Bicarbonate Fixation and Malate Compartmentation in Relation to Salt-induced Stoichiometric Synthesis of Organic Acid

The relationship of malate synthesis to K⁺ absorption from solutions of K₂SO₄ and KHCO₃ was compared in nonvacuolate barley (Hordeum vulgare) root tips and whole excised roots. The comparison has permitted separation of the process which evokes organic acid synthesis from that which leads to stoichiometry between net acid equivalents formed and excess K⁺ absorbed from K₂SO₄, on the one hand, and total K⁺ absorbed from KHCO₃, on the other. Both in tips and in roots K⁺ uptake from 20 mN salt solution exceeds malate synthesis in the first hour. In vacuolate roots the expected stoichiometry is achieved with time. When root tips are transferred to dilute CaSO₄, malate is rapidly metabolized, and K⁺ is lost to the solution. By contrast, in excised whole roots the malate level remains unchanged, the salt-induced organic acid presumably being retained in the vacuole. In excised roots malonate leads to a marked drop in malate levels in untreated roots as well as in roots which have experienced salt-induced net malate synthesis. In consequence, it is contended that malonate makes available normally sequestered vacuolar malate.     

Relationship of Cell Sap pH to Organic Acid Change During Ion Uptake

Excised roots of barley (Hordeum vulgare, var. Campana) were incubated in KCl, K₂SO₄, CaCl₂, and NaCl solutions at concentrations of 10⁻⁵ to 10⁻² n. Changes in substrate solution pH, cell sap pH, and organic acid content of the roots were related to differences in cation and anion absorption. The pH of expressed sap of roots increased when cations were absorbed in excess of anions and decreased when anions were absorbed in excess of cations. The pH of the cell sap shifted in response to imbalances in cation and anion uptake in salt solutions as dilute as 10⁻⁵ n. Changes in cell sap pH were detectable within 15 minutes after the roots were placed in 10⁻³ n K₂SO₄. Organic acid changes in the roots were proportional to expressed sap pH changes induced by unbalanced ion uptake. Changes in organic acid content in response to differential cation and anion uptake appear to be associated with the low-salt component of ion uptake.     

Photosynthesis in the Higher Plant Vicia faba: V. Role of Malate as a Precursor of the Tricarboxylic Acid Cycle

In the higher plant Vicia faba, anomalous labeling patterns in the organic acids and related amino acids of the tricarboxylic acid cycle which result from photosynthetic ¹⁴CO₂ fixation (in conjunction with an enzyme localization pattern unique to plant mitochondria) suggest that the tricarboxylic acid cycle functions primarily as a pathway leading to glutamic acid biosynthesis during autotrophic growth. The distribution of isotope in citrate indicates little recycling of oxaloacetate for the resynthesis of citrate. Rather, malate appears to provide both the C₂ and C₄ fragments for the synthesis of citrate, and [³H]formate and ¹⁴CO₂-labeling patterns implicate serine as the ultimate C₃ precursor of malate.     

Pathway of malic Acid synthesis in response to ion uptake in wheat and lupin roots: evidence from fixation of C and C

Malate synthesis by CO₂ fixation in wheat (Triticum aestivum L.) and lupin (Lupinus luteus) roots was investigated by labeling with NaH¹³CO₃ as well as with NaH¹⁴CO₃. The distribution of ¹⁴C label in the malate was examined, using enzymic degradation methods (malic enzyme, pyruvate decarboxylase) and, in the case of ¹³C, gas chromatography-mass spectrometry. In long-term experiments (2 to 12 hours), both methods showed that the [1-C] and [4-C] positions of malic acid are approximately equally labeled, in agreement with former findings. Short-term experiments (15, 30 seconds) showed that ¹⁴C is confined initially to the [4-C] position of malate but then is distributed quickly to the [1-C] atom. Neither labeling pattern nor rate of randomization was influenced by salt treatment. Analysis of malate from roots by gas chromatography-mass spectrometry, a procedure which was tested against in vitro-prepared [1-¹³C]-, [4-¹³C]-, and [1,4-¹³C] malate, gave strong evidence for the existence of only singly labeled malate molecules. These data suggest that only one carboxylation step, catalyzed by phosphoenolpyruvate carboxylase and/or phosphoenolpyruvate carboxykinase, is responsible for malic acid synthesis in roots and that malate label is randomized by a fumarase-like reaction, presumably in mitochondria.     

