Laboratory evaluation of a two-stage treatment system for TCE cometabolism by a methane-oxidizing mixed culture

The objective of this research was to evaluate several factors affecting the performance of a two-stage treatment system employing methane-oxidizing bacteria for trichloroethylene (TCE) biodegradation. The system consists of a completely mixed growth reactor and a plug-flow transformation reactor in which the TCE is cometabolized. Laboratory studies were conducted with continuous growth reactors and batch experiments simulating transformation reactor conditions. Performance was characterized in terms of TCE transformation capacity (T(C), g TCE/g cells), transformation yield (T(Y), g TCE/g CH(4)), and the rate coefficient ratio k(TCE)/K(S,TCE) (L/mg-d). The growth reactor variables studied were solids retention time (SRT) and nutrient nitrogen (N) concentration. Formate and methane were evaluated as potential transformation reactor amendments. Comparison of cultures from 2- and 8-day SRT (nitrogen-limited) growth reactors indicated that there was no significant effect of growth reactor SRT or nitrogen availability on T(C) or T(Y), but N-limited conditions yielded higher k(TCE)/K(S,TCE). The TCE cometabolic activity of the 8-day SRT, N-limited growth reactor culture varied significantly during a 7-year period of operation. The T(C) and T(Y) of the resting cells increased gradually to levels a factor of 2 higher than the initial values. The reasons for this increase are unknown. Formate addition to the transformation reactor gave higher T(C) and T(Y) for 2-day SRT growth reactor conditions and significantly lower T(C), T(Y), and k(TCE)/K(S,TCE) for 8-day SRT N-limited conditions. Methane addition to the transformation reactor inhibited TCE cometabolism at low TCE concentrations and enhanced TCE cometabolism at high TCE concentrations, indicating that the TCE cometabolism in the presence of methane does not follow simple competitive inhibition kinetics. (c) 1997 John Wiley & Sons, Inc. Biotechnol Bioeng 55: 650-659, 1997.     

Effects of toxicity, aeration, and reductant supply on trichloroethylene transformation by a mixed methanotrophic culture

The trichloroethylene (TCE) transformation rate and capacity of a mixed methanotrophic culture at room temperature were measured to determine the effects of time without methane (resting), use of an alternative energy source (formate), aeration, and toxicity of TCE and its transformation products. The initial specific TCE transformation rate of resting cells was 0.6 mg of TCE per mg of cells per day, and they had a finite TCE transformation capacity of 0.036 mg of TCE per mg of cells. Formate addition resulted in increased initial specific TCE transformation rates (2.1 mg/mg of cells per day) and elevated transformation capacity (0.073 mg of TCE per mg of cells). Significant declines in methane conversion rates following exposure to TCE were observed for both resting and formate-fed cells, suggesting toxic effects caused by TCE or its transformation products. TCE transformation and methane consumption rates of resting cells decreased with time much more rapidly when cells were shaken and aerated than when they remained dormant, suggesting that the transformation ability of methanotrophs is best preserved by storage under anoxic conditions.     

Numerical modeling and uncertainties in rate coefficients for methane utilization and TCE cometabolism by a methane-oxidizing mixed culture

