Should the Same Safety Scrutiny of Antiobesity Medications be Applied to Other Chronic Usage Drugs?

Obesity treatment is highly stigmatized, mainly because of the stigma of obesity itself. The frequent withdrawal of medications, lorcaserin being the last example, contributes to this stigma, but it is also probably a reflection of it, as data suggest that the threshold for a withdrawal is lower than with other classes of drugs. Safety should always be an absolute priority for every new medication, especially when used on a chronic basis; however, the safety scrutiny given to antiobesity medications is not given for other medications, such as postmenopausal hormone therapy and central nervous system drugs for psychiatric use. The withdrawal of medications for obesity can also impact future research in the area, so we need transparency and equality. Transparency in knowing exactly what reason led to a drug being discontinued and equality in long‐term safety should be a concern with any medication prescribed for chronic diseases.     

Levodopa in Parkinsonism: the Effects of Withdrawal of Anticholinergic Drugs

The results are reported of a trial in which 34 patients receiving a stable dose of levodopa for the treatment of idiopathic Parkinsonism, as well as anticholinergic drugs which they had been taking before the introduction of levodopa, underwent withdrawal of their anticholinergic remedies. Withdrawal was gradual over four weeks in 17 patients (group 1) and abrupt in the remaining 17 (group 2).Only 11 out of 34 patients on stable levodopa therapy were able to tolerate withdrawal of anticholinergic drugs for more than eight weeks. The main reasons for the resumption of these remedies were subjective increases in slowness in 20 (59%), tremor in 15 (44%), and recurrence of hypersalivation in 5 (15%). Hypersalivation was the single feature which was most significantly and adversely influenced by anticholinergic withdrawal in patients on levodopa irrespective of whether withdrawal was sudden or gradual. It is suggested that the synergism which seems to exist between anticholinergic remedies and levodopa may be due to inhibition of dopamine inactivation by anticholinergic drugs, thus ensuring continual utilization, or alternatively, to a primary central anticholinergic effect.Objective and more severe subjective deterioration occurred only on sudden withdrawal. Hence we would advise that if for any reason anticholinergic drugs are to be withdrawn in patients receiving a stable dosage of levodopa this must be done slowly. Conversely it would appear from our results that the introduction of anticholinergic drugs in patients treated initially with levodopa is likely to produce additional benefit, particularly when the maximum tolerated dose of levodopa is small.     

Drug Withdrawal Syndromes: A Literature Review

Drug withdrawal syndromes reportedly have been caused by numerous pharmacological agents, but only a few drugs have been adequately studied in this regard. Criteria for evaluating drug withdrawal syndromes have been proposed. Sedative-hypnotic agents, opiates, corticosteroids, clonidine, tricyclic antidepressant medications and beta-adrenergic blocking agents meet the criteria for such syndromes. Gradual tapering of the dose of these drugs is recommended when therapy must be discontinued. Whether or not other drugs cause rebound reactions is questionable, but caution should be used when discontinuing drugs for which numerous reports of withdrawal syndromes exist.     

The pentylenetetrazol model of anxiety detects withdrawal from diazepam in rats

This experiment tested whether benzodiazepine withdrawal could be detected in an animal model of anxiety. Rats were trained in operant chambers using food reward to press one lever after pentylenetetrazol (PTZ), 20 mg/kg, injection and the other lever after saline injection. Previously, the PTZ cue has been shown to be simulated by anxiogenic drugs and blocked by anxiolytic drugs. After rats reliably performed this discrimination, they were injected with diazepam, 20 mg/kg, from 1 to 4 times a day for six days. For one group of subjects, on the third, fourth and sixth days, they were also injected with 40 mg/kg of RO 15-1788, a benzodiazepine receptor antagonist, and tested for lever selection: 50–80% of the subjects selected the PTZ lever; these results are in contrast to those obtained prior to chronic diazepam treatment in which RO 15-1788 did not generalize to PTZ. A second group of subjects was also injected for six days with diazepam and then allowed to withdraw spontaneously for eight days: PTZ lever selection over this period varied from 20 to 60% of rats. These data indicate that animals trained to discriminate a PTZ cue: 1) generalize the benzodiazepine withdrawal state to the PTZ cue, and 2) discriminate the withdrawal state for long periods of time, agreeing with clinical observations of long-lasting anxiety signs during benzodiazepine withdrawal.     

