Miniaturization and validation of a high-throughput serine kinase assay using the AlphaScreen platform

Reducing costs while maintaining the highest readout quality is a precept of modern high-throughput screening. Given the trend toward nonradiometric screening platforms, this has been a big challenge for some kinase target classes. Common issues include low sensitivity, susceptibility to nonspecific interference, or the need for costly reagents. In this study, the authors describe the feasibility of miniaturization of a serine kinase assay using generic reagents in the AlphaScreen format. They have validated the robustness of this assay in the course of miniaturization from a 35-to 4.375-microL final assay volume in 384-and 1536-well formats. Within this volume range, they consistently obtained Z' values above 0.5 and have investigated the suitability of these assay formats for measuring compound effects by testing a set of 25 previously identified active compounds. These active compounds were also reliably identified in the miniaturized assay formats. The results presented here show that the AlphaScreen technology permits robust and cost-efficient miniaturization of serine/threonine kinase assays.     

Comparison of miniaturized time-resolved fluorescence resonance energy transfer and enzyme-coupled luciferase high-throughput screening assays to discover inhibitors of Rho-kinase II (ROCK-II)

Kinases are important drug discovery targets for a wide variety of therapeutic indications; consequently, the measurement of kinase activity remains a common high-throughput screening (HTS) application. Recently, enzyme-coupled luciferase-kinase (LK) format assays have been introduced. This format measures luminescence resulting from metabolism of adenosine triphosphate (ATP) via a luciferin/luciferase-coupled reaction. In the research presented here, 1536-well format time-resolved fluorescence resonance energy transfer (TR-FRET) and LK assays were created to identify novel Rho-associated kinase II (ROCK-II) inhibitors. HTS campaigns for both assays were conducted in this miniaturized format. It was found that both assays were able to consistently reproduce the expected pharmacology of inhibitors known to be specific to ROCK-II (fasudil IC50: 283 +/- 27 nM and 336 +/- 54 nM for TR-FRET and LK assays, respectively; Y-27632 IC50: 133 +/- 7.8 nM and 150 +/- 22 nM for TR-FRET and LK assays, respectively). In addition, both assays proved robust for HTS efforts, demonstrating excellent plate Z' values during the HTS campaign (0.84 +/- 0.03; 0.72 +/- 0.05 for LK and TR-FRET campaigns, respectively). Both formats identified scaffolds of known and novel ROCK-II inhibitors with similar sensitivity. A comparison of the performance of these 2 assay formats in an HTS campaign was enabled by the existence of a subset of 25,000 compounds found in both our institutional and the Molecular Library Screening Center Network screening files. Analysis of the HTS campaign results based on this subset of common compounds showed that both formats had comparable total hit rates, hit distributions, amount of hit clusters, and format-specific artifact. It can be concluded that both assay formats are suitable for the discovery of ROCK-II inhibitors, and the choice of assay format depends on reagents and/or screening technology available.     

Miniaturization of fluorescence polarization receptor-binding assays using CyDye-labeled ligands

Fluorescence polarization (FP) is an established technique for the study of biological interactions and is frequently used in the high-throughput screening (HTS) of potential new drug targets. This work describes the miniaturization of FP receptor assays to 1536-well formats for use in HTS. The FP assays were initially developed in 384-well microplates using CyDye-labeled nonpeptide and peptide ligands. Receptor expression levels varied from approximately 1 to 10 pmols receptor per mg protein, and ligand concentrations were in the 0.5- to 1.0-nM range. The FP assays were successfully miniaturized to 1536-well formats using Cy3B-labeled ligands, significantly reducing reagent consumption, particularly the receptor source, without compromising assay reliability. Z' factor values determined for the FP receptor assays in both 384- and 1536-well formats were found to be > 0.5, indicating the assays to be robust, reliable, and suitable for HTS purposes.     

