Effect of membrane potential and pH gradient on electron transfer in cytochrome oxidase

Steady-state spectra of cytochrome oxidase in phospholipid vesicles were obtained by using hexaammineruthenium(II) and ascorbate as reductants. Cytochrome a was up to 80% reduced in the steady state in coupled vesicles. Upon addition of nigericin or acetate, which decrease delta pH, resulting in an increase in delta psi, cytochrome a became more oxidized in the steady state with no change in the rate of respiration. On the other hand, uncouplers or valinomycin plus nigericin, which lower both delta psi and delta pH, stimulated respiration 2-8-fold and also lowered the steady-state level of reduction of cytochrome a. These experiments indicate that electron transfer between cytochromes a and a 3 is sensitive primarily to the pH gradient. Studies with the reconstituted and the soluble enzyme at various pH values indicated that the pH on the matrix side of the membrane, rather than delta pH, controlled the steady-state level of reduced cytochrome a. Hexaammineruthenium(II) substituted for cytochrome c in measurements of proton pumping by cytochrome oxidase. Dicyclohexylcarbodiimide, which eliminated proton pumping by cytochrome oxidase, decreased the effect of ionophores on the steady-state level of reduced cytochrome a.     

Fusion of phospholipid vesicles reconstituted with cytochrome c oxidase and mitochondrial hydrophobic protein.

Reconstituted cytochrome oxidase liposomes were fused with liposomes reconstituted with mitochondrial hydrophobic protein, which acts as a membrane-bound uncoupler of cytochrome oxidase. Fusion was assayed by the loss of respiratory control of cytochrome oxidase as measured by the increased rate of ascorbate oxidation induced by hydrophobic protein when both proteins shared the same vesicles. Fusion was dependent on the presence of phosphatidylserine in the liposomes Ca++ in the aqueous medium. Phosphatidylcholine-phosphatidylserine liposomes required higher concentrations of phosphatidylserine and Ca++ than did phosphatidylethanolamine-phosphatidylserine liposomes. Cytochrome oxidase vesicles containing high concentrations of phosphatidylserine showed little or no respiratory control, while those with lower concentrations showed high respiratory control; respiratory control could be induced by fusing cytochrome oxidase vesicles containing high phosphatidylserine with protein-free liposomes containing low phosphatidylserine concentration. If cytochrome oxidase vesicles and hydrophobic protein vesicles were prefused separately for 15 min, they lost the ability to fuse upon being subsequently mixed together. The reconstituted vesicles had diameters of about 200 A; fusion yielded vesicles with diameters in excess of 1000 A.     

Fusion of phospholipid vesicles reconstituted with cytochromec oxidase and mitochondrial hydrophobic protein

Summary Reconstituted cytochrome oxidase liposomes were fused with liposomes reconstituted with mitochondrial hydrophobic protein, which acts as a membrane-bound uncoupler of cytochrome oxidase. Fusion was assayed by the loss of respiratory control of cytochrome oxidase as measured by the increased rate of ascorbate oxidation induced by hydrophobic protein when both proteins shared the same vesicles. Fusion was dependent on the presence of phosphatidylserine in the liposomes and Ca⁺⁺ in the aqueous medium. Phosphatidylcholine-phosphatidylserine liposomes required higher concentrations of phosphatidylserine and Ca⁺⁺ than did phosphatidylethanolamine-phosphatidylserine liposomes. Cytochrome oxidase vesicles containing high concentrations of phosphatidylserine showed little or no respiratory control, while those with lower concentrations showed high respiratory control; respiratory control could be induced by fusing cytochrome oxidase vesicles containing high phosphatidylserine with protein-free liposomes containing low phosphatidylserine concentration. If cytochrome oxidase vesicles and hydrophobic protein vesicles were prefused separately for 15 min, they lost the ability to fuse upon being subsequently mixed together. The reconstituted vesicles had diameters of about 200 Å; fusion yielded vesicles with diameters in excess of 1000 Å.     

Cation transport in cytochrome oxidase reconstituted vesicles.

