Selection of viral RNA-derived tRNA-like structures with improved valylation activities

The tRNA-like structure (TLS) of turnip yellow mosaic virus (TYMV) RNA was previously shown to be efficiently charged by yeast valyl-tRNA synthetase (ValRS). This RNA has a noncanonical structure at its 3'-terminus but mimics a tRNA L-shaped fold, including an anticodon loop containing the major identity nucleotides for valylation, and a pseudoknotted amino acid accepting domain. Here we describe an in vitro selection experiment aimed (i) to verify the completeness of the valine identity set, (ii) to elucidate the impact of the pseudoknot on valylation, and (iii) to investigate whether functional communication exists between the two distal anticodon and amino acid accepting domains. Valylatable variants were selected from a pool of 2 x 10(13) RNA molecules derived from the TYMV TLS randomized in the anticodon loop nucleotides and in the length (1-6 nucleotides) and sequence of the pseudoknot loop L1. After nine rounds of selection by aminoacylation, 42 have been isolated. Among them, 17 RNAs could be efficiently charged by yeast ValRS. Their sequence revealed strong conservation of the second and the third anticodon triplet positions (A(56), C(55)) and the very 3'-end loop nucleotide C(53). A large variability of the other nucleotides of the loop was observed and no wild-type sequence was recovered. The selected molecules presented pseudoknot domains with loop L1 varying in size from 3-6 nucleotides and some sequence conservation, but did neither reveal the wild-type combination. All selected variants are 5-50 times more efficiently valylated than the wild-type TLS, suggesting that the natural viral sequence has emerged from a combination of evolutionary pressures among which aminoacylation was not predominant. This is in line with the role of the TLS in viral replication.     

Valylation of the two RNA components of turnip-yellow mosaic virus and specificity of the tRNA aminoacylation reaction.

A comparative study of the aminoacylation of the two RNA components of turnip yellow mosaic virus, of yeast tRNAVal, tRNAfMet and of tRNAPhe by purified yeast valyl-tRNA synthetase is reported. Aminoacylations were performed in the presence of pure yeast tRNA nucleotidyltransferase, since 85% of the viral RNA molecules lacked the 3'-adenosine. We find that aminoacylation of the viral RNAs, like tRNA aminoacylation, reflects an equilibrium between the acylation and deacylation reactions. The kinetic parameters of TYM virus RNA valylation resemble the values found for tRNAVal valylation; in particular, there is a strong affinity between the viral RNA and valyl-tRNA synthetase and the rate constant for TYM virus RNA valylation is only slightly lower than that for tRNAVal. This result contrasts with the reduced rates observed in tRNA mischarging, and suggests that the viral RNA could be easily aminoacylated in vivo. Considering the fact that the 3'-terminal sequence of TYM virus RNA has only a few points of resemblance to a tRNA sequence, we propose that there are some structural motifs found in both tRNAVal and TYM virus RNA which are brought in a similar spatial arrangement recognized by valyl-tRNA synthetase.     

Role of acceptor stem conformation in tRNAVal recognition by its cognate synthetase.

Although the anticodon is the primary element in Escherichia coli tRNAValfor recognition by valyl-tRNA synthetase (ValRS), nucleotides in the acceptor stem and other parts of the tRNA modulate recognition. Study of the steady state aminoacylation kinetics of acceptor stem mutants of E.coli tRNAValdemonstrates that replacing any base pair in the acceptor helix with another Watson-Crick base pair has little effect on aminoacylation efficiency. The absence of essential recognition nucleotides in the acceptor helix was confirmed by converting E.coli tRNAAlaand yeast tRNAPhe, whose acceptor stem sequences differ significantly from that of tRNAVal, to efficient valine acceptors. This transformation requires, in addition to a valine anticodon, replacement of the G:U base pair in the acceptor stem of these tRNAs. Mutational analysis of tRNAValverifies that G:U base pairs in the acceptor helix act as negative determinants of synthetase recognition. Insertion of G:U in place of the conserved U4:A69 in tRNAValreduces the efficiency of aminoacylation, due largely to an increase in K m. A smaller but significant decline in aminoacylation efficiency occurs when G:U is located at position 3:70; lesser effects are observed for G:U at other positions in the acceptor helix. The negative effects of G:U base pairs are strongly correlated with changes in helix structure in the vicinity of position 4:69 as monitored by19F NMR spectroscopy of 5-fluorouracil-substituted tRNAVal. This suggests that maintaining regular A-type RNA helix geometry in the acceptor stem is important for proper recognition of tRNAValby valyl-tRNA synthetase.19F NMR also shows that formation of the tRNAVal-valyl-tRNA synthetase complex does not disrupt the first base pair in the acceptor stem, a result different from that reported for the tRNAGln-glutaminyl-tRNA synthetase complex.     

