Evolutionary transition from C3 to C4 photosynthesis and the route to C4 rice

Compared with C₃ plants, C₄ plants possess a mechanism to concentrate CO₂ around the ribulose-1,5-bisphosphate carboxylase/oxygenase in chloroplasts of bundle sheath cells so that the carboxylation reaction work at a much more efficient rate, thereby substantially eliminate the oxygenation reaction and the resulting photorespiration. It is observed that C₄ photosynthesis is more efficient than C₃ photosynthesis under conditions of low atmospheric CO₂, heat, drought and salinity, suggesting that these factors are the important drivers to promote C₄ evolution. Although C₄ evolution took over 66 times independently, it is hypothesized that it shared the following evolutionary trajectory: 1) gene duplication followed by neofunctionalization; 2) anatomical and ultrastructral changes of leaf architecture to improve the hydraulic systems; 3) establishment of two-celled photorespiratory pump; 4) addition of transport system; 5) co-option of the duplicated genes into C₄ pathway and adaptive changes of C₄ enzymes. Based on our current understanding on C₄ evolution, several strategies for engineering C₄ rice have been proposed to increase both photosynthetic efficiency and yield significantly in order to avoid international food crisis in the future, especially in the developing countries. Here we summarize the latest progresses on the studies of C₄ evolution and discuss the strategies to introduce two-celled C₄ pathway into rice.     

Temperature response of photosynthesis in C3, C4, and CAM plants: temperature acclimation and temperature adaptation

Most plants show considerable capacity to adjust their photosynthetic characteristics to their growth temperatures (temperature acclimation). The most typical case is a shift in the optimum temperature for photosynthesis, which can maximize the photosynthetic rate at the growth temperature. These plastic adjustments can allow plants to photosynthesize more efficiently at their new growth temperatures. In this review article, we summarize the basic differences in photosynthetic reactions in C₃, C₄, and CAM plants. We review the current understanding of the temperature responses of C₃, C₄, and CAM photosynthesis, and then discuss the underlying physiological and biochemical mechanisms for temperature acclimation of photosynthesis in each photosynthetic type. Finally, we use the published data to evaluate the extent of photosynthetic temperature acclimation in higher plants, and analyze which plant groups (i.e., photosynthetic types and functional types) have a greater inherent ability for photosynthetic acclimation to temperature than others, since there have been reported interspecific variations in this ability. We found that the inherent ability for temperature acclimation of photosynthesis was different: (1) among C₃, C₄, and CAM species; and (2) among functional types within C₃ plants. C₃ plants generally had a greater ability for temperature acclimation of photosynthesis across a broad temperature range, CAM plants acclimated day and night photosynthetic process differentially to temperature, and C₄ plants was adapted to warm environments. Moreover, within C₃ species, evergreen woody plants and perennial herbaceous plants showed greater temperature homeostasis of photosynthesis (i.e., the photosynthetic rate at high-growth temperature divided by that at low-growth temperature was close to 1.0) than deciduous woody plants and annual herbaceous plants, indicating that photosynthetic acclimation would be particularly important in perennial, long-lived species that would experience a rise in growing season temperatures over their lifespan. Interestingly, across growth temperatures, the extent of temperature homeostasis of photosynthesis was maintained irrespective of the extent of the change in the optimum temperature for photosynthesis (T _opt), indicating that some plants achieve greater photosynthesis at the growth temperature by shifting T _opt, whereas others can also achieve greater photosynthesis at the growth temperature by changing the shape of the photosynthesis–temperature curve without shifting T _opt. It is considered that these differences in the inherent stability of temperature acclimation of photosynthesis would be reflected by differences in the limiting steps of photosynthetic rate.     

