Genetic analysis of chloroplast biogenesis in higher plants

The biogenesis of chloroplasts is genetically complex, involving hundreds of genes distributed between the nucleus and organelle. In higher plants, developmental parameters confer an added layer of complexity upon the genetic control of chloroplast biogenesis: the properties of plastids differ dramatically between different cell types. While the biochemistry and structure of different plastid types have been described in detail, factors that determine the timing and localization of chloroplast development and that mediate chloroplast assembly have remained elusive. To identify nuclear genes that play novel roles in chloroplast biogenesis, we are exploiting nuclear mutations that block the accumulation of subsets of chloroplast proteins. Detailed study of the mutant phenotypes provides clues concerning the primary defect in each mutant. Mutants with defects in chloroplast translation and mRNA metabolism have been identified. Other mutants defective in the accumulation of multiple thylakoid complexes show no apparent defect in the synthesis of the missing proteins. These may identify factors involved in the integration of proteins into the thylakoid membrane and their assembly into functional complexes.     

Identification of chloroplast signal recognition particle RNA genes

The signal recognition particle (SRP) is a ribonucleoprotein complex responsible for targeting proteins to the ER membrane in eukaryotes, the plasma membrane in bacteria and the thylakoid membrane in chloroplasts. In higher plants two different SRP-dependent mechanisms have been identified: one post-translational for proteins imported to the chloroplast and one co-translational for proteins encoded by the plastid genome. The post-translational chloroplast SRP (cpSRP) consists of the protein subunits cpSRP54 and cpSRP43. An RNA component has not been identified and does not seem to be required for the post-translational cpSRP. The co-translational mechanism is known to involve cpSRP54, but an RNA component has not yet been identified. Several chloroplast genomes have been sequenced recently, making a phylogenetically broad computational search for cpSRP RNA possible. We have analysed chloroplast genomes from 27 organisms. In higher plant chloroplasts, no SRP RNA genes were identified. However, eight plastids from red algae and Chlorophyta were found to contain an SRP RNA gene. These results suggest that SRP RNA forms a complex in these plastids with cpSRP54, reminiscent of the eubacterial SRP.     

Y3IP1, a Nucleus-Encoded Thylakoid Protein, Cooperates with the Plastid-Encoded Ycf3 Protein in Photosystem I Assembly of Tobacco and Arabidopsis

The intricate assembly of photosystem I (PSI), a large multiprotein complex in the thylakoid membrane, depends on auxiliary protein factors. One of the essential assembly factors for PSI is encoded by ycf3 (hypothetical chloroplast reading frame number 3) in the chloroplast genome of algae and higher plants. To identify novel factors involved in PSI assembly, we constructed an epitope-tagged version of ycf3 from tobacco (Nicotiana tabacum) and introduced it into the tobacco chloroplast genome by genetic transformation. Immunoaffinity purification of Ycf3 complexes from the transplastomic plants identified a novel nucleus-encoded thylakoid protein, Y3IP1 (for Ycf3-interacting protein 1), that specifically interacts with the Ycf3 protein. Subsequent reverse genetics analysis of Y3IP1 function in tobacco and Arabidopsis thaliana revealed that knockdown of Y3IP1 leads to a specific deficiency in PSI but does not result in loss of Ycf3. Our data indicate that Y3IP1 represents a novel factor for PSI biogenesis that cooperates with the plastid genome-encoded Ycf3 in the assembly of stable PSI units in the thylakoid membrane.     

Events surrounding the early development of Euglena chloroplasts. 15. Origin of plastid thylakoid polypeptides in wild-type and mutant cells

Techniques are described for the isolation of plastid thylakoid membranes from light-grown and dark-grown cells of Euglena gracilis var. bacillaris, and from mutants affecting plastid development. These membranes, which have minimal contamination with other cell fractions, are localized in sucrose gradients by using the thylakoid membrane sulfolipid as a specific marker. The plastid thylakoid membrane polypeptides isolated from these membranes were separated on SDS polyacrylamide gels and yielded patterns containing 30–40 polypeptides. Light-grown strain Z gave patterns identical with bacillaris. Since the plastid thylakoid polypeptide patterns obtained from dark-grown wild-type cells and from a bleached mutant W₃BUL in which plastid DNA is undetectable are identical, it appears that the proplastid thylakoid polypeptides of wild-type cannot be coded in plastid DNA and are probably coded in nuclear DNA. The plastid thylakoid polypeptide patterns obtained from various dark-grown mutants are identical to those obtained from dark-grown wild-type cells. Light-grown mutants, making large but abnormal chloroplasts, show a correlation between the amount of chlorophyll formed and the amount of a plastid thylakoid polypeptide thought to be associated with one of the pigment-protein light-harvesting complexes. Treatment with SAN 9789 (4-chloro-5-(methyl-amino)-2-(α,α,α,-trifluoro-m-tolyl)-3-(2H(pyridazinone) known to block carotenoid synthesis at the level of phytoene, causes a progressive loss of all plastid thylakoid polypeptides during growth in darkness and results in the establishment of a new, lower steady-state level of sulfolipid. At least ten of the plastid thylakoid polypeptides become labeled when isolated chloroplasts are supplied with radioactive amino acids; of these six are undectable in W₃BUL and are, therefore, candidates for coding by plastid DNA.     

