A comparative study of the NAH and TOL catabolic plasmids in Pseudomonas putida

A comparative study of the NAH and TOL catabolic plasmids was carried out to provide information for future genetic manipulation experiments involving these two plasmids. The plasmids were studied in a strain of P. putida and its mutant derivatives. The NAH and TOL plasmids were found to be incompatible. Under the conditions used in these experiments the TOL plasmid transferred into some strains into which NAH was unable to transfer. The use of mutants to remove certain catabolic activities encoded by the bacterial host cell facilitated the allocation of growth genotypes to the NAH and TOL plasmids. TOL encoded the degradation of benzoate, m-toluate and p-toluate, whereas NAH encoded the degradation of naphthalene and salicylate. The other plasmid-associated growth phenotypes were partly plasmid-specified and partly specified by the host cell. The pH optimum of the catechol 2,3-dioxygenase specified by the TOL plasmid was approximately 6.7, whereas that of the NAH-encoded enzyme was approximately 8.3.     

Characterization of Pseudomonas putida mutants unable to catabolize benzoate: cloning and characterization of Pseudomonas genes involved in benzoate catabolism and isolation of a chromosomal DNA fragment able to substitute for xylS in activation of the TOL lower-pathway promoter.

Mutants of Pseudomonas putida mt-2 that are unable to convert benzoate to catechol were isolated and grouped into two classes: those that did not initiate attack on benzoate and those that accumulated 3,5-cyclohexadiene-1,2-diol-1-carboxylic acid (benzoate diol). The latter mutants, represents by strain PP0201, were shown to lack benzoate diol dehydrogenase (benD) activity. Mutants from the former class were presumed either to carry lesions in one or more subunit structural genes of benzoate dioxygenase (benABC) or the regulatory gene (benR) or to contain multiple mutations. Previous work in this laboratory suggested that benR can substitute for the TOL plasmid-encoded xylS regulatory gene, which promotes gene expression from the OP2 region of the lower or meta pathway operon. Accordingly, structural and regulatory gene mutations were distinguished by the ability of benzoate-grown mutant strains to induce expression from OP2 without xylS by using the TOL plasmid xylE gene (encoding catechol 2,3-dioxygenase) as a reporter. A cloned 12-kb BamHI chromosomal DNA fragment from the P. aeruginosa PAO1 chromosome complemented all of the mutations, as shown by restoration of growth on benzoate minimal medium. Subcloning and deletion analyses allowed identification of DNA fragments carrying benD, benABC, and the region possessing xylS substitution activity, benR. Expression of these genes was examined in a strain devoid of benzoate-utilizing ability, Pseudomonas fluorescens PFO15. The disappearance of benzoate and the production of catechol were determined by chromatographic analysis of supernatants from cultures grown with casamino acids. When P. fluorescens PFO15 was transformed with plasmids containing only benABCD, no loss of benzoate was observed. When either benR or xylS was cloned into plasmids compatible with those plasmids containing only the benABCD regions, benzoate was removed from the medium and catechol was produced. Regulation of expression of the chromosomal structural genes by benR and xylS was quantified by benzoate diol dehydrogenase enzyme assays. The results obtained when xylS was substituted for benR strongly suggest an isofunctional regulatory mechanism between the TOL plasmid lower-pathway genes (via the OP2 promoter) and chromosomal benABC. Southern hybridizations demonstrated that DNA encoding the benzoate dioxygenase structural genes showed homology to DNA encoding toluate dioxygenase from the TOL plasmid pWW0, but benR did not show homology to xylS. Evolutionary relationships between the regulatory systems of chromosomal and plasmid-encoded genes for the catabolism of benzoate and related compounds are suggested.     

Molecular relationships between pseudomonas INC P-9 degradative plasmids TOL, NAH, and SAL

We have examined the extent to which the degradative plasmids SAL, NAH, and TOL of the Inc P-9 incompatibility group share common DNA sequences. The homology we observe using 32P-labeled SAL and NAH DNA probes can be assigned to six regions of the TOL (pWWO) restriction endonuclease cleavage map. At least three of these regions are probably related to transfer and replication functions, whereas a fourth region is related to the common metacleavage pathway. Restriction endonuclease maps of the SAL and NAH plasmids are derived and the relationships between these plasmids discussed.     