Evolutionary switch and genetic convergence on rbcL following the evolution of C4 photosynthesis

Rubisco is responsible for the fixation of CO2 into organic compounds through photosynthesis and thus has a great agronomic importance. It is well established that this enzyme suffers from a slow catalysis, and its low specificity results into photorespiration, which is considered as an energy waste for the plant. However, natural variations exist, and some Rubisco lineages, such as in C4 plants, exhibit higher catalytic efficiencies coupled to lower specificities. These C4 kinetics could have evolved as an adaptation to the higher CO2 concentration present in C4 photosynthetic cells. In this study, using phylogenetic analyses on a large data set of C3 and C4 monocots, we showed that the rbcL gene, which encodes the large subunit of Rubisco, evolved under positive selection in independent C4 lineages. This confirms that selective pressures on Rubisco have been switched in C4 plants by the high CO2 environment prevailing in their photosynthetic cells. Eight rbcL codons evolving under positive selection in C4 clades were involved in parallel changes among the 23 independent monocot C4 lineages included in this study. These amino acids are potentially responsible for the C4 kinetics, and their identification opens new roads for human-directed Rubisco engineering. The introgression of C4-like high-efficiency Rubisco would strongly enhance C3 crop yields in the future CO2-enriched atmosphere.     

C4 photosynthesis: discovery and resolution

This Minireview provides a brief account of the scene and interesting turn of events surrounding the discovery and resolution of the mechanism of C₄ photosynthesis, as well as the recognition of the process by the wider plant science community. This revised version was published online in June 2006 with corrections to the Cover Date.     

Effects of elevated CO2 on the tolerance of photosynthesis to acute heat stress in C3, C4, and CAM species

Determining the effect of elevated CO(2) on the tolerance of photosynthesis to acute heat stress (AHS) is necessary for predicting plant responses to global warming because photosynthesis is heat sensitive and AHS and atmospheric CO(2) will increase in the future. Few studies have examined this effect, and past results were variable, which may be related to methodological variation among studies. In this study, we grew 11 species that included cool and warm season and C(3), C(4), and CAM species at current or elevated (370 or 700 ppm) CO(2) and at species-specific optimal growth temperatures and at 30°C (if optimal ≠ 30°C). We then assessed thermotolerance of net photosynthesis (P(n)), stomatal conductance (g(st)), leaf internal [CO(2)], and photosystem II (PSII) and post-PSII electron transport during AHS. Thermotolerance of P(n) in elevated (vs. ambient) CO(2) increased in C(3), but decreased in C(4) (especially) and CAM (high growth temperature only), species. In contrast, elevated CO(2) decreased electron transport in 10 of 11 species. High CO(2) decreased g(st) in five of nine species, but stomatal limitations to P(n) increased during AHS in only two cool-season C(3) species. Thus, benefits of elevated CO(2) to photosynthesis at normal temperatures may be partly offset by negative effects during AHS, especially for C(4) species, so effects of elevated CO(2) on acute heat tolerance may contribute to future changes in plant productivity, distribution, and diversity.     

C4 photosynthesis and water stress

Background

In contrast to C₃ photosynthesis, the response of C₄ photosynthesis to water stress has been less-well studied in spite of the significant contribution of C₄ plants to the global carbon budget and food security. The key feature of C₄ photosynthesis is the operation of a CO₂-concentrating mechanism in the leaves, which serves to saturate photosynthesis and suppress photorespiration in normal air. This article reviews the current state of understanding about the response of C₄ photosynthesis to water stress, including the interaction with elevated CO₂ concentration. Major gaps in our knowledge in this area are identified and further required research is suggested.

Scope

Evidence indicates that C₄ photosynthesis is highly sensitive to water stress. With declining leaf water status, CO₂ assimilation rate and stomatal conductance decrease rapidly and photosynthesis goes through three successive phases. The initial, mainly stomatal phase, may or may not be detected as a decline in assimilation rates depending on environmental conditions. This is because the CO₂-concentrating mechanism is capable of saturating C₄ photosynthesis under relatively low intercellular CO₂ concentrations. In addition, photorespired CO₂ is likely to be refixed before escaping the bundle sheath. This is followed by a mixed stomatal and non-stomatal phase and, finally, a mainly non-stomatal phase. The main non-stomatal factors include reduced activity of photosynthetic enzymes; inhibition of nitrate assimilation, induction of early senescence, and changes to the leaf anatomy and ultrastructure. Results from the literature about CO₂ enrichment indicate that when C₄ plants experience drought in their natural environment, elevated CO₂ concentration alleviates the effect of water stress on plant productivity indirectly via improved soil moisture and plant water status as a result of decreased stomatal conductance and reduced leaf transpiration.

