Edmund B. Wilson's the cell and cell theory between 1896 and 1925

Edmund Beecher Wilson is generally celebrated for his contribution to chromosome theory and genetics, whereas opinion concerning his cytological thinking is often restricted to the idea that he provided evidence for the dominant role of the nucleus. But Wilson's cell theory was much more. It was a child of the German Zellforschung, and its attempt to provide a comprehensive cellular answer to a wide range of biological and physiological questions. Wilson developed a corpuscular, micromeristic and preformistic concept, and treated the cell as an organism subject to ontogenetic and phylogenetic processes. He defended his comprehensive theory even in the 1920's, when cytological research had become specialised and directed at more practical goals. For many of his younger readers this concept might have seemed antiquated, but today many of its features sound surprisingly modern.     

The cell theory. Progress in studies on cell-cell communications

Current data confirm the fundamental statement of the cell theory concerning the cell reproduction in a series of generations (omnis cellula e cellula). Cell communities or ensembles integrated by the signaling systems established in prokaryotes and protists and functioning in multicellular organisms including mammals are considered as the structural and functional unit of a multicellular organism. The cell is an elementary unit of life and basis of organism development and functioning. At the same time, the adult organism is not just a totality of cells. Multinucleated cells in some tissues, syncytial structure, and structural-functional units of organs are adaptations for optimal functioning of the multicellular organism and manifestations of cell-cell communications in development and definitive functioning. The cell theory was supplemented and developed by studies on cell-cell communications; however, these studies do not question the main generalizations of the theory.     

Biological atomism and cell theory

Biological atomism postulates that all life is composed of elementary and indivisible vital units. The activity of a living organism is thus conceived as the result of the activities and interactions of its elementary constituents, each of which individually already exhibits all the attributes proper to life. This paper surveys some of the key episodes in the history of biological atomism, and situates cell theory within this tradition. The atomistic foundations of cell theory are subsequently dissected and discussed, together with the theory's conceptual development and eventual consolidation. This paper then examines the major criticisms that have been waged against cell theory, and argues that these too can be interpreted through the prism of biological atomism as attempts to relocate the true biological atom away from the cell to a level of organization above or below it. Overall, biological atomism provides a useful perspective through which to examine the history and philosophy of cell theory, and it also opens up a new way of thinking about the epistemic decomposition of living organisms that significantly departs from the physicochemical reductionism of mechanistic biology.     

A test of the stochastic theory of stem cell differentiation.

Stochastic theories of stem cell renewal are shown to predict turnover of intestinal crypts. While I found ample evidence of production of new crypts from direct in vivo studies in adult mice, I failed to find evidence of crypt loss. Thus, it would appear that the simple stochastic models may not provide an adequate theory of control of intestinal stem cell function.     

The second cell membrane: the basal lamina and the tissue cell theory of metazoa.

We suggest that the basal lamina is essentially a second plasma or cell membrane appearing at the next higher level of biological organization; that together with associated cell monolayers it creates a tissue level membrane which is used to form multicellular cells and that collections of these provide the essential structure of metazoa. Thus when the histological structure of multicellular organisms is viewed in a topologically simplified form such organisms appear to be sets of multicellular cells (m-cells) formed by a unit tissue membrane built around the basal lamina. Not only are m-cells in this way structurally isomorphous (homeomorphic) to unit or classical biological cells (u-cells) but the two cellular levels are also functionally isomorphous. This suggests a “General Principle of Hierarchical Isomorphism or Iteration”, i.e. that multicellular evolution recapitulates unicellular evolution. This principle of structural and functional isomorphic mappability of unicellular onto multicellular organisms then governs the organization of matter all the way from molecules to man. Just as cytoplasm precipitates the bimolecular plasma membrane to form u-cells for the purpose of achieving reaction sequestration, in turn, these u-cells precipitate a common basal lamina to form m-cells, the histologist's acini, to produce sequestered “tissue plasms”. Thus, the “generalized acinus” with its basal laminar complex seem to constitute a second level (multicellular) cell and cell membrane, respectively.Four operators, ultimately under genetic control, can generate both u and m-cells from planar configurations of their respective unit membranes therewith providing the essential structure of all cells, tissues, organs and organisms. These are the ply, permeability vector, topological and stratificational operators. They are collected into a set of “organ formulae”. Both the plasma membrane and the basal lamina act as covering membranes and, again, as membranes for subcells so that a complete multicellular organism is a tetrahierarchical cell in which the molecule is the element of the first two cellular domains and the cell is the element of the last two. The analysis identifies a new transport organ group which together with the classical endocrine and exocrine groups comprises nearly the whole of the soft tissue organs. In a major reduction, all these organs are continuously (topologically) transformable into each and into hollow spheres, cells or acini thus greatly simplifying the histology of metazoa. Given this emphasis on cellularization it would seem that life, i.e. the autonomous chemoservo, results from the cooperation of cellularization and replication operations on the catalyzation process. Through cellularization, the lipid bilayer and basal laminar membranes provide the essential catalytic reaction sequestration demanded by chemical reaction theory while through complementary base pairing the DNA double helix provides the essential memory which stores the patterns of the variations of the sequestered reactions.     

