Changes in purine specificity in tandem GAF chimeras from cyanobacterial cyaB1 adenylate cyclase and rat phosphodiesterase 2

The C-terminal catalytic domains of the 11 mammalian phosphodiesterase families (PDEs) are important drug targets. Five of the 11 PDE families contain less well-characterized N-terminal GAF domains. cGMP is the ligand for the GAF domains in PDEs 2, 5, 6 and 11, and cAMP is the ligand for PDE10. Structurally related tandem GAF domains signalling via cAMP are present in the cyanobacterial adenylate cyclases cyaB1 and cyaB2. Because current high-resolution crystal structures of the tandem GAF domains of PDE2 and cyaB2 do not reveal how cNMP specificity is encoded, we generated chimeras between the tandem GAF domains of cyaB1 and PDE2. Both bind the ligand in the GAF B subdomains. Segmental replacements in the highly divergent beta1-beta3 region of the GAF B subdomain of cyaB1 by the corresponding PDE2 regions switched signalling from cAMP to cGMP. Using 10 chimeric constructs, we demonstrated that, for this switch in purine specificity, only 11% of the sequence of the cyanobacterial GAF B needs to be replaced by PDE2 sequences. We were unable, however, to switch the purine specificity of the PDE2 tandem GAF domain from cGMP to cAMP in reverse constructs, i.e. by replacement of PDE2 segments with those from the cyaB1 GAF tandem domain. The data provide a novel view on the structure-function relationships underlying the purine specificity of cNMP-binding GAF domains and indicate that, as potential drug targets, they must be characterized structurally and biochemically one by one.     

cAMP is a ligand for the tandem GAF domain of human phosphodiesterase 10 and cGMP for the tandem GAF domain of phosphodiesterase 11

N-terminal tandem GAF domains are present in 5 out of 11 mammalian phosphodiesterase (PDE) families. The ligand for the GAF domains of PDEs 2, 5, and 6 is cGMP, whereas those for PDEs 10 and 11 remained enigmatic for years. Here we used the cyanobacterial cyaB1 adenylyl cyclase, which has an N-terminal tandem GAF domain closely related to those of the mammalian PDEs, as an assay system to identify the ligands for the human PDEs 10 and 11 GAF domains. We report that a chimera between the PDE10 GAF domain and the cyanobacterial cyclase was 9-fold stimulated by cAMP (EC50= 19.8 microm), whereas cGMP had only low activity. cAMP increased Vmax in a non-cooperative manner and did not affect the Km for ATP of 27 microm. In an analogous chimeric construct with the tandem GAF domain of human PDE11A4, cGMP was identified as an allosteric activator (EC50 = 72.5 microm) that increased Vmax of the cyclase non-cooperatively 4-fold. GAF-B of PDE10 and GAF-A of PDE11A4 contain an invariant NKFDE motif present in all mammalian PDE GAF ensembles. We mutated the aspartates within this motif in both regions and found that intramolecular signaling was considerably reduced or abolished. This was in line with all data concerning GAF domains with an NKFDE motif as far as they have been tested. The data appeared to define those GAF domains as a distinct subclass within the >3100 annotated GAF domains for which we propose a tentative classification scheme.     

Crystal structure of the GAF-B domain from human phosphodiesterase 10A complexed with its ligand, cAMP

Cyclic nucleotide phosphodiesterases (PDEs) catalyze the degradation of the cyclic nucleotides cAMP and cGMP, which are important second messengers. Five of the 11 mammalian PDE families have tandem GAF domains at their N termini. PDE10A may be the only mammalian PDE for which cAMP is the GAF domain ligand, and it may be allosterically stimulated by cAMP. PDE10A is highly expressed in striatal medium spiny neurons. Here we report the crystal structure of the C-terminal GAF domain (GAF-B) of human PDE10A complexed with cAMP at 2.1-angstroms resolution. The conformation of the PDE10A GAF-B domain monomer closely resembles those of the GAF domains of PDE2A and the cyanobacterium Anabaena cyaB2 adenylyl cyclase, except for the helical bundle consisting of alpha1, alpha2, and alpha5. The PDE10A GAF-B domain forms a dimer in the crystal and in solution. The dimerization is mainly mediated by hydrophobic interactions between the helical bundles in a parallel arrangement, with a large buried surface area. In the PDE10A GAF-B domain, cAMP tightly binds to a cNMP-binding pocket. The residues in the alpha3 and alpha4 helices, the beta6 strand, the loop between 3(10) and alpha4, and the loop between alpha4 and beta5 are involved in the recognition of the phosphate and ribose moieties. This recognition mode is similar to those of the GAF domains of PDE2A and cyaB2. In contrast, the adenine base is specifically recognized by the PDE10A GAF-B domain in a unique manner, through residues in the beta1 and beta2 strands.     