Morphometric analysis of the regression in the changes occurring in the adrenal cortex in experimental hypercholesterolemia

Morphometric, histochemical and biochemical methods were used to study the adrenal cortex of rabbits given cholesterol over 60 days' period and killed 5.5 months after the treatment was discontinued. Cholesterol-induced changes were found to undergo considerable regression 5.5 months after the treatment withdrawal.     

Regional Alterations in Blood-to-Brain Transfer of α-Aminoisobutyric Acid and Sucrose, After Chronic Administration and Withdrawal of Dexamethasone

The effect of dexamethasone administration and withdrawal was studied with respect to blood-brain barrier function. The tracers alpha-[3H]aminoisobutyric acid (AIB) (MW 104) and [14C]sucrose (MW 342), which have a low permeability across the intact endothelium, were simultaneously injected intravenously in rats treated with dexamethasone and placebo-treated control animals or in rats in which dexamethasone treatment was discontinued 3 days before the experiment. Unidirectional transfer constants (Ki) were determined in discrete brain regions. Steroid administration reduced the rate of influx of AIB and sucrose, whereas discontinuation of drug resulted in an increased permeability. These findings suggest that when exposure to glucocorticoids is prolonged, the efficiency of medical treatment of CNS diseases may decrease due to reduction of drug delivery to CNS. Thus, these experimental findings may have particular importance in the clinical setting of drug administration when considering the combination of steroids with other drugs, and may aid in understanding better the pathogenesis of some types of brain edema seen in patients from whom corticosteroid therapy has been withdrawn.     

Follow-up of Cases of Opiate Addiction from the Time of Notification to the Home Office

Follow-up of 108 opiate addicts for a period of six to seven years showed that 35 were still being prescribed opiates, 25 were off drugs, 19 were dead, and for 29 it was not certain whether they were on or off drugs. Most patients who came off drugs did so in the first two years after notification to the Home Office. Clearly treatment is more likely to be successful if given early in the life history of the addict, when it is appropriate to give treatment based on withdrawal of drugs rather than substitution.     

Controlled study of withdrawal symptoms and rebound anxiety after six week course of diazepam for generalised anxiety.

A group of patients suffering from anxiety, as assessed by general practitioners and psychologists using research criteria for generalised anxiety, were treated with either diazepam or placebo double blind for six weeks. This active treatment period was preceded by a one week single blind placebo "wash in" period and followed by a two week single blind placebo "wash out" period. The results suggest that diazepam can produce rebound anxiety and withdrawal symptoms when used in moderate doses and for what has previously been regarded as a safe length of time. If replicated these results have implications for the therapeutic use of benzodiazepines.     

Benzodiazepineverslaving; een stille verslaving onder ouderen

Benzodiazepines are frequently prescribed for a longer period of time for anxiety disorders and insomnia in spite of the many guidelines to prescribe these drugs only short-term. These guidelines are based on the risk-benefit balance between long-term effectiveness and side effects like addiction, anterograde amnesia, and increased risk on falling (resulting in hip fractures), traffic accidents and even mortality. Also low-dose benzodiazepine use can lead to benzodiazepine dependence. Although initially most attention has been paid to the physical withdrawal syndrome, psychological aspects of benzodiazepine dependence have received more and more attention in the past decades. Recently, a relationship between the brain-reward system, involved in addiction, and benzodiazepine use, was demonstrated. When long-term benzodiazepine use is recognised as problematic by both physician and patient, different treatment modalities are available to support patients in achieving abstinence. One of every four patients is able to stop by themselves with the aid of a minimal intervention providing psychoeducation and encouragement. Two out of three long-term uses are able to stop their usage with the aid of systematic tapering protocols guided by a physician or psychologist. In case of an underlying insomnia or anxiety disorder, cognitive-behavioural therapy should be added to the tapering protocol. In contrast to the general opinion, advanced old age has no negative impact on the treatment response.     

