Relationships of the Col plasmids E2, E3, E4, E5, E6, and E7: Restriction mapping and colicin gene fusions

Thirteen ColE plasmids representing the E2-E7 types have been compared by restriction mapping. Over 80% of their restriction sites were found to be similarly positioned, indicating that these plasmids share a common structure. Three variants are ColE2-CA42 and ColE7-K317, both of which contain 1.8-kb DNA segments in place of a 2.5-kb segment common to the other plasmids, and ColE6-CT14, which has an additional 5.0-kb DNA segment compared to the other plasmids. The colicin (col), immunity (imm), and colicin release (hic) genes of these plasmids have been localized to regions corresponding to those known for ColE3-CA38 and ColE2-P9, with the imm and hic genes adjacent to the 3' end of the col gene. Active colicin is produced from hybrid col genes containing 5' and 3' ends from different E-type plasmids. The 3'-termini of the fused col genes specify the colicin type.     

Characterisation of the ColE8 plasmid, a new member of the group E colicin plasmids

We have determined the restriction map of the ColE8-J plasmid after cloning it into the pBR322 vector. By subcloning and transposon mutagenesis we have localized the colicin immunity gene, the colicin structural gene, and lys, the region that determines MC sensitivity. In contrast to the ColE3-CA38 plasmid, the genes coding for colicin E8 production and immunity cannot be cloned on a single EcoRI fragment. Insertion of Tn5 transposons into the colicin structural gene region of the recombinant plasmid inactivated colicin production and MC sensitivity. Insertion of transposons into the lys region reduced colicin E8 production and MC induced lysis, the extent of which was dependent upon the precise site of insertion. We propose that the colicin E8 structural gene and lys must be transcribed from a common promoter situated proximal to the structural gene, whilst the colicin E8 immunity gene is transcribed from a second promoter. The lys region is responsible both for cell lysis after MC induction and positive regulation of colicin E8 synthesis.     

Molecular structure and immunity specificity of colicin E6, an evolutionary intermediate between E-group colicins and cloacin DF13.

The primary structure of a 3.1-kilobase E6 or E3 segment carrying colicin and related genes was determined. Plasmid ColE6-CT14 showed striking homology to ColE3-CA38 throughout this segment, including homology to the secondary immunity gene, immE8, downstream of the E6 or E3 immunity gene. The ColE3-CA38 and ColE6-CT14 sequences, however, contained an exceptional hot spot region encoding both the colicin-active domain (RNase region) and the immunity protein, reflecting their different immunity specificities. On the other hand, some chimeric plasmids were constructed through homologous recombination between colicin E3 and cloacin DF13 operons. The resulting plasmids were deduced to produce chimeric colicins with a colicin E3-type N-terminal part, a cloacin DF13-type C-terminal-active domain, and the DF13 immunity protein. The killing spectra of the chimeric colicins and the immunities of the plasmids were identical to those of colicin E6 and ColE6-CT14, respectively, showing that the colicin E6 immunity specificity is completely equivalent to that of cloacin DF13. Nevertheless, colicin E6 has been found to show a sequence diversity from cloacin DF13 almost to the same extent as that from colicin E3 in their RNase and immunity regions, indicating that only a small number of amino acids defines the immunity specificity for discrimination between colicins E3 and E6 (or cloacin DF13).     

