Roles of ring C oxygens in the binding of colchicine to tubulin

The roles of the oxygens in ring C of colchicine in its binding to tubulin were probed by a study of the interactions of two allocolchicine biphenyl analogues, 2,3,4,4'-tetramethoxy-1,1'-biphenyl (TMB) and 2,3,4-trimethoxy-4'-acetyl-1,1'-biphenyl (TKB), the first one containing a methoxy group in position 4', the second a keto group. Both analogues were found to bind specifically to the colchicine-binding site on tubulin in a rapidly reversible equilibrium. The standard free energies of binding at 25 degrees C were delta G zero (TKB) = 7.19 +/- 0.11 kcal mol-1 and delta G zero (TMB) = -6.76 +/- 0.22 kcal mol-1. The binding of TKB induced the same perturbation in protein circular dichroism at 220 nm as colchicine and allocolchicine, as well as quenching of protein tryptophan fluorescence. Binding of TMB did not affect the protein CD spectrum within experimental error and induced only a marginal quenching of protein fluorescence. Comparison with the binding properties of allocolchicine and its des(ring B) analogue 2,3,4-trimethoxy-4'-carbomethoxy-1,1'-biphenyl (TCB) [Medrano et al. (1989) Biochemistry 28, 5589-5599] has shown that the binding properties of the 4'-keto analogue (TKB) were closer to those of allocolchicine, even though the substituent in the 4'-position of TCB is identical with that of allocolchicine. It has been proposed that binding in the ring C subsite on tubulin, which is stabilized thermodynamically by stacking interactions, can be modulated in a nonidentical fashion by the carbonyl and the ether oxygens in the para position of ring C.     

Anion-induced increases in the rate of colchicine binding to tubulin.

The rate of binding of colchicine to tubulin to tubulin is enhanced by certain anions. Among the inorganic anions tested, only sulfate was effective. The organic anions include mostly dicarboxylic acids, among which tartrate was the most effective. This effect occurs onlt at low concentrations of colchicine (less than 0.6 X 10(-5) M). The rate increase dor sulfate and L-(+)-tartrate is ca. 2.5-fold at 1.0 mM and plateaus at a limiting value of ca. 4-fold at 100mM. The overall dissociation rate of the colchicine from the complex, which includes both the true rate of dissociation and the rate of irreversible denaturation of tubulin, is not influenced by 1.0 mM tartrate. The affinity constants for colchicine determined from the rate constants are 8.7 X 10(6) and 2.1 X 10(7) M-1 in the absence and the presence of 1.0 mM L-(+)-tartrate. The limiting value is 3.2 X 10(7) M-1. The affinity constant calculated from steady-state measurements is 3.2 X 10(6) M-1 with or without anions. The binding of other ligands like podophyllotoxin, vinblastine, and 1 -anilino-8-naphthalenesulfonate to tubulin is not affected by tartrate. No major conformational changes resulting from anion treatment could be detected by circular dichroism or intrinsic fluorescence. However, the ability of tubulin to polymerize is inhibited by L-(+)-tartrate at concentrations that increase the rate of colchicine binding. We conclude that anions must have a local effect at or near the binding site which enhances the binding rate of colchicine and which may be related to inhibition of polymerization.     

Luminescence studies of perturbation of tryptophan residues of tubulin in the complexes of tubulin with colchicine and colchicine analogues