The rates of methane utilization and trichloroethylene (TCE) cometabolism by a methanotrophic mixed culture were characterized in batch and pseudo-steady-state studies. Procedures for determination of the rate coefficients and their uncertainties by fitting a numerical model to experimental data are described. The model consisted of a system of differential equations for the rates of Monod kinetics, cell growth on methane and inactivation due to TCE transformation product toxicity, gas/liquid mass transfer of methane and TCE, and the rate of passive losses of TCE. The maximum specific rate of methane utilization (k(CH(4) )) was determined by fitting the numerical model to batch experimental data, with the initial concentration of active methane-oxidizing cells (X(0) (a)) also used as a model fitting parameter. The best estimate of k(CH(4) ) was 2.2 g CH(4)/g cells-d with excess copper available, with a single-parameter 95% confidence interval of 2.0-2.4 mg/mg-d. The joint 95% confidence region for k(CH(4) ) and X(0) (a) is presented graphically. The half-velocity coefficient (K(S,CH(4) )) was 0.07 mg CH(4)/L with excess copper available and 0.47 mg CH(4)/L under copper limitation, with 95% confidence intervals of 0.02-0.11 and 0.35-0.59 mg/L, respectively. Unique values of the TCE rate coefficients k(TCE) and K(S,TCE) could not be determined because they were found to be highly correlated in the model fitting analysis. However, the ratio k(TCE)/K(S,TCE) and the TCE transformation capacity (T(C)) were well defined, with values of 0.35 L/mg-day and 0.21 g TCE/g active cells, respectively, for cells transforming TCE in the absence of methane or supplemental formate. The single-parameter 95% confidence intervals for k(TCE)/K(S,TCE) and T(C) were 0.27-0.43 L/mg-d and 0.18-0.24 g TCE/g active cells, respectively. The joint 95% confidence regions for k(TCE)/K(S,TCE) and T(C) are presented graphically. (c) 1997 John Wiley & Sons, Inc. Biotechnol Bioeng 53: 320-331, 1997.     

Transformation yields of chlorinated ethenes by a methanotrophic mixed culture expressing particulate methane monooxygenase.

Transformation yields for the aerobic cometabolic degradation of five chlorinated ethenes were determined by using a methanotrophic mixed culture expressing particulate methane monooxygenase (pMMO). Transformation yields (expressed as moles of chlorinated ethene degraded per mole of methane consumed) were 0.57, 0.25, 0.058, 0.0019, and 0.00022 for trans-1,2-dichloroethylene (t-DCE), vinyl chloride (VC), cis-1,2-dichloroethylene (c-DCE), trichloroethylene (TCE), and 1,1-dichloroethylene (1,1-DCE), respectively. Degradation of t-DCE and VC was observed only in the presence of formate or methane, sources of reducing energy necessary for cometabolism. The t-DCE and VC transformation yields represented 35 and 15%, respectively, of the theoretical maximum yields, based on reducing-energy availability from methane dissimilation to carbon dioxide, exclusive of all other processes that require reducing energy. The yields for t-DCE and VC were 20 times greater than the yields reported by others for cells expressing soluble methane monooxygenase (sMMO). Transformation yields for c-DCE, TCE, and 1,1-DCE were similar to or less than those for cultures expressing sMMO. Although methanotrophic biotreatment systems have typically been designed to incorporate cultures expressing sMMO, these results suggest that pMMO expression may be highly advantageous for degradation of t-DCE or VC. It may also be much easier to maintain pMMO expression in treatment systems, because pMMO is expressed by all methanotrophs whereas sMMO is expressed only by type II methanotrophs under copper-limited conditions.     

Effects of toxicity, aeration, and reductant supply on trichloroethylene transformation by a mixed methanotrophic culture.

The trichloroethylene (TCE) transformation rate and capacity of a mixed methanotrophic culture at room temperature were measured to determine the effects of time without methane (resting), use of an alternative energy source (formate), aeration, and toxicity of TCE and its transformation products. The initial specific TCE transformation rate of resting cells was 0.6 mg of TCE per mg of cells per day, and they had a finite TCE transformation capacity of 0.036 mg of TCE per mg of cells. Formate addition resulted in increased initial specific TCE transformation rates (2.1 mg/mg of cells per day) and elevated transformation capacity (0.073 mg of TCE per mg of cells). Significant declines in methane conversion rates following exposure to TCE were observed for both resting and formate-fed cells, suggesting toxic effects caused by TCE or its transformation products. TCE transformation and methane consumption rates of resting cells decreased with time much more rapidly when cells were shaken and aerated than when they remained dormant, suggesting that the transformation ability of methanotrophs is best preserved by storage under anoxic conditions.     

