Induction and Transmission of a Merodiploid Condition near the Terminal Area of the Chromosome of BACILLUS SUBTILIS

A small fraction (about 0.5%) of the transformants for a particular marker of B. subtilis (ilvA4; most probably a deletion) were found to be relatively unstable merodiploids. They possess a redundancy of the metB–ilvA chromosome segment. When their DNA is used as donor in transformation a merodiploid condition for the whole of this segment is created in all ilvA4⁺ transformants. For several of the duplicated loci both copies often are of recipient strain origin. Markers originally belonging to different copies of the diploidized region can be contransferred in PBS1-mediated transduction. The data are well in agreement with the hypothesis that the merodiploids carry a tandem duplication. An alternative hypothesis which does not call for integration of the exogenote within the recipient chromosome was also considered. Models are proposed for interpreting the segregation of the merodiploids, the transmission of the diploid state and its generation during transformation of the ilvA4 marker by wild-type DNA.     

Transduction of Merodiploidy: Induced Duplication of Recipient Genes

Escherichia coli PB160, which carries a tandem duplication with the gene order metB(+)argH(-)su(159) (+)thi(+): metB(+)argH(+)su(159) (-)thi(+), was used to study the mechanism of P1 transduction of genes in the duplicated region. Transduction of the su(159) (+) allele contained within the duplicated segment yields two kinds of su(159) (+) recombinants: 91% are haploid su(159) (+) and 9% are su(159) (+)/su(159) (-) merodiploids. The duplication in these merodiploid transductants includes the metB locus; however, both copies of the metB locus usually are derived from the recipient. Thus, the requirements for transduction of the "condition of merodiploidy" appear to be the cotransduction of the repeat point (the region where the duplication begins to repeat itself) and, of course, the selected marker (in this case su(159) (+)). A mechanism whereby two recipient chromosomes interact with the transduced "repeat point" region to regenerate the tandem duplication is implicated. It appears that a duplication much larger than the quantity of genetic material carried by a P1 phage can be produced in a transductant.     

Merodiploidy in ESCHERICHIA COLI-SALMONELLA TYPHIMURIUM Crosses: The Role of Unequal Recombination between Ribosomal RNA Genes

Previous workers have shown that intergeneric crosses between Salmonella typhimurium and Escherichia coli produce a high proportion of merodiploid recombinants among the viable progeny. We have examined the unequal cross-over event that was responsible for a number of intergeneric merodiploids. The merodiploids that we studied were all heterozygous for the metB-argH interval and were the products of intergeneric conjugal crosses. We found that when the S. typhimurium donor had its transfer origin closely linked to metB and argH, all recombinants examined were merodiploid, and they generally arose as F-prime factors. Many of these F-prime factors had been created by recombination between flanking rrn genes in the donor. When the S. typhimurium Hfr transfer origin was more distant from the selected markers, quite different results were obtained. Depending on the donor, 19-47% of the recombinants that acquired the donor argH+ or metB+ genes were merodiploid for these loci, but none of the recombinants were F-prime. A majority of the merodiploids had a novel (nonparental) rrn gene, indicating that unequal recombination between nonidentical rrn genes was a prevalent mechanism for establishing the merodiploidy. Both tandem and nontandem duplications were found. Some of the merodiploids duplicated E. coli genes in addition to acquiring S. typhimurium genes. Some merodiploids contained the oriC region from each parent. Of a total of 118 intergeneric merodiploids characterized from all donors, 48 different genotypes were observed, and 38 of the 48 had one or more nonparental rrn operons.     

Merodiploid ribosomal loci arising by transformation and mutation in pneumococcus

Merodiploid states have been detected in the ery and str loci of the pneumococcal genome. They are associated with particular mutations (ery-r10 and str-d2) which add to, rather than replace their homologous sites during deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA)-mediated transformation. Markers at linked sites do not become diploid at the same time. The heterozygous condition thus produced is maintained during cell reproduction. However, in the case of the ery merodiploid at least, segregation of haploid types does occasionally occur. The transforming properties of DNA isolated from the merodiploids, taken together with the segregation patterns of the merodiploids, reveal the heterozygous condition. The merodiploid condition can be transferred via a single molecule of DNA, which can be explained by assuming that both alleles at the diploid site are integrated into the linear continuity of the bacterial chromosome. In the case of the ery merodiploid, two distinct, relatively stable but interconvertible states are recognizable. Their interconvertibility, as well as the segregation of hapliod descendants, can be explained as the result of occasional pairing of the duplicated regions with loss of one of these duplicated regions by recombination.     