Cation translocation across the membrane of cytochrome oxidase reconstituted vesicles may be followed with a simple spectrophotometric method. Cytochrome oxidase reconstituted vesicles, supplemented with ascorbate and cytochrome c. induce large spectral changes of the positive dye safranine, reversed by uncouplers and inhibitors of respiration. The dye is probably accumulated in the inner space of the vesicles, where it reaches high concentrations and aggregates. The spectral shifts and the absorbance changes, due to aggregation, are proportional to the amount of the dye taken up and depend on the respiratory control. In the presence of potassium, valinomycin causes an inhibition, whereas nigericin stimulates the dye uptake. The data are discussed in terms of electrical potential dependent fluxes.     

A mechanism of respiratory control: studies with proteoliposomes containing cytochrome oxidase and bacteriorhodopsin

Both beef heart cytochrome oxidase and bacteriorhodopsin of Halobacterium halobium were reconstituted into liposomes by the sonication-cholate dialysis method. The proteoliposomes showed the respiratory control ratio of 4.2, and steady-state illumination of the vesicles lead to the 2.7-fold stimulation of the oxidase activity in the absence of uncouplers. The light-stimulated state 4 respiration increased with light intensity, but light had no effect on the oxidase activity that had been relieved by addition of uncouplers. Proteoliposomes with the photosensitive oxidase activity were also obtained when cytochrome oxidase vesicles were fused with bacteriorhodopsin vesicles in the presence of calcium chloride, and the extent of photoactivation was maximally 1.4-fold. The light-induced respiratory release was observed even in the presence of valinomycin or nigericin, indicating that the oxidase activity was sensitive to both the membrane potential and the pH gradient. We propose as a mechanism of the respiratory control that the process of proton transport to the reaction center for water formation is the rate limiting step for the cytochrome oxidase activity.     

Reconstitution of cytochrome c oxidase in phospholipid vesicles containing polyvinylic polymers.

Cytochrome c oxidase was reconstituted in phospholipid vesicles in the presence of highly hydrophobic poly(vinyl alkanoate) polymers. Electron-microscopy observations demonstrated that polymer interaction with the lipid phase induces vesicles to adopt smaller diameters than those typical of standard proteoliposomes. Functional characterization of these polymer-proteoliposome structures indicates that the reconstitution of the enzyme proceeds efficiently without causing either scrambling of the protein orientation in the membrane or loss of respiratory control. A clear dependence of respiratory control ratio on vesicle size was also demonstrated, which is in agreement with a previous model proposed for control of activity of cytochrome c oxidase vesicles [Brunori, Sarti, Colosimo, Antonini, Malatesta, Jones & Wilson (1985) EMBO J. 4, 2365-2368].     

Selective incorporation of membrane proteins into proteoliposomes of different compositions.

1. Cytochrome oxidase was incorporated into preformed liposomes containing phosphatidylserine. When confronted with a mixture of liposomes, some containing phosphatidylserine and some without it, the enzyme was incorporated only into the phosphatidylserine-containing liposomes. 2. The hydrophobic proteins of the oligomycin-sensitive ATPase incubated in the presence of a mixture of liposomes with and without cytochrome oxidase were preferentially incorporated into cytochrome oxidase-containing liposomes. This selectivity was abolished by either cytochrome c or ascorbate. 3. Cytochrome oxidase incubated in the presence of a mixture of liposomes with and without the hydrophobic proteins of the ATPase was preferentially incorporated into liposomes that did not contain the hydrophobic proteins. 4. Cytochrome oxidase and the oligomycin-sensitive ATPase were preferentially incorporated into pure liposomes over bacteriorhodopsin-containing vesicles. 5. Reduced coenzyme Q (QH2)-cytochrome c reductase was incorporated randomly when incubated in the presence of a mixture of pure liposomes and liposomes containing the hydrophobic proteins of the ATPase complex. 6. The significance of the incorporation procedure as a model for membrane biogenesis is discussed.     

Control of respiration in proteoliposomes containing cytochrome aa3. I. Stimulation by valinomycin and uncoupler