Diazepam withdrawal syndrome: its prolonged and changing nature.

The diazepam withdrawal syndrome was studied in 10 patients who had abused the drug for 3 to 14 years. In the previous 6 months their consumption of diazepam had ranged from 60 to 120 mg daily; none had used other drugs during this period. The withdrawal period lasted about 6 weeks. The intensity of the symptoms and signs was high initially, fell during the first 2 weeks, then rose again in the third week, before finally declining. Three groups of symptoms and signs were identified. Group A symptoms occurred throughout withdrawal and included tremor, anorexia, insomnia and myoclonus. Group B symptoms and signs were largely confined to the first 10 days and were those of a toxic psychosis. Group C symptoms reached a peak in the third and fourth weeks of withdrawal and were characterized by sense perceptions that were either heightened or lowered. The symptom groups, the presence of tremor and myoclonus, and the relief of symptoms by a test dose permit diazepam withdrawal to be distinguished from anxiety. The biphasic course of the symptoms is probably related to the pharmacokinetics of diazepam.     

Evidence for permanent enhancement of residual ADH induced by antidiuretic agents (chlorpropamide, carbamazepine, clofibrate) in patients with pituitary diabetes insipidus.

Excretion of free water was studied in 7 patients with pituitary diabetes insipidus before treatment and after withdrawal of antidiuretic drugs (chlorpropamide, carbamazepine, clofibrate) used on a long-term basis. A statistically significant decrease in free water clearance was found after 2-4 weeks of withdrawal of antidiuretic agents. This was considered as a clinical evidence for the permanently enhanced release of residual ADH induced by chlorpropamide, carbamazepine and clofibrate in patients with partial defect in ADH secretion.     

Alterations in cerebral diazepam binding inhibitor expression in drug dependence: a possible biochemical alteration common to drug dependence

Mechanisms for formation of drug dependence and expression of withdrawal syndrome have not fully clarified despite of huge accumulation of experimental and clinical data at present. Several clinical features of withdrawal syndrome are considered to be common among patients with drug dependence induced by different drugs of abuse. One of them is anxiety. Recent investigations have revealed that diazepam binding inhibitor (DBI), a peptide consisting of 87 amino acids with molecular weight of about 10 kDa, serves as an inverse agonist for benzodiazepine (BZD) receptors with endogenously anxiogenic potential. These lines of data suggest that cerebral DBI expression in brain may participates in formation of drug dependence and/or emergence of withdrawal syndrome. Based on this working hypothesis, we have examined DBI expression in the brain derived from mice depended on alcohol (ethanol), nicotine, and morphine to investigate functional relationship between cerebral DBI expression and drug dependence. Cerebral DBI expression significantly increases in animals with drug dependence induced by these drugs, and in the cases of nicotine- and morphine-dependent mice concomitant administration of antagonists for nicotinic acetylcholine and opioid receptors, respectively, abolished the increase. Abrupt cessation of administration of drugs facilitated further increase in DBI expression. Therefore, these alterations in DBI expression have close relationship with formation of drug dependence and/or emergence of withdrawal syndrome, and are considered to be a common biochemical process in drug dependence induced by different drugs of abuse. Finding and elucidation of mechanisms for common biochemical alterations among drug dependence may provide a clue to clarify mechanisms for formation of drug dependence and/or emergence of withdrawal syndrome.     

