Transformation efficiencies and progeny analysis after varying different parameters of direct gene transfer of Nicotiana tabacum protoplasts

Nicotiana tabacum protoplasts were transformed by polyethylene glycol (PEG)-mediated uptake and electroporation, with circular and linear DNA, and with or without X-ray irradiation. We investigated the influence on the transient expression by these parameters as well as on the frequencies for stable transformation. Plants were regenerated and selfed, and the progenies of the transformed plants were analysed and used to compare the pattern of gene integration by these different variations in transformation methods. The results from the transient expression as judged by glucuronidase (GUS) activity, showed electroporation to give higher and more reproducible results than PEG-mediated uptake. Using linear instead of circular DNA increased the rate of stable transformation about 3 times. Including a mild X-ray treatment gave an increase in the same range. When the inheritance of the transferred trait was investigated, it was found that protoplasts transformed with linear DNA resulted in the highest number of plants with single-copy insertions. Protoplasts transformed with circular DNA showed the highest incidence of losing the trait, while plants in which the transformation included an X-ray treatment, had the highest frequency of multicopy insertion events.     

Electroporation of rapeseed protoplasts – transient and stable transformation

Protoplasts of Brassica napus hypocotyls were transfected using electroporation. Parameters such as discharge potential, protoplast density and buffer constituents were tested to determine the most suitable conditions for gene transfer. To monitor the introduction of DNA into protoplasts a plasmid containing the β-glucuronidase (EC 3.2.1.31), and the neomycin phospotransferase (EC 2.7.1.95) genes was used. By using this construct, expression of a screenable marker gene for transient expression analysis as well as an antibiotic resistance marker gene for selection of stable transformants were obtained. Refined electroporation conditions resulted in a frequency of 0.1% transiently transformed protoplasts. Microcalluses were cultured under selective conditions in a bead-type culture system. Resistant callus, with an absolute transformation frequency of 4.9 × 10⁻⁵ and a relative transformation frequency of 0.3% could be achieved. X-ray irradiation of newly electroporated protoplasts did not enhance absolute transformation frequencies. From some of the resistant calluses, transgenic plants could be regenerated which were characterized by molecular analysis.     

Direct DNA transfer to plant cells

A range of somatic cell and molecular techniques are now available to supplement conventional plant breeding. The introduction and expression of foreign DNA has been used to modify basic aspects of physiology and development, to introduce commercially important characteristics such as herbicide and insect resistance into plants and to insert genes suitable as dominant selectable markers for somatic hybridisation. Several techniques for direct DNA delivery are available, ranging from uptake of DNA into isolated protoplasts mediated by chemical procedures or electroporation, to injection and the use of high-velocity particles to introduce DNA into intact tissues. Direct DNA uptake is applicable to both stable and transient gene expression studies and utilises a range of vectors, including those employed for gene cloning. Although the frequency of stable transformation is low, direct DNA uptake is applicable to those plants not amenable to Agrobacterium transformation, particularly monocotyledons.     

Experession and integration of genes introduced into highly synchronized plant protoplasts

Summary Chimaeric genes containing the chloramphenicol acetyltransferase (CAT) coding sequence were introduced into protoplasts of suspension-cultured tobacco cells using improved conditions of electroporation (Okada et al. 1986). CAT activity became detectable in the protoplasts within 3 h, was maximal during a period of 18–36 h after electroporation, and then declined gradually. Alpha-amanitin added to the medium abolished the transient expression of the CAT gene. The closed circular form of input DNA was as effective as the linear form for the transient expression. The suspension culture was treated with aphidicolin, and S, G₂, M and G₁ phases were identified in the highly synchronized cell cycle obtained by releasing the cells from the inhibition of DNA synthesis. When a chimacric CAT gene was introduced into M phase protoplasts prepared from the synchronized culture, the transient expression of the CAT gene was 3–4 times higher than when it was introduced into protoplasts of other cell cycle phases. The frequency of stable transformation with a chimaeric neomycin phosphotransferase II gene was studied using the same system. G-418-resistant transformants were obtained from M phase protoplasts at frequencies 2–8 times those obtained from protoplasts at other cell cycle phases. The results indicate that the absence of the nuclear membrane in mitotic cells favours delivery to the nucleus of exogenous DNA introduced into the cytoplasm.     

