Analysis of myogenesis by somatic cell hybridization. II. Retention of myogenic competence and suppression of transformed properties in hybrids between differentiation competent and incompetent rat L6 myoblasts

This study describes the characteristics of hybrids between two closely related rat myoblast lines, which differ both in the ability to express their program of differentiation and in the expression of neoplastic properties. Myogenic, nonneoplastic L6J1-S cells were hybridized with nonmyogenic, neoplastic L6J1-N1 cells. Six hybrid clones were isolated and expanded for analysis of myogenic competence, and four of these clones were also evaluated for parameters of transformation, including tumorigenicity, ability to clone in agar, and surface fibronectin. In addition to our analysis of isolated clones, we also assessed myogenic differentiation in colonies representing 226 early hybrid clones. Results of all these analyses demonstrate that the myogenic phenotype is retained and that the tumorigenic/transformed phenotype is suppressed in the hybrids. Furthermore, our results indicate that when the programs for myogenesis and neoplastic transformation are confronted within a single cell, they are expressed as mutually exclusive alternatives. In contrast to these results on myogenic X nonmyogenic L6 hybrids, it has been reported that isolated clones of A9 X L6 exhibited extinction of myogenic competence and retention of transformed properties. We have evaluated myotube formation in over 300 early hybrid clones between A9 and either diploid or subtetraploid L8 rat myoblasts. Our results demonstrate that all of these hybrid clones exhibit extinction regardless of the ploidy of the myoblast parent, and they further indicate that extinction is not a consequence of chromosome loss. These results support the conclusion that in A9 X L6 hybrids, the nonmyogenic, transformed phenotype is dominant.     

Analysis of myogenesis by somatic cell hybridization: III. Myogenic competence of hybrids derived from rat L6 myoblasts and mouse primary fibroblasts and myoblasts

Hybrid cells derived from rat L6 myoblasts and mouse primary fibroblasts (M x F hybrids), as well as those derived from rat L6 myoblasts and mouse primary myoblasts (M x M hybrids), were examined for their ability to engage in myogenesis as judged by muscle fiber formation plus the expression of skeletal muscle myosin and creatine kinase (CK). Of 172 primary hybrid colonies scored, 59% were myogenic in the M x F fusion and 97% exhibited muscle fiber formation in the M x M fusion. Individual hybrid clones from each cross were isolated, expanded and analyzed for myogenic capabilities as well. All three M x M and all ten M x F isolated clones exhibited preferential elimination of mouse chromosomes. Nonetheless, all were capable of fusing spontaneously and of elaborating skeletal muscle myosin and CK. The three M x M hybrids expressed only MM-CK whereas nine out of ten M x F hybrids produced all three CK isoenzymes (MM, MB, BB). These results suggest that M X M hybrids express CK patterns reminiscent of the rat L6 parental cells while M X F hybrids apparently mimic mouse muscle fiber CK patterns. Various models are discussed which address these phenomena.     

Characterization of heterokaryons between skeletal myoblasts and somatic cells formed by fusion with HVJ (Sendai virus); effects on myogenic differentiation

In skeletal myogenic differentiation, myoblasts fuse with myogenic cells spontaneously, but do not fuse with non-myogenic cells either in vivo or in vitro, suggesting that the fusion of myoblasts with non-myogenic cells is unsuitable for differentiation. To understand the inevitability of the fusion among myoblasts, we prepared heterokaryons in crosses between quail myoblasts transformed with a temperature-sensitive mutant of Rous sarcoma virus (QM-RSV cells) and rodent non-myogenic cells, such as tumor cells, fibroblasts, or neurogenic cells by HVJ (Sendai virus) and examined how myogenic differentiation was influenced in the prepared heterokaryons, focusing on myogenin expression and myofibril formation as markers of differentiation. When presumptive QM-RSV cells were fused with non-myogenic cells by HVJ and induced to differentiate, both myogenin expression and myofibril formation were suppressed. When myotubes of QM-RSV cells that had already expressed myogenin and formed myofibrils were fused with non-myogenic cells, both myogenin and myofibrils disappeared. Especially, fibrous structures of myofibrils were significantly lost and dots or aggregations of F-actin were formed within 24 hr after formation of heterokaryons. However, the fusion of presumptive or differentiated QM-RSV cells with rodent myoblasts did not disturb myogenin expression or myofibril formation. These results suggest that mutual fusion of myoblasts is indispensable for normal myogenic differentiation irrespective of the species, and that some factors inhibiting myogenic differentiation exist in the cytoplasm of non-myogenic cells, but not in myoblasts.     

