Dynamin's helical geometry does not destabilize membranes during fission

It is now widely accepted that dynamin‐mediated fission is a fundamentally mechanical process: dynamin undergoes a GTP‐dependent conformational change, constricting the neck between two compartments, somehow inducing their fission. However, the exact connection between dynamin's conformational change and the scission of the neck is still unclear. In this paper, we re‐evaluate the suggestion that a change in the pitch or radius of dynamin's helical geometry drives the lipid bilayer through a mechanical instability, similar to a well‐known phenomenon occurring in soap films. We find that, contrary to previous claims, there is no such instability. This lends credence to an alternative model, in which dynamin drives the membrane up an energy barrier, allowing thermal fluctuations to take it into the hemifission state.      

A Dynamin Homolog Promotes the Transition from Hemifusion to Content Mixing in Intracellular Membrane Fusion

The convergence of the antagonistic reactions of membrane fusion and fission at the hemifusion/hemifission intermediate has generated a captivating enigma of whether Soluble N‐ethylmaleimide sensitive factor Attachment Protein Receptor (SNAREs) and dynamin have unusual counter‐functions in fission and fusion, respectively. SNARE‐mediated fusion and dynamin‐driven fission are fundamental membrane flux reactions known to occur during ubiquitous cellular communication events such as exocytosis, endocytosis and vesicle transport. Here we demonstrate the influence of the dynamin homolog Vps1 (Vacuolar protein sorting 1) on lipid mixing and content mixing properties of yeast vacuoles, and on the incorporation of SNAREs into fusogenic complexes. We propose a novel concept that Vps1, through its oligomerization and SNARE domain binding, promotes the hemifusion‐content mixing transition in yeast vacuole fusion by increasing the number of trans‐SNAREs .      

The protein coat in membrane fusion: lessons from fission

Multiple cell biological processes involve two opposite rearrangements of membrane configuration, referred to as fusion and fission. While membrane intermediates in protein-mediated fusion have been studied in some detail, the global force which drives sequential stages of the fusion reaction from early local intermediates to an expanding fusion pore remains unknown. Fusion proceeds via stages, which are analogous but in the opposite direction to that of membrane budding-off and fission driven by protein coats. On the basis of this analogy, we propose that an interconnected coat formed by membrane-bound activated fusion proteins surrounding the membrane contact zone generates the driving force for fusion. This fusion protein coat has a strongly curved intrinsic shape opposite to that of the protein coat driving fission. To relieve internal stresses, the fusion protein coat spontaneously bends out of the initial shape of the membrane surface. This bending produces elastic stresses in the underlying lipid bilayer and drives its fusion with the apposing membrane. The hypothesis that 'bystander' proteins (i.e. fusion proteins outside the contact zone) generate the driving force for fusion offers a new interpretation for a number of known features of the fusion reaction mediated by the prototype fusion protein, influenza hemagglutinin, and might bring new insights into mechanisms of other fusion reactions.     

Physical aspects of COPI vesicle formation

Coat proteins orchestrate membrane budding and molecular sorting during the formation of transport intermediates. Coat protein complex I (COPI) vesicles shuttle between the Golgi apparatus and the endoplasmic reticulum and between Golgi stacks. The formation of a COPI vesicle proceeds in four steps: coat self-assembly, membrane deformation into a bud, fission of the coated vesicle and final disassembly of the coat to ensure recycling of coat components. Although some issues are still actively debated, the molecular mechanisms of COPI vesicle formation are now fairly well understood. In this review, we argue that physical parameters are critical regulators of COPI vesicle formation. We focus on recent real-time in vitro assays highlighting the role of membrane tension, membrane composition, membrane curvature and lipid packing in membrane remodelling and fission by the COPI coat.     

The genetic basis of a craniofacial disease provides insight into COPII coat assembly

Proteins trafficking through the secretory pathway must first exit the endoplasmic reticulum (ER) through membrane vesicles created and regulated by the COPII coat protein complex. Cranio-lenticulo-sutural dysplasia (CLSD) was recently shown to be caused by a missense mutation in SEC23A, a gene encoding one of two paralogous COPII coat proteins. We now elucidate the molecular mechanism underlying this disease. In vitro assays reveal that the mutant form of SEC23A poorly recruits the Sec13-Sec31 complex, inhibiting vesicle formation. Surprisingly, this effect is modulated by the Sar1 GTPase paralog used in the reaction, indicating distinct affinities of the two human Sar1 paralogs for the Sec13-Sec31 complex. Patient cells accumulate numerous tubular cargo-containing ER exit sites devoid of observable membrane coat, likely representing an intermediate step in COPII vesicle formation. Our results indicate that the Sar1-Sec23-Sec24 prebudding complex is sufficient to form cargo-containing tubules in vivo, whereas the Sec13-Sec31 complex is required for membrane fission.     