Transient expression of fluorescent fusion proteins in protoplasts of suspension cultured cells

Transient expression of fluorescent fusion proteins in plant cells has dramatically facilitated our study of newly identified genes and proteins. This protocol details an in vivo transient expression system to study the subcellular localization and dynamic associations of plant proteins using protoplasts freshly prepared from Arabidopsis or tobacco BY-2 suspension cultured cells. The method relies on the transformation of DNA constructs into protoplasts via electroporation. The whole protocol is comprised of three major stages: protoplast generation and purification, transformation of DNA into protoplasts via electroporation and incubation of protoplasts for protein analysis. Similar to stably transformed cell lines, transformed protoplasts are compatible with protein localization studies, pharmaceutical drug treatment and western blot analysis. This protocol can be completed within 11-24 h from protoplast production to protein detection.     

质粒DNA物理形态和其它因素对获得可育转基因小麦的影响

本工作分析了不同形态质粒DNA和未成熟胚高渗透压处理对基因枪小麦转化体系的适用性.高渗处理对瞬间表达和转基因小麦的再生均有明显的促进作用.轰击之前对质粒DNA进行变性处理导致瞬间表达反应大幅度下降,但稳定转化频率(指从100个轰击未成熟胚得到的再生可育转基因植株数)与双链DNA相差不大.使用单链质粒DNA、线性双链质粒DNA和环状双链质粒DNA均可以得到转基因小麦植株.迄今已得到26个不同的转基因冬小麦株系和4个不同的转基因春小麦株系.这些转基因小麦大多数已产生种子,几个春小麦株系已获第二代种子.     

Hybrid genes in the analysis of transformation conditions: II. Transient expression vs stable transformation—analysis of parameters influencing gene expression levels and transformation efficiency

Reports on direct gene transfer have dealt with either the obtention of stable transformants and transgenic plants, or described the use of reporter genes to analyse different aspects of gene expression in plant protoplasts and conditions for their use in transient gene expression assays.
In this paper we present comparisons between several transformation techniques, show species-specific differences in efficiencies of stable transformants and in the levels of transient gene expression, and report on the identification of major parameters responsible for DNA uptake as judged from transient chloramphenicol acetyl transferase (CAT) expression levels and from efficiencies of transformation based on kanamycin-resistance. The described procedures have been simplified, optimized and standardized and should allow routine use with a great variety of plant species.     

Physical,chemical and physiological parameters for electroporation-mediated gene delivery into rice protoplasts

Transformation of cereal protoplasts has been reported using several methods; however, the efficiencies of transformations are still very low. We have evaluated a number of parameters that influence electroporation-mediated DNA uptake and have also compared the efficiency of transient GUS activity and stable transformation obtained using an optimized electroporation method with that of the PEG method. The electroporation conditions tested were ionic composition of buffer, ionic strength, resistivity of buffer, type of anions, voltage, and capacitance.Protoplasts isolated from suspension cultures derived from immature embryos of rice (cvs Radon and IR-54) were used for this study. Stable transformation or transient GUS expression experiments were carried out using a plasmid construct containing the CaMV 35S promoter driving thebar gene and a rice actin promoter driving thegus A (uid A) gene (pAG35bar). Electroporation under optimized conditions resulted in about 13-fold higher GUS activities compared to the PEG method. Protoplast survival following optimized electroporation conditions was 55–60%, compared to 35–40% with the PEG treatment. Protoplasts isolated from a suspension culture at different ages gave substantially different levels of transient GUS expression following electroporation-mediated DNA uptake. In contrast, the age of the suspension culture did not influence PEG-mediated DNA uptake and transient GUS activities, which remained low throughout the culture period examined (21 months). Putatively transformed calluses were selected after three to four weeks on medium containing phosphinothricin as the selection agent. The transformation frequencies ranged from 6.2×10^–5 to 5.4×10^–4 with the electroporation method compared to 1.3×10^–5 to 5.3×10^–5 with the PEG method. Southern blot analysis of PPT-resistant calluses obtained by the electroporation-mediated transformation showed simple intergration patterns of integrated DNA in most of the transformants.     

Factors influencing transient gene expression in electroporated tall fescue protoplasts

For the rapid establishment of optimal conditions for a genetic transformation system for tall fescue, several factors influencing transient gene expression were studied in protoplasts, after the reporter β-glucuronidase gene was introduced by electroporation. In a time-course study of transient gene expression, GUS activity peaked at 24 h after electroporation. Among the different field strength conditions tested, maximum GUS activity was observed at 750 V/cm. Increases in the amount of plasmid DNA to 80 μg/ml led to increased GUS activity. GUS activities increased in linear fashion with increasing protoplast densities up to 2 × 10⁶/ml. Age of suspension cells from which protoplasts were derived influenced transient expression with maximum GUS activity obtained in 3- and 5-day-old suspensions. These results show that monocot and dicot protoplasts respond similarly in electroporation.     

