DNA replication initiation as a key element in thymineless death

Thymine deprivation results in the loss of viability in cells from bacteria to eukaryotes. Numerous studies have identified a variety of molecular processes and cellular responses associated with thymineless death (TLD). It has been observed that TLD occurs in actively growing cells, and DNA damage and DNA recombination structures have been associated with cells undergoing TLD. We measured the loss of viability in thymine-starved cells differing in the number of overlapping replication cycles (n), and we found that the magnitude of TLD correlates with the number of replication forks. By using pulsed field gel electrophoresis (PFGE), we determined the proportion of linear DNA (DSBs) and the amount of DNA remaining in the well after treatment with XbaI (nmDNA) under thymine starvation in the absence or presence of both rifampicin (suppressing TLD) and hydroxyurea (maintaining TLD). Our results indicate that DSBs and nmDNA are induced by thymine starvation, but they do not correlate with the lethality observed in the presence of the drugs. We asked whether TLD was related to chromosomal DNA initiation. DNA labeling experiments and flow cytometric analyses showed that new initiation events were induced under thymine starvation. These new DNA replication initiation events were inhibited in the presence of rifampicin but not in the presence of hydroxyurea, indicating that TLD correlates with the induction of new initiation events in Escherichia coli. In support of this finding, cells carrying a deletion of the datA site, in which DNA initiation is allowed in the presence of rifampicin, underwent TLD in the presence of rifampicin. We propose that thymineless-induced DNA initiation generates a fraction of DNA damage and/or nmDNA at origins that is critical for TLD. Our model provides new elements to be considered when testing mammalian chemotherapies that are based on the inhibition of thymidylate synthetase.     

Sources of thymidine and analogs fueling futile damage-repair cycles and ss-gap accumulation during thymine starvation in Escherichia coli

Thymine deprivation in thyA mutant E. coli causes thymineless death (TLD) and is the mode of action of popular antibacterial and anticancer drugs, yet the mechanisms of TLD are still unclear. TLD comprises three defined phases: resistance, rapid exponential death (RED) and survival, with the nature of the resistance phase and of the transition to the RED phase holding key to TLD pathology. We propose that a limited source of endogenous thymine maintains replication forks through the resistance phase. When this source ends, forks undergo futile break-repair cycle during the RED phase, eventually rendering the chromosome non-functional. Two obvious sources of the endogenous thymine are degradation of broken chromosomal DNA and recruitment of thymine from stable RNA. However, mutants that cannot degrade broken chromosomal DNA or lack ribo-thymine, instead of shortening the resistance phase, deepen the RED phase, meaning that only a small fraction of T-starved cells tap into these sources. Interestingly, the substantial chromosomal DNA accumulation during the resistance phase is negated during the RED phase, suggesting futile cycle of incorporation and excision of wrong nucleotides. We tested incorporation of dU or rU, finding some evidence for both, but DNA-dU incorporation accelerates TLD only when intracellular [dUTP] is increased by the dut mutation. In the dut ung mutant, with increased DNA-dU incorporation and no DNA-dU excision, replication is in fact rescued even without dT, but TLD still occurs, suggesting different mechanisms. Finally, we found that continuous DNA synthesis during thymine starvation makes chromosomal DNA increasingly single-stranded, and even the dut ung defect does not completely block this ss-gap accumulation. We propose that instability of single-strand gaps underlies the pathology of thymine starvation.     

Beyond DnaA: The Role of DNA Topology and DNA Methylation in Bacterial Replication Initiation

