Topology of the outer membrane usher PapC determined by site-directed fluorescence labeling

In contrast to typical membrane proteins that span the lipid bilayer via transmembrane alpha-helices, bacterial outer membrane proteins adopt a beta-barrel architecture composed of antiparallel transmembrane beta-strands. The topology of outer membrane proteins is difficult to predict accurately using computer algorithms, and topology mapping protocols commonly used for alpha-helical membrane proteins do not work for beta-barrel proteins. We present here the topology of the PapC usher, an outer membrane protein required for assembly and secretion of P pili by the chaperone/usher pathway in uropathogenic Escherichia coli. An initial attempt to map PapC topology by insertion of protease cleavage sites was largely unsuccessful due to lack of cleavage at most sites and the requirement to disrupt the outer membrane to identify periplasmic sites. We therefore adapted a site-directed fluorescence labeling technique to permit topology mapping of outer membrane proteins using small molecule probes in intact bacteria. Using this method, we demonstrated that PapC has the potential to encode up to 32 transmembrane beta-strands. Based on experimental evidence, we propose that the usher consists of an N-terminal beta-barrel domain comprised of 26 beta-strands and that a distinct C-terminal domain is not inserted into the membrane but is located instead within the lumen of the N-terminal beta-barrel similar to the plug domains encoded by the outer membrane iron-siderophore uptake proteins.     

Function of the usher N-terminus in catalysing pilus assembly

The chaperone/usher (CU) pathway is a conserved bacterial secretion system that assembles adhesive fibres termed pili or fimbriae. Pilus biogenesis by the CU pathway requires a periplasmic chaperone and an outer membrane (OM) assembly platform termed the usher. The usher catalyses formation of subunit-subunit interactions to promote polymerization of the pilus fibre and provides the channel for fibre secretion. The mechanism by which the usher catalyses pilus assembly is not known. Using the P and type 1 pilus systems of uropathogenic Escherichia coli, we show that a conserved N-terminal disulphide region of the PapC and FimD ushers, as well as residue F4 of FimD, are required for the catalytic activity of the ushers. PapC disulphide loop mutants were able to bind PapDG chaperone-subunit complexes, but did not assemble PapG into pilus fibres. FimD disulphide loop and F4 mutants were able to bind chaperone-subunit complexes and initiate assembly of pilus fibres, but were defective for extending the pilus fibres, as measured using in vivo co-purification and in vitro pilus polymerization assays. These results suggest that the catalytic activity of PapC is required to initiate pilus biogenesis, whereas the catalytic activity of FimD is required for extension of the pilus fibre.     

Bacterial outer membrane ushers contain distinct targeting and assembly domains for pilus biogenesis

Biogenesis of a superfamily of surface structures by gram-negative bacteria requires the chaperone/usher pathway, a terminal branch of the general secretory pathway. In this pathway a periplasmic chaperone works together with an outer membrane usher to direct substrate folding, assembly, and secretion to the cell surface. We analyzed the structure and function of the PapC usher required for P pilus biogenesis by uropathogenic Escherichia coli. Structural analysis indicated PapC folds as a beta-barrel with short extracellular loops and extensive periplasmic domains. Several periplasmic regions were localized, including two domains containing conserved cysteine pairs. Functional analysis of deletion mutants revealed that the PapC C terminus was not required for insertion of the usher into the outer membrane or for proper folding. The usher C terminus was not necessary for interaction with chaperone-subunit complexes in vitro but was required for pilus biogenesis in vivo. Interestingly, coexpression of PapC C-terminal truncation mutants with the chromosomal fim gene cluster coding for type 1 pili allowed P pilus biogenesis in vivo. These studies suggest that chaperone-subunit complexes target an N-terminal domain of the usher and that subunit assembly into pili depends on a subsequent function provided by the usher C terminus.     