A bioluminogenic HDAC activity assay: validation and screening

Histone deacetylase (HDAC) enzymes modify the acetylation state of histones and other important proteins. Aberrant HDAC enzyme function has been implicated in many diseases, and the discovery and development of drugs targeting these enzymes is becoming increasingly important. In this article, the authors report the evaluation of homogeneous, single-addition, bioluminogenic HDAC enzyme activity assays that offer less assay interference by compounds in comparison to fluorescence-based formats. The authors assessed the key operational assay properties including sensitivity, scalability, reproducibility, signal stability, robustness (Z'), DMSO tolerance, and pharmacological response to standard inhibitors against HDAC-1, HDAC-3/NcoR2, HDAC-6, and SIRT-1 enzymes. These assays were successfully miniaturized to a 10 μL assay volume, and their suitability for high-throughput screening was tested in validation experiments using 640 drugs approved by the Food and Drug Administration and the Hypha Discovery MycoDiverse natural products library, which is a collection of 10 049 extracts and fractions from fermentations of higher fungi and contains compounds that are of low molecular weight and wide chemical diversity. Both of these screening campaigns confirmed that the bioluminogenic assay was high-throughput screening compatible and yielded acceptable performance in confirmation, counter, and compound/extract and fraction concentration-response assays.     

Two simple and generic antibody-independent kinase assays: comparison of a bioluminescent and a microfluidic assay format

In this study, the authors have compared the performance of 2 high-throughput screening assays for a serin/threonine kinase: a microplate-based, bioluminescent assay that uses the luciferin/luciferase system to monitor ATP consumption, and a microfluidic assay that measures the change in mobility in an electric field of a fluorescently labeled peptide upon phosphorylation. Both assays are homogeneous, nonradioactive, antibody independent and could be miniaturized to a reaction volume of 4 microl. The robustness of both formats was demonstrated by Z' values > 0.8. Screening of a small library (2133 compounds) showed that the results obtained with both technologies correlate very well. Although the threshold for hits was set to a comparably low value-22.2% and 13.7% inhibition for the ATP consumption and microfluidic assay, respectively, corresponding to mean plus 3 standard deviations-the overlap of active compounds identified with the 2 assay formats was greater than 94%. Thus, both assays allow the identification of even low potency inhibitors with a high level of confidence.     

A fluorescent reporter assay for the detection of ligands acting through Gi protein-coupled receptors

Accompanying the advances in basic biology of G protein-coupled receptors (GPCRs) is the practical need among biopharmaceutical companies for sensitive assays to assess GPCR function, particularly formats that are compatible with high-throughput drug screening. Here we describe a novel cell-based assay format for the high-throughput detection of ligands for Gi protein-coupled receptors. Two Gi-GPCRs, mu-opioid receptor (mu-OPR) and 5-hydroxytryptamine receptor la (5HT1aR) are employed as model receptor targets. The key feature of this assay system is the isolation of stable, clonal Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cell lines that carry three separate expression plasmids: (1) a chimeric Gq/i5 protein (which re-directs a negative Gi-type signal to a positive Gq-type response), (2) a given Gi-GPCR, and (3) a beta-lactamase (beta1a) reporter gene responsive to Gi-GPCR signaling. Cell-based assays built using this format show appropriate rank order of potency among a reference set of receptor agonist and antagonist compounds. Such assays are also robust, reliable, and can be used for industrial-scale applications such as high-throughput screening for drug leads.     

A homogeneous and nonisotopic assay for phosphatidylinositol 4-kinases

Phosphatidylinositol 4-kinases (PI 4-kinases) catalyze the conversion of phosphatidylinositol to phosphatidylinositol 4-phosphate (PtdIns4P). The four known mammalian PI 4-kinases, PI4KA, PI4KB, PI4K2A, and PI4K2B have roles in intracellular lipid and protein trafficking. PI4KA and PI4KB also assist in the replication of several positive-sense RNA viruses. The identification of selective inhibitors of these kinases would be facilitated by assays suitable for high-throughput screening. We describe a homogeneous and nonisotopic assay for PI 4-kinase activity based on the bioluminescent detection of the ADP produced by kinase reactions. We have evaluated this assay with known nonselective inhibitors of PI 4-kinases and show that it performs similar to radiometric assay formats previously described in the literature. In addition, this assay generates Z-factor values of >0.7 for PI4KA in a 384-well format, demonstrating its suitability for high-throughput screening applications.     