The replication of chromosomal DNA is a fundamental event in the life cycle of every cell. The first step of replication, initiation, is controlled by multiple factors to ensure only one round of replication per cell cycle. The process of initiation has been described most thoroughly for bacteria, especially Escherichia coli, and involves many regulatory proteins that vary considerably between different species. These proteins control the activity of the two key players of initiation in bacteria: the initiator protein DnaA and the origin of chromosome replication (oriC). Factors involved in the control of the availability, activity, or oligomerization of DnaA during initiation are generally regarded as the most important and thus have been thoroughly characterized. Other aspects of the initiation process, such as origin accessibility and susceptibility to unwinding, have been less explored. However, recent findings indicate that these factors have a significant role. This review focuses on DNA topology, conformation, and methylation as important factors that regulate the initiation process in bacteria. We present a comprehensive summary of the factors involved in the modulation of DNA topology, both locally at oriC and more globally at the level of the entire chromosome. We show clearly that the conformation of oriC dynamically changes, and control of this conformation constitutes another, important factor in the regulation of bacterial replication initiation. Furthermore, the process of initiation appears to be associated with the dynamics of the entire chromosome and this association is an important but largely unexplored phenomenon.     

Evidence for a chromosome origin unwinding system broadly conserved in bacteria

Genome replication is a fundamental requirement for the proliferation of all cells. Throughout the domains of life, conserved DNA replication initiation proteins assemble at specific chromosomal loci termed replication origins and direct loading of replicative helicases (1). Despite decades of study on bacterial replication, the diversity of bacterial chromosome origin architecture has confounded the search for molecular mechanisms directing the initiation process. Recently a basal system for opening a bacterial chromosome origin (oriC) was proposed (2). In the model organism Bacillus subtilis, a pair of double-stranded DNA (dsDNA) binding sites (DnaA‐boxes) guide the replication initiator DnaA onto adjacent single-stranded DNA (ssDNA) binding motifs (DnaA‐trios) where the protein assembles into an oligomer that stretches DNA to promote origin unwinding. We report here that these core elements are predicted to be present in the majority of bacterial chromosome origins. Moreover, we find that the principle activities of the origin unwinding system are conserved in vitro and in vivo. The results suggest that this basal mechanism for oriC unwinding is broadly functionally conserved and therefore may represent an ancestral system to open bacterial chromosome origins.     

Replication initiated at the origin (oriC) of the E. coli chromosome reconstituted with purified enzymes

A crude soluble enzyme system capable of authentic replication of a variety of oriC plasmids has been replaced by purified proteins constituting three functional classes: initiation proteins (RNA polymerase, dnaA protein, gyrase) that recognize the oriC sequence and presumably prime the leading strand of the replication fork; replication proteins (DNA polymerase III holoenzyme, single-strand binding protein, primosomal proteins) that sustain progress of the replication fork; and specificity proteins (topoisomerase I, RNAase H₁ protein HU) that suppress initiation of replication at sequences other than oriC, coated with dnaA protein. Protein HU and unidentified factors in crude enzyme fractions stimulate replication at one or more stages. Replication has been separated temporally and physically into successive stages of RNA synthesis and DNA synthesis.     

Overproduction of DnaA protein stimulates initiation of chromosome and minichromosome replication in Escherichia coli

Summary Increased synthesis of DnaA protein, obtained with plasmids carrying the dnaA gene controlled by the heat inducible pL promoter, stimulated initiation of replication from oriC about threefold. The overinitiation was determined both as an increase in copy number of a minichromosome and as an increase in chromosomal gene dosage of oriC proximal DNA. The additional replication forks which were initiated on the chromosome did not lead to an overall increase in DNA content. DNA/DNA hybridization showed an amplification encompassing less than a few hundred kilobases on each side of oriC. Kinetic studies showed that the overinitiation occurred very rapidly after the induction, and that the initiation frequency then decreased to a near normal frequency per oriC. The results indicate that the DnaA protein is one important factor in regulation of initiation of DNA replication from oriC.     

