Evaluation of different plating media used in the isolation of salmonellas from environmental samples

Different serotypes of salmonellas were compared for selectivity and efficiency of recovery using 11 plating media. No optimal growth was obtained after 24h incubation in any of the media, but after 48h, brilliant green, brilliant green-phenol red-lactose-sucrose, bismuth sulphite, xylose-lysine-deoxycholate and Hektoen enteric agars showed optimal recovery of all the salmonella serotypes.
Xylose-lysine-deoxycholate and brilliant green-phenol red-lactose-sucrose agars were the most selective media for all salmonella serotypes. Addition of 10 μg/ml of sodium novobiocin to the tryptic soy-xylose-lysine and tryptic soy-brilliant green agars significantly improved their selectivity but reduced or inhibited the growth of some salmonella serotypes, including Salmonella typhi. Xylose-lysine-deoxycholate agar gave the highest recovery percentage of stressed salmonellas with a double-agar layer technique. Good recovery was also obtained on brilliant green-phenol red-lactose-sucrose, tryptic soy-brilliant green, tryptic soy-brilliant green-novobiocin, tryptic, soy-xylose-lysine and tryptic soy-xylose-lysine-novobiocin agars. Salmonella-shigella agar was the least efficient medium for the recovery of salmonellas under stress-induced or non-stressed conditions.     

Evaluation of different plating media used in the isolation of salmonellas from environmental samples

Different serotypes of salmonellas were compared for selectivity and efficiency of recovery using 11 plating media. No optimal growth was obtained after 24 h incubation in any of the media, but after 48 h, brilliant green, brilliant green-phenol red-lactose-sucrose, bismuth sulphite, xylose-lysine-deoxycholate and Hektoen enteric agars showed optimal recovery of all the salmonella serotypes. Xylose-lysine-deoxycholate and brilliant green-phenol red-lactose-sucrose agars were the most selective media for all salmonella serotypes. Addition of 10 micrograms/ml of sodium novobiocin to the tryptic soy-xylose-lysine and tryptic soy-brilliant green agars significantly improved their selectivity but reduced or inhibited the growth of some salmonella serotypes, including Salmonella typhi. Xylose-lysine-deoxycholate agar gave the highest recovery percentage of stressed salmonellas with a double-agar layer technique. Good recovery was also obtained on brilliant green-phenol red-lactose-sucrose, tryptic soy-brilliant green, tryptic soy-brilliant green-novobiocin, tryptic, soy-xylose-lysine and tryptic soy-xylose-lysine-novobiocin agars. Salmonella-shigella agar was the least efficient medium for the recovery of salmonellas under stress-induced or non-stressed conditions.     

A comparison of isolation procedures for salmonellas from polluted water using two forms of Rappaport's medium

F ricker , C.R. 1984. A comparison of isolation procedures for salmonellas from polluted water using two forms of Rappaport's medium. Journal of Applied Bacteriology 56 , 305–309.
The efficiency of Rappaport's broth (RB10) and Rappaport's broth containing novobiocin (NRB10) were compared for the isolation of salmonellas from polluted water, both as direct enrichment media and after pre-enrichment in buffered peptone water. Ninety samples were examined and 41 were found to contain salmonellas by at least one of the procedures used. Direct inoculation of the sample into RB10 resulted in the recovery of salmonellas from only 29.3% of the samples found to be positive. The use of NRB10 as a direct enrichment medium increased the percentage recovery to 78.0% of the total positive samples. Pre-enrichment in buffered peptone water allowed the recovery of salmonellas from a total of 41 samples whereas direct enrichment recovered them from only 32. No significant difference was demonstrated in the efficiencies of RB10 and NRB10 in recovering salmonellas after pre-enrichment in buffered peptone water. Three selective agars were used; no significant difference in their ability to recover salmonellae was demonstrated.     