Kinetic analysis of a tod-lux bacterial reporter for toluene degradation and trichloroethylene cometabolism

Kinetics of toluene and trichloroethylene (TCE) degradation and bioluminescence from the bioreporter Pseudomonas putida B2 and TVA8 were investigated utilizing batch and continuous culture, respectively. Degradation was modeled using a Michaelis-Menten expression for the competition of two substrates for a single enzyme system, and bioluminescence was modeled assuming a luciferase enzyme saturational dependence on toluene as the inducer and growth substrate. During the batch experiments, bioluminescence increased at approximately 90 namp/min for initial toluene concentrations of 10 to 50 mg/L, but more slowly at higher toluene concentrations, suggesting maximum promoter induction at below 10 mg/L and toxic effects above 50 mg/L toluene. TCE degradation did not occur until toluene depletion, presumably due to competition between toluene and TCE for the toluene dioxygenase enzyme. During continuous culture, bioluminescence transiently increased, then gradually decreased in response to increasing step changes in toluene feed concentration. Bioluminescence in the CSTR appeared to be limited by growth substrate and/or inducer.     

Effects of copper on expression of methane monooxygenases,trichloroethylene degradation,and community structure in methanotrophic consortia

Copper plays a key role in regulating the expression of enzymes that promote biodegradation of contaminants in methanotrophic consortia (MC). Here, we utilized MC isolated from landfill cover to investigate cometabolic degradation of trichloroethylene (TCE) at nine different copper (Cu²⁺) concentrations. The results demonstrated that an increase in Cu²⁺ concentration from 0 to 15 μM altered the specific first‐order rate constant k_1,TCE, the expression levels of methane monooxygenase (pmoA and mmoX) genes, and the specific activity of soluble methane monooxygenase (sMMO). High efficiency TCE degradation (95%) and the expression levels of methane monooxygenase (MMO) were detected at a Cu²⁺ concentration of 0.03 μM. Notably, sMMO‐specific activity ranged from 74.41 nmol/(mg_cell h) in 15 μM Cu²⁺ to 654.99 nmol/(mg_cell h) in 0.03 μM Cu²⁺, which contrasts with cultures of pure methanotrophs in which sMMO activity is depressed at high Cu²⁺ concentrations, indicating a special regulatory role for Cu²⁺ in MC. The results of MiSeq pyrosequencing indicated that higher Cu²⁺ concentrations stimulated the growth of methanotrophic microorganisms in MC. These findings have important implications for the elucidation of copper‐mediated regulatory mechanisms in MC.     

Simultaneous nitrification and denitrification in a mixed methanotrophic culture

Simultaneous nitrification and denitrification using a mixed methanotrophic culture was investigated. When both NO₃ ^–-N (108 mg l^–1) and NH₃-N (59 mg l^–1) were added into batch reactors, nitrate removal was complete within 10 h at the rate of 47 mg NO₃ ^–-N g VSS^–1 day^–1 when dissolved oxygen (DO) concentration was maintained at 2 mg DO l^–1. Ammonia removal started simultaneously with nitrate removal at a slower rate of 14 NH₃-N g VSS^–1 day^–1. No significant accumulation of nitrite or nitrate during ammonia utilization suggested the occurrence of simultaneous nitrification and denitrification.     

Effects of nutrient dosing on subsurface methanotrophic populations and trichloroethylene degradation