Characterization of myogenic cell membrane: spontaneous formation of heterokaryotic myotubes between two different kinds of myoblasts

In a previous study, it has been shown that presumptive mouse C2 myoblast cells are strongly resistant to HVJ (hemaglutinating virus of Japan, Sendai virus)-mediated cell fusion, but do become capable of fusion upon differentiation. Quail myoblasts transformed with a temperature-sensitive mutant of Rous sarcoma virus (QM-RSV cells) also become more sensitive to HVJ-mediated cell fusion during differentiation. Investigations were undertaken to see whether heterokaryotic myotubes were formed spontaneously by co-culture of two different kinds of myogenic cells, QM-RSV cells and C2 cells. When both cells were committed to myotube formation, they spontaneously fused without HVJ on co-culture. On the other hand, when both or one of the cells were in the presumptive state, heterokaryons were not formed by co-culturing. Furthermore, committed QM-RSV cells did not fuse with non-myogenic cells. These results indicate that the membranes of myogenic cells change to become capable of fusion for myotube formation during differentiation.     

Localized cyclic AMP-dependent protein kinase activity is required for myogenic cell fusion

Multinucleated myotubes are formed by fusion of mononucleated myogenic progenitor cells (myoblasts) during terminal skeletal muscle differentiation. In addition, myoblasts fuse with myotubes, but terminally differentiated myotubes have not been shown to fuse with each other. We show here that an adenylate cyclase activator, forskolin, and other reagents that elevate intracellular cyclic AMP (cAMP) levels induced cell fusion between small bipolar myotubes in vitro. Then an extra-large myotube, designated a "myosheet," was produced by both primary and established mouse myogenic cells. Myotube-to-myotube fusion always occurred between the leading edge of lamellipodia at the polar end of one myotube and the lateral plasma membrane of the other. Forskolin enhanced the formation of lamellipodia where cAMP-dependent protein kinase (PKA) was accumulated. Blocking enzymatic activity or anchoring of PKA suppressed forskolin-enhanced lamellipodium formation and prevented fusion of multinucleated myotubes. Localized PKA activity was also required for fusion of mononucleated myoblasts. The present results suggest that localized PKA plays a pivotal role in the early steps of myogenic cell fusion, such as cell-to-cell contact/recognition through lamellipodium formation. Furthermore, the localized cAMP-PKA pathway might be involved in the specification of the fusion-competent areas of the plasma membrane in lamellipodia of myogenic cells.     

Myogenic differentiation of mesenchymal stem cells co‐cultured with primary myoblasts

TE (tissue engineering) of skeletal muscle is a promising method to reconstruct loss of muscle tissue. This study evaluates MSCs (mesenchymal stem cells) as new cell source for this application. As a new approach to differentiate the MSCs towards the myogenic lineage, co‐cultivation with primary myoblasts has been developed and the myogenic potential of GFP (green fluorescent protein)‐transduced rat MSC co‐cultured with primary rat myoblasts was assessed by ICC (immunocytochemistry). Myogenic potential of MSC was analysed by ICC, FACS and qPCR (quantitative PCR). MSC—myoblast fusion phenomena leading to hybrid myotubes were evaluated using a novel method to evaluate myotube fusion ratios based on phase contrast and fluorescence microscopy. Furthermore, MSC constitutively expressed the myogenic markers MEF2 (myogenic enhancer factor 2) and α‐sarcomeric actin, and MEF2 expression was up‐regulated upon co‐cultivation with primary myoblasts and the addition of myogenic medium supplements. Significantly higher numbers of MSC nuclei were involved in myotube formations when bFGF (basic fibroblast growth factor) and dexamethasone were added to co‐cultures. In summary, we have determined optimal co‐culture conditions for MSC myogenic differentiation up to myotube formations as a promising step towards applicability of MSC as a cell source for skeletal muscle TE as well as other muscle cell‐based therapies.     