Direct allosteric regulation between the GAF domain and catalytic domain of photoreceptor phosphodiesterase PDE6

Photoreceptor cGMP phosphodiesterase (PDE6) is the central enzyme in the visual transduction cascade. The PDE6 catalytic subunit contains a catalytic domain and regulatory GAF domains. Unlike most GAF domain-containing cyclic nucleotide phosphodiesterases, little is known about direct allosteric communication of PDE6. In this study, we demonstrate for the first time direct, inter-domain allosteric communication between the GAF and catalytic domains in PDE6. The binding affinity of PDE6 for pharmacological inhibitors or for the C-terminal region of the inhibitory gamma subunit (Pgamma), known to directly inhibit PDE6 catalysis, was increased approximately 2-fold by ligands binding to the GAF domain. Binding of the N-terminal half of Pgamma to the GAF domains suffices to induce this allosteric effect. Allosteric communication between GAF and catalytic domains is reciprocal, in that drug binding to the catalytic domain slowed cGMP dissociation from the GAF domain. Although cGMP hydrolysis was not affected by binding of Pgamma1-60, Pgamma lacking its last seven amino acids decreased the Michaelis constant of PDE6 by 2.5-fold. Pgamma1-60 binding to the GAF domain increased vardenafil but not cGMP affinity, indicating that substrate- and inhibitor-binding sites do not totally overlap. In addition, prolonged incubation of PDE6 with vardenafil or sildenafil (but not 3-isobutyl-1-methylxanthine and zaprinast) induced a distinct conformational change in the catalytic domain without affecting the binding properties of the GAF domains. We conclude that although Pgamma-mediated regulation plays the dominant role in visual excitation, the direct, inter-domain allosteric regulation described in this study may play a feedback role in light adaptational processes during phototransduction.     

PDE5 is converted to an activated state upon cGMP binding to the GAF A domain

cGMP-specific, cGMP-binding phosphodiesterase (PDE5) regulates such physiological processes as smooth muscle relaxation and neuronal survival. PDE5 contains two N-terminal domains (GAF A and GAF B), but the functional roles of these domains have not been determined. Here we show that recombinant PDE5 is activated directly upon cGMP binding to the GAF A domain, and this effect does not require PDE5 phosphorylation. PDE5 exhibited time- and concentration-dependent reversible activation in response to cGMP, with the highest activation (9- to 11-fold) observed at low substrate concentrations (0.1 micro M cGMP). A monoclonal antibody directed against GAF A blocked cGMP binding, prevented PDE5 activation and decreased basal activity, revealing that PDE5 in its non-activated state has low intrinsic catalytic activity. Activated PDE5 showed higher sensitivity towards sildenafil than non-activated PDE5. The stimulatory effect of cGMP binding on the catalytic activity of PDE5 suggests that this mechanism of enzyme activation may be common among other GAF domain-containing proteins. The data also suggest that development of agonists and antagonists of PDE5 activity based on binding to this site might be possible.     