Phase resetting of embryonic chick atrial heart cell aggregates. Experiment and theory.

The influence of brief duration current pulses on the spontaneous electrical activity of embryonic chick atrial heart cell aggregates was investigated experimentally and theoretically. A pulse could either delay or advance the time of the action potential subsequent to the pulse depending upon the time in the control cycle at which it was applied. The perturbed cycle length throughout the transition from delay to advance was a continuous function of the time of the pulse for small pulse amplitudes, but was discontinuous for larger pulse amplitudes. Similar results were obtained using a model of the ionic currents which underlie spontaneous activity in these preparations. The primary ion current components which contribute to phase resetting are the fast inward sodium ion current, INa, and the primary, potassium ion repolarization current, IX1. The origin of the discontinuity in phase resetting of the model can be elucidated by a detailed examination of the current-voltage trajectories in the region of the phase response curve where the discontinuity occurs.     

Transport theory for growing cell populations

The partial differential equation that describes the growth of cell populations whose maturation rate is random is developed. The equation resembles that used in classical transport theory but mitotic boundary conditions and the restriction of the maturation rate to non-negative values brings out new features and new problems. This is a generalization of a previously published formulation in which cells could make transitions at random between only two maturation velocities: a characteristic velocity and zero. Growth rates, cycle time distributions and pulsed labeled mitotic curves are calculated for a simple choice of parameters. A numerical algorithm that is suited to the solution of the transport equation is given.     

Stomatal patterning in Tradescantia: an evaluation of the cell lineage theory.

The cell lineage theory, which explains stomatal patterning in monocot leaves as a consequence of orderly divisions, was studied in Tradescantia. Data were collected to test the theory at three levels of organization: the individual stoma; stomata distributed in one dimension, in linear fashion along cell files; and stomata apportioned in two dimensions, across the length and breadth of the leaf. In an attempt to watch the patterning process through regeneration, stomata in all visible stages of development were laser ablated. The results showed that the formation of stomatal initials was highly regular, and measurements of stomatal frequency and spacing showed that pattern was determined near the basal meristem when the stomatal initials arose. Following the origin of initials, the pattern was not readjusted by division of epidermal cells. Stomatal initials were not committed when first present and a small percentage of them arrested. The arrested cells, unlike stomata, were consistently positioned in cell files midway between a developed pair of stomata. At the one-dimensional level of pattern, stomata in longitudinal files were separated by a variable number of epidermal cells and the frequency of these separations was not random. The sequential spacing of stomata also was not random, and stomata separated by single epidermal cells were grouped into more short and long series than expected by chance. The stomatal pattern across the width of the leaf resulted from cell files free of stomata which alternated with cell files containing stomata, but not with a recurring periodicity. Files lacking stomata were found only over longitudinal vascular bundles. Laser ablations of developing stomata did not disrupt the pattern in nearby cells or result in stomatal regeneration. We conclude that the cell lineage theory explains pattern as an individual stomatal initial arises from its immediate precursor and satisfactorily accounts for the minimum spacing of stomata in a cell file, i.e., stoma-epidermal cell-stoma. However, the theory does not explain the collective stomatal pattern along the cell files, at the one-dimensional level of patterning. Nor does the theory account for the for the two-dimensional distribution of stomata in which regions devoid of stomata alternate with regions enriched with stomata, but not in a highly regular nor haphazard manner. We suggest that the grouping of epidermal cells and stomata separated by single epidermal cells in cell files may result from cell lineages at a specific position in the cell cycle as they traverse the zone where stomatal initials form.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)     

The distribution of cell surface proteins on spreading cells. Comparison of theory with experiment.

Bretscher (1983) has shown that on uniformly spread giant HeLa cells, the receptors for low density lipoprotein (LDL) and transferrin are concentrated toward the periphery of the cells. To explain these nonuniform distributions, he proposed that on giant HeLa cells, recycling receptors return to the cell surface at the cell's leading edge. Since the distribution of coated pits on these cells is uniform, Bretscher and Thomson (1983) proposed that there is a bulk membrane flow toward the cell centers. Here we present a mathematical model that allows us to predict the distribution of cell surface proteins on a thin circular cell, when exocytosis occurs at the cell periphery and endocytosis occurs uniformly over the cell surface. We show that on such a cell, a bulk membrane flow will be generated, whose average velocity is zero at the cell center and increases linearly with the distance from the cell center. Our model predicts that proteins that aggregate in coated pits will have concentrations that are maximal at the cell periphery. We fit our theory to the data of Bretscher and Thomson (1983) on the distribution of ferritin receptors for the following cases: the receptors move by diffusion alone; they move by bulk membrane flow alone; they move by a combination of diffusion and bulk membrane flow. From our fits we show that tau m greater than 3.5 tau p, where tau m and tau p are the lifetimes of the membrane and the ferritin receptor on the cell surface, and that tau pD less than 6.9 X 10(-7) cm2, where D is the ferritin receptor diffusion coefficient. Surprisingly, we obtain the best fits to the data when we neglect membrane flow. Our model predicts that for proteins that are excluded from coated pits, the protein concentration will be Gaussian, being maximal at the cell center and decreasing with the distance from the cell center. If on giant HeLa cells a protein with such a distribution could be found, it would strongly support Bretcher's proposal that there is an inward membrane flow.     