The usher N terminus is the initial targeting site for chaperone-subunit complexes and participates in subsequent pilus biogenesis events

Pilus biogenesis on the surface of uropathogenic Escherichia coli requires the chaperone/usher pathway, a terminal branch of the general secretory pathway. In this pathway, periplasmic chaperone-subunit complexes target an outer membrane (OM) usher for subunit assembly into pili and secretion to the cell surface. The molecular mechanisms of protein secretion across the OM are not well understood. Mutagenesis of the P pilus usher PapC and the type 1 pilus usher FimD was undertaken to elucidate the initial stages of pilus biogenesis at the OM. Deletion of residues 2 to 11 of the mature PapC N terminus abolished the targeting of the usher by chaperone-subunit complexes and rendered PapC nonfunctional for pilus biogenesis. Similarly, an intact FimD N terminus was required for chaperone-subunit binding and pilus biogenesis. Analysis of PapC-FimD chimeras and N-terminal fragments of PapC localized the chaperone-subunit targeting domain to the first 124 residues of PapC. Single alanine substitution mutations were made in this domain that blocked pilus biogenesis but did not affect targeting of chaperone-subunit complexes. Thus, the usher N terminus does not function simply as a static binding site for chaperone-subunit complexes but also participates in subsequent pilus assembly events.     

Analysis of the requirements for pilus biogenesis at the outer membrane usher and the function of the usher C-terminus

Uropathogenic strains of Escherichia coli assemble type 1 and P pili to colonize the bladder and kidney respectively. These pili are prototype structures assembled by the chaperone/usher secretion pathway. In this pathway, a periplasmic chaperone works together with an outer membrane (OM) usher to control the folding of pilus subunits, their assembly into a pilus fibre and secretion of the fibre to the cell surface. The usher serves as the assembly and secretion platform in the OM. The usher has distinct functional domains, with the N-terminus providing the initial targeting site for chaperone-subunit complexes and the C-terminus required for subsequent stages of pilus biogenesis. In this study, we investigated the molecular interactions occurring at the usher during pilus biogenesis and the function of the usher C-terminus. We provide genetic and biochemical evidence that the usher functions as a complex in the OM and that interaction of the pilus adhesin with the usher is critical to prime the usher for pilus biogenesis. Analysis of C-terminal truncation and substitution mutants of the P pilus usher PapC demonstrated that the C-terminus is required for proper binding of chaperone-subunit complexes to the usher and plays an important role in assembly of complete pili.     

Modulating Effects of the Plug, Helix, and N- and C-terminal Domains on Channel Properties of the PapC Usher

The chaperone/usher system is one of the best characterized pathways for protein secretion and assembly of cell surface appendages in Gram-negative bacteria. In particular, this pathway is used for biogenesis of the P pilus, a key virulence factor used by uropathogenic Escherichia coli to adhere to the host urinary tract. The P pilus individual subunits bound to the periplasmic chaperone PapD are delivered to the outer membrane PapC usher, which serves as an assembly platform for subunit incorporation into the pilus and secretion of the pilus fiber to the cell surface. PapC forms a dimeric, twin pore complex, with each monomer composed of a 24-stranded transmembrane β-barrel channel, an internal plug domain that occludes the channel, and globular N- and C-terminal domains that are located in the periplasm. Here we have used planar lipid bilayer electrophysiology to characterize the pore properties of wild type PapC and domain deletion mutants for the first time. The wild type pore is closed most of the time but displays frequent short-lived transitions to various open states. In comparison, PapC mutants containing deletions of the plug domain, an α-helix that caps the plug domain, or the N- and C-terminal domains form channels with higher open probability but still exhibiting dynamic behavior. Removal of the plug domain results in a channel with extremely large conductance. These observations suggest that the plug gates the usher channel closed and that the periplasmic domains and α-helix function to modulate the gating activity of the PapC twin pore.     

