The ubiquitin landscape at DNA double-strand breaks

The intimate relationship between DNA double-strand break (DSB) repair and cancer susceptibility has sparked profound interest in how transactions on DNA and chromatin surrounding DNA damage influence genome integrity. Recent evidence implicates a substantial commitment of the cellular DNA damage response machinery to the synthesis, recognition, and hydrolysis of ubiquitin chains at DNA damage sites. In this review, we propose that, in order to accommodate parallel processes involved in DSB repair and checkpoint signaling, DSB-associated ubiquitin structures must be nonuniform, using different linkages for distinct functional outputs. We highlight recent advances in the study of nondegradative ubiquitin signaling at DSBs, and discuss how recognition of different ubiquitin structures may influence DNA damage responses.     

The ubiquitin- and SUMO-dependent signaling response to DNA double-strand breaks

DNA double-strand breaks (DSBs) represent the most destructive type of chromosomal lesion and trigger rapid chromatin restructuring accompanied by accumulation of proteins in the vicinity of the DSB. Non-proteolytic ubiquitylation of chromatin surrounding DSBs, mediated by the RNF8/RNF168 ubiquitin ligase cascade, has emerged as a key mechanism for restoration of genome integrity by licensing the DSB-modified chromatin to concentrate genome caretaker proteins such as 53BP1 and BRCA1 near the lesions. In parallel, SUMOylation of upstream DSB regulators is also required for execution of this ubiquitin-dependent chromatin response, but its molecular basis is currently unclear. Here, we discuss recent insights into how ubiquitin- and SUMO-dependent signaling processes cooperate to orchestrate protein interactions with sites of DNA damage to facilitate DSB repair.     

Lyn tyrosine kinase promotes silencing of ATM-dependent checkpoint signaling during recovery from DNA double-strand breaks

DNA damage activates the DNA damage checkpoint and the DNA repair machinery. After initial activation of DNA damage responses, cells recover to their original states through completion of DNA repair and termination of checkpoint signaling. Currently, little is known about the process by which cells recover from the DNA damage checkpoint, a process called checkpoint recovery. Here, we show that Src family kinases promote inactivation of ataxia telangiectasia mutated (ATM)-dependent checkpoint signaling during recovery from DNA double-strand breaks. Inhibition of Src activity increased ATM-dependent phosphorylation of Chk2 and Kap1. Src inhibition increased ATM signaling both in G2 phase and during asynchronous growth. shRNA knockdown of Lyn increased ATM signaling. Src-dependent nuclear tyrosine phosphorylation suppressed ATM-mediated Kap1 phosphorylation. These results suggest that Src family kinases are involved in upstream signaling that leads to inactivation of the ATM-dependent DNA damage checkpoint.     

RNF8 ubiquitylates histones at DNA double-strand breaks and promotes assembly of repair proteins

Accumulation of repair proteins on damaged chromosomes is required to restore genomic integrity. However, the mechanisms of protein retention at the most destructive chromosomal lesions, the DNA double-strand breaks (DSBs), are poorly understood. We show that RNF8, a RING-finger ubiquitin ligase, rapidly assembles at DSBs via interaction of its FHA domain with the phosphorylated adaptor protein MDC1. This is accompanied by an increase in DSB-associated ubiquitylations and followed by accumulation of 53BP1 and BRCA1 repair proteins. Knockdown of RNF8 or disruption of its FHA or RING domains impaired DSB-associated ubiquitylation and inhibited retention of 53BP1 and BRCA1 at the DSB sites. In addition, we show that RNF8 can ubiquitylate histone H2A and H2AX, and that its depletion sensitizes cells to ionizing radiation. These data suggest that MDC1-mediated and RNF8-executed histone ubiquitylation protects genome integrity by licensing the DSB-flanking chromatin to concentrate repair factors near the DNA lesions.     

DNA damage signaling in response to double-strand breaks during mitosis

The signaling cascade initiated in response to DNA double-strand breaks (DSBs) has been extensively investigated in interphase cells. Here, we show that mitotic cells treated with DSB-inducing agents activate a “primary” DNA damage response (DDR) comprised of early signaling events, including activation of the protein kinases ataxia telangiectasia mutated (ATM) and DNA-dependent protein kinase (DNA-PK), histone H2AX phosphorylation together with recruitment of mediator of DNA damage checkpoint 1 (MDC1), and the Mre11–Rad50–Nbs1 (MRN) complex to damage sites. However, mitotic cells display no detectable recruitment of the E3 ubiquitin ligases RNF8 and RNF168, or accumulation of 53BP1 and BRCA1, at DSB sites. Accordingly, we found that DNA-damage signaling is attenuated in mitotic cells, with full DDR activation only ensuing when a DSB-containing mitotic cell enters G1. Finally, we present data suggesting that induction of a primary DDR in mitosis is important because transient inactivation of ATM and DNA-PK renders mitotic cells hypersensitive to DSB-inducing agents.     

