Development of surface plasmon resonance biosensor assays for primary and secondary screening of acetylcholine binding protein ligands

Surface plasmon resonance (SPR) biosensors recently gained an important place in drug discovery. Here we present a primary and secondary SPR biosensor screening methodology. The primary screening method is based on a direct binding assay with covalent immobilized drug target proteins. For the secondary screening method, a sequential competition assay has been developed where the captured protein is first exposed to an unknown test compound, followed directly by an exposure to a high-molecular-weight reporter ligand. Using the high-molecular-weight reporter ligand to probe the remaining free binding site on the sensor, a significant signal enhancement is obtained. Furthermore, this assay format allows the validation of the primary direct binding assay format, efficiently revealing false positive data. As a model system, acetylcholine binding protein (AChBP), which is a soluble model protein for neuronal nicotinic acetylcholine receptors, has been used. The secondary assay is lower in throughput than the primary assay; however, the signal-to-noise ratio is two times higher compared with the direct assay, and it has a z′ factor of 0.96. Using both assays, we identified the compound tacrine as a ligand for AChBP.     

Label-free detection of cupric ions and histidine-tagged proteins using single poly(pyrrole)-NTA chelator conducting polymer nanotube chemiresistive sensor

Novel chemical and biological sensors based on a single poly(pyrrole)-NTA chelator nanotube for sensitive, selective, rapid and real-time detection of histidine-tagged protein and cupric ions are reported. NTA groups on the nanotube surface provided a simple mechanism for metal ion sensing via the high-affinity interaction between NTA and the subsequent detection of histidine-tagged protein through the coordination with metal chelated nanotube. Poly(pyrrole)-NTA chelator nanotubes of 190 nm outside diameter, 35 nm wall thickness and 30 microm long were synthesized by electrochemical polymerization of pyrrole-NTA inside a 200 nm diameter alumina template and assembled as a chemoresistive device by bottom-up contact geometry on a pair of parallel gold electrodes with a gap distance of 3 microm. The chemoresistive sensors based on single poly(pyrrole)-NTA chelator nanotube exhibited detection as low as one-hundredth attomolar (0.6 ppt) cupric ions and 1 ng/ml of penta-histidine tagged syntaxin protein.     

Nanodiscs allow the use of integral membrane proteins as analytes in surface plasmon resonance studies

Nanodiscs are small-sized and flat model membranes that provide a close to native environment for reconstitution of integral membrane proteins. Incorporation of membrane proteins into nanodiscs results in water-soluble proteolipid particles making the membrane proteins amenable to a multitude of bioanalytical techniques originally developed for soluble proteins. The transmembrane domain of the human CD4 receptor was fused to ubiquitin with a preceding N-terminal decahistidine tag. The resulting integral membrane protein was incorporated into nanodiscs. Binding of the nanodisc-inserted histidine-tagged protein to a monoclonal anti-pentahistidine antibody was quantified using surface plasmon resonance (SPR) experiments. For the first time, a membrane-inserted transmembrane protein was employed as analyte while the antibody served as ligand immobilized on the sensor chip surface. SPR experiments were conducted in single-cycle mode. We demonstrate that the nanodisc-incorporated membrane protein showed nearly identical affinity toward the antibody as did the soluble decahistidine-tagged ubiquitin studied in a comparative experiment. Advantages of the new experimental setup and potential applications are discussed.     

Label Free Fragment Screening Using Surface Plasmon Resonance as a Tool for Fragment Finding – Analyzing Parkin,a Difficult CNS Target

Surface Plasmon Resonance (SPR) is rarely used as a primary High-throughput Screening (HTS) tool in fragment-based approaches. With SPR instruments becoming increasingly high-throughput it is now possible to use SPR as a primary tool for fragment finding. SPR becomes, therefore, a valuable tool in the screening of difficult targets such as the ubiquitin E3 ligase Parkin. As a prerequisite for the screen, a large number of SPR tests were performed to characterize and validate the active form of Parkin. A set of compounds was designed and used to define optimal SPR assay conditions for this fragment screen. Using these conditions, more than 5000 pre-selected fragments from our in-house library were screened for binding to Parkin. Additionally, all fragments were simultaneously screened for binding to two off target proteins to exclude promiscuous binding compounds. A low hit rate was observed that is in line with hit rates usually obtained by other HTS screening assays. All hits were further tested in dose responses on the target protein by SPR for confirmation before channeling the hits into Nuclear Magnetic Resonance (NMR) and other hit-confirmation assays.     

