting other ligand-binding sites.     

The iron-sulphur protein Ind1 is required for effective complex I assembly

NADH:ubiquinone oxidoreductase (complex I) of the mitochondrial inner membrane is a multi-subunit protein complex containing eight iron-sulphur (Fe-S) clusters. Little is known about the assembly of complex I and its Fe-S clusters. Here, we report the identification of a mitochondrial protein with a nucleotide-binding domain, named Ind1, that is required specifically for the effective assembly of complex I. Deletion of the IND1 open reading frame in the yeast Yarrowia lipolytica carrying an internal alternative NADH dehydrogenase resulted in slower growth and strongly decreased complex I activity, whereas the activities of other mitochondrial Fe-S enzymes, including aconitase and succinate dehydrogenase, were not affected. Two-dimensional gel electrophoresis, in vitro activity tests and electron paramagnetic resonance signals of Fe-S clusters showed that only a minor fraction (approximately 20%) of complex I was assembled in the ind1 deletion mutant. Using in vivo and in vitro approaches, we found that Ind1 can bind a [4Fe-4S] cluster that was readily transferred to an acceptor Fe-S protein. Our data suggest that Ind1 facilitates the assembly of Fe-S cofactors and subunits of complex I.     

Mitochondrial NADH kinase, Pos5p, is required for efficient iron-sulfur cluster biogenesis in Saccharomyces cerevisiae

In Saccharomyces cerevisiae, the mitochondrial inner membrane readily allows transport of cytosolic NAD(+), but not NADPH, to the matrix. Pos5p is the only known NADH kinase in the mitochondrial matrix. The enzyme phosphorylates NADH to NADPH and is the major source of NADPH in the matrix. The importance of mitochondrial NADPH for cellular physiology is underscored by the phenotypes of the Δpos5 mutant, characterized by oxidative stress sensitivity and iron-sulfur (Fe-S) cluster deficiency. Fe-S clusters are essential cofactors of proteins such as aconitase [4Fe-4S] and ferredoxin [2Fe-2S] in mitochondria. Intact mitochondria isolated from wild-type yeast can synthesize these clusters and insert them into the corresponding apoproteins. Here, we show that this process of Fe-S cluster biogenesis in wild-type mitochondria is greatly stimulated and kinetically favored by the addition of NAD(+) or NADH in a dose-dependent manner, probably via transport into mitochondria and subsequent conversion into NADPH. Unlike wild-type mitochondria, Δpos5 mitochondria cannot efficiently synthesize Fe-S clusters on endogenous aconitase or imported ferredoxin, although cluster biogenesis in isolated Δpos5 mitochondria is restored to a significant extent by a small amount of imported Pos5p. Interestingly, Fe-S cluster biogenesis in wild-type mitochondria is further enhanced by overexpression of Pos5p. The effects of Pos5p on Fe-S cluster generation in mitochondria indicate that one or more steps in the biosynthetic process require NADPH. The role of mitochondrial NADPH in Fe-S cluster biogenesis appears to be distinct from its function in anti-oxidant defense.     

The Fe-only nitrogenase from Rhodobacter capsulatus: identification of the cofactor, an unusual, high-nuclearity iron-sulfur cluster, by Fe K-edge EXAFS and 57Fe Mössbauer spectroscopy

Samples of the dithionite-reduced FeFe protein (the dinitrogenase component of the Fe-only nitrogenase) from Rhodobacter capsulatus have been investigated by 57Fe M?ssbauer spectroscopy and by Fe and Zn EXAFS as well as XANES spectroscopy. The analyses were performed on the basis of data known for the FeMo cofactor and the P cluster of Mo nitrogenases. The prominent Fourier transform peaks of the Fe K-edge spectrum are assigned to Fe-S and Fe-Fe interactions at distances of 2.29 A and 2.63 A, respectively. A significant contribution to the Fe EXAFS must be assigned to an Fe backscatterer shell at 3.68 A, which is an unprecedented feature of the trigonal prismatic arrangement of iron atoms found in the FeMo cofactor of nitrogenase MoFe protein crystal structures. Additional Fe...Fe interactions at 2.92 A and 4.05 A clearly indicate that the principal geometry of the P cluster is also conserved. M?ssbauer spectra of 57Fe-enriched FeFe protein preparations were recorded at 77 K (20 mT) and 4.2 K (20 mT, 6.2 T), whereby the 4.2 K high-field spectrum clearly demonstrates that the cofactor of the Fe-only nitrogenase (FeFe cofactor) is diamagnetic in the dithionite-reduced ("as isolated") state. The evaluation of the 77 K spectrum is in agreement with the assumption that this cofactor contains eight Fe atoms. In the literature, several genetic and biochemical lines of evidence are presented pointing to a significant structural similarity of the FeFe, the FeMo and and the FeV cofactors. The data reported here provide the first spectroscopic evidence for a structural homology of the FeFe cofactor to the heterometal-containing cofactors, thus substantiating that the FeFe cofactor is the largest iron-sulfur cluster so far found in nature.     

