T/NK bipotent progenitors in the thymus retain the potential to generate dendritic cells

We have previously shown that the earliest thymic progenitors retain the potential to generate T and NK cells and that they lose the bipotentiality to give rise to unipotent T and NK progenitors during the progression of intrathymic developmental stages. The present study examines the ability of these thymic progenitors for generation of dendritic cells (DC) with a new clonal assay that is capable of determining the developmental potential for DC in addition to T cells and NK cells. We found that the large majority of the T/NK bipotential progenitors in the earliest population of fetal thymus was able to generate DC. Although the DC potential is lost with the progression of the differentiation stage, some of the T/NK bipotential progenitors still retain their DC potential even at the CD44(+)CD25(+) stage.     

Emergence of T, B, and myeloid lineage-committed as well as multipotent hemopoietic progenitors in the aorta-gonad-mesonephros region of day 10 fetuses of the mouse.

We investigated the developmental potential of hemopoietic progenitors in the aorta-gonad-mesonephros (AGM) region, where the definitive type hemopoietic progenitors have been shown to emerge before the fetal liver develops. By using an assay system that is able to determine the developmental potential of individual progenitors toward the T, B, and myeloid lineages, we show that not only multipotent progenitors but also progenitors committed to the T, B, or myeloid lineage already exist in this region of day 10 fetuses. Bipotent progenitors generating myeloid and T cells or those generating myeloid and B cells were also detected, suggesting that the commitment to T and B cell lineages is in progress in the AGM region. The numbers of these progenitors, however, were only 1/200-1/1000 of those in fetal liver of day 12 fetuses. Such small numbers of progenitors suggest that hemopoiesis has just started in the AGM region of day 10 fetuses. Although most of T cell lineage-committed progenitors in the AGM region generated only a small number of immature T cells, some were able to generate a large number of mature T cells. The detection of various types of lineage-committed progenitors strongly suggests that the AGM region is not only the site of stem cell emergence, but also the site of hemopoiesis, including lineage commitment. The T cell progenitors found in the AGM region may represent the first immigrants to the thymus anlage.     

Prethymic T-cell development defined by the expression of paired immunoglobulin-like receptors

T cells are produced in the thymus from progenitors of extrathymic origin. As no specific markers are available, the developmental pathway of progenitors preceding thymic colonization remains unclear. Here we show that progenitors in murine fetal liver and blood, which are capable of giving rise to T cells, NK cells and dendritic cells, but not B cells, can be isolated by their surface expression of paired immunoglobulin-like receptors (PIR). PIR expression is maintained until the earliest intrathymic stage, then downregulated before the onset of CD25 expression. Unlike intrathymic progenitors, generation of prethymic PIR(+) progenitors does not require Hes1-mediated Notch signaling. These findings disclose a prethymic stage of T-cell development programmed for immigration of the thymus, which is genetically separable from intrathymic stages.     

Generation of macrophages from early T progenitors in vitro

Early T progenitors in the thymus have been reported to have the capacity to develop into B cells, thymic dendritic cells, and NK cells. Here we describe conditions that induce early T progenitors to develop into macrophages. Initially, we observed that early T progenitors could be induced to develop into macrophages by cytokines produced from a thymic stromal cell line, TFGD, and later we found that the cytokine mixture of M-CSF plus IL-6 plus IL-7 also induced macrophage differentiation from pro-T cells. M-CSF by itself was unable to induce macrophage differentiation from early T progenitors. To correlate this observation with the developmental potential of early T progenitors, mouse embryonic thymocytes were sorted into four populations, pro-T1 to pro-T4, based on the expression of CD44 and CD25, and then cultured with TFGD culture supernatant. We found that pro-T1 and pro-T2 cells, but not pro-T3 and pro-T4 cells, generate macrophages. Limiting dilution analysis of the differentiation capability of sorted pro-T2 cells also confirmed that pro-T2 cells could generate macrophages. These results suggest that T cells and thymic macrophages could originate from a common intrathymic precursor.     

