Compositional patterns in vertebrate genomes: Conservation and change in evolution

Summary The evolution of vertebrate genomes can be investigated by analyzing their regional compositional patterns, namely the compositional distributions of large DNA fragments (in the 30–100-kb size range), of coding sequences, and of their different codon positions. This approach has shown the existence of two evolutionary modes. In the conservative mode, compositional patterns are maintained over long times (many million years), in spite of the accumulation of enormous numbers of base substitutions. In the transitional, or shifting, mode, compositional patterns change into new ones over much shorter times.The conservation of compositional patterns, which has been investigated in mammalian genomes, appears to be due in part to some measure of compositional conservation in the base substitution process, and in part to negative selection acting at regional (isochore) levels in the genome and eliminating deviations from a narrow range of values, presumably corresponding to optimal functional properties. On the other hand, shifts of compositional patterns, such as those that occurred between cold-blooded and warm-blooded vertebrates, appear to be due essentially to both negative and positive selection again operating at the isochore level, largely under the influence of changes in environmental conditions, and possibly taking advantage of mutational biases in the replication/repair enzymes and/or in the enzyme make-up of nucleotide precursor pools. Other events (like translocations and changes in chromosomal structure) also play a role in the transitional mode of genome evolution.The present findings (1) indicate that isochores, which correspond to the DNA segments of individual or contiguous chromatin domains, represent selection units in the vertebrate genome; and (2) shed new light on the selectionist-neutralist controversy.This work was presented at the EMBO Workshop on Evolution (Cambridge, UK, 4–6 July 1988) and at the 16th International Congress of Genetics (Toronto, Canada, 20–27 August 1988)     

Compositional compartmentalization and compositional patterns in the nuclear genomes of plants.

We report here results which indicate (i) that the nuclear genomes of angiosperms is characterized by a compositional compartmentalization and an isochore structure; and (ii) that the nuclear genomes of some Gramineae exhibit strikingly different compositional patterns compared to those of many dicots. Indeed, the compositional distribution of nuclear DNA molecules (in the 50-100 Kb size range) from three dicots (pea, sunflower and tobacco) and three monocots (maize, rice and wheat) were found to be centered around lower (41%) and higher (45% for rice, 48% for maize and wheat) GC levels, respectively (and to trail towards even higher GC values in maize and wheat). Experiments on gene localization in density gradient fractions showed a remarkable compositional homogeneity in vast (greater than 100-200 Kb) regions surrounding the genes. On the other hand, the compositional distribution of coding sequences (GenBank and literature data) from dicots (several orders) was found to be narrow, symmetrical and centered around 46% GC, that from monocots (essentially barley, maize and wheat) to be broad, asymmetrical and characterized by an upward trend towards high GC values, with the majority of sequences between 60 and 70% GC. Introns exhibited a similar compositional distribution, but lower GC levels, compared to exons from the same genes.     

Compositional transitions in the nuclear genomes of cold-blooded vertebrates

Summary The compositional properties of DNAs from 122 species of fishes and from 18 other coldblooded vertebrates (amphibians and reptiles) were compared with those from 10 warm-blooded vertebrates (mammals and birds) and found to be substantially different. Indeed, DNAs from cold-blooded vertebrates are characterized by much lower intermolecular compositional heterogeneities and CsCl band asymmetries, by a much wider spectrum of modal buoyant densities in CsCl, by generally lower amounts of satellites, as well as by the fact that in no case do buoyant densities reach the high values found in the GC-richest components of DNAs from warm-blooded vertebrates.In the case of fish genomes, which were more extensively studied, different orders were generally characterized by modal buoyant densities that were different in average values as well as in their ranges. In contrast, different families within any given order were more often characterized by narrow ranges of modal buoyant densities, and no difference in modal buoyant density was found within any single genus (except for the genusAphyosemion, which should be split into several genera).The compositional differences that were found among species belonging to different orders and to different families within the same order are indicative of compositional transitions, which were shown to be essentially due to directional base substitutions. These transitions were found to be independent of geological time. Moreover, the rates of directional base substitutions were found to be very variable and to reach, in some cases, extremely high values, that were even higher than those of silent substitutions in primates. The taxonomic and evolutionary implications of these findings are discussed.     

Compositional bimodality and evolution of retroviral genomes.

The compositional distributions of genomes, genes (and their third codon positions) and long terminal repeats from retroviruses of warm-blooded vertebrates are characterized by a striking bimodality which is accompanied by a remarkable compositional homogeneity within each retroviral genome. A first, major class of retroviral genomes is GC-rich, whereas a second, minor class is GC-poor. Representative expressed viral genomes from the two classes integrate in GC-rich and GC-poor isochores, respectively, of host genomes. The first class comprises all oncoviruses (except B-types and some D-types), the second, lentiviruses, spumaviruses, as well as B-type and some D-type oncoviruses (e.g., mouse mammary tumor virus and simian retroviruses type D, respectively). The compositional bimodal distribution of retroviral genomes and the accompanying compositional homogeneity within each retroviral genome appear to be the result of the compositional evolution of retroviral genomes in their integrated form.     