The discovery of plastid-to-nucleus retrograde signaling—a personal perspective

DNA and machinery for gene expression have been discovered in chloroplasts during the 1960s. It was soon evident that the chloroplast genome is relatively small, that most genes for chloroplast-localized proteins reside in the nucleus and that chloroplast membranes, ribosomes, and protein complexes are composed of proteins encoded in both the chloroplast and the nuclear genome. This situation has made the existence of mechanisms highly probable that coordinate the gene expression in plastids and nucleus. In the 1970s, the first evidence for plastid signals controlling nuclear gene expression was provided by studies on plastid ribosome deficient mutants with reduced amounts and/or activities of nuclear-encoded chloroplast proteins including the small subunit of Rubisco, ferredoxin NADP+ reductase, and enzymes of the Calvin cycle. This review describes first models of plastid-to-nucleus signaling and their discovery. Today, many plastid signals are known. They do not only balance gene expression in chloroplasts and nucleus during developmental processes but are also generated in response to environmental changes sensed by the organelles.     

Role of galactolipid biosynthesis in coordinated development of photosynthetic complexes and thylakoid membranes during chloroplast biogenesis in Arabidopsis

The galactolipids monogalactosyldiacylglycerol (MGDG) and digalactosyldiacylglycerol (DGDG) are the predominant lipids in thylakoid membranes and indispensable for photosynthesis. Among the three isoforms that catalyze MGDG synthesis in Arabidopsis thaliana, MGD1 is responsible for most galactolipid synthesis in chloroplasts, whereas MGD2 and MGD3 are required for DGDG accumulation during phosphate (Pi) starvation. A null mutant of Arabidopsis MGD1 (mgd1‐2), which lacks both galactolipids and shows a severe defect in chloroplast biogenesis under nutrient‐sufficient conditions, accumulated large amounts of DGDG, with a strong induction of MGD2/3 expression, during Pi starvation. In plastids of Pi‐starved mgd1‐2 leaves, biogenesis of thylakoid‐like internal membranes, occasionally associated with invagination of the inner envelope, was observed, together with chlorophyll accumulation. Moreover, the mutant accumulated photosynthetic membrane proteins upon Pi starvation, indicating a compensation for MGD1 deficiency by Pi stress‐induced galactolipid biosynthesis. However, photosynthetic activity in the mutant was still abolished, and light‐harvesting/photosystem core complexes were improperly formed, suggesting a requirement for MGDG for proper assembly of these complexes. During Pi starvation, distribution of plastid nucleoids changed concomitantly with internal membrane biogenesis in the mgd1‐2 mutant. Moreover, the reduced expression of nuclear‐ and plastid‐encoded photosynthetic genes observed in the mgd1‐2 mutant under Pi‐sufficient conditions was restored after Pi starvation. In contrast, Pi starvation had no such positive effects in mutants lacking chlorophyll biosynthesis. These observations demonstrate that galactolipid biosynthesis and subsequent membrane biogenesis inside the plastid strongly influence nucleoid distribution and the expression of both plastid‐ and nuclear‐encoded photosynthetic genes, independently of photosynthesis.     

The Arabidopsis chloroplast ribosomal protein L21 is encoded by a nuclear gene of mitochondrial origin.

Many chloroplast genes of cyanobacterial origin have been transferred to the nucleus during evolution and their products are re-addressed to chloroplasts. The RPL21 gene encoding the plastid r-protein L21 has been lost in higher plant chloroplast genomes after the divergence from bryophytes. Based on phylogenetic analysis and intron conservation, we now provide evidence that in Arabidopsis a nuclear RPL21c gene of mitochondrial origin has replaced the chloroplast gene. The control of expression of this gene has been adapted to the needs of chloroplast development by the acquisition of plastid-specific regulatory promoter cis-elements.     