Characterization of FimC, a periplasmic assembly factor for biogenesis of type 1 pili in Escherichia coli

Assembly of type 1 pili from Escherichia coli is mediated by FimC, a periplasmic chaperone (assembly factor) consisting of two immunoglobulin-like domains. FimC is assumed to recognize the individual pilus subunits in the periplasm mainly via their conserved C-terminal segments and to deliver the subunits to an assembly platform in the outer membrane. Here we present the first biochemical characterization of a periplasmic pilus chaperone and analyze the importance of the two chaperone domains for stability and function. Comparison of the isolated C-terminal domain with wild-type FimC revealed a strongly reduced thermodynamic stability, indicating strong interdomain interactions. The affinity of FimC toward a peptide corresponding to the 11 C-terminal residues of the type 1 pilus adhesin FimH is at least 1000-fold lower compared to binding of intact FimH, confirming that bacterial pilus chaperones, unlike other chaperones, specifically interact with folded pilus subunits.     

Crystal structure of the ternary FimC-FimF(t)-FimD(N) complex indicates conserved pilus chaperone-subunit complex recognition by the usher FimD

Type 1 pili, anchored to the outer membrane protein FimD, enable uropathogenic Escherichia coli to attach to host cells. During pilus biogenesis, the N-terminal periplasmic domain of FimD (FimD(N)) binds complexes between the chaperone FimC and pilus subunits via its partly disordered N-terminal segment, as recently shown for the FimC-FimH(P)-FimD(N) ternary complex. We report the structure of a new ternary complex (FimC-FimF(t)-FimD(N)) with the subunit FimF(t) instead of FimH(p). FimD(N) recognizes FimC-FimF(t) and FimC-FimH(P) very similarly, predominantly through hydrophobic interactions. The conserved binding mode at a "hot spot" on the chaperone surface could guide the design of pilus assembly inhibitors.     

The differential affinity of the usher for chaperone–subunit complexes is required for assembly of complete pili

Attachment to host cells via adhesive surface structures is a prerequisite for the pathogenesis of many bacteria. Uropathogenic Escherichia coli assemble P and type 1 pili for attachment to the host urothelium. Assembly of these pili requires the conserved chaperone/usher pathway, in which a periplasmic chaperone controls the folding of pilus subunits and an outer membrane usher provides a platform for pilus assembly and secretion. The usher has differential affinity for pilus subunits, with highest affinity for the tip‐localized adhesin. Here, we identify residues F21 and R652 of the P pilus usher PapC as functioning in the differential affinity of the usher. R652 is important for high‐affinity binding to the adhesin whereas F21 is important for limiting affinity for the PapA major rod subunit. PapC mutants in these residues are specifically defective for pilus assembly in the presence of PapA, demonstrating that differential affinity of the usher is required for assembly of complete pili. Analysis of PapG deletion mutants demonstrated that the adhesin is not required to initiate P pilus biogenesis. Thus, the differential affinity of the usher may be critical to ensure assembly of functional pilus fibres.     

Recognition of the N-terminal lectin domain of FimH adhesin by the usher FimD is required for type 1 pilus biogenesis

In this work we discover that a specific recognition of the N-terminal lectin domain of FimH adhesin by the usher FimD is essential for the biogenesis of type 1 pili in Escherichia coli. These filamentous organelles are assembled by the chaperone-usher pathway, in which binary complexes between fimbrial subunits and the periplasmic chaperone FimC are recognized by the outer membrane protein FimD (the usher). FimH adhesin initiates fimbriae polymerization and is the first subunit incorporated in the filament. Accordingly, FimD shows higher affinity for the FimC/FimH complex although the structural basis of this specificity is unknown. We have analysed the assembly into fimbria, and the interaction with FimD in vivo, of FimH variants in which the N-terminal lectin domain of FimH was deleted or substituted by different immunoglobulin (Ig) domains, or in which these Ig domains were fused to the N-terminus of full-length FimH. From these data, along with the analysis of a FimH mutant with a single amino acid change (G16D) in the N-terminal lectin domain, we conclude that the lectin domain of FimH is recognized by FimD usher as an essential step for type 1 pilus biogenesis.     

