Determinants of target gene specificity for steroid/thyroid hormone receptors

The molecular specificity of the receptors for steroid and thyroid hormones is achieved by their selective interaction with DNA binding sites referred to as hormone response elements (HREs). HREs can differ in primary nucleotide sequence as well as in the spacing of their dyadic half-sites. The target gene specificity of the glucocorticoid receptor can be converted to that of the estrogen receptor by changing three amino acids clustered in the first zinc finger. Remarkably, a single Gly to Glu change in this region produces a receptor that recognizes both glucocorticoid and estrogen response elements. Further replacement of five amino acids in the stem of the second zinc finger transforms the specificity to that of the thyroid hormone receptor. These findings localize structural determinants required for discrimination of HRE sequence and half-site spacing, respectively, and suggest a simple pathway for the coevolution of receptor DNA binding domains and hormone-responsive gene networks.     

Receptor binding of NBD-labeled fluorescent estrogens and progestins in whole cells and cell-free preparations

We have studied the interactions of four fluorescent steroid conjugates with either the estrogen or progesterone receptor, both in whole cells and cell-free receptor preparations. The fluorophore, nitrobenzoxadiazole (NBD), was conjugated with a synthetic progestin, with a steroidal estrogen, a non-steroidal estrogen, and with an antiestrogen. With all compounds, receptor-specific binding could be detected by fluorescence measurements following extraction from the protein into an organic solvent. In the native state, however, the NBD-ligand-receptor complex is essentially non-emissive, although these ligands fluoresce strongly when associated with non-specific binders such as albumin. The binding site concentrations and relative affinities determined by fluorescence (after extraction) correspond well with those determined by [3H]estradiol or [3H]R5020 binding to their respective receptors. In T47D breast cancer cells, the NBD-progestin showed receptor-mediated uptake and nuclear localization. These compounds have provided valuable information about the interactions of low and medium affinity ligands with their receptors; however, the successful use of fluorescent ligands for detecting steroid receptors under native-bound conditions, by "imaging" modalities (fluorescence microscopy and flow cytometry) will require the development of fluorophores that are emissive while receptor bound or assay protocols that enable the environment of ligands associated with the receptor to be controlled.     

DNA binding properties of the vitamin D3 receptor zinc finger region.

The DNA binding domains of the nuclear receptor superfamily are highly conserved and consist of residues that fold into two zinc finger-like motifs, suggesting that the structures of this region among the members of the superfamily are likely to be very similar. Furthermore, the response elements that these receptors bind to are similar in sequence and organization. Nevertheless, these receptors selectively recognize target response elements and differentially regulate linked genes. In order to study the details of receptor:DNA binding, we have overexpressed and purified the vitamin D3 receptor DNA binding domain (VDRF) and have begun characterizing its DNA binding properties. We find that the VDRF protein binds strongly and specifically to direct repeats constituting a vitamin D response element from the mouse osteopontin (Spp-1) promoter region but weakly to the human osteocalcin vitamin D response element. Unlike receptors that recognize hormone response elements oriented as inverted repeats, such as the glucocorticoid receptor (GR) and estrogen receptor, VDRF appears to bind half-sites noncooperatively, without the free energy contribution of dimerization seen when the glucocorticoid receptor DNA binding domain associates with a glucocorticoid response element. By comparing and contrasting the DNA binding properties of the vitamin D and glucocorticoid receptors, we suggest a model for how receptors that prefer direct repeats differ in their binding strategy from those that recognize inverted repeats.     

Competition for DNA steroid response elements as a possible mechanism for neuroendocrine integration

For the analysis of a simple steroid-dependent mating behavior, careful response definition, complete neural circuit delineation and placement of estrogen-responsive cells within this circuit have been accomplished. Molecular studies of two relevant genes have emphasized DNA/RNA hybridization assays nd DNA binding techniques. For both the rat preproenkephalin gene and the gene for the progesterone receptor, a strong induction by estrogen, tissue specificity of expression and a sex difference in regulation are prominent phenomena. On the rat preproenkephalin promoter, estrogen (ER) and thyroid receptors may compete for a DNA binding site. Likewise, progesterone (PR) and glucocorticoid receptors may compete for the same sites. On the rat PR gene, interactions between ER and AP-1 binding proteins are of special interest. Such interactions could underlay competitions and synergies between steroid hormones and neurally signalled events in the environment.     

