Dimethyl sulfoxide interferes with in vitro differentiation of chick embryo endochondral chondrocytes

Dedifferentiated chondrocytes derived from 6-day-old chick embryo tibiae when transferred on agarose, revert to the chondrocytic phenotype and mature to hypertrophic, type X collagen-producing chondrocytes (Castagnola et al. (1986). J. Cell Biol. 102, 2310-2317). The continuous presence of 180 mM dimethyl sulfoxide (DMSO) during the culture specifically inhibited synthesis of type X collagen and accumulation of its mRNA. The synthesis of the cartilage-specific type II collagen and the level of its mRNA were essentially unchanged in treated and control untreated cells.     

Immunological and biochemical studies of collagen type transition during in vitro chondrogenesis of chick limb mesodermal cells

This work describes an approach to monitor chondrogenesis of stage-24 chick limb mesodermal cells in vitro by analyzing the onset of type II collagen synthesis with carboxymethyl-cellulose chromatography, immunofluorescence, and radioimmunoassay. This procedure allowed specific and quantitative determination of chondrocytes in the presence of fibroblasts and myoblasts, both of which synthesize type I collagen. Chondrogenesis was studied in high-density cell preparations on tissue culture plastic dishes and on agar base. It was found that stage-24 limb mesenchymal cells initially synthesized only type I collagen. With the onset of chondrogenesis, a gradual transition to type II collagen synthesis was observed. In cell aggregates formed over agar, type II collagen synthesis started after 1 day in culture and reached levels of 80-90 percent of the total collagen synthesis at 6-8 days. At that time, the cells in the center of the aggregates had acquired the typical chondrocyte phenotype and stained only with type II collagen antibodies, whereas the peripheral cells had developed into a "perichondrium" and stained with type I and type II collagen antibodies. On plastic dishes plated with 5 X 10(6) cells per 35mm dish, cartilage nodules developed after 4-6 days, but the type II collagen synthesis only reached levels of 10-20 percent of the total collagen. The majority of the cells differentiated into fibroblasts and myoblasts and synthesized type I collagen. These studies demonstrate that analysis of cell specific types of collagen provides a useful method for detailing the specific events in the differentiation of mesenchymal cells in vitro.     

Developmentally regulated synthesis of a low molecular weight protein (Ch 21) by differentiating chondrocytes

When transferred to suspension culture on agarose-coated dishes, dedifferentiated chick embryo chondrocytes resume the chondrocyte phenotype and continue their maturation to hypertrophic chondrocytes (Castagnola, P., G. Moro, F. Descalzi Cancedda, and R. Cancedda. 1986. J. Cell Biol. 102:2310-2317). In this paper we report the identification, purification, and characterization of a low molecular weight protein, named Ch 21, expressed and secreted by in vitro differentiating chondrocytes at a late stage of development. This protein is detectable in the cells after a short pulse labeling and is directly secreted in the culture medium. The Ch 21 protein has a peculiar resistance to limited pepsin digestion; nevertheless it is not collagenous in nature as revealed by its unaltered mobility when isolated from cells grown in the presence of alpha-alpha' dipyridyl, its resistance to bacterial collagenase, and its amino acid composition. By metabolic labeling of tissue slices and by immunohistochemistry, we show that in the chick embryo tibia the Ch 21 protein first appears at the boundary of the cone of hypertrophic cartilage and in the newly formed bone between the 6 and 10 d of embryo development and localizes in calcifying hypertrophic cartilage thereafter. The Ch 21 protein synthesized by the cultured chondrocytes is closely related and possibly identical to a 21K transformation- sensitive protein associated to the cell substratum of chick embryo fibroblasts.     

Flow cytometric evaluation of cell cycle characteristics during in vitro differentiation of chick embryo chondrocytes

The cell cycle kinetic characteristics of chick endochondral chondrocytes differentiating in vitro were studied by flow cytometry. In addition, the synthesis of type I and type X collagens of the same cells was evaluated by immunoprecipitation. Dedifferentiated cells, derived from chick embryo tibiae and grown attached to a substratum, were characterized by type I collagen synthesis, a high growth fraction (GF = 0.94), minimal cell loss factor (phi = 0.02), and a total cell cycle time of the proliferating cells of about 17 h (tG1 = 8 h, tS = 5 h, and tG2 + M = 4 h). Transfer of dedifferentiated cells to suspension culture on agarose-coated dishes induced differentiation to hypertrophic chondrocytes. These were characterized by type X collagen synthesis, a low growth fraction (GF = 0.52), maximal cell loss factor (phi = 1.0), and a total cell cycle time of the proliferating cells of about 73 h (tG1 = 53 h, tS = 12 h, and tG2 + M = 8 h). The transition from dedifferentiated chondrocytes to hypertrophic chondrocytes was accompanied by large increases of the duration of all the cell cycle phases and of the number of quiescent and degenerating cells. Associated with these alterations in cell cycle kinetics was a switch from type I to type X collagen synthesis. Further preliminary data suggest that the population of differentiating chondrocytes (a state between dedifferentiated and hypertrophic chondrocytes) comprises a heterogeneous population of fast and slow growing cells.     