Tubulin, a heterodimeric (alphabeta) protein, the main constituent of microtubules, binds efficiently with colchicine (consisting of a trimethoxybenzene ring, a seven-member ring and methoxy tropone moiety) and its analogues, viz., demecolcine and AC [2-methoxy-5-(2',3',4'-trimethoxyphenyl)tropone]. Tubulin contains eight tryptophan (Trp) residues at A21, A346, A388, A407, B21, B103, B346, and B407 in the two subunits. The role of these eight Trp residues in this interaction and also their perturbation due to binding have been explored via time-resolved fluorescence at room temperature and low-temperature (77 K) phosphorescence in a suitable cryosolvent. Both the time-resolved fluorescence data and 77 K phosphorescence spectra indicate that the emitting residues move toward a more hydrophobic and less polar environment after complex formation. The environment of emitting Trps in the complex also becomes slightly more heterogeneous. Our analysis using the experimental results, the calculation of the accessible surface area (ASA) of all the Trps in the wild type and tubulin-colchicine complex [Ravelli, R. B. G., et al. (2004) Nature 428, 198-202], the distance of the Trp residues from the different moieties of the colchicine molecule, the knowledge of the nature of the immediate residues (<5 A) present near each Trp residue, and the calculation of the intramolecular Trp-Trp energy transfer efficiencies indicate that Trp A346, Trp A407, Trp B21, and Trp B407 are the major contributors to the emission in the free protein, while Trp B21 and Trp B103 are mainly responsible for the emission of the complexes. A comparative account of the photophysical aspects of the drug molecules bound to protein in aqueous buffer and in buffer containing 40% ethylene glycol has been presented. The quantum yield and average lifetime of fluorescence in tubulin and its complexes with colchicine are used to predict the possible donors and the energy transfer (ET) efficiency in the ET process from Trps to colchicine in the complex. This study is a unique attempt to identify the Trp residues contributing to the emission in the free protein and in a complex of a multi-Trp protein with a drug molecule without performing the mutation of the protein.     

Polymerization and colchicine binding. Two independent properties of tubulin

When stored frozen in 1 M sucrose and 1 mM GTP, tubulin loses polymerizing ability exponentially. Since addition of diethiothreitol does not change the decay half-life, this decrease in activity can not be attributed to disulfide bond formation. When tubulin is stored frozen in dithiothreitol and GTP only, the decay half-life increases by a factor of four, indicating that sucrose destabilizes polymerizing ability. Frozen storage in sucrose has the opposite effect on colchicine binding, which remains at 100% for 40 days. This temporal divergence indicates that colchine binding and polymerization are two independent properties of tubulin.     

The binding of vincristine, vinblastine and colchicine to tubulin

Preparations of tubulin were examined for their ability to bind vincristine, vinblastine, and colchicine, as measured by adsorption on DEAE impregnated filter paper. Vincristine and vinblastine were found to bind very rapidly with tubulin (<5 min), while colchicine took considerably longer (>4 hr). When varying concentrations of the alkaloids were employed, and the data examined on a Scatchard plot, it was found that colchicine had an association constant of 1.8 × 10⁶ liters/mole, while vinblastine and vincristine had constants of 6.0 × 10⁶ liters/mole and 8.0 × 10⁶ liters/mole respectively. In addition, it was found that the ratio of molar binding of colchicine was always twice that of vinblastine or vincristine.     

Effect of tubulin binding and self-association on the near-ultraviolet circular dichroic spectra of colchicine and analogues

Near-UV circular dichroic (CD) spectra of three colchicine analogues that differ at the C-10 position have been obtained in the presence and absence of tubulin. All three colchicine analogues show dramatic alterations in the low-energy near-UV CD band upon tubulin binding that cannot be mimicked by solvent, but in no event does the rotational strength of the CD band decrease to nearly zero as in the case of colchicine [Detrich, H. W., III, Williams, R. C., Jr., Macdonald, T. L., & Puett, D. (1981) Biochemistry 20, 5999-6005]. The effect of self-association of colchicine and one of the C-10 analogues, thiocolchicine, on the near-UV CD band was also investigated. A qualitative similarity was seen between the near-UV CD spectra of colchicine and thiocolchicine dimers and the spectra of these molecules bound to tubulin. These observations support the previous suggestion that ligands bound to the colchicine site on tubulin may be interacting with an aromatic amino acid in the colchicine binding site [Hastie, S. B., & Rava, R. P. (1989) J. Am. Chem. Soc. 110, 6993-7001].     

Mechanism of binding of the new antimitotic drug MDL 27048 to the colchicine site of tubulin: equilibrium studies.

