Accuracy of DNA polymerase-alpha in copying natural DNA

The fidelity of DNA polymerase-alpha from calf thymus (9S enzyme) in copying bacteriophage phi174am16 DNA in vitro has been determined from the frequency of production of different revertants. In the self-priming reaction we were able to measure the frequencies of base pairing mismatches during the course of replication on biasing the ratios of deoxynucleoside triphosphates. The frequency of dGTP:T, dGTP:G and dATP:G mismatches were 7.6 x 10(-5), 4.4 x 10(-5) and 2.8 x 10(-5), respectively, at equal concentrations of the deoxynucleoside triphosphates. dCTP:A, dGTP:A, dCTP:T and dTTP:T mismatches were below the limit of detection (<5 x 10(-6)). A synthetic dodecamer primer with a 3' end covering the first two bases of the amber codon was used to determine the misinsertion frequency of the first nucleotide incorporated. This gave a misinsertion frequency of 1.5 x 10(-4) for the dGTP:T mismatch, which is slightly higher than that observed from the pool bias studies. Further, it showed no sensitivity to biasing the nucleotide pool, suggesting a different mechanism for the incorporation of the first nucleotide. These data do not support 'energy-relay'-like models for achieving high accuracy in eukaryotes. The observed misinsertion frequencies were corrected for mismatch repair of the heteroduplexes during the transfection experiments by parallel experiments using a mismatched primer. This was synthesized to have the same G:T mismatch as produced in the preceding experiment.     

Processing of mispaired and unpaired bases in heteroduplex DNA in E. coli

Bacteriophage lambda and phi X 174 DNAs, carrying sequenced mutations, have been used to construct in vitro defined species of heteroduplex DNA. Such heteroduplex DNAs were introduced by transfection, as single copies, into E. coli host cells. The progeny of individual heteroduplex molecules from each infective center was analyzed. The effect of the presence of GATC sequences (phi X 174 system) and of their methylation (lambda system) was tested. The following conclusions can be drawn: some mismatched base pairs trigger the process of mismatch repair, causing a localized strand-to-strand information transfer in heteroduplex DNA: transition mismatches G:T and A:C are efficiently repaired, whereas the six transversion mismatches are not always readily recognized and/or repaired. The recognition of transversion mismatches appears to depend on the neighbouring nucleotide sequence; single unpaired bases (frameshift mutation "mismatches") are recognized and repaired, some equally efficiently on both strands (longer and shorter), some more efficiently on the shorter (-1) strand; large non-homologies (about 800 bases) are not repaired by the Mut H, L, S, U system, but some other process repairs the non-homology with a relatively low efficiency; full methylation of GATC sequences inhibits mismatch repair on the methylated strand: this is the chemical basis of strand discrimination (old/new) in mismatch correction; unmethylated GATC sequences appear to improve mismatch repair of a G:T mismatch in phi X 174 DNA, but there may be some residual mismatch repair in GATC-free phi X 174, at least for some mismatches.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Joining of short DNA oligonucleotides with base pair mismatches by T4 DNA ligase

Oligonucleotide-directed mutagenesis is a widely used method for studying enzymes and improving their properties. The number of mutants that can be obtained with this method is limited by the number of synthetic 25-30mer oligonucleotides containing the mutation mismatch, becoming impracticably large with increasing size of a mutant library. To make this approach more practical, shorter mismatching oligonucleotides (7-12mer) might be employed. However, the introduction of these oligonucleotides in dsDNA poses the problem of sealing a DNA nick containing 5'-terminal base pair mismatches. In the present work we studied the ability of T4 DNA ligase to catalyze this reaction. It was found that T4 DNA ligase effectively joins short oligonucleotides, yielding dsDNA containing up to five adjacent mismatches. The end-joining rate of mismatching oligonucleotides is limited by the formation of the phosphodiester bond, decreasing with an increase in the number of mismatching base pairs at the 5'-end of the oligonucleotide substrate. However, in the case of a 3 bp mismatch, the rate is higher than that obtained with a 2 bp mismatch. Increasing the matching length with the number of mismatching base pairs fixed, or moving the mismatching motif downstream with respect to the joining site increases the rate of ligation. The ligation rate increases with the molar ratio [oligonucleotide:dsDNA]; however, at high excess of the oligonucleotide, inhibition of joining was observed. In conclusion, 9mer oligonucleotides containing a 3 bp mismatch are found optimal substrates to introduce mutations in dsDNA, opening perspectives for the application of T4 DNA ligase in mutagenesis protocols.     

