Genetic toxicology testing of 41 industrial chemicals

41 compounds or mixtures of diverse structure and application have been tested for genotoxic activity. The materials were tested in bacterial mutation assays, in Saccharomyces cerevisiae JD1 for mitotic gene conversion and in a cultured rat-liver cell line for structural chromosome damage. 11 compounds were bacterial mutagens, 4 induced mitotic gene conversion in yeast and 5 were positive in the chromosome assay. 5 of the materials were positive in bacteria only and 2 compounds induced chromosome damage in cultured cells in the absence of mutation in bacteria or gene conversion in yeast. The materials were tested over a 5-year period and the performance and evolution of the 3 assays during this time is evaluated. The results are considered in relation to the structure of the chemicals and the genotoxicity of related compounds.     

Ethylene thiourea (ETU). A review of the genetic toxicity studies

Ethylene thiourea (ETU) is a common contaminant, metabolite and degradation product of the fungicide class of ethylene bisdithiocarbamates (EBDCs); as such, they present possible exposure and toxicological concerns to exposed individuals. ETU has been assayed in many different tests to assess genotoxicity activity. While a great number of negative results are found in the data base, there is evidence that demonstrates ETU is capable of inducing genotoxic endpoints. These include responses for gene mutations (e.g. Salmonella), structural chromosomal alterations (e.g. aberrations in cultured mammalian cells as well as a dominant lethal assay) and other genotoxic effects (e.g. bacterial rec assay and several yeast assays).It is important to consider the magnitude of the positive responses as well as the concentrations/doses used when assessing the genotoxicity of ETU. While ETU induces a variety of genotoxic endpoints, it does not appear to be a potent genotoxic agent. For example, it is a weak bacterial mutagen in the Salmonella assay without activation in strain TA1535 at concentrations generally above 1000 μg/plate. Weak genotoxic activity of this sort is usually observed in most of the assays with positive results. Since ETU does not appear very potent and is not extremely toxic to test cells and organisms, it is not surprising to find that ETU does not produce consistent effects in many of the assays reviewed. Consequently, in many instances, mixed results for the same assay type are reported by different investigators, but as reviewed herein, these results may be dependent upon the test conditions in each individual laboratory. A primary shortcoming with many of the reported negative results is that the concentrations or doses used are not high enough for an adequate test for ETU activity. There are also problems with many of the negative assays generally in protocol or reporting, particularly with the in vivo studies (e.g. inappropriate sample number and/or sampling times; inadequate top dose employed).Overall, while ETU does not appear to be a potent genotoxic agent, it is capable of producing genotoxic effects (e.g. gene mutations, structural chromosomal aberrations). This provides a basis for weak genotoxic activity by ETU. Furthermore, based on a suggestive dominant lethal positive result, there may be a concern for heritable effects. Due to the many problems with the conduct and assessment of the in vivo assays, it is worth repeating in vivo     

No mutagenic or recombinogenic effects of mobile phone fields at 900 MHz detected in the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae

Both actively growing and resting cells of the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae were exposed to 900-MHz fields that closely matched the Global System for Mobile Communication (GSM) pulsed modulation format signals for mobile phones at specific absorption rates (SAR) of 0.13 and 1.3 W/kg. Two identical anechoic test chambers were constructed to perform concurrent control and test experiments under well-controlled exposure conditions. Using specific test strains, we examined the genotoxic potential of mobile phone fields, alone and in combination, with a known genotoxic compound, the alkylating agent methyl methansulfonate. Mutation rates were monitored by two test systems, a widely used gene-specific forward mutation assay at CAN1 and a wide-range assay measuring the induction of respiration-deficient (petite) clones that have lost their mitochondrial function. In addition, two further assays measured the recombinogenic effect of mobile phone fields to detect possible effects on genomic stability: First, an intrachromosomal, deletion-formation assay previously developed for genotoxic screening; and second, an intragenic recombination assay in the ADE2 gene. Fluctuation tests failed to detect any significant effect of mobile phone fields on forward mutation rates at CAN1, on the frequency of petite formation, on rates of intrachromosomal deletion formation, or on rates of intragenic recombination in the absence or presence of the genotoxic agent methyl methansulfonate.     