Direct triazine herbicide detection using a self-assembled photosynthetic reaction center from purple bacterium

In this study, a direct detection system for triazine derivative herbicides was developed using the photosynthetic reaction center (RC) from the purple bacterium,Rhodobacter sphaeroides, and surface plasmon resonance (SPR) apparatus. The histidine-tagged RCs were immobilized on an SPR gold chip using nickel-nitrilotriacetic acid groups as a binder for one of the triazine herbicide, atrazine. The SPR responses were proportional to the sample concentrations of atrazine in the range 0.1–1 μg/mL. The sensitivity of the direct detection of atrazine using the RC-assembled sensor chip was higher than that using the antibody-immobilized chip. The other types of herbicides, DCMU or MCPP, were not detected with such high sensitivity. The results indicated the high binding selectivity of the RC complex.     

Surface plasmon resonance: a useful technique for cell biologists to characterize biomolecular interactions

Surface plasmon resonance (SPR) is a powerful technique for monitoring the affinity and selectivity of biomolecular interactions. SPR allows for analysis of association and dissociation rate constants and modeling of biomolecular interaction kinetics, as well as for equilibrium binding analysis and ligand specificity studies. SPR has received much use and improved precision in classifying protein–protein interactions, as well as in studying small-molecule ligand binding to receptors; however, lipid–protein interactions have been underserved in this regard. With the field of lipids perhaps the next frontier in cellular research, SPR is a highly advantageous technique for cell biologists, as newly identified proteins that associate with cellular membranes can be screened rapidly and robustly for lipid specificity and membrane affinity. This technical perspective discusses the conditions needed to achieve success with lipid–protein interactions and highlights the unique lipid–protein interaction mechanisms that have been elucidated using SPR. It is intended to provide the reader a framework for quantitative and confident conclusions from SPR analysis of lipid–protein interactions.     

Direct analysis of a GPCR-agonist interaction by surface plasmon resonance

Despite their clinical importance, detailed analysis of ligand binding at G-protein coupled receptors (GPCRs) has proved difficult. Here we successfully measure the binding of a GPCR, neurotensin receptor-1 (NTS-1), to its ligand, neurotensin (NT), using surface plasmon resonance (SPR). Specific responses were observed between NT and purified, detergent-solublised, recombinant NTS-1, using a novel configuration where the biotinylated NT ligand was immobilised on the biosensor surface. This SPR approach shows promise as a generic approach for the study of ligand interactions with other suitable GPCRs.     

A metal-chelating microscopy tip as a new toolbox for single-molecule experiments by atomic force microscopy

In recent years, the atomic force microscope (AFM) has contributed much to our understanding of the molecular forces involved in various high-affinity receptor-ligand systems. However, a universal anchor system for such measurements is still required. This would open up new possibilities for the study of biological recognition processes and for the establishment of high-throughput screening applications. One such candidate is the N-nitrilo-triacetic acid (NTA)/His-tag system, which is widely used in molecular biology to isolate and purify histidine-tagged fusion proteins. Here the histidine tag acts as a high-affinity recognition site for the NTA chelator. Accordingly, we have investigated the possibility of using this approach in single-molecule force measurements. Using a histidine-peptide as a model system, we have determined the binding force for various metal ions. At a loading rate of 0.5 microm/s, the determined forces varied from 22 +/- 4 to 58 +/- 5 pN. Most importantly, no interaction was detected for Ca(2+) and Mg(2+) up to concentrations of 10 mM. Furthermore, EDTA and a metal ion reloading step demonstrated the reversibility of the approach. Here the molecular interactions were turned off (EDTA) and on (metal reloading) in a switch-like fashion. Our results show that the NTA/His-tag system will expand the "molecular toolboxes" with which receptor-ligand systems can be investigated at the single-molecule level.     

Delineating protein-protein interactions via biomolecular interaction analysis-mass spectrometry

The utility of biomolecular interaction analysis-mass spectrometry (BIA/MS) in screening for protein-protein interactions was explored in this work. Experiments were performed in which proteins served as ligands for screening of possible interactions with other proteins from human plasma and urine. The proteins utilized were beta-2-microglobulin, cystatin C (cysC), retinol binding protein (RBP), transthyretin (TTR), alpha-1-microglobulin, C-reactive protein, transferrin and papain. The immobilization of functionally active proteins was confirmed via interactions with antibodies to the corresponding proteins. Various dilutions of human urine and plasma were injected over the protein-derivatized surfaces. It was observed that the urine injections generally yielded smaller SPR responses than those observed after the plasma injections. The BIA/MS experiments did not reveal novel protein-protein interactions, although several established interactions (such as those between RBP and TTR, and cysC and papain) were validated. Few protein ligand deficiencies (such as truncations) leading to false negative and false positive BIA/MS results were also discovered.     