MDL 27048 [trans-1-(2,5-dimethoxyphenyl)-3-[4-(dimethylamino)phenyl]-2- methyl-2-propen-1-one] fluoresces when bound to tubulin but not in solution. This effect has been investigated and found to be mimicked by viscous solvents. Therefore, MDL 27048 appears to be a fluorescent compound whose intramolecular rotational relaxation varies as a function of microenvironment viscosity. The binding parameters of MDL 27048 to tubulin have been firmly established by fluorescence of the ligand, quenching of the protein fluorescence, and gel equilibrium chromatography. The apparent binding equilibrium constant was (2.75 +/- 0.45) x 10(6)M-1, and the binding site number was 0.81 +/- 0.12 (10 mM sodium phosphate-0.1 mM GTP, pH 7.0, at 25 degrees C). The binding is exothermic. The binding of MDL 27048 overlaps the colchicine and podophyllotoxin binding sites. Binding of MDL 27048 to the colchicine site was also measured by competition with MTC [2-methoxy-5-(2,3,4-trimethoxyphenyl)-2,4,6-cycloheptatrien-1-one] , a well-characterized reversibly binding probe of the colchicine site [Andreu et al. (1984) Biochemistry 23, 1742-1752; Bane et al., (1984) J. Biol. Chem. 259, 7391-7398]. In contrast with close analogues of colchicine, MDL 27048 and podophyllotoxin neither affected the far-ultraviolet circular dichroism spectrum of tubulin, within experimental error, nor induced tubulin GTPase activity. Like podophyllotoxin, an excess of MDL 27048 over tubulin induced no abnormal cooperative polymerization of tubulin, which is characteristic of colchicine binding.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Effect of B-ring substituents on absorption and circular dichroic spectra of colchicine analogues.

Near-ultraviolet absorption and circular dichroic spectra of several B-ring derivatives of colchicine have been obtained in a variety of solvents. The spectra of the molecules in solvent were analyzed and compared with spectra of the molecules bound to tubulin. Absorption spectra of deacetamidocolchicine, deacetylcolchicine, demecolcine, and N-methyldemecolcine [B-ring substituents = H, NH2, NHCH3, and N(CH3)2, respectively] were analyzed by multiple differentiation of the spectrum. It was found that an amine substituent at the C-7 position on the B-ring of the colchicinoid affected the higher energy transition of the near-ultraviolet spectra of the colchicinoid in the absence of tubulin in a manner consistent with a hyperconjugative alteration of this transition. The fourth derivatives of the absorption spectra of all four molecules bound to tubulin were similar to each other and to colchicine. As was true in the case of colchicine, the negative near-ultraviolet circular dichroic band of the aminoclochicinoids was relatively unaffected by solvent, but the molar ellipticity of the band was greatly reduced with tubulin binding. It is concluded that the binding site environments of the B-ring analogues of colchicine, as probed by absorption and circular dichroic spectroscopy, are equivalent.     

Interaction of tubulin with bifunctional colchicine analogues: an equilibrium study

The interaction of tubulin with simple analogues of colchicine that contain both its tropolone and trimethoxyphenyl rings has been characterized, and the results were analyzed in terms of the simple bifunctional ligand model developed for the binding of colchicine [ Andreu , J. M., & Timasheff , S. N. (1982) Biochemistry 21, 534-543] on the basis of interactions of tubulin with single-ring analogues. The compound 2-methoxy-5-(2,3,4-trimethoxyphenyl)-2,4,6- cycloheptatrien -1-one has been found to bind reversibly to 0.86 +/- 0.06 site of purified calf brain tubulin with an equilibrium constant of (4.9 +/- 0.3) X 10(5) M-1 (25 degrees C), delta H degrees app = -1.6 +/- 0.7 kcal mol-1, and delta S degrees app = 20.5 +/- 2.5 eu. The binding appears specific for the colchicine site. The closely related compound 2-methoxy-5-[[3-(3,4,5-trimethoxyphenyl)-propionyl]amino] -2,4,6- cycloheptatrien -1-one interacts weakly with tubulin. Binding of the first analogue is accompanied by ligand fluorescence appearance, quenching of protein fluorescence, perturbation of the far-ultraviolet circular dichroism of tubulin, and induction of the tubulin GTPase activity, similarly to colchicine binding. Substoichiometric concentrations of the analogue inhibit microtubule assembly in vitro. Excess analogue concentration under microtubule-promoting conditions induces an abnormal cooperative polymerization of tubulin, similar to that of the tubulin-colchicine complex.     