Genotoxicity of acrylamide and glycidamide in human lymphoblastoid TK6 cells

The recent finding that acrylamide (AA), a potent carcinogen, is formed in foods during cooking raises human health concerns. In the present study, we investigated the genotoxicity of AA and its metabolite glycidamide (GA) in human lymphoblastoid TK6 cells examining three endpoints: DNA damage (comet assay), clastogenesis (micronucleus test) and gene mutation (thymidine kinase (TK) assay). In a 4 h treatment without metabolic activation, AA was mildly genotoxic in the micronucleus and TK assays at high concentrations (> 10 mM), whereas GA was significantly and concentration-dependently genotoxic at all endpoints at > or = 0.5 mM. Molecular analysis of the TK mutants revealed that AA predominantly induced loss of heterozygosity (LOH) mutation like spontaneous one while GA-induced primarily point mutations. These results indicate that the genotoxic characteristics of AA and GA were distinctly different: AA was clastogenic and GA was mutagenic. The cytotoxicity and genotoxicity of AA were not enhanced by metabolic activation (rat liver S9), implying that the rat liver S9 did not activate AA. We discuss the in vitro and in vivo genotoxicity of AA and GA.     

IPCS guidelines for the monitoring of genotoxic effects of carcinogens in humans. International Programme on Chemical Safety

The purpose of these guidelines is to provide concise guidance on the planning, performing and interpretation of studies to monitor groups or individuals exposed to genotoxic agents. Most human carcinogens are genotoxic but not all genotoxic agents have been shown to be carcinogenic in humans. Although the main interest in these studies is due to the association of genotoxicity with carcinogenicity, there is also an inherent interest in monitoring human genotoxicity independently of cancer as an endpoint.The most often studied genotoxicity endpoints have been selected for inclusion in this document and they are structural and numerical chromosomal aberrations assessed using cytogenetic methods (classical chromosomal aberration analysis (CA), fluorescence in situ hybridisation (FISH), micronuclei (MN)); DNA damage (adducts, strand breaks, crosslinking, alkali-labile sites) assessed using bio-chemical/electrophoretic assays or sister chromatid exchanges (SCE); protein adducts; and hypoxanthine-guanine phosphoribosyltransferase (HPRT) mutations. The document does not consider germ cells or gene mutation assays other than HPRT or markers of oxidative stress, which have been applied on a more limited scale.     

Genotoxicity of aloeemodin in vitro and in vivo

The present in vitro and in vivo experiments were undertaken to clarify the genotoxic potential of the hydroxyanthrachinone aloeemodin which can be found in different plant derived products for therapy of constipation. The results demonstrate that aloeemodin is able to induce mutagenic effects in vitro. Positive results were obtained in the chromosomal aberration assay with CHO cells, as well as in the Salmonella reverse mutation assay (frameshift mutations in strains TA 1537, TA 1538 and TA 98). No mutagenic potential of aloeemodin, however, was observed in the gene mutation assay with mammalian cells in vitro (HPRT assay in V79 cells). Each assay was performed in the presence and absence of an extrinsic metabolic activation system (S9-mix). In in vivo studies (micronucleus assay in bone marrow cells of NMRI mice; chromosome aberration assay in bone marrow cells of Wistar rats; mouse spot test [DBA/2J × NMRI]) no indication of a mutagenic activity of aloeemodin was found. Information about a possible reaction of aloeemodin with DNA was derived from an in vivo UDS assay. Hepatocytes of aloeemodin-treated male Wistar rats did not show DNA damage via repair synthesis. All these data suggest that aloeemodin is able to interact with DNA under certain in vitro conditions. However, in vivo the results that were negative did not indicate a genotoxic potential. Therefore, it may be assumed that a genotoxic risk for man might be unlikely.     