The earliest thymic progenitors in adults are restricted to T, NK, and dendritic cell lineage and have a potential to form more diverse TCRbeta chains than fetal progenitors

T cell progenitors in the adult thymus (AT) are not well characterized. In the present study, we show that the earliest progenitors in the murine AT are, like those in fetal thymus (FT), unable to generate B or myeloid cells, but still retain the ability to generate NK cells and dendritic cells. However, AT progenitors are distinct from those in FT or fetal liver, in that they are able to produce approximately 100 times larger numbers of T cells than progenitors in fetuses. Such a capability to generate a large number of T cells was mainly attributed to their potential to extensively proliferate before the TCRbeta chain gene rearrangement. We propose that the AT is colonized by T/NK/dendritic cell tripotential progenitors with much higher potential to form diversity in TCRbeta chains than FT progenitors.     

Emergence of T cell progenitors without B cell or myeloid differentiation potential at the earliest stage of hematopoiesis in the murine fetal liver

It has been unclear whether the progenitors colonizing the thymus are multipotent or T cell lineage restricted. We investigated the developmental potential of hematopoietic progenitors in various populations of liver and blood cells from day 12 fetuses using the recently established in vitro experimental system effective in determining the capability of individual progenitors to generate T, B, and myeloid cells. Multipotent progenitors (p-Multi) were exclusively found in the Sca-1 high-positive (Sca-1high) subpopulation of lineage marker (Lin)-c-kit+CD45+ fetal liver cells. Restriction of developmental capacity begins at the Sca-1high stage, and a large majority of progenitors in the Sca-1low or Sca-1- population are restricted to generate T, B, or myeloid cells. Such a lineage commitment or restriction taking place in the fetal liver is independent of the thymus, because no difference in the proportion of different types of progenitors were seen between nu/nu and nu/+ fetuses. T cell lineage-restricted progenitors (p-T) were abundant in the blood of day 12 fetuses, whereas p-Multi were undetectable. It was further shown that the p-Multi generated a large number of B and myeloid cells in the thymic lobe. These results strongly suggest that it is p-T but not p-Multi that migrate into the thymus.     

Clonal analysis reveals uniformity in the molecular profile and lineage potential of CCR9(+) and CCR9(-) thymus-settling progenitors

The entry of T cell progenitors to the thymus marks the beginning of a multistage developmental process that culminates in the generation of self-MHC-restricted CD4(+) and CD8(+) T cells. Although multiple factors including the chemokine receptors CCR7 and CCR9 are now defined as important mediators of progenitor recruitment and colonization in both the fetal and adult thymi, the heterogeneity of thymus-colonizing cells that contribute to development of the T cell pool is complex and poorly understood. In this study, in conjunction with lineage potential assays, we perform phenotypic and genetic analyses on thymus-settling progenitors (TSP) isolated from the embryonic mouse thymus anlagen and surrounding perithymic mesenchyme, including simultaneous gene expression analysis of 14 hemopoietic regulators using single-cell multiplex RT-PCR. We show that, despite the known importance of CCL25-CCR9 mediated thymic recruitment of T cell progenitors, embryonic PIR(+)c-Kit(+) TSP can be subdivided into CCR9(+) and CCR9(-) subsets that differ in their requirements for a functional thymic microenvironment for thymus homing. Despite these differences, lineage potential studies of purified CCR9(+) and CCR9(-) TSP reveal a common bias toward T cell-committed progenitors, and clonal gene expression analysis reveals a genetic consensus that is evident between and within single CCR9(+) and CCR9(-) TSP. Collectively, our data suggest that although the earliest T cell progenitors may display heterogeneity with regard to their requirements for thymus colonization, they represent a developmentally homogeneous progenitor pool that ensures the efficient generation of the first cohorts of T cells during thymus development.     