Pattern of polypeptide synthesis in myoblast hybrids

We have examined cell hybrids derived from L6J1 rat myoblasts and A9 mouse fibroblastic cells for expression of the myogenic phenotype. Initial results showed that hybrid cells were no longer able to form myotubes and hence showed extinction of the myogenic phenotype. We then proceeded to characterize the pattern of protein synthesis in these cells using two-dimensional gel electrophoresis. Although we did detect extinction of synthesis of a small number of myoblast polypeptides in the hybrids these did not appear to be rat myoblast specific. Instead they correlated well with polypeptides lost upon viral transformation in another rat cell line. Analysis of the ability of parental cells and hybrids to grow in soft agar confirmed that both A9 cells and hybrids were more transformed than the parental L6J1 cells. The results are consistent with the interpretation that extinction of the ability to form myotubes is due to either transformation and/or a disrupted cell organization but is unlikely to be due to specific extinction of myoblast specific polypeptides, at least at the level detectable by 2D gel electrophoresis.     

Reconstitution of cells by fusion of cell fragments : I. Myogenic expression after fusion of minicells from rat myoblasts (L6) with mouse fibroblast (A9) cytoplasm

Rat L6 myoblasts and mouse A9 fibroblasts (HGPRT-) were enucleated by centrifugation of monolayers in the presence of cytochalasin B. Intact cells were reconstituted by Sendai virus mediated fusion of nuclei (minicells) from enucleated rat myoblasts and cytoplasms from enucleated mouse fibroblasts. Colonies arising from proliferating reconstituted cells were distinguished from intact parental cell types on the basis of nuclear and cytoplasmic markers. In five replicate experiments, approx. 70% of all colonies found after fusion were derived from reconstituted cells, 30% arose from intact rat myoblasts contaminating the minicell preparations, and two colonies were identified as hybrids between the parental cell types. Clones derived from reconstituted cells formed myotubes which produced myosin and developed the cross-striated pattern typical of skeletal muscle. The myogenic program of the rat myoblast thus can persist through the enucleation and reconstitution procedures, and is not obviously altered by a period of exposure to mouse fibroblast cytoplasm.     

Human epicardium-derived cells fuse with high efficiency with skeletal myotubes and differentiate toward the skeletal muscle phenotype: a comparison study with stromal and endothelial cells

Recent studies have underscored a role for the epicardium as a source of multipotent cells. Here, we investigate the myogenic potential of adult human epicardium-derived cells (EPDCs) and analyze their ability to undergo skeletal myogenesis when cultured with differentiating primary myoblasts. Results are compared to those obtained with mesenchymal stromal cells (MSCs) and with endothelial cells, another mesodermal derivative. We demonstrate that EPDCs spontaneously fuse with pre-existing myotubes with an efficiency that is significantly higher than that of other cells. Although at a low frequency, endothelial cells may also contribute to myotube formation. In all cases analyzed, after entering the myotube, nonmuscle nuclei are reprogrammed to express muscle-specific genes. The fusion competence of nonmyogenic cells in vitro parallels their ability to reconstitute dystrophin expression in mdx mice. We additionally show that vascular cell adhesion molecule 1 (VCAM1) expression levels of nonmuscle cells are modulated by soluble factors secreted by skeletal myoblasts and that VCAM1 function is required for fusion to occur. Finally, treatment with interleukin (IL)-4 or IL-13, two cytokines released by differentiating myotubes, increases VCAM1 expression and enhances the rate of fusion of EPDCs and MSCs, but not that of endothelial cells.     