1. Both valinomycin and p-trifluoromethoxy carbonyl cyanide phenylhydrazone (FCCP) are required for full release of respiration by cytochrome c oxidase-containing proteoliposomes (prepared by sonicating beef heart cytochrome aa₃ in salt solution with 4 parts phosphatidylcholine, 4 parts phosphatidylethanolamine and 2 parts cardiolipin) in the presence of external ascorbate and cytochrome c. In the absence of valinomycin the response to FCCP is rather sluggish, as reported by Wrigglesworth et al. (1976) (Abstracts, 10th Int. Congr. Biochem., No. 06-6-230).2. The K_m for cytochrome c in 67 mM, pH 7.4, phosphate buffer with ascorbate as substrate, was 9 μM in both absence and presence of valinomycin and FCCP. Energization thus acts non-competitively towards cytochrome c oxidation.3. The apparent K_m for oxygen is greater in the energized than in the deenergized state; double reciprocal plots of respiration rate versus oxygen concentration are concave downward in the absence of uncouplers, as found with intact mitochondria. Energization thus acts “competitively” towards oxygen.4. Despite the lack of a functional ATPase system, all the kinetic features of energization found in intact mitochondria can be mimicked in the reconstituted liposomes. This supports the chemiosmotic idea that electrical and perhaps H⁺ gradients modify the oxidase activity in reconstituted vesicles.     

Electrochemical potential and ion transport in vesicles of yeast plasma membrane

Vesicles from yeast plasma membrane were prepared according to Franzusoff and Cirillo [1983) J. Biol. Chem. 258, 3608), with slight modifications. When Mg-ATP was added, this preparation was able to generate a membrane potential, that was sensitive to inhibitors of the yeast H+-ATPase and uncouplers, and could be decreased by the addition of permeant anions, as measured by the fluorescence changes of the dye oxonol V. The addition of ATP could also generate a pH gradient, detectable by the fluorescence changes of the monitor aminochloromethoxyacridine. This gradient was sensitive to inhibitors of ATPase and uncouplers, and could be increased by the addition of permeant anions to the incubation mixture. When the vesicles were loaded with KCl, an increased rate of K+ efflux was produced upon the addition of ATP. Cytochrome oxidase from bovine heart could be reconstituted into the vesicles and was shown to generate a membrane potential difference, negative inside, evidenced by the fluorescence quenching of the cyanide dipropylthiacarbocyanine and the uptake of tetraphenylphosphonium. Besides, in these vesicles, K+ and Rb+, but not Na+ or NH+4 could decrease the quenching of fluorescence and the uptake of tetraphenylphosphonium produced when the electron-donor system was present. In the vesicles in which cytochrome oxidase was incorporated, upon the addition of cytochrome c and ascorbate, the uptake of 86Rb+ could be demonstrated also. This uptake was found to be saturable and inhibited by K+, and to a lesser degree by Na+. The results obtained indicate that these vesicles are reasonably sealed and capable of generating and maintaining a membrane potential. The membrane potential could be used to drive ions across the membrane of the vesicles, indicating the presence and functionality of the monovalent cation carrier. The vesicles, in general terms seem to be suitable for studying transport of ions and metabolites in yeast.     

Chemical modification of the CuA site affects the proton pumping activity of cytochrome c oxidase

Cytochrome c oxidase in which the CuA site has been perturbed by extensive modification of the enzyme with the thiol reagent p-(hydroxymercuri)benzoate has been reconstituted into phospholipid vesicles. The reconstituted vesicles lack respiratory control, and the orientation of the enzyme in the vesicles is similar to that of the native cytochrome c oxidase. In the proton translocation assay, the vesicles containing the modified enzyme behave as if they are unusually permeable to protons. When the modified and native proteins were coreconstituted, a substantial portion of the latter became uncoupled as revealed by low respiratory control and low overall proton pumping activity. These results suggest that the modified enzyme catalyzes a passive transport of protons across the membrane. When milder conditions were used for the chemical modification, a majority of the thiols reacted while the CuA site remained largely intact. Reconstitution of such a partially modified cytochrome c oxidase produced vesicles with respiratory control and proton translocating activity close to those of reconstituted native enzyme. It thus appears that the appearance of a proton leak is related to the perturbation of the CuA site. These observations suggest that the structure of CuA may be related to the role of this site in the proton pumping machinery of cytochrome c oxidase.     

Membrane potential generation by two reconstituted mitochondrial systems: Liposomes inlayed with cytochrome oxidase or with ATPase

Formation of a membrane potential in two types of liposomes, one inlayed with cytochrome c + cytochrome oxidase, and another, with oligomycin-sensitive ATPase, has been demonstrated. To detect a membrane potential, phenyl dicarbaundecaborane (PCB⁻), a penetrating anion probe, was used.

