Reeler: new tales on an old mutant mouse

Neurological mouse mutants provide an opportunity to dissect the complex mechanisms that underlie vertebrate brain development. Advances in genetic technologies have permitted the identification of genes disrupted in many mutants, allowing a molecular interpretation of the phenotypes. For several decades, the spontaneous mutant mouse reeler has been used as a model for the analysis of the development of laminated brain structures. In this ataxic mutant, the migration of many neurons is aberrant, resulting in disrupted cellular organization. Recently, reelin, the gene disrupted in the reeler mouse, has been identified. reelin encodes a novel extracellular molecule that controls neural cell positioning through mechanisms that are not yet completely understood. Analysis of the expression pattern and the properties of the reelin gene product (Reelin) suggests models for its function during brain development. Furthermore, the recent identification of genes that may function in the Reelin signaling pathway advances our knowledge of the molecular basis of neuronal migration. BioEssays 20 :235–244, 1998.© 1998 John Wiley & Sons, Inc.     

Essential mesenchymal role of small GTPase Rac1 in interdigital programmed cell death during limb development

Developing vertebrate limbs are often utilized as a model for studying pattern formation and morphogenetic cell death. Herein, we report that conditional deletion of Rac1, a member of the Rho family of proteins, in mouse limb bud mesenchyme led to skeletal deformities in the autopod and soft tissue syndactyly, with the latter caused by a complete absence of interdigital programmed cell death. Furthermore, the lack of interdigital programmed cell death and associated syndactyly was related to down-regulated gene expression of Bmp2, Bmp7, Msx1, and Msx2, which are known to promote apoptosis in the interdigital mesenchyme. Our findings from Rac1 conditional mutants indicate crucial roles for Rac1 in limb bud morphogenesis, especially interdigital programmed cell death.     

In the limb AER Bmp2 and Bmp4 are required for dorsal-ventral patterning and interdigital cell death but not limb outgrowth

The apical ectodermal ridge (AER) in the vertebrate limb is required for limb outgrowth and patterning. To investigate the role BMP ligands expressed in the AER play in limb development we selectively inactivated both Bmp2 and Bmp4 in this tissue. The autopods of mice lacking both of these genes contained extra digits, digit bifurcations and interdigital webbing due to a decrease in programmed cell death and an increase in cell proliferation in the underlying mesoderm. Upon removal of Bmp2 and Bmp4 in the AER, no defects in proximal-distal patterning were observed. At the molecular level, removal of Bmp2 and Bmp4 in the AER caused an increase in Fgf expression, which correlated with an increase in both the width and length of the AER. Investigation of Engrailed-1 (En1) expression in the AER of limb buds in which Bmp2 and Bmp4 had been removed indicated that En1 expression was absent from this tissue. Our data suggests that AER expression of Bmp2 and Bmp4 is required for digit and dorsal-ventral patterning but surprisingly not for limb outgrowth.     

The BMP antagonist Gremlin regulates outgrowth, chondrogenesis and programmed cell death in the developing limb.

In this study, we have analyzed the expression and function of Gremlin in the developing avian limb. Gremlin is a member of the DAN family of BMP antagonists highly conserved through evolution able to bind and block BMP2, BMP4 and BMP7. At early stages of development, gremlin is expressed in the dorsal and ventral mesoderm in a pattern complementary to that of bmp2, bmp4 and bmp7. The maintenance of gremlin expression at these stages is under the control of the AER, ZPA, and BMPs. Exogenous administration of recombinant Gremlin indicates that this protein is involved in the control of limb outgrowth. This function appears to be mediated by the neutralization of BMP function to maintain an active AER, to restrict the extension of the areas of programmed cell death and to confine chondrogenesis to the central core mesenchyme of the bud. At the stages of digit formation, gremlin is expressed in the proximal boundary of the interdigital mesoderm of the chick autopod. The anti-apoptotic influence of exogenous Gremlin, which results in the formation of soft tissue syndactyly in the chick, together with the expression of gremlin in the duck interdigital webs, indicates that Gremlin regulates the regression of the interdigital tissue. At later stages of limb development, gremlin is expressed in association with the differentiating skeletal pieces, muscles and the feather buds. The different expression of Gremlin in relation with other BMP antagonists present in the limb bud, such as Noggin, Chordin and Follistatin indicates that the functions of BMPs are regulated specifically by the different BMP antagonists, acting in a complementary fashion rather than being redundant signals.     