Evaluation of the in vitro genetic toxicity of 4-(2, 4-dichlorophenoxy)butyric acid

The herbicide 4-(2,4-dichlorophenoxy)butyric acid (2,4-DB) is principally used in the USA on peanuts, soybeans and alfalfa. In Europe, it is used on undersown spring barley and grassland (with clover). The genetic toxicity in vitro of the dimethylamine salt of 2,4-DB was examined by employing a range of end points including gene mutation in bacteria (Ames test) and mammalian cell cultures (CHO/HGPRT assay), cytogenetic abnormalities in mammalian cells (CHO/chromosomal aberration assay), and induction of DNA damage and repair in rat hepatocytes. There were no indications of genotoxic potential for 2,4-DB in the first three of these assays. One of the two criteria for a positive response in the UDS assay was exceeded but the increases did not exceed the second criteria for a positive response. The test material was therefore evaluated as weakly active in this assay. The weight of the evidence clearly indicates that 2, 4-DB is not genotoxic to mammals and are consistent with the reported lack of carcinogenic potential for 2,4-DB in both mice and rats.     

Evaluation of genotoxicity of tert.-butylhydroquinone in an hepatocyte-mediated assay with V79 Chinese hamster lung cells and in strain D7 of Saccharomyces cerevisiae.

tert.-Butylhydroquinone (TBHQ) has been reported to be genotoxic in some short-term assays but non-genotoxic in others. We have examined cytotoxicity and genotoxicity of TBHQ, a principal metabolite of the phenolic antioxidant 2(3)-tert.-butyl-4-hydroxyanisole (BHA), in an hepatocyte-mediated assay with V79 Chinese hamster lung cells including both sister-chromatid exchange (SCE) and thioguanine-resistance (TGR) endpoints. The ability of BHA and of TBHQ to elicit a genotoxic response in Saccharomyces cerevisiae strain D7 was also investigated. In V79 cytotoxicity tests, TBHQ without hepatocytes produced a 50% reduction in colony formation at 4.2 micrograms/ml and was lethal to 100% of the cells at concentrations above 5 micrograms/ml. At partially cytotoxic dose levels, (0.17-3.4 micrograms/ml of medium), TBHQ sometimes increased significantly the frequency of SCE. TBHQ also produced sporadic statistically significant increases in the mutation frequency at the HGPRTase (TGR) gene locus when tested alone or with activation by rat or hamster hepatocytes. Mitotic gene conversion and reverse mutation were not induced in strain D7 of Saccharomyces cerevisiae by exposure to BHA or to TBHQ for 4 h at concentrations as high as 200 micrograms/ml for BHA or 500 micrograms/ml for TBHQ, either alone or with activation by rat-liver S9. Incubation of the yeast cells with BHA or TBHQ for 24 h in growth medium without activation also did not induce genotoxic activity. The slight and sporadic response to TBHQ in the V79 test system may indicate weak genotoxicity which is sensitive to slight differences in test conditions. The classification and test strategies adopted for compounds such as TBHQ could have important implications for regulatory decisions and for the validation of short-term tests.     

Retroviral expression of the hepatitis B virus x gene promotes liver cell susceptibility to carcinogen-induced site specific mutagenesis

Mutational inactivation of the tumor suppressor gene p53 is common in hepatocellular carcinomas (HCC). AGG to AGT transversion in codon 249 of exon 7 of the p53 gene occurs in over 50% of HCC from endemic regions, where both chronic infection with the hepatitis B virus (HBV) and exposure to carcinogens such as aflatoxin B1 (AFB1) prevail. In this study, we report the effect of the HBV x protein (HBx) on carcinogen-induced cytotoxicity and AGG to AGT mutation in codon 249 of the p53 gene in the human liver cell line CCL13. Expression of HBx, as revealed by its transactivation function, results in enhanced cell susceptibility to cytotoxicity induced by the AFB1 active metabolite, AFB1-8,9-epoxide, and benzo(a)pyrene diol-epoxide. Under similar conditions, expression of HBx promotes apoptosis in a subset of cell population. Exposure to AFB1-8, 9-epoxide alone induces a low frequency of AGG to AGT mutation in codon 249 of the p53 gene, as determined by an allele-specific polymerase chain reaction (AS-PCR) assay. However, expression of HBx enhances the frequency of AFB1-epoxide-induced AGG to AGT mutation compared to control cells. In summary, this study demonstrates that expression of HBx enhances liver cell susceptibility to carcinogen-induced mutagenesis, possibly through alteration of the balance between DNA repair and apoptosis, two cellular defense mechanisms against genotoxic stress.     