Colicin E3 and its immunity genes

A DNA segment of plasmid ColE3-CA38 was cloned into pBR328 and its nucleotide sequence was determined. This segment contains the putative promoter-operator region, the structural genes of protein A (gene A) and protein B (gene B) of colicin E3, and a part of gene H. Just behind the promoter region, there is an inverted repeat structure of two 'SOS boxes', the specific binding site of the lexA protein. This suggests that the expression of colicin E3 is regulated directly by the lexA protein. Genes A and B face the same direction, with an intergenic space of nine nucleotides between them. ColE3-CA38 and ColE1-K30 are homologous in their promoter-operator regions, but hardly any homology was found in their structural genes. On the other hand, ColE3-CA38 is fairly homologous to CloDF13 throughout the regions sequenced, with some exceptions including putative receptor-binding regions. By deletion mapping of the immunity gene and recloning of gene B, it was shown genetically that protein B itself is the actual immunity substance of colicin E3. It was also found that the expression of E3 immunity partially depends on the recA function. Thus, we propose two modes of expression of E3 immunity: in the uninduced state, only a slight amount of protein B is produced constitutively to protect the cell from being attacked by the exogenous colicin; and in the SOS-induced state, a large amount of protein B is produced to protect the protein synthesis system of the host cell from ribosome inactivation by endogenously produced colicin E3.     

Characterization of three group A klebicin plasmids: localization of their E colicin immunity genes

We have investigated the immunity to E colicins conferred by three group A klebicin plasmids. pP5a, which encodes klebicin A1-P5, like pClo-DF13, confers immunity to colicin E6 on Escherichia coli K12, whilst pP5b and pP3, which encode klebicins A2-P5 and A3-P3 respectively, both confer immunity to colicin E3. We have determined the restriction endonuclease and functional maps of the three group A klebicin plasmids. By sub-cloning and transposon mutagenesis we have investigated the relationship between the klebicin immunity and the E colicin immunity conferred by these plasmids. The colicin E6 and the klebicin A1 immunity are encoded by a single gene present on pP5a. The colicin E3 and the klebicin A2 immunity are encoded by a single gene present on pP5b. The colicin E3 and the klebicin A3 immunity are encoded by separate genes present on pP3. Recombinant pML8412, which is derived from the ColE6-CT14 plasmid and encodes colicin E6 immunity, confers klebicin A1-P5 immunity upon Klebsiella pneumoniae UNF5023. Recombinant pKC23, which is derived from the ColE3-CA38 plasmid and confers colicin E3 immunity, confers immunity to klebicin A2-P5, but not to klebicin A3-P3.     

Nucleotide sequences from the colicin E8 operon: homology with plasmid ColE2-P9

The primary structures of the immunity (Imm) and lysis (Lys) proteins, and the C-terminal 205 amino acid residues of colicin E8 were deduced from nucleotide sequencing of the 1,265 bp ClaI-PvuI DNA fragment of plasmid ColE8-J. The gene order is col-imm-lys confirming previous genetic data. A comparison of the colicin E8 peptide sequence with the available colicin E2-P9 sequence shows an identical receptor-binding domain but 20 amino acid replacements and a clustering of synonymous codon usage in the nuclease-active region. Sequence homology of the two colicins indicates that they are descended from a common ancestral gene and that colicin E8, like colicin E2, may also function as a DNA endonuclease. The native ColE8 imm (resident copy) is 258 bp long and is predicted to encode an acidic protein of 9,604 mol. wt. The six amino acid replacements between the resident imm and the previously reported non-resident copy of the ColE8 imm ([E8 imm]) found in the ribonuclease-producing ColE3-CA38 plasmid offer an explanation for the incomplete protection conferred by [E8 Imm] to exogenously added colicin E8. Except for one nucleotide and amino acid change in the putative signal peptide sequence, the ColE8 lys structure is identical to that present in ColE2-P9 and ColE3-CA38.     

Colicin E8, a DNase which indicates an evolutionary relationship between colicins E2 and E3.

Colicin E8-J and its immunity protein were characterized with regard to their activities and gene structures. Colicin E8 is a complex of proteins A and B; protein A (the naked E8) exhibits an apparently nonspecific DNase activity that is inhibited by protein B (the immunity protein), as in the case of colicin E2. The nucleotide sequence of the downstream half of the colicin operon of ColE8-J was determined to be highly homologous to that of ColE2-P9, with the exception of the hot spot region of the 3'-terminal segment of the colicin gene and the adjacent immunity gene. The immE2-like gene of ColE3-CA38 was, as assumed previously, extensively homologous to the immE8 gene of ColE8-J, and thus, ColE8-J was shown to be situated between ColE2-P9 and ColE3-CA38 in the evolution of the E-group Col plasmids.     

