Unwounded plants elicit Agrobacterium vir gene induction and T-DNA transfer: transformed plant cells produce opines yet are tumour free

Agrobacterium tumefaciens is well known to cause crown gall tumours at plant wound sites and to benefit from this plant association by obtaining nutrients called opines that are produced by these tumours. Tumourigenesis requires expression of the vir regulon in response to chemical signals that are thought to be released from wound sites. Here, we examine chemical interactions between A. tumefaciens and unwounded plants. To determine whether unwounded plants can release significant amounts of vir gene inducers, we constructed an A. tumefaciens strain carrying a PvirB-gfp fusion. This fusion was strongly induced by co-culture with tobacco seedlings that have been germinated without any intentional wounding. The release of phenolic vir gene inducers was confirmed by GC/MS analysis. We also constructed a strain containing the gfp reporter located on an artificial T-DNA and expressed from a plant promoter. A. tumefaciens efficiently transferred this T-DNA into cells of unwounded plants in the absence of exogenous vir gene inducers. Many cells of seedlings colonized by the bacteria also produced octopine, which was detected using a Pocc-gfp reporter strain. This indicates transfer of the native T-DNA. However, these transformed plant cells did not form tumours. These results suggest that successful colonization of plants by A. tumefaciens, including T-DNA transfer and opine production, does not require wounding and does not necessarily cause cell proliferation. Transformation of plant cells without inciting tumours may represent a colonization strategy for this pathogen that has largely been overlooked.     

Activity of the quorum-sensing regulator TraR of Agrobacterium tumefaciens is inhibited by a truncated, dominant defective TraR-like protein

Horizontal transfer of Agrobacterium tumefaciens tumour-inducing plasmids requires opines, which are released from plant tumours as nutrients for the bacteria. The opine octopine causes synthesis of the quorum-sensing TraR protein, which activates several tra promoters in the presence of a pheromone called Agrobacterium autoinducer (AAI). A gene, traS , was previously found on the same Ti plasmid in an operon that directs the uptake of mannopine, another opine. TraS strongly resembles TraR but lacks a DNA-binding module. TraS did not activate a TraR-dependent promoter and blocked TraR function, probably by forming inactive heteromultimers. Expression of traS was induced by mannopine, although this induction was strongly inhibited by the favoured catabolites succinate, glutamine and tryptone. Mannopine inhibited conjugation in a TraS-dependent fashion, and artificial overexpression of TraS also inhibited conjugation. Favoured catabolites restored tra gene expression in wild-type strains but not in strains that overexpress TraS. Downstream of traS is a gene encoding a truncated, defective chemoreceptor whose expression abolished chemotaxis.     

Structure and characterization of the crown gall opines heliopine, vitopine and ridéopine

The crown gall opines heliopine from tumors induced by octopine type Agrobacterium tumefaciens strains A6, A136(pTiB6-806), E9, A652 and 1590-1 and vitopine from tumor induced by grapevine strains S4 and T2 are identical to synthetic N2-(1'R-carboxyethyl)-L-glutamine. Tumors produced by strains S4 and T2 do not contain octopine or lysopine, but they do contain heliopine and the new opine ridéopine identified as N-(4'-aminobutyl)-D-glutamic acid. Grapevine strains S4 and T2 grow normally on tumor heliopine or synthetic heliopine and on tumor and synthetic ridéopine as well as on ridéopine lactam as sole carbon source. While octopine strains A6 and A136(pTiB6-806) do not grow on heliopine, mutant colonies do appear after a few weeks. Heliopine catabolism by octopine strains is not induced by octopine.     

Isolation of Agrobacterium Ti-plasmid regulatory mutants

Summary Crown gall tumors incited by Agrobacterium tumefaciens synthesize basic amino acid derivatives called opines. Opine production in tumours and opine catabolism by A. tumefaciens are coded by Ti-plasmids which confer oncogenicity on this bacterium. Catabolism of opines is inducible, and a method for isolation of regulatory mutants is described. From octopine-type bacteria, by plating on non-inducing substrates (noroctopine, noroctopine acid, D-histopine) we have isolated regulatory mutants of three types: constitutive, partially constitutive, and fully inducible by the analogue. From nopaline-type bacteria, by plating on octopine (a non inducing substrate) we have isolated analogous regulatory mutants.Synthetic opines, in which the amino acid moiety has been replaced by toxic arginine analogues, are toxic for these regulatory mutants. We isolated mutants resistant to such synthetic opines, and found that some had lost the capacity to utilize octopine. A survey of a large number of such mutants revealed that all of them still incited octopine synthetizing tumors.Mutants constitutive for octopine catabolism are in some instances also constitutive for Ti-plasmid transfer. A simple method for screening regulatory mutants for constitutive Ti-plasmid transfer is described.This work has been supported in part by grants from the Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique (contrats ATP 2814 and 3363).     