Evolutionary patterns in prokaryotic genomes

Prokaryotic genomics is shifting towards comparative approaches to unravel how and why genomes change over time. Both phylogenetic and population genetics approaches are required to dissect the relative roles of selection and drift under these conditions. Lineages evolve adaptively by selection of changes in extant genomes and the way this occurs is being explored from a systemic and evolutionary perspective to understand how mutations relate with gene repertoire changes and how both are contextualized in cellular networks. Through an increased appreciation of genome dynamics in given ecological contexts, a more detailed picture of the genetic basis of prokaryotic evolution is emerging.     

Compositional features of eukaryotic genomes for checking predicted genes

Gene prediction relies on the identification of characteristic features of coding sequences that distinguish them from non-coding DNA. The recent large-scale sequencing of entire genomes from higher eukaryotes, in conjunction with currently used gene prediction algorithms, has provided an abundance of putative genes that can now be analysed for their compositional properties. Strong, systematic differences still exist, in several species, between the compositional properties of sets of ex novo predicted genes and genes that have been experimentally detected and/or verified. This is particularly evident in the estimated gene set (>45,000 genes) of the recently sequenced rice genome, where roughly half the predicted genes are compositionally unusual and have no known orthologues in the dicot Arabidopsis. In a few cases such differences might suggest a bias in experimental gene-finding protocols, but the quasi-random nature of the compositionally aberrant predicted genes is a strong indication that many, if not most, of them are false positives. It therefore appears that some important features of coding regions have not yet been taken into account in existing gene prediction programs. Statistical base compositional properties of curated gene data sets from vertebrates, which we briefly review here, should therefore provide a useful benchmark for fine-tuning probabilistic gene models and model parameters that are currently in use.     

Compositional evolution of noncoding DNA in the human and chimpanzee genomes

We have examined the compositional evolution of noncoding DNA in the primate genome by comparison of lineage-specific substitutions observed in 1.8 Mb of genomic alignments of human, chimpanzee, and baboon with 6542 human single-nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) rooted using chimpanzee sequence. The pattern of compositional evolution, measured in terms of the numbers of GC-->AT and AT-->GC changes, differs significantly between fixed and polymorphic sites, and indicates that there is a bias toward fixation of AT-->GC mutations, which could result from weak directional selection or biased gene conversion in favor of high GC content. Comparison of the frequency distributions of a subset of the SNPs revealed no significant difference between GC-->AT and AT-->GC polymorphisms, although AT-->GC polymorphisms in regions of high GC segregate at slightly higher frequencies on average than GC-->AT polymorphisms, which is consistent with a fixation bias favoring high GC in these regions. However, the substitution data suggest that this fixation bias is relatively weak, because the compositional structure of the human and chimpanzee genomes is becoming homogenized, with regions of high GC decreasing in GC content and regions of low GC increasing in GC content. The rate and pattern of nucleotide substitution in 333 Alu repeats within the human-chimpanzee-baboon alignments are not significantly affected by the GC content of the region in which they are inserted, providing further evidence that, since the time of the human-chimpanzee ancestor, there has been little or no regional variation in mutation bias.     

Compositional patterns in the nuclear genome of cold-blooded vertebrates

Summary DNA preparations obtained from 122 species of fishes, 5 species of amphibians, and 13 species of reptiles were investigated in their compositional properties by analytical equilibrium centrifugation in CsCl density gradients. These species represented 21 orders of Osteichthyes, 3 orders of Chondrichthyes, 2 orders of amphibians, and 3 orders of reptiles. Modal buoyant densities of fish DNAs ranged from 1.696 to 1.707 g/cm³, the vast majority of values falling, however, between 1.699 and 1.704 g/cm³, which is the range covered by the DNAs of amphibians and reptiles. In all cases, DNA bands in CsCl were only weakly asymmetrical and only very rarely were accompanied by separate satellite bands (mostly on the GC-rich side). Intermolecular compositional heterogeneities were low in the vast majority of cases, and, like CsCl band asymmetries, at least partially due to cryptic or poorly resolved satellites. The present findings indicate, therefore, that DNAs from cold-blooded vertebrates are characterized by a number of common properties, namely a very wide spectrum of modal buoyant densities, low intermolecular compositional heterogeneities, low CsCl band asymmetries, and, in most cases, small amounts of satellite DNAs. In the case of fish DNAs a negative correlation was found between the GC level and the haploid size (c value) of the genome. If polyploidization is neglected, this phenomenon appears to be mainly due to the fact that increases and decreases in GC are associated with contraction and expansion phenomena, respectively, of intergenic noncoding sequences, which are GC poor relative to coding sequences.     