The first type of liposome was reconstituted from a solution of purified cytochrome oxidase, mitochondrial phospholipids and cytochrome c, the latter being enclosed inside liposomes. Cytochrome c bound to the outer surface of the liposome membrane was removed by washing with NaCl. Such liposomes catalyzed oxidation of ascorbate by oxygen in the presence of phenazine methosulfate or N,N,N′,N′-tetramethyl-p-phenylenediamine. The oxidation was found to support the PCB⁻ uptake by liposomes. The PCB⁻ response was prevented and reversed by cyanide, protonophorous uncouplers and external cytochrome c.

Liposomes of the second type were prepared from a solution of mitochondrial phospholipids, coupling factors F₁and F_c, and the hydrophobic proteins of the oligomycin-sensitive ATPase. These liposomes catalyzed ATP hydrolysis coupled with the PCB⁻ uptake. The latter effect was prevented and reversed by oligomycin and uncouplers.

The conclusion is made that membrane potential can be independently formed by enzymic reactions of two different kinds: (1) redox (e.g. cytochrome c oxidase) and (2) hydrolytic (ATPase).     

Inhibition of Iron-oxidizing Activity by Bisulfite Ion in Thiobacillus ferrooxidans

Growth of Thiobacillus ferrooxidans on iron- and sulfur-salts media and iron oxidizing activity of this bacterium were strongly inhibited by bisulfite ion. The mechanism of inhibition by bisulfite ion of iron-oxidizing activity was studied with the plasma membrane of T. ferrooxidans AP19-3. The c-type cytochrome in the plasma membrane was reduced by ferrous ion and the cytochrome reduced by Fe²⁺ was oxidized by cytochrome c oxidase in the plasma membrane. In contrast, c-type cytochrome was reduced by bisulfite ion, but it was not oxidized by cytochrome c oxidase in the membrane. Cytochrome c-oxidizing activity was also inhibited by the ion when mammalian cytochrome c was used as an electron donor, suggesting that cytochrome c oxidase, one of the component of iron oxidase, is the site of inhibition by bisulfite ion.     

Respiratory control in cytochrome oxidase

Vesicles of cytochrome oxidase, generated by dilution of the oxidase with a 15-fold excess of lipid by the Hinkle-Racker method, showed a respiratory control index of greater than 5 in presence of the combination of valinomycin and nigericin. Uncouplers were found to be ineffective in releasing respiratory control in the absence of valinomycin. Valinomycin titration in the presence of excess nigericin gave approximately a one to one stoichiometry with cytochrome oxidase. We propose that coupling of electron transfer to valinomycin K⁺ transport in cytochrome oxidase vesicles is a molecular event; the insensitivity of respiratory control to uncouplers is a consequence of the absence of the systems other than cytochrome oxidase which are required for the action of uncouplers.     

Ca2+ transport against its electrochemical gradient in cytochrome oxidase vesicles reconstituted with mitochondrial hydrophobic proteins

Cytochrome oxidase vesicles have recently been shown to accumulate Ca²⁺ in an energy-dependent manner. Energization of these vesicles with internally trapped cytochrome c and externally added ascorbate and phenazine methylsulfate generated an internally positive membrane potential and prevented Ca²⁺ influx (R. N. Rosier and T. E. Gunter, 1980, FEBS Lett.109, 99–103). In contradistinction, when cytochrome oxidase vesicles were reconstituted with complex V, a mitochondrial protein fraction containing the uncoupler binding site (Y. Hatefi, D. L. Stiggall, Y. Galante and W. G. Hanstein, 1974, Biochem. Biophys. Res. Commun.61, 313–321), both Ca²⁺ uptake and generation of an internally positive membrane potential were observed. The uptake was specifically dependent on energization of electron transport. Control experiments verified that the energization conditions used produced appropriately oriented membrane potentials. Other partially purified hydrophobic mitochondrial protein complexes were found to be less effective than complex V. The reconstituted system showed cation selectivity since Ca²⁺, Mn²⁺, and Rb⁺ were transported, while Na⁺ was not. Low levels of uncoupler, which did not affect oxidation rates, were found to partially inhibit Ca²⁺ uptake regardless of the membrane potential polarity. Uncoupling levels of uncoupler markedly inhibited Ca²⁺ uptake in internally negative cytochrome oxidase vesicles; however, inhibition in internally positive cytochrome oxidase vesicles was less relative to that at lower levels of uncoupler. The uncoupling combination of nigericin, valinomycin, and K⁺ was inhibitory to uptake regardless of membrane potential polarity. A reconstituted system of oxidative phosphorylation, which contains a hydrophobic protein fraction, energized with cytochrome oxidase similarly accumulated Ca²⁺ despite formation of an internally positive membrane potential. The results suggest that cytochrome oxidase, when coupled to appropriate hydrophobic mitochondrial proteins, can act as an electrogenic Ca²⁺ pump deriving its energy directly from electron transport.     