Temperature effects on malic-acid efflux from the vacuoles and on the carboxylation pathways in crassulacean-acid-metabolism plants

The studies described in the paper were conducted with tissue slices of Crassulacean acid metabolism (CAM) plants floating in isotonic buffer. In a first series of experiments, temperature effects on the efflux of [¹⁴C]malate and¹⁴CO₂ were studied. An increase of temperature increased the efflux from the tissue in a non-linear manner. The efflux was markedly influenced also by the temperatures applied during the pretreatment. The rates of label export in response to the temperature and the relative contributions of¹⁴CO₂ and [¹⁴C]malate to the label export were different in the two studied CAM plants (Kalanchoë daigremontiana, Sempervivum montanum). In further experiments, temperature response of the labelling patterns produced by¹⁴CO₂ fixation and light and darkness were studied. In tissue which had accumulated malate (acidified state) an increase of temperature decreased the rates of dark CO₂ fixation whilst the rates of CO₂ fixation in light remained largely unaffected. An increase of temperature shifted the labelling patterns from a C₄-type (malate being the mainly labelled compound) into a C₃-type (label in carbohydrates). No such shift in the labelling patterns could be observed in the tissue which had depleted the previously stored malate (deacidified state). The results indicate that in the acidified tissue the increase of temperature increases the efflux of malate from the vacuole by changing the properties of the tonoplast. It is assumed that the increased export of malic acid lowers the in-vivo activity of phosphoenol pyruvate carboxylase by feedback inhibition.Abbreviations CAM Crassulacean acid metabolism - FW fresh weight - PEPCase phosphoenolpyruvate carboxylase Dedicated to Professor O.L. Lange, Würzburg, on the occasion of his 60th birthday     

Ethylene-independent and ethylene-dependent biochemical changes in ripening tomatoes

Fruits of Lycopersicon esculentum Mill cv Sonatine stored in 6% CO₂, 6% O₂, and 88% N₂ for 14 weeks at 12°C, exhibited a temporal separation of certain biochemical events associated with ripening.

The specific activity of two citric acid cycle enzymes, citrate synthase and malate dehydrogenase, fell substantially during the first 2 weeks of storage when changes in organic acid concentration also occurred. During this period, lycopene, polygalacturonase, and ethylene were undetectable.

When fruit were removed from store, ethylene was evolved and polygalacturonase and invertase activity were rapidly initiated as was synthesis of lycopene.

To determine whether the changes in organic acid metabolism were affected by ethylene, fruit was kept at 22°C in either a normal atmosphere or a normal atmosphere supplemented with 27 microliters per liter of ethylene, and it was shown that in both atmospheres similar quantitative changes to those described above occurred in the citric acid cycle enzymes specific activities before any detectable increase in the specific activities of invertase and polygalacturonase. These latter changes, together with pigment changes, occurred between 2 and 3 days earlier in fruit exposed to ethylene, compared with those kept in a normal atmosphere.

     

ORGANIC ACID SYNTHESIS IN RESPONSE TO EXCESS CATION ABSORPTION IN VACUOLATE AND NON-VACUOLATE SECTIONS OF CORN AND BARLEY ROOTS

1. ¹⁴CO₂ fixation into organic acids in tips and proximal sectionsof both corn and barley roots was studied as a function of thenature and concentration of the salt in the external solution.
2. In comparison with the level of ¹⁴CO₂ fixation by vacuolateproximal sections in KCI, incorporation was markedly enhancedin K₂SO₄ and diminished in CaCk. By contrast, non-vacuolateroot tips were indifferent to the type of external salt withrespect to UCO₂ incorporation into organic acids.
3. The effectof salt type on organic acid formation from ¹⁴CO₂was most pronouncedat relatively high concentrations.
4. The conclusion was reachedthat organic acid synthesis in responsetoexcess cation uptakeis the result of cation movement into thevacuole, and thattransport into the vacuole is mediated bythe low-affinity componentof the dual mechanisms involved inion absorption.

¹Present address: Government Forst Experiment Station, Meguro,Tokyo.     