Evolutionary relationships between catabolic pathways for aromatics: Conservation of gene order and nucleotide sequences of catechol oxidation genes of pWW0 and NAH7 plasmids

Summary TOL plasmid pWW0 and plasmid NAH7 encode catabolic enzymes required for oxidative degradation of toluene and naphthalene, respectively. The gene order of the catabolic operon of NAH7 for salicylate oxidation was determined to be: promoter-nahG (the structural gene for salicylate hydroxylase)-nahH (catechol 2,3-dioxygenase)-nahI (hydroxymuconic semialdehyde dehydrogenase)-nahN (hydroxymuconic semialdehyde hydrolase)-nahL (2-oxopent-4-enoate hydratase). This order is identical to that of the isofunctional genes of TOL plasmid pWW0. The complete nucleotide sequence of nahH was determined and compared with that of xylE, the isofunctional gene of TOL plasmid pWW0. There were 20% and 16% differences in their nucleotide and amino acid sequences, respectively. The homology between the NAH7 and TOL pWW0 plasmids ends upstream of the Shine-Dalgarno sequences of nahH and xylE, but the homology continues downstream of these genes. This observation suggested that genes for the catechol oxidative enzymes of NAH7 and TOL pWW0 were derived from a common ancestral sequence which was transferred as a discrete segment of DNA between plasmids.     

Application of DNA-DNA colony hybridization to the detection of catabolic genotypes in environmental samples

The application of preexisting DNA hybridization techniques was investigated for potential in determining populations of specific gene sequences in environmental samples. Cross-hybridizations among two degradative plasmids, TOL and NAH, and two cloning vehicles, pLAFR1 and RSF1010, were determined. The detection limits for the TOL plasmid against a nonhomologous plasmid-bearing bacterial background was ascertained. The colony hybridization technique allowed detection of one colony containing TOL plasmid among 10(6) Escherichia coli colonies of nonhomologous DNA. Comparisons between population estimates derived from growth on selective substrates and from hybridizations were examined. Findings indicated that standard sole carbon source enumeration procedures for degradative populations lead to overestimations due to nonspecific growth of other bacteria on the microcontaminant carbon sources present in the media. Population estimates based on the selective growth of a microcosm population on two aromatic substrates (toluene and naphthalene) and estimates derived from DNA-DNA colony hybridizations, using the TOL or NAH plasmid as a probe, corresponded with estimates of substrate mineralization rates and past exposure to environmental contaminants. The applications of such techniques are hoped to eventually allow enumeration of any specific gene sequences in the environment, including both anabolic and catabolic genes. In addition, this procedure should prove useful in monitoring recombinant DNA clones released into environmental situations.     

The effect of lipophilic weak acids on the segregational stability of TOL plasmids in Pseudomonas putida

The effect of various lipophilic weak acids on the stability of certain TOL plasmids was investigated. Benzoate induced deletion of TOL plasmid DNA in Pseudomonas putida MT15, followed by loss of the plasmid; this effect was pH- and concentration-dependent, suggesting that undissociated benzoic acid was a more effective curing agent than the benzoate anion. Plasmid loss always approached a frequency of 100% after a lag and apparently depended on the prior occurrence of deletions, although deleted plasmid was stably maintained in the absence of the acid. m-Toluate, acetate and butyrate also induced deletions and plasmid loss at high frequencies, although these acids were less effective than benzoate. Benzoate inhibited the growth of plasmid-containing cells rather than permitting faster growth of cured cells on benzoate. Similar results were obtained with P. putida strains MT20 and MT84, which contain different TOL plasmids. We suggest that lipophilic weak acids induced deletions, possibly by excision of a transposon-like region, and disrupted the segregation of deleted plasmid.     

Application of DNA-DNA colony hybridization to the detection of catabolic genotypes in environmental samples.

The application of preexisting DNA hybridization techniques was investigated for potential in determining populations of specific gene sequences in environmental samples. Cross-hybridizations among two degradative plasmids, TOL and NAH, and two cloning vehicles, pLAFR1 and RSF1010, were determined. The detection limits for the TOL plasmid against a nonhomologous plasmid-bearing bacterial background was ascertained. The colony hybridization technique allowed detection of one colony containing TOL plasmid among 10(6) Escherichia coli colonies of nonhomologous DNA. Comparisons between population estimates derived from growth on selective substrates and from hybridizations were examined. Findings indicated that standard sole carbon source enumeration procedures for degradative populations lead to overestimations due to nonspecific growth of other bacteria on the microcontaminant carbon sources present in the media. Population estimates based on the selective growth of a microcosm population on two aromatic substrates (toluene and naphthalene) and estimates derived from DNA-DNA colony hybridizations, using the TOL or NAH plasmid as a probe, corresponded with estimates of substrate mineralization rates and past exposure to environmental contaminants. The applications of such techniques are hoped to eventually allow enumeration of any specific gene sequences in the environment, including both anabolic and catabolic genes. In addition, this procedure should prove useful in monitoring recombinant DNA clones released into environmental situations.     