Phase resetting of the rhythmic activity of embryonic heart cell aggregates. Experiment and theory.

Injection of a current pulse of brief duration into an aggregate of spontaneously beating chick embryonic heart cells resets the phase of the activity by either advancing or delaying the time of occurrence of the spontaneous beat subsequent to current injection. This effect depends upon the polarity, amplitude, and duration of the current pulse, as well as on the time of injection of the pulse. The transition from prolongation to shortening of the interbeat interval appears experimentally to be discontinuous for some stimulus conditions. These observations are analyzed by numerical investigation of a model of the ionic currents that underlie spontaneous activity in these preparations. The model consists of: Ix, which underlies the repolarization phase of the action potential, IK2, a time-dependent potassium ion pacemaker current, Ibg, a background or time-independent current, and INa, an inward sodium ion current that underlies the upstroke of the action potential. The steady state amplitude of the sum of these currents is an N-shaped function of potential. Slight shifts in the position of this current-voltage relation along the current axis can produce either one, two, or three intersections with the voltage axis. The number of these equilibrium points and the voltage dependence of INa contribute to apparent discontinuities of phase resetting. A current-voltage relation with three equilibrium points has a saddle point in the pacemaker voltage range. Certain combinations of current-pulse parameters and timing of injection can shift the state point near this saddle point and lead to an interbeat interval that is unbounded . Activation of INa is steeply voltage dependent. This results in apparently discontinuous phase resetting behavior for sufficiently large pulse amplitudes regardless of the number of equilibrium points. However, phase resetting is fundamentally a continuous function of the time of pulse injection for these conditions. These results demonstrate the ionic basis of phase resetting and provide a framework for topological analysis of this phenomenon in chick embryonic heart cell aggregates.     

Limitations of the cancer stem cell theory

Cancer stem cells (CSCs) can be operationally defined as a subset of neoplastic cells which are responsible for the growth and re-growth of primary and metastatic tumors. Although the existence of perpetually dividing cells is a logical necessity to explain the malignant properties of human tumors, experimental data supporting their existence have only recently been obtained. New knowledge in basic stem cell biology and the availability of several cell surface markers for the definition and isolation of small subsets of immature cells coupled to the use of the classical model of xenotransplantation in immune deficient mice has identified putative CSCs in several solid tumors such as mammary, colon, brain, pancreas, prostate, melanoma and others. However, the theory must be considered as still in its infancy, since tumors grown in mice only partially recapitulate the biology of human cells. In addition, whether the “transformed” cell is the neoplastic counterpart of a normal stem cell or whether complete malignant behaviour can occur in a more differentiated cell has still to be demonstrated. In spite of these difficulties, the CSC hypothesis could be of clinical relevance, especially in the definition of new ways to assay drug sensitivity of primary human tumors.     

A mortalization theory for the control of the cell proliferation and for the origin of immortal cell lines.

An increasing rate of cellular mortalization sets a limit to the proliferation of fibroblast populations. Failure of the mortalization mechanism leads to the formation of immortal clones of cells. A possible molecular model for the mortalization process is described.     

A thermodynamic and biomechanical theory of cell adhesion. Part I: General formulism

The equilibrium thermodynamics calculus of cell adhesion developed by Bell et al. (1984, Biophys. J. 45, 1051-1064) has been extended to the general non-equilibrium case. In contrast to previous models which could only compute the end results of equilibrium states, the present theory is able to calculate the kinetic process of evolution of adhesion, which may or may not approach towards equilibrium. Starting from a basic constitutive hypothesis for Helmholtz free energy, equations of balance of normal forces, energy balance at the edge of the contact area and rate of entropy production are derived using an irreversible thermodynamics approach, in which the restriction imposed by the Second Law of Thermodynamics takes the place of free energy minimization used by Bell et al. (1984). An explicit expression for adhesion energy density is derived for the general transient case as the difference of the usable work transduced from chemical energy liberation from bond formation of specific crosslinking molecules and the repulsive potential of non-specific interactions. This allows the energy balance to be used as an independent boundary equation rather than a practical way of computing the adhesion energy. Jump conditions are obtained from the conservation of crosslinking molecules across the edge of adhesion region which is treated as a singular curve. The bond formation and lateral motion of the crosslinking molecules are assumed to obey a set of reaction-diffusion equations. These equations and the force balance equation within the contact area, plus the jump conditions and the energy balance equation at the edge form a well-posed moving boundary problem which determines the propagation of the adhesion boundary, the separation distance between the two cell membranes over the contact area as well as the distributions of the crosslinking molecules on the cell surfaces. The behavior of the system depends on the relative importance of virtual convection, lateral diffusion and bond formation of the crosslinking molecules at the edge of the adhesion region, according to which two types of rate limiting cases are discussed, viz, reaction-limited and diffusion-limited processes.