Carbon Dioxide Fixation in Roots and Nodules of Alnus glutinosa: I. Role of Phosphoenolpyruvate Carboxylase and Carbamyl Phosphate Synthetase in Dark CO(2) Fixation, Citrulline Synthesis, and N(2) Fixation

Detached roots and nodules of the N₂-fixing species, Albus glutinosa (European black alder), actively assimilate CO₂. The maximum rates of dark CO₂ fixation observed for detached nodules and roots were 15 and 3 micromoles CO₂ fixed per gram dry weight per hour, respectively. The net incorporation of CO₂ in these tissues was catalyzed by phosphoenolpyruvate carboxylase which produces organic acids, some of which are used in the synthesis of the amino acids, aspartate, glutamate, and citrulline and by carbamyl phosphate synthetase. The latter accounts for approximately 30 to 40% of the CO₂ fixed and provides carbamyl phosphate for the synthesis of citrulline. Results of labeling studies suggest that there are multiple pools of malate present in nodules. The major pool is apparently metabolically inactive and of unknown function while the smaller pool is rapidly utilized in the synthesis of amino acids. Dark CO₂ fixation and N₂ fixation in nodules decreased after treatment of nodulated plants with nitrate while the percentage of the total ¹⁴C incorporated into organic acids increased. Phosphoenolpyruvate carboxylase and carbamyl phosphate synthetase play key roles in the synthesis of amino acids including citrulline and in the metabolism of N₂-fixing nodules and roots of alder.     

Products of Dark CO(2) Fixation in Pea Root Nodules Support Bacteroid Metabolism

Products of the nodule cytosol in vivo dark [¹⁴C]CO₂ fixation were detected in the plant cytosol as well as in the bacteroids of pea (Pisum sativum L. cv “Bodil”) nodules. The distribution of the metabolites of the dark CO₂ fixation products was compared in effective (fix⁺) nodules infected by a wild-type Rhizobium leguminosarum (MNF 300), and ineffective (fix⁻) nodules of the R. leguminosarum mutant MNF 3080. The latter has a defect in the dicarboxylic acid transport system of the bacterial membrane. The ¹⁴C incorporation from [¹⁴C]CO₂ was about threefold greater in the wild-type nodules than in the mutant nodules. Similarly, in wild-type nodules the in vitro phosphoenolpyruvate carboxylase activity was substantially greater than that of the mutant. Almost 90% of the ¹⁴C label in the cytosol was found in organic acids in both symbioses. Malate comprised about half of the total cytosol organic acid content on a molar basis, and more than 70% of the cytosol radioactivity in the organic acid fraction was detected in malate in both symbioses. Most of the remaining ¹⁴C was contained in the amino acid fraction of the cytosol in both symbioses. More than 70% of the ¹⁴C label found in the amino acids of the cytosol was incorporated in aspartate, which on a molar basis comprised only about 1% of the total amino acid pool in the cytosol. The extensive ¹⁴C labeling of malate and aspartate from nodule dark [¹⁴C]CO₂ fixation is consistent with the role of phosphoenolpyruvate carboxlase in nodule dark CO₂ fixation. Bacteroids from the effective wild-type symbiosis accumulated sevenfold more ¹⁴C than did the dicarboxylic acid transport defective bacteroids. The bacteroids of the effective MNF 300 symbiosis contained the largest proportion of the incorporated ¹⁴C in the organic acids, whereas ineffective MNF 3080 bacteroids mainly contained ¹⁴C in the amino acid fraction. In both symbioses a larger proportion of the bacteroid ¹⁴C label was detected in malate and aspartate than their corresponding proportions of the organic acids and amino acids on a molar basis. The proportion of ¹⁴C label in succinate, 2-oxogultarate, citrate, and fumarate in the bacteroids of the wild type greatly exceeded that of the dicarboxylate uptake mutant. The results indicate a central role for nodule cytosol dark CO₂ fixation in the supply of the bacteroids with dicarboxylic acids.     

An improved method for the liquid scintillation counting of 14CO2

A method has been described which permits the determination of the specific activity of ¹⁴CO₂ with an accuracy limited only by the accuracy of the liquid scintillation counter. Its principal idea is the selective conversion of CO₂ to nonvolatile organic compounds, such as benzoic acid. While this method is applicable quite generally it has been applied with particular success in connection with the Schmidt degradation of samples as small as 0.2 mmole where contamination of the evolved CO₂ is serious due to the necessarily large excess of reactants.     