Pilus chaperone FimC-adhesin FimH interactions mapped by TROSY-NMR

The 23 kDa two-domain periplasmic chaperone FimC from Escherichia coli is required for the assembly of type-1 pili, which are filamentous, highly oligomeric protein complexes anchored to the outer bacterial membrane that mediate adhesion of pathogenic E. coli strains to host cell surfaces. Here we identified the contact sites on the surface of the NMR structure of FimC that are responsible for the binding of the 28 kDa mannose-binding type-1 pilus subunit FimH by 15N and 1H NMR chemical shift mapping, using transverse relaxation-optimized spectroscopy (TROSY). The FimH-binding surface of FimC is formed nearly entirely by the N-terminal domain, and its extent and shape indicate that FimC binds a folded form of the pilus subunits.     

Conserved Hydrophobic Clusters on the Surface of the Caf1A Usher C-Terminal Domain Are Important for F1 Antigen Assembly

The outer membrane usher protein Caf1A of the plague pathogen Yersinia pestis is responsible for the assembly of a major surface antigen, the F1 capsule. The F1 capsule is mainly formed by thin linear polymers of Caf1 (capsular antigen fraction 1) protein subunits. The Caf1A usher promotes polymerization of subunits and secretion of growing polymers to the cell surface. The usher monomer (811 aa, 90.5 kDa) consists of a large transmembrane β-barrel that forms a secretion channel and three soluble domains. The periplasmic N-terminal domain binds chaperone-subunit complexes supplying new subunits for the growing fiber. The middle domain, which is structurally similar to Caf1 and other fimbrial subunits, serves as a plug that regulates the permeability of the usher. Here we describe the identification, characterization, and crystal structure of the Caf1A usher C-terminal domain (Caf1A_C). Caf1A_C is shown to be a periplasmic domain with a seven-stranded β-barrel fold. Analysis of C-terminal truncation mutants of Caf1A demonstrated that the presence of Caf1A_C is crucial for the function of the usher in vivo, but that it is not required for the initial binding of chaperone-subunit complexes to the usher. Two clusters of conserved hydrophobic residues on the surface of Caf1A_C were found to be essential for the efficient assembly of surface polymers. These clusters are conserved between the FGL family and the FGS family of chaperone-usher systems.     

Chaperone-subunit-usher interactions required for donor strand exchange during bacterial pilus assembly

The assembly of type 1 pili on the surface of uropathogenic Escherichia coli proceeds via the chaperone-usher pathway. Chaperone-subunit complexes interact with one another via a process termed donor strand complementation whereby the G1beta strand of the chaperone completes the immunoglobulin (Ig) fold of the pilus subunit. Chaperone-subunit complexes are targeted to the usher, which forms a channel across the outer membrane through which pilus subunits are translocated and assembled into pili via a mechanism known as donor strand exchange. This is a mechanism whereby chaperone uncapping from a subunit is coupled with the simultaneous assembly of the subunit into the pilus fiber. Thus, in the pilus fiber, the N-terminal extension of every subunit completes the Ig fold of its neighboring subunit by occupying the same site previously occupied by the chaperone. Here, we investigated details of the donor strand exchange assembly mechanism. We discovered that the information necessary for targeting the FimC-FimH complex to the usher resides mainly in the FimH protein. This interaction is an initiating event in pilus biogenesis. We discovered that the ability of an incoming subunit (in a chaperone-subunit complex) to participate in donor strand exchange with the growing pilus depended on a previously unrecognized function of the chaperone. Furthermore, the donor strand exchange assembly mechanism between subunits was found to be necessary for subunit translocation across the outer membrane usher.     