Quantitation of changes in cell surface determinants during skeletal muscle cell differentiation using monospecific antibody

The differentiation of skeletal muscle is characterized by recognition, alignment, and subsequent fusion of myoblast cells at their surfaces to form large, multinucleated myotubes. Monoclonal antibodies were used to investigate anti-genie changes in the cell surface membrane specific for various stages of myogenesis. Chick embryonic skeletal muscle cells were cultured in vitro to the desired stage of differentiation and then injected into BALB/c mice. Spleen cells from the immunized mice were hybridized with NS-1 or P3 8653 mouse myeloma cells. Hybrid cell clones were selected in HAT medium and screened using an indirect radioimmunoassay for the production of monoclonal antibodies specific to myogenic cell surfaces. Target cells for the radioimmunoassay included three stages of myogenesis (myoblasts, midfusion myoblasts, and myotubes) and chick lung cells as a control for polymorphic antigens. Sixty-one clones were obtained which produced antibodies specific for myogenic cells. Thirty-five of these clones were generated from mice immunized with midfusion myoblast stages of myogenesis and 26 were obtained from mice immunized with the later myotube stage of myogenesis. Quantitative measurements by RIA of myogenic determinants per cell surface area on each target cell type revealed that most of the determinants decrease during myogenesis when midfusion myoblasts are used as the immunogen. When myotube stages are used as the immunogen, more determinants increase with cell differentiation. Therefore, the most common pattern of determinant change is for them to be present at all stages of myogenesis but to vary quantitively through development. There are determinants unique to each stage of myogenesis and marked quantitative differences within a cell stage for each determinant.     

Coexpression of myogenic functions in L6 rat × T984 mouse myoblast hybrids

L6 rat myoblasts differ from T984 mouse myoblasts in the expression of several myogenic functions. Simple hybrids between these myogenic lines contained mostly chromosomes and expressed the mouse phenotype. Hybrids containing an approximately balanced set of chromosomes from each parent were constructed by fusing tetraploid L6 cells to T984 myoblasts. These hybrids were allowed to differentiate and their expression of myogenic proteins was compared to the parental phenotypes. The synthesis of creatine phosphokinase isoenzymes is codominantly expressed in the hybrid cells. Myosin light chain synthesis and the levels of acetylcholine receptor are either regulated by the mouse genome or are codominantly expressed.     

Control of differentiation in heterokaryons and hybrids involving differentiation-defective myoblast variants

Clones of differentiation-defective myoblasts were isolated by selecting clones of L6 rat myoblasts that did not form myotubes under differentiation-stimulating conditions. Rat skeletal myosin light chain synthesis was induced in heterokaryons formed by fusing these defective myoblasts to differentiated chick skeletal myocytes. This indicates that the structural gene for this muscle protein was still responsive to chick inducing factors and that the defective myoblasts were not producing large quantities of molecules that dominantly suppressed the expression of differentiated functions. The regulation of the decision to differentiate was then examined in hybrids between differentiation- defective myoblasts and differentiation-competent myoblasts. Staining with antimyosin antibodies showed that the defective myoblasts and homotypic hybrids formed by fusing defective myoblasts to themselves could in fact differentiate, but did so more than a thousand times less frequently than the 64% differentiation achieved by competent L6 myoblasts or homotypic competent X competent L6 hybrids. Heterotypic hybrids between differentiation-defective myoblasts and competent L6 cells exhibited an intermediate behavior of approximately 1% differentiation. A theoretical model for the regulation of the commitment to terminal differentiation is proposed that could explain these results by invoking the need to achieve threshold levels of secondary inducing molecules in response to differentiation-stimulating conditions. This model helps explain many of the stochastic aspects of cell differentiation.     

Phenotypic expression in chick erythrocyte X rat myoblast hybrids and in chick myoblast X rat myoblast hybrids

