Membrane topology of transmembrane proteins: determinants and experimental tools

Membrane topology refers to the two-dimensional structural information of a membrane protein that indicates the number of transmembrane (TM) segments and the orientation of soluble domains relative to the plane of the membrane. Since membrane proteins are co-translationally translocated across and inserted into the membrane, the TM segments orient themselves properly in an early stage of membrane protein biogenesis. Each membrane protein must contain some topogenic signals, but the translocation components and the membrane environment also influence the membrane topology of proteins. We discuss the factors that affect membrane protein orientation and have listed available experimental tools that can be used in determining membrane protein topology.     

A single negatively charged residue affects the orientation of a membrane protein in the inner membrane of Escherichia coli only when it is located adjacent to a transmembrane domain

The orientation of membrane proteins is determined by the asymmetric distribution of charged residues in the sequences flanking the transmembrane domains. For the inner membrane of Escherichia coli, numerous studies have shown that an excess of positively charged residues defines a cytoplasmic domain of a membrane protein ("positive inside" rule). The role of negatively charged residues in establishing membrane protein topology, however, is not completely understood. To investigate the influence of negatively charged residues on this process in detail, we have constructed a single spanning chimeric receptor fragment comprising the N terminus and first transmembrane domain of the heptahelical G protein-coupled vasopressin V(2) receptor and the first cytoplasmic loop of the beta(2)-adrenergic receptor. When fused to alkaline phosphatase (PhoA), the receptor fragment inserted into the inner membrane of E. coli with its N terminus facing the cytoplasm (N(in)-C(out) orientation), although both membrane-flanking domains had rather similar topogenic determinants. The orientation of the receptor fragment was changed after the introduction of single glutamate residues into the N terminus. Orientation inversion, however, was found to be dependent on the location of the glutamate substitutions, which had to lie within a narrow window up to 6 residues distant from the transmembrane domain. These results demonstrate that a single negatively charged residue can play an active role as a topogenic determinant of membrane proteins in the inner membrane of E. coli, but only if it is located adjacent to a transmembrane domain.     

Genetic analysis of the membrane insertion and topology of MalF, a cytoplasmic membrane protein of Escherichia coli

MalF is an essential cytoplasmic membrane protein of the maltose transport system of Escherichia coli. We have developed a general approach for analysis of the mechanism of integration of membrane proteins and their membrane topology by characterizing a series of fusions of beta-galactosidase to MalF. The properties of the fusion proteins indicate the following. (1) The first two presumed transmembrane segments of MalF are sufficient to anchor beta-galactosidase firmly to the inner membrane. (2) Hybrid proteins with beta-galactosidase fused to a presumed cytoplasmic domain of MalF have high beta-galactosidase specific activity; fusions to periplasmic domains have low activity. We propose therefore, that periplasmic and cytoplasmic domains of integral membrane proteins can be distinguished by the enzymatic properties of such hybrid proteins. In general, it appears that cleaved or non-cleaved signal sequences when attached to beta-galactosidase cause it to become embedded in the membrane, and this results in the inability of the hybrid proteins to assemble into active enzyme. Additional properties of these fusion proteins contribute to our understanding of the regulation of MalF synthesis. The MalF protein, synthesized as part of the malEFG operon of E. coli, is approximately 30-fold less abundant in the cell than MalE protein (the maltose-binding protein). Differential amounts of the fusion proteins indicate that a regulatory signal occurs within the malF gene that is responsible for the step-down in expression from the malE gene to the malF gene.     

Proper insertion of a complex membrane protein in the absence of its amino-terminal export signal

The MalF protein spans the Escherichia coli cytoplasmic membrane eight times. Deletion of the first transmembrane stretch of MalF, which acts as an export signal, results in a truncated protein that still exhibits high levels of maltose transport activity. These and additional results indicate that the orientation of a membrane protein is not determined by the amino-terminal export signal, topological information is distributed throughout the MalF protein, and insertion of a protein into the cytoplasmic membrane can occur nonsequentially.     