Roles of colchicine rings B and C in the binding process to tubulin

The interactions of tubulin with colchicine analogues in which the tropolone methyl ether ring had been transformed into a p-carbomethoxybenzene have been characterized. The analogues were allocolchicine (ALLO) and 2,3,4-trimethoxy-4'-carbomethoxy-1,1'-biphenyl (TCB), the first being transformed colchicine and the second transformed colchicine with ring B eliminated. The binding of both analogues has been shown to be specific for the colchicine binding site on tubulin by competition with colchicine and podophyllotoxin. Both analogues bind reversibly to tubulin with the generation of ligand fluorescence. The binding of ALLO is slow, the fluorescence reaching a steady state in the same time span as colchicine; that of TCB is rapid. The displacement of ALLO by podophyllotoxin proceeds with a half-life of ca. 40 min. Binding isotherms generated from gel filtration and fluorescence measurements have shown that both analogues bind to tubulin with a stoichiometry of 1 mol of analogue/mol of alpha-beta tubulin. The equilibrium binding constants at 25 degrees C have been found to be (9.2 +/- 2.5) x 10(5) M-1 for ALLO and (1.0 +/- 0.2) X 10(5) M-1 for TCB. Binding of both analogues was accompanied by quenching of protein fluorescence, perturbation of the far-ultraviolet circular dichroism of tubulin, and induction of the tubulin GTPase activity, similarly to colchicine binding. Both inhibited microtubule assembly in vitro, ALLO substoichiometrically, and both induced the abnormal cooperative polymerization of tubulin, which is characteristic of the tubulin-colchicine complex. Analysis in terms of the simple bifunctional ligand binding mechanism developed for colchicine [Andreu, J.M., & Timasheff, S.N. (1982) Biochemistry 21, 534-543] and comparison with the binding of the colchicine two-ring analogue, 2-methoxy-5-(2,3,4-trimethoxyphenyl)-2,4,6-cycloheptatrien-1-one [Andreu, J. M., Gorbunoff, M. J., Lee, J. C., & Timasheff, S. N. (1984) Biochemistry 23, 1742-1752], have shown that transformation of the tropolone methyl ether part of colchicine into p-carbomethoxybenzene weakens the standard free energy of binding to tubulin by 1.4 +/- 0.1 kcal/mol, while elimination of ring B weakens it by 1.0 +/- 0.1 kcal/mol. The roles of rings C and B of colchicine in the thermodynamic and kinetic mechanisms of binding to tubulin were analyzed in terms of these findings.     

Podophyllotoxin as a probe for the colchicine binding site of tubulin.

The binding of [3H]podophyllotoxin to tubulin, measured by a DEAE-cellulose filter paper method, occurs with an affinity constant of 1.8 X 10(6) M-1 (37 degrees at pH 6.7). Like colchicine, approximately 0.8 mol of podophyllotixin are bound per mol of tubulin dimer, and the reaction is entropy-driven (43 cal deg-1 mol-1). At 37 degrees the association rate constant for podophyllotoxin binding is 3.8 X 10(6) M-1 h-1, approximtaely 10 times higher than for colchicine; this is reflected in the activation energies for binding which are 14.7 kcal/mol for podophyllotoxin and 20.3 kcal/mol for colchicine. The dissociation rate constant for the tubulin-podophyllotoxin complex is 1.9 h-1, and the affinity constant calculated from the ratio of the rates is close to that obtained by equilibrium measurements. Podophyllotxin and colchicine are mutually competitive inhibitors. This can be ascribed to the fact that both compounds have a trimethoxyphenyl ring and analogues of either compound with bulky substituents in their trimethoxyphenyl moiety are unable to inhibit the the binding of either of the two ligands. Tropolone, which inhibits colchicine binding competitively, has no effect on the podophyllotoxin/tubulin reaction. Conversely, podophyllotoxin does not influence tropolone binding. Moreover, the tropolone binding site of tubulin does not show the temperature and pH lability of the colchicine and podophyllotoxin domains, hence this lability can be ascribed to the trimethoxyphenyl binding region of tubulin. Since podophyllotoxin analogues with a modified B ring do not bind, it is concluded that both podophyllotoxin and colchicine each have at least two points of attachment to tubulin and that they share one of them, the binding region of the trimethoxyphenyl moiety.     

Aging of tubulin at neutral pH: stabilization by colchicine and its analogues.