Analysis of RNA-protein interactions by a microplate-based fluorescence anisotropy assay

Quantitative studies of RNA-protein interactions are quite cumbersome using traditional methods. We developed a rapid microplate-based fluorescence anisotropy (FA)/fluorescence polarization assay that works well, even with RNA probes >90 nucleotides long. We analyzed binding of RNA targets by vigilin/DDP1/SCP160p and by c-myc coding region instability determinant (CRD) binding protein, CRD-BP. Vigilin is essential for cell viability and functions in heterochromatin formation and mRNA decay. The CRD-BP stabilizes c-myc mRNA. Vigilin bound to a vitellogenin mRNA 3'-UTR probe with a two to three-fold lower affinity than to a Drosophila dodecasatellite ssDNA binding site and bound to the c-myc CRD with a two- to three-fold lower affinity than to the vitellogenin mRNA 3'-UTR. Competition between vigilin and CRD-BP for binding to the CRD may therefore play a role in regulating c-myc mRNA degradation. We analyzed suitability of the microplate-based FA assay for high-throughput screening for small-molecule regulators of RNA-protein interactions. The assay exhibits high reproducibility and precision and works well in 384-well plates and in 5 microl to 20 microl samples. To demonstrate the potential of this assay for screening libraries of small molecules to identify novel regulators of RNA-protein interactions, we identified neomycin and H33342 as inhibitors of binding of vigilin to the vitellogenin mRNA 3'-UTR.     

Mechanism of high-mobility group protein B enhancement of progesterone receptor sequence-specific DNA binding

The DNA-binding domain (DBD) of progesterone receptor (PR) is bipartite containing a zinc module core that interacts with progesterone response elements (PRE), and a short flexible carboxyl terminal extension (CTE) that interacts with the minor groove flanking the PRE. The chromosomal high-mobility group B proteins (HMGB), defined as DNA architectural proteins capable of bending DNA, also function as auxiliary factors that increase the DNA-binding affinity of PR and other steroid receptors by mechanisms that are not well defined. Here we show that the CTE of PR contains a specific binding site for HMGB that is required for stimulation of PR-PRE binding, whereas the DNA architectural properties of HMGB are dispensable. Specific PRE DNA inhibited HMGB binding to the CTE, indicating that DNA and HMGB–CTE interactions are mutually exclusive. Exogenous CTE peptide increased PR-binding affinity for PRE as did deletion of the CTE. In a PR-binding site selection assay, A/T sequences flanking the PRE were enriched by HMGB, indicating that PR DNA-binding specificity is also altered by HMGB. We conclude that a transient HMGB–CTE interaction alters a repressive conformation of the flexible CTE enabling it to bind to preferred sequences flanking the PRE.     

Fluorescence investigation of the sex steroid binding protein of rabbit serum: steroid binding and subunit dissociation

The relationship between steroid binding and protein subunit interactions of rabbit sex steroid binding protein (rSBP) has been studied by steady-state and time-resolved fluorescence spectroscopy. The high-affinity (Ka approximately 10(8) M-1 at 4 degrees C), fluorescent estrogen d-1,3,5(10),6,8-estrapentaene-3,17 beta-diol [dihydroequilenin (DHE)] was used as a fluorescent probe of the steroid-binding site. Perturbation of the binding site with guanidinium chloride (Gdm.Cl) was monitored by changes in the steady-state fluorescence anisotropy of DHE as well as by changes in fluorescence quenching of DHE with acrylamide. The results of acrylamide quenching at 11 degrees C show that, while between 0 and 1 M Gdm.Cl the steroid-binding site is completely shielded from bulk solvent, there is decreased DHE binding. To study the subunit-subunit interactions, rSBP was covalently labeled with dansyl chloride in the presence of saturating 5 alpha-dihydrotestosterone (DHT), which yielded a dansyl-conjugated protein that retained full steroid-binding activity. The protein subunit perturbation was monitored by changes in the steady-state fluorescence anisotropy of the dansyl group. At 11 degrees C, the dansyl anisotropy perturbation, reflecting changes in global and segmental motions of the dimer protein, occurs at concentrations of Gdm.Cl above 1 M. The Gdm.Cl titration in the presence of steroids with equilibrium association constants less than 10(8) M-1 shows a plateau near 3 M Gdm.Cl at 11 degrees C; at this Gdm.Cl concentration, no DHE is bound. No plateau is observed at 21 degrees C. At higher Gdm.Cl concentrations, the dansyl fluorescence anisotropy decreases further and shows no steroid dependence. Recovery of steroid-binding activity (assayed by saturation binding with [3H]DHT), under renaturation conditions, is dependent on both steroid concentration and affinity. Both unlabeled and dansyl-labeled protein recovery the same amount of activity, and according to fluorescence anisotropy, dansyl-labeled rSBP re-forms a dimer upon dilution below 1 M or removal of Gdm.Cl. From the steroid requirement for recovery of steroid-binding activity, it appears that a conformational template is required for the dimeric protein to re-form a steroid-binding site with native-like properties.     