The immunity genes of colicins E2 and E8 are closely related

We have determined the nucleotide sequence of the newly characterized colicin E8imm gene which exists in tandem with the colicin E3imm gene in the: ColE3-CA38 plasmid. Comparison of these immunity structures reveals considerable sequence divergence) but the ColE8imm gene is markedly homologous to the colicin E2imm gene from the ColE2-P9 plasmid.Issued as NRCC no. 23586 and as CBRI no. 1480.     

Incompatibility between E colicin plasmids

We have tested the ability of pairs of colicin E plasmids to replicate stably in the same cell line. Although many of the pairs of E colicin plasmids were compatible, plasmids ColE3-CA38, ColE7-K317 and ColE8-J were mutually incompatible, as were ColE5-099, ColE6-CT14 and ColE9-J. Incompatibility between ColE6-CT14 and ColE5-099 or ColE9-J was asymmetrical, whereas incompatibility between the other plasmid pairs was symmetrical.     

Escherichia coli K317, formerly used to define colicin group E2, produces colicin E7, is immune to colicin E2, and carries a bacteriophage-restricting conjugative plasmid.

Escherichia coli strain CL137, a K-12 derivative made E colicinogenic by contact with Fredericq's strain K317, was unaffected by colicin E2-P9, but K-12 carrying ColE2-P9 was sensitive to the E colicin made by strains CL137 and K317. This colicin we named E7-K317 because by the test of colicinogenic immunity it differed from colicins E1-K30, E2-P9, and E3-CA38 and from recently recognized colicins termed E4Horak, E5, and E6. Strain K317 as conjugational donor transmitted E7 colicinogeny; about half the E7-colicinogenic transconjugants were immune to colicin E2-P9. A spontaneous variant of CL137 retained E7 colicinogeny but was sensitive to E2 colicins. We attribute the E2 immunity of strain CL137 and some E7-coliconogeic transconjugants to a "colicin-immunity plasmid," ColE2imm-K317, from strain K317. Tra+ E7-colicinogenic transconjugants restricted phage BF23 in the same way as strains carrying ColIb-P9. We attribute Tra+ and restricting ability to a plasmid, pRES-K317, acquired from strain K317, and related to the ColI plasmids.     

Comparative nucleotide sequences encoding the immunity proteins and the carboxyl-terminal peptides of colicins E2 and E3

Using the M13 dideoxy sequencing technique, we have established the DNA sequences of colicins E2 and E3 which encompass the receptor-binding and the catalytic domains of each of the nucleases, and their immunity (imm) genes. The imm gene of plasmid ColE2-P9 is 255 bp long and is separated from the end of the col gene by a dinucleotide. This gene pair is arranged similarly in plasmid ColE3-CA38 except that the intergenic space is 9 bp and the E3 imm gene is one codon shorter than its E2 counterpart. Comparisons of the E2 and E3 imm sequences indicate considerable divergence whereas the receptor-binding domains of both colicins are highly conserved. The two nuclease domains appear to share some sequence homology. A possible evolutionary relationship between colicin E3 and other microbial extracellular ribonucleases is also suggested from the sequence alignment analysis.     

Identification of a unique specificity determinant of the colicin E3 immunity protein.