Ubiquity of plasmids in coding for toluene and xylene metabolism in soil bacteria: evidence for the existence of new TOL plasmids.

Thirteen bacteria have been isolated from nine different soil samples by selective enrichment culture on m-toluate (m-methylbenzoate) minimal medium. Eight of these were classified as Pseudomonas putida, one as a fluorescent Pseudomonas sp., and four as nonfluorescent Pseudomonas sp. All 13 strains appeared to carry TOL plasmids superficially similar to that previously described in P. putida mt-2 in that: (i) all the wild-type strains could utilize toluene, m-xylene, and p-xylene as sole carbon and energy sources, (ii) these growth substrates were metabolized through the corresponding alcohols and aldehydes to benzoate, m-toluate, and p-toluate, respectively, and thence by the divergent meta (or alpha-ketoacid) pathway, and (iii) the isolates could simultaneously and spontaneously lose their ability to utilize the hydrocarbons, alcohols, aldehydes, and acids, particularly during growth on benzoate, giving rise to cured strains which could grow only on benzaldehyde and benzoate of the aromatic substrates by the alternative ortho (or beta-ketoadipate) pathway. Eight of the isolates were able to transfer their TOL plasmids into their own cured strains, but only five were able to transfer them in interstrain conjugation into the cured strains, but only five were able to transfer them in interstrain conjugation into the cured derivative of P. putida mt-2. However, P. putida mt-2 was able to transfer its TOL plasmid into 11 of the cured isolates, and eight of these were able to retransmit this foreign plasmid in intrastrain conjugation with their own cured derivatives. Three of the isolates, MT 14, MT 15, and MT 20, differed significantly from the others in that the wild-type strains dissimilated the p-methyl-substituted substrates poorly, and also, during growth on benzoate, in addition to the cured derivatives, they gave rise to derivatives with a phenotype intermediate between the cured and wild-type strains, the biochemical and genetic nature of which has not been elucidated.     

Molecular relationships of degradative plasmids determined by in situ hybridisation of their endonuclease-generated fragments

Summary Plasmid inter-relationships were studied by hybridisation of a radioactively labelled DNA probe to endonuclease-derived fragmentation patterns of plasmids bound to a nitrocellulose filter. The degradative plasmids SAL and NAH were found to be very closely related, but probably one did not give rise to the other by just a single deletion or insertion. Relationships between SAL and other degradative plasmids are complex; substantial homology was found with TOL and other plasmids encoding toluate dissimilation and significant homology was found with OCT.     

Impact of Growth in Benzoate and m-Toluate Liquid Media on Culturability of Pseudomonas putida on Benzoate and m-Toluate Plates

Pseudomonas putida grown in continuous culture on benzoate or m-toluate lost the ability to grow on benzoate or m-toluate plates. A similar effect was not seen with a glucose continuous culture. Cells carrying and expressing a TOL plasmid rapidly lost their ability to grow on benzoate solid medium.     

Enzyme recruitment in vitro: use of cloned genes to extend the range of haloaromatics degraded by Pseudomonas sp. strain B13.

DNA fragments containing the xylD and xylL genes of TOL plasmid pWW0 -161 of Pseudomonas putida, which code for the catabolic enzymes toluate 1,2-dioxygenase and dihydrodihydroxybenzoic acid dehydrogenase, respectively, and the nahG gene of the NAH plasmid NAH7 , which codes for salicylate hydroxylase, were cloned in pBR322 vector plasmid. Deletion and insertion mutagenesis were used to localize these genes with respect to crucial endonuclease cleavage sites. The pBR322-based plasmids were ligated to the broad host range cloning vector pKT231 , or derivatives of it, and the hybrid plasmids were introduced into Pseudomonas sp. B13( WR1 ), a bacterium able to degrade 3-chlorobenzoate but not 4-chlorobenzoate, 3,5- dichlorobenzoate , salicylate, or chlorosalicylates . The cloned xylD gene expanded the catabolic range of WR1 to include 4-chlorobenzoate, whereas the cloned xylD - xylL genes enabled the isolation of derivatives of WR1 that degraded 3-chlorobenzoate, 4-chlorobenzoate, and 3,5- dichlorobenzoate . The cloned nahG gene extended the catabolic range of WR1 to include salicylate and 3-, 4-, and 5- chlorosalicylate .     