Differential Synthesis of Photosystem Cores and Light-Harvesting Antenna during Proplastid to Chloroplast Development in Spirodela oligorrhiza

Proplastids and etioplasts are common starting points for monitoring chloroplast development in higher plants. Although proplastids are the primary precursor of chloroplasts, most proplastid to chloroplast systems are cumbersome to study temporally. Conversely, the etioplast to chloroplast transition is initiated by light and is readily examined as a function of time. Etioplasts, however, are found mostly in plants germinated in the dark and are not an obligatory step in chloroplast development. We have chosen to study chloroplast ontogeny in Spirodela oligorrhiza (Kurtz) Hegelm (a C₃-monocot) because of its unique ability to grow indefinitely in the dark. Ultrastructural, physiological, and molecular evidence is presented in support of a temporal, light-triggered proplastid to chloroplast transition in Spirodela. The dark-grown plants are devoid of chlorophyll, and upon illumination synchronously green over a 3- to 5-day period. Synthesis of chloroplast proteins involved in photosynthesis is coincident with thylakoid assembly, chlorophyll accumulation, and appearance of CO₂ fixation activity. Interestingly, the developmental sequence in Spirodela was slow enough to reveal that biosynthesis of the D1 photosystem II reaction center protein precedes biosynthesis of the major light-harvesting antenna proteins. This, coupled with the high chlorophyll a/b ratio observed early in development, indicated that reaction center assembly occurred prior to accumulation of the light-harvesting complexes. Thus, with Spirodela one can study proplastid to chloroplast conversions temporally in higher plants and follow the process on a time scale that enables a detailed dissection of plastid maturation processes.     

Too rigid to fold: Carotenoid-dependent decrease in thylakoid fluidity hampers the formation of chloroplast grana

In chloroplasts of land plants, the thylakoid network is organized into appressed regions called grana stacks and loosely arranged parallel stroma thylakoids. Many factors determining such intricate structural arrangements have been identified so far, including various thylakoid-embedded proteins, and polar lipids that build the thylakoid matrix. Although carotenoids are important components of proteins and the lipid phase of chloroplast membranes, their role in determining the thylakoid network structure remains elusive. We studied 2D and 3D thylakoid network organization in carotenoid-deficient mutants (ccr1-1, lut5-1, szl1-1, and szl1-1npq1-2) of Arabidopsis (Arabidopsis thaliana) to reveal the structural role of carotenoids in the formation and dynamics of the internal chloroplast membrane system. The most significant structural aberrations took place in chloroplasts of the szl1-1 and szl1-1npq1-2 plants. Increased lutein/carotene ratio in these mutants impaired the formation of grana, resulting in a significant decrease in the number of thylakoids used to build a particular stack. Further, combined biochemical and biophysical analyses revealed that hampered grana folding was related to decreased thylakoid membrane fluidity and significant changes in the amount, organization, and phosphorylation status of photosystem (PS) II (PSII) supercomplexes in the szl1-1 and szl1-1npq1-2 plants. Such changes resulted from a synergistic effect of lutein overaccumulation in the lipid matrix and a decreased level of carotenes bound with PS core complexes. Moreover, more rigid membrane in the lutein overaccumulating plants led to binding of Rubisco to the thylakoid surface, additionally providing steric hindrance for the dynamic changes in the level of membrane folding.

Increases in lutein/carotenoid ratios lead to decreased thylakoid fluidity and hamper grana folding due to carotenoid-dependent changes in both photosynthetic complexes and lipid matrix organization.     

Some unusual features of the ultrastructure of the chloroplasts of the green algal orderCaulerpales and their development

Summary The ultrastructure of developing and mature chloroplasts of members of the green algal orderCaulerpales is described. The mature chloroplasts develop from small starch containing plastids. These small starch containing plastids may also develop into the large amyloplasts characteristic of this order. The thylakoid organizing body (TOB), a system of concentric lamellae found at one end of the plastid, appears to be involved in initial thylakoid membrane synthesis. During early plastid development the first formed thylakoids, the plastid DNA and lipid are closely associated with this body. Many developing plastids also have a number of microfilaments near the chloroplast envelope. These microfilaments extend from the TOB towards the opposite end of the plastid.The size and structure of the mature caulerpalean chloroplast varies greatly between species, as does the size and structure of the TOB. The simplest type of TOB occurs inAvrainvillea erecta and the most complex inCaulerpa cactoides. The membranes of the TOB are connected by crossbridges and they are also connected with the inner chloroplast envelope membrane. The structure of the TOB, its relation to the chloroplast envelope, its association with the thylakoids and its possible functions are described.     

Mechanisms of protein import into thylakoids of chloroplasts

The thylakoid membrane of chloroplasts contains the major photosynthetic complexes, which consist of several either nuclear or chloroplast encoded subunits. The biogenesis of these thylakoid membrane complexes requires coordinated transport and subsequent assembly of the subunits into functional complexes. Nuclear-encoded thylakoid proteins are first imported into the chloroplast and then directed to the thylakoid using different sorting mechanisms. The cpSec pathway and the cpTat pathway are mainly involved in the transport of lumenal proteins, whereas the spontaneous pathway and the cpSRP pathway are used for the insertion of integral membrane proteins into the thylakoid membrane. While cpSec-, cpTat- and cpSRP-mediated targeting can be classified as 'assisted' mechanisms involving numerous components, 'unassisted' spontaneous insertion does not require additional targeting factors. However, even the assisted pathways differ fundamentally with respect to stromal targeting factors, the composition of the translocase and energy requirements.