Functional chimeras of the phosphodiesterase 5 and 10 tandem GAF domains

The tandem GAF domain of hPDE10A uses cAMP as an allosteric ligand (Gross-Langenhoff, M., Hofbauer, K., Weber, J., Schultz, A., and Schultz, J. E. (2006) J. Biol. Chem. 281, 2841-2846). We used a two-pronged approach to study how discrimination of ligand is achieved in human (h)PDE10A and how domain selection in the phosphodiesterase GAF tandems is determined. First, we examined which functional groups of cAMP are responsible for purine ring discrimination. Changes at the C-6 ring position (removal of the amino group; chloride substitution) and at the N-1 ring position reduced stimulation efficacy by 80%, i.e. marking those positions as decisive for nucleotide discrimination. Second, we generated a GAF tandem chimera that consisted of the cGMP-binding GAF-A unit from hPDE5A1, which signals through cGMP in PDE5, and the GAF-B from hPDE10A1, which signals through cAMP in PDE10. Stimulation of the reporter enzyme exclusively was through the GAF-B domain of hPDE10A1 (EC(50) = 7 mum cAMP) as shown by respective point mutations. The PDE5 GAF-A domain in the chimera did not signal, and its function was reduced to a strictly structural role. Signaling was independent of the origin of the N terminus. Generating 10 additional PDE5/10 tandem GAF chimeras surprisingly demonstrated that the length-conserved linker in GAF tandems between GAF-A and GAF-B played an unforeseen decisive role in intramolecular signaling. Swapping the linker sections between PDE5 and PDE10 GAF tandem domains abrogated signaling completely pointing to specific domain interactions within GAF tandems, which are not visible in the available crystal structures with bound ligands.     

Functional mapping of interacting regions of the photoreceptor phosphodiesterase (PDE6) γ-subunit with PDE6 catalytic dimer, transducin, and regulator of G-protein signaling9-1 (RGS9-1)

The cGMP phosphodiesterase (PDE6) involved in visual transduction in photoreceptor cells contains two inhibitory γ-subunits (Pγ) which bind to the catalytic core (Pαβ) to inhibit catalysis and stimulate cGMP binding to the GAF domains of Pαβ. During visual excitation, interaction of activated transducin with Pγ relieves inhibition. Pγ also participates in a complex with RGS9-1 and other proteins to accelerate the GTPase activity of activated transducin. We studied the structural determinants for these important functions of Pγ. First, we identified two important sites in the middle region of Pγ (amino acids 27-38 and 52-54) that significantly stabilize the overall binding affinity of Pγ with Pαβ. The ability of Pγ to stimulate noncatalytic cGMP binding to the GAF domains of PDE6 has been localized to amino acids 27-30 of Pγ. Transducin activation of PDE6 catalysis critically depends on the presence of Ile54 in the glycine-rich region of Pγ in order to relieve inhibition of catalysis. The central glycine-rich region of Pγ is also required for transducin to increase cGMP exchange at the GAF domains. Finally, Thr-65 and/or Val-66 of Pγ are critical residues for Pγ to stimulate GTPase activity of transducin in a complex with RGS9-1. We propose that the glycine-rich region of Pγ is a primary docking site for PDE6-interacting proteins involved in the activation/inactivation pathways of visual transduction. This functional mapping of Pγ with its binding partners demonstrates the remarkable versatility of this multifunctional protein and its central role in regulating the activation and lifetime of visual transduction.     

Solution structure of the cGMP binding GAF domain from phosphodiesterase 5: insights into nucleotide specificity, dimerization, and cGMP-dependent conformational change

Phosphodiesterase 5 (PDE5) controls intracellular levels of cGMP through its regulation of cGMP hydrolysis. Hydrolytic activity of the C-terminal catalytic domain is increased by cGMP binding to the N-terminal GAF A domain. We present the NMR solution structure of the cGMP-bound PDE5A GAF A domain. The cGMP orientation in the buried binding pocket was defined through 37 intermolecular nuclear Overhauser effects. Comparison with GAF domains from PDE2A and adenylyl cyclase cyaB2 reveals a conserved overall domain fold of a six-stranded beta-sheet and four alpha-helices that form a well defined cGMP binding pocket. However, the nucleotide coordination is distinct with a series of altered binding contacts. The structure suggests that nucleotide binding specificity is provided by Asp-196, which is positioned to form two hydrogen bonds to the guanine ring of cGMP. An alanine mutation of Asp-196 disrupts cGMP binding and increases cAMP affinity in constructs containing only GAF A causing an altered cAMP-bound structural conformation. NMR studies on the tandem GAF domains reveal a flexible GAF A domain in the absence of cGMP, and indicate a large conformational change upon ligand binding. Furthermore, we identify a region of approximately 20 residues directly N-terminal of GAF A as critical for tight dimerization of the tandem GAF domains. The features of the PDE5 regulatory domain revealed here provide an initial structural basis for future investigations of the regulatory mechanism of PDE5 and the design of GAF-specific regulators of PDE5 function.     