A cost-effective solution to reduce dead volume of a standard dispenser system by a factor of 5

A key trend in high-throughput screening is assay miniaturization to control reagent costs and increase throughput. For this purpose, liquid-handling devices are used that transfer nano-to low-microliter volumes into all currently used microtiter well plates. One drawback of many available dispenser and pipetting systems are high dead volumes. Therefore, the authors were looking for an easy and simple solution to modify their standard liquid-handling device, PerkinElmer's FlexDrop Precision IV, allowing for a dead volume reduction to receive maximum benefit from miniaturized assay formats. Internal reservoirs were developed and constructed by Schering's Technical Development Laboratory (TDL), which are directly connected to the dispenser banks of FlexDrop without tubing. Using these newly built reservoirs, the dead volume was decreased by a factor of 5 in comparison to the manufacturer's reservoirs without compromising liquid-handling parameters such as accuracy and precision. The modified system displayed a high robustness and reliability under routine high-throughput screening conditions.     

Development of a generic dual-reporter gene assay for screening G-protein-coupled receptors

Multiple assay formats have been developed for the pharmacological characterization of G-protein-coupled receptors (GPCRs) and for screening orphan receptors. However, the increased pace of target identification and the rapid expansion of compound libraries present the need to develop novel assay formats capable of screening multiple GPCRs simultaneously. To address this need, the authors have developed a generic dual-reporter gene assay that can detect ligand activity at 2 GPCRs within the same assay. Two stable HEK293 cell lines were generated expressing either a firefly (Photinus) luciferase gene under the control of multiple cAMP-response elements (CREs) or a Renilla luciferase gene under the control of multiple 12-O-tetradecanoylphorbol-13-acetate (TPA)-responsive elements (TREs). Coseeded reporter cells were used to assess ligand binding activity at both Galphas-and Galphaq-coupled receptors. By selectively coexpressing receptors with a chimeric G-protein, agonist activity was assessed at Galphai/o-coupled receptors in combination with either Galphas-or Galphaq-coupled receptors. The dual-reporter gene assay was shown to be capable of simultaneously performing duplexed screens for a variety of agonist and/or antagonist combinations. The data generated from the duplexed reporter assays were pharmacologically relevant, and Z' factor analysis indicated the suitability of both agonist and antagonist screens for use in high-throughput screening.     

Comparison of assay technologies for a nuclear receptor assay screen reveals differences in the sets of identified functional antagonists

Many assay technologies currently exist to develop high-throughput screening assays, and the number of choices continues to increase. Results from a previous study comparing assay technologies in our laboratory do not support the common assumption that the same hits would be found regardless of which assay technology is used. To extend this investigation, a nuclear receptor antagonist assay was developed using 3 assay formats: AlphaScreen, time-resolved fluorescence (TRF), and time-resolved fluorescence resonance energy transfer (TR-FRET). Compounds ( approximately 42000) from the Novartis library were evaluated in all 3 assay formats. A total of 128 compounds were evaluated in dose-response experiments, and 109 compounds were confirmed active from all 3 formats. The AlphaScreen, TRF, and TR-FRET assay technologies identified 104, 23, and 57 active compounds, respectively, with only 18 compounds active in all 3 assay formats. A total of 128 compounds were evaluated in a cell-based functional assay, and 35 compounds demonstrated activity in this cellular assay. Furthermore, 34, 11, and 16 hits that were originally identified in the dose-response experiment by AlphaScreen, TRF, and TR-FRET assay technologies, respectively, were functionally active. The results of the study indicated that AlphaScreen identified the greatest number of functional antagonists.     