Subcellular localization and membrane topology of the melon ethylene receptor CmERS1

Ethylene receptors are multispanning membrane proteins that negatively regulate ethylene responses via the formation of a signaling complex with downstream elements. To better understand their biochemical functions, we investigated the membrane topology and subcellular localization of CmERS1, a melon (Cucumis melo) ethylene receptor that has three putative transmembrane domains at the N terminus. Analyses using membrane fractionation and green fluorescent protein imaging approaches indicate that CmERS1 is predominantly associated with the endoplasmic reticulum (ER) membrane. Detergent treatments of melon microsomes showed that the receptor protein is integrally bound to the ER membrane. A protease protection assay and N-glycosylation analysis were used to determine membrane topology. The results indicate that CmERS1 spans the membrane three times, with its N terminus facing the luminal space and the large C-terminal portion lying on the cytosolic side of the ER membrane. This orientation provides a platform for interaction with the cytosolic signaling elements. The three N-terminal transmembrane segments were found to function as topogenic sequences to determine the final topology. High conservation of these topogenic sequences in all ethylene receptor homologs identified thus far suggests that these proteins may share the same membrane topology.     

TRAP assists membrane protein topogenesis at the mammalian ER membrane

Membrane protein insertion and topogenesis generally occur at the Sec61 translocon in the endoplasmic reticulum membrane. During this process, membrane spanning segments may adopt two distinct orientations with either their N- or C-terminus translocated into the ER lumen. While different topogenic determinants in membrane proteins, such as flanking charges, polypeptide folding, and hydrophobicity, have been identified, it is not well understood how the translocon and/or associated components decode them. Here we present evidence that the translocon-associated protein (TRAP) complex is involved in membrane protein topogenesis in vivo. Small interfering RNA (siRNA)-mediated silencing of the TRAP complex in HeLa cells enhanced the topology effect of mutating the flanking charges of a signal-anchor, but not of increasing signal hydrophobicity. The results suggest a role of the TRAP complex in moderating the ‘positive-inside’ rule.     

Transmembrane domain analysis of polycystin-1, the product of the polycystic kidney disease-1 (PKD1) gene: evidence for 11 membrane-spanning domains

Polycystin-1, the protein product of the polycystic kidney disease-1 (PKD1) gene, was originally predicted to be an integral membrane glycoprotein with 11 transmembrane (TM) domains (TM 1-11). Subsequent comparative sequence analyses led to a revision of the original model, which retained the overall topology and 11 TM segments (TM I-XI) but dropped 3 of the original domains and introduced 3 new TM domains. The membrane-spanning potential and the orientation of each of the proposed TM domains following the extracellular REJ domain (TM I-XI and TM 11) have now been tested. Using a series of N-terminal polycystin TM-glycosylation reporter gene fusions expressed in vivo, we assayed N-linked glycosylation of the C-terminal glycosylation reporter as an indicator of TM domain presence and orientation. This approach has clearly demonstrated that 7 of the 12 TM domains tested function as membrane-spanning domains. In vitro analysis of the topogenic potential of the five remaining TM domains revealed that four of these also function as membrane-spanning domains, thus supporting an 11 TM structure for polycystin-1 comprised of TM domains I-XI. In addition, these studies suggest that the membrane insertion of TM domains I-IX occurs in a cotranslational and sequential manner, while multiple topogenic determinants appear to be required for the integration of the C-terminal-most TM segments of polycystin-1.     

Topology of the retinal cone NCKX2 Na/Ca-K exchanger

The Na/Ca-K exchanger (NCKX) is a polytopic membrane protein that plays a critical role in Ca(2+) homeostasis in retinal rod and cone photoreceptors. The NCKX1 isoform is found in rods, while the NCKX2 isoform is found in cones, in retinal ganglion cells, and in various parts of the brain. The topology of the Na/Ca-K exchanger is thought to consist of two large hydrophilic loops and two sets of transmembrane spanning segments (TMs). The first large hydrophilic loop is located extracellularly at the N-terminus; the other is cytoplasmic and separates the two sets of TMs. The TMs consist of either five and five membrane spanning helices or five and six membrane spanning helices, depending upon the predictive algorithm used. Little specific information is yet available on the orientation of the various membrane spanning helices and the localization of the short loops connecting these helices. In this study, we have determined which of the connecting loops are exposed to the extracellular milieu using two different methods: accessibility of substituted cysteine residues and insertion of N-glycosylation sites. The two methods resulted in a consistent NCKX topology in which the two sets of TMs each contain five membrane spanning helices. Our new model places what was previously membrane spanning helix six in the cytoplasm, which places the C-terminus on the extracellular surface. Surprisingly, this NCKX topology model is different from the current NCX topology model with respect to the C-terminal three membrane helices.     