In in situ bioremediation demonstration at the Savannah River Site in Aiken, South Carolina, trichloroethylene-degrading microorganisms were stimulated by delivering nutrients to the TCE-contaminated subsurface via horizontal injection wells. Microbial and chemical monitoring of groundwater from 12 vertical wells was used to examine the effects of methane and nutrient (nitrogen and phosphorus) dosing on the methanotrophic populations and on the potential of the subsurface microbial communities to degrade TCE. Densities of methanotrophs increased 3–5 orders of magnitude during the methane- and nutrient-injection phases; this increase coincided with the higher methane levels observed in the monitoring wells. TCE degradation capacity, although not directly tied to methane concentration, responded to the methane injection, and responded more dramatically to the multiple-nutrient injection. These results support the crucial role of methane, nitrogen, and phosphorus as amended nutrients in TCE bioremediation. The enhancing effects of nutrient dosing on microbial abundance and degradative potentials, coupled with increased chloride concentrations, provided multiple lines of evidence substantiating the effectiveness of this integrated in situ bioremediation process. Received 13 November 1995/ Accepted in revised form 12 September 1996     

Cellulose degradation by a mixed bacterial culture

Summary An integrated mixed bacterial culture consisting of four strains has been isolated by a batch enrichment technique. The cellulolytic member (strain D) is aCellulomonas sp. and the others are non-cellulolytic. The interaction between strains D and C is pronounced and appears to involve an exchange of reducing sugars and growth factors. The symbiotic relationship of this naturally occurring mixed culture is therefore one of mutualism. The filter paper cellulase and carboxymethyl cellulase activities in extracellular fluid are high, while -glucosidase activity is low. The mixed culture digests a variety of lignocellulosics efficiently and is of fundamental interest in the study of microbial interrelationships.     

Anaerobic degradation of cellulose by mixed culture

A mixed culture in which cellulose is capable of being converted to methane and carbon dioxide was obtained from an inoculum procured from a sewage-treatment plant and maintained in a synthetic medium containing tissue paper and an inorganic salt and vitamin mixture. The culture was tested for its ability to degrade 12 different paper and cotton products under batch conditions in 3-l anaerobic fermenters. This culture degraded 6-8 mmol/l per week of cellulose, expressed as glucose equivalents, with total gas yields of 0.3 m3/kg of cellulose degraded. The gas produced contained between 56 and 59% of methane. Maximum cellulose degradation occurred at chemical oxygen demand:nitrogen:phosphorus level of 80:5:1 and was adversely affected by high stirring rate. Also the presence of higher proportions of lignin in cellulose products adversely affected the ability of this culture to degrade cellulose.     

Sulfate reduction and anaerobic glycerol degradation by a mixed microbial culture

Anaerobic glycerol degradation by a mixed microbial culture from a fermenter fed with industrial alcohol distillation waste water, was investigated in the absence or presence of sulfate, at 37°C and at a constant pH of 7.2. In the absence of sulfate, glycerol utilization was found to be characterized by the transient formation of 1,3-propanediol prior to propionate and acetate accumulation. In the presence of sulfate, 1,3-propanediol production was minor, and the carbon balance reflected a considerable accumulation of intermediate(s). A study of the role of sulfate reduction and methanogenesis on anaerobic 1,3-propanediol degradation showed that consumption of this substrate by the mixed microbial culture required a terminal electron acceptor. The number of fermentative and sulfate-reducing bacteria with glycerol or 1,3-propanediol as carbon and energy source revealed that sulfate-reducing bacteria outcompete fermentative bacteria for these substrates. The possible ecological role of sulfate-reducing bacteria in the metabolism of these reduced substrates is discussed.     

Changes in soil microbial community composition induced by cometabolism of toluene and trichloroethylene

The effects of trichloroethylene (TCE) on microbial community composition were analyzed by reverse sample genome probing. Soil enrichments were incubated in dessicators containing an organic phase of either 1 or 10% (w/w) toluene in vacuum pump oil, delivering constant equilibrium aqueous concentrations of 16 and 143mg/l, respectively. Increasing the equilibrium aqueous concentration of TCE from 0 to 10mg/l led to shifts in community composition at 16, but not at 143mg/l of toluene. In closed system co-degradation studies, TCE at an aqueous concentration of 1mg/1 was effectively degraded by toluene-degrading soil enrichments once the aqueous toluene concentration dropped below 25mg/l. Little TCE degradation was observed at higher toluene concentrations (50–250mg/l). The results indicate that TCE changes microbial community composition under conditions where it is being actively metabolized.     