The absence of cell death during development of free digits in amphibians

Massive cellular death occurs in the interdigital regions of developing limbs of free-digited birds and mammals. This mesodermal degeneration occurs at the same time that digits become free. The present study of digit formation in amphibians, using vital staining and histological and autoradiographic techniques, demonstrates the absence of zones of interdigital degeneration during the formation of free digits. Furthermore, no other areas of predictable cell death occur during amphibian limb development, a situation quite unlike the case for avian limb development where predictable zones of degeneration occur in the mesoderm along the pre- and postaxial borders of the developing wing and leg. Thus, zones of cell death are not a part of amphibian limb morphogenesis. Analysis of the labeling index of the developing free-digited forelimb of Xenopus laevis reveals that during stage 52 the interdigital and digital labeling indexes are the same. The change in the ratio of interdigital labeling index to the digital labeling index in the forelimb suggests that during subsequent development the interdigital labeling index decreases while the digital labeling index is maintained. In comparison, the same analysis indicates that the interdigital labeling index of the webbed hindlimb increases when compared to the digital labeling index, which stays the same from early to late stages. It is proposed that free digits develop in Xenopus laevis forelimb as a result of a decrease in the proliferation rate of the interdigital region as compared to the digital region, which remains unchanged. Conversely, webbed digits develop in the hindlimb as a result of an interdigital rate at least equal to the digital rate.     

Evidence that the limb bud ectoderm is required for survival of the underlying mesoderm

The limb forms from a bud of mesoderm encased in a hull of ectoderm that grows out from the flank of the embryo. Coordinated signaling between the limb mesoderm and ectoderm is critical for normal limb outgrowth and patterning. The apical ectodermal ridge (AER), found at the distal tip, is a rich source of signaling molecules and has been proposed to specify distal structures and maintain the survival of cells in the underlying distal mesoderm. The dorsal and ventral non-AER ectoderm is also a source of signaling molecules and is important for dorsal–ventral patterning of the limb bud. Here we determine if this ectoderm provides cell survival signals by surgically removing the dorsal or ventral ectoderm during early chicken limb bud development and assaying for programmed cell death. We find that, similar to the AER, removal of the dorsal or ventral non-AER ectoderm results in massive cell death in the underlying mesoderm. In addition, although a re-epithelialization occurs, we find perturbations in the timing of Shh expression and, for the case of the dorsal ectoderm removal, defects in soft tissue and skeletal development along the proximal–distal axis. Furthermore, ectoderm substitution experiments show that the survival signal produced by the dorsal limb ectoderm is specific. Thus, our results argue that the non-AER ectoderm, like the AER, provides a specific survival signal to the underlying mesoderm that is necessary for normal limb development and conclusions drawn from experiments in which the non-AER ectoderm is removed, need to take into consideration this observation.     

Smad8 is expressed in the anterior necrotic zone: evidence for a role of bone morphogenetic proteins/SMAD signaling in the activation of a molecular cascade that culminates in cell death

Bone morphogenetic proteins (BMPs) play a crucial role in programmed cell death (PCD), a biological process required for the sculpturing of the embryonic limbs. However, it is unknown if BMP signaling directly promotes cell death, or if it induces a molecular cascade that culminates in cell death. Given that Smad8, which encodes one component of BMP signaling, is expressed during the regression of interdigital tissue and responds to BMPs, we presumed that it may be expressed in other cell death areas during chick limb development such as the anterior and posterior necrotic zones (ANZ and PNZ). The present study found that the Smad8 expression pattern in the anterior mesoderm of the hindlimb is very similar to that observed in limbs stained to detect cell death. Also, BMPs and retinoic acid, which act as apoptosis-promoting factors, induced expression of Smad8 before the onset of cell death, while sonic hedgehog protein, acting as a survival factor, inhibited Smad8 expression in the ANZ. However, although there was correlation between Smad8 expression patterns and PCD in the ANZ, phosphorylated forms of SMAD1/5/8 and TUNEL staining did not co-localize in dying cells. Interestingly, a short pulse of BMP was sufficient to trigger cell death. On the other hand, most dying cells were located in the avascular region, while many cells expressing Smad8 were located in the vascular region of the ANZ. These results suggest that BMPs mediated by SMAD signaling activate a molecular cascade that culminates in PCD.     