Orientation and reactivity of cytochrome aa3 heme groups in proteoliposomes

Reduction of cytochrome aa₃ in proteoliposomes with ascorbate plus cytochrome c confirms that not more than 55% of the molecules are externally accessible and that the remainder are reduced only on the addition of membrane-permeable N,N,N′,N′tetramethyl-p-henylenediamine. Reduction in the presence of terminal inhibitors such as cyanide, azide, and carbon monoxide shows that likewise 50% of the cytochrome a is accessible and 50% inaccessible. Dithionite reduces part of the cytochrome a₃ in the presence of azide, and none in the presence of cyanide. Methyl viologen, which is somewhat membrane permeable, can reduce part of the cyanide-complexed cytochrome a₃ at low concentrations and all of it at high concentrations. Cytochrome a₃ is therefore also distributed randomly inside and outside the vesicles. Cytochrome c oxidase with externally facing cytochrome a is stimulated to high activity by its membrane association. Its turnover is dependent on the external pH and it is inhibited by external azide; trapping of azide cannot be used to demonstrate the orientation of the cytochrome a₃ hemes associated with externally facing cytochrome a. Cytochrome c oxidase with internally facing cytochrome a is rather sluggishly reactive. Its low activity accounts for the apparent failure of detergents to release extra activity on lysing proteoliposomes. Double reciprocal plots of the reaction of added cytochrome c with proteoliposomes indicate apparent biphasic binding in the energized state, which is abolished upon the addition of uncouplers and valinomycin. But no transmembraneous effect upon the oxidase reaction other than energization has been identified.     

Effect of organophosphorus insecticides on the oxidative processes in rat brain synaptosomes

Abstract: This paper describes the effect of four organophosphorus insecticides: Dipterex, DDVP, Ronnel and its oxygen analogue on the respiration of rat brain synaptosomes. Dipterex and DDVP in the concentrations used, 5, 50, or 500 μM, did not change the rate of oxygen uptake and oxidative phosphorylation in rat brain synaptosomes. Ronnel in the highest concentration (500 μM) inhibited respiration in state 3 conditions and abolished respiratory control by ADP. This inhibition was correlated with a change of cytochrome c oxidase activity. The oxygen analogue of Ronnel (OAR) in micromolar concentrations (50 μM) increased the rate of respiration of synaptosomes utilizing glutamate plus malate as substrate. Higher concentrations of OAR produced inhibition of respiration, cytochrome c oxidase and NADH: cytochrome c reductase activities. These observations are typical for uncouplers of oxidative phosphorylation. Noteworthy is the fact that the uncoupling activity of OAR was observed at concentrations which did not inhibit acetylcholinesterase activity. These findings seem to suggest that disturbances in oxidative processes could play an important role in the toxicity of organophosphorus insecticides. The relation between chemical structure and the ability of insecticides to affect oxidative phosphorylation is discussed.     

Measurements of the proton motive force generated by cytochrome c oxidase from Bacillus subtilis in proteoliposomes and membrane vesicles

Cytochrome c oxidase from Bacillus subtilis was reconstituted in liposomes and its energy-transducing properties were studied. The reconstitution procedure used included Ca2+-induced fusion of pre-formed membranes. The orientation of the enzyme in liposomes is influenced by the phospholipid composition of the membrane. Negatively charged phospholipids are essential for high oxidase activity and respiratory control. Analyses of the proteoliposomes by gel filtration, density gradient centrifugation and electron microscopy indicated a heterogeneity of the proteoliposomes with respect to size and respiratory control. Cytochrome c oxidase activity in the proteoliposomes resulted in the generation of a proton motive force, internally negative and alkaline. In the presence of the electron donor, ascorbate/N,N,N',N'-tetramethyl-p-phenylenediamine/cytochrome c or ascorbate/phenazine methosulphate, the reconstituted enzyme generated an electrical potential of 84 mV which was increased by the addition of nigericin to 95 mV and a pH gradient of 32 mV which was increased by the addition of valinomycin to 39 mV. Similar results were obtained with beef-heart cytochrome c oxidase reconstituted in liposomes. The maximal proton motive force which could be generated, assuming no endogenous ion leakage, varied over 110-140 mV. From this the efficiency of energy transduction by cytochrome c oxidase was calculated to be 18-23%, indicating that the oxidase is an efficient proton-motive-force-generating system.     