Electroporation of cells

By measuring uptake of the membrane impermeable dye. phenosafranine, it can be shown that the plasma membrane of intact cells within cell aggregates can be reversibly permeabilized by electroporation. However, the plant cell wall is a barrier to DNA uptake by intact cells, although under certain circumstances expression of DNA, electroporated into intact cells, can be demonstrated. The level of expression is about 20–50 times lower than that obtained by electroporation of protoplasts, and depends on cell wall properties and pretreatments of cell aggregates. In contrast, efficient transformation of whole cells of bacteria and yeasts can be achieved by electroporation. Factors which influence DNA transfer into whole plant cells and the possibility of stable transformation are discussed.     

质粒DNA物理形态和其它因素对获得可育转基因小麦的影响

The applicability of hyperosmotic treatment and different configurations of plasmid DNA for stable transformation of wheat mediated by particle bombardment was investigated. Hyperosmotic treatment increased the frequency of transient expression and had also a positive effect on stable transformation. Denaturation of plasmid DNA prior to bombardment led to dramatic reduction of transient expression. However, there were no marked differences between single-stranded and double-stranded DNA in stable transformation. Single-stranded plasmid DNA, double-stranded plasmid DNA in linear state and double-stranded plasmid DNA in circular state could all be used to produce transgenic wheat plants. A total of 26 independent transgenic plants of winter wheat genotype Florida and 4 independent transgenic plants of spring wheat genotype Veery were obtained. Most transgenic plants have set seeds. T2 seeds of some spring wheat transgenic plants have also been harvested.     

Genetic Transformation of Rice

Rice was the first major monocot crop species to be transformed and regenerated. Initially, rice transformation was limited to japonica cultivars. Subsequently, a number of indica and javanica cultivars have also been transformed and regenerated into fertile transgenic plants. Most transformation studies in rice have used direct DNA uptake into protoplasts, induced by polyethylene glycol treatment or electroporation. Recently, other transformation methods have been developed that are less genotype dependent, such as microprojectile bombardment of cell suspensions and immature embryos. This review summarizes progress in both protoplast-based and other transformation methods.     

Use of a transient expression assay for the optimization of direct gene transfer into tobacco mesophyll protoplasts by electroporation

Plasmid DNA was transfected into tobacco mesophyll protoplasts by electroporation. Transfection efficiency was estimated, using a transient expression assay based on the measurement of chloramphenicol transacetylase activity or by scoring colonies expressing resistance to paromomycin, an aminoglycoside related to kanamycin. Under conditions of cell survival superior to 50% after electroporation, transient expression signals and transformation efficiencies were found to be proportional. Factors affecting the efficiency of transformation were studied. A clear-cut optimum voltage (250-300 V/cm) was detected. Among various salts tested, potassium chloride was the best electrolyte. No improvement of electroporation efficiency was obtained by a heat-shock (45 degrees C/5 min) treatment prior to electroporation or by the presence of polyethylene glycol in the electroporation medium. The physiological state of plants used as the protoplast source significantly affected the transfection ability of the resulting protoplasts. These results are discussed and compared to previously published procedures.     

Electroporation: Mechanism and transient expression, stable transformation and biological effects in plant protoplasts

The present state of knowledge about the mechanistic and theoretical aspects of electroporation is summarized. Parameters affecting the efficiency of transient expression and stable transformation of electroporated plant protoplasts are rewieved. Biological effects of electroporation on plant protoplasts are described.     

Expression of green-fluorescent protein gene in sweet potato tissues

Green-fluorescent protein (GFP) gene expression, transient and stable after electroporation and particle bombardment, was analyzed in tissues of sweet potato cv.Beauregard. Leaf and petiole tissues were used for protoplast isolation and electroporation. After 48 h, approximately 25–30% of electroporated mesophyll cell protoplasts regenerated cell walls, and of these, 3% expressed GFP. Stable expression of GFP after four weeks of culture was observed in 1.0% of the initial GFP positive cells. In a separate experiment, we observed 600–700 loci expressing GFP 48 h after bombarding leaf tissue or embryogenic calli, and stable GFP-expressing sectors were seen in leaf-derived embryogenic calli after four weeks of protoplast culture without selection. These results demonstrate GFP gene expression in sweet potato tissues. Screening for GFP gene expression may prove useful to improve transformation efficiency and to facilitate detection of transformed sweet potato plants.     