Contact areas of the turnip yellow mosaic virus tRNA-like structure interacting with yeast valyl-tRNA synthetase

The tRNA-like structure of turnip yellow mosaic virus is known to be efficiently recognized and aminoacylated by valyl-tRNA synthetase. The present work reports domains in the isolated tRNA-like fragment (159 terminal nucleotides at the 3'-end of the two viral RNAs) in contact with purified yeast valyl-tRNA synthetase. These domains were determined in protection experiments using chemical and enzymatic structural probes. In addition, new data, re-enforcing the validity of the tertiary folding model for the native RNA, are given. In particular, at the level of the amino acid accepting arm it was found that the two phosphate groups flanking the three guanine residues of loop I are inaccessible to ethylnitrosourea. This is in agreement with a higher-order structure of this loop involving "pseudo knotting", as proposed by Rietveld et al. (1982). Valyl-tRNA synthetase efficiently protects the viral RNA against digestion by single-strand-specific S1 nuclease at the level of the anticodon loop. With cobra venom ribonuclease, specific for double-stranded regions of RNA, protection was detected on both sides of the anticodon arm and at the 5'-ends of loop I, a region that is involved in the building up of the acceptor arm. Loop II, which is topologically homologous to the T-loop of canonical tRNA was likewise protected. Weak protection was observed between arms I and II, and at the 3'-side of arm V. This arm, located at the 5'-side of arm IV (homologous to the D-arm of tRNA), does not participate in the pseudo-knotted model of the valine acceptor arm. Ethylnitrosourea was used to determine the phosphates of the tRNA-like structure in close contact with the synthetase. These are grouped in several stretches scattered over the RNA molecule. In agreement with the nuclease digestion results, protected phosphates are located in arms I, II, and III. Additionally, this chemical probe permits detection of other protected phosphates on the 3'-side of arm IV and on both sides of arm V. When displayed in the three-dimensional model of the tRNA-like structure, protected areas are localized on both limbs of the L-shaped RNA. It appears that valyl-tRNA synthetase embraces the entire tRNA-like structure. This is reminiscent of the interaction model of canonical yeast tRNAVal with its cognate synthetase.     

Turnip yellow mosaic virus RNAs with anticodon loop substitutions that result in decreased valylation fail to replicate efficiently.

Single and multiple nucleotide substitutions have been introduced into the anticodon loop of the tRNA-like structure of turnip yellow mosaic virus (TYMV) genomic RNA. We studied the effects of these mutations on in vitro valylation and on replication in Chinese cabbage protoplasts and plants. Only those mutants capable of efficient and complete valylation showed efficient replication in protoplasts and gave rise to systemic symptoms in whole plants. Mutants that accepted valine inefficiently (in some cases Vmax/Km values were less than 10(-3) relative to wild-type values) replicated to levels 200- to 500-fold below wild-type levels in protoplasts (estimated on the basis of coat protein and genomic RNA levels). These mutants could not support systemic spread in plants. In one plant inoculated with TYMC-A55 RNA, which replicates poorly in protoplasts, systemic symptoms developed after a delay. The reversion in replication was accompanied by improved valine acceptance and the appearance of a U57 second-site mutation. Our results indicate a correlation between valine acceptance activity and viral yield. Possible roles for valylation are discussed, and the results are compared with those of similar studies with brome mosaic virus which suggested that tyrosylation is not crucial for brome mosaic virus replication (T. W. Dreher, A. L. N. Rao, and T. C. Hall, J. Mol. Biol. 206:425-438, 1989).     