High Throughput Scintillation Proximity Assay for the Identification of FKBP-12 Ligands

A high throughput scintillation proximity assay (SPA) was developed to identify novel ligands of FKBP-12, an immunophilin with peptidyl prolyl isomerase (rotamase) activity. Recombinant histidine-tagged FKBP-12 was expressed in Escherichia coli, purified by metal ion affinity chromatography, and immobilized to SPA beads by an antibody that recognizes the histidine tag of the recombinant protein. Using 1 nM [3H] FK506, a well-known macrolid ligand of FKBP-12, specific binding was saturable and accounted for 95% of total binding. Analysis of saturation and homologous displacement isotherms indicated the existence of a single binding site with a Kd value of 1.6 nM. The specificity of [3H] FK506 binding was demonstrated in displacement experiments and showed that rapamycin, another macrolid, was as active as FK506 (IC50 of 3.5 and 3.2 nM, respectively), whereas GPI-1046, a prototype of small molecular compounds with neurotrophic properties and affinity for FKBP-type immunophilins, was more than 1000-fold less active. The high signal-to-noise ratio of 30, together with small standard deviations, makes this novel assay well suited for automated high throughput screening.     

The novel chelator lipid 3(nitrilotriacetic acid)-ditetradecylamine (NTA(3)-DTDA) promotes stable binding of His-tagged proteins to liposomal membranes: potent anti-tumor responses induced by simultaneously targeting antigen, cytokine and costimulatory signals to T cells

Recent studies indicate that the chelator lipid nitrilotriacetic acid ditetradecylamine (NTA-DTDA) can be used to engraft T cell costimulatory molecules onto tumor cell membranes, potentially circumventing the need for genetic manipulation of the cells for development of cell- or membrane-based tumor vaccines. Here, we show that a related lipid 3(nitrilotriacetic acid)-ditetradecylamine (NTA(3)-DTDA, which has three NTA moieties in its headgroup instead of one) is several-fold more effective than NTA-DTDA at promoting stable His-tagged protein engraftment. IAsys biosensor studies show that binding of His-tagged B7.1 (B7.1-6H) to NTA(3)-DTDA-containing membranes, exhibit a faster on-rate and a slower off-rate, compared to membranes containing NTA-DTDA. Also, NTA(3)-DTDA-containing liposomes and plasma membrane vesicles (PMV) engrafted with B7.1-6H and CD40-6H exhibit greater binding to T cells, in vitro and in vivo. Engrafted NTA(3)-DTDA-containing PMV encapsulated cytokines such as IL-2, IL-12, GM-CSF and IFN-gamma, allowing targeted delivery of both antigen and cytokine to T cells, and stimulation of antigen-specific T cell proliferation and cytotoxicity. Importantly, use of B7.1-CD40-engrafted PMV containing IL-2 and IL-12 as a vaccine in DBA/2J mice induced protection against challenge with syngeneic tumor cells (P815 mammary mastocytoma), and regression of established tumors. The results show that stable protein engraftment onto liposomal membranes using NTA(3)-DTDA can be used to simultaneously target associated antigen, costimulatory molecules and cytokines to T cells in vivo, inducing strong anti-tumor responses and immunotherapeutic effect.     

Surface plasmon resonance analysis of ricin binding to plasma membranes isolated from NIH 3T3 cells

As the potential for bioterrorism has appeared to increase, the need for simple systems for identifying potential inhibitors of the binding of such biological agents to cell membranes has increased. In this work, surface plasmon resonance (SPR) was used to monitor binding of ricin, a ribosome-inactivating protein, to the plasma membranes of NIH 3T3 cells. Once conditions were established, efficacy of the system for monitoring effectiveness of compounds at inhibiting ricin binding was ascertained by determining the IC₅₀ values for asialofetuin (ASF) and for bovine serum albumin derivatized with an average of 34 lactosyl moieties (BSA-Lac₃₄). Results indicated that SPR is an efficient method for measuring adherence of a toxin to isolated cell plasma membranes. SPR can also indicate whether a compound that is an effective inhibitor of binding when a single ligand such as ASF is used will be as effective when used in studies with cells that may express multiple cell surface ligands for ricin and/or the inhibitor.     