Molecular clocks underlying vertebrate embryo segmentation: A 10-year-old hairy-go-round

Segmentation of the vertebrate embryo body is a fundamental developmental process that occurs with strict temporal precision. Temporal control of this process is achieved through molecular segmentation clocks, evidenced by oscillations of gene expression in the unsegmented presomitic mesoderm (PSM, precursor tissue of the axial skeleton) and in the distal limb mesenchyme (limb chondrogenic precursor cells). The first segmentation clock gene, hairy1, was identified in the chick embryo PSM in 1997. Ten years later, chick hairy2 expression unveils a molecular clock operating during limb development. This review revisits vertebrate embryo segmentation with special emphasis on the current knowledge on somitogenesis and limb molecular clocks. A compilation of human congenital disorders that may arise from deregulated embryo clock mechanisms is presented here, in an attempt to reconcile different sources of information regarding vertebrate embryo development. Challenging open questions concerning the somitogenesis clock are presented and discussed, such as When?, Where?, How?, and What for? Hopefully the next decade will be equally rich in answers. Birth Defects Research (Part C) 81:65–83, 2007. © 2007 Wiley‐Liss, Inc.     

Paraxial left-sided nodal expression and the start of left–right patterning in the early chick embryo

A common element during early left–right patterning of the vertebrate body is left-sided nodal expression in the early-somite stage lateral plate mesoderm. Leftward cell movements near the node of the gastrulating chick embryo recently offered a plausible mechanism for breaking the presomite-stage molecular symmetry in those vertebrates which lack rotating cilia on the notochord or equivalent tissues. However, the temporal and functional relationships between generation of the known morphological node asymmetry, onset of leftward cell movements and establishment of stable molecular asymmetry in the chick remain unresolved. This study uses high-resolution light microscopy and in situ gene expression analysis to show that intranodal cell rearrangement during the phase of counter-clockwise node torsion at stage 4+ is immediately followed by symmetry loss and rearrangement of shh and fgf8 expression in node epiblast between stages 5− and 5+. Surprisingly, left-sided nodal expression starts at stage 5−, too, but lies in the paraxial mesoderm next to the forming notochordal plate, and can be rendered symmetrical by minimal mechanical disturbance of distant tissue integrity at stage 4. The “premature” paraxial nodal expression together with morphological and molecular asymmetries in, and near, midline compartments occurring at defined substages of early gastrulation help to identify a new narrow time window for early steps in left–right patterning in the chick and support the concept of a causal relationship between a—still enigmatic—chiral (motor) protein, cell movements and incipient left–right asymmetry in the amniote embryo.     

Role of FGFs in the control of programmed cell death during limb development

We have investigated the role of FGFs in the control of programmed cell death during limb development by analyzing the effects of increasing and blocking FGF signaling in the avian limb bud. BMPs are currently considered as the signals responsible for cell death. Here we show that FGF signaling is also necessary for apoptosis and that the establishment of the areas of cell death is regulated by the convergence of FGF- and BMP-mediated signaling pathways. As previously demonstrated, cell death is inhibited for short intervals (12 hours) after administration of FGFs. However, this initial inhibition is followed (24 hours) by a dramatic increase in cell death, which can be abolished by treatments with a BMP antagonist (Noggin or Gremlin). Conversely, blockage of FGF signaling by applying a specific FGF-inhibitor (SU5402) into the interdigital regions inhibits both physiological cell death and that mediated by exogenous BMPs. Furthermore, FGF receptors 1, 2 and 3 are expressed in the autopodial mesoderm during the regression of the interdigital tissue, and the expression of FGFR3 in the interdigital regions is regulated by FGFs and BMPs in the same fashion as apopotosis. Together our findings indicate that, in the absence of FGF signaling BMPs are not sufficient to trigger apoptosis in the developing limb. Although we provide evidence for a positive influence of FGFs on BMP gene expression, the physiological implication of FGFs in apoptosis appears to result from their requirement for the expression of genes of the apoptotic cascade. We have identified MSX2 and Snail as candidate genes associated with apoptosis the expression of which requires the combined action of FGFs and BMPs.     