The aromatic amine carcinogens o-toluidine and o-anisidine induce free radicals and intrachromosomal recombination in Saccharomyces cerevisiae

Aniline-based aromatic amine carcinogens are poorly detected in short-term mutagenicity assays such as the Salmonella reverse mutation (Ames) assay. More information on the mechanism of toxicity of such Salmonella-negative carcinogens is needed. Aniline and o-toluidine are negative in the Ames assay, but induce deletions (DEL) due to intrachromosomal recombination in Saccharomyces cerevisiae with an apparent threshold. We show here that the DEL assay also detects the genotoxic activity of another aromatic amine carcinogen, o-anisidine, which is also negative in the Salmonella assay. We also show that the DEL assay distinguishes between o-anisidine and its non-carcinogenic structural analog 2, 4-dimethoxyaniline. We have investigated whether the ability of the DEL assay to detect the carcinogens and to distinguish between the carcinogen/non-carcinogen pair is linked to rises in intracellular free radical species following exposure to the carcinogens. Toxicity induced by all three compounds was reduced in the presence of the free radical scavenger and antioxidant N-acetyl cysteine, recombination induced by o-anisidine and o-toluidine was also reduced by N-acetyl cysteine. All three compounds induced oxidation of the free radical-sensitive reporter compound dichlorofluorescin diacetate. Superoxide dismutase-deficient strains, however, were hypersensitive to cytotoxicity induced by o-toluidine and o-anisidine but not by the non-carcinogen 2,4-dimethoxyaniline, indicating a different potential for generating superoxide radical between the carcinogens and the non-carcinogen analog. The results indicate that the yeast DEL assay is a useful tool for investigating the genotoxic activity of aromatic amine carcinogens.     

Studies on the genotoxicity of endosulfan in bacterial systems

Endosulfan, an organochlorine pesticide, was subjected to the differential sensitivity assay in repair-deficient and repair-proficient strains of Escherichia coli K12, prophage lambda induction assay in WP2s (lambda) and mutation induction in E. coli K12. The induction of umu gene expression with endosulfan was studied also in Salmonella typhimurium TA1535/pSK1002 cells. The differential sensitivity assay revealed that the recA 13 strain was the most sensitive. Endosulfan induced prophage lambda in E. coli and umu gene expression in S. typhimurium cells; however, the extent of the effects were low. Endosulfan also induced a dose-dependent increase in forward mutations in E. coli K12 cells from ampicillin sensitivity to ampicillin resistance. Our studies indicate the genotoxic potential of endosulfan and the role of the recA gene in the repair of endosulfan-induced DNA damage.     

Potassium bromate treatment predominantly causes large deletions, but not GC>TA transversion in human cells

Potassium bromate (KBrO(3)) is strongly carcinogenic in rodents and mutagenic in bacteria and mammalian cells in vitro. The proposed genotoxic mechanism for KBrO(3) is oxidative DNA damage. KBrO(3) can generate high yields of 8-hydroxydeoxyguanosine (8OHdG) DNA adducts, which cause GC>TA transversions in cell-free systems. In this study, we investigated the in vitro genotoxicity of KBrO(3) in human lymphoblastoid TK6 cells using the comet (COM) assay, the micronucleus (MN) test, and the thymidine kinase (TK) gene mutation assay. After a 4h treatment, the alkaline and neutral COM assay demonstrated that KBrO(3) directly yielded DNA damages including DNA double strand breaks (DSBs). KBrO(3) also induced MN and TK mutations concentration-dependently. At the highest concentration (5mM), KBrO(3) induced MN and TK mutation frequencies that were over 30 times the background level. Molecular analysis revealed that 90% of the induced mutations were large deletions that involved loss of heterozygosity (LOH) at the TK locus. Ionizing-irradiation exhibited similar mutational spectrum in our system. These results indicate that the major genotoxicity of KBrO(3) may be due to DSBs that lead to large deletions rather than to 8OHdG adducts that lead to GC>TA transversions, as is commonly believed. To better understand the genotoxic mechanism of KBrO(3), we analyzed gene expression profiles of TK6 cells using Affymetrix Genechip. Some genes involved in stress, apoptosis, and DNA repair were up-regulated by the treatment of KBrO(3). However, we could not observe the similarity of gene expression profile in the treatment of KBrO(3) to ionizing-irradiation as well as oxidative damage inducers.     