Plasmid immunity to a nuclease-type colicin is defined by the specific binding of an immunity (or inhibitor) protein, Imm, to the C-terminal nuclease domain, T2A, of the colicin molecule. Whereas most regions of colicin operons exhibit extensive sequence identity, the small plasmid region encoding T2A and Imm is exceptionally varied. Since immunity is essential for the survival of the potentially lethal colicin plasmid (Col), we inferred that T2A and Imm must have co-evolved, retaining their mutual binding specificities. To evaluate this co-evolution model for the col and imm genes of ColE3 and ColE6, we attempted to obtain a stabilized clone from a plasmid which had been destabilized with a non-cognate immunity gene. A hybrid Col, in which the immE3 gene of the ColE3 was replaced with immE6 from ColE6, was lethal to the host cells upon SOS induction. From among this suicidal cell population, we isolated a stabilized, i.e., evolved, clone which produced colicin E3 (E3) stably and exhibited immunity to E3. This change arose from only a single mutation in ImmE6, from Trp48 to Cys, the same residue as in the ImmE3 sequence. In addition, we constructed a series of chimeric genes through homologous recombination between immE3 and immE6. Characterization of these chimeric immunity genes confirmed the above finding that colicins E3 and E6 are mostly distinguished by only Cys48 of the ImmE3 protein.     

A DNA segment within the colicin E1 structural gene on ColE1 affecting immunity to colicin

Summary Insertion of DNA at the EcoRI site of ColE1 results in increase of immunity to colicin killing in E. coli harboring such recombinant ColE1 plasmid as compared to E. coli (ColE1). This effect is neither due to cis or trans interactions originating from the inserted foreign DNA fragment, nor to changes in plasmid copy number. This defect in the immunity mechanism is not trans complemented for by wild type ColE1. Increase in immunity can also be obtained by deleting a DNA segment from the ColE1 genome. This segment is 120 bp left to the EcoRI site within the colicin structural gene. It is concluded that the structure of DNA per se, around the EcoRI site, within colicin structural gene, is the structure which affects immunity expression.     

Nucleotide sequences from the colicin E5, E6 and E9 operons: Presence of a degenerate transposon-like structure in the ColE9-J plasmid

Summary The nucleotide sequences of 1288 bp of plasmid ColE5-099, 1609 bp of ColE6-CT14 and 2099 bp of ColE9-J were determined. These sequences encompass the structural genes for the C-terminal receptor-binding and nuclease domains of colicins E5, E6 and E9, theircis- ortrans-acting immunity proteins and four lysis proteins including an atypical one of non-lipoprotein nature (Lys^*) present in the ColE9-J plasmid. The ColE6 gene organisation, in the ordercol-imm-E8imm-lys, is identical to that found in the previously described double-immunity gene system of ColE3-CA38 (an RNase producer). The corresponding genes in the two plasmids are 87%–94% homologous. In ColE9-J, the genes are organised ascol-imm-lys ^*-E5imm-lys. The E9col-imm gene pair is homologous to the colicin E2-P9 type (a DNase producer). Downstream from E9imm is an E5imm (designated E5imm[E9]) which istrans-acting. Neither the predicted structures of E5Imm[E9] nor thecis-acting Imm resident in the ColE5-099 plasmid which differs by a single amino acid shows any resemblance to other immunity structures which have been sequenced. Furthermore, the E5col sequences differ from those predicted previously for other colicins except for the conservedbtuB-specified receptor-binding domain. A novel 205 nucleotide long insertion sequence is found in the ColE9-J plasmid. This insertion sequence, which we named ISE9, has features reminiscent of the degenerate transposon IS101 previously found in plasmid pSC101. One effect of ISE9 is the presence of the atypical lysis gene,lys ^*. The presence of a transposon-like element in the ColE9 plasmid exemplifies a new phenomenon relevant to the evolution of colicin E plasmids. Issued as NRCC publication no. 30065     

Mutants of ColE1 plasmid with altered expression of the colicin E1 immunity gene

Mutagenesis with Tn1 transposon was used to isolate mutants of ColE1 plasmid with inactivated gene responsible for immunity to colicin E1. Cells containing such mutants synthesized active colicin E1 and were sensitive to its action. Spontaneous and UV-induced colicin synthesis was strongly changed in the mutants, as compared to the control. Mutations occurring outside the immunity gene, including those within the structural gene for colicin E1, could also affect the immunity gene expression.     