Attempts were made to reprogram chick erythrocyte nuclei to specify the synthesis of chick myosin. Chick erythrocytes were fused with rat myogenic cells with the aid of UV-inactivated Sendai virus. In the heterokaryons and hybrid myotubes which resulted from this fusion, the erythrocyte nuclei resumed RNA synthesis and formed nucleoli. Although some new chick antigens developed in those myotubes which contained fully reactivated chick erythrocyte nuclei, accumulation of chick myosin could not be detected by immunological methods. Neither small heterokaryons nor large hybrid myotubes which were actively synthesizing rat myosin reacted with antibodies directed against chick myosin. A small number of mononucleated cells, believed to be synkaryons formed by mitotic division of heterokaryons, did, however, react strongly with antibodies directed against chick myosin and showed a cross striation typical of skeletal muscle. The frequency of such cells was too low, however, to permit karyological analysis or further characterization of the antigen. Hybrids between chick myoblasts and rat myoblasts produced both chick and rat myosin thus indicating that simultaneous translation of chick and rat mRNA for myosin in a common cytoplasm was possible. In summary the evidence obtained suggested that reprogramming of chick erythrocyte nuclei, if it did occur in the present system, was a rare phenomenon.The possibility that hybrids between chick erythrocytes and rat myoblasts expressed markers typical of an erythroid phenotype was examined by immune staining with antibodies directed against chick haemoglobin. The results suggested that haemoglobin was introduced into hybrid cells by erythrocytes which failed to lyse before fusion. The intensity of this immune fluorescence decreased with increasing time after fusion. The rate at which this decrease occurred was not affected by inhibition of RNA synthesis. Thus, there was no evidence for the accumulation of haemoglobin in the hybrid cells.     

Reduced amount of the glucose-regulated protein GRP94 in skeletal myoblasts results in loss of fusion competence.

We previously showed that skeletal myocytes of the adult rabbit do not accumulate the endoplasmic reticulum glucose-regulated protein GRP94, neither constitutively nor inducibly, at variance with skeletal myocytes during perinatal development (5). Here we show that C2C12 cells up-regulate GRP94 during differentiation and, similarly to primary cultures of murine skeletal myocytes, specifically display GRP94 immunoreactivity on the cell surface. Stable transfection of C2C12 cells with grp94 antisense cDNA shows lack of myotube formation in clones displaying >40% reduction in GRP94 amount. The same result is obtained after in vivo injection of grp94-antisense myoblasts. Conversely, GRP94 overexpression is accompanied by accelerated myotube formation. Analyses of BrdU incorporation, p21 nuclear translocation, and muscle-gene expression show that muscle differentiation is not apparently affected in grp94-antisense clones. In contrast, cell-surface GRP94 is greatly reduced in grp94-antisense clones, as shown by immunocytochemistry and precipitation of cell-surface biotinylated proteins. Thus, cell-surface expression of GRP94 is necessary for maintenance of fusion competence. Furthermore, differentiating C2C12 cells grown in the presence of anti-GRP94 antibody show decreased myotube number suggesting that cell-surface GRP94 is directly involved in myoblast fusion process.     

Synthesis of type IV collagen and laminin in cultures of skeletal muscle cells and their assembly on the surface of myotubes

The synthesis of two components of the basal lamina, laminin and type IV collagen, and their extracellular deposition on the surface of myotubes was studied in cultures of embryonic mouse and quail skeletal muscle cells and in the rat myoblast cell line L6. Production of type IV collagen and laminin by myoblasts and muscle fibroblasts was demonstrated by incorporation of radioactive amino acids into proteins and by immunoprecipitation with specific antibodies and electrophoretic analysis of labeled proteins. Immunofluorescence staining experiments revealed strong intracellular reactions with antibodies to laminin and type IV collagen in mononucleated myogenic and fibrogenic cells. Cells of fibroblast-like morphology showed a more intense staining than bipolar, spindle-shaped cells which perhaps represented postmitotic myoblasts. Myotubes did not show detectable intracellular staining. The formation of a basal lamina on myotubes was indicated by the deposition of laminin and type IV collagen on the surface of myotubes as viewed by immunofluorescence examination of unfixed cells. Staining for extracellular laminin was stronger in mass cultures than in myogenic clones, suggesting that secretion and deposition of components of the basal lamina on the myotube surface are complex processes which may involve cooperation between myogenic and fibrogenic cells.     