Experimental genome evolution: large-scale genome rearrangements associated with resistance to replacement of a chromosomal restriction-modification gene complex

Type II restriction enzymes are paired with modification enzymes that protect type II restriction sites from cleavage by methylating them. A plasmid carrying a type II restriction-modification gene complex is not easily replaced by an incompatible plasmid because loss of the former leads to cell death through chromosome cleavage. In the present work, we looked to see whether a chromosomally located restriction-modification gene complex could be replaced by a homologous stretch of DNA. We tried to replace the PaeR7I gene complex on the Escherichia coli chromosome by transducing a homologous stretch of PaeR7I-modified DNA. The replacement efficiency of the restriction-modification complex was lower than expected. Some of the resulting recombinant clones retained the recipient restriction-modification gene complex as well as the homologous DNA (donor allele), and slowly lost the donor allele in the absence of selection. Analysis of their genome-wide rearrangements by Southern hybridization, inverse polymerase chain reaction (iPCR) and sequence determination demonstrated the occurrence of unequal homologous recombination between copies of the transposon IS3. It was strongly suggested that multiple rounds of unequal IS3-IS3 recombination caused large-scale duplication and inversion of the chromosome, and that only one of the duplicated copies of the recipient PaeR7I was replaced.     

Genetic Studies Relating to the Production of Transformed Clones Diploid in the Tryptophan Region of the Bacillus subtilis Genome

Transformation experiments with Bacillus subtilis strains carrying trpE26 (the marker responsible for the detection of merodiploid clones after transformation or transduction) have established the precise position of this marker on the "aromatic region" of the chromosome, at the distal end of the anthranilate synthetase locus. Integration efficiency of the mutant allele (trpE26) seems to be very low. Co-transfer of markers situated on either side of it is almost nil when both donor and recipient carry this mutation. The "exclusion" of trpE26 does not, however, affect recombination frequencies for nearby markers. To explain these facts we considered the hypothesis of a preferential breakage of the deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA) at the trpE26 site or that of an insertion mutation. These studies have also demonstrated the establishment of physical linkage of a marker from the exogenote (hisH2) to a resident marker (tyrA1) in stable and unstable merodiploid clones, thus confirming integration of the donor DNA segment into a genetic structure of the recipient. Furthermore, duplication was shown in merodiploid clones (through reversion and transformation) for a locus of the recipient (tyrA) which was not involved in the initial transformation. This suggests that the diploid condition in this region extends beyond the transformed area. Interpretation of the genetic constitution of these partial diploids calls for postulation of the existence of long duplications, a second (incomplete) chromosome, or an episome-like element.     

Unequal crossing-over within the B duplication of Drosophila melanogaster: a molecular analysis.

The B mutation is associated with a tandem duplication of 16A1-16A7. It is unstable, mutating to wild type and to a more extreme form at a frequency of one in 1000 to 3000. The reversion to wild type is associated with the loss of one copy of the duplication, whereas the mutation to extreme B is associated with a triplication of the region. The instability of B has been attributed to unequal crossing-over between the two copies of the duplication. Recent molecular data show that there is a transposable element, B104, between the two copies of the duplication and support the hypothesis that this element generated the duplication via a recombination event. These data suggest that unequal crossing-over within the duplication may not be the cause of the instability of B. Instead, the instability may be caused by a recombination event involving the B104 element. This issue was addressed using probes for the DNA on either side of the B104 element at the B breakpoint. All of the data indicate that the B104 element is not involved in the instability of B and support the original unequal crossing-over model.     

Tandem genetic duplications in phage lambda. IV. The locations of spontaneously arising tandem duplications.

Twenty-four spontaneously arising, long DNA addition derivatives of phage lambda have been isolated by two methods (one physical, one genetic) based on phage DNA content. All are shown to contain a tandem duplication of phage DNA by a number of criteria. The location of the duplicated segment in each has been determined by electron microscopy of DNA hereroduplexes. The duplications are found to lie at random throughout the chromosome, with no preferential locations for endpoints. This rules out the possibility that duplications are formed by crossing-over at regions of homology on the phage chromosome.     

A selection system for unequal crossing-over: Plasmid construction and initial studies in Escherichia coli

Unequal crossing-over is involved in genetic duplication and deletion in such diverse genetic systems as Drosophila, bacteria, and animal viruses. It is proposed to be involved in the form of unequal sister chromatid exchange in gene amplification in cultured animal cells and during carcinogenesis. Studies of the process of unequal crossing-over have been hampered by the lack of genetic systems allowing specific selection for cells that have undergone such unequal crossing-over. We report here on the construction of plasmids designed to provide specific selection of unequal crossing-over. One such plasmid was studied in Escherichia coli. We show that kanamycin resistance is generated, as predicted, by the expected unequal crossover event.     