Effect of Abscisic Acid on the Activities of Photosynthetic Enzymes and 14CO2 Fixation Products in Leaves of Pennisetum typhoides Seedlings

Abscisic acid inhibited the rate of ¹⁴CO₂ fixation in leaves of Pennisetum typhoides (Burm. f.) Stapf & Hubbard seedlings, but increased the activities of phosphoenol-pyruvate-carboxylase and malic enzyme. The leaves of the seedlings grown in the presence of abscisic acid incorporated, in comparison to the control, more radioactivity in the fraction of organic acids, but less radioactivity was recorded in the amino acid fraction. On the other hand, gibberellic acid which also inhibits photosynthetic ¹⁴CO₂ assimilation and decreases the activities of photosynthetic enzymes, favours greater incorporation in alanine, and reduces that in malate. It is deduced that bio-regulants can greatly influence the flow of ¹⁴C into individual photosynthetic products. As in growth, abscisic and gibberellic acids in combination tended to antagonize each other in their effects on enzyme activity as well as in incorporation of ¹⁴CO₂ into photosynthetic products.     

Carbon Dioxide Fixation in the Carbon Economy of Developing Seeds of Lupinus albus (L.)

The effects of CO₂ concentration and illumination on net gas exchange and the pathway of ¹⁴CO₂ fixation in detached seeds from developing fruits of Lupinus albus (L.) have been studied.

Increasing the CO₂ concentration in the surrounding atmosphere (from 0.03 to 3.0% [v/v] in air) decreased CO₂ efflux by detached seeds either exposed to the light flux equivalent to that transmitted by the pod wall (500 to 600 micro-Einsteins per square meter per second) in full sunlight or held in darkness. Above 1% CO₂ detached seeds made a net gain of CO₂ in the light (up to 0.4 milligrams of CO₂ fixed per gram fresh weight per hour) but ¹⁴CO₂ injected into the gas space of intact fruits (containing around 1.5% CO₂ naturally) was fixed mainly by the pod and little by the seeds.

Throughout development seeds contained ribulose-1,5-bisphosphate carboxylase activity (EC 4.1.1.39), especially in the embryo (up to 99 micromoles of CO₂ fixed per gram fresh weight per hour) and phosphoenolpyruvate carboxylase (EC 4.1.1.31) in both testa (up to 280 micromoles of CO₂ fixed per gram fresh weight per hour) and embryo (up to 355 micromoles of CO₂ fixed per gram fresh weight per hour).

In kinetic experiments the most significant early formed product of ¹⁴CO₂ fixation in both light and dark was malate but in the light phosphoglyceric acid and sugar phosphates were also rapidly labeled. ¹⁴CO₂ fixation in the light was linked to the synthesis of sugars and amino acids but in the dark labeled sugars were not formed.

     

Effect of Fusicoccin on Dark CO(2) Fixation by Vicia faba Guard Cell Protoplasts

When Vicia faba guard cell protoplasts were treated with fusicoccin, dark ¹⁴CO₂ fixation rates increased by as much as 8-fold. Rate increase was saturated with less than 1 micromolar fusicoccin. Even after 6 minutes of dark ¹⁴CO₂ fixation, more than 95% of the incorporated radioactivity was in stable products derived from carboxylation of phosphoenolpyruvate (about 50% and 30% in malate and aspartate, respectively). The relative distribution of ¹⁴C among products and in the C-4 position of malate (initially more than 90% of [¹⁴C]malate) was independent of fusicoccin concentration. After incubation in the dark, malate content was higher in protoplasts treated with fusicoccin. A positive correlation was observed between the amounts of ¹⁴CO₂ fixed and malate content.

It was concluded that (a) fusicoccin causes an increase in the rate of dark ¹⁴CO₂ fixation without alteration of the relative fluxes through pathways by which it is metabolized, (b) fusicoccin causes an increase in malate synthesis, and (c) dark ¹⁴CO₂ fixation and malate synthesis are mediated by phosphoenolpyruvate carboxylase.

     

CO2 and malate metabolism in starch-containing and starch-lacking guard-cell protoplasts

