Floral developmental evidence for the systematic position of Batis (Bataceae)

Molecular phylogenies have associated Bataceae with Salvadoraceae and Koeberliniaceae in an expanded Brassicales. Despite a long taxonomic history, the knowledge of the flower of Batis is still fragmentary. The floral development of pistillate and staminate inflorescences of Batis maritima was investigated to understand homologies of floral structures and to discuss the phylogenetic position of Bataceae within the Brassicales. There has been considerable controversy in the past about the male flower, especially on the nature of the petals and the tubular structure enclosing the flower. Developmental evidence confirms that the male flower is built on a basic tetramerous bauplan and that the tubular structure is derived from four congenitally fused sepal lobes with the three anterior lobes highly reduced. The development of petals and stamens is unidirectional, and the androecium initiates the median stamens before the lateral stamens, suggesting the existence of two whorls. The pistillate flowers are reduced to the bare minimum with two transversal carpels enclosed by a bract. Partial inflorescences function as a swollen dispersal unit. The vestigial stipules probably represent colleters and are not homologous with true stipules. Several characters of Batis are reminiscent of the Brassicaceae, although a link with Salvadoraceae and Koeberliniaceae cannot be excluded.     

Chemosystematics of Brassicales

The order Brassicales, sensu APG III, belongs to Eurosids, and comprises 17 families and 398 genera. The present work discusses the chemical features of Brassicales through the micromolecular chemical data of its taxa and selected taxonomic markers to assess pertinent affinities between its families by correlating their chemosystematic parameters. Although the chemical data of all families were obtained, the data of Brassicaceae, Capparaceae, and Cleomaceae were the most studied. The chemistry of the Brassicales species is diverse, but it reveals the chemical affinity of its families due to occurrence of flavonoids (35%) and glucosinolates (25%), which were characterized as good chemical markers. The flavonoids consist primarily of flavones and flavonols, presenting a low flavone/flavonol ratio. These micromolecules commonly contain unprotected hydroxyls, which are mainly protected by glucosilation, revealing the basal features of its taxa. In Brassicales, the predominantly allyl glucosinolates are usually found in Brassicaceae, Capparaceae, and Cleomaceae families. In the present study, the results of the chemosystematic analysis confirmed the affinity among the Brassicaceae, Capparaceae, and Cleomaceae families, and supported the concept of their monophyly in the Brassicales order. However, more chemical data of the other families is required to improve the chemosystematic conclusions.     

Floral development and anatomy of Salvadoraceae

Background and Aims

This study is an investigation into the floral development and anatomy of two genera of the small family Salvadoraceae, which belongs to the Brassicales in a clade with Batis and Koeberlinia. Salvadoraceae remains little known, despite its wide distribution in arid areas of the globe. Floral morphological data are scarce, and information on floral anatomy is limited to a single study, although morphological and anatomical characters are now used increasingly as a counterpart of molecular data. There remain a number of controversial morphological questions, such as the fusion of the petals, the number of carpels and the nature of the nectaries.

Methods

Floral anatomy and ontogeny were studied in two species of Salvadora and one species of Dobera. Only for S. persica could a full floral developmental sequence be done.

Key Results

The floral development demonstrates that the ovary of Salvadoraceae is basically bicarpellate and pseudomonomerous with a single locule and parietal placenta. The ovary of Dobera resembles Azima tetracantha in the presence of a false apical septum. Evidence for a staminodial nature of the nectaries is not decisive. In Salvadora petals and stamens are lifted by a short hypanthium.