Receptor-ligand binding assays: technologies and applications

Receptor-ligand interactions play a crucial role in biological systems and their measurement forms an important part of modern pharmaceutical development. Numerous assay formats are available that can be used to screen and quantify receptor ligands. In this review, we give an overview over both radioactive and non-radioactive assay technologies with emphasis on the latter. While radioreceptor assays are fast, easy to use and reproducible, their major disadvantage is that they are hazardous to human health, produce radioactive waste, require special laboratory conditions and are thus rather expensive on a large scale. This has led to the development of non-radioactive assays based on optical methods like fluorescence polarization, fluorescence resonance energy transfer or surface plasmon resonance. In light of their application in high-throughput screening environments, there has been an emphasis on so called "mix-and-measure" assays that do not require separation of bound from free ligand. The advent of recombinant production of receptors has contributed to the increased availability of specific assays and some aspects of the expression of recombinant receptors will be reviewed. Applications of receptor-ligand binding assays described in this review will relate to screening and the quantification of pharmaceuticals in biological matrices.     

A Fluorescent Reporter Assay for the Detection of Ligands Acting Through GI Protein-Coupled Receptors

Abstract

Accompanying the advances in basic biology of G protein-coupled receptors (GPCRs) is the practical need among biopharmaceutical companies for sensitive assays to assess GPCR function, particularly formats that are compatible with high-throughput drug screening. Here we describe a novel cell-based assay format for the high-throughput detection of ligands for G, protein-coupled receptors. Two G_i-GPCRs, μ-opioid receptor (μ-OPR) and 5-hydroxytryptamine receptor la (5HTlaR) are employed as model receptor targets. The key feature of this assay system is the isolation of stable, clonal Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cell lines that carry three separate expression plasmids: (1) a chimeric G_q/i5 protein (which re-directs a negative G_i-type signal to a positive Gq-type response), (2) a given G_i-GPCR, and (3) a β-lactamase (βla) reporter gene responsive to G_i-GPCR signaling. Cell-based assays built using this format show appropriate rank order of potency among a reference set of receptor agonist and antagonist compounds. Such assays are also robust, reliable, and can be used for industrial-scale applications such as high-throughput screening for drug leads.     

Data concordance from a comparison between filter binding and fluorescence polarization assay formats for identification of ROCK-II inhibitors

The Rho-associated coiled-coil-containing protein serine/threonine kinases ROCK-I and ROCK-II are thought to play a major role in cytoskeletal dynamics by serving as downstream effectors of the Rho/Rac family of cytokine- and growth factor-activated small GTPases. As such, the ROCK family members are attractive intervention targets for a variety of pathologies, including cancer and cardiovascular disease. The authors developed a high-throughput screen to identify ROCK-II inhibitors and report results from a direct comparison of 2 screening campaigns for ROCK-II inhibitors using fluorescence polarization (FP) and filter binding (FB). Screening protocols to identify inhibitors of ROCK-II were developed in FB and FP formats under similar assay and kinetic conditions. A 30,000-member compound library was screened using FB ((33)P) and FP detection systems, and compounds that were active in either assay were retested in 5-point curve confirmation assays. Analysis of these data showed an approximate 95% agreement of compounds identified as active in both assay formats. Also, compound potency determinations from FB and FP had a high degree of correlation and were considered equivalent. These data suggest that the assay methodology has little impact on the quality and productivity of the screen, provided that the assays are developed to standardize kinetic conditions.     

Further comparison of primary hit identification by different assay technologies and effects of assay measurement variability

High-throughput screening (HTS) has grown rapidly in the past decade, with many advances in new assay formats, detection technologies, and laboratory automation. Recently, several studies have shown that the choice of assay technology used for the screening process is particularly important and can yield quite different primary screening outcomes. However, because the screening assays in these previous studies were performed in a single-point determination, it is not clear to what extent the difference observed in the screening results between different assay technologies is attributable to inherent assay variability and day-to-day measurement variation. To address this question, a nuclear receptor coactivator recruitment assay was carried out in 2 different assay formats, namely, AlphaScreen and time-resolved fluorescence resonance energy transfer, which probed the same biochemical binding events but with different detection technologies. For each assay format, 4 independent screening runs in a typical HTS setting were completed to evaluate the run-to-run screening variability. These multiple tests with 2 assay formats allow an unambiguous comparison between the discrepancies of different assay formats and the effects of the variability of assay and screening measurements on the screening outcomes. The results provide further support that the choice of assay format or technology is a critical factor in HTS assay development.     