Comparison of classical isolation protocols with a 24 h screen to detect viable salmonellas in faeces

A 24 h screen which detects three viable salmonella cells per g of faeces was compared with classical isolation procedures for their ability to identify salmonella-positive samples from a pig rearing unit. The screen involved an overnight enrichment in Muller-Kauffmann tetrathionate (MK) broth, subculture for 4 h in M broth containing 10 μg ml⁻¹ novobiocin, followed by detection of the presence of salmonellas by BacTrace and Salmonella-tek ELISAs. The classical protocols were: (1) an overnight and 48 h incubation in MK or selenite cysteine broth; or (2) overnight incubation in buffered peptone water and 24 h subculture in Rappaport-Vassiliadis broth (BPW-RV). Salmonellas were isolated from the broth cultures on xylose lysine deoxycholate and brilliant green agars. Thirty four of 100 samples were positive for salmonellas but no single isolation protocol identified all of them. The best of the classical isolation protocols, 48 h incubation in MK broth, identified 27 (79%) of the 34 positive samples whilst the screen identified 26 (76%) of the 34 positive samples. False-positive results were obtained from all isolation protocols except BPW-RV.     

A comparison of isolation procedures for salmonellas from polluted water using two forms of Rappaport's medium

The efficiency of Rappaport's broth ( RB10 ) and Rappaport's broth containing novobiocin ( NRB10 ) were compared for the isolation of salmonellas from polluted water, both as direct enrichment media and after pre-enrichment in buffered peptone water. Ninety samples were examined and 41 were found to contain salmonellas by at least one of the procedures used. Direct inoculation of the sample into RB10 resulted in the recovery of salmonellas from only 29.3% of the samples found to be positive. The use of NRB10 as a direct enrichment medium increased the percentage recovery to 78.0% of the total positive samples. Pre-enrichment in buffered peptone water allowed the recovery of salmonellas from a total of 41 samples whereas direct enrichment recovered them from only 32. No significant difference was demonstrated in the efficiencies of RB10 and NRB10 in recovering salmonellas after pre-enrichment in buffered peptone water. Three selective agars were used: no significant difference in their ability to recover salmonellae was demonstrated.     

Detection of salmonellas in confectionery products by conductance

A modified lysine decarboxylase broth has been developed which could be used with a Bactometer M123 to differentiate salmonellas from other bacteria by the characteristics of the conductance detection curve. The medium was used in combination with a selenite cystine trimethylamine oxide dulcitol medium to screen 50 strains of salmonellas and 42 strains of other organisms to establish detection curve magnitude and rate values which could be used to identify curves specific to salmonellas. The combination of media detected all salmonellas tested except Salmonella pullorum. The two media were used to screen 100 inoculated product samples with the Bactometer instrument, in parallel with traditional plating procedures, and using various combinations of pre-enrichment and selective enrichment incubation periods. After 24 h pre-enrichment, the Bactometer system detected more positive samples than the conventional plating procedures after pre-enrichment and selective enrichment. It is considered that these media used in parallel in the Bactometer after conventional pre-enrichment could provide a 48 h screening procedure for salmonellas with a sensitivity comparable to present plating procedures.     

Detection of salmonellas in confectionery products by conductance

A modified lysine decarboxylase broth has been developed which could be used with a Bactometer M123 to differentiate salmonellas from other bacteria by the characteristics of the conductance detection curve. The medium was used in combination with a selenite cystine trimethylamine oxide dulcitol medium to screen 50 strains of salmonellas and 42 strains of other organisms to establish detection curve magnitude and rate values which could be used to identify curves specific to salmonellas. The combination of media detected all salmonellas tested except Salmonella pullorum . The two media were used to screen 100 inoculated product samples with the Bactometer instrument, in parallel with traditional plating procedures, and using various combinations of pre-enrichment and selective enrichment incubation periods. After 24 h pre-enrichment, the Bactometer system detected more positive samples than the conventional plating procedures after pre-enrichment and selective enrichment. It is considered that these media used in parallel in the Bactometer after conventional pre-enrichment could provide a 48 h screening procedure for salmonellas with a sensitivity comparable to present plating procedures.     