TSH and prolactin secretions in Hashimoto's thyroiditis following withdrawal of thyroid hormone therapy

Changes in the pituitary-thyroid axis in patients with Hashimoto's thyroiditis following withdrawal of thyroid suppressive therapy were analyzed. The group of patients with thyroid adenoma served as control (group I). Patients with Hashimoto's thyroiditis were divided into 2 groups on the basis of serum TSH levels 8 weeks after discontinuing the exogenous thyroid hormone (group II, less than 10 microunits/ml; group III, more than 10 microunits/ml). During treatment with L-T4(200 micrograms/day) or L-T3(50 micrograms/day), there was no significant difference in serum T4-I and T3 levels among the three groups. Following L-T4 withdrawal, basal serum TSH levels were higher at 2 to 8 weeks in groups II and III than in group I. Serum TSH response to TRH was greater at 4 to 8 weeks in groups II and III than in group I. Following L-T3 withdrawal, basal serum TSH levels were higher at 1 and 2 weeks in group II than in group I, while those of group III were consistently higher during the study. Higher TSH responses to TRH were observed at 1 to 8 weeks in groups II and III. Neither basal nor TRH-induced prolactin (PRL) secretion differed significantly among the three groups. We have demonstrated that pituitary TSH secretion in patients with Hashimoto's thyroiditis is affected more by withdrawal of thyroid hormone therapy than in patients with thyroid adenoma. In addition, the present findings suggest a difference between the sensitivity of thyrotrophs and lactotrophs in Hashimoto's thyroiditis after prolonged thyroid therapy is discontinued.     

In Canada: A Trial of Chemoprophylaxis in Inactive Tuberculosis

One thousand five hundred and thirty-six patients with inactive tuberculosis were given a course of preventive treatment consisting of either INH alone or INH and PAS while 840 similar patients served as a control group. Discontinuation of the treatment was frequent and was usually caused by development of complaints which the patients ascribed to the drugs they were taking.The annual reactivation rate among controls was 4.9 per 1000. During the period of taking drugs the treated group suffered a reactivation rate of 0.7 per 1000 and those who had taken the medication for at least six months suffered a subsequent annual reactivation rate of 1.3 per 1000. The rate for those who discontinued treatment in the first six months was 5.1 per 1000. There were no reactivations in patients who took INH and PAS for over six months. Bacilli from two of the patients with reactivations who were treated for a prolonged period with INH alone showed resistance to this drug.Chemoprophylaxis of inactive cases is a potent weapon in tuberculosis control; however, it requires thorough motivation and supervision.     

Two Anti-anxiety Drugs: A Psychoneuroendocrine Study

Eight males were studied during 27 weeks, including two periods of five weeks during which they received clinical doses of sodium amylobarbitone and benzoctamine. Substitution of placebo for either drug caused raised anxiety and impairment of mental concentration. The drugs reduced restlessness during sleep and reduced paradoxical sleep. By the fifth week of sodium amylobarbitone, although sleep was still less restless in the early night it was more restless than normal in the late night.Blood samples were taken half-hourly during sleep by indwelling venous catheter. Plasma growth hormone concentration was little affected during drug administration but rose temporarily after withdrawal. There was a reduction of plasma corticosteroid concentration during sleep throughout administration of the drugs and a rebound above normal during the first withdrawal week.     

Serotonin modulates anxiety-like behaviors during withdrawal from adolescent anabolic–androgenic steroid exposure in Syrian hamsters