Physical aspects of COPI vesicle formation

Abstract

Coat proteins orchestrate membrane budding and molecular sorting during the formation of transport intermediates. Coat protein complex I (COPI) vesicles shuttle between the Golgi apparatus and the endoplasmic reticulum and between Golgi stacks. The formation of a COPI vesicle proceeds in four steps: coat self-assembly, membrane deformation into a bud, fission of the coated vesicle and final disassembly of the coat to ensure recycling of coat components. Although some issues are still actively debated, the molecular mechanisms of COPI vesicle formation are now fairly well understood. In this review, we argue that physical parameters are critical regulators of COPI vesicle formation. We focus on recent real-time in vitro assays highlighting the role of membrane tension, membrane composition, membrane curvature and lipid packing in membrane remodelling and fission by the COPI coat.     

Probing intracellular vesicle trafficking and membrane remodelling by cryo-EM

Protein transport between the membranous compartments of the eukaryotic cells is mediated by the constant fission and fusion of the membrane-bounded vesicles from a donor to an acceptor membrane. While there are many membrane remodelling complexes in eukaryotes, COPII, COPI, and clathrin-coated vesicles are the three principal classes of coat protein complexes that participate in vesicle trafficking in the endocytic and secretory pathways. These vesicle-coat proteins perform two key functions: deforming lipid bilayers into vesicles and encasing selective cargoes. The three trafficking complexes share some commonalities in their structural features but differ in their coat structures, mechanisms of cargo sorting, vesicle formation, and scission. While the structures of many of the proteins involved in vesicle formation have been determined in isolation by X-ray crystallography, elucidating the proteins' structures together with the membrane is better suited for cryogenic electron microscopy (cryo-EM). In recent years, advances in cryo-EM have led to solving the structures and mechanisms of several vesicle trafficking complexes and associated proteins.     

Dynamin: possible mechanism of "Pinchase" action.

Dynamin is a GTPase playing an essential role in ubiquitous intra cellular processes involving separation of vesicles from plasma membranes and membranes of cellular compartments. Recent experimental progress (. Cell. 93:1021-1029;. Cell. 94:131-141) has made it possible to attempt to understand the action of dynamin in physical terms. Dynamin molecules are shown to bind to a lipid membrane, to self-assemble into a helicoidal structure constricting the membrane into a tubule, and, as a result of GTP hydrolysis, to mediate fission of this tubule (). In a similar way, dynamin is supposed to mediate fission of a neck connecting an endocytic bud and the plasma membrane, i.e., to complete endocytosis. We suggest a mechanism of this "pinchase" action of dynamin. We propose that, as a result of GTP hydrolysis, dynamin undergoes a conformational change manifested in growth of the pitch of the dynamin helix. We show that this gives rise to a dramatic change of shape of the tubular membrane constricted inside the helix, resulting in a local tightening of the tubule, which is supposed to promote its fission. We treat this model in terms of competing elasticities of the dynamin helix and the tubular membrane and discuss the predictions of the model in relation to the previous views on the mechanism of dynamin action.     

Prefission constriction of Golgi tubular carriers driven by local lipid metabolism: a theoretical model

Membrane transport within mammalian cells is mediated by small vesicular as well as large pleiomorphic transport carriers (TCs). A major step in the formation of TCs is the creation and subsequent narrowing of a membrane neck connecting the emerging carrier with the initial membrane. In the case of small vesicular TCs, neck formation may be directly induced by the coat proteins that cover the emerging vesicle. However, the mechanism underlying the creation and narrowing of a membrane neck in the generation of large TCs remains unknown. We present a theoretical model for neck formation based on the elastic model of membranes. Our calculations suggest a lipid-driven mechanism with a central role for diacylglycerol (DAG). The model is applied to a well-characterized in vitro system that reconstitutes TC formation from the Golgi complex, namely the pearling and fission of Golgi tubules induced by CtBP/BARS, a protein that catalyzes the conversion of lysophosphatidic acid into phosphatidic acid. In view of the importance of a PA-DAG cycle in the formation of Golgi TCs, we assume that the newly formed phosphatidic acid undergoes rapid dephosphorylation into DAG. DAG possesses a unique molecular shape characterized by an extremely large negative spontaneous curvature, and it redistributes rapidly between the membrane monolayers and along the membrane surface. Coupling between local membrane curvature and local lipid composition results, by mutual enhancement, in constrictions of the tubule into membrane necks, and a related inhomogeneous lateral partitioning of DAG. Our theoretical model predicts the exact dimensions of the constrictions observed in the pearling Golgi tubules. Moreover, the model is able to explain membrane neck formation by physiologically relevant mole fractions of DAG.     