Lipofectin: direct gene transfer to higher plants using cationic liposomes

Summary It has recently been shown that lipofectin, a commercially available preparation of cationic liposomes is capable of animal and plant cell line transfection. Here, it is analyzed with respect to its toxicity for higher plant protoplasts and used for transient expression and stable transformation experiments with mesophyll protoplasts of Nicotiana tabacum and Nicotiana plumbaginifolia. Transient expression of the -glucuronidase gene (GUS) under control of the CaMV-35S-promoter was lower than after introduction of the same gene by polyethylene glycol. By transferring the neomycin phosphotransferase gene (NPTII) and subsequent culture and regeneration under selection with kanamycin, stably transformed plants were recovered after using Lipofectin in various protocols with or without additional application of electroporation. Efficiencies of stable transformation were comparable to those achieved with PEG and/or electroporation. Confirmation of transformants included assaying the enzyme activity of the gene product, genomic blotting, and transfer of the resistant phenotype to the progeny produced from selfed primary transformants.     

Linear DNA introduced into carrot protoplasts by electroporation undergoes ligation and recircularization

The integrated DNA in stable transformants formed by direct gene transfer often shows complex restriction patterns. One cause of these complex restriction patterns could be the ligation of plasmid fragments prior to their integration. This paper provides evidence for the ligation of plasmid fragments by plant cells. Carrot protoplasts were electroporated in the presence of pCaMVCATM and assayed for chloramphenicol actyltransferase (CAT) activity 24h later. Linear and supercoiled forms of pCaMVCATM supported similar levels of CAT expression. Surprisingly, digestion of the plasmid at a site between the CaMV 35S promoter and the CAT coding region reduced expression by only 40–50%. Electroporation carried out in the presence of isolated plasmid fragments suggested that this result was due to ligation of the linearized plasmid by the protoplasts. CAT expression was obtained with a mixture of isolated CaMV 35S promoter and the CAT coding region; neither fragment alone supported expression. Further evidence of ligation was provided by electroporation of protoplasts in the presence of a mixture of linearized pGEM and the 1.5-kbHind III fragment of pCaMVCATM. DNA isolated from nuclei of the protoplasts was used to transform competent cells ofEscherichia coli, and colonies were recovered that carried pGEM withHind III-CaMVCAT inserts. Electroporation of protoplasts in the presence of linear and supercoiled pGEM and use of DNA isolated from nuclei to transformE. coli yielded an estimate of the frequency of plasmid ligation. A maximum of only 4% of the input linear DNA was recovered as circular molecules. This result suggests the frequency of ligation is low, but examination of the plasmid DNA in the plant nuclei by electrophoresis indicates extensive degradation of the plasmid and preferential loss of the circular forms. Thus, the ligated plasmids may be converted to the linear form and hence rendered unrecoverable by cloning intoE. coli.     

Linear forms of plasmid DNA are superior to supercoiled structures as active templates for gene expression in plant protoplasts

Introduction of the plasmids pUC8CaMVCAT and pNOSCAT into plant protoplasts is known to result in transient expression of the chloramphenicol acetyl transferase (CAT) gene. Also, transfection with the plasmid pDO432 results in transient appearance of the luciferase enzyme. In the present work we have used these systems to study the effect of DNA topology on the expression of the above recombinant genes. Linear forms of the above plasmids exhibited much higher activity in supporting gene expression than their corresponding super-coiled structures. CAT activity in protoplasts transfected with the linear forms of pUC8CaMVCAT and pNOSCAT was up to ten-fold higher than that observed in protoplasts transfected by the supercoiled template of these plasmids. This effect was observed in protoplasts derived from two different lines of Petunia hybrida and from a Nicotiana tabacum cell line. Transfection with the relaxed form of pUC8CaMVCAT resulted in very low expression of the CAT gene.Northern blot analysis revealed that the amount of poly(A)⁺ RNA extracted from protoplasts transformed with the linear forms of the DNA was about 10-fold higher than that found in protoplasts transformed with supercoiled DNA.Southern blot analysis revealed that about the same amounts of supercoiled and linear DNA molecules were present in nuclei of transfected protoplasts. No significant quantitative differences have been observed between the degradation rates of the various DNA templates used.     

Stable transformation of maize: the impact of feeder cells on protoplast growth and transformation efficiency

Summary The importance of cell culture conditions, including the use of feeder cells, on protoplast growth and transformation in maize (Zea mays L.) was investigated. Total GUS activity, measured two days after transformation, was five-fold higher in protoplasts cultured on feeder cells compared to those grown in the absence of feeder cells. Since the specific activity of GUS was only slightly higher in the transformed protoplasts plated over feeder cells, the stimulation in transient gene expression resulted mainly from the improved environment provided by the feeder system. For stable transformation, either PEG treatment or electroporation of protoplasts was used to introduce the neo gene. When PEG was used, over 85% of the putative transformants (resistant to kanamycin) contained the neo gene. The combination of PEG transformation and the optimized cell culture protocol using feeder cells enabled the selection of about 100 stably transformed lines per gFW of cells. Electroporation was less efficient.