Genetic Structure and Internal Rearrangements of Stable Merodiploids from BACILLUS SUBTILIS Strains Carrying the trpE26 Mutation

Transformation and transduction to tryptophan independence of strains of Bacillus subtilis carrying the "trpE26" chromosomal aberrations (a translocation and an inversion) with a "normal" 168 type strain as donor induce a tandem duplication of the thrA-ilvA region of the chromosome. The clones possessing this unstable duplication segregate besides the Trp^- some stable Trp⁺ cells which retain only part of the duplication (the trpE-ilvA region) in nontandem configuration. Such clones may also be produced directly during the crosses. The genetic map of these clones (designated as class I stable merodiploids) was constructed: they possess the tranlocation and the inversion of the trpE26 parental strain. Another type of stable Trp⁺ clones (class II) also appears, although more rarely, in similar crosses. Studies on their genetic structure revealed that they are haploid for the trpE-ilvA region and carry a nontandem duplication of the thrA-trpE region. In these clones the cysB-tre region has the orientation of the 168 type strain. The duplications in both classes are stable, that of class I being more stable than that of class II where loss of one copy of the thrA-trpE region leads to about 1% haploid cells. Detailed genetic studies on heterozygous clones from both classes have shown exchange of alleles between copies of the nontandem duplications. Models are proposed for the formation of each class of merodiploids and for recombination events taking place in them. These models imply recombination at sequences of intrachromosomal homology and (or) introduction of heterologous juncions ("novel joints") by transformation or transduction.     

Tandem duplications of the histidine operon observed following generalized transduction in Salmonella typhimurium

Unstable merodiploid transductants may be observed among the progeny of certain generalized transductional crosses between complementing mutations in the histidine operon of Salmonella typhimurium. In the presence of a functional recombination system, these transductants are unstable and they segregate His^? clones of both parental genotypes. The properties of these His⁺ transductants suggest that they contain tandem duplications of a region of DNA which includes the histidine operon, such that each copy of the duplication contains one of the two complementing mutations involved in the transduction. Transductional duplications have been observed from 14 pairs of his mutations, but only with complementing pairs of parental mutations. The length of duplicated material may be quite large: two duplications were found to include genetic markers ten minutes removed from the histidine operon on the Salmonella chromosomal map.These transductants appear to arise in a subpopulation of recipient cells which contain pre-existing tandem duplications of the histidine operon. As much as 0.01 to 0.1% of the cell population appears to be tandemly duplicated for a chromosomal region which includes the histidine operon.     

The pericentromeric region of human chromosome 11: evidence for a chromosome-specific duplication

We have identified a chromosome duplication in the pericentromeric region of human chromosome 11 located in 11p11 and 11q14. A detailed physical map of each duplicated region was generated to describe the nature of the duplication, the involvement at the centromere and to resolve the correct maps. All clones were evaluated to ensure they were representative of their genetic origin. The order of clones, based on their marker content, as well as the distance covered was determined by SEGMAP. Each duplication encompasses more than 1 Mb of DNA and appears to be chromosome 11 specific. Ten STS markers were mapped within each duplication. Comparative sequence analysis along the duplication identified 35 nucleotide changes in 2,036 bp between the two copies, suggesting the duplication occurred over 14 million years ago. A suggested organization of the pericentromeric region, including the duplications and alpha-related repetitive sequences, is presented.     

Determining the order of genes,centromeres, and rearrangement breakpoints inNeurospora by tests of duplication coverage

Nontandem segmental duplications provide a useful alternative to conventional recombination mapping for determining gene order in a haploid organism such asNeurospora. When an insertional or terminal rearrangement is crossed by Normal sequence, a class of progeny is produced that have a precisely delimited chromosome segment duplicated. In such Duplication progeny, a recessive gene in the Normal-sequence donor chromosome may or may not be masked (“covered”) by its dominant wild-type allele in the translocation-sequence recipient chromosome. Coverage depends upon whether the gene in question is left or right of the rearrangement breakpoint. The recessive gene will be heterozygous and covered (not expressed) if its locus is within the duplicated segment, but it will be haploid and expressed if the locus is outside the segment. Not only genes but also centromeres can be mapped by means of duplications, because genes included in. the same viable duplication must reside in the same chromosome arm. - Numerous sequences in the current genetic maps ofN. crassa have been determined using duplications. Gene order in the albino region and in the centromere region of linkage group I provide examples. Over 50 insertional or terminal rearrangements are available from which nontandem duplications of defined content can be obtained at will; collectively these cover about 75% of the genome. - Intercrosses between partially overlapping chromosome rearrangements also produce Duplication progeny containing two copies of regions between the breakpoints. The 180 mapped reciprocal translocations and inversions include numerous overlapping combinations that can be used for duplication mapping.     