Tolerance and biodegradation of m-toluate by Scots pine, a mycorrhizal fungus and fluorescent pseudomonads individually and under associative conditions

The tolerance to, and degradation of m-toluate by Scots pine (Pinus sylvestris), a symbiotic mycorrhizal fungus (Suillus bovinus) and Pseudomonas fluorescens strains, with or without m-toluate-degrading capacity, was determined individually and in all symbiotic/associative plant-microbe combinations. Fungal survival on medium with m-toluate was increased in co-culture with the degradative bacterial strains on agar plates (up to 0.02%, w/v). When fungi were grown in mycorrhizal association with Scots pine seedlings in test-tube microcosms containing expanded clay pellets and growth media, the fungus was able to withstand m-toluate concentrations up to 2.0%, w/v in all treatments. The seedling tolerance remained unaltered regardless of the presence or absence of mycorrhizal fungi or biodegradative bacteria. Reduction in m-toluate levels was only detected in treatments inoculated with bacterial strains harbouring TOL catabolic plasmids. The plant and fungus, alone or in mycorrhizal symbiosis, were unable to cleave m-toluate. The presence of easily available plant-derived carbon sources did not impede m-toluate degradation by the bacteria in the mycorrhizosphere.     

Naphthalene plasmids in pseudomonads.

A rapid method beginning with the direct lysis of bacteria in alkaline sodium dodecyl sulfate was used to detect naphthalene plasmids in pseudomonads. The strains NCIB 9816, PG, ATCC 17483, and ATCC 17484, which can grow on naphthalene as the sole source of carbon and energy, were examined. All except ATCC 17483 contained more than one plasmid. ATCC 17483 did not contain any plasmids. The largest pair of plasmids found in each of NCIB 9816 and PG(NAH2 and NAH3, respectively) determined naphthalene metabolism and could be transferred by conjugation. This also transferred the unusually regulated meta pathway enzymes for catechol metabolism. NAH2 determines the constitutive production of low concentrations of catechol 2,3-dioxygenase and 2-hydroxymuconic acid semialdehyde dehydrogenase, and NAH3 determines the constitutive production of high concentration of these. NAH2 and NAH3 gave identical fragments on digestion with BamHI or HindIII, but these were quite different from those of NAH. Nonetheless, NAH2 and NAH3 hybridized with NAH.     

Cloning and expression in Escherichia coli of the naphthalene degradation genes from plasmid NAH7

The genes encoding the enzymes responsible for conversion of naphthalene to 2-hydroxymuconic acid (nahA through nahI) are contained on a 25-kilobase EcoRI fragment of an 85-kilobase NAH plasmid of Pseudomonas putida. These genes were cloned into the plasmid vectors pBR322 and RSF1010 to obtain the recombinant plasmids pKGX505 and pKGX511, respectively. To facilitate cloning and analysis, an NAH7 plasmid containing a Tn5 transposon in the salicylate hydroxylase gene (nahG) was used to derive the EcoRI fragment. The genes for naphthalene degradation were expressed at a low level in Escherichia coli strains containing the fragment on the recombinant plasmids pKGX505 or pKGX511. This was shown by the ability of whole cells to convert naphthalene to salicylic acid and by in vitro enzyme assays. The expression of at least two of these genes in E. coli appeared to be regulated by the presence of the inducer salicylic acid. In addition, high-level expression and induction appear to be mediated by an NAH plasmid promoter and a regulatory gene located on the fragment. A restriction endonuclease cleavage map of the cloned fragment was generated, and the map positions of several nah genes were determined by analysis of various subcloned DNA fragments.     

Localization of camphor degradative plasmids on the chromosome of Pseudomonas putida strains PaW]

Camphor degradative plasmids (CAM, pRK1) are preferentially situated on chromosomes of Pseudomonas putida strains PaW. After having been transferred into Cam+ strains, the TOL plasmid pWWO dissociates into the cryptic plasmid pWWO-8 and chromosome-borne transposon Tn4651. The opposite situation, i.e. reconstruction of the TOL plasmid pWWO from the cryptic plasmid pWWO-8 and chromosome-borne catabolic operons of the pWWO plasmid has been described. Cam- derivatives of the CAM plasmid were obtained in vivo which contain the TOL plasmid transposons Tn4651 or Tn4652 as obligatory structural elements. These plasmids as well as pWWO-8 determine conjugational mobilization of chromosome-located cam operons followed by their integration into the chromosome of recipient.     