Isolated, purified mesophyll and guard-cell protoplasts of Vicia faba L. and Allium cepa L. were exposed to ¹⁴CO₂ in the light and in the dark. The guard-cell protoplasts of Vicia and Allium did not show any labeling in phosphorylated products of the Calvin cycle, thus appearing to lack the ability to reduce CO₂ photosynthetically. In Vicia, high amounts of radioactivity (35%) appeared in starch after 60-s pulses of ¹⁴CO₂ both in the light and in the dark. Presumably, the ¹⁴CO₂ is fixed into the malate via PEP carboxylase and then metabolized into starch as the final product of gluconeogenesis. This is supported by the fact that guard-cell protoplasts exposed to malic acid uniformly labeled with ¹⁴CO₂ showed high amounts of labeled starch after the incubation, whereas cells labeled with [4-¹⁴C]malate had minimal amounts of labeled starch (1/120).In contrast, the starch-deficient Allium, guard-cell protoplasts did not show any significant ¹⁴CO₂ fixation. However, adding PEP to an homogenate stimulated ¹⁴CO₂ uptake, thus supporting the interpretation that the presence of starch as a source of PEP is necessary for incorporating CO₂ and delivering malate. With starch-containing Vicia guard-cell protoplasts, the correlation between changes in volume and the interconversion of malate and starch was demonstrated. It was shown that the rapid gluconeogenic conversion of malate into starch prevents an increase of the volume of the protoplasts, whereas the degradation of starch to malate is accompanied by a swelling of the protoplasts.Abbreviations GCPs guard-cell protoplasts - MCPs mesophyll cell protoplasts - PEP phosphoenolpyruvate - DTT dithiothreitol - 3-PGA 3-phosphoglyceric acid - RiBP ribulose 1,5 bisphosphate - MDH malate dehydrogenase - MES 2-(N-morpholino)ethane sulfonic acid - CAM crassulacean acid metabolism     

The Influence of 0.03% Carbon Dioxide on Protein Metabolism of Etiolated Avena sativa Coleoptiles

The influence of indoleacetic acid, 0.03% CO₂, and malate on protein metabolism of etiolated Avena sativa coleoptile sections has been investigated. All three were found to elevate both the rate of incorporation of labeled leucine into protein, and the level of soluble protein. The combination of indoleacetic acid and CO₂ stimulated these values in an additive or weakly synergistic manner, in contrast to the nonadditive influence of malate and CO₂. Evidence is presented that cyclo-heximide inhibited the stimulation of protein synthesis by CO₂, and that indoleacetic acid increased the incorporation of ¹⁴C-bicarbonate into protein. These data are discussed in the context of CO₂-stimulated growth of etiolated tissue, and proposals that CO₂-stimulated growth involves dark CO₂ fixation.     

Characterization of Early Morning Crassulacean Acid Metabolism in Opuntia erinacea var Columbiana (Griffiths) L. Benson

The nature and sequence of metabolic events during phase II (early morning) Crassulacean acid metabolism in Opuntia erinacea var columbiana (Griffiths) L. Benson were characterized. Gas exchange measurements under 2 and 21% O₂ revealed increased O₂ inhibition of CO₂ fixation with progression of phase II. Malate and titratable acidity patterns indicated continued synthesis of C₄ acids for at least 30 minutes into the light period. Potential activities of phosphoenolpyruvate carboxylase (PEPC) and NADP-malic enzyme exhibited little change during phase II, while light activation of NADP-malate dehydrogenase, pyruvate, orthophosphate dikinase, and ribulose-1,5-bisphosphate carboxylase was apparent. Short-term ¹⁴CO₂ fixation experiments showed that the per cent of ¹⁴C incorporated into C₄ acids decreased while incorporation into other metabolites increased with time. PEPC exhibited increased sensitivity to 2 millimolar malate, and the K_i(malate) for PEPC decreased markedly with time. Sensitivity of PEPC to malate inhibition was considerably greater at pH 7.5 than at 8.0. The results indicate that decarboxylation and synthesis of malate occur simultaneously during the early morning period, and that phase II acid metabolism is not limited by CO₂ diffusion through stomata. With progression of phase II, CO₂ fixation by PEPC decreases while fixation by ribulose-1,5-bisphosphate carboxylase increases.     

Dark CO(2) Fixation and its Role in the Growth of Plant Tissue

Experiments were designed to determine the significance of dark CO₂ fixation in excised maize roots, carrot slices and excised tomato roots grown in tissue culture. Bicarbonate-¹⁴C was used to determine the pathway and amounts of CO₂ fixation, while leucine-¹⁴C was used to estimate protein synthesis in tissues aerated with various levels of CO₂.

Organic acids were labeled from bicarbonate-¹⁴C, with malate being the major labeled acid. Only glutamate and aspartate were labeled in the amino acid fraction and these 2 amino acids comprised over 90% of the ¹⁴C label in the ethanol-water insoluble residue.