Study of chromosome rearrangements associated with the trpE26 mutation of Bacillus subtilis

Chromosome rearrangements involved in the formation of merodiploid strains in the Bacillus subtilis 168-166 system were explained by postulating the existence of intrachromosomal homology regions. This working hypothesis was tested by analysing sequences and restriction patterns of the, as yet uncharacterized, junctions between chromosome segments undergoing rearrangements in parent, 168 trpC2 and 166 trpE26, as well as in derived merodiploid strains. Identification, at the Ia/Ib chromosome junction of both parent strains, of a 1.3 kb segment nearly identical to a segment of prophage SPbeta established the existence of one of the postulated homology sequences. Inspection of relevant junctions revealed that a set of different homology regions, derived from prophage SPbeta, plays a key role in the formation of so-called trpE30, trpE30+, as well as of new class I merodiploids. Analysis of junctions involved in the transfer of the trpE26 mutation, i.e. simultaneous translocation of chromosome segment C and rotation of the terminal relative to the origin moiety of the chromosome, did not confirm the presence of any sequence suitable for homologous recombination. We propose a model involving simultaneous introduction of four donor DNA molecules, each comprising a different relevant junction, and their pairing with the junction regions of the recipient chromosome. The resolution of this structure, resting on homologous recombination, would confer the donor chromosome structure to the recipient, achieving some kind of 'transstamping'. In addition, a rather regular pattern of inverse and direct short sequence repeats in regions flanking the breaking points could be correlated with the initial, X-ray-induced, rearrangement.     

Role of gene duplication in evolution

It is now known that many multigene and supergene families exist in eukaryote genomes: multigene families with uniform copy members like genes for ribosomal RNA, those with variable members like immunoglobulin genes, and supergene families such as those for various growth factor and hormone receptors. Many such examples indicate that gene duplication and subsequent differentiation are extremely important for organismal evolution. In particular, gene duplication could well have been the primary mechanism for the evolution of complexity in higher organisms. Population genetic models for the origin of gene families with diverse functions are presented, in which natural selection favors those genomes with more useful mutants in duplicated genes. Since any gene has a certain probability of degenerating by mutation, success versus failure in acquiring a new gene by duplication may be expressed as the ratio of probabilities of spreading of useful versus detrimental mutations in redundant gene copies. Also examined are the effects of gene duplication on evolution by compensatory advantageous mutations. Results of the analyses show that both natural selection and random drift are important for the origin of gene families. In addition, interaction between molecular mechanisms such as unequal crossing-over and gene conversion, and selection or drift is found to have a large effect on evolution by gene duplication.     

An interstitial deletion in mouse Y chromosomal DNA created a transcribed Zfy fusion gene.

The small portion of the mouse Y chromosome retained in the Sxra transposition is thought to carry at least five genes including, as demonstrated here, the entirety of the zinc-finger genes Zfy-1 and Zfy-2. Sxrb, a derivative of Sxra, was previously thought to retain Zfy-1 but to be deleted for Zfy-2. Here we show that Sxrb differs from Sxra as the result of unequal crossing-over between Zfy-1 and Zfy-2. This unequal crossing-over created a transcribed Zfy-2/1 fusion gene and an interstitial deletion. Our data and previous results together suggest that this deletion encompassed the 3' portion of Zfy-2, the histocompatibility gene Hya, the spermatogenesis factor Spy, and the 5' portion of Zfy-1. We suggest that not only Zfy but also other neighboring genes such as Spy and Hya may exist in two copies on the Y as the result of a large tandem duplication during rodent evolution.     

Fate of Donor Deoxyribonucleic Acid in a Highly Transformation-Deficient Strain of Haemophilus influenzae