The GAF domain of the cGMP-binding, cGMP-specific phosphodiesterase (PDE5) is a sensor and a sink for cGMP

We describe here a novel sensor for cGMP based on the GAF domain of the cGMP-binding, cGMP-specific phosphodiesterase 5 (PDE5) using bioluminescence resonance energy transfer (BRET). The wild type GAFa domain, capable of binding cGMP with high affinity, and a mutant (GAFa F163A) unable to bind cGMP were cloned as fusions between GFP and Rluc for BRET (2) assays. BRET (2) ratios of the wild type GAFa fusion protein, but not GAFa F163A, increased in the presence of cGMP but not cAMP. Higher basal BRET (2) ratios were observed in cells expressing the wild type GAFa domain than in cells expressing GAFa F163A. This was correlated with elevated basal intracellular levels of cGMP, indicating that the GAF domain could act as a sink for cGMP. The tandem GAF domains in full length PDE5 could also sequester cGMP when the catalytic activity of PDE5 was inhibited. Therefore, these results describe a cGMP sensor utilizing BRET (2) technology and experimentally demonstrate the reservoir of cGMP that can be present in cells that express cGMP-binding GAF domain-containing proteins. PDE5 is the target for the anti-impotence drug sildenafil citrate; therefore, this GAF-BRET (2) sensor could be used for the identification of novel compounds that inhibit cGMP binding to the GAF domain, thereby regulating PDE5 catalytic activity.     

Binding of cGMP to GAF domains in amphibian rod photoreceptor cGMP phosphodiesterase (PDE). Identification of GAF domains in PDE alphabeta subunits and distinct domains in the PDE gamma subunit involved in stimulation of cGMP binding to GAF domains

Retinal cGMP phosphodiesterase (PDE6) is a key enzyme in vertebrate phototransduction. Rod PDE contains two homologous catalytic subunits (Palphabeta) and two identical regulatory subunits (Pgamma). Biochemical studies have shown that amphibian Palphabeta has high affinity, cGMP-specific, non-catalytic binding sites and that Pgamma stimulates cGMP binding to these sites. Here we show by molecular cloning that each catalytic subunit in amphibian PDE, as in its mammalian counterpart, contains two homologous tandem GAF domains in its N-terminal region. In Pgamma-depleted membrane-bound PDE (20-40% Pgamma still present), a single type of cGMP-binding site with a relatively low affinity (K(d) approximately 100 nm) was observed, and addition of Pgamma increased both the affinity for cGMP and the level of cGMP binding. We also show that mutations of amino acid residues in four different sites in Pgamma reduced its ability to stimulate cGMP binding. Among these, the site involved in Pgamma phosphorylation by Cdk5 (positions 20-23) had the largest effect on cGMP binding. However, except for the C terminus, these sites were not involved in Pgamma inhibition of the cGMP hydrolytic activity of Palphabeta. In addition, the Pgamma concentration required for 50% stimulation of cGMP binding was much greater than that required for 50% inhibition of cGMP hydrolysis. These results suggest that the Palphabeta heterodimer contains two spatially and functionally distinct types of Pgamma-binding sites: one for inhibition of cGMP hydrolytic activity and the second for activation of cGMP binding to GAF domains. We propose a model for the Palphabeta-Pgamma interaction in which Pgamma, by binding to one of the two sites in Palphabeta, may preferentially act either as an inhibitor of catalytic activity or as an activator of cGMP binding to GAF domains in frog PDE.     