From the U.S. to Europe and Australia anabolic steroid abuse remains high in the adolescent population. This is concerning given that anabolic steroid use is associated with a higher incidence of pathological anxiety that often appears during withdrawal from use. This study uses pubertal Syrian hamsters (Mesocricetus auratus) to investigate the hypothesis that adolescent anabolic/androgenic steroid (AAS) exposure predisposes hamsters to heightened levels of anxiety during AAS withdrawal that is modulated by serotonin (5HT) neural signaling. In the first two sets of experiments, adolescent AAS-treated hamsters were tested for anxiety 21 days after the cessation of AAS administration (i.e., during AAS withdrawal) using the elevated plus maze (EPM), dark/light (DL), and seed finding (SF) tests and then examined for differences in 5HT afferent innervation to select areas of the brain important for anxiety. In the EPM and DL tests, adolescent AAS exposure leads to significant increases in anxiety-like response during AAS withdrawal. AAS-treated hamsters showed long-term reductions in 5HT innervation within several areas of the hamster brain implicated in anxiety, most notably the anterior hypothalamus and the central and medial amygdala. However, no differences in 5HT were found in other anxiety areas, e.g., frontal cortex and lateral septum. In the last experiment, adolescent AAS-treated hamsters were scored for anxiety on the 21st day of AAS withdrawal following the systemic administration of saline or one of three doses of fluoxetine, a selective serotonin reuptake inhibitor. Saline-treated hamsters showed high levels of AAS withdrawal-induced anxiety, while treatment with fluoxetine reduced AAS withdrawal-induced anxiety. These findings indicate that early AAS exposure has potent anxiogenic effects during AAS withdrawal that are modulated, in part, by 5HT signaling.     

Chronic morphine treatment decreases acoustic startle response and prepulse inhibition in rats

The reward-related effects of addictive drugs primarily act via the dopamine system, which also plays an important role in sensorimotor gating. The mesolimbic dopamine system is the common pathway of drug addiction and sensorimotor gating. However, the way in which addictive drugs affect sensorimotor gating is currently unclear. In previous studies, we examined the effects of morphine treatment on sensory gating in the hippocampus. The present study investigated the effects of morphine on sensorimotor gating in rats during chronic morphine treatment and withdrawal. Rats were examined during treatment with morphine for 10 successive days, followed by a withdrawal period. Acoustic startle responses to a single startle stimulus (115 dB SPL) and prepulse inhibition responses were recorded. The results showed that acoustic startle responses were attenuated during morphine treatment, but not during withdrawal. PPI was impaired in the last 2 morphine treatment days, but returned to a normal level during withdrawal.     

Is steroid therapy needed in the treatment of destructive thyrotoxicosis induced by alpha-interferon in chronic hepatitis C?

OBJECTIVE: Treatment with interferon (IFN) of patients affected by chronic hepatitis C (CH-C) may produce alterations in thyroid function, such as hypothyroidism, Graves'-like hyperthyroidism and destructive thyrotoxicosis (DT). IFN-induced DT is characterized by suppressed serum TSH levels, normal or elevated FT4 and FT3 concentrations, with the presence or absence of thyroid peroxidase antibodies and antithyroglobulin antibodies, the absence of thyroid receptor antibodies and radioactive iodine uptake suppressed or <5%. DESIGN: IFN-induced DT is a mild clinical disease, because thyroid-destructive processes last for a short time and involve a small portion of the gland. At present, the therapeutic approach in DT suggests IFN withdrawal and 1-2 months of methylprednisolone treatment. METHODS: In consideration of possible untoward side effects of steroid treatment in patients with CH-C, we studied two groups of patients with CH-C who developed DT after treatments with various preparations of recombinant IFN (with or without ribavirin). Patients sequentially entered the study during a 4-year period, at the time of DT diagnosis, when IFN therapy was discontinued. The first 12 subjects (group A) were treated with 8-16 mg/day methylprednisolone for 30-40 days after IFN withdrawal; in the following 15 patients (group B), IFN withdrawal was not followed by any additional treatment. All patients underwent clinical and laboratory controls of thyroid function at 1, 2, 3 and 6 months after DT diagnosis. RESULTS: The results showed restoration of euthyroidism in both group A and group B patients at 6 months after DT diagnosis, regardless of steroid treatment. CONCLUSIONS: The simple withdrawal of IFN therapy in patients with CH-C, who had developed DT, appears to be effective in the treatment of the thyroid disease. This therapeutic approach should be preferred in order to avoid possible undesired side effects of steroid therapy in patients with CH-C.     