Membrane protein spanning segments as export signals.

Escherichia coli lac permease is a polytopic integral membrane protein with six translocated (periplasmic) domains. Individual N-terminal cytoplasmic regions and membrane-spanning segments adjacent to each of the periplasmic domains acted as export signals for an attached sensor protein (alkaline phosphatase). However, the export activity of one of the spanning segments was considerably lower than that of the others, and was limited by the presence of a positively charged residue (Arg302). These observations are compatible with models of membrane protein insertion in which hydrophilic domains are translocated independently. However, the results suggest that efficient translocation may sometimes require interaction between individual spanning segments.     

The topological analysis of integral cytoplasmic membrane proteins

Summary We review three general approaches to determining the topology of integral cytoplasmic membrane proteins. (i) Inspection of the amino acid sequence and use of algorithms to predict membrane spanning segments allows the construction of topological models. For many proteins, the mere identification of such segments and an analysis of the distribution of basic amino acids in hydrophilic domains leads to correct structure predictions. For others, additional factors must come into play in determining topology, (ii) Gene fusion analysis of membrane proteins, in many cases, leads to complete topological models. Such analyses have been carried out in both bacteria and in the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae. Conflicts between results from gene fusion analysis and other approaches can be used to explore details of the process of membrane protein assembly. For instance, anomalies in gene fusion studies contributed evidence for the important role of basic amino acids in determining topolog. (iii) Biochemical probes and the site of natural biochemical modifications of membrane proteins give information on their topology. Chemical modifiers, proteases and antibodies made to different domains of a membrane protein can identify which segments of the protein are in the cytoplasm and which are on the extracytoplasmic side of the membrane. Sites of such modifications as glycosylation and phosphorylation help to specify the location of particular hydrophilic domains. The advantages and limitations of these methods are discussed.This work was supported by a fellowship from the National Institute of General Medical Sciences to B.T., by a grant from the National Science Foundation to D.B. and by a grant from the National Institutes of Health to J.B.. J.B. is an American Cancer Society Research Professor.     

Structure-function study of MalF protein by random mutagenesis

MalF is one of the two integral inner membrane proteins of the maltose-maltodextrin transport system. To identify functional regions in this protein, we characterized a collection of malF mutants obtained by random mutagenesis. We analyzed their growth on maltose and maltodextrins, the steady-state levels and subcellular localization of the mutant proteins, and the subcellular localization of MalK. Only 2 of the 21 MalF mutant proteins allowed growth on maltose and maltodextrins. Most mutations resulting in immunodetectable proteins mapped to hydrophilic domains, indicating that insertions affecting transmembrane segments gave rise to unstable or lethal proteins. All MalF mutant proteins, even those C-terminally truncated or with large N-terminal deletions, were inserted into the cytoplasmic membrane. Having identified mutations leading to reduced steady-state level, to partial mislocation, and/or to misfolding, we were able to assign to some regions of MalF a role in the assembly of the MalFGK2 complex and/or in the transport mechanism.     

Membrane topology and insertion of membrane proteins: search for topogenic signals.

Integral membrane proteins are found in all cellular membranes and carry out many of the functions that are essential to life. The membrane-embedded domains of integral membrane proteins are structurally quite simple, allowing the use of various prediction methods and biochemical methods to obtain structural information about membrane proteins. A critical step in the biosynthetic pathway leading to the folded protein in the membrane is its insertion into the lipid bilayer. Understanding of the fundamentals of the insertion and folding processes will significantly improve the methods used to predict the three-dimensional membrane protein structure from the amino acid sequence. In the first part of this review, biochemical approaches to elucidate membrane protein topology are reviewed and evaluated, and in the second part, the use of similar techniques to study membrane protein insertion is discussed. The latter studies search for signals in the polypeptide chain that direct the insertion process. Knowledge of the topogenic signals in the nascent chain of a membrane protein is essential for the evaluation of membrane topology studies.     