Conclusions

Salvadoraceae share several morphological and developmental synapomorphies with Batis (Bataceae) and possibly Koeberlinia (Koeberliniaceae), supporting their close relationship as indicated by molecular phylogeny.Key words: Batis, Brassicales, Dobera, Emblingia, floral development, floral anatomy, Koeberlinia, phylogeny, Salvadora, Salvadoraceae, SEM     

The systematic relationships of glucosinolate-producing plants and related families: a cladistic investigation based on morphological and molecular characters

A cladistic analysis is performed using 94 morphological and biochemical characters for 42 genera to compare a phylogeny based on morphological data with those obtained using different genes ( rbc L, atp B, 18S RNA, mat K) or their combination with morphological data, and to understand the floral evolution within the expanded Brassicales (Capparales) relative to Sapindales and Malvales. The tree produced with morphological data is congruent with those obtained from macromolecular studies in obtaining a well-supported glucosinolate-producing clade and an expanded Sapindales. The combined analysis of the morphological and molecular characters is generally well resolved with support for many of the relationships. The inclusion of the fossil taxon Dressiantha demonstrates the value of inserting fossil evidence in phylogenetic analyses. However, the fossil appears to be related to the Anacardiaceae and not to the Brassicales. The core Brassicales are well supported by a number of synapomorphies, although the internal position of Tovariaceae and Pentadiplandraceae is not well resolved. Emblingiaceae appears to be related to Bataceae and Salvadoraceae. Several significant morphological characters are mapped on the combined trees and their evolutionary significance is discussed. Within Brassicales and Sapindales several well supported clades can be recognized which merit ordinal or subordinal status, putting the present orders at a higher level; these include: Tropaeolales, Setchellanthales, Batidales, Brassicales (Brassiciflorae), Burserales, Sapindales and Rutales (Sapindiflorae). The present scheme of affinities within the Brassicales corresponds well with a gradual morphological evolution in the order.  © 2006 The Linnean Society of London, Botanical Journal of the Linnean Society , 2006, 151 , 453–494.     

Parallel evolution of glucosinolate biosynthesis inferred from congruent nuclear and plastid gene phylogenies

The phytochemical system of mustard-oil glucosides (glucosinolates) accompanied by the hydrolytic enzyme myrosinase (beta-thioglucosidase), the latter usually compartmented in special myrosin cells, characterizes plants in 16 families of angiosperms. Traditional classifications place these taxa in many separate orders and thus imply multiple convergences in the origin of this chemical defense system. DNA sequencing of the chloroplast rbcL gene for representatives of all 16 families and several putative relatives, with phylogenetic analyses by parsimony and maximum likelihood methods, demonstrated instead a single major clade of mustard-oil plants and one phylogenetic outlier. In a further independent test, DNA sequencing of the nuclear 18S ribosomal RNA gene for all these exemplars has yielded the same result, a major mustard-oil clade of 15 families (Akaniaceae, Bataceae, Brassicaceae, Bretschneideraceae, Capparaceae, Caricaceae, Gyrostemonaceae, Koeberliniaceae, Limnanthaceae, Moringaceae, Pentadiplandraceae, Resedaceae, Salvadoraceae, Tovariaceae, and Tropaeolaceae) and one outlier, the genus Drypetes, traditionally placed in Euphorbiaceae. Concatenating the two gene sequences (for a total of 3254 nucleotides) in a data set for 33 taxa, we obtain robust support for this finding of parallel origins of glucosinolate biosynthesis. From likely cyanogenic ancestors, the "mustard oil bomb" was invented twice.     

Brassicales: an update on chromosomal evolution and ancient polyploidy

Brassicales comprise 17 families, c. 400 genera and more than 4600 species. Despite the mustard family (crucifers, Brassicaceae) continuing to be the subject of intensive research, the remaining 16 families are largely under studied. Here I summarize the available data on chromosome number and genome size variation across Brassicales in the context of a robust phylogenetic framework. This analysis has revealed extensive knowledge gaps in karyological data for non-crucifer and species-rich families in particular (i.e., Capparaceae, Cleomaceae, Resedaceae and Tropaeolaceae). A parsimonious interpretation of the combined chromosomal and phylogenetic data set suggests that the ancestral pre-Brassicales genome had 9 or 14 chromosome pairs, later multiplied by the At-β (beta) whole-genome duplication (WGD) to n?=?18 or 28. This WGD was followed by post-polyploid diploidization marked by diversification to 12 or 13 families and independent decreases in chromosome numbers. Family-specific WGDs are proposed to precede the diversification of Capparaceae, Resedaceae and Tropaeolaceae.     