Synthesis of rat myosin light chains in heterokaryons formed between undifferentiated rat myoblasts and chick skeletal myocytes

The control of gene expression during terminal myogenesis was explored in heterokaryons between differentiated and undifferentiated myogenic cells by analyzing the formation of species specific myosin light chains of chick and rat skeletal muscle. Dividing L6 rat myoblasts served as the biochemically undifferentiated parent. The differentiated parental cells were mononucleated muscle cells (myocytes) that were obtained from primary cultures of embryonic chick thigh muscle by blocking myotube formation with EGTA and later incubating the postimitotic cells in cytochalasin B. Heterokaryons were isolated by the selective rescue of fusion products between cells previously treated with lethal doses of different cell poisons. 95-99% pure populations of heterokaryons formed between undifferentiated rat myoblasts and differentiated chick myocytes were obtained. The cells were labeled with [35S]methionine, and whole cell extracts were analyzed on two-dimensional polyacrylamide gels. These heterokaryons synthesize the light chain of chick myosin and both embryonic and adult light chains of rat skeletal myosin. Control homokaryons formed by fusing undifferentiated cells to themselves did not synthesize skeletal myosin light chains. Control heterokaryons formed between undifferentiated rat myoblasts and chick fibroblasts also failed to synthesize myosin light chains. These results indicate that differentiated chick muscle cells provide some factor that induces L6 myoblasts to synthesize rat myosin light chains. This system provides a model for investigating the processes by which differentiated cell functions are induced.     

Requirement of the transmembrane semaphorin Sema4C for myogenic differentiation

Semaphorins constitute a large family of signaling proteins that contribute to axonal guidance. Here we demonstrate that the transmembrane semaphorin Sema4C is up-regulated both in the early stage of differentiation of C2C12 mouse skeletal myoblasts into myotubes and during injury-induced muscle regeneration in vivo. Depletion of Sema4C in C2C12 cells resulted in marked attenuation of myotube formation. A fusion protein containing the extracellular Sema domain and a peptide corresponding to the intracellular COOH-terminal region of Sema4C each inhibited the differentiation of C2C12 cells. These findings indicate that Sema4C-mediated interaction among myoblasts plays an important role in terminal myogenic differentiation.     

Suppression of the transformed phenotype of hepatoma cells after hybridization with normal diploid fibroblasts

Hybrids were generated between mouse hepatoma cells which exhibit a transformed phenotype, and rat normal diploid fibroblasts. Most isolated hybrid clones contain a single set of chromosomes from each parent. Such clones grow to low saturation densities and are unable to grow or to form colonies in soft agar. The transformed phenotype of the parental hepatoma cells is thus suppressed in these hybrids. Suppression is very stable; however, subclones which have regained a transformed phenotype could be selected; these subclones show a significant reduction of their chromosome number. Amongst the hybrid clones isolated after fusion, a few are characterized by an excess of mouse chromosomes and a reduced number of rat chromosomes. Such clones exhibit a transformed phenotype. Our results show that, provided the hybrids contain an almost complete single set of chromosomes of each parent, spontaneous transformation behaves as a recessive trait in hybrids formed with normal diploid cells.     

Activation of production of mouse liver enzymes in rat hepatoma-mouse lymphoid cell hybrids

The production of four liver-specific enzymes (tyrosine aminotransferase or TAT, alanine aminotransferase, aldolase B, and alcohol dehydrogenase) has been analyzed in rat hepatoma-mouse lymphoid cell hybrids containing a 1s or 2s complement of rat chromosomes. The hybrid clones which retain a nearly 2s complement of rat chromosomes show high activity of all four enzymes; those which contain a 1s rat complement show partial or complete extinction of these enzymes. The tyrosine aminotransferase produced by most of the hybrid clones is identifiable as being of both rat and mouse origin, based upon criteria of temperature sensitivity and electrophoretic mobility; antiserum to the rat liver enzyme was used to distinguish the pseudo-TAT produced by the lymphoid parent from liver-TAT produced by hepatoma and hybrid cells. By the criteron of electrophoretic mobility, the liver form (B) of aldolase, produced by only some of the hybrid clones, appears to be composed of both rat and mouse subunits. We conclude that when extinction of tissue-specific proteins does not occur or is only partial in hybrid cells (due to gene dosage effects), the genomes of both parents may be active in directing synthesis of these proteins.