Membrane Topology and Insertion of Membrane Proteins: Search for Topogenic Signals

Integral membrane proteins are found in all cellular membranes and carry out many of the functions that are essential to life. The membrane-embedded domains of integral membrane proteins are structurally quite simple, allowing the use of various prediction methods and biochemical methods to obtain structural information about membrane proteins. A critical step in the biosynthetic pathway leading to the folded protein in the membrane is its insertion into the lipid bilayer. Understanding of the fundamentals of the insertion and folding processes will significantly improve the methods used to predict the three-dimensional membrane protein structure from the amino acid sequence. In the first part of this review, biochemical approaches to elucidate membrane protein topology are reviewed and evaluated, and in the second part, the use of similar techniques to study membrane protein insertion is discussed. The latter studies search for signals in the polypeptide chain that direct the insertion process. Knowledge of the topogenic signals in the nascent chain of a membrane protein is essential for the evaluation of membrane topology studies.     

Biotinylation in vivo as a sensitive indicator of protein secretion and membrane protein insertion.

Escherichia coli biotin ligase is a cytoplasmic protein which specifically biotinylates the biotin-accepting domains from a variety of organisms. This in vivo biotinylation can be used as a sensitive signal to study protein secretion and membrane protein insertion. When the biotin-accepting domain from the 1.3S subunit of Propionibacterium shermanii transcarboxylase (PSBT) is translationally fused to the periplasmic proteins alkaline phosphatase and maltose-binding protein, there is little or no biotinylation of PSBT in wild-type E. coli. Inhibition of SecA with sodium azide and mutations in SecB, SecD, and SecF, all of which slow down protein secretion, result in biotinylation of PSBT. When PSBT is fused to the E. coli inner membrane protein MalF, it acts as a topological marker: fusions to cytoplasmic domains of MalF are biotinylated, and fusions to periplasmic domains are generally not biotinylated. If SecA is inhibited by sodium azide or if the SecE in the cell is depleted, then the insertion of the MalF second periplasmic domain is slowed down enough that PSBT fusions in this part of the protein become biotinylated. Compared with other protein fusions that have been used to study protein translocation, PSBT fusions have the advantage that they can be used to study the rate of the insertion process.     

Improved membrane protein topology prediction by domain assignments

Topology predictions for integral membrane proteins can be substantially improved if parts of the protein can be constrained to a given in/out location relative to the membrane using experimental data or other information. Here, we have identified a set of 367 domains in the SMART database that, when found in soluble proteins, have compartment-specific localization of a kind relevant for membrane protein topology prediction. Using these domains as prediction constraints, we are able to provide high-quality topology models for 11% of the membrane proteins extracted from 38 eukaryotic genomes. Two-thirds of these proteins are single spanning, a group of proteins for which current topology prediction methods perform particularly poorly.     

Topogenic signals in integral membrane proteins

Integral membrane proteins are characterized by long apolar segments that cross the lipid bilayer. Polar domains flanking these apolar segments have a more balanced amino acid composition, typical for soluble proteins. We show that the apolar segments from three different kinds of membrane-assembly signals do not differ significantly in amino acid content, but that the inside/outside location of the polar domains correlates strongly with their content of arginyl and lysyl residues, not only for bacterial inner-membrane proteins, but also for eukaryotic.proteins from the endoplasmic reticulum, the plasma membrane, the inner mitochondrial membrane, and the chloroplast thylakoid membrane. A positive-inside rule thus seems to apply universally to all integral membrane proteins, with apolar regions targeting for membrane integration and charged residues providing the topological information.     

Cytoplasmic Signals Mediate Apical Early Endosomal Targeting of Endotubin in MDCK Cells

Endotubin is an integral membrane protein that targets into apical endosomes in polarized epithelial cells. Although the role of cytoplasmic targeting signals as mediators of basolateral targeting and endocytosis is well established, it has been suggested that apical targeting requires either N-glycosylation of the ectoplasmic domains or partitioning of macromolecules into glycolipid-rich rafts. However, we have previously shown that the cytoplasmic portion of endotubin possesses signals that are necessary for its proper sorting into the apical early endosomes. To further define the targeting signals involved in this apically directed event, as well as to determine if the cytoplasmic domain was sufficient to mediate apical endosomal targeting, we generated a panel of endotubin and Tac-antigen chimeras and expressed them in Madin–Darby canine kidney cells. We show that both the apically targeting wild-type endotubin and a basolaterally targeted cytoplasmic domain mutant do not associate with rafts and are TX-100 soluble. The cytoplasmic tail of endotubin is sufficient for apical endosomal targeting, as chimeras with the endotubin cytoplasmic domain and Tac transmembrane and extracellular domains are efficiently targeted to the apical endosomal compartment. Furthermore, we show that overexpression of these chimeras results in their missorting to the basolateral membrane, indicating that the apical sorting process is a saturable event. These results show that cells contain machinery in both the biosynthetic and endosomal compartments that recognize cytoplasmic apical sorting signals.     