DNA alkylation repair limits spontaneous base substitution mutations in Escherichia coli.

The Escherichia coli Ada and Ogt DNA methyltransferases (MTases) are known to transfer simple alkyl groups from O6-alkylguanine and O4-alkylthymine, directly restoring these alkylated DNA lesions to guanine and thymine. In addition to being exquisitely sensitive to the mutagenic effects of methylating agents, E. coli ada ogt null mutants display a higher spontaneous mutation rate than the wild type. Here, we determined which base substitution mutations are elevated in the MTase-deficient cells by monitoring the reversion of six mutated lacZ alleles that revert via each of the six possible base substitution mutations. During exponential growth, the spontaneous rate of G:C to A:T transitions and G:C to C:G transversions was elevated about fourfold in ada ogt double mutant versus wild-type E. coli. Furthermore, compared with the wild type, stationary populations of the MTase-deficient E. coli (under lactose selection) displayed increased G:C to A:T and A:T to G:C transitions (10- and 3-fold, respectively) and increased G:C to C:G, A:T to C:G, and A:T to T:A transversions (10-, 2.5-, and 1.7-fold, respectively). ada and ogt single mutants did not suffer elevated spontaneous mutation rates for any base substitution event, and the cloned ada and ogt genes each restored wild-type spontaneous mutation rates to the ada ogt MTase-deficient strains. We infer that both the Ada MTase and the Ogt MTase can repair the endogenously produced DNA lesions responsible for each of the five base substitution events that are elevated in MTase-deficient cells. Simple methylating and ethylating agents induced G:C to A:T and A:T to G:C transitions in these strains but did not significantly induce G:C to C:G, A:T to C:G, and A:T to T:A transversions. We deduce that S-adenosylmethionine (known to e a weak methylating agent) is not the only metabolite responsible for endogenous DNA alkylation and that at least some of the endogenous metabolites that cause O-alkyl DNA damage in E. coli are not simple methylating or ethylating agents.     

Exonucleolytic proofreading increases the accuracy of DNA synthesis by human lymphocyte DNA polymerase alpha-DNA primase.

DNA polymerase-primase complex, isolated with an apparently undegraded alpha-subunit, was immunoaffinity-purified to near homogeneity from the human lymphoblast line HSC93. The undegraded state of the alpha-subunit was monitored by Western-blot analysis of crude cellular extracts and all active fractions obtained during purification. The human polymerase-primase consists of four subunits with molecular weights of 195, 68, 55 and 48 kd. The fidelity of the polymerase-primase in copying bacteriophage phi X174am16 DNA in vitro was determined by measuring the frequency of production of different revertent phages. The overall accuracy was between 4 x 10(-6) and 10 x 10(-6). This value reflects the spontaneous mutation frequency of phi X174am16 phages in Escherichia coli, and is 10- to 20-fold higher than the accuracy of a conventionally purified enzyme from calf thymus. The frequencies of base pairing mismatches, estimated from pool bias measurements, were 3.5 x 10(-7) (1/2 880,000) for dGMP:Ttemplate mispairs, between 10(-7) and 10(-8) for dCMP:Ttemplate (1/35,000,000), dCMP:Atemplate (1/18,200,000) and dAMP:Gtemplate mispairs (1/16,500,000), and below 10(-8) (1/100,000,000) for dTMP:Ttemplate, dGMP:Atemplate and dGMP:Gtemplate mispairs. In contrast to previous preparations, the intact polymerase-primase possesses a 3'----5' exonuclease activity. This exonuclease removes both matched and mismatched 3'-OH ends, with a preference for mismatched bases. Fidelity was reduced 8-fold by increasing the concentration of the next nucleotide following the incorporated mismatch nucleotide.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

On the fidelity of DNA replication. The accuracy of T4 DNA polymerases in copying phi X174 DNA in vitro