Arginine catabolism: a new function of both octopine and nopaline Ti-plasmids of Agrobacterium.

Summary The oncogenic plasmids of Agrobacterium, the Ti-plasmids, carry genes that enable their bacterial host to catabolize opines. Opines are unusual amino acid derivatives that are only produced in crown gall tumours incited by oncogenic strains of Agrobacterium. The 2 opines, octopine and nopaline, are degraded by Agrobacterium strains carrying the octopine or the nopoline Ti-plasmid, respectively, to arginine and pyruvic acid, and to arginine and -ketoglutaric acid. In this paper it is shown that the Ti-plasmids carry gene(s) involved in the utilisation of arginine as a carbon source. Strains harbouring wild type octopine or nopaline Ti-plasmids in the chromosomal context of strain C58C1 do not grow on arginine as a carbon source. However, they are able to grow on arginine provided that they are induced, or constitutive for opine catabolism. The features of ornithine utilisation are identical. The gene(s) involved in arginine and ornithine utilization in C58C1 (pTi-oct) or C58C1 (pTi-nop) are under the control of the regulator gene that controls octopine or nopaline catabolism. A tentative pathway of octopine utilization is proposed, in which at least two steps are Ti-plasmid coded, and probably belong to the same operon: 1-scission of octopine into arginine and pyruvic acid 2-transformation of an arginine derivative (GSA?) to glutamic acid.Arginine utilization as a carbon source is therefore a new function of the Ti-plasmid. As this function is not inducible by arginine but by opines, it provides a method for selecting regulatory mutants of opine catabolism in the genetic background of strain C58.     

Specificity of Octopine Uptake by Rhizobium and Pseudomonas Strains

The octopine-utilizing strain Agrobacterium tumefaciens B6S3 and three nonagrobacteria which had the capacity to utilize this opine were compared for octopine uptake. The characteristics of uptake by Rhizobium meliloti A3 and strain B6S3 were similar. In both bacteria, uptake activity was inducible by octopine and by the related opine octopinic acid, and competition assays showed that these two opine substrates were accepted by the same uptake system with an equivalent affinity. Cells of Pseudomonas putida 203 accumulated octopine against a concentration gradient, and this activity was induced specifically by octopine. While strain 203 did not utilize octopinic acid, a spontaneous mutant with a combined capacity for octopine and octopinic acid utilization was obtained. Both opines induced octopine uptake by this mutant, but octopinic acid was not a substrate for the induced system. Thus, the Pseudomonas uptake system exhibited a different specificity for octopine than the corresponding Agrobacterium system. The nonfluorescent pseudomonad GU187j, which utilized the three related opines octopine, octopinic acid, and nopaline, was constitutive for octopine uptake. Strain GU187j possessed a system which accepted these three opines, but not arginine or ornithine, with a similar affinity.     

Detection of opines by colorimetric assay

A colorimetric procedure for confirming the presence of arginine-derived opines (nopaline and octopine) in plant tissue extracts is described. Those materials are widely used as markers of plant cell transformation and tumorigenesis mediated by the tumor-inducing plasmids of Agrobacterium tumefaciens. Nopaline and octopine are generally detected, following resolution by paper electrophoresis, by observation of the uv-fluorescent products formed upon reaction with phenanthrenequinone. We found that a further heat treatment step, compatible with paper electrophoresis, results in rapid production of a red-purple pigment. Our colorimetric assay is sensitive to 1.25-micrograms quantities of opine and eliminates problems of background fluorescence encountered with crude plant extract in the usual assay.     

Ornithine cyclodeaminase from octopine Ti plasmid Ach5: identification, DNA sequence, enzyme properties, and comparison with gene and enzyme from nopaline Ti plasmid C58.