Global Identification of Genes Affecting Iron-Sulfur Cluster Biogenesis and Iron Homeostasis

Iron-sulfur (Fe-S) clusters are ubiquitous cofactors that are crucial for many physiological processes in all organisms. In Escherichia coli, assembly of Fe-S clusters depends on the activity of the iron-sulfur cluster (ISC) assembly and sulfur mobilization (SUF) apparatus. However, the underlying molecular mechanisms and the mechanisms that control Fe-S cluster biogenesis and iron homeostasis are still poorly defined. In this study, we performed a global screen to identify the factors affecting Fe-S cluster biogenesis and iron homeostasis using the Keio collection, which is a library of 3,815 single-gene E. coli knockout mutants. The approach was based on radiolabeling of the cells with [2-¹⁴C]dihydrouracil, which entirely depends on the activity of an Fe-S enzyme, dihydropyrimidine dehydrogenase. We identified 49 genes affecting Fe-S cluster biogenesis and/or iron homeostasis, including 23 genes important only under microaerobic/anaerobic conditions. This study defines key proteins associated with Fe-S cluster biogenesis and iron homeostasis, which will aid further understanding of the cellular mechanisms that coordinate the processes. In addition, we applied the [2-¹⁴C]dihydrouracil-labeling method to analyze the role of amino acid residues of an Fe-S cluster assembly scaffold (IscU) as a model of the Fe-S cluster assembly apparatus. The analysis showed that Cys37, Cys63, His105, and Cys106 are essential for the function of IscU in vivo, demonstrating the potential of the method to investigate in vivo function of proteins involved in Fe-S cluster assembly.     

Computational studies of modified [Fe3S4] clusters: why iron is optimal

This work reports density functional computations of metal-substituted models of biological [Fe3S4] clusters in oxidation states [MFe2S4](+/0/-1) (M=Mn, Fe, Co, Ni, Cu, Zn, and Mo). Geometry optimization with a dielectric screening model is shown to provide a substantial improvement in structure, compared to earlier used standard procedures. The error for average Fe-S bonds decreased from 0.038A to 0.016A with this procedure. Four density functionals were compared, B3LYP, BP86, TPSS, and TPSSh. B3LYP and to a lesser extent TPSSh energies were inconsistent with experiment for the oxidized [Fe3S4]+ cluster. BP86 (and to a slightly lesser extent TPSS) was within expected theoretical and experimental uncertainties for all oxidation states, the only qualitative error being 5kJ/mol in favor of the M(S)=3/2 configuration for the [Fe3S4]+ cluster, so BP86 was used for quantitative results. Computed reorganization energies and reduction potentials point directly towards the [Fe3S4] cluster as the superior choice of electron carrier, with the [ZnFe2S4] cluster a close second. In addition, partially and fully Mo-substituted clusters were investigated and found to have very low reorganization energies but too negative reduction potentials. The results provide a direct rationale why any substitution weakens the cluster as an electron carrier, and thus why the [Fe3S4] composition is optimal in the biological clusters.     

Biogenesis of iron-sulfur clusters in mammalian cells: new insights and relevance to human disease

Iron-sulfur (Fe-S) clusters are ubiquitous cofactors composed of iron and inorganic sulfur. They are required for the function of proteins involved in a wide range of activities, including electron transport in respiratory chain complexes, regulatory sensing, photosynthesis and DNA repair. The proteins involved in the biogenesis of Fe-S clusters are evolutionarily conserved from bacteria to humans, and many insights into the process of Fe-S cluster biogenesis have come from studies of model organisms, including bacteria, fungi and plants. It is now clear that several rare and seemingly dissimilar human diseases are attributable to defects in the basic process of Fe-S cluster biogenesis. Although these diseases –which include Friedreich’s ataxia (FRDA), ISCU myopathy, a rare form of sideroblastic anemia, an encephalomyopathy caused by dysfunction of respiratory chain complex I and multiple mitochondrial dysfunctions syndrome – affect different tissues, a feature common to many of them is that mitochondrial iron overload develops as a secondary consequence of a defect in Fe-S cluster biogenesis. This Commentary outlines the basic steps of Fe-S cluster biogenesis as they have been defined in model organisms. In addition, it draws attention to refinements of the process that might be specific to the subcellular compartmentalization of Fe-S cluster biogenesis proteins in some eukaryotes, including mammals. Finally, it outlines several important unresolved questions in the field that, once addressed, should offer important clues into how mitochondrial iron homeostasis is regulated, and how dysfunction in Fe-S cluster biogenesis can contribute to disease.     