Experimental manipulation leading to induction of dorsal ectodermal ridges on normal limb buds results in a phenocopy of the eudiplopodia chick mutant

Elongation of chick limb buds depends on the presence of the apical ectodermal ridge which is induced by subjacent limb bud mesoderm. Recombination experiments have shown that the limb bud mesoderm loses the capacity to induce ridges by late stage 17. Moreover, in normal limb development only one ridge forms. However, in the eudiplopodia chick mutant accessory ectodermal ridges form on the dorsal surface of limb buds as late as stage 22. Tissue recombinant experiments show that the mutation affects the ectoderm, extending the time it responds to ridge induction (Fraser and Abbott, 1971a, Fraser and Abbott, 1971b while the mesoderm is normal. The result is polydactyly, with extra digits dorsal to the normal digits. Because eudiplopodia limb bud dorsal mesoderm can induce ridges at stage 22 but is unaffected by the gene, genetically normal dorsal limb bud mesoderm may also be able to induce ridges after stage 17. To test this possibility we grafted stages 14–18 flank ectoderm to normal limb bud dorsal mesoderm and found that mesoderm from stages 17 through 20 was able to induce a ridge and subsequently dorsal digits developed. Limbs with duplicate digits were similar to eudiplopodia limbs. In other experiments, stage 18, 19, and 20 leg bud dorsal ectoderm did not form ridges when grafted to leg bud dorsal mesoderm of the same stage, indicating a lack of response to the mesoderm. Finally, the inductive capacity of limb bud mesoderm appeared to be reduced compared to mesoderm at pre-limb bud stages. These experiments demonstrate a spatially generalized potential in limb bud dorsal mesoderm to induce ridges during the stages when the apical ridge is induced. The determination of where the ridge will form and the acquired inability of limb bud dorsal ectoderm to respond to induction by underlying mesoderm are necessary early pattern forming events which assure that a single proximodistal limb axis will form.     

The in vitro maintenance of the apical ectodermal ridge of the chick embryo wing bud: an assay for polarizing activity.

We have devised an in vitro bioassay for limb bud polarizing activity in the chick embryo. This assay has proven to be a relatively quick and effective test for a morphogenetic factor asymmetrically distributed in the limb bud which is capable of maintaining or thickening the apical ectodermal ridge.A small section of the preaxial border of the chick embryo wing bud was cultured alone, with tissue from the posterior border, mid-dorsal or anterior corner of a second donor wing, or from the flank. The tissue from the preaxial border (responding tissue) consisted of mesoderm with overlying ectoderm and apical ectodermal ridge. When the responding tissue was cultured alone, with flank, or with anterior corner limb tissue, the apical ectodermal ridge flattened in 24–36 hr and many macrophages appeared in the underlying mesoderm. When cultured with posterior border limb tissue however, the apical ridge of the responding tissue remained thickened for up to 48 hr., and no macrophages appear in the underlying mesoderm. The behavior of responding tissue was intermediate between these two extremes when cultured with mid-dorsal limb tissue. The morphogenetic activity assayed by this procedure thus seems to be present as a gradient in the wing bud, with activity decreasing from posterior to anterior. Contact with the responding tissue is not required to enable posterior border tissue to elicit ridge thickening and inhibit the cell death.     

The relationship of intramuscular nerve branching and synaptogenesis to motoneuron survival

The target has been considered for some time to play a major role in allowing neurons to survive the period of naturally occurring cell death. For the motoneurons that innervate the chick limb, evidence is presented that suggests access to target-derived trophic factor via intramuscular nerve branches and synapses may be important in regulating neuronal survival. Alterations in branching and synapse formation produced by activity blockade as well as by alteration of adhesion molecule function are shown to result in changes in motoneuron survival consistent with the proposed hypothesis. The relevance of these observations to the numerical-matching hypothesis of vertebrate neuronal cell death is also considered. © 1992 John Wiley & Sons, Inc.     

Irx1 and Irx2 Are Coordinately Expressed and Regulated by Retinoic Acid,TGFβ and FGF Signaling during Chick Hindlimb Development

The Iroquois homeobox (Irx) genes play a crucial role in the regionalization and patterning of tissues and organs during metazoan development. The Irx1 and Irx2 gene expression pattern during hindlimb development has been investigated in different species, but its regulation during hindlimb morphogenesis has not been explored yet. The aim of this study was to evaluate the gene expression pattern of Irx1 and Irx2 as well as their regulation by important regulators of hindlimb development such as retinoic acid (RA), transforming growth factor β (TGFβ) and fibroblast growth factor (FGF) signaling during chick hindlimb development. Irx1 and Irx2 were coordinately expressed in the interdigital tissue, digital primordia, joints and in the boundary between cartilage and non-cartilage tissue. Down-regulation of Irx1 and Irx2 expression at the interdigital tissue coincided with the onset of cell death. RA was found to down-regulate their expression by a bone morphogenetic protein-independent mechanism before any evidence of cell death. Furthermore, TGFβ protein regulated Irx1 and Irx2 in a stage-dependent manner at the interdigital tissue, it inhibited their expression when it was administered to the interdigital tissue at developing stages before their normal down-regulation. TGFβ administered to the interdigital tissue at developing stages after normal down-regulation of Irx1 and Irx2 evidenced that expression of these genes marked the boundary between cartilage tissue and non-cartilage tissue. It was also found that at early stages of hindlimb development FGF signaling inhibited the expression of Irx2. In conclusion, the present study demonstrates that Irx1 and Irx2 are coordinately expressed and regulated during chick embryo hindlimb development as occurs in other species of vertebrates supporting the notion that the genomic architecture of Irx clusters is conserved in vertebrates.     