The valine anticodon and valylatability of Peanut clump virus RNAs are not essential but provide a modest competitive advantage in plants

The role of valine aminoacylation of the two genomic RNAs of Peanut clump virus (PCV) was studied by comparing the amplification in vivo of RNAs with GAC, GDeltaC, or CCA anticodons in the tRNA-like structure (TLS) present at the 3' end of each viral RNA. The PCV RNA1 TLS of isolate PCV2 possesses a GAC anticodon and is capable of highly efficient valylation, whereas the RNA2 TLS has a GDeltaC anticodon that does not support valylation. The presence in RNA1 of GDeltaC or CCA anticodons that conferred nonvalylatability resulted in about 2- to 4-fold and a 14- to 24-fold reduction, respectively, in RNA accumulations in tobacco BY-2 protoplasts inoculated with the RNA1 variants together with wild-type RNA2(GDeltaC). No differences in RNA levels were observed among protoplasts inoculated with the three variant RNA2s in the presence of wild-type RNA1(GAC). All combinations of valylatable and nonvalylatable RNAs 1 and 2 were similarly infectious in Nicotiana benthamiana plants, and viral RNAs accumulated to similar levels; all input TLS sequences were present unchanged in apical leaves. In direct competition experiments in N. benthamiana plants, however, both RNA1 and RNA2 with GAC valylatable anticodons outcompeted the nonvalylatable variants. We conclude that valylation provides a small but significant replicational advantage to both PCV RNAs. Sequence analysis of the TLS from RNA2 of a second PCV isolate, PO2A, revealed the presence of an intact GAC valine anticodon, suggesting that the differential valylation of the genomic RNAs of isolate PCV2 is not a general characteristic of PCV.     

The exchange of the discriminator base A73 for G is alone sufficient to convert human tRNA(Leu) into a serine-acceptor in vitro.

Transfer RNA (tRNA) identify is maintained by the highly specific interaction of a few defined nucleotides or groups of nucleotides, called identity elements, with the cognate aminoacyl-tRNA synthetase, and by nonproductive interactions with the other 19 aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases. Most tRNAs have a set of identity elements in at least two locations, commonly in the anticodon loop or in the acceptor stem, and at the discriminator base position 73. We have used T7 RNA polymerase transcribed tRNAs to demonstrate that the sole replacement of the discriminator base A73 of human tRNA(Leu) with the tRNA(Ser)-specific G generates a complete identity switch to serine acceptance. The reverse experiment, the exchange of G73 in human tRNA(Ser) for the tRNA(Leu-specific A, causes a total loss of serine specificity without creating any leucine acceptance. These results suggest that the discriminator base A73 of human tRNA(Leu) alone protects this tRNA against serylation by seryl-tRNA synthetase. This is the first report of a complete identity switch caused by an exchange of the discriminator base alone.     

Efficient aminoacylation of resected RNA helices by class II aspartyl-tRNA synthetase dependent on a single nucleotide.

We show here that small RNA helices which recapitulate part or all of the acceptor stem of yeast aspartate tRNA are efficiently aminoacylated by cognate class II aspartyl-tRNA synthetase. Aminoacylation is strongly dependent on the presence of the single-stranded G73 'discriminator' identity nucleotide and is essentially insensitive to the sequence of the helical region. Substrates which contain as few as 3 bp fused to G73CCAOH are aspartylated. Their charging is insensitive to the sequence of the loop closing the short helical domains. Aminoacylation of the aspartate mini-helix is not stimulated by a hairpin helix mimicking the anticodon domain and containing the three major anticodon identity nucleotides. A thermodynamic analysis demonstrates that enzyme interactions with G73 in the resected RNA substrates and in the whole tRNA are the same. Thus, if the resected RNA molecules resemble in some way the earliest substrates for aminoacylation with aspartate, then the contemporary tRNA(Asp) has quantitatively retained the influence of the major signal for aminoacylation in these substrates.     