Effect of replacement of "zinc finger" zinc on estrogen receptor DNA interactions.

Exposure of bovine estrogen receptor to the metal chelators EDTA and 1,10-phenanthroline results in a loss of nonspecific DNA binding, presumably because of the removal of "zinc finger" zinc. Nonspecific DNA binding, as measured by a DNA-cellulose binding assay, can be restored by dialysis of the aporeceptor against buffer containing zinc, cadmium, and cobalt but not with buffer containing copper or nickel. More detailed studies were carried out using a bacterially expressed polypeptide encompassing the DNA binding domain of the human estrogen receptor. Apopolypeptide fails to bind DNA specifically, as measured by mobility shift assay using a consensus estrogen response element hexamer containing oligonucleotide, but DNA binding was restored by dialysis of the apopolypeptide against buffer containing zinc, cadmium, and cobalt but not with buffer containing copper or nickel. Dissociation constants of zinc- and cadmium-reconstituted polypeptide for the estrogen response element hexamer (66 and 48 nM, respectively) are virtually indistinguishable from native polypeptide (Kd = 48 nM) whereas cobalt-reconstituted polypeptide has a lower affinity (Kd = 720 nM). However, native, zinc-, cadmium-, and cobalt-reconstituted polypeptides gave identical results in a methylation interference assay. Competition experiments with zinc and copper or nickel suggest that copper and nickel are able to bind to zinc finger residues but do so nonproductively. The relative affinities copper greater than cadmium greater than zinc greater than cobalt greater than nickel for the polypeptide were determined by a zinc blot competition assay. The ability of cadmium and cobalt to substitute for zinc in the zinc fingers demonstrates a structural "flexibility" in the DNA binding domain as each of these metals has slightly different ionic radii. On the other hand, subtle differences in DNA binding affinity and/or specificity could exist, which may not be detectable here. Also, the ability of metals to substitute for zinc in the DNA binding domain suggests that metal substitution in these zinc fingers in vivo may be of relevance to the toxicity and/or carcinogenicity of some of these metals.     

Development of a generic dual-reporter gene assay for screening G-protein-coupled receptors

Multiple assay formats have been developed for the pharmacological characterization of G-protein-coupled receptors (GPCRs) and for screening orphan receptors. However, the increased pace of target identification and the rapid expansion of compound libraries present the need to develop novel assay formats capable of screening multiple GPCRs simultaneously. To address this need, the authors have developed a generic dual-reporter gene assay that can detect ligand activity at 2 GPCRs within the same assay. Two stable HEK293 cell lines were generated expressing either a firefly (Photinus) luciferase gene under the control of multiple cAMP-response elements (CREs) or a Renilla luciferase gene under the control of multiple 12-O-tetradecanoylphorbol-13-acetate (TPA)-responsive elements (TREs). Coseeded reporter cells were used to assess ligand binding activity at both Galphas-and Galphaq-coupled receptors. By selectively coexpressing receptors with a chimeric G-protein, agonist activity was assessed at Galphai/o-coupled receptors in combination with either Galphas-or Galphaq-coupled receptors. The dual-reporter gene assay was shown to be capable of simultaneously performing duplexed screens for a variety of agonist and/or antagonist combinations. The data generated from the duplexed reporter assays were pharmacologically relevant, and Z' factor analysis indicated the suitability of both agonist and antagonist screens for use in high-throughput screening.     