Hypertrophic chondrocytes undergo further differentiation in culture

Conditions have been defined for promoting growth and differentiation of hypertrophic chondrocytes obtained in culture starting from chick embryo tibiae. Hypertrophic chondrocytes, grown in suspension culture as described (Castagnola P., G. Moro, F. Descalzi Cancedda, and R. Cancedda. 1986. J. Cell Biol. 102:2310-2317), when they reached the stage of single cells, were transferred to substrate-dependent culture conditions in the presence of ascorbic acid. Cells showed a change in morphology, became more elongated and flattened, expressed alkaline phosphatase, and eventually mineralized. Type II and X collagen synthesis was halted and replaced by type I collagen synthesis. In addition the cells started to produce and to secrete in large amount a protein with an apparent molecular mass of 82 KD in reducing conditions and 63 KD in unreducing conditions. This protein is soluble in acidic solutions, does not contain collagenous domains, and is glycosylated. The Ch21 protein, a marker of hypertrophic chondrocytes and bone cells, was synthesized throughout the culture. We have defined this additional differentiation stage as an osteoblast-like stage. Calcium deposition in the extracellular matrix occurred regardless of the addition of beta glycerophosphate to the culture medium. Comparable results were obtained both when the cells were plated at low density and when they were already at confluence and maintained in culture without passaging up to 50 d. When retinoic acid was added to the hypertrophic chondrocyte culture between day 1 and day 5 the maturation of the cells to the osteoblast-like stage was highly accelerated. The switch in the collagen secretion was already observed after 2 d and the production of the 63-kD protein after 3 d. Mineralization was observed after 15-20 d.     

Type X collagen synthesis by chick sternal cartilage and its relationship to endochondral development

Our morphological studies have demonstrated that the appearance of localized, paired zones of primary calcification on either side of the midline of the 19-d embryonic chick sternum is heralded by the development of paired, translucent zones 2 d previously. Histological studies demonstrated that the majority of chondrocytes within these translucent zones are hypertrophic, and that the zones are surrounded by a margin of flattened nonhypertrophic cells. The discrete localization of these paired areas of hypertrophic chondrocytes and subsequent endochondral bone development allows for the direct correlation of the histological and biochemical characteristics of the zones sequentially during development and makes it possible to precisely match the synthetic activity to the cellular morphology, thereby eliminating possible minor but critical variations in developmental staging that could otherwise arise. Our studies have demonstrated that there is a direct spatial and temporal correlation between the degree of cellular maturation and the synthesis of type X collagen, and that the sudden and profound initiation of type X collagen synthesis on days 16-17 of development occurs concurrently with the attainment of hypertrophic characteristics by the majority of cells within the translucent zone. Before acquisition of these hypertrophic characteristics, the cells of this precalcification zone synthesize only type II and the minor cartilage collagens. Chondrocytes isolated from these regions in more immature sternae (i.e., 11+ d embryos) were found to synthesize high levels of type X collagen within 4 d of culture within collagen gels even though hypertrophic development and type X collagen synthesis by cells within this region would not normally have been apparent in ovo for several more days. These data indicate that there is a direct correlation between the development of hypertrophic characteristics and the synthesis of type X collagen, and that the maturation of chondrocytes in precalcification zones may be regulated by matrix components and/or stimulated by culture within collagen gels.     