GAF domains: two-billion-year-old molecular switches that bind cyclic nucleotides

GAF domains represent one of the largest families of small-molecule binding units present in nature. The first mammalian GAF domains discovered were the cGMP-binding regulatory domains of several cyclic nucleotide phosphodiesterases (PDEs). The crystal structure of the PDE2A GAF domains has provided our first look at the architecture of the binding site for the second messenger cGMP. The topology of this site differs greatly from all other previously determined cyclic nucleotide binding sites. In PDE2A, cGMP binds to a well-defined pocket in one of the two GAF domains that is analogous to the ligand-binding pocket of the distantly related PAS domains of photoactive yellow protein and FixL. The consensus cGMP-binding motif suggests strongly that only certain GAF domains will bind cGMP. Although the detailed mechanism for how cGMP binding to the GAF domain regulates catalysis remains to be determined, recent data from a GAF domain-containing cAMP-stimulated adenylyl cyclase from Anabaena suggest a mechanism conserved across two billion years of evolution. Because of their unique ligand-binding topologies, the GAF domains of PDEs are likely to offer good new targets for rational drug design.     

Identification and characterization of two unusual cGMP-stimulated phoshodiesterases in dictyostelium

Recently, we recognized two genes, gbpA and gbpB, encoding putative cGMP-binding proteins with a Zn(2+)-hydrolase domain and two cyclic nucleotide binding domains. The Zn(2+)-hydrolase domains belong to the superfamily of beta-lactamases, also harboring a small family of class II phosphodiesterases from bacteria and lower eukaryotes. Gene inactivation and overexpression studies demonstrate that gbpA encodes the cGMP-stimulated cGMP-phosphodiesterase that was characterized biochemically previously and was shown to be involved in chemotaxis. cAMP neither activates nor is a substrate of GbpA. The gbpB gene is expressed mainly in the multicellular stage and seems to encode a dual specificity phosphodiesterase with preference for cAMP. The enzyme hydrolyses cAMP approximately 9-fold faster than cGMP and is activated by cAMP and cGMP with a K(A) value of approximately 0.7 and 2.3 microM, respectively. Cells with a deletion of the gbpB gene have increased basal and receptor stimulated cAMP levels and are sporogeneous. We propose that GbpA and GbpB hydrolyze the substrate in the Zn(2+)-hydrolase domain, whereas the cyclic nucleotide binding domains mediate activation. The human cGMP-stimulated cAMP/cGMP phosphodiesterase has similar biochemical properties, but a completely different topology: hydrolysis takes place by a class I catalytic domain and GAF domains mediate cGMP activation.     

The catalytic and GAF domains of the rod cGMP phosphodiesterase (PDE6) heterodimer are regulated by distinct regions of its inhibitory gamma subunit

The central effector of visual transduction in retinal rod photoreceptors, cGMP phosphodiesterase (PDE6), is a catalytic heterodimer (alphabeta) to which low molecular weight inhibitory gamma subunits bind to form the nonactivated PDE holoenzyme (alphabetagamma(2)). Although it is known that gamma binds tightly to alphabeta, the binding affinity for each gamma subunit to alphabeta, the domains on gamma that interact with alphabeta, and the allosteric interactions between gamma and the regulatory and catalytic regions on alphabeta are not well understood. We show here that the gamma subunit binds to two distinct sites on the catalytic alphabeta dimer (K(D)(1) < 1 pm, K(D)(2) = 3 pm) when the regulatory GAF domains of bovine rod PDE6 are occupied by cGMP. Binding heterogeneity of gamma to alphabeta is absent when cAMP occupies the noncatalytic sites. Two major domains on gamma can interact independently with alphabeta with the N-terminal half of gamma binding with 50-fold greater affinity than its C-terminal, inhibitory region. The N-terminal half of gamma is responsible for the positive cooperativity between gamma and cGMP binding sites on alphabeta but has no effect on catalytic activity. Using synthetic peptides, we identified regions of the amino acid sequence of gamma that bind to alphabeta, restore high affinity cGMP binding to low affinity noncatalytic sites, and retard cGMP exchange with both noncatalytic sites. Subunit heterogeneity, multiple sites of gamma interaction with alphabeta, and positive cooperativity of gamma with the GAF domains are all likely to contribute to precisely controlling the activation and inactivation kinetics of PDE6 during visual transduction in rod photoreceptors.     