Octopine and nopaline are two arginine-derived opines synthesized in plant cells transformed with octopine or nopaline plasmids. Utilization in Agrobacterium tumefaciens is mediated by Ti plasmid regions called occ or noc (octopine or nopaline catabolism), and recent experiments showed that noc in pTiC58 codes for a pathway from nopaline to L-proline. The last enzyme is ornithine cyclodeaminase (OCD), an unusual protein converting L-ornithine directly into L-proline. We investigated whether octopine plasmid pTiAch5 also harbors a gene for OCD. The results revealed an ocd gene which is induced by octopine and maps in the occ region. DNA sequence analysis and comparison with the gene from pTiC58 showed that the two genes are related (69% homology in DNA and deduced amino acid sequence), and antiserum against OCD(C58) also reacted with OCD(Ach5). The enzyme activity was characterized, and a comparison with OCD(C58) showed that the properties are similar, but not identical. Differences were detected in the regulation of enzyme activity by L-arginine and L-proline and in the response to varying ratios of NAD+/NADH. It is proposed that this reflects different mechanisms for integration of opine catabolism into general metabolism.     

The in vitro effects of opines and other compounds on DNAs originating from bacteria, and from healthy and tumorous plant tissues

Purified total DNAs were isolated from oncogenic or nononcogenic Agrobacterium tumefaciens cells as well as from normal and crown gall tissues. Opines (octopine, nopaline, lysopine), plant hormone (auxin IAA) and some carcinogenic compounds were used in order to correlate their effects on in vitro strand separation and synthesis of DNAs with in vivo tumorous cell multiplication. Octopine (or nopaline) induced chain opening of DNAs originating from octopine (or nopaline)-metabolizing bacteria and from same bacteria strain-induced tumorous cells. This phenomenon was measured by the increase in DNA hyperchromicity which is concentration dependent. The tested compounds stimulated the in vitro synthesis of the same DNAs. Under the same conditions, in vitro strand separation and synthesis of healthy plant DNA was not (or only slightly) enhanced, except in the case of particular hormone-connected healthy cell DNA. IAA and carcinogens stimulated in vitro synthesis and induced in vitro strand separation (dose-dependent effect) of DNAs isolated from crown gall cells and inducing bacteria. Compared to healthy cell DNAs, these DNAs were thus susceptible to structurally very diversified molecules and in this way behave as do mammalian tissue DNAs. The opine and IAA actions observed here were specific for plant tissue DNA; cancerous human or animal tissue DNAs were insensitive. By their presence in the crown gall cells, opines possibly maintain destabilized areas (required for rapid growth and division) on tumor cell DNA. The cooperative actions of IAA and opines as well as small RNA and RNA fragments on gene activation, might explain the autonomy of plant tumor cells.     

Co-evolution of the agrocinopine opines and the agrocinopine-mediated control of TraR, the quorum-sensing activator of the Ti plasmid conjugation system

Conjugal transfer of Agrobacterium tumefaciens Ti plasmids is controlled by a hierarchical system in which opines, substrates produced by crown gall tumours, induce a quorum-sensing system. The cascade results from the control of expression of traR, the quorum-sensing activator, by a regulator responsive to the opine. In the two cases studied to date, the gene arrangements responsible for the cascade differ remarkably, suggesting that considerable diversity exists among the many Ti-like plasmids in the agrobacteria. In this study, we demonstrated that the novel Ti plasmid pTiChry5 is induced to transfer at high frequency by extracts from tumours initiated by strain Chry5. The purified inducer had the chemical and biological properties of agrocinopines C and D, a set of sugar phosphodiester opines known to induce transfer of another Ti plasmid, pTiBo542. The T-region of pTiChry5 contained a gene whose product, called Acs(Chry5), is virtually identical to the agrocinopine C+D synthase from the T-region of pTiBo542. The two genes are less closely related to acs of pTiC58, which is responsible for the production of agrocinopines A+B, a similar but not identical set of phosphodiester opines by tumours induced by strain C58. Agrocinopines A+B induce transfer of pTiC58 but did not induce transfer of pTi(Chry5). A single copy of traR was identified at the 11 o'clock region of pTi(Chry5), where it is part of a two-gene operon called arc(Chry5). Although altered by deletions, arc(Chry5) is related to the five-gene arc operon that controls the expression of traR on pTiC58. Expression of traR(Chry5) was induced by agrocinopines C+D and the opines isolated from Chry5 tumours but not by agrocinopines A+B. A mutation in traR(Chry5) abolished transfer, and transfer was restored by complementation in trans. We conclude that the agrocinopine opines and the corresponding opine-meditated conjugal regulatory regions of pTiChry5 and pTiC58 share a common origin, but that the opine signals for the two Ti plasmids have evolved divergently through changes in the opine synthase enzymes. The alterations in the opines, in turn, necessitated a co-evolutionary change in the opine recognition systems responsible for controlling expression of the traR genes on these two types of Ti plasmids.     