RB signaling prevents replication-dependent DNA double-strand breaks following genotoxic insult

Cell cycle checkpoints induced by DNA damage play an integral role in preservation of genomic stability by allowing cells to limit the propagation of deleterious mutations. The retinoblastoma tumor suppressor (RB) is crucial for the maintenance of the DNA damage checkpoint function because it elicits cell cycle arrest in response to a variety of genotoxic stresses. Although sporadic loss of RB is characteristic of most cancers and results in the bypass of the DNA damage checkpoint, the consequence of RB loss upon chemotherapeutic responsiveness has been largely uninvestigated. Here, we employed a conditional knockout approach to ablate RB in adult fibroblasts. This system enabled us to examine the DNA damage response of adult cells following acute RB deletion. Using this system, we demonstrated that loss of RB disrupted the DNA damage checkpoint elicited by either cisplatin or camptothecin exposure. Strikingly, this bypass was not associated with enhanced repair, but rather the accumulation of phosphorylated H2AX (γH2AX) foci, which indicate DNA double-strand breaks. The formation of γH2AX foci was due to ongoing replication following chemotherapeutic treatment in the RB-deficient cells. Additionally, peak γH2AX accumulation occurred in S-phase cells undergoing DNA replication in the presence of damage, and these γH2AX foci co-localized with replication foci. These results demonstrate that acute RB loss abrogates DNA damage-induced cell cycle arrest to induce γH2AX foci formation. Thus, secondary genetic lesions induced by RB loss have implications for the chemotherapeutic response and the development of genetic instability.     

SCF ubiquitin E3 ligase regulates DNA double-strand breaks in early meiotic recombination

Homeostasis of meiotic DNA double strand breaks (DSB) is critical for germline genome integrity and homologous recombination. Here we demonstrate an essential role for SKP1, a constitutive subunit of the SCF (SKP1-Cullin-F-box) ubiquitin E3 ligase, in early meiotic processes. SKP1 restrains accumulation of HORMAD1 and the pre-DSB complex (IHO1-REC114-MEI4) on the chromosome axis in meiotic germ cells. Loss of SKP1 prior to meiosis leads to aberrant localization of DSB repair proteins and a failure in synapsis initiation in meiosis of both males and females. Furthermore, SKP1 is crucial for sister chromatid cohesion during the pre-meiotic S-phase. Mechanistically, FBXO47, a meiosis-specific F-box protein, interacts with SKP1 and HORMAD1 and targets HORMAD1 for polyubiquitination and degradation in HEK293T cells. Our results support a model wherein the SCF ubiquitin E3 ligase prevents hyperactive DSB formation through proteasome-mediated degradation of HORMAD1 and subsequent modulation of the pre-DSB complex during meiosis.     

The cellular control of DNA double-strand breaks

DNA double-strand breaks (DSBs) are the most hazardous lesions arising in the genome of eukaryotic organisms, and yet occur normally during DNA replication, meiosis, and immune system development. The efficient repair of DSBs is crucial in maintaining genomic integrity, cellular viability, and the prevention of tumorigenesis. As a consequence, eukaryotic cells have evolved efficient mechanisms that sense and respond to DSBs and ultimately repair the break. The swiftness of the DNA DSB response has paved to the identification of sensors and transducers which allowed to generate a hierarchical signaling paradigm depicting the transduction of the damage signal to numerous downstream effectors (Fig. 1). The function of such effectors involve posttranslational modifications through phosphorylation, acetylation, and methylation of the substrates. This review will address the control of DSBs in damaged eukaryotic cells, the physiological processes that require the introduction of a DSB into the genome, and the maintenance of DSBs in non-damaged cells.     