Identification and characterization of the chaperone-subunit complex-binding domain from the type 1 pilus assembly platform FimD

The outer membrane protein FimD represents the assembly platform of adhesive type 1 pili from Escherichia coli. FimD forms ring-shaped oligomers of 91.4 kDa subunits that recognize complexes between the pilus chaperone FimC and individual pilus subunits in the periplasm and mediate subunit translocation through the outer membrane. Here, we have identified a periplasmic domain of FimD (FimD(N)) comprising the N-terminal 139 residues of FimD. Purified FimD(N) is a monomeric, soluble protein that specifically recognizes complexes between FimC and individual type 1 pilus subunits, but does not bind the isolated chaperone, or isolated subunits. In addition, FimD(N) retains the ability of FimD to recognize different chaperone-subunit complexes with different affinities, and has the highest affinity towards the FimC-FimH complex. Overexpression of FimD(N) in the periplasm of wild-type E.coli cells diminished incorporation of FimH at the tip of type 1 pili, while pilus assembly itself was not affected. The identification of FimD(N) and its ternary complexes with FimC and individual pilus subunits opens the avenue to structural characterization of critical type 1 pilus assembly intermediates.     

Assembly of complex organelles: pilus biogenesis in gram-negative bacteria as a model system

Pathogenic bacteria assemble a variety of adhesive structures on their surface for attachment to host cells. Some of these structures are quite complex. For example, the hair-like organelles known as pili or fimbriae are generally composed of several components and often exhibit composite morphologies. In gram-negative bacteria assembly of pili requires that the subunits cross the cytoplasmic membrane, fold correctly in the periplasm, target to the outer membrane, assemble into an ordered structure, and cross the outer membrane to the cell surface. Thus, pilus biogenesis provides a model for a number of basic biological problems including protein folding, trafficking, secretion, and the ordered assembly of proteins into complex structures. P pilus biogenesis represents one of the best-understood pilus systems. P pili are produced by 80-90% of all pyelonephritic Escherichia coli and are a major virulence determinant for urinary tract infections. Two specialized assembly factors known as the periplasmic chaperone and outer membrane usher are required for P pilus assembly. A chaperone/usher pathway is now known to be required for the biogenesis of more than 30 different adhesive structures in diverse gram-negative pathogenic bacteria. Elucidation of the chaperone/usher pathway was brought about through a powerful combination of molecular, biochemical, and biophysical techniques. This review discusses these approaches as they relate to pilus assembly, with an emphasis on newer techniques.     

The Outer Membrane Usher Guarantees the Formation of Functional Pili by Selectively Catalyzing Donor-Strand Exchange between Subunits That Are Adjacent in the Mature Pilus

Type 1 pili from uropathogenic Escherichia coli are a prototype of adhesive surface organelles assembled and secreted by the conserved chaperone/usher pathway. They are composed of four different homologous protein subunits that need to be assembled in a defined order. In the periplasm, the pilus chaperone FimC donates a β-strand segment to the subunits to complete their imperfect immunoglobulin-like fold. During subunit assembly, this segment of the chaperone is displaced by an amino-terminal extension of an incoming subunit in a reaction termed donor-strand exchange. To date, the molecular mechanisms underlying the coordinated subunit assembly, in particular the role of the outer membrane usher FimD, are still poorly understood. Here we show that the binding of complexes between FimC and the different pilus subunits to the amino-terminal substrate recognition domain of FimD is an extremely fast process, with association rate constants in the range of 10⁷-10⁸ M^− 1 s^− 1 at 20 °C. Furthermore, we demonstrate that the ordered assembly of pilus subunits is a consequence of the usher's ability to selectively catalyze the assembly of defined subunit-subunit pairs that are adjacent in the mature pilus. The usher therefore coordinates the assembly of pilus subunits at the stage of donor-strand exchange between pairs of subunits and not at the level of the initial binding of chaperone-subunit complexes.     

Ramifications of kinetic partitioning on usher-mediated pilus biogenesis.