The fidelity with which wild type T4 DNA polymerase copies phi X174 amber 3 plus strand DNA at position 587 in vitro has been measured. Synthesis is initiated by hybridizing to the template a HaeIII restriction fragment whose 3'-OH terminus is 83 nucleotides from the amber 3 site. Based on gel electrophoresis of product DNA molecules and genetic marker rescue data, T4 DNA polymerase copies significantly beyond the mutant site. Transfection analysis shows that the A X T leads to G X C mutation at position 587 occurs 10- to 100-fold less frequently with T4 DNA polymerase than with E. coli DNA polymerase I. The aberrant incorporation of cytosine opposite adenine at position 587 by the T4 polymerase alone is occurring at a frequency not greater than about 10(-7) which, for this particular locus, may be similar to the fidelity exhibited by the T4 accessory proteins plus the polymerase comprising the replication complex. A comparison of the accuracy of mutator L56 and antimutator L141 T4 DNA polymerases relative to wild type shows at most a 2- to 4-fold decrease and increase, respectively, in fidelity. When compared to 10- to 1000-fold effects on mutation frequencies that these same mutant alleles have in vivo, these results suggest that the wide range in expression of mutator and antimutator phenotypes in vivo may be dependent on an abnormal interaction of the aberrant DNA polymerases with other protein components of the replication complex.     

Exonuclease proofreading by human mitochondrial DNA polymerase

We have examined the ability of the human mitochondrial DNA polymerase to correct errors in DNA sequence using single turnover kinetic methods. The rate of excision of single-stranded DNA ranged from 0.07 to 0.17 x s(-1), depending on the identity of the 3'-base. Excision of the 3'-terminal base from correctly base paired DNA occurred at a rate of 0.05 x s(-1), indicating that the cost of proofreading is minimal, as defined by the ratio of the k(exo) for correctly base-paired DNA divided by the rate of forward polymerization (0.05/37 = 0.14%). Excision of duplex DNA containing 1-7 mismatches was biphasic, and the rate and amplitude of the fast phase increased with the number of mismatches, reaching a maximum of 9 x s(-1). We showed that transfer of DNA from the polymerase to the exonuclease active site and back again occurs through an intramolecular reaction, allowing for a complete cycle of reactions for error correction. For DNA containing a buried mismatch (T:T followed by C:G base pairs), the 3' base was removed at a rate of 3 x s(-1). The addition of nucleotide to the reaction that is identical to the 3' base increased the rate of excision 7-fold to 21 x s(-1). We propose that the free nucleotide enhances the rate of transfer of the DNA to the exonuclease active site by interrupting the correct 3' base pair through interaction with the template base. The exonuclease contribution to fidelity is minimal if the calculation is based on hydrolysis of a single mismatch: (k(exo) + k(pol,over))/(k(pol,over)) = 10, but this value increases to approximately 200 when examining error correction in the presence of nucleotides.     

Fidelity of DNA polymerase epsilon holoenzyme from budding yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae

DNA polymerases delta and epsilon (pol delta and epsilon) are the major replicative polymerases and possess 3'-5' proofreading exonuclease activities that correct errors arising during DNA replication in the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae. This study measures the fidelity of the holoenzyme of wild-type pol epsilon, the 3'-5' exonuclease-deficient pol2-4, a +1 frameshift mutator for homonucleotide runs, pol2C1089Y, and pol2C1089Y pol2-4 enzymes using a synthetic 30-mer primer/100-mer template. The nucleotide substitution rate for wild-type pol epsilon was 0.47 x 10(-5) for G:G mismatches, 0.15 x 10(-5) for T:G mismatches, and less than 0.01 x 10(-5) for A:G mismatches. The accuracy for A opposite G was not altered in the exonuclease-deficient pol2-4 pol epsilon; however, G:G and T:G misincorporation rates increased 40- and 73-fold, respectively. The pol2C1089Y pol epsilon mutant also exhibited increased G:G and T:G misincorporation rates, 22- and 10-fold, respectively, whereas A:G misincorporation did not differ from that of wild type. Since the fidelity of the double mutant pol2-4 pol2C1089Y was not greatly decreased, these results suggest that the proofreading 3'-5' exonuclease activity of pol2C1089Y pol epsilon is impaired even though it retains nuclease activity and the mutation is not in the known exonuclease domain.     