A fluorescence lifetime-based assay for serine and threonine kinases that is suitable for high-throughput screening

We describe the development of a novel method for the assay of serine/threonine protein kinases based on fluorescence lifetime. The assay consists of three generic peptides (which have been used by others in the assay of >140 protein kinases in various assay formats) labeled with a long lifetime fluorescent dye (14 or 17 ns) that act as substrates for protein kinases and an iron(III) chelate that modulates the fluorescence lifetime of the peptide only when it is phosphorylated. The decrease in average fluorescence lifetime as measured in a recently developed fluorescence lifetime plate reader (Edinburgh Instruments) is a measure of the degree of phosphorylation of the peptide. We present data showing that the assay performs as well as, and in some cases better than, the “gold standard” radiometric kinase assays with respect to Z′ values, demonstrating its utility in high-throughput screening applications. We also show that the assay gives nearly identical results in trial screening to those obtained by radiometric assays and that it is less prone to interference than simple fluorescence intensity measurements.     

TR-FRET-based high-throughput screening assay for identification of UBC13 inhibitors

UBC13 is a noncanonical ubiquitin conjugating enzyme (E2) that has been implicated in a variety of cellular signaling processes due to its ability to catalyze formation of lysine 63-linked polyubiquitin chains on various substrates. In particular, UBC13 is required for signaling by a variety of receptors important in immune regulation, making it a candidate target for inflammatory diseases. UBC13 is also critical for double-strand DNA repair and thus a potential radiosensitizer and chemosensitizer target for oncology. The authors developed a high-throughput screening (HTS) assay for UBC13 based on the method of time-resolved fluorescence resonance energy transfer (TR-FRET). The TR-FRET assay combines fluorochrome (Fl)-conjugated ubiquitin (fluorescence acceptor) with terbium (Tb)-conjugated ubiquitin (fluorescence donor), such that the assembly of mixed chains of Fl- and Tb-ubiquitin creates a robust TR-FRET signal. The authors defined conditions for optimized performance of the TR-FRET assay in both 384- and 1536-well formats. Chemical library screens (total 456 865 compounds) were conducted in high-throughput mode using various compound collections, affording superb Z' scores (typically >0.7) and thus validating the performance of the assays. Altogether, the HTS assays described here are suitable for large-scale, automated screening of chemical libraries in search of compounds with inhibitory activity against UBC13.     

Homogeneous time-resolved G protein-coupled receptor–ligand binding assay based on fluorescence cross-correlation spectroscopy

G protein-coupled receptors (GPCRs) mediate many important physiological functions and are considered as one of the most successful therapeutic target classes for a wide spectrum of diseases. Drug discovery projects generally benefit from a broad range of experimental approaches for screening compound libraries and for the characterization of binding modes of drug candidates. Owing to the difficulties in solubilizing and purifying GPCRs, assay formats have been so far mainly limited to cell-based functional assays and radioligand binding assays. In this study, we used fluorescence cross-correlation spectroscopy (FCCS) to analyze the interaction of detergent-solubilized receptors to various types of GPCR ligands: endogenous peptides, small molecules, and a large surrogate antagonist represented by a blocking monoclonal antibody. Our work demonstrates the suitability of the homogeneous and time-resolved FCCS assay format for a robust, high-throughput determination of receptor–ligand binding affinities and kinetic rate constants for various therapeutically relevant GPCRs.     