Conclusions

It is suggested that there is a limited capacity for photorespiration or the Mehler reaction to act as significant alternative electron sinks under water stress in C₄ photosynthesis. This may explain why C₄ photosynthesis is equally or even more sensitive to water stress than its C₃ counterpart in spite of the greater capacity and water use efficiency of the C₄ photosynthetic pathway.Key words: C₃ and C₄ photosynthesis, stomatal and non-stomatal limitation, high CO₂, water stress     

Oligomeric enzymes in the C4 pathway of photosynthesis

This review deals with the factors controlling the aggregation-state of several enzymes involved in C₄ photosynthesis, namely phosphoenolpyruvate carboxylase, NAD-and NADP-malic enzyme, NADP-malic dehydrogenase and pyruvate, phosphate dikinase and its regulatory protein. All of these enzymes are oligomeric and have been shown to undergo changes in their quaternary structure in vitro under different conditions. The activity changes linked to variations in aggregation-state are discussed in terms of their putative physiological role in the regulation of C₄ metabolism.Abbreviations P-enolpyruvate phosphoenolpyruvate - NAD-ME NAD-dependent malic enzyme - NADP-ME NADP-dependent malic enzyme - NADP-MDH NADP-dependent malic dehydrogenase - PPDK pyruvate, phosphate dikinase - PPDK-RP pyruvate, phosphate dikinase regulatory protein - V_max maximal velocity - K_m Michaelis constant - CAM Crassulacean acid metabolism     

C4 photosynthesis in the vegetation of Aldabra Atoll

Summary The occurrence of the C₄ photosynthetic system, based upon an examination of leaf anatomy, of nearly all species of the vegetation of Aldabra Atoll, western Indian Ocean, is reported. About 19% of the flora has the C₄ system. It only occurs in herbaceous plants, which grow either in grasslands or as an understorey to tall shrubs. Both C₃ and C₄ species compete side by side in the mixed-species communities.The Royal Society Aldabra Research Station     

C3 photosynthesis in the gametophyte of the epiphytic CAM fern Pyrrosia longifolia (Polypodiaceae)

Sporophytes of some epiphytic species in the fern genus Pyrrosia exhibit Crassulacean acid metabolism (CAM), generally considered to be a derived physiological response to xeric habitats. Because these species alternate between independent sporophytic and gametophytic generations yet only the sporophyte has been characterized physiologically, experiments were conducted to determine the photosynthetic pathways present in mature sporophytes, immature sporophytes, and gametophytes of Pyrrosia longifolia. Diurnal CO₂ exchange and malic acid fluctuations demonstrated that although the mature sporophytes exhibited CAM, only C₃ photosynthesis occurred in the gametophytes and young sporophytes. Consideration of the above results and those from previous studies, as well as the life cycle of ferns, indicates that the induction of CAM probably occurs at a certain developmental stage of the sporophyte and/or following exposure to stress. Elucidation of the precise mechanisms underlying this C₃-CAM transition awaits further research.     

C4 cycles: past, present, and future research on C4 photosynthesis

In the late 1960s, a vibrant new research field was ignited by the discovery that instead of fixing CO(2) into a C(3) compound, some plants initially fix CO(2) into a four-carbon (C(4)) compound. The term C(4) photosynthesis was born. In the 20 years that followed, physiologists, biochemists, and molecular and developmental biologists grappled to understand how the C(4) photosynthetic pathway was partitioned between two morphologically distinct cell types in the leaf. By the early 1990s, much was known about C(4) biochemistry, the types of leaf anatomy that facilitated the pathway, and the patterns of gene expression that underpinned the biochemistry. However, virtually nothing was known about how the pathway was regulated. It should have been an exciting time, but many of the original researchers were approaching retirement, C(4) plants were proving recalcitrant to genetic manipulation, and whole-genome sequences were not even a dream. In combination, these factors led to reduced funding and the failure to attract young people into the field; the endgame seemed to be underway. But over the last 5 years, there has been a resurgence of interest and funding, not least because of ambitious multinational projects that aim to increase crop yields by introducing C(4) traits into C(3) plants. Combined with new technologies, this renewed interest has resulted in the development of more sophisticated approaches toward understanding how the C(4) pathway evolved, how it is regulated, and how it might be manipulated. The extent of this resurgence is manifest by the publication in 2011 of more than 650 pages of reviews on different aspects of C(4). Here, I provide an overview of our current understanding, the questions that are being addressed, and the issues that lie ahead.     