Synthesis and extracellular deposition of fibronectin in chondrocyte cultures. Response to the removal of extracellular cartilage matrix

Fibronectin, the major cell surface glycoprotein of fibroblasts, is absent from differentiated cartilage matrix and chondrocytes in situ. However, dissociation of embryonic chick sternal cartilage with collagenase and trypsin, followed by inoculation in vitro reinitiates fibronectin synthesis by chondrocytes. Immunofluorescence microscopy with antibodies prepared against plasma fibronectin (cold insoluble globulin [CIG]) reveals fibronectin associated with the chondrocyte surface. Synthesis and secretion of fibronectin into the medium are shown by anabolic labeling with [35S]methionine or [3H]glycine, and identification of the secreted proteins by immunoprecipitation and sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS)-disc gel electrophoresis. When chondrocytes are plated onto tissue culture dishes, the pattern of surface-associated fibronectin changes from a patchy into a strandlike appearance. Where epithelioid clones of polygonal chondrocytes develop, only short strands of fibronectin appear preferentially at cellular interfaces. This pattern is observed as long as cells continue to produce type II collagen that fails to precipitate as extracellular collagen fibers for some time in culture. Using the immunofluorescence double-labeling technique, we demonstrate that fibroblasts as well as chondrocytes which synthesize type I collagen and deposit this collagen as extracellular fibers show a different pattern of extracellular fibronectin that codistributes in large parts with collagen fibers. Where chondrocytes begin to accumulate extracellular cartilage matrix, fibronectin strands disappear. From these observations, we conclude (a) that chondrocytes synthesize fibronectin only in the absence of extracellular cartilage matrix, and (b) that fibronectin forms only short intercellular "stitches" in the absence of extracellular collagen fibers in vitro.     

Effect of heparin on synthesis of short chain collagen by chondrocytes and smooth muscle cells

The treatment of embryonic chick chondrocyte cultures with heparin results in a decrease in collagen synthesis. One of the collagens synthesized by hypertrophic chondrocytes, specifically type X collagen, may play an important role in cartilage mineralization and endochondral ossification. Recently a new short chain collagenous component was found in cultures of rat vascular smooth muscle cells (Majack, R. A., and P. Bornstein, 1985, J. Cell Biol., 100: 613-619). The present study was initiated to investigate heparin's effect on type X collagen in embryonic chick chondrocytes and to further evaluate the nature of the short chain component synthesized by rat vascular smooth muscle cells. Different tissues may respond differently to the administration of heparin. In chondrocyte cultures heparin decreased both total collagen synthesis as well as the synthesis of type X collagen. There was an accumulation of collagen precursors, found principally in the cell layer compartment, which appeared to be the result of heparin's inhibition of the NH2-terminal protease. In cultures of rat vascular smooth muscle cells heparin was found to increase the synthesis of a short chain collagenous component as previously reported. However, comparison with a type X collagen standard showed this to be different from type X. In all cases, the effect of heparin on collagen chain precursors, chondrocyte type X synthesis, and synthesis of a vascular smooth muscle short chain collagen was shown to be reversible. Similar effects were obtained by adding chondroitin sulfate to chondrocytes, suggesting a role for extracellular matrix components in the modulation of collagen synthesis. These findings are consistent with the concept of a group of short chain collagens with type X collagen being unique to hypertrophic chondrocytes.     

In vitro development of hypertrophic chondrocytes starting from selected clones of dedifferentiated cells

Single cells from enzymatically dissociated chick embryo tibiae have been cloned and expanded in fresh or conditioned culture media. A cloning efficiency of approximately 13% was obtained using medium conditioned by dedifferentiated chondrocytes. A cloning efficiency of only 1.4% was obtained when conditioned medium from hypertrophic chondrocytes was used, and efficiencies of essentially 0 were found with fresh medium or medium conditioned by J2-3T3 mouse fibroblasts. Cell clones were selected by morphological criteria and clones showing a dedifferentiated phenotype (fibroblast-like) were further characterized. Out of 38 clones analyzed, 17 were able to differentiate to the hypertrophic chondrocyte stage and reconstitute hypertrophic cartilage when placed in the appropriate culture conditions. Cells from these clones expressed the typical markers of chondrocyte differentiation, i.e., type II and type X collagens. Clones not undergoing differentiation continued to express only type I collagen. Hypertrophic chondrocytes from differentiating clones were analyzed at the single cell level by immunofluorescence; all the cells were positive for type X collagen, while approximately 50% of them showed positivity for type II collagen.     