Initiation of DNA replication in Bacillus subtilis. V. Role of DNA gyrase and superhelical structure in initiation

Summary When spores of a thymine-requiring mutant of Bacillus subtilis were germinated in a medium lacking thymine, an initiation potential (an ability to initiate and complete one round of replication in the presence of thymine and in the absence of protein and RNA synthesis) was formed for both chromosomal and plasmid replication. The effect of two inhibitors of DNA gyrase, novobiocin (Nov) and nalidixic acid (Nal), on the initiation potential formed during germination for chromosomal and plasmid replication was examined.Nov and Nal inhibited formation of the initiation potential completely if the drug was added at the onset of germination. In contrast, initiation of chromosomal and plasmid replication occurred in the presence of DNA gyrase inhibitors when the drug was added after the initiation potential had been fully formed. However, chromosomal replication initiated in the presence of the inhibitors ceased after a fragment of approximately 15 MD (15×10⁶ daltons) had been replicated, and plasmid replication was limited to one round of replication in approximately half of the plasmid molecules present in the spores.Furthermore the initiation potential for both chromosomal and plasmid replication though established was destroyed gradually but steadily by prolonged incubation with Nov in the absence of thymine. In addition, relaxation of the superhelical structure of plasmid DNA during incubation with Nov was observed in vivo. This relaxation was blocked by ethidium bromide, which dissociated the S-complex. On the other hand, incubation with Nal did not reduce the initiation potential nor did it change the superhelicity of the plasmid DNA in vivo. This is consistent with the known effect of gyrase inhibitors on the enzymatic activity of DNA gyrase.These results clearly demonstrate that both the action of DNA gyrase and the superhelical structure of the DNA are essential for the initiation of chromosomal and plasmid replication. The specific chromosome organization essential for initiation and elongation and the role of DNA gyrase are discussed.IV of this series is Yoshikawa et al. 1980     

Mechanisms of primer RNA synthesis and D-loop/R-loop-dependent DNA replication in Escherichia coli

In DNA replication, DNA chains are generally initiated from small pieces of ribonucleotides attached to DNA templates. These ‘primers’ are synthesized by various enzymatic mechanisms in Escherichia coli. Studies on primer RNA synthesis on single-stranded DNA templates containing specific ‘priming signals’ revealed the presence of two distinct modes, ie immobile and mobile priming. The former includes primer RNA synthesis by primase encoded by dnaG and by RNA polymerase containing a σ⁷⁰ subunit. Priming is initiated at a specific site in immobile priming. Novel immobile priming signals were identified from various plasmid replicaons, some of which function in initiation of the leading strand synthesis. The latter, on the other hand, involves a protein complex, primosome, which contains DnaB, the replicative helicase for E coli chromosomal replication. Utilizing the energy fueled by ATP hydrolysis of DnaB protein, primosomes are able to translocate on a template DNA and primase synthesizes primer RNAs at multiple sites. Two distinct primosomes. DnaA-dependent primosome supports normal chromosomal identified, which are differentially utilized for E coli chromosomal replication. Whereas DnaA-dependent primosome supports normal chromosomal replication from oriC, the PriA-dependent primosome functions in oriC-independent chromosomal replication observed in DNA-damaged cells or cells lacking RNaseH activity. In oriC-independent replication, PriA protein may recognize the D- or R-loop structure, respectively, to initiate assembly of a primosome which mediates primer RNA synthesis and replication fork progression.     

Prokaryotic ParA-ParB-parS system links bacterial chromosome segregation with the cell cycle

While the essential role of episomal par loci in plasmid DNA partitioning has long been appreciated, the function of chromosomally encoded par loci is less clear. The chromosomal parA-parB genes are conserved throughout the bacterial kingdom and encode proteins homologous to those of the plasmidic Type I active partitioning systems. The third conserved element, the centromere-like sequence called parS, occurs in several copies in the chromosome. Recent studies show that the ParA-ParB-parS system is a key player of a mitosis-like process ensuring proper intracellular localization of certain chromosomal regions such as oriC domain and their active and directed segregation. Moreover, the chromosomal par systems link chromosome segregation with initiation of DNA replication and the cell cycle.     