Programmed cell death in the embryonic vertebrate limb

The developing limb bud provides one of the best examples in which programmed cell death exerts major morphogenetic functions. In this work, we revise the distribution and the developmental significance of cell death in the embryonic vertebrate limb and its control by the BMP signalling pathway. In addition, paying special attention to the interdigital apoptotic zones, we review current data concerning the intracellular death machinery implicated in mesodermal limb apoptosis.     

The relationship of intramuscular nerve branching and synaptogenesis to motoneuron survival.

The target has been considered for some time to play a major role in allowing neurons to survive the period of naturally occurring cell death. For the motoneurons that innervate the chick limb, evidence is presented that suggests access to target-derived trophic factor via intramuscular nerve branches and synapses may be important in regulating neuronal survival. Alterations in branching and synapse formation produced by activity blockade as well as by alteration of adhesion molecule function are shown to result in changes in motoneuron survival consistent with the proposed hypothesis. The relevance of these observations to the numerical-matching hypothesis of vertebrate neuronal cell death is also considered.     

Role of chondrogenic tissue in programmed cell death and BMP expression in chick limb buds

In the developing chick leg bud, massive programmed cell death occurs in the interdigital region. Previously, we reported the inhibition of cell death by separation of the interdigital region from neighboring digit cartilage. In this study, we examined the relationship between cell death and cartilaginous tissue in vitro. First, cell fate was observed with DiI that was used to examine cell movement in the distal tip of leg bud. Labeled cells in the prospective digital region were distributed only in the distal region as a narrow band, while cells in the prospective interdigital region expanded widely in the interdigit. In coculture of monolayer cells and a cell pellet tending to differentiate into cartilage, monolayer cells migrated into the cell pellet. These results suggested that digit cartilage tends to recruit neighboring cells into the cartilage during limb development. Next, we observed the relationship between cell death and chondrogenesis in monolayer culture. Apoptotic cell death that could be detected by TUNEL occurred in regions between cartilaginous nodules in mesenchymal cell culture. More apoptotic cell death was detected in the cell culture of leg bud mesenchyme of stage 25/26 than that of leg bud mesenchyme of stage 22 or that of stage 28. The most developed cartilaginous nodules were observed in the cell culture of stage 25/26. Finally, we observed Bmp expression in vitro and in vivo. Bmp-2, Bmp-4 and Bmp-7 were detected around the cartilage nodules. When the interdigit was separated from neighboring digit cartilage, Bmp-4 expression disappeared near the cut region but remained near the digit cartilage. This correlation between cell death and cartilaginous region suggests that cartilage tissue can induce apoptotic cell death in the developing chick limb bud due to cell migration accompanying chondrogenesis and Bmp expression.     

Inhibition of focal adhesion kinase expression correlates with changes in the cytoskeleton but not apoptosis in primary cultures of chick embryo cells

Cell adhesion to the extracellular matrix through integrin receptors can activate signaling cascades within the cell. Focal adhesion kinase (FAK) is a protein tyrosine kinase activated by integrin adhesion. The role of FAK within the cell is not clear, although evidence suggests roles in cell motility or the regulation of adhesion-dependent cell survival. We have treated primary cultures of chick embryo cells with antisense oligonucleotides to FAK to reduce the level of FAK protein expression. Levels of the related protein, proline-rich tyrosine kinase 2 (Pyk2) and the FAK substrate paxillin, were unaffected by the addition of oligonucleotides, whereas FAK expression was reduced by 70%. Levels of apoptotic cell death did not significantly increase after the addition of oligonucleotides. However, there was a change in the distribution of focal adhesion sites from a uniformly distributed pattern to a mainly peripheral pattern. This was accompanied by a loss of stress fibers and an increase in the peripheral actin cytoskeleton, as the cells became rounded. These results suggest that in these early embryonic cells, FAK expression regulates the arrangement of focal adhesions and the cytoskeleton that result in a motile phenotype, but that FAK does not appear to regulate apoptosis.