Comparative study of different methods for detection and enumeration of Salmonella spp. in natural waters

Seven enrichment media (two proposed by the authors) for detecting salmonellas from polluted freshwater were compared. The Most Probable Number technique for enumeration of salmonellas in water samples was used, directly adding filtered water to buffered peptone water as the pre-enrichment medium. The results indicate that Rappaport-Vassiliadis/43 and Rappaport-Vassiliadis/43 supplemented with 10 micrograms of sodium novobiocin per ml are the best media for the recovery and enumeration of salmonellas from water samples.     

Comparative study of different methods for detection and enumeration of Salmonella spp. in natural waters

Seven enrichment media (two proposed by the authors) for detecting salmonellas from polluted freshwater were compared. The Most Probable Number technique for enumeration of salmonellas in water samples was used, directly adding filtered water to buffered peptone water as the pre-enrichment medium. The results indicate that Rappaport-Vassiliadis/43 and Rappaport-Vassiliadis/43 supplemented with 10 μg of sodium novobiocin per ml are the best media for the recovery and enumeration of salmonellas from water samples.     

Detection of salmonellas in animal feeds by electrical conductance

A comparison was made between standard culture methods and electrical conductance using a Malthus AT Microbiological Analyser for the examination of animal feeds for salmonella. Conductance testing with a selenite cystine/trimethylamine-N-oxide/dulcitol medium resulted in the detection of salmonellas in 49 of 55 known positive animal feeds, 13 of 19 spiked feed samples and 36 of 47 salmonella cultures. Testing with a lysine decarboxylase/glucose medium gave significantly better results (P less than 0.05) than with selenite cystine medium but five lysine decarboxylase negative strains of salmonella were undetected. When both media were used in parallel all salmonella positive samples were detected. No difference was found between preenrichment in buffered peptone water containing trimethylamine/mannitol and that containing lysine/glucose. Positive detection criteria for selenite medium of conductance peak at greater than or equal to 500 microsiemens (microS) with a rate of change of greater than or equal to 60 microS/h or 400-499 microS with a rate of change of greater than or equal to 40 microS/h and for lysine medium with a peak of greater than or equal to 100 microS have been established. The method offers savings in media and operating costs over conventional standard culture methods, provides results within 48 h and is recommended for statutory feed monitoring purposes.     

Some modification to the media for rapid automated detection of salmonellas by conductance measurement

A selenite medium for the automated detection of salmonellas by conductance measurements has been modified to eliminate the negative results given by some dulcitol-negative strains. The dulcitol is replaced with mannitol and pre-enrichment is best done in buffered peptone water containing mannitol and dimethylsulphoxide. It is suggested that both versions of the selenite medium be used initially.     

Improved Salmonella recovery from moderate to highly polluted waters

A new enrichment procedure for the recovery of salmonellas from aquatic environments is proposed. It has been tested in a eutrophic lake showing moderate to high faecal contamination levels (the Albufera lake near Valencia, Spain), and in effluents coming into a wastewater treatment plant. The new method consists of the addition of sodium novobiocin to a modification of Rappaport's medium (R10/43°C). The new medium (NR10/43°C) allows a better recovery of salmonellas from water than selenite broth.     

A study of isolation procedures for multiple infections of Salmonella and Arizona in a wild marsupial, the quokka (Setonix brachyurus)

Rectal swabs and faeces were used in the regular sampling for salmonellas and Arizonas from a heavily-infected population of a marsupial, the quokka ( Setonix brachyurus ). The media used were strontium selenite A and strontium chloride B enrichment broths, with subculture onto modified bismuth sulphite agar and deoxycholate citrate agar. A study of sampling, enrichment, sub-culture and colony selection procedures produced an optimal scheme giving high yields but consistent with reasonable economy of time and materials. A three-swab sample was taken and inoculated into the two enrichment media, and with each enrichment subjected to three subcultures. The absolute efficiency of this procedure was greater than 80% (and confirmed by a serological method), compared with only 67% for a single swab in a single enrichment. Recovery of some serotypes depended on the media used; e.g. Arizonas could not be recovered satisfactorily from strontium chloride B enrichment. Faeces samples were found to be greatly superior to rectal swabs for detecting salmonellas and arizonas but they were less convenient in field studies. In a comparison of rectal swabs and faeces samples where the actual concentration of salmonellas was known, it was found that the efficiency of rectal swabs approached 100% if there were more than 10³ salmonellas/g faeces, but this declined to approximately 50% if there were 10²-10³ salmonellas/g faeces and only 25% if there were less than 10² salmonellas/g faeces. A new statistical procedure was introduced for comparing the number of isolations from two methods, and this should be of use in similar methodological studies.     