In vitro morphogenesis of chick embryo hypertrophic cartilage

Dedifferentiated chick embryo chondrocytes (Castagnola, P., G. Moro, F. Descalzi-Cancedda, and R. Cancedda, 1986, J. Cell Biol., 102:2310-2317), when transferred to suspension culture on agarose-coated dishes in the presence of ascorbic acid, aggregate and remain clustered. With time in culture, clusters grow in size and adhere to each other, forming structures that may be several millimeters in dimension. These structures after 7 d of culture have the histologic appearance of mature hypertrophic cartilage partially surrounded by a layer of elongated cells resembling the perichondrium. Cells inside the aggregates have ultrastructural features of stage I (proliferating) or stage II (hypertrophic) chondrocytes depending on their location. Occurrence and distribution of type I, II, and X collagens in the in vitro-formed cartilage at different times of culture, show a temporal and spatial distribution of these antigens reminiscent of the maturation events occurring in the cartilage in vivo. A comparable histologic appearance is shown also by cell aggregates obtained starting with a population of cells derived from a single, cloned, dedifferentiated chondrocyte.     

The Persistence in the Synthesis of Type H Proteoglycan and Type II Collagen by Chondrocytes Cultured in the Presence of Chick Embryo Extract1

The effect of chick embryo extract on the phenotypic expression of differentiated chondrocytes has been studied in consideration of the fact that these cells are well characterized by certain specific cell products, such as type H proteochondroitin sulfate and type II collagen. In this study, we utilized floating chondrocytes derived from chick embryonic sterna, which can be cultured in suspension with no apparent change in the type of cell products for at least a period of eight weeks, as described in a previous paper (1). In the presence of chick embryo extract in the medium, the floating chondrocytes became attached to the bottom of the culture dish, and the attached cells took on a fibroblast-like appearance. Biochemical analyses of the proteochondroitin sulfate and collagen synthesized by the attached cells revealed that if the culture medium was renewed everyday, the cells having a fibroblast-like appearance continued to synthesize type H proteochondroitin sulfate and type II collagen. When however, the medium was replaced every other day, the synthesis of both proteochondroitin sulfate and collagen by the attached cells switched from the chondrocyte type to the fibroblast type, i.e. the synthesis of type M proteochondroitin sulfate and type I collagen, with little change in the fibroblast-like appearance. The results show that the morphological features of chondrocytes are not necessarily associated with the biochemical properties of these cells, and further suggest that, in chick embryo extract, there is no modulator capable of acting directly on the chondrocytes to bring about phenotypic changes with respect to the synthesis of collagen and proteoglycans.     

Association of the Myosin-binding Subunit of Myosin Phosphatase and Moesin: Dual Regulation of Moesin Phosphorylation by Rho-associated Kinase and Myosin Phosphatase

To examine the role of bone morphogenetic protein (BMP) signaling in chondrocytes during endochondral ossification, the dominant negative (DN) forms of BMP receptors were introduced into immature and mature chondrocytes isolated from lower and upper portions of chick embryo sternum, respectively. We found that control sternal chondrocyte populations expressed type IA, IB, and II BMP receptors as well as BMP-4 and -7. Expression of a DN-type II BMP receptor (termed DN-BMPR-II) in immature lower sternal (LS) chondrocytes led to a loss of differentiated functions; compared with control cells, the DN-BMPR- II–expressing LS chondrocytes proliferated more rapidly, acquired a fibroblastic morphology, showed little expression of type II collagen and aggrecan genes, and upregulated type I collagen gene expression. Expression of DN-BMPR-II in mature hypertrophic upper sternal (US) chondrocytes caused similar effects. In addition, the DN-BMPR-II–expressing US cells exhibited little alkaline phosphatase activity and type X collagen gene expression, while the control US cells produced both alkaline phosphatase and type X collagen. Both DN-BMPR-II–expressing US and LS chondrocytes failed to respond to treatment with BMP-2 . When we examined the effects of DN forms of types IA and IB BMP receptors, we found that DN-BMPR-IA had little effect, while DN-BMPR-IB had similar but weaker effects compared with those of DN-BMPR-II. We conclude that BMP signaling, particularly that mediated by the type II BMP receptor, is required for maintenance of the differentiated phenotype, control of cell proliferation, and expression of hypertrophic phenotype.     

Induction and prevention of chondrocyte hypertrophy in culture

Primary chondrocytes from whole chick embryo sterna can be maintained in suspension culture stabilized with agarose for extended periods of time. In the absence of FBS, the cells remain viable only when seeded at high densities. They do not proliferate at a high rate but they deposit extracellular matrix with fibrils resembling those of authentic embryonic cartilage in their appearance and collagen composition. The cells exhibit many morphological and biochemical characteristics of resting chondrocytes and they do not produce collagen X, a marker for hypertrophic cartilage undergoing endochondral ossification. At low density, cells survive in culture without FBS when the media are conditioned by chondrocytes grown at high density. Thus, resting cartilage cells in agarose cultures can produce factors required for their own viability. Addition of FBS to the culture media leads to profound changes in the phenotype of chondrocytes seeded at low density. Cells form colonies at a high rate and assume properties of hypertrophic cells, including the synthesis of collagen X. They extensively deposit extracellular matrix resembling more closely that of adult rather than embryonic cartilage.     