DNA Rearrangements Associated with Reversion of Bacteriophage Mu-Induced Mutations

Excision of transposable genetic elements from host DNA is different from the classical prophage lambda type of excision in that it occurs at low frequency and is mostly imprecise; only a minority of excision events restores the wild-type host sequences. In bacteriophage Mu, a highly efficient transposon, imprecise excision is 10-100 times more frequent than precise excision. We have examined a large number of these excision events by starting with mucts X mutants located in the Z gene of the lac operon of Escherichia coli. Mucts X mutants are defective prophages whose excision occurs at a measurable frequency. Imprecise excision was monitored by selecting for melibiose+ (Mel+) phenotype, which requires only a functioning lacY gene. Mel+ revertants exhibit an array of DNA rearrangements and fall in four main classes, the predominant one being comprised of revertants that have no detectable Mu DNA. Most of these revertants can further revert to Lac+. Perhaps 5 base-pair duplications, originally present at prophage-host junctions, are left in these lacZ-Y+ revertants, and they can be further repaired to lacZ+. Another class has, in addition to the loss of Mu DNA, deletions that extend generally, but not always, to only one side of the prophage. The other two classes of revertants, surprisingly, still have Mu DNA in the lacZ gene. One class has deletions in the Z gene, whereas, no deletions can be detected in the other. Many of the revertants in the last class can further revert to lacZ+, indicating that the lacY gene must have been turned on by a rearrangement within Mu DNA. Apparently, all of the detectable precise and most of the imprecise excision events require functioning of the Mu A gene. We suggest that a block in large-scale Mu replication allows the excision process to proceed.     

An error-prone viral DNA ligase

Our recent demonstration that DNA polymerase X (Pol X), the DNA repair polymerase encoded by the African swine fever virus (ASFV), is extremely error prone during single-nucleotide gap filling led us to hypothesize that it might contribute to genetic variability in ASFV. For the infidelity of Pol X to be relevant, however, the DNA ligase working downstream of it would need to be capable of sealing nicks containing 3'-OH mismatches. We therefore examined the nick ligation capabilities of the ASFV-encoded DNA ligase and here report the first complete 3' fidelity analysis, employing catalytic parameters, for any DNA ligase. The catalytic efficiency of nick sealing by both ASFV DNA ligase and bacteriophage T4 DNA ligase was determined in the steady state for substrates containing all 16 possible matched and mismatched base pair combinations at the 3' side of a nick. Our results indicate that ASFV DNA ligase is the lowest-fidelity DNA ligase ever reported, capable of ligating a 3' C:T mismatched nick (where C and T are the templating and nascent nucleotides, respectively) more efficiently than nicks containing Watson-Crick base pairs. Comparison of the mismatch specificity of Pol X with that of ASFV DNA ligase suggests that the latter may have evolved toward low fidelity for the purpose of generating the broadest possible spectrum of sealed mismatches. These findings are discussed in light of the genetic and antigenic variability observed among some ASFV isolates. Two novel assays for determining the concentration of active DNA ligase are also reported.     

Low-energy (30 keV) carbon ion induced mutation spectrum in the LacZ alpha gene of M13 mp 18 double-stranded DNA

Double-stranded M13 mp 18 DNA was irradiated with 30 ke V carbon ions in dry state under vacuum to investigate the low-energy heavy ion induced mutation spectra. When the irradiated DNA was used to transfect Escherichia coli JM 105, 3.6-5.7-fold increases in mutation frequency were observed, in contrast to the spontaneous group. Sequences of the 92 induced mutants showed that the carbon ions in this study could induce an interesting mutation spectrum in the lacZ alpha gene. One-base mutations (96.8%) and base pair substitutions (56.4%) were predominant, most of which involved G:C base pairs (90.6%), especially G:C --> T:A transversions (49.6%) and G:C --> A:T transitions (39.6%). This is similar to the spectra induced by gamma-rays in the same ds M13, wild type E. coli system. We also found a considerable amount of carbon ion induced one-base deletion (38.5%) and the mutation sites distribution on the target lacZ alpha gene was obviously non-random. We compared this study with previous data employing gamma-rays to discuss the possible causes of the mutation spectrum.     