Comparative thermodynamic analysis of cyclic nucleotide binding to protein kinase A

We have investigated the thermodynamic parameters and binding of a regulatory subunit of cAMP-dependent protein kinase (PKA) to its natural low-molecular-weight ligand, cAMP, and analogues thereof. For analysis of this model system, we compared side-by-side isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC) with surface plasmon resonance (SPR). Both ITC and SPR analyses revealed that binding of the protein to cAMP or its analogues was enthalpically driven and characterised by similar free energy values (DeltaG=-9.4 to -10.7 kcal mol-1) for all interactions. Despite the similar affinities, binding of the cyclic nucleotides used here was characterised by significant differences in the contribution of entropy (-TDeltaS) and enthalpy (DeltaH) to DeltaG. The comparison of ITC and SPR data for one cAMP analogue further revealed deviations caused by the method. These equilibrium parameters could be complemented by thermodynamic data of the transition state (DeltaHnot equal, DeltaGnot equal, DeltaSnot equal) for both association and dissociation measured by SPR. This direct comparison of ITC and SPR highlights method-specific advantages and drawbacks for thermodynamic analyses of protein/ligand interactions.     

Recognition of nitrogen-responsive upstream activation sequences of Saccharomyces cerevisiae by the product of the GLN3 gene.

We describe the purification of the product of the GLN3 gene of Saccharomyces cerevisiae and the demonstration that the purified product, Gln3p, binds specifically to the DNA sequences GATAAG and GATTAG, previously identified as nitrogen-responsive upstream activation sequences (UASN). When Gln3p is overproduced, it is released from the cells in a highly aggregated form incapable of specific binding to UASN. We used Gln3p tagged with six histidine codons at the 5' terminus and equipped with a galactose-inducible promoter to overproduce histidine-tagged Gln3p. The material was denatured, adsorbed to an Ni-nitrilotriacetic acid (NTA)-agarose column, eluted with imidazole, and after renaturation further purified on a gel filtration column. We then demonstrated the specific binding of the more than 90% pure Gln3p to the UASN by gel shift and footprinting methods.     

Immobilization and clustering of structurally defined oligosaccharides for sugar chips: an improved method for surface plasmon resonance analysis of protein-carbohydrate interactions

Oligosaccharides are increasingly being recognized as important partners in receptor-ligand binding and cellular signaling. Surface plasmon resonance (SPR) is a very powerful tool for the real-time study of the specific interactions between biological molecules. We report here an advanced method for the immobilization of oligosaccharides in clustered structures for SPR and their application to the analysis of heparin-protein interactions. Reductive amination reactions and linker molecules were designed and optimized. Using mono-, tri-, or tetravalent linker compounds, we incorporated synthetic structurally defined disaccharide units of heparin and immobilized them as ligands for SPR. Their binding to an important hemostatic protein, von Willebrand factor (vWf), and its known heparin-binding domain was quantitatively analyzed. These multivalent ligand conjugates exhibited reproducible binding behavior, with consistency of the surface conditions of the SPR chip. This novel technique for oligosaccharide immobilization in SPR studies is accurate, specific, and easily applicable to both synthetic and naturally derived oligosaccharides.     

A strategy for high-throughput screening of ligands suitable for molecular imprinting of proteins

For facilitating the identification of appropriate functionalities that may serve as a binding motif of functional monomers, a selection strategy based on high-throughput screening of the binding properties of readily available sorbent materials has been developed. Thereby, the affinity of such ligands to the protein of interest may be rapidly determined. From these studies, it is anticipated that ligand functionalities will be derived, which may lead to advanced selection and design of dedicated functional monomers suitable for decorating the surface of a scavenger material. Thus, specific binding of the target protein of interest should be enabled even in complex solutions such as e.g., biotechnologically relevant cell lysates. In the present contribution, an automated screening method for studying ligand interactions of selected sorbent materials with pepsin - a protein of the protease family - was developed. Aqueous buffer solutions containing pepsin at known constant concentration were pipetted through an array of miniaturized chromatographic solid phase extraction (SPE) columns containing a variety of sorbent materials, and the eluted solutions were analyzed by UV/vis spectroscopy. The established screening protocol was validated against resin materials of known interaction with pepsin. Finally, the developed screening strategy was adapted for a robot system enabling high-throughput screening for a wide variety of sorbent materials and ligand functionalities in a fully automated approach. The obtained results clearly indicate that the established screening routine provides valuable data for characterizing resin-immobilized ligands, and their affinity toward pepsin.     