Activation or detoxification of mutagenic and carcinogenic compounds in transgenic Drosophila expressing human glutathione S-transferase.

Sensitivity of transgenic Drosophila melanogaster with expression of a human gene encoding the glutathione S-transferase alpha subunit (GSTA1-1) to 1,2:5,6-dibenzanthracene (DBA) and 1,2-dichloroethane (DCE) was investigated in the somatic mutation and recombination test (SMART). We performed the same assay in control transgenic flies expressing the bacterial lacZ gene. Three types of transgenic Drosophila strains carrying GSTA1-1 were used: two transgenic strains homozygous for the second chromosome with a single-copy transgene insertion and one strain with two transgene insertions. Larvae carrying the lacZ gene were significantly more sensitive to genotoxic effects of DBA than those carrying three copies of the GSTA1-1 gene. The larvae with lacZ expression showed significantly lower sensitivity to DCE compared with those expressing GSTA1-1. Finally, a pretreatment with buthionine-sulphoximine (BSO) in experiment with DCE significantly decreased the frequency of mutation events in larvae with three GSTA1-1 copies in comparison with others.     

Analysis of low density lipoprotein receptor gene mutations and microsatellite haplotypes in Greek FH heterozygous children: six independent ancestors account for 60% of probands

This study reports the characterization of 60% of low density lipoprotein receptor (LDLR) gene mutations in 150unrelated Greek familial hypercholes-terolaemia (FH) heterozygous children by the analysis of six LDLR gene mutations. The linkage disequilibrium of two polymorphic microsatellites (D19S394 and D19S221) flanking the LDLR gene on chromosome19 to the four most common mutations strongly suggests that each mutation is identical-by-descent in the probands included in this study (this is also supported by the geographical distribution of FH families with these mutations throughout Greece) and permits an estimation of the number of generations from a common ancestor for each mutation. The characterization of 60% of LDLR mutations in a representative sample of Greek FH heterozygotes provides a basis for the diagnosis of FH through DNA analysis in Greece, by using single-strand conformation polymorphism analysis followed by allele-specific oligonucleotide hybridization (exon6 mutations) or restriction endonuclease analysis (C152R, V408M). A rapid diagnostic assay positive for the mutation has been developed for the most common mutation, G528D. The application of simple DNA diagnostic assays for LDLR mutation analysis are appropriate for the early identification of FH heterozygotes in Greece and are useful for the primary prevention of coronary artery disease. Received: 7 July 1997 / Accepted: 5 November 1997     

Evaluation of the genotoxic activity of 2-nitroanthrafurans

We measured the genotoxic activities in two bacterial tests, the Salmonella/histidine assay (a reverse mutation assay) and the SOS chromotest (an assay for SOS induction in E. coli), of three 2-nitroanthrafurans: 2-nitroanthra[1,2-b]furan (R-7688), the isomeric compound 2-nitroanthra[2,1-b]furan (R-7686) and its 8-methoxylated derivative (R-7707). Their genotoxic activities were compared to that of 7-methoxy-2-nitronaphtho[2,1-b]furan (R-7000) which has been studied in previous works (Arnaise et al., 1986). We found that: (1) for all three 2-nitroanthrafurans, as generally observed for other 2-nitrofuran derivatives, the responses were correlated in the 2 tests and were decreased in the presence of an 'activating mixture' and in nitroreductase-deficient strains; (2) in contrast to what is usually observed with other 2-nitrofuran derivatives for which methoxylation increases genotoxic activity, the genotoxic activity of the methoxylated 2-nitroanthrafuran (R-7707) was comparable and may be even lower than that of the unsubstituted 2-nitroanthrafuran (R-7686); (3) the addition of a third ring that leads from 2-nitronaphthofurans to 2-nitroanthrafurans increased slightly the genotoxic activity of these compounds; (4) compounds with the oxygen heteroatom outside the 'bay region', R-7686 and R-7707, gave higher responses than their isomers with the oxygen heteroatom within the 'bay region', R-7688.     