Nucleotide sequence of xylE from the TOL pDK1 plasmid and structural comparison with isofunctional catechol-2,3-dioxygenase genes from TOL, pWW0 and NAH7.

Detailed restriction and nucleotide sequence analysis of the Pseudomonas putida TOL plasmid pDK1 xylE gene revealed significant homology with isofunctional xylE (81.5%) and nahH (78.0%) genes from the TOL pWW0 and NAH7 plasmids. The highest degrees of nucleotide and apparent amino acid conservation (82.2 and 86.4%, respectively) among all three genes were found to exist within a region comprising 264 nucleotides encoding the C terminus. A comparison of localized regions revealed significantly greater homology between xylEpWW0 and xylEpDK1 within the C-terminal region, whereas xylEpWW0 and nahH showed greater similarity at the N terminus. The possibility that xylEpWW0 may represent a genetic hybrid of xylEpDK1 and nahH is discussed.     

Isolation of metabolic plasmid DNA from Pseudomonas putida

Metabolic plasmids conferring on $\text{Pseudomonas putida}$ the aromatic growth phenotypes naphthalene, Nah⁺, salicylate, Sal⁺, or toluate, Tol⁺, have been isolated as covalently closed circular DNA in 100 μg amounts. Plasmid DNA was banded in CsCl-ethidium bromide density gradients and sedimentation rates measured in sucrose gradients and by analytical centrifuge. The plasmid sizes found, in millions, were /NAH 42, /SAL 43, /TOL 55, 42. Transformation of metabolic plasmid free $\text{P. putida}$ with the isolated DNA confirmed the respective aromatic pathway gene contents.     

Retrotransfer of DNA in the rhizosphere

Retrotransfer of DNA refers to the phenomenon by which a plasmid travels from a host strain to a recipient one and returns to the original host, bringing with it DNA from the recipient. The resultant host strain with DNA from the recipient is called a retrotransconjugant. The retrotransfer phenomenon mediated by the TOL plasmid pWW0 and other plasmids has been documented on plates under optimal laboratory culture conditions, but never under natural conditions. In this work, we show that retrotransfer mediated by the IncP9 TOL pWW0 plasmid occurs in the rhizosphere, a niche in which the continuous supply of nutrients via root exudates allows cells to reach a high density. This suggests that this unusual sexual fertilization may be of great importance in lateral gene transfer. We also show that retrotransfer of DNA seems to require co-integration of the plasmid and the host chromosome and subsequent resolution, because a TOL plasmid with a mutation in the tnpR gene, encoding the resolvase of the Tn 4653 of the TOL plasmid, was self-transferred between Pseudomonas strains, but unable to mobilize chromosome.     

Molecular cloning of gene xylS of the TOL plasmid: evidence for positive regulation of the xylDEGF operon by xylS.

The xylDEGF operon and the regulatory gene xylS of the TOL plasmid found in Pseudomonas putida mt-2 were cloned onto Escherichia coli vector plasmids. A 9.5-kilobase fragment, derived from the TOL segment of pTN2 deoxyribonucleic acid, carried the xyl genes D, E, G, and F, which encode toluate oxygenase, catechol 2,3-oxygenase, 2-hydroxymuconic semialdehyde dehydrogenase, and 2-hydroxymuconic semialdehyde hydrolase, respectively. The enzymes were noninducible unless a 3-kilobase PstI fragment, derived also from the TOL segment, was provided in either cis or trans. The PstI fragment appeared to contain the regulatory gene xylS, which produced a positive regulator. The regulator was activated by m-toluate or benzoate, but not by m-xylene or m-methylbenzyl alcohol. the map positions of xylG and xylF were also determined.     

Homologies between plasmid and chromosomally-encoded benzoate-oxidizing genes in Pseudomonas putida

DNA-DNA hydridization has been used to detect homologies between the TOL plasmid-encoded gene cluster xylXYZL and the chromosomally-located benABCD genes in Pseudomonas putida; both sets of genes code for isofunctional enzymes converting benzoate and toluates into catechol and its derivatives. A DNA probe corresponding to a region downstream of xylL , however, failed to hybridize to Pseudomonas chromosomal DNA. These results support the notion that catabolic operons may evolve by successive recruitment of other genes, in this case via the juxtaposition of the benABCD gene cluster upstream of the xylE gene on TOL plasmids.