A transformation-deficient strain of Haemophilus influenzae (efficiency of transformation 10⁴-fold less than that of the wild type), designated TD24, was isolated by selection for sensitivity to mitomycin C. In its properties the mutant was equivalent to recA type mutants of Escherichia coli. The TD24 mutation was linked with the str-r marker (about 30%) and only weakly linked with the nov-r2.5 marker. The uptake of donor deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA) was normal in the TD24 strain, but no molecules with recombinant-type activity (molecules carrying both the donor and the resident marker) were formed. In the mutant the intracellular presynaptic fate of the donor DNA was the same as that in the transformation-proficient (wild-type) strain, and the radioactive label of the donor DNA associated covalently with the recipient chromosome in about the same quantity as in the wild type. However, many fewer donor atoms were associated with segments of the mutant's recipient chromosome as compared with segments of the wild-type chromosome. In the mutant the association was accompanied by complete loss of donor marker activity. The lack of donor marker activity of the donor-recipient complex of DNA isolated from the mutant was not due to lack of uptake of the complex by the second recipient and its inability to associate with the second recipient's chromosome. Because the number of donor-atom-carrying resident molecules was higher than could be accounted for by the lengths of presynaptic donor molecules, we favor the idea that the association of donor DNA atoms with the mutant chromosome results from local DNA synthesis rather than from dispersive integration of donor DNA by recombination.     

Evidence of Tandem Duplication of Genes in a Merodiploid Region of Pneumococcal Mutants Resistant to Sulfonamide

A Pneumococcal mutant, sulr-c, resistant to sulfonamides, and three transformants bearing associated d or d+ resistance markers have earlier been reported to be unstable and show distinct patterns and frequencies of segregating stable progeny lacking the c marker. Each of the four strains showed a characteristic dosage of the genes involved in the merodiploidy. Complementary strands of DNA's from these stable and unstable strains were resolved and homoduplex and heteroduplex hybrids made from the separated DNA strands were used as donors in genetic transformations. Activities of a normal marker (streptomycin resistance) and those involved in the heterozygosity (c, d and d+) were quantitatively measured. From those heteroduplexes made up of opposite strands derived from a heterozygote and a stable strain, the normal marker is transferred efficiently, but the heterozygous markers are not. On the other hand, if both strands of a heteroduplex are derived from different heterozygotic strains, all markers can be transferred with usual efficiency to a stable recipient strain. The lowered efficiency in the former type of heteroduplex is attributed to an inhomology resulting from a tandem duplication in the merodiploid strains, and a postulated DNA repair process stimulated by it while in the form of the donor duplex. The inhomology probably includes (a) a microheterogeneity between the c site and the wild type locus, and (b) a more extensive incompatibility attributable to an extra segment of genome in a tandem duplication covering the c and d sites. The first of these inhomologies produces a lowered efficiency of transfer from all configurations of the particular d allele associated with the mutant c marker, and therefore accounts for the characteristic transfer patterns even from the native merodiploid DNA's.     

The G4 gene is duplicated in 44% of human immunoglobulin heavy chain constant region haplotypes

The structure of the human immunoglobulin heavy chain constant region (IGHC), on chromosome 14q32, comprises nine CH genes and two pseudogenes, all originating from multiple duplication events. Continuing evolution of the region is demonstrated by the finding of various types of duplicated and deleted haplotypes, which together add up to 6%. Here we provide molecular and genetic evidence that the G4 gene is duplicated in 44% of IGHC haplotypes in the Italian population. The duplication spans about 20 kb of genomic DNA and probably originated through unequal crossing over. Refined characterisation of the genomic region downstream from the G4 gene improves our knowledge of the evolutionary history of CH genes. Received: 4 December 1996 / Accepted: 10 February 1997     

Pulsed-field electrophoresis screening for immunoglobulin heavy-chain constant-region (IGHC) multigene deletions and duplications.

Genome regions containing multiple copies of homologous genes, such as the immunoglobulin (Ig) heavy-chain constant-region (IGHC) locus, are often unstable and give rise to duplicated and deleted haplotypes. Analysis of such processes is fundamental to understanding the mechanisms of evolution of multigene families. In the IGHC region, a number of single and multiple gene deletions, derived from either unequal crossing-over or looping-out excision, have been described. To study these haplotypes at the population level, a simple and efficient method for preparing large numbers of DNA samples suitable for pulsed-field gel electrophoresis (PFGE) analysis was set up, and a sample of 110 blood donors was screened. Deletions were found to be frequent, as expected on the basis of previous serological surveys for homozygotes. Furthermore, a number of multigene duplications, never identified before, were detected. The total frequency of individuals bearing rearranged IGHC haplotypes was 10%. The genes involved in these deletions and duplications were assessed by densitometric analysis of standard Southern blots hybridized with several IGHC probes; two types of deletion and two types of duplication could thus be characterized. These data provide further evidence of the instability of the IGHC locus and demonstrate that unequal crossing-over is the most likely origin of rearranged IGHC haplotypes; they also suggest that such recombination events may be relatively frequent. Moreover, the simplicity and effectiveness of the large-scale PFGE screening approach will be of great help in the study of multigene families and of other loci involved in aberrant recombinations.