Computational Model of Membrane Fission Catalyzed by ESCRT-III

ESCRT-III proteins catalyze membrane fission during multi vesicular body biogenesis, budding of some enveloped viruses and cell division. We suggest and analyze a novel mechanism of membrane fission by the mammalian ESCRT-III subunits CHMP2 and CHMP3. We propose that the CHMP2-CHMP3 complexes self-assemble into hemi-spherical dome-like structures within the necks of the initial membrane buds generated by CHMP4 filaments. The dome formation is accompanied by the membrane attachment to the dome surface, which drives narrowing of the membrane neck and accumulation of the elastic stresses leading, ultimately, to the neck fission. Based on the bending elastic model of lipid bilayers, we determine the degree of the membrane attachment to the dome enabling the neck fission and compute the required values of the protein-membrane binding energy. We estimate the feasible values of this energy and predict a high efficiency for the CHMP2-CHMP3 complexes in mediating membrane fission. We support the computational model by electron tomography imaging of CHMP2-CHMP3 assemblies in vitro. We predict a high efficiency for the CHMP2-CHMP3 complexes in mediating membrane fission.     

Actin filament severing by cofilin is more important for assembly than constriction of the cytokinetic contractile ring

We created two new mutants of fission yeast cofilin to investigate why cytokinesis in many organisms depends on this small actin-binding protein. These mutant cofilins bound actin monomers normally, but bound and severed ADP-actin filaments much slower than wild-type cofilin. Cells depending on mutant cofilins condensed nodes, precursors of the contractile ring, into clumps rather than rings. Starting from clumped nodes, mutant cells slowly assembled rings from diverse intermediate structures including spiral strands containing actin filaments and other contractile ring proteins. This process in mutant cells depended on α-actinin. These slowly assembled contractile rings constricted at a normal rate but with more variability, indicating ring constriction is not very sensitive to defects in severing by cofilin. Computer simulations of the search-capture-pull and release model of contractile ring formation predicted that nodes clump when the release step is slow, so cofilin severing of actin filament connections between nodes likely contributes to the release step.     

Mechanisms of COPII vesicle formation and protein sorting

The evolutionarily conserved coat protein complex II (COPII) generates transport vesicles that mediate protein transport from the endoplasmic reticulum (ER). COPII coat is responsible for direct capture of cargo proteins and for the physical deformation of the ER membrane that drives the COPII vesicle formation. In addition to coat proteins, recent data have indicated that the Ras-like small GTPase Sar1 plays multiple roles, such as COPII coat recruitment, cargo sorting, and completion of the final fission. In the present review, we summarize current knowledge of COPII-mediated vesicle formation from the ER, as well as highlighting non-canonical roles of COPII components.     

FisB relies on homo-oligomerization and lipid binding to catalyze membrane fission in bacteria

Little is known about mechanisms of membrane fission in bacteria despite their requirement for cytokinesis. The only known dedicated membrane fission machinery in bacteria, fission protein B (FisB), is expressed during sporulation in Bacillus subtilis and is required to release the developing spore into the mother cell cytoplasm. Here, we characterized the requirements for FisB-mediated membrane fission. FisB forms mobile clusters of approximately 12 molecules that give way to an immobile cluster at the engulfment pole containing approximately 40 proteins at the time of membrane fission. Analysis of FisB mutants revealed that binding to acidic lipids and homo-oligomerization are both critical for targeting FisB to the engulfment pole and membrane fission. Experiments using artificial membranes and filamentous cells suggest that FisB does not have an intrinsic ability to sense or induce membrane curvature but can bridge membranes. Finally, modeling suggests that homo-oligomerization and trans-interactions with membranes are sufficient to explain FisB accumulation at the membrane neck that connects the engulfment membrane to the rest of the mother cell membrane during late stages of engulfment. Together, our results show that FisB is a robust and unusual membrane fission protein that relies on homo-oligomerization, lipid binding, and the unique membrane topology generated during engulfment for localization and membrane scission, but surprisingly, not on lipid microdomains, negative-curvature lipids, or curvature sensing.