Structural and functional features in human PDE5A1 regulatory domain that provide for allosteric cGMP binding, dimerization, and regulation

The cGMP-binding cGMP-specific phosphodiesterase (PDE5) contains a catalytic domain that hydrolyzes cGMP and a regulatory (R) domain that contains two GAFs (a and b; GAF is derived from the proteins mammalian cGMP-binding PDEs, Anabaena adenylyl cyclases, and Escherichia coli (FhlA)). The R domain binds cGMP allosterically, provides for dimerization, and is phosphorylated at a site regulated by allosteric cGMP binding. Quaternary structures and cGMP-binding properties of 10 human PDE5A1 constructs containing one or both GAFs were characterized. Results reveal that: 1) high affinity homo-dimerization occurs between GAF a modules (K(D) < 30 nM) and between GAF b modules (K(D) = 1-20 pM), and the sequence between the GAFs (Thr322-Asp403) contributes to dimer stability; 2) 176 amino acids (Val156-Gln331) in GAF a are adequate for cGMP binding; 3) GAF a has higher affinity for cGMP (K(D) < 40 nM) than does the isolated R domain (K(D) = 110 nM) or holoenzyme (K(D) = 200 nM), suggesting that the sequence containing GAF b and its flanking amino acids autoinhibits GAF a cGMP-binding affinity in intact R domain; 4) a mutant (Met1-Glu321) containing only GAF a has high affinity, biphasic cGMP-binding kinetics consistent with structural heterogeneity of GAF a, suggesting that the presence of GAF b is not required for biphasic cGMP-dissociation kinetics observed in holoenzyme or isolated R domain; 5) significant cGMP binding by GAF b was not detected; and 6) the sequence containing GAF b and its flanking amino acids is critical for cGMP stimulation of Ser102 phosphorylation by cyclic nucleotide-dependent protein kinases. Results yield new insights into PDE5 functions, further define boundaries that provide for allosteric cGMP binding, and identify regions that contribute to dimerization.     

Allosteric Regulation of Rod Photoreceptor Phosphodiesterase 6 (PDE6) Elucidated by Chemical Cross-Linking and Quantitative Mass Spectrometry

Photoreceptor phosphodiesterase (PDE6) is the central effector enzyme in the visual excitation pathway in rod and cone photoreceptors. Its tight regulation is essential for the speed, sensitivity, recovery, and adaptation of visual signaling. The rod PDE6 holoenzyme (Pαβγ₂) is composed of a catalytic heterodimer (Pαβ) that binds two inhibitory γ subunits. Each of the two catalytic subunits (Pα and Pβ) contains a catalytic domain responsible for cGMP hydrolysis and two tandem GAF domains, one of which binds cGMP noncatalytically. Unlike related GAF-containing PDEs where cGMP binding allosterically activates catalysis, the physiological significance of cGMP binding to the GAF domains of PDE6 is unknown. To elucidate the structural determinants of PDE6 allosteric regulators, we biochemically characterized PDE6 complexes in various allosteric states (Pαβ, Pαβ–cGMP, Pαβγ₂, and Pαβγ₂–cGMP) with a quantitative cross-linking/mass spectrometry approach. We employed a normalization strategy to dissect the cross-linking reactivity of individual residues in order to assess the spatial cross-linking propensity of detected pairs. In addition to identifying cross-linked pairs that undergo conformational changes upon ligand binding, we observed an asymmetric binding of the inhibitory γ-subunit and the noncatalytic cGMP to the GAFa domains of rod PDE6, as well as a stable open conformation of Pαβ catalytic dimer in different allosteric states. These results advance our understanding of the exquisite regulatory control of the lifetime of rod PDE6 activation/deactivation during visual signaling, as well as providing a structural basis for interpreting how mutations in rod PDE6 subunits can lead to retinal diseases.