Quantification of CD59- mutants in human-hamster hybrid (AL) cells by flow cytometry

Mutation assay is an important approach in evaluating the genotoxic risk of potentially harmful environmental chemicals. The human-hamster hybrid (A(L)) cell mutagenesis system, based on the complement/antibody-mediated cytotoxicity principle, has been used successfully to evaluate the mutagenic potential of a variety of environmental toxicants. The A(L) cells contain a standard set of CHO chromosomes and a single human chromosome 11, which expresses several cell surface proteins including CD59 encoded by the CD59 gene at 11p13.5. A modified mutation assay by flow cytometry was developed to determine the yield of CD59- mutants after either radiation or chemical treatment. After incubation with phycoerythrin-conjugated mouse monoclonal anti-CD59 antibody, the CD59- mutant yields were determined by quantifying the fluorescence of the cells using flow cytometry. This method is faster and eliminates the commonly encountered toxicity problems of the complements with the traditional complement/antibody assay. By comparing the mutant fractions of radiation or chemically treated A(L) cultures using the two methods, we show here that the flow cytometry assay is an excellent substitute in providing an efficient and highly sensitive method in mutant detection for the traditional complement/antibody assay.     

Pitfalls in the genetic diagnosis of hereditary hemochromatosis

The widespread use of the genotype assay that identifies the common C282Y mutation in the HFE gene has allowed an earlier diagnosis to be made in many subjects. A significant number of these patients may have no evidence of phenotypic disease and have a normal serum ferritin level. This phenomenon is more common when the genotype assay is used to screen populations rather than higher-risk groups such as family members of a proband with hereditary hemochromatosis. Moreover, patients with significant iron overload may be wild type for the C282Y mutation and have no other demonstrable mutation of the HFE gene. The HFE genotype assay has recently been found to give a false-positive C282Y homozygous result in half of the subjects in one population screening study due to the presence of a single nucleotide polymorphism (SNP) that interfered with primer binding in the PCR assay. The problem may be overcome by using alternate primers. A number of other groups have confirmed the finding but in a much smaller number of subjects, whereas others found that their assays were not affected by the SNP. The use of the HFE genotype assay as the sole diagnostic criterion for hereditary hemochromatosis is not recommended. The genotype assay should be used as an adjunct to the established methods of demonstrating iron overload and be viewed as a predictor of either the presence of iron overload or the subsequent development of iron overload during an individual's lifetime.     

Non-phenotypic selection of N-methyl-N-nitrosourea-induced mutations in human cells.

The distribution of mutations in a particular gene as detected by a selective mutation assay could be affected by the structural properties of the target protein. To investigate this, we have analysed N-methyl-N-nitrosourea (MNU)-induced mutations in two restriction recognition sequences of a target gene for mutation analysis and compared these data with what previously observed in a phenotypic mutation assay. DNA base changes in the Ncil and EcoRV sites of the gpt gene maintained in human cells by a shuttle vector system were measured by restriction fragment length polymorphism/polymerase chain reaction (RFLP/PCR) technique. After MNU-treatment of human cells, mutations were detected in the Ncil recognition sequence but not in the EcoRV site. DNA sequencing analysis revealed that all Ncil-resistant mutations were GC to AT transitions located over four bases of the Ncil recognition sequence. Only one of these mutations drastically affected the functionality of the GPT protein. The Ncil-resistant mutations were randomly distributed in both DNA strands of the gpt gene and were preferentially targeted at guanine residues flanked 5' by a guanine. Our results indicate that the structure of the GPT protein is the main contributor to the strand-specificity of MNU-induced mutations previously reported by using a phenotypic mutation assay. The potential use of the RFLP/PCR technique as a general tool for mutation detection is also discussed.     