Fungal Catabolism of Crown Gall Opines

This study was conducted to determine the capacities of 37 fungi to utilize various crown gall opines as their sole carbon and nitrogen source. One strain of Fusarium solani, two of Cylindrocarpon destructans, and six of Cylindrocarpon heteronema catabolized octopine, mannopine, octopinic acid, succinamopine, or a combination of these opines. One C. heteronema and one Fusarium dimerum strain grew only on succinamopine. None of the fungal isolates had the ability to grow on nopaline. The catabolism of opines by fungi was confirmed by the disappearance of the opine from the growth medium and by an increase in final mycelial dry weight with rising initial concentration of test substrate. This study thus shows that the catabolism of opines is not restricted to bacteria.     

Diversity of Opines and Opine-Catabolizing Bacteria Isolated from Naturally Occurring Crown Gall Tumors

The diversity of opines from 43 naturally occurring crown gall tumors on several plant species was analyzed for the presence of agropine, chrysopine, iminodiacid, an unidentified leucinopine-like iminodiacid (IDA-B), mannopine, octopine, nopaline, DL- and LL-succinamopine, leucinopine and heliopine. Opine utilization patterns of agrobacteria and fluorescent pseudomonads resident in a tumor were then analyzed and compared for agreement with the opine isolated from that tumor. Nopaline was the most common opine found and was detected in tumors from cherry, blackberry, grape, and plum. Octopine was not found, although octopine-catabolizing bacteria were isolated from several tumors. A new, previously undescribed iminodiacid of the succinamopine-leucinopine type (provisionally designated IDA-B) was isolated from tumors of wild blackberry. Field tumors from apple, blueberry and grape yielded no detectable opines, even though opine-utilizing bacteria were present. Bacterial isolates from plum and cherry showed the best correspondence between the opine in tumors (nopaline) and the presence of bacteria that catabolized that opine. However, several unusual opine catabolic combinations were identified, including isolates that catabolized a variety of opines but were nonpathogenic. More variability was observed among isolates from field tumors on the remaining plant species. We isolated novel mannopine-nopaline type agrobacteria from field tumors of cherry, plum and blackberry that induced tumors containing either mannopine (plus agropine) or nopaline, but not both. Epidemiologically, the galled plants from an area were not of clonal origin (same Ti plasmid), indicating that the field tumors from a small area were incited by more than one type of Ti plasmid.     

N2-(1-carboxyethyl)methionine. A ''pseudo-opine'' in octopine-type crown-gall tumours.

A novel methionine-containing plasmid-determined compound, N2-(1-carboxyethyl)methionine (NCEM) has been identified in crown-gall tumours induced by octopine-type strains of Agrobacterium tumefaciens. NCEM is probably synthesized by octopine synthase. Cell-free preparations from octopine-type strains of A. tumefaciens can degrade NCEM; however, the bacterium cannot transport the compound into the cell, although these strains can take up and degrade the octopine family of opines.     

Transport of nonmetabolizable opines by Agrobacterium tumefaciens.

We have examined the uptake of [14C]octopine and [14C]nopaline by Agrobacterium tumefaciens strains containing the C58 chromosomal background in medium suitable for the induction of vir genes. All strains tested could transport both of these opines, regardless of the presence or type of Ti plasmid (octopine or nopaline) present in the bacterium. The transport of these opines required active cellular metabolism. Nonradioactive octopine, nopaline, and arginine competed effectively with [14C]octopine and [14C]nopaline for transport into A. tumefaciens A136, suggesting that the transport of these opines occurs via an arginine transport pathway not encoded by the Ti plasmid.     

Aeromonas, a possible etiological agent in the formation of secondary tumors of crown gall

Abstract From a secondary tumor in a bean stem we have isolated a Gram-negative bacteria, named by us T.2. These bean stems had crown gall tumors induced by the ATV strain of Agrobacterium tumefaciens . This bacterium was classified as belonging to the genus Aeromonas and possesses the capacity of inducing overgrowths in plants, synthesizing indole acetic acid (IAA). The codified phenotypic characteristics of bacterium T.2. via the Ti-plasmid of A. tumefaciens , such as opine utilization and sensitivity to agrocin 84, have been studied. Neither octopine nor nopaline is utilized by T.2. and it is resistant to agrocin 84, whereas the strain ATV of A. tumefaciens utilizes nopaline, and is sensitive to agrocin 84.