Constitutive myc expression impairs hypertrophy and calcification in cartilage.

The myc oncogene is expressed by proliferating quail embryo chondrocytes (QEC) grown as adherent cells and is repressed in QEC maintained in suspension culture. To investigate the interference of myc expression during chondrocyte differentiation, QEC were infected with a retrovirus carrying the v-myc oncogene (QEC-v-myc). Uninfected or helper virus-infected QEC were used as control. In adherent culture, QEC-v-myc displayed a chondrocytic phenotype and synthesized type II collagen and Ch21 protein, while control chondrocytes synthesized type I and type II collagen with no Ch21 protein detected as long as the attachment to the plastic was kept. In suspension culture, QEC-v-myc readily aggregated and within 1 week the cell aggregates released small single cells; still they secreted only type II collagen and Ch21 protein. In the same conditions control cell aggregates released hypertrophic chondrocytes producing type II and type X collagens and Ch21 protein. In the appropriate culture conditions, QEC-v-myc reconstituted a tissue defined as nonhypertrophic, noncalcifying cartilage by the high cellularity, the low levels of alkaline phosphatase enzymatic activity, and the absence of type X collagen synthesis and of calcium deposition. We conclude that the constitutive expression of the v-myc oncogene keeps chondrocytes in stage I (active proliferation and synthesis of type II collagen) and prevents these cells from reconstituting hypertrophic calcifying cartilage.     

Microfilament modification by dihydrocytochalasin B causes retinoic acid-modulated chondrocytes to reexpress the differentiated collagen phenotype without a change in shape

Primary monolayers of rabbit articular chondrocytes synthesize high levels of type II collagen and proteoglycan. This capacity was used as a marker for the expression of the differentiated phenotype. Such cells were treated with 1 microgram/ml retinoic acid (RA) for 10 d to produce a modulated collagen phenotype devoid of type II and consisting of predominantly type I trimer and type III collagen. After transfer to secondary culture in the presence of RA, the stability of the RA-modulated phenotype was investigated by culture in the absence of RA. Little reexpression of type II collagen synthesis occurred in this period unless cultures were treated with 3 X 10(-6) M dihydrocytochalasin B to modify microfilament structures. Reexpression of the differentiated phenotype began between days 6-8 and was essentially complete by day 14. Substantial reexpression occurred by day 8 without a detectable increase in cell rounding. Colony formation, characteristic of primary chondrocytes, was infrequent even after reexpression was complete. These data suggest that the integrity of microfilament cytoskeletal structures can be a source of regulatory signals that mechanistically appear to be more proximal to phenotypic change than the overt changes in cell shape that accompany reexpression of subculture-modulated chondrocytes in agarose culture.     

Thyroid hormone, insulin, and glucocorticoids are sufficient to support chondrocyte differentiation to hypertrophy: a serum-free analysis

Chondrocytes from chicken embryo tibia can be maintained in culture as adherent cells in Coon's modified Ham's F-12 medium supplemented with 10% FCS. In this condition, they dedifferentiate, losing type II collagen expression in favor of type I collagen synthesis. Their differentiation to hypertrophy can be obtained by transferring them to suspension culture. Differentiation is evidenced by the shift from type I to type II and type IX collagen synthesis and the following predominant expression of type X collagen, all markers of specific stages of the differentiation process. To identify the factors required for differentiation, we developed a serum-free culture system where only the addition of triiodothyronine (T3; 10(-11) M), insulin (60 ng/ml), and dexamethasone (10(-9) M) to the F-12 medium was sufficient to obtain hypertrophic chondrocytes. In this hormonal context, chondrocytes display the same changes in the pattern of protein synthesis as described above. For proper and complete cell maturation, T3 and insulin concentrations cannot be modified. Insulin cannot be substituted by insulin-like growth factor-I, but dexamethasone concentration can be decreased to 10(-12) M without chondrogenesis being impaired. In the latter case, the expression of type X collagen and its mRNA are inversely proportional to dexamethasone concentration. When ascorbic acid is added to the hormone-supplemented medium, differentiating chondrocytes organize their matrix leading to a cartilage-like structure with hypertrophic chondrocytes embedded in lacunae. However, this structure does not present detectable calcification, at variance with control cultures maintained in FCS. Accordingly, in the presence of the hormone mixture, the differentiating chondrocytes have low levels of alkaline phosphatase activity. This report indicates that T3 and insulin are primary factors involved in the onset and progression of chondrogenesis, while dexamethasone supports cell viability and modulates some differentiated functions.     