Specific substitution into the anticodon loop of yeast tyrosine transfer RNA

The aminoacylation kinetics of 19 different variants of yeast tRNATyr with nucleotide substitutions in positions 33-35 were determined. Substitution of the conserved uridine-33 does not alter the rate of aminoacylation. However, substitution of the anticodon position 34 or position 35 reduces Km from 2- to 10-fold and Vmax as much as 2-fold, depending on the nucleotide inserted. The ochre and amber suppressor tRNAsTyr both showed about a 7-fold reduction in Vmax/Km. Data from tRNATyr with different modified nucleotides at position 35 suggest that specific hydrogen bonds form between the synthetase and both the N1 and N3 hydrogens of psi-35. The effect of simultaneous substitutions at positions 34 and 35 can be predicted reasonably well by combining the effects of single substitutions. These data suggest that yeast tyrosyl-tRNA synthetase interacts with positions 34 and 35 of the anticodon of tRNATyr and opens the possibility that nonsense suppressor efficiency may be mediated by the level of aminoacylation.     

Mutational analysis of the tRNA mimicry of brome mosaic virus RNA. Sequence and structural requirements for aminoacylation and 3'-adenylation

The genomic RNAs of brome mosaic virus (BMV) exhibit various tRNA-like properties, including specific tyrosylation by tyrosyl-tRNA synthetases and adenylation of the 3'-CCOH derivative by tRNA nucleotidyl transferases. We have studied the effect of numerous mutations in all domains of the tRNA-like structure of BMV RNA on tyrosylation and adenylation in vitro. Surprisingly few mutations resulted in more than 50% decrease in tyrosylation rates with either wheat germ or yeast synthetases; those mutations were at the 3' terminus, the pseudoknot, and the bases of arms B and E. The results suggest an interaction of synthetase with arm A as the analog of the aminoacyl acceptor stem of tRNAs, and arm B as the analog of the anticodon arm of tRNAs, although there is no apparent interaction with the terminal loop of arm B analogous to the interaction with the anticodon in tRNAs. Mutations at several loci resulted in large losses of adenylation activity catalyzed by wheat germ and Escherichia coli nucleotidyl transferases; those loci were the pseudoknot, the bases of arms B, C and D, and at the junctions of these arms with arm A. These studies have identified mutants specifically defective in one of the tRNA-like activities, which are appropriate for investigating the role of these activities during infection in vivo.     

Mutational analysis of the pseudoknot in the tRNA-like structure of turnip yellow mosaic virus RNA. Aminoacylation efficiency and RNA pseudoknot stability.

Site-directed mutations were introduced in the connecting loops and one of the two stem regions of the RNA pseudoknot in the tRNA-like structure of turnip yellow mosaic virus RNA. The kinetic parameters of valylation for each mutated RNA were determined in a cell-free extract from wheat germ. Structure mapping was performed on most mutants with enzymic probes, like RNase T1, nuclease S1 and cobra venom ribonuclease. An insertion of four A residues in the four-membered connecting loop L1 that crosses the deep groove of the pseudoknot reduces aminoacylation efficiency. Deletions up to three nucleotides do not affect aminoacylation or RNA pseudoknot formation. Deletion of the entire loop abolishes aminoacylation. Although elimination of the pseudoknot is presumed, this could not be demonstrated. Unlike the mutations in loop L1, all mutations in the three-membered connecting loop L2 that crosses the shallow groove of the RNA pseudoknot decrease the aminoacylation efficiency considerably. Nonetheless, the RNA pseudoknot is still present in most mutated RNAs. These results indicate that a number of mutations can be introduced in both loops without abolishing aminoacylation. Results obtained with the introduction of mismatches and A.U base-pairs in stem S1 of the pseudoknot, containing three G.C base-pairs in wild-type RNA, indicate that the pseudoknot is only marginally stable. Our estimation of the gain of free energy due to the pseudoknot formation is at most 2.0 kcal/mol. The pseudoknot structure can, however, be stabilized upon binding the valyl-tRNA synthetase.