Resolving the compartmentation and function of C4 photosynthesis in the single-cell C4 species Bienertia sinuspersici

Bienertia sinuspersici is a land plant known to perform C(4) photosynthesis through the location of dimorphic chloroplasts in separate cytoplasmic domains within a single photosynthetic cell. A protocol was developed with isolated protoplasts to obtain peripheral chloroplasts (P-CP), a central compartment (CC), and chloroplasts from the CC (C-CP) to study the subcellular localization of photosynthetic functions. Analyses of these preparations established intracellular compartmentation of processes to support a NAD-malic enzyme (ME)-type C(4) cycle. Western-blot analyses indicated that the CC has Rubisco from the C(3) cycle, the C(4) decarboxylase NAD-ME, a mitochondrial isoform of aspartate aminotransferase, and photorespiratory markers, while the C-CP and P-CP have high levels of Rubisco and pyruvate, Pidikinase, respectively. Other enzymes for supporting a NAD-ME cycle via an aspartate-alanine shuttle, carbonic anhydrase, phosophoenolpyruvate carboxylase, alanine, and an isoform of aspartate aminotransferase are localized in the cytosol. Functional characterization by photosynthetic oxygen evolution revealed that only the C-CP have a fully operational C(3) cycle, while both chloroplast types have the capacity to photoreduce 3-phosphoglycerate. The P-CP were enriched in a putative pyruvate transporter and showed light-dependent conversion of pyruvate to phosphoenolpyruvate. There is a larger investment in chloroplasts in the central domain than in the peripheral domain (6-fold more chloroplasts and 4-fold more chlorophyll). The implications of this uneven distribution for the energetics of the C(4) and C(3) cycles are discussed. The results indicate that peripheral and central compartment chloroplasts in the single-cell C(4) species B. sinuspersici function analogous to mesophyll and bundle sheath chloroplasts of Kranz-type C(4) species.     

Wide-band tracheids in genera of Portulacaceae: novel, non-xylary tracheids possibly evolved as an adaptation to water stress

Wide-band tracheids (WBTs) are novel tracheids with wide, lignified secondary walls that intrude deeply into the cell lumen when viewed in transverse sections. These tracheids are found in a few genera in related families in the order Caryophyllales: Aizoaceae, Cactaceae, and Portulacaceae. WBTs in these three families vary in (1) systematic occurrence (found in more highly derived genera in each family), (2) location in plant organs, and (3) structure and dimensions. In addition, an analysis was conducted of WBT cell walls to test the hypothesis that WBTs evolved as an adaptation to water stress (i.e., the wide secondary walls should prevent collapse of the primary wall during water stress). The cell wall data show that primary cell walls in WBTs cannot inwardly collapse to occlusion, thus providing support for the water stress hypothesis of WBT evolution. With consideration of their systematic occurrence, the molecular phylogenetic data, and data here showing support for a water stress adaptive origin, it is logical to assume that WBTs evolved in genera that were adapting to environments undergoing a rapid trend toward aridification.     

C(4) photosynthesis: differentiating causation and coincidence

Determination of the historical causes of organismal adaptations is difficult, but a recent study has suggested that at least one of the transitions to C(4) photosynthesis was directly facilitated by changes in atmospheric CO(2) levels. But what about the other 50+ origins of C(4)?     

C3 photosynthesis and high temperature acclimation of CAM in opuntia basilaris engelm. and bigel

Summary Carbon fixation by CAM at high night temperatures was examined in the stem succulent, Opuntia basilaris. Nighttime accumulation of titratable acids was uniformly high among plants growing naturally along an altitudinal temperature gradient in Death Valley, California during the hot summer period. Plants grown at high temperature regimes (40°/30°C) had rates of CAM and C₃ fixation similar to rates observed in plants maintained at a cool temperature (20°/10°C). C₃ fixation comprised 30% of the total carbon fixed by the potted, well watered plants. However, when pads were excised, C₃ fixation was suppressed while CAM continued unabated.     