The effect of colchicine and its analogues, allocolchicine, 2,3,4-trimethoxy-4'-carbomethoxy-1,1'biphenyl, 2,3,4,4'-tetramethoxy-1,1'-biphenyl, 2,3,4-trimethoxy-4'-acetyl-1,1'-biphenyl, and tropolone methyl ether, on the aging process of tubulin has been examined. In contrast to the vinca alkaloid drugs which accelerate the formation of the paucidisperse 9 S polymers by a factor of 3.5, the colchicine class of ligands stabilize alpha,beta-tubulin. Less than 10% of the protein is transformed into the aggregates after 50 h of incubation in the presence of 1 x 10(-3) M colchicine, as compared to nearly 70-75% transformation in its absence. These results are supported by fluorescence examination of the retention of colchicine binding ability, as well as circular dichroism spectroscopy. In the presence of colchicine, the rate determining step is a conformational change, just as in its absence. The colchicine analogues which bind to tubulin in a rapidly reversible equilibrium were almost as effective in tubulin stabilization. Addition of vincristine to the system reduced the stability of the tubulin-colchicine complex. Furthermore, vincristine was found to have the same effects on the fresh complex as it does on pure tubulin; i.e., it induced the isodesmic linear polymerization and inhibited assembly into the microtubule-mimicking large polymers. This inhibition, however, was stoichiometric, whereas it is substoichiometric in the case of microtubules.     

Comparative molecular field analysis of colchicine inhibition and tubulin polymerization for combretastatins binding to the colchicine binding site on beta-tubulin

A molecular modeling study using Comparative Molecular Field Analysis (CoMFA) was undertaken to develop a predictive model for combretastatin binding to the colchicine binding site of tubulin. Furthermore, we examined the potential contribution of lipophilicity (log P) and molecular dipole moment and were unable to correlate these properties to the observed biological data. In this study we first confirmed that tubulin polymerization inhibition (IC50) correlated (R2 = 0.92) with [3H]colchicine displacement. Although these data correlated quite well, we developed two independent models for each set of data to quantify structural features that may contribute to each biological property independently. To develop our predictive model we first examined a series of molecular alignments for the training set and ultimately found that overlaying the respective trimethoxyphenyl rings (A ring) of the analogues generated the best correlated model. The CoMFA yielded a cross-validated R2 = 0.41 (optimum number of components equal to 5) for the tubulin polymerization model and an R2 = 0.38 (optimum number of components equal to 5) for [3H]colchicine inhibition. Final non-cross-validation generated models for tubulin polymerization (R2 of 0.93) and colchicine inhibition (R2 of 0.91). These models were validated by predicting both biological properties for compounds not used in the training set. These models accurately predicted the IC50 for tubulin polymerization with an R2 of 0.88 (n = 6) and those of [3H]colchicine displacement with an R2 of 0.80 (n = 7). This study represents the first predictive model for the colchicine binding site over a wide range of combretastatin analogues.     

Involvement of colchicine binding site of tubulin in the polymerisation process

Role of lysine residues in the colchicine binding site and in the assembly-disassembly process was examined. It was observed that at 4 degrees C (pH 7.5-8, 8 +/- 1) lysine residues and the N-terminal methionine residue of tubulin were all buried within the molecule. Evidence indicates that epsilon-amino groups of lysine residues of tubulin are shared by both the colchicine binding site and the polymerisation process.     

Polymerization and colchicine binding: Two independent properties of tubulin

When stored frozen in 1 M sucrose and 1 mM GTP, tubulin loses polymerizing ability exponentially. Since addition of dithiothreitol does not change the decay half-life, this decrease in activity can not be attributed to disulfide bond formation. When tubulin is stored frozen in dithiothreitol and GTP only, the decay half-life increases by a factor of four, indicating that sucrose destabilizes polymerizing ability. Frozen storage in sucrose has the oppostite effect on colchicine binding, which remains at 100% for 40 days. This temporal divergence indicates that colchicine binding and polymerization are two independent properties of tubulin.     

Sulfhydryl groups of Mimosa pudica tubulin implicated in colchicine binding and polymerization in vitro.