Comparison of plasmids Co1E2-P9 and Co1E2-CA42 and their immunity proteins

Plasmids ColE2-CA42 (6.1 kilobases) and ColE2-P9 (6.8 kilobases) were found to have homologous (4.3-kilobase) DNA segments which contain their colicin and immunity genes. The relatedness of their immunity proteins was verified by determining their amino acid compositions and N-terminal sequences. These characteristics were compared with those of ColE3-CA38.     

Plasmid-encoded regulation of colicin E1 gene expression.

A plasmid-encoded factor that regulates the expression of the colicin E1 gene was found in molecular cloning experiments. The 2,294-base-pair AvaII fragment of the colicin E1 plasmid (ColE1) carrying the colicin E1 structural gene and the promoter-operator region had the same information with respect to the repressibility and inducibility of colicin E1 synthesis as the original ColE1 plasmid. An operon fusion was constructed between the 204-bp fragment containing the colicin E1 promoter-operator and xylE, the structural gene for catechol 2,3-dioxygenase encoded on the TOL plasmid of Pseudomonas putida. The synthesis of the dioxygenase from the resulting plasmid occurred in recA+, but not in recA- cells and was derepressed in the recA lexA(Def) double mutant. These results indicate that the ColE1 plasmid has no repressor gene for colicin E1 synthesis and that the lexA protein functions as a repressor. Colicin E1 gene expression was adenosine 3',5'-phosphate (cAMP) dependent. Upon the removal of two PvuII fragments (2,000 bp in length) from the ColE1 plasmid, the induced synthesis of colicin E1 occurred in the adenylate-cyclase mutant even without cAMP. The 3,100-bp Tth111I fragment of the ColE1 plasmid cloned on pACYC177 restored the cAMP dependency of the deleted ColE1 plasmid. Since the deleted fragments correspond to the mobility region of ColE1, the cAMP dependency of the gene expression should be somehow related to the plasmid mobilization function.     

Genetic analysis of the functional relationship between colicin E3 and its immunity protein.

Partial deletions in the immunity gene of the colicin E3 operon were used to study possible functions of the immunity protein besides protection against exogenous colicin. Nuclease BAL-31 was used to create a series of carboxyl-terminal deletions of the immunity gene. Mutants displaying lowered immunity against exogenous colicin were found, and six that had reduced but detectable levels of immunity were chosen for further analysis. DNA sequence analysis of the deletions showed that all six terminated within the last five codons of the immunity gene. The wild-type immunity gene was replaced by each of the six mutated immunity genes in a plasmid containing an otherwise functional colicin E3 operon. Transformants containing the resulting plasmids produced smaller colonies on solid medium and grew more slowly in liquid culture than transformants carrying the wild-type colicin and immunity genes. This result suggested that immunity protein was required to protect the cell against endogenous colicin E3. This idea was confirmed in experiments in which the colicin E3 and immunity genes were independently cloned on two compatible plasmid vectors.     

Nucleotide sequence of the immunity and lysis region of the ColE9-J plasmid

We have determined the nucleotide sequence of a 1500 bp fragment of the ColE9-J plasmid which encodes colicin E9 immunity and colicin E5 immunity and contains two lys genes. Open reading frames corresponding to the four genes have been located and their position confirmed by transposon mutagenesis of sub-clones of the ColE9-J plasmid. The E9imm gene shows 69% homology at both the nucleotide and the amino acid level to the previously sequenced E2imm gene. The E5imm gene shows little homology to any other E colicin immunity gene which has been sequenced. The lys gene distal to the 3' end of the E5imm gene shows considerable sequence homology to all other previously sequenced E colicin lys genes. The lys gene distal to the 3' end of the E9imm gene is identical to the pColE2 and pColE3 lys genes for the first 59 nucleotides but encodes a much smaller gene product than any other lys gene which has been sequenced. The two lys genes sequenced here are exceptions to Shepherd's rule concerning the number of RNY codons in the three possible reading frames.