Characterisation of nuclear localisation signals of the four human core histones

The four core histones H2A, H2B, H3 and H4 are transported from the cytoplasm into the nucleus by a receptor-mediated and energy-dependent process. This nuclear transport depends on topogenic signals in the individual histone protein sequences. We have analysed such nuclear localisation signals in the core histones by means of fusion proteins consisting of individual core histones (or fragments thereof) and beta-galactosidase as a reporter protein. The results show that each of the four core histones contains several portions that are capable of mediating nuclear transport. One type of topogenic sequences consists of clustered basic amino acids in the amino terminal segments of each of the core histones. The globular portions of the core histones represent a second type of nuclear localisation signals that could only mediate nuclear transport when the whole protein domains were fused to the beta-galactosidase reporter. Fragments of the globular domains derived from each of the four core histones could not serve as nuclear localisation signals. We conclude that the nuclear targeting of core histones requires information conferred by the globular domain conformation.     

WRF-TMH: predicting transmembrane helix by fusing composition index and physicochemical properties of amino acids

Membrane protein is the prime constituent of a cell, which performs a role of mediator between intra and extracellular processes. The prediction of transmembrane (TM) helix and its topology provides essential information regarding the function and structure of membrane proteins. However, prediction of TM helix and its topology is a challenging issue in bioinformatics and computational biology due to experimental complexities and lack of its established structures. Therefore, the location and orientation of TM helix segments are predicted from topogenic sequences. In this regard, we propose WRF-TMH model for effectively predicting TM helix segments. In this model, information is extracted from membrane protein sequences using compositional index and physicochemical properties. The redundant and irrelevant features are eliminated through singular value decomposition. The selected features provided by these feature extraction strategies are then fused to develop a hybrid model. Weighted random forest is adopted as a classification approach. We have used two benchmark datasets including low and high-resolution datasets. tenfold cross validation is employed to assess the performance of WRF-TMH model at different levels including per protein, per segment, and per residue. The success rates of WRF-TMH model are quite promising and are the best reported so far on the same datasets. It is observed that WRF-TMH model might play a substantial role, and will provide essential information for further structural and functional studies on membrane proteins. The accompanied web predictor is accessible at http://111.68.99.218/WRF-TMH/.     

The nucleotide sequence of the gene for malF protein, an inner membrane component of the maltose transport system of Escherichia coli. Repeated DNA sequences are found in the malE-malF intercistronic region

The malF gene product is an inner membrane component of the maltose transport system in Escherichia coli. Some gene fusions between malF and lacZ (encoding the normally cytoplasmic enzyme beta-galactosidase) produce hybrid proteins which are membrane-bound while other fusions produce hybrid proteins which are cytoplasmic (Silhavy, T. J., Casadaban, M. J., Shuman, H. A., and Beckwith, J. R. (1976) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U. S. A. 73, 3423-3427). To further analyze the localization properties of the different classes of fusion proteins and of the intact MalF protein, we have obtained the DNA sequence of 5 malF-lacZ fusions and the wild type malF gene. From the predicted amino acid sequence, MalF protein contains 514 amino acids and has a molecular weight of 56,947. Analysis of the hydropathic character of MalF using the Kyte-Doolittle assignments (Kyte, J., and Doolittle, R. F. (1982) J. Mol. Biol. 157, 105-132), indicates that the protein may have 2 or 3 amino-terminal membrane-spanning segments and 4 or 5 carboxy-terminal membrane-spanning segments separated by a region of 181 hydrophilic residues. Localization properties of the different fusion proteins correspond with degree of hydrophobicity. By sequencing upstream from malF, the malE-malF intercistronic region was found to be 153 base pairs in length and to contain inverted repeats, homologous to intercistronic repeats of many other operons. Further analysis of this region may help in understanding the observed step-down in synthesis of the MalF protein.