Glucosinolate biochemical diversity and innovation in the Brassicales

Glucosinolates were analysed from herbarium specimens and living tissues from representative of all families of the Brassicales, following the phylogenetic schemes of Rodman et al. (1998) and Hall et al. (2002, 2004), including specimens of Akania, Setchellanthus, Emblingia, Stixis, Forchhammeria and members of the Capparaceae for which glucosinolate content had not previously been reported. The results are reviewed along with additional published data on glucosinolate content of members of the Brassicales. In addition to providing an overview of the evolution of glucosinolate biochemical diversity within the core Brassicales, there were three main findings. Firstly, the glucosinolate content of some 'orphan' taxa of the Brassicales, such as Setchellanthus and Emblingia were consistent with recent phylogentic analyses based upon DNA sequence comparisons, while further analyses of Tirania and Stixis is required. Secondly, methyl glucosinolate is found within the Capparaceae and Cleomaceae, but also, unexpectedly, within Forchhammeria, with implications for the biochemical and evolutionary origin of methyl glucosinolate and the phylogenetic relationships of Forchhammeria. Thirdly, whereas Old World Capparaceae contain methyl glucosinolate, New World Capparaceae, including New World Capparis, either contain methyl glucosinolates or glucosinolates of complex and unresolved structures, indicative of continued innovation in glucosinolate biosynthesis. These taxa may be productive sources of glucosinolate biosynthetic genes and alleles that are not found in the model plant Arabidopsis thaliana.     

The embryology and taxonomic relationships of Bretschneidera (Bretschneideraceae)

TOBE, H. & PENG, C.-I, 1990. The embryology and taxonomic relationships of Bretschneidera (Bretschneideraceae). We present the first report on the embryology of Bretschneidera , the only genus of Bretschneideraceae (which are one of 15 glucosinolate-producing families), to clarify its relationships. Embryologically Bretschneidera is characterized by the following features: ovule campylotropous, bitegmic and crassinucellate; outer integument thick, multiplicative and vascularized; embryo sac formation of the Allium type; seed exalbuminous; seed coat 'exotestal' with a palisade of columellar, thick-walled exotestal cells; mesotesta thick with the inner half aerenchymatous. These features suggest that Bretschneidera is distinct from any of the taxonomically related families but resembles both Hippocastanaceae and Sapindaceae (Sapindales) more closely than Moringaceae or Capparaceae (Capparales) which have been considered alternative allies, supporting most of the modern taxonomic treatments that place Bretschneidera as a separate family in Sapindales.     

Morphological Studies on Circaeaster agrestis Maxim. (1) Process of Embryolo gical Development

The present paper aims at discovering the characters of embryological development of Circaeaster agrestis, which makes up a monotypic genus, Circaeaster, to establish the phylogenetic relationships of the genus. The different opinions on its systematic position among botanists are briefly explained. The embryological studies show that the most important advanced characters of the genus are as follows. The ovule is amphitropous, unitegmic and tenuinucelar; the embryo sac formation is in accordance with the Polygonum type; endosperm formation is of the cellular type, the primary endosperm nucleus dividing to form two cells and the first wall vertical; embryo formation follows the variation of the Caryophyllad type; at the early stage of development of embryo, the integument has been already atrophied and at last disappeared, so that the seed coat is absent in the mature fruit. On the basis of the embryological and some morphological evidence, the authors consider that a close relationship between the genus and Ranunculaceae and its related families seems to be unlikely. The affinities of the genus Circaeaster are still uncertain.     