Development of a 24 h screen to detect viable salmonellas in faeces

A 24 h screen to detect viable salmonellas in faeces was developed by studying growth dynamics of salmonellas and competing flora in combinations of enrichment media and artificially-inoculated pig faeces. Muller-Kauffmann tetrathionate (MK) broth, incubated overnight at 42°C, maintained the lowest ratio of salmonella: competing flora and identified all inoculated samples. A 4 h postenrichment in M broth plus novobiocin reduced the number of false-positive results in subsequent ELISAs. Adjusting the negative cut-off values and incubation time of the chromogenic substrate from that recommended in the ELISA instructions reduced the rate of false-positive results further and allowed the detection of 10³ salmonellas per ml in the presence of up to 10⁷ ml⁻¹ aerobic-competing cells. Suspension of faeces diluted 1 in 2 and 1 in 5, rather than 1 in 10 in MK broth did not necessitate further adjustments to the ELISA baseline values. The proposed screen protocol is an overnight incubation of faeces suspended 1 in 10 in MK broth, a 1 in 100 subculture into M broth plus 10 μg ml⁻¹ novobiocin (MbN) for 4 h, steam inactivation of MbN cultures and testing by ELISA, and can detect three salmonella cells per g faeces.     

Growth of salmonellas in different enrichment media

The usefulness of selenite-F (S-F), tetrathionate (MKT) and Rappaport-10 (R-10) broths as enrichment media to support growth of salmonellas either alone or in the presence of other competing organisms was studied. Their ability to support the growth of stressed salmonellas from water was also investigated. It was observed that R-10 was more inhibitory to competing organisms than MKT and S-F. It strongly inhibited the growth of Pseudomonas aeruginosa, Citrobacter freundii and Proteus vulgaris though not of Escherichia coli and Enterobacter aerogenes. It was more toxic, however, to small numbers of salmonellas than MKT and S-F. Tetrathionate was strongly inhibitory for E. coli and Ent. aerogenes but much less so for Proteus and Pseudomonas species. Selenite-F was much less inhibitory than MKT to Ps. aeruginosa and it did not inhibit growth of E. coli and Ent. aerogenes as much as MKT. Salmonellas were inhibited by all three enrichment media and none of them is ideally suited for direct use. Of the three media, R-10 was much more inhibitory to stressed organisms than S-F or MKT.     

Growth of salmonellas in different enrichment media

The usefulness-of selenite-F (S-F), tetrathionate (MKT) and Rappaport-10 (R-10) broths as enrichment media to support growth of salmonellas either alone or in the presence of other competing organisms was studied. Their ability to support the growth of stressed salmonellas from water was also investigated. It was observed that R-10 was more inhibitory to competing organisms than MKT and S-F. It strongly inhibited the growth of Pseudomonas aeruginosa, Citrobacter freundii and Proteus vulgaris though not of Escherichia coli and Enterobacter aerogenes. It was more toxic, however, to small numbers of salmonellas than MKT and S-F. Tetrathionate was strongly inhibitory for E. coli and Ent. aerogenes but much less so for Proteus and Pseudomonas species. Selenite-F was much less inhibitory than MKT to Ps. aeruginosa and it did not inhibit growth of E. coli and Ent. aerogenes as much as MKT. Salmonellas were inhibited by all three enrichment media and none of them is ideally suited for direct use. Of the three media, R-10 was much more inhibitory to stressed organisms than S-F or MKT.     