Mismatches in DNA double strands: thermodynamic parameters and their correlation to repair efficiencies.

The helix-coil transitions of the 16 octadecameric DNA duplexes dCGTCGTTTXACAACGTCG X dCGACGTTGTX1AAACGACG with A, T, G, and C for X and X1 were measured by UV-absorption. This sequence was taken from former studies of in vivo determination of efficiencies of mismatch repair (Kramer, Kramer, and Fritz (1984) Cell 38, 879-887). The thermodynamic parameters for double strand and mismatch formation have been obtained by evaluating the partition function of a stack model which allowed for loop formation. As a result the mismatches could be classified into wobble base pairs (T/G, G/G, C/A, A/A, A/G), open base pairs, i.e. permanent loops (T/T, C/T, T/C, C/C), and intermediate or weak base pairs (G/T, A/C, G/A). There is no correlation between Tm and the biological repair efficiency of X/X1. The structure classes, however, as described above show a close correlation: Open base pairs show the lowest repair efficiencies, whereas mismatches with high repair efficiency always belong to the structural class of wobble base pairs. Because of the palindromic nearest neighbors of the variation site X/X1, the influence of next-nearest neighbor interactions could be detected and be estimated to about 1 kJ/mol for one stack.     

Structures of mismatched base pairs in DNA and their recognition by the Escherichia coli mismatch repair system.

The Escherichia coli mismatch repair system does not recognize and/or repair all mismatched base pairs with equal efficiency: whereas transition mismatches (G X T and A X C) are well repaired, the repair of some transversion mismatches (e.g. A X G or C X T) appears to depend on their position in heteroduplex DNA of phage lambda. Undecamers were synthesized and annealed to form heteroduplexes with a single base-pair mismatch in the centre and with the five base pairs flanking each side corresponding to either repaired or unrepaired heteroduplexes of lambda DNA. Nuclear magnetic resonance (n.m.r.) studies show that a G X A mismatch gives rise to an equilibrium between fully helical and a looped-out structure. In the unrepaired G X A mismatch duplex the latter predominates, while the helical structure is predominant in the case of repaired G X A and G X T mismatches. It appears that the E. coli mismatch repair enzymes recognize and repair intrahelical mismatched bases, but not the extrahelical bases in the looped-out structures.     

Either bacteriophage T4 RNase H or Escherichia coli DNA polymerase I is essential for phage replication.

Bacteriophage T4 rnh encodes an RNase H that removes ribopentamer primers from nascent DNA chains during synthesis by the T4 multienzyme replication system in vitro (H. C. Hollingsworth and N. G. Nossal, J. Biol. Chem. 266:1888-1897, 1991). This paper demonstrates that either T4 RNase HI or Escherichia coli DNA polymerase I (Pol I) is essential for phage replication. Wild-type T4 phage production was not diminished by the polA12 mutation, which disrupts coordination between the polymerase and the 5'-to-3' nuclease activities of E. coli DNA Pol I, or by an interruption in the gene for E. coli RNase HI. Deleting the C-terminal amino acids 118 to 305 from T4 RNase H reduced phage production to 47% of that of wild-type T4 on a wild-type E. coli host, 10% on an isogenic host defective in RNase H, and less than 0.1% on a polA12 host. The T4 rnh(delta118-305) mutant synthesized DNA at about half the rate of wild-type T4 in the polA12 host. More than 50% of pulse-labelled mutant DNA was in short chains characteristic of Okazaki fragments. Phage production was restored in the nonpermissive host by providing the T4 rnh gene on a plasmid. Thus, T4 RNase H was sufficient to sustain the high rate of T4 DNA synthesis, but E. coli RNase HI and the 5'-to-3' exonuclease of Pol I could substitute to some extent for the T4 enzyme. However, replication was less accurate in the absence of the T4 RNase H, as judged by the increased frequency of acriflavine-resistant mutations after infection of a wild-type host with the T4 rnh (delta118-305) mutant.     