Assembly of Helicobacter pylori Initiation Complex Is Determined by Sequence-Specific and Topology-Sensitive DnaA–oriC Interactions

In bacteria, chromosome replication is initiated by binding of the DnaA initiator protein to DnaA boxes located in the origin of chromosomal replication (oriC). This leads to DNA helix opening within the DNA-unwinding element. Helicobacter pylori oriC, the first bipartite origin identified in Gram-negative bacteria, contains two subregions, oriC1 and oriC2, flanking the dnaA gene. The DNA-unwinding element region is localized in the oriC2 subregion downstream of dnaA. Surprisingly, oriC2–DnaA interactions were shown to depend on DNA topology, which is unusual in bacteria but is similar to initiator–origin interactions observed in higher organisms. In this work, we identified three DnaA boxes in the oriC2 subregion, two of which were bound only as supercoiled DNA. We found that all three DnaA boxes play important roles in orisome assembly and subsequent DNA unwinding, but different functions can be assigned to individual boxes. This suggests that the H. pylori oriC may be functionally divided, similar to what was described recently for Escherichia coli oriC. On the basis of these results, we propose a model of initiation complex formation in H. pylori.     

Initiation of chromosome replication in Escherichia coli. I. Requirements for RNA and protein synthesis at different growth rates

The effects of inhibition of protein and RNA synthesis on initiation of chromosome replication in Escherichia coli$\text{B}\text{r}$ were determined by measuring rates of DNA synthesis during the division cycle before and after addition of chloramphenicol and rifampicin. The ability of cells to initiate a round of replication depended upon the pattern of chromosome replication during the division cycle. Initiation in the presence of chloramphenicol (200 μ/ml) and rifampicin (100 gmg/ml) was observed only in slowly growing cells which normally initiated a new round between the end of the previous round and the subsequent division (i.e. in the D period of the division cycle). The cells that initiated were in the D period at the time of addition of the drugs. Rapidly growing cells which normally initiated before the D period and slowly growing cells which normally initiated after the D period did not initiate in the presence of the drugs. The contrasting effects of the drugs in cells possessing different chromosome replication patterns, and the coupling between septum-crosswall formation (the D period) and initiation suggest that the timing of initiation of chromosome replication in E. coli is controlled by the cell envelope.     

DnaA structure, function, and dynamics in the initiation at the chromosomal origin

Escherichia coli DnaA is the initiator of chromosomal replication. Multiple ATP-DnaA molecules assemble at the oriC replication origin in a highly regulated manner, and the resultant initiation complexes promote local duplex unwinding within oriC, resulting in open complexes. DnaB helicase is loaded onto the unwound single-stranded region within oriC via interaction with the DnaA multimers. The tertiary structure of the functional domains of DnaA has been determined and several crucial residues in the initiation process, as well as their unique functions, have been identified. These include specific DNA binding, inter-DnaA interaction, specific and regulatory interactions with ATP and with the unwound single-stranded oriC DNA, and functional interaction with DnaB helicase. An overall structure of the initiation complex is also proposed. These are important for deepening our understanding of the molecular mechanisms that underlie DnaA assembly, oriC duplex unwinding, regulation of the initiation reaction, and DnaB helicase loading. In this review, we summarize recent progress on the molecular mechanisms of the functions of DnaA on oriC. In addition, some members of the AAA+ protein family related to the initiation of replication and its regulation (e.g., DnaA) are briefly discussed.     

Role of DNA replication and repair in thymineless death in Escherichia coli

Inhibition of DNA replication with hydroxyurea during thymine starvation of Escherichia coli shows that active DNA synthesis is not required for thymineless death (TLD). Hydroxyurea experiments and thymine starvation of lexA3 and uvrA DNA repair mutants rule out unbalanced growth, the SOS response, and nucleotide excision repair as explanations for TLD.     

DNA synthesis in Lactobacillus acidophilus in the absence of RNA and protein synthesis: a study with rifampicin

Summary Synthesis of DNA in Lactobacillus acidophilus R-26 was investigated in the presence of rifampicin which inhibits RNA and protein synthesis. Increments in DNA of between 140 and 200% were found under these conditions. Indirect evidence is presented that these large increments are not due to the presence of several replication points in the bacterial chromosome at the time of addition of the drug. Incubation with rifampicin was found to result in a progressive decrease in the capacity for DNA synthesis. This decrease was independent of the amount of DNA synthesized during incubation with rifampicin but was dependent on the time of incubation in the presence of the drug. It is proposed that inhibition of protein and RNA synthesis in L. acidophilus does not inhibit initiation of new cycles of chromosome replication but results in a progressive loss of the capacity to replicate DNA.     