Reduction of oxygen-pulsed cytochrome c oxidase by cytochrome c and other electron donors

1. Stopped-flow experiments were performed in which solutions containing dithionite were mixed with air-saturated buffer. Cytochrome c oxidase present in the dithionite-containing syringe is fully oxidized within the mixing time and the oxygen-pulsed form of the oxidase is produced.2. The reduction of this form by dithionite, by dithionite plus cytochrome c and by dithionite plus methyl viologen or benzyl viologen was followed and compared with the corresponding reduction reactions of the ‘resting’ oxidized enzyme. Reduction by dithionite is relatively slow, but the rate of reduction is greatly increased by addition of cytochrome c or the viologens, which are even more effective than cytochrome c on a molar basis.3. Profound differences between the transient kinetics of the reduction of the two oxidized oxidase derivatives were observed. The results are consistent with a direct reduction of cytochrome a followed by an intramolecular electron transfer to cytochrome a₃ (k^obs₁ = 7.5 s^?1 for the oxygen-pulsed oxidase).4. The spectrum of the oxygen-pulsed oxidase formed within 5 ms of the mixing closely resembles that of the ‘oxygenated’ compound, but there were small differences between the two spectra.     

Differential effects of osmotic pressure on mitochondrial respiratory chain and indices of oxidative phosphorylation

Oxidative phosphorylation was critically evaluated in terms of activities which are sensitive and insensitive to variations in external osmotic pressure in mitochondria. Integrity of mitochondria was determined in terms of a variety of parameters, including the latency of the occluded enzymes, by careful titrations as a function of external osmotic pressure as well as detergent concentrations. The evidence indicated that the rate-limiting step in respiratory states 2 and 4 would be osmotically insensitive, as opposed to the osmotically sensitive respiration of states 1 and 3 and uncoupler-stimulated respiration with glutamate + malate and succinate. Cytochrome oxidase activity in mitochondria as well as in purified reconstituted systems exhibited osmotic insensitivity but marked sensitivity to ionic strength, offering an interesting model to study the osmotically insensitive respiration. Cytochrome oxidase activity led to permeation of mannitol across the mitochondrial inner membrane. Stimulation of cytochrome oxidase activity by uncouplers did not require an intact membrane.     

Reconstitution of ion transport and respiratory control in vesicles formed from reduced coenzyme Q-cytochrome c reductase and phospholipids.

Reduced coenzyme Q-cytochrome c reductase from bovine heart mitochondria (complex III) was incorporated into phospholipid vesicles by the cholate dialysis procedure. Soybean phospholipids or mixtures of purified phosphatidylcholine, phosphatidylethanolamine, and cardiolipin could be used. Oxidation of reduced coenzyme Q2 by the reconstituted vesicles with cytochrome c as oxidant showed the following energy-coupling phenomena. 1. Protons were translocated outward with a coupling ratio, H+/2e, of 1.9 +/- 0.2. Measurements with mitochondria under similar conditions showed an H+/2e ratio of 1.8. Proton translocation was not seen in the presence of uncoupling agents and was in addition to the net acidification of the medium from the over-all oxidation reaction. 2. Potassium ions were taken up by the reconstituted vesicles in the presence of valinomycin in a reaction coupled to electron transfer. The coupling ratio for K+ uptake, K+/2e, was 2.0 in the vesicles and approximately 1.5 in mitochondria. 3. The rate of oxidation of reduced coenzyme Q2 by the reconstituted vesicles was stimulated up to 10-fold by uncouplers or by valinomycin plus nigericin and K+ ions. Addition of valinomycin alone in a K+ medium caused a transient stimulation of electron transfer. The results indicate that energy coupling can be observed with isolated reduced coenzyme Q-cytochrome c reductase if the enzyme complex is properly incorporated into a phospholipid vesicle.