Assessment of genotoxic potential of ethylenediamine: in vitro and in vivo studies

Ethylenediamine (EDA) was evaluated for potential genotoxic activity using a battery in vitro and in vivo mammalian tests. The tests employed were the Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) gene mutation assay, the sister-chromatid exchange (SCE) test with CHO cells, unscheduled DNA synthesis (UDS) assays with primary rat hepatocytes and a dominant lethal study with Fischer 344 rats. EDA did not produce a positive, dose-related, mutagenic effect in either the CHO mutation assay or in the SCE test when evaluated both with and without the addition of a rat-liver S9 activation system. With hepatocytes, no positive effects of EDA upon UDS values were noted in 2 separate studies using either a scintillation counting procedure or an autoradiographic method to determine UDS activity. In a dominant lethal study, male rats fed for 23 weeks with dietary levels of EDA X 2HCl of 0, 0.05, 0.15 or 0.50 g/kg/day, and mated with 1 virgin female/week for 3 consecutive weeks, showed no dose-related or statistically significant effects upon fertility, total number of implantations/female, or the number of living and dead implants per female; marked effects upon the incidence of dominant lethal mutations were noted in the positive control group injected intraperitoneally with one dose of 0.25 mg/kg triethylenemelamine. We conclude that EDA was not genotoxic in the in vitro and in vivo mammalian test systems employed.     

Testing strategies in mutagenicity and genetic toxicology: an appraisal of the guidelines of the European Scientific Committee for Cosmetics and Non-Food Products for the evaluation of hair dyes

The European Scientific Committee on Cosmetics and Non-Food Products (SCCNFP) guideline for testing of hair dyes for genotoxic/mutagenic/carcinogenic potential has been reviewed. The battery of six in vitro tests recommended therein differs substantially from the batteries of two or three in vitro tests recommended in other guidelines. Our evaluation of the chemical types used in hair dyes and comparison with other guidelines for testing a wide range of chemical substances, lead to the conclusion that potential genotoxic activity may effectively be determined by the application of a limited number of well-validated test systems that are capable of detecting induced gene mutations and structural and numerical chromosomal changes. We conclude that highly effective screening for genotoxicity of hair dyes can be achieved by the use of three assays, namely the bacterial gene mutation assay, the mammalian cell gene mutation assay (mouse lymphoma tk assay preferred) and the in vitro micronucleus assay. These need to be combined with metabolic activation systems optimised for the individual chemical types. Recent published evidence [D. Kirkland, M. Aardema, L. Henderson, L. Müller, Evaluation of the ability of a battery of three in vitro genotoxicity tests to discriminate rodent carcinogens and non-carcinogens. I. Sensitivity, specificity and relative predictivity, Mutat. Res. 584 (2005) 1-256] suggests that our recommended three tests will detect all known genotoxic carcinogens, and that increasing the number of in vitro assays further would merely reduce specificity (increase false positives). Of course there may be occasions when standard tests need to be modified to take account of special situations such as a specific pathway of biotransformation, but this should be considered as part of routine testing. It is clear that individual dyes and any other novel ingredients should be tested in this three-test battery. However, new products are formed on the scalp by reaction between the chemicals present in hair-dye formulations. Ideally, these should also be tested for genotoxicity, but at present such experiences are very limited. There is also the possibility that one component could mask the genotoxicity of another (e.g. by being more toxic), and so it is not practical at this time to recommend routine testing of complete hair-dye formulations as well. The most sensible approach would be to establish whether any reaction products within the hair-dye formulation penetrate the skin under normal conditions of use and test only those that penetrate at toxicologically relevant levels in the three-test in vitro battery. Recently published data [D. Kirkland, M. Aardema, L. Henderson, L. Müller, Evaluation of the ability of a battery of three in vitro genotoxicity tests to discriminate rodent carcinogens and non-carcinogens. I. Sensitivity, specificity and relative predictivity, Mutat. Res. 584 (2005) 1-256] suggest the three-test battery will produce a significant number of false as well as real positives. Whilst we are aware of the desire to reduce animal experiments, determining the relevance of positive results in any of the three recommended in vitro assays will most likely have to be determined by use of in vivo assays. The bone marrow micronucleus test using routes of administration such as oral or intraperitoneal may be used where the objective is extended hazard identification. If negative results are obtained in this test, then a second in vivo test should be conducted. This could be an in vivo UDS in rat liver or a Comet assay in a relevant tissue. However, for hazard characterisation, tests using topical application with measurement of genotoxicity in the skin would be more appropriate. Such specific site-of-contact in vivo tests would minimise animal toxicity burden and invasiveness, and, especially for hair dyes, be more relevant to human routes of exposure, but there are not sufficient scientific data available to allow recommendations to be made. The generation of such data is encouraged.