Multiplexed molecular interactions of nuclear receptors using fluorescent microspheres

BACKGROUND: We describe a novel microsphere-based system to identify and characterize multiplexed interactions of nuclear receptors with peptides that represent the LXXLL binding region of coactivator proteins. METHODS: In this system, individual microsphere populations with unique red and orange fluorescent profiles are coupled to specific coactivator peptides. The coactivator peptide-coupled microsphere populations are combined and incubated with a nuclear receptor that has been coupled to a green fluorochrome. Flow cytometric analysis of the microspheres simultaneously decodes each population and detects the binding of receptor to respective coactivator peptides by the acquisition of green fluorescence. RESULTS: We have used this system to determine the binding affinities of human estrogen receptor beta ligand binding domain (ERbeta LBD) and human peroxisome proliferator activated receptor gamma ligand binding domain (PPARgamma LBD) to a set of 34 coactivator peptides. Binding of ERbeta LBD to a coactivator peptide sequence containing the second LXXLL motif of steroid receptor coactivator-1 (SRC-1(2) (676-700) is shown to be specific and saturable. Analysis of receptor binding to a multiplexed set of coactivator peptides shows PPARgamma LBD binds with high affinity to cAMP response element binding protein (CBP) peptides and to the related P300 peptide while ERbeta LBD exibits little binding to these peptides. Using the microsphere-based assay we demonstrate that ERbeta LBD and PPARgamma LBD binding affinities for the coactivator peptides are increased in the presence of agonist (estradiol or GW1929, respectively) and that ERbeta LBD binding is decreased in the presence of antagonist (raloxifene or tamoxifen). CONCLUSIONS: This unique microsphere-based system is a sensitive and efficient method to simultaneously evaluate many receptor-coactivator interactions in a single assay volume. In addition, the system offers a powerful approach to study small molecule modulation of nuclear receptor binding.     

Homogeneous time-resolved G protein-coupled receptor–ligand binding assay based on fluorescence cross-correlation spectroscopy

G protein-coupled receptors (GPCRs) mediate many important physiological functions and are considered as one of the most successful therapeutic target classes for a wide spectrum of diseases. Drug discovery projects generally benefit from a broad range of experimental approaches for screening compound libraries and for the characterization of binding modes of drug candidates. Owing to the difficulties in solubilizing and purifying GPCRs, assay formats have been so far mainly limited to cell-based functional assays and radioligand binding assays. In this study, we used fluorescence cross-correlation spectroscopy (FCCS) to analyze the interaction of detergent-solubilized receptors to various types of GPCR ligands: endogenous peptides, small molecules, and a large surrogate antagonist represented by a blocking monoclonal antibody. Our work demonstrates the suitability of the homogeneous and time-resolved FCCS assay format for a robust, high-throughput determination of receptor–ligand binding affinities and kinetic rate constants for various therapeutically relevant GPCRs.     

A nuclear binding assay for measurement of biologically active androgen receptors in animal tissues and human prostate cancer

A nuclear binding (NB) assay has been developed for the measurement in intact viable cells of biologically active (functional) estrogen and progesterone receptors, i.e. those capable of binding to nuclear acceptor sites [Spelsberg et al., Endocrinology 121: 631 (1987)]. This paper describes the application of this assay to analyses of androgen receptors in the guinea pig seminal vesicle and in human prostatic carcinoma. Cells from fresh animal seminal vesicles or human prostate carcinoma are isolated using collagenase and are incubated with [3H]R1881 for 1 h at 22 degrees C, after which nuclei are isolated at 4 degrees C and assayed for DNA and radioactivity. This NB assay demonstrates a saturable, temperature dependent, steroid and tissue specific nuclear binding of [3H]R1881 for the guinea pig-seminal vesicle system. The nuclear binding is of high affinity and low capacity. The NB assay reveals several important aspects of the androgen and estrogen receptors in target tissues: (1) the nuclear acceptor sites for androgen receptor (AR) are steroid receptor specific; (2) there are different concentrations of the androgen and estrogen receptors between the epithelium and the fibromuscular components of the guinea pig seminal vesicle; and finally (3) some biopsies of human prostate cancer appear to contain biologically inactive AR. This assay may be useful in the analyses of functional receptors in biopsies of human cancer cells.