Human thymic epithelial cells inhibit IL-15- and IL-2-driven differentiation of NK cells from the early human thymic progenitors

T/NK progenitors are present in the thymus; however, the thymus predominantly promotes T cell development. In this study, we demonstrated that human thymic epithelial cells (TEC) inhibit NK cell development. Most ex vivo human thymocytes express CD1a, indicating that thymic progenitors are predominantly committed to the T cell lineage. In contrast, the CD1a(-)CD3(-)CD56(+) NK population comprises only 0.2% (n = 7) of thymocytes. However, we observed increases in the percentage (20- to 25-fold) and absolute number (13- to 71-fold) of NK cells when thymocytes were cultured with mixtures of either IL-2, IL-7, and stem cell factor or IL-15, IL-7, and stem cell factor. TEC, when present in the cultures, inhibited the increases in the percentage (3- to 10-fold) and absolute number (3- to 25-fold) of NK cells. Furthermore, we show that TEC-derived soluble factors inhibit generation of NK-CFU and inhibit IL15- or IL2-driven NK cell differentiation from thymic CD34(+) triple-negative thymocytes. The inhibitory activity was found to be associated with a 8,000- to 30,000 Da fraction. Thus, our data demonstrate that TEC inhibit NK cell development from T/NK CD34(+) triple negative progenitors via soluble factor(s), suggesting that the human thymic microenvironment not only actively promotes T cell maturation but also controls the development of non-T lineage cells such as the NK lineage.     

A common pathway for dendritic cell and early B cell development

B cells and dendritic cells (DCs) each develop from poorly described progenitor cells in the bone marrow (BM). Although a subset of DCs has been proposed to arise from lymphoid progenitors, a common developmental pathway for B cells and BM-derived DCs has not been clearly identified. To address this possibility, we performed a comprehensive analysis of DC differentiative potential among lymphoid and B lymphoid progenitor populations in adult mouse BM. We found that both the common lymphoid progenitors (CLPs), shown here and elsewhere to give rise exclusively to lymphocytes, and a down-stream early B-lineage precursor population devoid of T and NK cell precursor potential each give rise to DCs when exposed to the appropriate cytokines. This result contrasts with more mature B-lineage precursors, all of which failed to give rise to detectable numbers of DCs. Significantly, both CLP and early B-lineage-derived DCs acquired several surface markers associated with functional DCs, and CLP-derived DCs readily induced proliferation of allogeneic CD4(+) T cells. Surprisingly, however, DC differentiation from both lymphoid-restricted progenitors was accompanied by up-regulation of CD11b expression, a cell surface molecule normally restricted to myeloid lineage cells including putative myeloid DCs. Together, these data demonstrate that loss of DC developmental potential is the final step in B-lineage commitment and thus reveals a previously unrecognized link between early B cell and DC ontogeny.     

Notch1 and IL-7 receptor interplay maintains proliferation of human thymic progenitors while suppressing non-T cell fates

Notch signaling is critical for T cell development of multipotent hemopoietic progenitors. Yet, how Notch regulates T cell fate specification during early thymopoiesis remains unclear. In this study, we have identified an early subset of CD34high c-kit+ flt3+ IL-7Ralpha+ cells in the human postnatal thymus, which includes primitive progenitors with combined lymphomyeloid potential. To assess the impact of Notch signaling in early T cell development, we expressed constitutively active Notch1 in such thymic lymphomyeloid precursors (TLMPs), or triggered their endogenous Notch pathway in the OP9-Delta-like1 stroma coculture. Our results show that proliferation vs differentiation is a critical decision influenced by Notch at the TLMP stage. We found that Notch signaling plays a prominent role in inhibiting non-T cell differentiation (i.e., macrophages, dendritic cells, and NK cells) of TLMPs, while sustaining the proliferation of undifferentiated thymocytes with T cell potential in response to unique IL-7 signals. However, Notch activation is not sufficient for inducing T-lineage progression of proliferating progenitors. Rather, stroma-derived signals are concurrently required. Moreover, while ectopic IL-7R expression cannot replace Notch for the maintenance and expansion of undifferentiated thymocytes, Notch signals sustain IL-7R expression in proliferating thymocytes and induce IL-7R up-regulation in a T cell line. Thus, IL-7R and Notch pathways cooperate to synchronize cell proliferation and suppression of non-T lineage choices in primitive intrathymic progenitors, which will be allowed to progress along the T cell pathway only upon interaction with an inductive stromal microenvironment. These data provide insight into a mechanism of Notch-regulated amplification of the intrathymic pool of early human T cell progenitors.     