Little is known about how membrane fission occurs in bacteria; this study suggests that the membrane fission protein FisB exploits the unique cellular geometry encountered during sporulation to enable its localization to the fission site through a novel mechanism, where it catalyzes membrane scission.     

The novel tail-anchored membrane protein Mff controls mitochondrial and peroxisomal fission in mammalian cells

Few components of the mitochondrial fission machinery are known, even though mitochondrial fission is a complex process of vital importance for cell growth and survival. Here, we describe a novel protein that controls mitochondrial fission. This protein was identified in a small interfering RNA (siRNA) screen using Drosophila cells. The human homologue of this protein was named Mitochondrial fission factor (Mff). Mitochondria of cells transfected with Mff siRNA form a closed network similar to the mitochondrial networks formed when cells are transfected with siRNA for two established fission proteins, Drp1 and Fis1. Like Drp1 and Fis1 siRNA, Mff siRNA also inhibits fission induced by loss of mitochondrial membrane potential, it delays cytochrome c release from mitochondria and further progression of apoptosis, and it inhibits peroxisomal fission. Mff and Fis1 are both tail anchored in the mitochondrial outer membrane, but other parts of these proteins are very different and they exist in separate 200-kDa complexes, suggesting that they play different roles in the fission process. We conclude that Mff is a novel component of a conserved membrane fission pathway used for constitutive and induced fission of mitochondria and peroxisomes.     

Three-dimensional reconstruction of dynamin in the constricted state

Members of the dynamin family of GTPases have unique structural properties that might reveal a general mechanochemical basis for membrane constriction. Receptor-mediated endocytosis, caveolae internalization and certain trafficking events in the Golgi all require dynamin for vesiculation. The dynamin-related protein Drp1 (Dlp1) has been implicated in mitochondria fission and a plant dynamin-like protein phragmoplastin is involved in the vesicular events leading to cell wall formation. A common theme among these proteins is their ability to self-assemble into spirals and their localization to areas of membrane fission. Here we present the first three-dimensional structure of dynamin at a resolution of approximately 20 A, determined from cryo-electron micrographs of tubular crystals in the constricted state. The map reveals a T-shaped dimer consisting of three prominent densities: leg, stalk and head. The structure suggests that the dense stalk and head regions rearrange when GTP is added, a rearrangement that generates a force on the underlying lipid bilayer and thereby leads to membrane constriction. These results indicate that dynamin is a force-generating 'contrictase'.     

ADP-ribosylation factor and coatomer couple fusion to vesicle budding

The coat proteins required for budding COP-coated vesicles from Golgi membranes, coatomer and ADP-ribosylation factor (ARF) protein, are shown to be required to reconstitute the orderly process of transport between Golgi cisternae in which fusion of transport vesicles begins only after budding ends. When either coat protein is omitted, fusion is uncoupled from budding-donor and acceptor compartments pair directly without an intervening vesicle. Coupling may therefore results from the sequestration of fusogenic membrane proteins into assembling coated vesicles that are only exposed when the coat is removed after budding is complete. This mechanism of coupling explains the phenomenon of "retrograde transport" triggered by uncouplers such as the drug brefeldin A.     

Regulated Oligomerization Induces Uptake of a Membrane Protein into COPII Vesicles Independent of Its Cytosolic Tail

Export of transmembrane proteins from the endoplasmic reticulum (ER) is driven by directed incorporation into coat protein complex II (COPII)‐coated vesicles. The sorting of some cargo proteins into COPII vesicles was shown to be mediated by specific interactions between transmembrane and COPII‐coat‐forming proteins. But even though some signals for ER exit have been identified on the cytosolic domains of membrane proteins, the general signaling and sorting mechanisms of ER export are still poorly understood. To investigate the role of cargo protein oligomer formation in the export process, we have created a transmembrane fusion protein that – owing to its FK506‐binding protein domains – can be oligomerized in isolated membranes by addition of a small‐molecule dimerizer. Packaging of the fusion protein into COPII vesicles is strongly enhanced in the presence of the dimerizer, demonstrating that the oligomeric state is an ER export signal for this membrane protein. Surprisingly, the cytosolic tail is not required for this oligomerization‐dependent effect on protein sorting. Thus, an alternative mechanism, such as membrane bending, must account for ER export of the fusion protein.      