Predictors of normotension on withdrawal of antihypertensive drugs in elderly patients: prospective study in second Australian national blood pressure study cohort

ObjectivesTo identify simple long term predictors of maintenance of normotension after withdrawal of antihypertensive drugs in elderly patients in general practice.DesignProspective cohort study.Setting169 general practices in Victoria, Australia.Participants503 patients aged 65-84 with treated hypertension who were withdrawn from all antihypertensive drugs and remained drug free and normotensive for an initial two week period; all were followed for a further 12 months.ResultsThe likelihood of remaining normotensive at 12 months was greater among younger patients (65-74 years), patients with lower “on-treatment” systolic blood pressure, patients on single agent treatment, and patients with a greater waist:hip ratio. The likelihood of return to hypertension was greatest for patients with higher “on-treatment” systolic blood pressure.ConclusionsAge, blood pressure control, and the number of antihypertensive drugs are important factors in the clinical decision to withdraw drug treatment. Because of consistent rates of return to antihypertensive treatment, all patients from whom such treatment is withdrawn should be monitored indefinitely to detect a recurrence of hypertension.

What is already known on this topic

Systematic reviews have identified predictors of success of withdrawal of antihypertensive medicationThe reviewed studies have mainly been in a hospital or specialist clinic setting, and their recommendations may not be practical in general practice

What this paper adds

This study has identified simple predictors of success that are readily available to general practitionersOn-treatment systolic blood pressure, the number of blood pressure lowering drugs, and the age of the patient are reliable indicators of who may successfully stop taking their drugsGeneral practitioner practitioners should not be dissuaded from offering drug withdrawal to patients with greater waist:hip ratios     

The management of hyperthyroidism due to Graves' disease in Japan in 1988. The Japan Thyroid Association

The management of hyperthyroidism due to Graves' disease in Japan was the subject of a survey of the members of the Japan Thyroid Association (JTA), and the results were compared to those of the European Thyroid Association (ETA). In the questionnaire, in vivo and in vitro diagnostic procedures, the choice of treatment and the details of the treatment for a patient with typical, moderate and uncomplicated hyperthyroidism due to Graves' disease was at first asked, and eight variations with a single alternative were proposed to evaluate how each alternative would affect the choice of treatment. For the diagnostic procedures, thyroid uptake/scintigraphy was carried out by approximately 60% of the respondents and the isotope mainly used was 123I. The number of in vitro tests used for diagnosis averaged 8.1 +/- 1.8 tests. Measurements of basal TSH and free T4 were the most frequent tests performed to confirm the diagnosis of hyperthyroidism (94 and 80%, respectively). Determinations of microsomal, thyroglobulin and TSH-receptor autoantibodies were also employed by many respondents (96, 96 and 77%, respectively). On the other hand, the free T4 index and TRH test were less frequently employed. In the treatment of these patients, antithyroid drug treatment was the first choice, and surgery was not, in general, regarded as a primary therapy except in a patient with a large goiter. The frequency of the respondents who advocated radioiodine therapy was considerably higher for patients with recurrences and old age. No respondents proposed radioiodine therapy for young patients. Specialists tended to favor their own specialist treatment regimens. The initial dose of antithyroid drugs was reduced according to thyroid function, and withdrawal of antithyroid drug treatment was determined by some specific criteria (basal TSH in supersensitive assays, TSH-receptor autoantibodies, T3 suppression test, etc.). The aim of radioiodine therapy and surgery was to restore euthyroidism. The significant differences between the results from the JTA and those from the ETA were as follows; radionuclide used for thyroid uptake/scintigraphy was mainly 123I in Japan, but 131I in Europe, the number of diagnostic studies in Japan was more than that in Europe, and the dosage of antithyroid drugs was reduced according to thyroid function and discontinued based on certain specific criteria in Japan, but after fixed periods in Europe. These results may represent actual trends in how hyperthyroidism due to Graves' disease is managed in specialist clinics in Japan today and the differences between the JTA and the ETA.