Inhibitory Action of Various Plating Media on the Growth of Certain Salmonella Serotypes

The growth of 68 strains of Salmonella typhi , 697 other Salmonella strains and 213 strains of other Gram negative intestinal bacteria on 8 plating media was assessed semi-quantitatively. These media were found to be differentially inhibitory to different Salmonella serotypes. The combined use of two plating media, brilliant green MacConkey agar and deoxycholate citrate agar, allowed potentially the recovery of the maximum number of Salmonella strains. If only one medium was used, brilliant green MacConkey agar would appear to be the best plating medium for the isolation of non-typhoid salmonellas in general and S. choleraesuis in particular. Xylose lysine deoxycholate agar, on which a certain proportion of salmonellas failed to yield typical, recognizable colonies, was found not to be a good plating medium for their isolation.     

Effect of carbohydrate source in selenite cystine trimethylamine oxide broth on the detection of salmonellas using the Bactometer

Ninety-five salmonellas and 40 non-salmonellas were screened in the Bactometer using the standard formulation for Easter and Gibson's selenite cystine trimethylamine oxide dulcitol broth and versions in which dulcitol was replaced by mannitol or deoxyribose. More strains of salmonellas exceeded the current detection criteria (magnitude 250, rate 25) when dulcitol was replaced by either mannitol or deoxyribose as carbohydrate source. Using mannitol, more non-salmonella strains exceeded the detection criteria than with either dulcitol or deoxyribose.     

A Note on the Inhibition of Pseudomonas aeruginosa by a Modification of Brilliant Green Agar for Improved Salmonella Isolation

A strain of Pseudomonas aeruginosa having colonies that resemble those of salmonellas on brilliant green agar is almost totally inhibited by the addition of 1.0 mg/ml of sulphacetamide to the medium. Low numbers of Ps. aeruginosa grew equally well on brilliant green and nutrient agar, but 10⁶–10⁷ organisms were needed before any growth appeared on the medium containing sulphacetamide. During 12 months of routine use of the sulphacetamide medium, involving almost 3000 plates, Ps. aeruginosa has been isolated as a contaminant only once. Forty-seven salmonella serotypes were grown on the sulphacetamide brilliant green agar in the same period.     

Fate of salmonellas and competing flora in meat sample enrichments in buffered peptone water and in Muller-Kauffmann's tetrathionate medium

Studies have been carried out in which growth patterns of a Salmonella sp. and competing micro-organisms, especially other Enterobacteriaceae, were followed during pre-enrichment in buffered peptone water (BPw) and subsequent selective enrichment in tetrathionate broth (TBB). Pre-enrichment cultures were inoculated with minced meat and three reference samples containing nalidixic acid-resistant salmonellas. Irrespective of their initial numbers in BPw, Enterobacteriaceae increased to 10(8)/ml or more. During incubation in TBB at 43 degrees C, numbers of lactose-positive Enterobacteriaceae decreased in most enrichments which resulted in a positive salmonella isolation, but remained constant in the majority of those that did not. Levels of lactose-negative Enterobacteriaceae did not decrease in most salmonella-positive tests, but did so in half of the salmonella-negative ones. In the salmonella-positive tests the numbers of salmonellas had increased to 10(3)-10(7)/ml in BPw and after transfer to TBB slowly reached 10(4)/ml or more. In all cases the numbers of salmonellas exceeded those of the competing flora on brilliant green agar (BGA). In the salmonella-negative tests the numbers of salmonellas had increased less in BPw and decreased in most of the TBB enrichments. In none of these negative tests did the numbers of salmonellas exceed those of the competing flora on BGA. Escherichia coli dominated in most of the salmonella-negative tests. The results suggest more influence of lactose-positive than lactose-negative Enterobacteriaceae on the detection of salmonellas. The effect of competing microorganisms seems to depend not only upon their initial numbers, but also upon the types that can interact with salmonellas during selective enrichment.