Influence of endogenous and exogenous electron donors and trichloroethylene oxidation toxicity on trichloroethylene oxidation by methanotrophic cultures from a groundwater aquifer

Trichloroethylene (TCE)-transforming aquifer methanotrophs were evaluated for the influence of TCE oxidation toxicity and the effect of reductant availability on TCE transformation rates during methane starvation. TCE oxidation at relatively low (6 mg liter-1) TCE concentrations significantly reduced subsequent methane utilization in mixed and pure cultures tested and reduced the number of viable cells in the pure culture Methylomonas sp. strain MM2 by an order of magnitude. Perchloroethylene, tested at the same concentration, had no effect on the cultures. Neither the TCE itself nor the aqueous intermediates were responsible for the toxic effect, and it is suggested that TCE oxidation toxicity may have resulted from reactive intermediates that attacked cellular macromolecules. During starvation, all methanotrophs tested exhibited a decline in TCE transformation rates, and this decline followed exponential decay. Formate, provided as an exogenous electron donor, increased TCE transformation rates in Methylomonas sp. strain MM2, but not in mixed culture MM1 or unidentified isolate, CSC-1. Mixed culture MM2 did not transform TCE after 15 h of starvation, but mixed cultures MM1 and MM3 did. The methanotrophs in mixed cultures MM1 and MM3, and the unidentified isolate CSC-1 that was isolated from mixed culture MM1 contained lipid inclusions, whereas the methanotrophs of mixed culture MM2 and Methylomonas sp. strain MM2 did not. It is proposed that lipid storage granules serve as an endogenous source of electrons for TCE oxidation during methane starvation.     

Kinetic and inhibition studies for the aerobic cometabolism of 1,1,1-trichloroethane, 1,1-dichloroethylene,and 1,1-dichloroethane by a butane-grown mixed culture

Batch kinetic and inhibition studies were performed for the aerobic cometabolism of 1,1,1-trichloroethane (1,1,1-TCA), 1,1-dichloroethylene (1,1-DCE), and 1,1-dichloroethane (1,1-DCA) by a butane-grown mixed culture. These chlorinated aliphatic hydrocarbons (CAHs) are often found together as cocontaminants in groundwater. The maximum degradation rates (k(max)) and half-saturation coefficients (K(s)) were determined in single compound kinetic tests. The highest k(max) was obtained for butane (2.6 micromol/mg TSS/h) followed by 1,1-DCE (1.3 micromol/mg TSS/h), 1,1-DCA (0.49 micromol/mg TSS/h), and 1,1,1-TCA (0.19 micromol/mg TSS/h), while the order of K(s) from the highest to lowest was 1,1-DCA (19 microM), butane (19 microM), 1,1,1-TCA (12 microM) and 1,1-DCE (1.5 microM). The inhibition types were determined using direct linear plots, while inhibition coefficients (K(ic) and K(iu)) were estimated by nonlinear least squares regression (NLSR) fits to the kinetic model of the identified inhibition type. Two different inhibition types were observed among the compounds. Competitive inhibition among CAHs was indicated from direct linear plots, and the CAHs also competitively inhibited butane utilization. 1,1-DCE was a stronger inhibitor than the other CAHs. Mixed inhibition of 1,1,1-TCA, 1,1-DCA, and 1,1-DCE transformations by butane was observed. Thus, both competitive and mixed inhibitions are important in cometabolism of CAHs by this butane culture. For competitive inhibition between CAHs, the ratio of the K(s) values was a reasonable indicator of competitive inhibition observed. Butane was a strong inhibitor of CAH transformation, having a much lower inhibition coefficient than the K(s) value of butane, while the CAHs were weak inhibitors of butane utilization. Model simulations of reactor systems where both the growth substrate and the CAHs are present indicate that reactor performance is significantly affected by inhibition type and inhibition coefficients. Thus, determining inhibition type and measuring inhibition coefficients is important in designing CAH treatment systems.     