ATM-dependent ERK signaling via AKT in response to DNA double-strand breaks

Ionizing radiation (IR) triggers many signaling pathways primarily originating from either damaged DNA or non-nuclear sources such as growth factor receptors. Thus, to study the DNA damage-induced signaling component alone by irradiation would be a challenge. To generate DNA double-strand breaks (DSBs) and minimize non-nuclear signaling, human cancer cells having bromodeoxyuridine (BrdU) - substituted DNA were treated with the photosensitizer Hoechst 33258 followed by long wavelength UV (UV-A) treatment (BrdU photolysis). BrdU photolysis resulted in well-controlled, dose- dependent generation of DSBs equivalent to radiation doses between 0.2 - 20 Gy, as determined by pulsed-field gel electrophoresis, and accompanied by dose-dependent ATM (ser-1981), H2AX (ser-139), Chk2 (thr-68), and p53 (ser-15) phosphorylation. Interestingly, low levels (≤2 Gy equivalents) of BrdU photolysis stimulated ERK phosphorylation whereas higher (>2 Gy eq.) resulted in ERK dephosphorylation. ERK phosphorylation was ATM-dependent whereas dephosphorylation was ATM-independent. The ATM-dependent increase in ERK phosphorylation was also seen when DSBs were generated by transfection of cells with an EcoRI expression plasmid or by electroporation of EcoRI enzyme. Furthermore, AKT was critical for transmitting the DSB signal to ERK. Altogether, our results show that low levels of DSBs trigger ATM- and AKT-dependent ERK pro-survival signaling and increased cell proliferation whereas higher levels result in ERK dephosphorylation consistent with a dose-dependent switch from pro-survival to anti-survival signaling.     

ATM-dependent ERK signaling via AKT in response to DNA double-strand breaks

Ionizing radiation (IR) triggers many signaling pathways primarily originating from either damaged DNA or non-nuclear sources such as growth factor receptors. Thus, to study the DNA damage-induced signaling component alone by irradiation would be a challenge. To generate DNA double-strand breaks (DSBs) and minimize non-nuclear signaling, human cancer cells having bromodeoxyuridine (BrdU)—substituted DNA were treated with the photosensitizer Hoechst 33258 followed by long wavelength UV (UV-A) treatment (BrdU photolysis). BrdU photolysis resulted in well-controlled, dose-dependent generation of DSBs equivalent to radiation doses between 0.2–20 Gy, as determined by pulsed-field gel electrophoresis and accompanied by dose-dependent ATM (ser-1981), H2AX (ser-139), Chk2 (thr-68) and p53 (ser15) phosphorylation. Interestingly, low levels (≤2 Gy equivalents) of BrdU photolysis stimulated ERK phosphorylation whereas higher (>2 Gy eq.) resulted in ERK dephosphorylation. ERK phosphorylation was ATM-dependent whereas dephosphorylation was ATM-independent. The ATM-dependent increase in ERK phosphorylation was also seen when DSBs were generated by transfection of cells with an EcoRI expression plasmid or by electroporation of EcoRI enzyme. Furthermore, AKT was critical for transmitting the DSB signal to ERK. Altogether, our results show that low levels of DSBs trigger ATM- and AKT-dependent ERK pro-survival signaling and increased cell proliferation whereas higher levels result in ERK dephosphorylation consistent with a dose-dependent switch from pro-survival to anti-survival signaling.Key words: bromodeoxyuridine, DNA repair, MAP kinase, p53, KU-55933, U87 glioma cells     

DNA double-strand breaks and gamma-H2AX signaling in the testis

Within minutes of the induction of DNA double-strand breaks in somatic cells, histone H2AX becomes phosphorylated at serine 139 and forms gamma-H2AX foci at the sites of damage. These foci then play a role in recruiting DNA repair and damage-response factors and changing chromatin structure to accurately repair the damaged DNA. These gamma-H2AX foci appear in response to irradiation and genotoxic stress and during V(D)J recombination and meiotic recombination. Independent of irradiation, gamma-H2AX occurs in all intermediate and B spermatogonia and in preleptotene to zygotene spermatocytes. Type A spermatogonia and round spermatids do not exhibit gamma-H2AX foci but show homogeneous nuclear gamma-H2AX staining, whereas in pachytene spermatocytes gamma-H2AX is only present in the sex vesicle. In response to ionizing radiation, gamma-H2AX foci are generated in spermatogonia, spermatocytes, and round spermatids. In irradiated spermatogonia, gamma-H2AX interacts with p53, which induces spermatogonial apoptosis. These events are independent of the DNA-dependent protein kinase (DNA-PK). Irradiation-independent nuclear gamma-H2AX staining in leptotene spermatocytes demonstrates a function for gamma-H2AX during meiosis. gamma-H2AX staining in intermediate and B spermatogonia, preleptotene spermatocytes, and sex vesicles and round spermatids, however, indicates that the function of H2AX phosphorylation during spermatogenesis is not restricted to the formation of gamma-H2AX foci at DNA double-strand breaks.     