The important characteristic of novel Mimosa pudica tubulin is its ability to bind colchicine only when dithiothreitol is included in the isolation buffer, indicating the involvement of sulfhydryl groups in colchicine binding. Modification of sulfhydryl groups by a sulfhydryl modifying agent also affects the normal assembly of tubulin into microtubules, as revealed by electron microscopic and spectrophotometric studies. The number of free sulfhydryl groups present in tubulin protein responsible for both colchicine binding and polymerization has been found to be 4, distributed in alpha and beta subunits, and is distinctly different from the number reported for animal tubulin.     

Involvement of tryptophan residues in colchicine binding and the assembly of tubulin

Chemical modification of tubulin with 2-hydroxy-5-nitrobenzyl bromide, a reagent selective for tryptophan, inhibits tubulin's colchicine binding and in vitro assembly activities. Loss of colchicine binding shows a linear relationship with the modification of tryptophan residues, and is complete when not more than five residues are modified. GTP affords partial protection against this loss of colchicine binding. The in vitro assembly of tubulin is somewhat less sensitive, since microtubules are formed from tubulin dimers possessing 3–4 but not five modified residues. Furthermore, two of the eight tryptophans per dimer are reactive when tubulin is assembled into microtubules.     

Docking study of ligands into the colchicine binding site of tubulin

Cancer is a major cause of mortality in developed countries, following only cardiovascular diseases. Death of cancerous cells can be achieved by stopping mitosis and the antimitotic class of drugs formed by the spindle poisons can be used for this purpose. Their role is to disorganize the mitotic spindle by targeting its main constituent, the microtubules, themselves made of heterodimers of alpha and beta-tubulin. They disrupt the dynamics of the microtubules either by stabilizing them, as do paclitaxel or epothilones, or destabilizing them, as do colchicine. The binding site of colchicine seems to lie between the two units of the tubulin dimer. Here, we report on the characterization of this site by the docking of a series of reference compounds, and the subsequent docking of ligands prepared in our laboratory.     

Sulfhydryls of platelet tubulin: their role in polymerization and colchicine binding

Sulfhydryls and disulfides of platelet tubulin have been quantified, their accessibility and reactivity measured, and their role in polymerization and colchicine binding evaluated. Platelet tubulin isolated by two cycles of temperature-dependent polymerization--depolymerization was found to contain 12 free sulfhydryl groups per tubulin monomer all of which reacted rapidly with p-chloromercuribenzoate. One sulfhydryl was inaccessible to dithiobis(nitrobenzoic acid). Under anaerobic conditions of tubulin extraction, one intrachain disulfide bridge was found per tubulin monomer. Polymerization of tubulin reduced the number of sulfhydryls by one which were able to react with p-chloromercuribenzoate or dithiobis(nicotinic acid) but did not affect the disulfide bridge. Polymerizability of platelet tubulin was very sensitive to blocking of free sulfhydryl groups. Complete inhibition of microtubule assembly was obtained when the number of free sulfhydryls per tubulin was reduced by 3 but could be reversed by the addition of dithiothreitol. Colchicine binding, on the other hand, was only minimally influenced by blocking of sulfhydryls.     

Nucleotide-dependent bisANS binding to tubulin.

Non-covalent hydrophobic probes such as 5, 5'-bis(8-anilino-1-naphthalenesulfonate) (bisANS) have become increasingly popular to gain information about protein structure and conformation. However, there are limitations as bisANS binds non-specifically at multiple sites of many proteins. Successful use of this probe depends upon the development of binding conditions where only specific dye-protein interaction will occur. In this report, we have shown that the binding of bisANS to tubulin occurs instantaneously, specifically at one high affinity site when 1 mM guanosine 5'-triphosphate (GTP) is included in the reaction medium. Substantial portions of protein secondary structure and colchicine binding activity of tubulin are lost upon bisANS binding in absence of GTP. BisANS binding increases with time and occurs at multiple sites in the absence of GTP. Like GTP, other analogs, guanosine 5'-diphosphate, guanosine 5'-monophosphate and adenosine 5'-triphosphate, also displace bisANS from the lower affinity sites of tubulin. We believe that these multiple binding sites are generated due to the bisANS-induced structural changes on tubulin and the presence of GTP and other nucleotides protect those structural changes.