Embryology and relationships of Akania (Akaniaceae)

We present the first extensive study of embryology of Akania , the only genus of Akaniaceae (one of the 15 glucosinolate-producing families). Akania has a distinctive combination of embryological features, which includes bitegmic and crassinucellate ovules; thick, multiplicative and vascularized outer integument; a Polygonum-type embryo sac; albuminous seed; 'exotestal' seed coat with a palisade of columellar, thick-walled cells and a thick and sclerotic mesotesta with the inner tissue aerenchymatous. A comparison of its embryological characteristics with those of some other groups indicates that Akania closely resembles Bretschneideraceae (another glucosinolate-producing family) and Sapindaceae, but it retains some archaic embryological features and is best treated as a separate family in or near Sapindales, as in most modern general classifications. Based on evidence from embryological and other data, Akaniaceae appear to be the sister group of Bretschneideraceae, possibly near to Sapindales. With the data at hand, we cannot fully assess the recent suggestion that Akaniaceae-Bretschneideraceae are a basal group in Capparales.     

Embryology of Siparunaceae (Laurales): characteristics and character evolution

Embryological characters of Siparunaceae, which are poorly understood, were studied on the basis of two constituent genera, an African Glossocalyx and a South American Siparuna, to better understand their evolution within Laurales. These two genera have many embryological characteristics in common with the other lauralean families. Noticeably, they share the multi-celled ovule archesporium (uncertain in Glossocalyx) as a synapomorphy with all the other lauralean families except Lauraceae, the anthers dehisced by valves as a synspomorphy with all the other lauralean families except Calycanthaceae and Monimiaceae, and the bisporangiate anther as a synapomorphy with Gomortegaceae and Atherospermataceae. Siparunaceae are, however, distinct from all other laularean families in having unitegmic ovules that were derived from bitegmic ovules, probably due to an elimination of the outer integument. Likewise, the lack of the testa (i.e., developed outer integument), the "endotegmic" seed coat, and the perichalazal seed at maturity are also characteristics of Siparunaceae. Within the family, Siparuna differs from Glossocalyx in having plural tetrads of megaspores and plural, starchy-rich, one-nucleate, tubular embryo sacs (autapomorphies). On the other hand, Glossocalyx is characterized by having bilaterally flattened seeds (autapomorphy). Although functional aspects of those autapomorphies are uncertain, both Glossocalyx and Siparuna show evolution in different embryological characters.     

Pollen morphology of Gyrostemonaceae,Bataceae andKoeberlinia

Pollen morphology of Gyrostemonaceae, Bataceae, andKoeberlinia, which have been affiliated with glucosinolate-producing taxa, was examined by field emission scanning and transmission electron microscopy. Pollen grains of Gyrostemonaceae are tricolpate with scabrate-spinulate surface and have a thick, unstratified exine, while those of Bataceae are tricolporoidate with granular surface and have a thin exine with a single, outermost granular layer. Gyrostemonaceae and Bataceae, which had often been considered sister taxa based on palynological similarity and now are considered more distantly related, have a similar spongy ektexine, but differences between them are evident.Koeberlinia, which is recently considered a sister group to Bataceae+Salvadoraceae (with no spongy ektexine), has tricolporoidate pollen composed of a plesiomorphic, stratified exine with columellae. The totality of evidence indicates that, contrary to earlier observations, pollen of Gyrostemonaceae and Bataceae does not closely resemble each other, and that the spongy ektexine, which looks to be similar in TEM sections, is a homoplasy that evolved independently in the two families. Dedicated to the late Prof. Emer. Kankichi Sohma (August 28, 1926–June 26, 1995), who supervised us for our M. Sc. and D. Sc. programs at Tohoku University, Sendai. He died after his 40 years career in palynology; his wide range of interests and enthusiasm for research, and his unfailing encouragement for students are greatly missed.     