Cutting edge: Thymic NK cells develop independently from T cell precursors

Although NK cells in the mouse are thought to develop in the bone marrow, a small population of NK cells in the thymus has been shown to derive from a GATA3-dependent pathway. Characteristically, thymic NK cells express CD127 and few Ly49 molecules and lack CD11b. Because these NK cells develop in the thymus, the question of their relationship to the T cell lineage has been raised. Using several different mouse models, we find that unlike T cells, thymic NK cells are not the progeny of Rorc-expressing progenitors and do not express Rag2 or rearrange the TCRγ locus. We further demonstrate that thymic NK cells develop independently of the Notch signaling pathway, supporting the idea that thymic NK cells represent bona fide NK cells that can develop independently of all T cell precursors.     

T cell lineage determination precedes the initiation of TCR beta gene rearrangement

Loss of dendritic cell potential is one of the major events in intrathymic T cell development, during which the progenitors become determined to the T cell lineage. However, it remains unclear whether this event occurs in synchrony with another important event, TCRbeta chain gene rearrangement, which has been considered the definitive sign of irreversible T cell lineage commitment. To address this issue, we used transgenic mice in which GFP expression is controlled by the lck proximal promoter. We found that the double-negative (DN) 2 stage can be subdivided into GFP- and GFP+ populations, representing functionally different developmental stages in that the GFP-DN2, but not GFP+DN2, cells retain dendritic cell potential. The GFP+DN2 cells were found to undergo several rounds of proliferation before the initiation of TCRbeta rearrangement as evidenced by the diversity of D-Jbeta rearrangements seen in T cells derived from a single GFP+DN2 progenitor. These results indicated that the determination step of progenitors to the T cell lineage is a separable event from TCRbeta rearrangement.     

Characterization of developmental pathway of natural killer cells from embryonic stem cells in vitro

In vitro differentiation of embryonic stem (ES) cells is often used to study hematopoiesis. However, the differentiation pathway of lymphocytes, in particular natural killer (NK) cells, from ES cells is still unclear. Here, we used a multi-step in vitro ES cell differentiation system to study lymphocyte development from ES cells, and to characterize NK developmental intermediates. We generated embryoid bodies (EBs) from ES cells, isolated CD34(+) EB cells and cultured them on OP9 stroma with a cocktail of cytokines to generate cells we termed ES-derived hematopoietic progenitors (ES-HPs). EB cell subsets, as well as ES-HPs derived from EBs, were tested for NK, T, B and myeloid lineage potentials using lineage specific cultures. ES-HPs derived from CD34(+) EBs differentiated into NK cells when cultured on OP9 stroma with IL-2 and IL-15, and into T cells on Delta-like 1-transduced OP9 (OP9-DL1) with IL-7 and Flt3-L. Among CD34(+) EB cells, NK and T cell potentials were detected in a CD45(-) subset, whereas CD45(+) EB cells had myeloid but not lymphoid potentials. Limiting dilution analysis of ES-HPs generated from CD34(+)CD45(-) EB cells showed that CD45(+)Mac-1(-)Ter119(-) ES-HPs are highly enriched for NK progenitors, but they also have T, B and myeloid potentials. We concluded that CD45(-)CD34(+) EB cells have lymphoid potential, and they differentiate into more mature CD45(+)Lin(-) hematopoietic progenitors that have lymphoid and myeloid potential. NK progenitors among ES-HPs are CD122(-) and they rapidly acquire CD122 as they differentiate along the NK lineage.     