Sixty years in algal physiology and photosynthesis

This personal perspective records research experiences in chemistry and biology at four German universities, two before and two after World War II. The research themes came from cytophysiology of green unicellular algae, in particular their photosynthesis. The function of inorganic ions in photosynthesis and dark respiration was investigated at different degrees of specific mineral stress (deficiencies), and the kinetics of recovery followed after the addition of the missing element. Two types of recovery of photosynthesis were observed: indirect restitution via growth processes and immediate normalisation. From the latter case (K⁺, phosphate, Mn⁺⁺) the effect of manganese was emphasized as its role in photosynthetic O₂ evolution became established during our research. Other themes of our group, with some bearing on photosynthesis were: synchronization of cell growth by light-dark change and effects of blue (vs. red) light on the composition of green cells. Some experiences in connection with algal mass cultures are included. Discussion of several editorial projects shows how photosynthesis, as an orginally separated field of plant biochemistry and biophysics, became included into general cell physiology and even ecophysiology of green plants. The paper contains an appreciation of the authors' main mentor Kurt Noack (1888–1963) and of Ernst Georg Pringsheim (1881–1970), founder of experimental phycology.Written at the invitation of Govindjee.     

Drought constraints on C4 photosynthesis: stomatal and metabolic limitations in C3 and C4 subspecies of Alloteropsis semialata

The C4 photosynthetic pathway uses water more efficiently than the C3 type, yet biogeographical analyses show a decline in C4 species relative to C3 species with decreasing rainfall. To investigate this paradox, the hypothesis that the C4 advantage over C3 photosynthesis is diminished by drought was tested, and the underlying stomatal and metabolic mechanisms of this response determined. The effects of drought and high evaporative demand on leaf gas exchange and photosynthetic electron sinks in C3 and C4 subspecies of the grass Alloteropsis semialata were examined. Plant responses to climatic variation and soil drought were investigated using a common garden experiment with well-watered and natural rainfall treatments, and underlying mechanisms analysed using controlled drying pot experiments. Photosynthetic rates were significantly higher in the C4 than the C3 subspecies in the garden experiment under well-watered conditions, but this advantage was completely lost during a rainless period when unwatered plants experienced severe drought. Controlled drying experiments showed that this loss was caused by a greater increase in metabolic, rather than stomatal, limitations in C4 than in the C3 leaves. Decreases in CO2 assimilation resulted in lower electron transport rates and decreased photochemical efficiency under drought conditions, rather than increased electron transport to alternative sinks. These findings suggest that the high metabolic sensitivity of photosynthesis to severe drought seen previously in several C4 grass species may be an inherent characteristic of the C4 pathway. The mechanism may explain the paradox of why C4 species decline in arid environments despite high water-use efficiency.     

Carbonic anhydrase and the molecular evolution of C4 photosynthesis

C(4) photosynthesis, a biochemical CO(2)-concentrating mechanism (CCM), evolved more than 60 times within the angiosperms from C(3) ancestors. The genus Flaveria, which contains species demonstrating C(3), C(3)-C(4), C(4)-like or C(4) photosynthesis, is a model for examining the molecular evolution of the C(4) pathway. Work with carbonic anhydrase (CA), and C(3) and C(4) Flaveria congeners has added significantly to the understanding of this process. The C(4) form of CA3, a β-CA, which catalyses the first reaction in the C(4) pathway by hydrating atmospheric CO(2) to bicarbonate in the cytosol of mesophyll cells (mcs), evolved from a chloroplastic C(3) ancestor. The molecular modifications to the ancestral CA3 gene included the loss of the sequence encoding the chloroplast transit peptide, and mutations in regulatory regions that resulted in high levels of expression in the C(4) mesophyll. Analyses of the CA3 proteins and regulatory elements from Flaveria photosynthetic intermediates indicated C(4) biochemistry very likely evolved in a specific, stepwise manner in this genus. The details of the mechanisms involved in the molecular evolution of other C(4) plant β-CAs are unknown; however, comparative genetics indicate gene duplication and neofunctionalization played significant roles as they did in Flaveria.