Myrosin cells and dilated cisternae of the endoplasmic reticulum in the order Capparales

Ultrastructural results for different types of protein–rich cells in five families generally accepted as Capparalean (Brassicaceae, Capparaceae, Resedaceae, Tovariaceae and Moringaceae) and two others (Gyrostemonaceae and Bataceae) considered by some workers to be Capparalean, support their alignment in the order Capparales. The term myrosin cell is used for those protein–rich cells which are typically idio–blastic and characterized by a homogenous, granular proteinaceous material in the vacuole and a cytoplasm which is filled with an extensive rough endoplasmic reticulum. This idioblastic myrosin cell type is characteristic for the Brassicaceae, Capparaceae, Tovariaceae, Moringaceae and Gyrostemonaceae. The guard cells of stomata may appear as myrosin cells, in which case they are termed guard–cell myrosin cells; they are found in the Resedaceae, Tovariaceae and Bataceae. Other proteinaceous cells are those with protein–rich dilated cisternae (DC) of the endoplasmic reticulum (ER). One type is the organelle–like DC, utricular or irregular dilations of the ER, filled with protein and ribosome–studded. Utricular DC are characteristic for the Brassicaceae and Capparaceae. Another type of DC is represented by protein–containing vacuoles derived from the ER, protein–rich ER–dependent vacuoles; these are found in the Brassicaceae, Capparaceae, Resedaceae, Tovariaceae and Gyrostemonaceae. The myrosin cells and cells with protein–rich dilated cisternae are here regarded as taxonomic criteria for the order Capparales.     

Morphological and molecular confirmation of Albugo resedae (Albuginales; Oomycota) as a distinct species from A. candida

The genus Albugo s.str. causes white blister rust on four families of the Brassicales, Brassicaceae, Capparaceae, Cleomaceae, and Resedaceae. Recent phylogenetic studies have revealed that several host specific lineages are present within Albugo on Brassicales, while it was also confirmed that Albugo candida has an exceptionally wide host range which extends from Brassicaceae to Cleomaceae and Capparaceae. The Albugo species infecting the Resedaceae was attributed in monographic studies as well as local floras to either A. resedae or, applying a broader species concept, to A. candida. In the present study, A. resedae specimens were morphologically and molecularly compared to the five Albugo species so far confirmed from Brassicales, A. candida, A. koreana, A. laibachii, A. lepidii, and A. voglmayrii. Both morphological differences of oospore ornamentation and phylogenetic analysis of cox2 mtDNA sequences provided evidence that A. resedae is distinct from A. candida and from the additional four species so far described from Brassicaceae. It thus seems possible that so far unknown factors restrict Albugo candida to Brassicaceae and its sister families, Cleomaceae and Capparaceae.     

The embryology of angiosperms: Its broad application to the systematic and evolutionary study

Embryology allows one to work with a wide array of characters (more than 50 in general) for each taxon of angiosperms. This paper, while providing a brief review of recent studies on Myrtales and associated families by me and my co-workers, discusses evidence for the general utility of embryological characters for the study of plant systematics. In particular, evidence is given that characters of seed coat anatomy may be best applied to the study of specific and sectional (and even familial) relationships, those of seed appendages as well as of integumentary morphology and histogenesis to the study of generic relationships, and other major characters to the study of familial relationships. Embryology thus provides many features that are complex and, when properly applied along with evidence from other sources, offers good indications of relationships at various taxonomic level, from the ordinal to the specific level. Despite its evident systematic value and increasing need, however, information on embryological characters is still lacking for a majority of genera, and even at the family level, data is lacking or insufficiently available for more than 30% of families. Recipient of the Botanical Society Award for Young Scientists, 1987.     

Embryology of the Irvingiaceae,a family with uncertain relationships among the Malpighiales