Capture of extranuclear DNA at fission yeast double-strand breaks

Proper repair of DNA double-strand breaks (DSBs) is necessary for the maintenance of genomic integrity. Here, a new simple assay was used to study extrachromosomal DSB repair in Schizosaccharomyces pombe. Strikingly, DSB repair was associated with the capture of fission yeast mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) at high frequency. Capture of mtDNA fragments required the Lig4p/Pku70p nonhomologous end-joining (NHEJ) machinery and its frequency was highly increased in fission yeast cells grown to stationary phase. The fission yeast Mre11 complex Rad32p/Rad50p/Nbs1p was also required for efficient capture of mtDNA at DSBs, supporting a role for the complex in promoting intermolecular ligation. Competition assays further revealed that microsatellite DNA from higher eukaryotes was preferentially captured at yeast DSBs. Finally, cotransformation experiments indicated that, in NHEJ-deficient cells, capture of extranuclear DNA at DSBs was observed if homologies--as short as 8 bp--were present between DNA substrate and DSB ends. Hence, whether driven by NHEJ, microhomology-mediated end-joining, or homologous recombination, DNA capture associated with DSB repair is a mutagenic process threatening genomic stability.     

DNA-PKcs-dependent phosphorylation of RECQL4 promotes NHEJ by stabilizing the NHEJ machinery at DNA double-strand breaks

Non-homologous end joining (NHEJ) is the major pathway that mediates the repair of DNA double-strand breaks (DSBs) generated by ionizing radiation (IR). Previously, the DNA helicase RECQL4 was implicated in promoting NHEJ, but its role in the pathway remains unresolved. In this study, we report that RECQL4 stabilizes the NHEJ machinery at DSBs to promote repair. Specifically, we find that RECQL4 interacts with the NHEJ core factor DNA-PK_cs and the interaction is increased following IR. RECQL4 promotes DNA end bridging mediated by DNA-PK_cs and Ku70/80 in vitro and the accumulation/retention of NHEJ factors at DSBs in vivo. Moreover, interaction between DNA-PK_cs and the other core NHEJ proteins following IR treatment is attenuated in the absence of RECQL4. These data indicate that RECQL4 promotes the stabilization of the NHEJ factors at DSBs to support formation of the NHEJ long-range synaptic complex. In addition, we observed that the kinase activity of DNA-PK_cs is required for accumulation of RECQL4 to DSBs and that DNA-PK_cs phosphorylates RECQL4 at six serine/threonine residues. Blocking phosphorylation at these sites reduced the recruitment of RECQL4 to DSBs, attenuated the interaction between RECQL4 and NHEJ factors, destabilized interactions between the NHEJ machinery, and resulted in decreased NHEJ. Collectively, these data illustrate reciprocal regulation between RECQL4 and DNA-PK_cs in NHEJ.     

MRE11 promotes AKT phosphorylation in direct response to DNA double-strand breaks

AKT is hyper-activated in many human cancers and promotes proliferation and cancer cell survival in response to DNA damaging agents. Ionizing radiation (IR) produces DNA double strand breaks (DSB) and activates AKT, however a direct mechanism linking intra-nuclear DSB and AKT signaling is lacking. Here we demonstrate that AKT is phosphorylated following IR in benign and malignant cells and, using colony-forming assays and in vitro rejoining assays, show that AKT promotes non-homologous end joining-mediated DSB repair and cell survival following IR. Further studies revealed that pAKT-S473, but not pAKT-T308 or total AKT, accumulates in the vicinity of IR-induced DSB and co-localizes with γH2AX and ATM-pSer1981. Based on whole-cell IR, nuclear UV microbeam, and endonuclease-induced DSB studies, we observed that pAKT-S473 is up-regulated by a DSB-induced signaling cascade, and this is dependent on the DSB sensor protein, MRE11. MRE11-dependent pAKT-S473 did not require the MRE11 endonuclease domain. The histone ubiquitin ligase RNF168 is also required for DSB-induced pAKT-S473, and DSB-induced pAKT-S473 is independent of DNA-PKcs, PI3K, and ATR. These data demonstrate that DSB activate a signaling cascade that directly promotes a PI3K-independent pathway of AKT phosphorylation that is dependent on MRE11-ATM-RNF168 signaling. Thus, these data directly link the presence of DNA breaks to AKT-mediated cell survival and support AKT as a target for cancer therapy.     