A novel high-throughput screening format to identify inhibitors of secreted acid sphingomyelinase

Secreted extracellular acid sphingomyelinase (sASM) activity has been suggested to promote atherosclerosis by enhancing subendothelial aggregation and retention of low-density lipoprotein (LDL) with resultant foam cell formation. Compounds that inhibit sASM activity, at neutral pH, may prevent lipid retention and thus would be expected to be anti-atherosclerotic. With the goal of identifying novel compounds that inhibit sASM at pH 7.4, a high-throughput screen was performed. Initial screening was run using a modification of a proven system that measures the hydrolysis of radiolabeled sphingomyelin presented in detergent micelles in a 96-well format. Separation of the radiolabeled aqueous phosphorylcholine reaction product from uncleaved sphingomyelin lipid substrate was achieved by chloroform/methanol extraction. During the screening campaign, a novel extraction procedure was developed to eliminate the use of the hazardous organic reagents. This new procedure exploited the ability of uncleaved, radiolabeled lipid substrate to interact with hydrophobic phenyl-sepharose beads. A comparison of the organic-based and the bead-based extraction sASM screening assays revealed Z' factor values ranging from 0.7 to 0.95 for both formats. In addition, both assay formats led to the identification of sub- to low micromolar inhibitors of sASM at pH 7.4 with similar IC(50) values. Subsequent studies demonstrated that both methods were also adaptable to run in a 384-well format. In contrast to the results observed at neutral pH, however, only the organic extraction assay was capable of accurately measuring sASM activity at its pH optimum of 5.0. The advantages and disadvantages of both sASM assay formats are discussed.     

Assaying Bcr-Abl kinase activity and inhibition in whole cell extracts by phosphorylation of substrates immobilized on agarose beads

There is a current and increasing demand for simple, robust, nonradioactive assays of protein tyrosine kinase activity with applications for clinical diagnosis and high-throughput screening of potential molecularly targeted therapeutic agents. One significant challenge is to detect and measure the activity of specific kinases with key roles in cell signaling as an approach to distinguish normal cells from cancer cells and as a means of evaluating targeted drug efficacy and resistance in cancer cells. Here, we describe a method in which kinase substrates fused to glutathione-S-transferase and immobilized on glutathione agarose beads are phosphorylated, eluted, and then assayed to detect kinase activity. The activity of recombinant, purified c-Abl kinase or Bcr-Abl kinase in whole cell extracts can be detected with equivalent specificity, sensitivity, and reproducibility. Similarly, inhibition of recombinant c-Abl or Bcr-Abl in cells or cell extracts by imatinib mesylate and other Bcr-Abl targeted kinase inhibitors is readily assayed. This simple kinase assay is sufficiently straightforward and robust for use in clinical laboratories and is potentially adaptable to high-throughput assay formats.     

TR-FRET cellular assays for interrogating posttranslational modifications of histone H3

Posttranslational modifications such as phosphorylation, acetylation, and methylation play important roles in regulating the structures and functions of histones, which in turn regulate gene expression and DNA repair and replication. Histone-modifying enzymes, such as deacetylases, methyltransferases and demethylases, have been pursued as therapeutic targets for various diseases. However, detection of the activities of these enzymes in high-throughput cell-based formats has remained challenging. The authors have developed high-throughput LanthaScreen cellular assays for Histone H3 site-specific modifications. These assays use cells expressing green fluorescence protein-tagged Histone H3 transiently delivered via BacMam and terbium-labeled anti-Histone H3 modification-specific antibodies. Robust time-resolved F?rster resonance energy transfer signals were detected for H3 lysine-9 acetylation and dimethylation (H3K9me2), serine-10 phosphorylation, K4 di- and trimethylation, and K27 trimethylation. Consistent with previous reports, hypoxic stress increased K4 methylation levels, and methyltransferase G9a inhibitor UNC-0638 decreased K9me2 levels significantly, with little effects on other modifications. To demonstrate the utility of this assay platform in screening, the K9 acetylation assay was used to profile the Enzo Epigenetics Library. Twelve known HDAC inhibitors were identified as hits and followed up in a dose-response format. In conclusion, this assay platform enables high-throughput cell-based analysis of diverse types of posttranslational modifications of Histone H3.