Identification of short 'eukaryotic' Okazaki fragments synthesized from a prokaryotic replication origin

Although archaeal genomes encode proteins similar to eukaryotic replication factors, the hyperthermophilic archaeon Pyrococcus abyssi replicates its circular chromosome at a high rate from a single origin (oriC) as in Bacteria. In further elucidating the mechanism of archaeal DNA replication, we have studied the elongation step of DNA replication in vivo. We have detected, in two main archaeal phyla, short RNA-primed replication intermediates whose structure and length are very similar to those of eukaryotic Okazaki fragments. Mapping of replication initiation points further showed that discontinuous DNA replication in P. abyssi starts at a well-defined site within the oriC recently identified in this hyperthermophile. Short Okazaki fragments and a high replication speed imply a very efficient turnover of Okazaki fragments in Archaea. Archaea therefore have a unique replication system showing mechanistic similarities to both Bacteria and Eukarya.     

Helicobacter pylori oriC��the first bipartite origin of chromosome replication in Gram-negative bacteria

Binding of the DnaA protein to oriC leads to DNA melting within the DNA unwinding element (DUE) and initiates replication of the bacterial chromosome. Helicobacter pylori oriC was previously identified as a region localized upstream of dnaA and containing a cluster of DnaA boxes bound by DnaA protein with a high affinity. However, no unwinding within the oriC sequence has been detected. Comprehensive in silico analysis presented in this work allowed us to identify an additional region (oriC2), separated from the original one (oriC1) by the dnaA gene. DnaA specifically binds both regions, but DnaA-dependent DNA unwinding occurs only within oriC2. Surprisingly, oriC2 is bound exclusively as supercoiled DNA, which directly shows the importance of the DNA topology in DnaA-oriC interactions, similarly as previously presented only for initiator-origin interactions in Archaea and some Eukaryota. We conclude that H. pylori oriC exhibits bipartite structure, being the first such origin discovered in a Gram-negative bacterium. The H. pylori mode of initiator-oriC interactions, with the loop formation between the subcomplexes of the discontinuous origin, resembles those discovered in Bacillus subtilis chromosome and in many plasmids, which might suggest a similar way of controlling initiation of replication.     

Initiation of DNA replication in Escherichia coli

Summary When E. coli F⁺ cells carrying the dna-167 or dnaC2 mutation, which causes the temperature-sensitive initiation of DNA replication, are exposed to a non-permissive temperature to stop the replication of chromosome and F factor, and then transferred back to a permissive temperature with the addition of chloramphenicol, one round of the chromosomal replication occurs, but further replication is inhibited. Under these conditions, F DNA replicates coincidentally with the initiation of the chromosomal replication in both strains. When rifampicin is added to the cells upon lowering of the temperature, the chromosome can not replicate in the F⁺ dna-167 strain, but can do so in the F⁺ dnaC2 strain. F DNA can replicate in both of the mutant strains under these conditions.     

Random initiation of replication of plasmids P1 and F (oriS) when integrated into the Escherichia coli chromosome

We have constructed intP1 and intFs strains of Escherichia coli in which the basic replicons of either plasmid P1 or plasmid F (oriS) were integrated into an inactivated oriC, such that chromosome replication is controlled by the integrated plasmid replicon. In this study, we have further analysed these strains, and density-shift experiments revealed that chromosome replication occurred randomly during the cell cycle. Flow-cytometry analyses of exponentially growing populations supported this conclusion, and also showed that the DNA/mass ratio of the strains decreased with increasing growth rate. Flow cytometry of exponentially growing cultures treated with rifampicin demonstrated that initiation of replication was uncoordinated in cells containing multiple replication origins.