Gene expression and extracellular matrix ultrastructure of a mineralizing chondrocyte cell culture system

Conditions were defined for promoting cell growth, hypertrophy, and extracellular matrix mineralization of a culture system derived from embryonic chick vertebral chondrocytes. Ascorbic acid supplementation by itself led to the hypertrophic phenotype as assessed by respective 10- and 15-fold increases in alkaline phosphatase enzyme activity and type X synthesis. Maximal extracellular matrix mineralization was obtained, however, when cultures were grown in a nutrient-enriched medium supplemented with both ascorbic acid and 20 mM beta-glycerophosphate. Temporal studies over a 3-wk period showed a 3-4-fold increase in DNA accompanied by a nearly constant DNA to protein ratio. In this period, total collagen increased from 3 to 20% of the cell layer protein; total calcium and phosphorus contents increased 15-20-fold. Proteoglycan synthesis was maximal until day 12 but thereafter showed a fourfold decrease. In contrast, total collagen synthesis showed a greater than 10-fold increase until day 18, a result suggesting that collagen synthesis was replacing proteoglycan synthesis during cellular hypertrophy. Separate analysis of individual collagen types demonstrated a low level of type I collagen synthesis throughout the 21-d time course. Collagen types II and X synthesis increased during the first 2 wk of culture; thereafter, collagen type II synthesis decreased while collagen type X synthesis continued to rise. Type IX synthesis remained at undetectable levels throughout the time course. The levels of collagen types I, II, IX, and X mRNA and the large proteoglycan core protein mRNA paralleled their levels of synthesis, data indicating pretranslational control of synthesis. Ultrastructural examination revealed cellular and extracellular morphology similar to that for a developing hypertrophic phenotype in vivo. Chondrocytes in lacunae were surrounded by a well-formed extracellular matrix of randomly distributed collagen type II fibrils (approximately 20-nm diam) and extensive proteoglycan. Numerous vesicular structures could be detected. Cultures mineralized reproducibly and crystals were located in extracellular matrices, principally associated with collagen fibrils. There was no clear evidence of mineral association with extracellular vesicles. The mineral was composed of calcium and phosphorus on electron probe microanalysis and was identified as a very poorly crystalline hydroxyapatite on electron diffraction. In summary, these data suggest that this culture system consists of chondrocytes which undergo differentiation in vitro as assessed by their elevated levels of alkaline phosphatase and type X collagen and their ultrastructural appearance.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)     

Apoptosis of Terminally Differentiated Chondrocytes in Culture

During the process of endochondral ossification chondrocytes progress through stages of terminal differentiation culminating in apoptotic death. We have developed a serum-free suspension culture that allows terminal differentiation and facilitates the investigation of factors affecting chondrocyte apoptosis. We have found that chondrocytes not committed to terminal differentiation, i.e., those from the caudal region of chick embryo sterna, a region that remains cartilaginous for some months after the chick hatches, maintained high viability in serum-free suspension culture. A strong dependence of viability on culture density and sensitivity to induction of apoptosis with the protein kinase inhibitor, staurosporine, was consistent with the proposal that these chondrocytes, like nearly all cells, require intercellular communication for survival. Chondrocytes that were committed to terminal differentiation, i.e., those from the cephalic region of chick embryo sterna, a region that is replaced by bone before the chick hatches, expressed the hypertrophic phenotype but maintained their viability in culture for only approximately 6 days. Subsequent cell death was very consistent between cultures and shown to occur by an apoptotic process by analysis of DNA fragmentation and cell morphology. Short-term viability of hypertrophic chondrocytes was independent of culture density and relatively resistant to treatment with staurosporine. Induction of the hypertrophic phenotype in immature chondrocytes committed them to cell death and prevention of expression of the hypertrophic phenotype prevented cell death. We conclude that commitment of chondrocytes to terminal differentiation is associated with a commitment to apoptosis and apoptosis of hypertrophic chondrocytes in growth cartilage does not require initiation by external signals.