Expression of alpha(4)beta(7) integrin defines a distinct pathway of lymphoid progenitors committed to T cells, fetal intestinal lymphotoxin producer, NK, and dendritic cells

During embryogenesis, the Peyer's patch anlagen are induced by a cell population that produces lymphotoxin (LT) alpha(1)beta(2) following stimulation of IL-7Ralpha. In this study, we show that the LT-producing cell is localized within the IL-7Ralpha(+) and integrin alpha(4)beta(7) (alpha(4)beta(7))(+) population in the embryonic intestine. Lineage commitment to the LT producer phenotype in the fetal liver coincides with expression of alpha(4)beta(7). Before expression of alpha(4)beta(7), the potential of IL-7Ralpha(+) population to generate B cells is lost. However, the progenitors for T cells and LT producer cells reside in the IL-7Ralpha(+)alpha(4)beta(7)(+) cells, but during subsequent differentiation, the potential to give rise to T cells is lost. This IL-7Ralpha(+)alpha(4)beta(7)(+) population migrates to the intestine, where it induces the Peyer's patch anlagen. When stimulated with IL-15 or IL-3 and TNF, the intestinal IL-7Ralpha(+)alpha(4)beta(7)(+) population can differentiate into fully competent NK1.1(+) NK cells or CD11c(+) APCs. Expression of alpha(4)beta(7) is lost during differentiation of both lineages; IL-7Ralpha expression is lost during NK1.1(+) cells differentiation. A newly discovered lineage(-)IL-7Ralpha(+)c-Kit(+)alpha(4)beta(7)(+) population in the fetal liver is committed to T, NK, dendritic, and fetal intestinal LT producer lineage, the latter being an intermediate stage during differentiation of NK and dendritic cells.     

CCR7 ligands, SLC/6Ckine/Exodus2/TCA4 and CKbeta-11/MIP-3beta/ELC, are chemoattractants for CD56(+)CD16(-) NK cells and late stage lymphoid progenitors

Two human CC chemokines, SLC/6Ckine/Exodus2/TCA4 and CKbeta-11/MIP-3beta/ELC, are previously reported as efficacious chemoattractants for T- and B-cells and dendritic cells. SLC and CKbeta-11 share only 32% amino acid identity, but are ligands for the same chemokine receptor, CCR7. In this study, we examined chemotactic activity of SLC and CKbeta-11 for NK cells and lymphoid progenitors in bone marrow and thymus. It was found that these two CCR7 ligands are chemoattractants for neonatal cord blood and adult peripheral blood NK cells and cell lines. SLC and CKbeta-11 preferentially attract the CD56(+)CD16(-) NK cell subset over CD56(+)CD16(+) NK cells. SLC and CKbeta-11 also demonstrate selective chemotactic activity on late stage CD34(-)CD19(+)IgM- B-cell progenitors and CD4(+) and CD8(+) single-positive thymocytes, but not early stage progenitors. It was noted that SLC is an efficient desensitizer of CKbeta-11-dependent NK cell chemotaxis, while CKbeta-11 is a weak desensitizer of SLC-dependent chemotaxis. Taken together, these results suggest that SLC and CKbeta-11 have the potential to control trafficking of NK cell subsets and late stage lymphoid progenitors in bone marrow and thymus.     