Compositional correlation studies among the three different codon positions in 12 bacterial genomes

Compositional distributions in the three codon positions of the coding sequences of 12 fully sequenced prokaryotic genomes, which are publicly available, were investigated. A universal compositional correlation was observed in most of the genomes under investigation irrespective of their overall genomic GC contents. In all the genomes, the GC contents at the first codon positions are always greater than the overall GC contents of the genomes whereas the reverse is true in the case of second codon positions. GC contents at the third codon positions are higher than the overall genomic GC contents in high GC containing genomes, and the opposite situation was found in case of low GC genomes except for Helicobacter pylori. In high-GC rich genomes, the GC contents at the first + second codon positions are less than the GC contents at the third codon positions, and they are low in low-GC genomes except for Helicobacter pylori. The distributions of four bases at the three different positions were also investigated for all 12 organisms. It was observed that in high-GC genomes G is the most dominant base and in low-GC genomes A is the most dominant base in the first codon positions. But purine bases, i.e., (A + G), predominantly occur in the first codon position. In the second codon position, A is the most dominant base in most of the organisms and G is the least dominant base in all the organisms. There is no unique regular pattern of individual bases at the third codon positions; however, there are significant differences in the occurrences of (G + C) contents in the third codon positions among the different organisms. Calculations of dinucleotide frequencies in 12 different organisms indicate that in GC-rich genomes GG, GC, CC, and CG dinucleotides are the most dominant whereas the reverse is true in case of low-GC genomes. Biological implications of these results are discussed in this paper.     

Isochore patterns and gene distributions in fish genomes

The compositional approach developed in our laboratory many years ago revealed a large-scale compositional heterogeneity in vertebrate genomes, in which GC-rich and GC-poor regions, the isochores, were found to be characterized by high and low gene densities, respectively. Here we mapped isochores on fish chromosomes and assessed gene densities in isochore families. Because of the availability of sequence data, we have concentrated our investigations on four species, zebrafish (Brachydanio rerio), medaka (Oryzias latipes), stickleback (Gasterosteus aculeatus), and pufferfish (Tetraodon nigroviridis), which belong to four distant orders and cover almost the entire GC range of fish genomes. These investigations produced isochore maps that were drastically different not only from those of mammals (in that only two major isochore families were essentially present in each genome vs five in the human genome) but also from each other (in that different isochore families were represented in different genomes). Gene density distributions for these fish genomes were also obtained and shown to follow the expected increase with increasing isochore GC. Finally, we discovered a remarkable conservation of the average size of the isochores (which match replicon clusters in the case of human chromosomes) and of the average GC levels of isochore families in both fish and human genomes. Moreover, in each genome the GC-poorest isochore families comprised a group of "long isochores" (2-20 Mb in size), which were the lowest in GC and varied in size distribution and relative amount from one genome to the other.     

Contrasting DNA sequence organisation patterns in sauropsidian genomes

The genomic DNA organisation patterns of four sauropsidian species, namely Python reticularis, Caiman crocodilus, Terrapene carolina triungius and Columba livia domestica were investigated by reassociation of short and long DNA fragments, by hyperchromicity measurements of reannealed fragments and by length estimations of S₁-nuclease resistant repetitive duplexes. While the genomic DNA of the three reptilian species shows a short period interspersion pattern, the genome of the avian species is organised in a long period interspersion pattern apparently typical for birds. These findings are discussed in view of the close phylogenetic relationships of birds and reptiles, and also with regard to a possible relationship between the extent of sequence interspersion and genome size.     

Compositional heterogeneity within and among isochores in mammalian genomes. II. Some general comments

The presence of long-range correlations and/or mosaicism in DNA sequences results in GC fluctuations, even within individual isochores that are much larger than expected correlation-free 'random' sequences. Neglecting the presence of such fluctuations can lead to incorrect conclusions regarding relative homogeneity or isochore borders. In this commentary, we address these and other methodological issues raised by the variations in GC level within human isochores. We also discuss some recent misconceptions.     

Compositional heterogeneity within and among isochores in mammalian genomes. I. CsCl and sequence analyses

GC level distributions of a species' nuclear genome, or of its compositional fractions, encode key information on structural and functional properties of the genome and on its evolution. They can be calculated either from absorbance profiles of the DNA in CsCl density gradients at sedimentation equilibrium, or by scanning long contigs of largely sequenced genomes. In the present study, we address the quantitative characterization of the compositional heterogeneity of genomes, as measured by the GC distributions of fixed-length fragments. Special attention is given to mammalian genomes, since their compartmentalization into isochores implies two levels of heterogeneity, intra-isochore (local) and inter-isochore (global). This partitioning is a natural one, since large-scale compositional properties vary much more among isochores than within them. Intra-isochore GC distributions become roughly Gaussian for long fragments, and their standard deviations decrease only slowly with increasing fragment length, unlike random sequences. This effect can be explained by 'long-range' correlations, often overlooked, that are present along isochores.     

Large-scale methylation patterns in the nuclear genomes of plants.

Methylation was investigated in compositional fractions of nuclear DNA preparations (50-100 kb in size) from five plants (onion, maize, rye, pea and tobacco), and was found to increase from GC-poor to GC-rich fractions. This methylation gradient showed different patterns in different plants and appears, therefore, to represent a novel, characteristic genome feature which concerns the noncoding, intergenic sequences that make up the bulk of the plant genomes investigated and mainly consist of repetitive sequences. The structural and functional implications of these results are discussed.