Use of SPR to Study the Interaction of G7-18NATE Peptide with the Grb7-SH2 Domain

Surface plasmon resonance (SPR) is a useful biosensor technique for the study of biomolecular interactions, with the potential for high-throughput screening of ligand interactions with drug targets. The key to its successful use, however, is in the appropriate design of the experiment, including the mode of immobilization to the biosensor chip. We report an investigation of the use of SPR for measuring the affinity of the G7-18NATE peptide ligand for its Grb7-SH2 domain target involved in the migratory and proliferative potential of cancer cells. Previous studies have shown that the cyclic non-phosphorylated peptide, G7-18NATE, inhibits Grb7 interactions with upstream binding partners and is able to inhibit both cell migration and proliferation of cancer cells. We report the synthesis of a biotinylated G7-18NATE covalently attached to a linker (G7-18NATE-ASASASK-Biotin) and compare its interaction with the Grb7-SH2 domain by SPR using three different immobilization strategies; immobilisation of the peptide via streptavidin, immobilization of glutathione S-transferase (GST)-Grb7-SH2 domain via anti-GST antibody, and immobilization of biotinylated Grb7-SH2 domain via streptavidin. This revealed that sensorgrams free from non-specific binding and displaying simple kinetics were most readily achieved by immobilising the protein rather than the peptide, in spite of the lower response associated with this method. K _D values of ~300 μM were determined for both strategies at pH 7.4. This compared with a K _D value of 4.4 μM at pH 6 demonstrating the importance of pH on this interaction. Overall, the immobilised protein systems are most suitable for future comparative screening efforts using SPR.     

Immunosensor with a controlled orientation of antibodies by using NeutrAvidin-protein A complex at immunoaffinity layer

The orientation of antibody was controlled by using NeutrAvidin-protein A complex on the gold surface of SPR biosensor. The surface density of receptor antibody (anti-hIgG) was compared by treatment of receptor antibody to the layer of avidin, NeutrAvidin, protein A, NeutrAvidin-protein A complex and bare gold surface of SPR biosensor. The ligand antibody (hIgG) was injected to each IA layer and the binding ratio of ligand antibody per unit receptor was estimated as a parameter of orientation control. The NeutrAvidin-protein A complex on gold surface of SPR biosensor showed the highest surface density of receptor antibody as well as the binding ratio of ligand antibody per receptor antibody. The NeutrAvidin-protein A complex was also prepared on biotin-labelled SAM, and the binding ratio of ligand per receptor was found to be significantly improved in comparison to the IA layer prepared by chemical coupling of receptor antibody to the SAM layer. The NeutrAvidin-protein A complex which showed the highest efficiency for the binding of ligand antibodies, was applied for the detection of a cancer marker called CEA. By using NeutrAvidin-protein A complex and sandwich assay for signal amplification, sensitivity was improved to be 1.5-fold higher than bare gold surface and the detection of CEA with the detection limit of 30 ng/ml was achieved.     

An ultraefficient affinity-based high-throughout screening process: application to bacterial cell wall biosynthesis enzyme MurF

The authors describe the discovery of a new class of inhibitors to an essential Streptococcus pneumoniae cell wall biosyn-thesis enzyme, MurF, by a novel affinity screening method. The strategy involved screening very large mixtures of diverse small organic molecules against the protein target on the basis of equilibrium binding, followed by iterative ultrafiltration steps and ligand identification by mass spectrometry. Hits from any affinity-based screening method often can be relatively nonselective ligands, sometimes referred to as "nuisance" or "promiscuous" compounds. Ligands selective in their binding affinity for the MurF target were readily identified through electronic subtraction of an empirically determined subset of promiscuous compounds in the library without subsequent selectivity panels. The complete strategy for discovery and identification of novel specific ligands can be applied to all soluble protein targets and a wide variety of ligand libraries.     

Discovery and characterization of cooperative ligand binding in the adaptive region of interleukin-2

The cytokine hormone interleukin-2 (IL-2) contains a highly adaptive region that binds small, druglike molecules. The binding properties of this adaptive region have been explored using a "tethering" method that relies on the formation of a disulfide bond between the protein and small-molecule ligands. Using tethering, surface plasmon resonance (SPR), and X-ray crystallography, we have discovered that the IL-2 adaptive region contains at least two cooperative binding sites where the binding of a first ligand to one site promotes or antagonizes the binding of a second ligand to the second site. Cooperative energies of interaction of -2 kcal/mol are observed. The observation that the adaptive region contains two adjacent sites may lead to the development of tight-binding antagonists of a protein-protein interaction. Cooperative ligand binding in the adaptive region of IL-2 underscores the importance of protein dynamics in molecular recognition. The tethering approach provides a novel and general strategy for discovering such cooperative binding interactions in specific, flexible regions of protein structure.