The biogenesis of diverse adhesive structures in a variety of Gram-negative bacterial species is dependent on the chaperone/usher pathway. Very little is known about how the usher protein translocates protein subunits across the outer membrane or how assembly of these adhesive structures occurs. We have discovered several mechanisms by which the usher protein acts to regulate the ordered assembly of type 1 pili, specifically through critical interactions of the chaperone-adhesin complex with the usher. A study of association and dissociation events of chaperone-subunit complexes with the usher in real time using surface plasmon resonance revealed that the chaperone-adhesin complex has the tightest and fastest association with the usher. This suggests that kinetic partitioning of chaperone-adhesin complexes to the usher is a defining factor in tip localization of the adhesin in the pilus. Furthermore, we identified and purified a chaperone-adhesin-usher assembly intermediate that was formed in vivo. Trypsin digestion assays showed that the usher in this complex was in an altered conformation, which was maintained during pilus assembly. The data support a model in which binding of the chaperone-adhesin complex to the usher stabilizes the usher in an assembly-competent conformation and allows initiation of pilus assembly.     

Fiber formation across the bacterial outer membrane by the chaperone/usher pathway

Gram-negative pathogens commonly exhibit adhesive pili on their surfaces that mediate specific attachment to the host. A major class of pili is assembled via the chaperone/usher pathway. Here, the structural basis for pilus fiber assembly and secretion performed by the outer membrane assembly platform--the usher--is revealed by the crystal structure of the translocation domain of the P pilus usher PapC and single particle cryo-electron microscopy imaging of the FimD usher bound to a translocating type 1 pilus assembly intermediate. These structures provide molecular snapshots of a twinned-pore translocation machinery in action. Unexpectedly, only one pore is used for secretion, while both usher protomers are used for chaperone-subunit complex recruitment. The translocating pore itself comprises 24 beta strands and is occluded by a folded plug domain, likely gated by a conformationally constrained beta-hairpin. These structures capture the secretion of a virulence factor across the outer membrane of gram-negative bacteria.     

Molecular and structural aspects of fimbriae biosynthesis and assembly in Escherichia coli

Abstract: Fimbriae are long filamentous polymeric protein structures located at the surface of bacterial cells. They enable the bacteria to bind to specific receptor structures and thereby to colonise specific surfaces. Fimbriae consist of so-called major and minor subunits, which form, in a specific order, the fimbrial structure. In this review emphasis is put on the genetic organisation, regulation and especially on the biosynthesis of fimbriae of enterotoxigenic Escherichia coli strains, and more in particular on K88 and related fimbriae, with ample reference to the well-studied P and type 1 fimbriae. The biosynthesis of these fimbriae requires two specific and unique proteins, a periplasmic chaperone and an outer membrane located molecular usher ('doorkeeper'). Molecular and structural aspects of the secretion of fimbrial subunits across the cytoplasmic membrane, the interaction of these subunits with the periplasmic molecular chaperone, their translocation to the inner site of the outer membrane and their interaction with the usher protein, as well as the (ordered) translocation of the subunits across the outer membrane and their assembly into a grwoing fimbrial structure will be described. A model for K88 fimbriae is presented.     

Specific residues in the N-terminal domain of FimH stimulate type 1 fimbriae assembly in Escherichia coli following the initial binding of the adhesin to FimD usher

Type 1 fimbriae are assembled by the chaperone–usher pathway where periplasmic protein complexes formed between fimbrial subunits and the FimC chaperone are recruited by the outer membrane protein FimD (the usher) for their ordered polymerization and export. FimH adhesin initiates and stimulates type 1 fimbriae polymerization by interacting with FimD. Previously we showed that the N-terminal lectin domain of FimH (N-FimH) is necessary for binding of the adhesin to FimD. In this work, we have selected mutants in N-FimH that reduce the levels of adhesin and type 1 fimbriae displayed in Escherichia coli without altering the levels of FimH in the periplasm. The selected mutations are mostly concentrated in residues G15, N46 and D47. In contrast to other mutations isolated that simply affect binding of FimH to FimD (e.g. C3Y), these variants associate to FimD and alter its susceptibility to trypsin digestion similarly to wild-type FimH. Importantly, their mutant phenotype is rescued when FimD is activated in vivo by the coexpression of wild-type FimH. Altogether, these data indicate that residues G15, N46 and D47 play an important role following initial binding of FimH to FimD for efficient type 1 fimbriae polymerization by this outer membrane usher.