The Irvingiaceae, one of 40 families of the Malpighiales, comprise a small woody family of 10 species in three genera distributed in Old World tropics. Its relationships with other families are unclear, although recent molecular analyses suggest affinities with Linaceae, Caryocaraceae, Erythroxylaceae, and Rhizophoraceae. To gain insight into family relationships, we investigated 63 embryological characters of two previously unstudied African species, Irvingia gabonensis and I. smithii, and compared them with other Malpighiales and the sister group Oxalidales. Embryologically, Irvingia is characterized by the absence of an integumentary tapetum and by having a non-multiplicative inner integument, a multiplicative testa, many discrete fascicles of vascular bundles running in the testa from the raphe to antiraphe (each fascicle comprised several strands arranged in a concentric manner), and a fibrous exotegmen. Comparisons showed that Irvingia did not resemble any of the Linaceae, Caryocaraceae, Erythroxylaceae, Rhizophoraceae, or any of the other malpighialean families for which embryological data are available. The genus rather resembled Huaceae and Connaraceae (Oxalidales) in seed coat structure. However, 18 families (45%) of the Malpighiales are still poorly understood embryologically, and therefore additional studies are required for further critical comparisons.     

Embryology of <Emphasis Type="Italic">Cardiopteris</Emphasis> (Cardiopteridaceae,Aquifoliales), with emphasis on unusual ovule and seed development

Cardiopteris (Cardiopteridaceae), a twining herb of two or three species distributed from Southeast Asia to Northern Australia, requires an embryological study for better understanding of its reproductive features. The present study of C. quinqueloba showed that the ovule and seed development involves a number of unusual structures, most of which are unknown elsewhere in angiosperms. The ovule pendant from the apical placenta is straight (not orthotropous), ategmic, and tenuinucellate, developing a monosporic seven-celled/eight-nucleate female gametophyte with an egg apparatus on the funicular side. Fertilization occurs by a pollen tube entering from the funicular side, resulting in a zygote on the funicular side. The endosperm is formed by the cell on the funicular side in the two endosperm cell stage. While retaining a (pro)embryo/endosperm as it is, the raphe (differentiating late in pre-fertilization stages) elongates toward the antiraphal side during post-fertilization stages, resulting in an anatropous seed. The two-cell-layered nucellar epidermis (belatedly forming by periclinal divisions), along with the raphe, envelops the embryo/endosperm entirely as the seed coat. The possibility was discussed that the arrested integument development triggers a series of the subsequent unusual structures of ovule and seed development. The fertilization mode in Cardiopteris underpins the hypothesis that the Polygonum?type female gametophyte comprises two four-celled archegonia.     

Development of ovule and seed in Rapateaceae

VENTURELLI, M. & BOUMAN, F., 1988. Development of ovule and seed in Rapateaceae. The structure of the ovules and/or seeds of twelve species of Rapateaceae were studied, some additional embryological characters also being recorded. The ovules are always anatropous, bitegmic and crassinucellate, but they differ in the shape, size and in thickness of the outer integument. In Rapateaceae the outer integument is initiated subdermally. The seed coat of the Rapateaceae shows two mechanical layers: an endotesta with silica present as bodies or as incrustations in cell walls, in conjunction with an exotegmen with a jigsaw cell pattern complicated by a labyrinth-like sculpturing of the outer cell walls. The innermost layer of the inner integument is tanniniferous. Large hilar scars with tracheidal plates on the corresponding fruit wall and a persistent obturator are recorded in Rapateaceae. On the basis of embryological characters the family fits well into the Commelinales. Testa structure most closely resembles that of the Commelinaceae. The differences in ovule and seed structure agree with the currently accepted tribal classification.     

Embryology and Seed Development of Paepalanthus sect. Actinocephalus (Koern.) Ruhland (Eriocaulaceae)

Abstract: The embryology and seed structure of Paepalanthus sect. Actinocephalus species were studied. The embryological and structural seed characters fit well with those of the other commelinaceous families. Within the Commelinales sensu Dahlgren, Eriocaulaceae and Xyridaceae represent two embryologically close families. In Paepalanthus sect. Actinocephalus the ovule is orthotropus, bitegmic, and tenuicellate with a micropyle formed by the inner integument. The seeds are endotestal. The outer cell layer of the testa and the outer periclinal wall of the endotesta disintegrate during development. The endotegmen is tanniniferous. The outer layer of the tegmen becomes compressed and is no longer recognizable in the mature seed. The seeds are operculate.