Specific interaction of the antiapoptotic protein Nr-13 with phospholipid monolayers is prevented by the BH3 domain of Bax

Members of the Bcl-2 protein family regulate apoptosis by controlling the release of apoptogenic proteins such as cytochrome c from the mitochondrial intermembrane space. Proapoptotic members induce release by increasing outer membrane permeability, while antiapoptotic members prevent this. The activity of Bcl-2 proteins depends mostly on their insertion into the mitochondrial membrane, which is reported to occur via putative channels formed by the two central hydrophobic helices. The pro- and antiapoptotic activity of Bcl-2 proteins can also be modulated by heterodimerization between antagonists through the BH3 domain of proapoptotic members, though the position of the heterodimer with respect to the membrane has never been elucidated. In this work, the membrane insertion capacity of the antiapoptotic Bcl-2 related protein Nr-13 was explored, using monolayer expansion measurements. Nr-13 penetrates into the monolayer with a molecular cross-section of 1100A(2), thereby implicating almost all alpha-helical domains of the molecule in this process. A mutant protein, bearing neutral instead of acidic residues in the loop between the two putative channel-forming fifth and sixth alpha-helices, retained the ability to interact with the lipid monolayer, suggesting that the membrane insertion of Nr-13 is not exclusively alpha5-alpha6-dependent. In contrast, the specific interaction of Nr-13 with the monolayer was prevented by heterodimer formation with the BH3 domain of proapoptotic Bax. These findings are discussed in terms of a model for monolayer insertion in which the antiapoptotic Nr-13 and proapoptotic proteins exert their antagonistic effects by preventing each other from reaching the membrane.     

Topography of protein kinase C substrates analyzed by membrane splitting

We have used the methods of planar cell and membrane monolayer formation and monolayer splitting to study structural details of the transmembrane signaling process mediated by protein kinase C. We analyzed human red cell membrane proteins phosphorylated by phorbol ester activation of protein kinase C. Planar single membrane preparations, extraction procedures, and gel electrophoresis coupled with silver staining and autoradiography confirmed that two bands in the 100 kDa region, and bands 4.1, and 4.9, were peripheral and phosphorylated by treatment with 12-O-tetradecanoylphorbol 13-acetate (TPA). TPA also stimulated minor incorporation of [32 P]Pi into most integral membrane proteins, including band 3, glycophorin A, the band 4.5 region (glucose transporter) and band 7. Planar cell and membrane-splitting methods revealed that neither integral nor peripheral phosphorylated polypeptides were cleaved by freeze fracture, that all phosphorylated peripheral proteins partitioned intact with the cytoplasmic side of the membrane, and that the percentages of [32P]Pi-labeled peripheral proteins were the same in split membrane cytoplasmic leaflets as in intact membranes. As a unique approach to examining protein topographies membrane splitting provides strong evidence that the major phosphorylated products of the polyphosphatidylinositide pathway are topographically associated with the cytoplasmic leaflet of the human erythrocyte plasma membrane. We further conclude that TPA-induced phosphorylation of red cell peripheral proteins does not significantly alter their transbilayer partitioning patterns after membrane splitting.     

Split-Doa10: A Naturally Split Polytopic Eukaryotic Membrane Protein Generated by Fission of a Nuclear Gene

Large polytopic membrane proteins often derive from duplication and fusion of genes for smaller proteins. The reverse process, splitting of a membrane protein by gene fission, is rare and has been studied mainly with artificially split proteins. Fragments of a split membrane protein may associate and reconstitute the function of the larger protein. Most examples of naturally split membrane proteins are from bacteria or eukaryotic organelles, and their exact history is usually poorly understood. Here, we describe a nuclear-encoded split membrane protein, split-Doa10, in the yeast Kluyveromyces lactis. In most species, Doa10 is encoded as a single polypeptide with 12–16 transmembrane helices (TMs), but split-KlDoa10 is encoded as two fragments, with the split occurring between TM2 and TM3. The two fragments assemble into an active ubiquitin-protein ligase. The K. lactis DOA10 locus has two ORFs separated by a 508-bp intervening sequence (IVS). A promoter within the IVS drives expression of the C-terminal KlDoa10 fragment. At least four additional Kluyveromyces species contain an IVS in the DOA10 locus, in contrast to even closely related genera, allowing dating of the fission event to the base of the genus. The upstream Kluyveromyces Doa10 fragment with its N-terminal RING-CH and two TMs resembles many metazoan MARCH (Membrane-Associated RING-CH) and related viral RING-CH proteins, suggesting that gene splitting may have contributed to MARCH enzyme diversification. Split-Doa10 is the first unequivocal case of a split membrane protein where fission occurred in a nuclear-encoded gene. Such a split may allow divergent functions for the individual protein segments.