Inefficient proofreading and biased error rates during inaccurate DNA synthesis by a mutant derivative of Saccharomyces cerevisiae DNA polymerase delta

DNA polymerase delta (pol delta) is a high fidelity eukaryotic enzyme that participates in DNA repair and is essential for DNA replication. Toward the goal of dissecting its multiple biological functions, here we describe the biochemical properties of Saccharomyces cerevisiae pol delta with a methionine replacing conserved leucine 612 at the polymerase active site. Compared with wild type pol delta, L612M pol delta has normal processivity and slightly higher polymerase specific activity. L612M pol delta also has normal 3' exonuclease activity, yet it is impaired in partitioning mismatches to the exonuclease active site, thereby reducing DNA synthesis fidelity. Error rates in vitro for L612M pol delta are elevated for both base substitutions and single base deletions but in a highly biased manner. For each of the six possible pairs of reciprocal mismatches that could arise during replication of complementary DNA strands to account for any particular base substitution in vivo (e.g. T-dGMP or A-dCMP for T to C transitions), L612M pol delta error rates are substantially higher for one mismatch than the other. These results provide a biochemical explanation for our observation, which confirms earlier genetic studies, that a haploid pol3-L612M S. cerevisiae strain has an elevated spontaneous mutation rate that is likely due to reduced replication fidelity in vivo.     

The relationship between DNA damage and mutation frequency in mammalian cell lines treated with N-nitroso-N-2-fluorenylacetamide

The induction of DNA single-strand breaks in C3H10T1/2 mouse fibroblasts and Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cells by N-nitroso-N-2-fluorenylacetamide (N-NO-2-FAA) was demonstrated by the alkaline elution technique. Without metabolic activating system (i.e., rat liver S9 fraction), N-NO-2-FAA exhibits more direct and strong damaging effects on DNA than its parent compound, 2-FAA, at equal concentration in both cell lines. To compare the DNA-damaging potency of N-NO-2-FAA with other well-known carcinogens, such as benzo[a]pyrene, 2-nitrofluorene, and N-methyl-N'-nitrosoguanidine (MNNG), the order of potency is as follows: MNNG (5 microM) greater than N-NO-2-FAA (150 microM) greater than benzo[a]pyrene (20 microM) at equitoxic concentrations, LD37, in the same cell system. Another parallel experiment indicated that N-NO-2-FAA could disrupt the superhelicity of circular plasmid DNA (pBR 322) at a dose range of 0.1-50 mM; however, a complete conversion to form III linear DNA was found at the highest concentration (50 mM). After treatment with various concentrations of N-NO-2-FAA, ouabain resistance (ouar) was induced in C3H10T1/2 cells, while both ouar and 6-thioguanine resistance (6-TGr) were induced in CHO cells. The mutation frequency in the Na+/K+-ATPase locus in CHO cells (1.5 X 10(-6) mutants/microM) is higher than that in C3H10T1/2 cells (1.0 X 10(-6) mutants/microM). The maximal mutation frequency at the Na+/K+-ATPase gene locus was attained with 30 min of exposure in C3H10T1/2 cells, whereas the mutation frequency in CHO cells continued to increase up to 80 min of treatment. Similarly, the maximal mutation frequency at the HPRT locus also continued to increase up to 80 min of treatment. Finally, a linear plot of alkali-labile lesions versus 6-TGr mutations was obtained; but the same relationship was not observed in the case of ouar mutation.     

On the fidelity of DNA polymerase alpha: the influence of alpha-thio dNTPs, Mn2+ and mismatch repair.

The phi X174am16 revertant system has been used to investigate the influence of alpha-thio-dNTPs and of Mn2+ on the fidelity of the 9S DNA polymerase alpha from calf thymus. Upon substituting dGTP by alpha-thio-dGTP during the in vitro replication, a nearly tenfold decrease in the frequency of G:G and G:T mispairs is observed. The formation of all other mispairs is not changed in the presence of the corresponding alpha-thio-dNTP. Mn2+ at concentrations of 0.5 mM does not influence the frequencies of the mispairs. The expression rate of errors formed during in vitro replication in the (-) strand has been determined for all mispairs detectable in the phi Xam16 system. The (-) strand expression of G:T, T:T and C:T mismatches is about 50%, whereas for A:G, G:G and C:A mismatches it is clearly below 50%. We conclude that the different base-base mismatches are repaired with different efficiencies.