Iron-sulfur cluster biosynthesis: characterization of Escherichia coli CYaY as an iron donor for the assembly of [2Fe-2S] clusters in the scaffold IscU

The biogenesis of iron-sulfur [Fe-S] clusters requires the coordinated delivery of both iron and sulfide. Sulfide is provided by cysteine desulfurases that use L-cysteine as sulfur source. So far, the physiological iron donor has not been clearly identified. CyaY, the bacterial ortholog of frataxin, an iron binding protein thought to be involved in iron-sulfur cluster formation in eukaryotes, is a good candidate because it was shown to bind iron. Nevertheless, no functional in vitro studies showing an involvement of CyaY in [Fe-S] cluster biosynthesis have been reported so far. In this paper we demonstrate for the first time a specific interaction between CyaY and IscS, a cysteine desulfurase participating in iron-sulfur cluster assembly. Analysis of the iron-loaded CyaY protein demonstrated a strong binding of Fe(3+) and a weak binding of Fe(2+) by CyaY. Biochemical analysis showed that the CyaY-Fe(3+) protein corresponds to a mixture of monomer, intermediate forms (dimer-pentamers), and oligomers with the intermediate one corresponding to the only stable and soluble iron-containing form of CyaY. Using spectroscopic methods, this form was further demonstrated to be functional in vitro as an iron donor during [Fe-S] cluster assembly on the scaffold protein IscU in the presence of IscS and cysteine. All of these results point toward a link between CyaY and [Fe-S] cluster biosynthesis, and a possible mechanism for the process is discussed.     

The prosthetic groups of succinate dehydrogenase: 30 years from discovery to identification

Recent studies using magnetic circular dichroism at cryogenic temperatures, electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) and linear electric field effect-EPR (LEFE) of succinate dehydrogenase in membranes and in soluble, homogeneous preparations demonstrated the presence of 3 different Fe-S clusters in the mammalian enzyme, as well as in a similar bacterial enzyme, fumarate reductase from Escherichia coli. There is one each of the 2Fe, 3Fe, and 4Fe clusters. Thus, succinate dehydrogenase is the first enzyme which has been shown to contain all 3 of these Fe-S clusters. The enzyme also contains 1 mol 8-[N(3)-histidyl]-FAD. It has taken the combined expertise of many laboratories and 15 years of effort to identify the flavin component, and nearly 3 decades to identify the Fe-S clusters. The data from physical methods appear to be internally consistent, in harmony with the results of chemical analysis, and provide a rational explanation for earlier results by the cluster extrusion method. There remains, however, a number of interesting and substantive questions for future investigations. This review traces the tortuous path, the many pitfalls and false leads, which have led us from the discovery of nonheme iron and ‘bound’ flavin in the enzyme to elucidation of their structures.     

Iron-sulfur cluster biogenesis in chloroplasts. Involvement of the scaffold protein CpIscA

The chloroplast contains many iron (Fe)-sulfur (S) proteins for the processes of photosynthesis and nitrogen and S assimilation. Although isolated chloroplasts are known to be able to synthesize their own Fe-S clusters, the machinery involved is largely unknown. Recently, a cysteine desulfurase was reported in Arabidopsis (Arabidopsis thaliana; AtCpNifS) that likely provides the S for Fe-S clusters. Here, we describe an additional putative component of the plastid Fe-S cluster assembly machinery in Arabidopsis: CpIscA, which has homology to bacterial IscA and SufA proteins that have a scaffold function during Fe-S cluster formation. CpIscA mRNA was shown to be expressed in all tissues tested, with higher expression level in green, photosynthetic tissues. The plastid localization of CpIscA was confirmed by green fluorescent protein fusions, in vitro import, and immunoblotting experiments. CpIscA was cloned and purified after expression in Escherichia coli. Addition of CpIscA significantly enhanced CpNifS-mediated in vitro reconstitution of the 2Fe-2S cluster in apo-ferredoxin. During incubation with CpNifS in a reconstitution mix, CpIscA was shown to acquire a transient Fe-S cluster. The Fe-S cluster could subsequently be transferred by CpIscA to apo-ferredoxin. We propose that the CpIscA protein serves as a scaffold in chloroplast Fe-S cluster assembly.