Studies with leucine-¹⁴C as an indicator of protein synthesis in carrot slices and tomato roots showed that those tissues aerated with air incorporated 33% more leucine-¹⁴C into protein than those aerated with CO₂-free air. Growth of excised tomato roots aerated with air was 50% more than growth of tissue aerated with CO₂-free air. These studies are consistent with the suggestion that dark fixation of CO₂ is involved in the growth of plant tissues.

     

Glutamic Acid metabolism and the photorespiratory nitrogen cycle in wheat leaves: metabolic consequences of elevated ammonia concentrations and of blocking ammonia assimilation

The effects of methionine sulfoximine and ammonium chloride on [¹⁴C] glutamate metabolism in excised leaves of Triticum aestivum were investigated. Glutamine was the principal product derived from [U¹⁴C]glutamate in the light and in the absence of inhibitor or NH₄Cl. Other amino acids, organic acids, sugars, sugar phosphates, and CO₂ became slightly radioactive. Ammonium chloride (10 mm) increased formation of [¹⁴C] glutamine, aspartate, citrate, and malate but decreased incorporation into 2-oxoglutarate, alanine, and ¹⁴CO₂. Methionine sulfoximine (1 mm) suppressed glutamine synthesis, caused NH₃ to accumulate, increased metabolism of the added radioactive glutamate, decreased tissue levels of glutamate, and decreased incorporation of radioactivity into other amino acids. Methionine sulfoximine also caused most of the ¹⁴C from [U-¹⁴C]glutamate to be incorporated into malate and succinate, whereas most of the ¹⁴C from [1-¹⁴C]glutamate was metabolized to CO₂ and sugar phosphates. Thus, formation of radioactive organic acids in the presence of methionine sulfoximine does not take place indirectly through “dark” fixation of CO₂ released by degradation of glutamate when ammonia assimilation is blocked. When illuminated leaves supplied with [U-¹⁴C] glutamate without inhibitor or NH₄Cl were transferred to darkness, there was increased metabolism of the glutamate to glutamine, aspartate, succinate, malate, and ¹⁴CO₂. Darkening had little effect on the labeling pattern in leaves treated with methionine sulfoximine.     

Veränderliche Markierungsmuster bei14CO2-Fütterung vonBryophyllum tubiflorum zu verschiedenen Zeitpunkten der Hell/Dunkelperiode

Summary Detached phyllodia ofBryophyllum tubiflorum were fed under illumination with¹⁴CO₂ at different times during the light/dark period (12:12 hours). After photosynthesis in presence of¹⁴CO₂ during the intrinsic dark period the greatest part of soluble radioactivity was found in malate. When the same experiment was repeated during the light period, radioactivity was incorporated mainly into sucrose in the first hours while malate was labelled rather weakly. In the late afternoon (last third of the light period), malate became most heavily labelled again during photosynthesis with¹⁴CO₂.Our results indicate that the synthesis of malate by PEP-carboxylase/malate dehydrogenase is inhibited at certain times during the night/day period by end product inhibition of PEP-carboxylase, as was demonstrated byQueiroz (1967, 1968) andTing (1968) in vitro.During inhibition of the PEP-carboxylase there is no competition between the synthesis of malate and CO₂-fixation by the Calvin cycle. Thus radioactivity can flow into sucrose via the Calvin cycle during this time. When the malate content of the phyllodia is low, CO₂-fixation by PEP-carboxylase is not inhibited. Now this pathway dominates over photosynthesis via the Calvin cycle, for PEP-carboxylase has a higher affinity for CO₂ than carboxydismutase. Therefore malate now becomes more labelled than sucrose.     

Biochemical components of the photosynthetic CO2 compensation point of higher plants.

Barley, Panicum milioides and Panicum maximum were exposed to ¹⁴CO₂ near their photosynthetic CO₂ compensation points and their respective ¹⁴C-products were determined. In short exposure times Panicum maximum had 100% of its ¹⁴C in malate and aspartate whereas Panicum milioides and barley had 16 and 3% of their respective ¹⁴C in C₄ organic acids. Near the respective CO₂ compensation points a linear relationship occurs in plotting the ratio of glycine, serine, and glycerate to C₄ organic acids. The ratio of ribulose 1,5-bisphosphate oxygenase to phosphoenolpyruvate carboxylase is linear with their CO₂ compensation points. The photosynthetic CO₂ compensation point apparently is controlled by the activity of enzymes producing photorespiration metabolites and the activity of phospheonolpyruvate carboxylase.