B lymphopoiesis in the thymus

The thymus has been regarded as the major site of T cell differentiation. We find that in addition to alphabeta and gammadelta T cells, a significant number (approximately 3 x 104 per day) of B220+IgM+ mature B cells are exported from the thymus of C57BL/6 mice. Of these emigrating B cells, we estimate that at least approximately 2 x 104 per day are cells which developed intrathymically, whereas a maximum of approximately 0.8 x 104 per day are cells which circulated through the thymus from the periphery. The thymus possesses a significant number of pro-B and pre-B cells that express CD19, VpreB, lambda5, and pax-5. These B cell progenitors were found in the thymic cortex, whereas increasingly mature B cells were found in the corticomedullar and medullary regions. Other lymphoid cells, including NK cells and lymphoid dendritic cells, are not exported from the thymus at detectable levels. Thus, the thymus contributes to the formation of peripheral pools of B cells as well as of alphabeta and gammadelta T cells.     

The common myelolymphoid progenitor: a key intermediate stage in hemopoiesis generating T and B cells

We have previously shown that the common progenitors for myeloid, T, and B cell lineages are enriched in the earliest population of murine fetal liver. However, it remained unclear whether such multipotent progenitors represent the pluripotent progenitors capable of generating all hemopoietic cells or they also comprise progenitors restricted to myeloid, T, and B cell lineages. To address this issue, we have developed a new clonal assay covering myeloid, erythroid, T, and B cell lineages, and using this assay the developmental potential of individual cells in subpopulations of lineage marker-negative (Lin(-)) c-kit(+) murine fetal liver cells was investigated. We identified the progenitor generating myeloid, T, and B cells, but not erythroid cells in the Sca-1(high) subpopulation of Lin(-)c-kit(+) cells that can thus be designated as the common myelolymphoid progenitor (CMLP). Common myeloerythroid progenitors were also detected. These findings strongly suggest that the first branching point in fetal hemopoiesis is between the CMLP and common myeloerythroid progenitors. T and B cell progenitors may be derived from the CMLP through the previously identified myeloid/T and myeloid/B bipotent stages, respectively.     

Entry into the thymic microenvironment triggers Notch activation in the earliest migrant T cell progenitors

Interactions between T cell precursors and thymic stromal cells are essential during thymocyte development. However, the role of the thymus in initial commitment of lymphoid progenitors to the T lineage remains controversial, with data providing evidence for both extra- and intrathymic commitment mechanisms. In this context, it is clear that Notch1 is an important mediator during initiation of T cell development. Here we have analyzed the mechanisms regulating Notch activation in lymphoid precursors at extrathymic sites and in the thymus, including stages representing the first wave of embryonic thymus colonization on embryonic day 12 of gestation. We show that Notch activation in migrant lymphoid precursors requires entry into the thymic microenvironment where they are exposed to Notch ligands expressed by immature thymic epithelial cells. Moreover, continued Notch signaling in such precursors requires sustained interactions with Notch ligands. Collectively, these findings suggest a role for Notch in an intrathymic mechanism of T cell lineage commitment involving sustained interactions with Notch ligand bearing thymic epithelium.     

The blood contains multiple distinct progenitor populations with clonogenic B and T lineage potential

The thymus is seeded by bone marrow-derived progenitors that circulate in the blood. Multiple cell types can be found in the thymus early after i.v. administration or in steady state, but most fail to satisfy the known characteristics of true T progenitors. Cells that do conform to classical definitions retain multilineage potential, but surprisingly, cannot make B cells. Because acquisition of the T lineage fate among noncommitted progenitors is a lengthy process, the absence of B cell potential in early thymocytes suggests that B and T lineages diverge prethymically. To test this suggestion, we screened numerous presumptive progenitor populations for T cell growth and differentiation potential, as well as for clonogenic T or B cell development. We find that blood and marrow each contain multiple distinct subsets that display growth and differentiation potential consistent with being canonical T progenitors. Assessment of clonogenic potential further shows that although all blood and marrow populations have high T cell cloning potential, no T/non-B cells are apparent. These data suggest that either true thymic reconstitution potential derives from a small T/non-B cell subset of one of these populations, or that most of the cells defined as canonical progenitors within the thymus do not, in fact, reside in the mainstream of T progenitor differentiation.