DNA mismatch repair-induced double-strand breaks

Escherichia coli dam mutants are sensitized to the cytotoxic action of base analogs, cisplatin and N-methyl-N'-nitro-N-nitrosoguanidine (MNNG), while their mismatch repair (MMR)-deficient derivatives are tolerant to these agents. We showed previously, using pulse field gel electrophoresis (PFGE), that MMR-mediated double-strand breaks (DSBs) are produced by cisplatin in dam recB(Ts) cells at the non-permissive temperature. We demonstrate here that the majority of these DSBs require DNA replication for their formation, consistent with a model in which replication forks collapse at nicks or gaps formed during MMR. DSBs were also detected in dam recB(Ts) ada ogt cells exposed to MNNG in a dose- and MMR-dependent manner. In contrast to cisplatin, the formation of these DSBs was not affected by DNA replication and it is proposed that two separate mechanisms result in DSB formation. Replication-independent DSBs arise from overlapping base excision and MMR repair tracts on complementary strands and constitute the majority of detectable DSBs in dam recB(Ts) ada ogt cells exposed to MNNG. Replication-dependent DSBs result from replication fork collapse at O(6)-methylguanine (O(6)-meG) base pairs undergoing MMR futile cycling and are more likely to contribute to cytotoxicity. This model is consistent with the observation that fast-growing dam recB(Ts) ada ogt cells, which have more chromosome replication origins, are more sensitive to the cytotoxic effect of MNNG than the same cells growing slowly.     

When cleavage is not attractive: non-catalytic inhibition of ubiquitin chains at DNA double-strand breaks by OTUB1

Non-degradative ubiquitylation plays a crucial role in many cellular signaling pathways, including the DNA damage response. Two ubiquitin ligases, RNF8 and RNF168, in combination with the E2 ubiquitin conjugating enzyme UBC13 catalyze the formation of K63-linked ubiquitin chains at sites of DNA double-strand breaks to promote their faithful repair. However, little is known about their negative regulation. A recent study identifies a deubiquitylating enzyme, OTUB1, which counteracts RNF8/RNF168-dependent ubiquitin chain formation at break sites. Surprisingly, this enzyme carries out its function not by cleavage of polyubiquitin chains, but by targeting UBC13. This non-canonical role for a deubiquitylating enzyme has implications for the regulation of ubiquitylation not just in DNA repair, but potentially in many other cellular signaling processes.     

Metastasis suppressor NME1 promotes non-homologous end joining of DNA double-strand breaks

NME1 (also known as NM23-H1) was the first identified tumor metastasis suppressor, which has been reported to link with genomic stability maintenance and cancer. However its underlying mechanisms are still not fully understood. Here we find that NME1 is required for non-homologous end joining (NHEJ) of DNA double-strand breaks (DSBs). Mechanistically, NME1 re-localizes to DNA damage sites in a Ku-XRCC4-dependent manner, and regulates downstream LIG4 recruitment and end joining efficiency. Furthermore, we show that the 3′-5′ exonuclease activity of NME1 is critical for its function in NHEJ. Taken together, our findings identify NME1 as a novel NHEJ factor, and reveal how this metastasis suppressor promotes genome stability.     

Novel highly selective inhibitors of ubiquitin specific protease 30 (USP30) accelerate mitophagy

Mitophagy is one of the processes that cells use to maintain overall health. An E3 ligase, parkin, ubiquitinates mitochondrial proteins prior to their degradation by autophagasomes. USP30 is an enzyme that de-ubiquitinates mitochondrial proteins; therefore, inhibiting this enzyme could foster mitophagy. Herein, we disclose the structure–activity relationships (SAR) within a novel series of highly selective USP30 inhibitors. Two structurally similar compounds, MF-094 (a potent and selective USP30 inhibitor) and MF-095 (a significantly less potent USP30 inhibitor), serve as useful controls for biological evaluation. We show that MF-094 increases protein ubiquitination and accelerates mitophagy.