Influence of endogenous and exogenous electron donors and trichloroethylene oxidation toxicity on trichloroethylene oxidation by methanotrophic cultures from a groundwater aquifer.

Trichloroethylene (TCE)-transforming aquifer methanotrophs were evaluated for the influence of TCE oxidation toxicity and the effect of reductant availability on TCE transformation rates during methane starvation. TCE oxidation at relatively low (6 mg liter-1) TCE concentrations significantly reduced subsequent methane utilization in mixed and pure cultures tested and reduced the number of viable cells in the pure culture Methylomonas sp. strain MM2 by an order of magnitude. Perchloroethylene, tested at the same concentration, had no effect on the cultures. Neither the TCE itself nor the aqueous intermediates were responsible for the toxic effect, and it is suggested that TCE oxidation toxicity may have resulted from reactive intermediates that attacked cellular macromolecules. During starvation, all methanotrophs tested exhibited a decline in TCE transformation rates, and this decline followed exponential decay. Formate, provided as an exogenous electron donor, increased TCE transformation rates in Methylomonas sp. strain MM2, but not in mixed culture MM1 or unidentified isolate, CSC-1. Mixed culture MM2 did not transform TCE after 15 h of starvation, but mixed cultures MM1 and MM3 did. The methanotrophs in mixed cultures MM1 and MM3, and the unidentified isolate CSC-1 that was isolated from mixed culture MM1 contained lipid inclusions, whereas the methanotrophs of mixed culture MM2 and Methylomonas sp. strain MM2 did not. It is proposed that lipid storage granules serve as an endogenous source of electrons for TCE oxidation during methane starvation.     

An influence of methane concentration on the methanotrophic activity of a model landfill cover

Evaluation of kinetic parameters of methane oxidation under various conditions, on the basis of an analysis of the literature and the authors’ own laboratory research, is presented. Variation in methanotrophic activity in the profile of a simulated landfill cover was observed. The greatest activity was found at a depth of 60 cm. A low affinity (1/K_M) and high potential activity (V_max) were observed. V_max values ranged from 0.11 × 10⁻³ to 0.86 × 10⁻³ units. The values of K_M ranged from 0.6 to 2.9% of CH₄ (v/v).     

Kinetic study of the anaerobic degradation of toluene by a mixed culture

Toluene was anaerobically degraded by an enriched mixed culture under methanogenic conditions. The mixed culture was originally developed from cow-dung and sludge from a laboratory reactor, in which benzene was anerobically degraded by sulphate-reducing bacteria. First the mixed culture was enriched on toluene over a year with and without the use of sulphate in the medium. For the evaluation of growth-kinetic and maintenance parameters, namely μ_max, K_s, k_d and Y, the anaerobic degradation of toluene was carried out in batch as well as in continous reactors systems. The gas volume and the methane content in the produced gas was somewhat lover than the theoretical value expected, indicating an incomplete degradation of some of the complex intermediates of the toluene degradation pathway. However, the mixed culture was able to transform 41.3% of the toluene carbon into methane.     

Mass spectrometric measurements of methane and oxygen utilization by methanotrophic bacteria

Abstract A mass spectrometer with membrane inlet was used to measure methane and oxygen utilization rates at various methane concentrations in Methylosinus trichosporium and a locally isolated strain of a methane-oxidizing coccus (OU-4-1). The apparent K _m for methane was found to be 2 μM for M. trichosporium and 0.8 μM for strain OU-4-1. These K _m-values are 10–30 times lower than most previously reported values. The ratio of oxygen to methane utilization rates was 1.7 for M. trichosporium and 1.5 for strain OU-4-1 corresponding to a growth yield of 0.38 and 0.63 g dry weight/g methane, respectively.