Distribution,occurrence and biotoxin composition of the main shellfish toxin producing microalgae within European waters: A comparison of methods of analysis

Harmful algal blooms (HABs) are a natural global phenomena emerging in severity and extent. Incidents have many economic, ecological and human health impacts. Monitoring and providing early warning of toxic HABs are critical for protecting public health. Current monitoring programmes include measuring the number of toxic phytoplankton cells in the water and biotoxin levels in shellfish tissue. As these efforts are demanding and labour intensive, methods which improve the efficiency are essential. This study compares the utilisation of a multitoxin surface plasmon resonance (multitoxin SPR) biosensor with enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) and analytical methods such as high performance liquid chromatography with fluorescence detection (HPLC-FLD) and liquid chromatography–tandem mass spectrometry (LC–MS/MS) for toxic HAB monitoring efforts in Europe. Seawater samples (n = 256) from European waters, collected 2009–2011, were analysed for biotoxins: saxitoxin and analogues, okadaic acid and dinophysistoxins 1/2 (DTX1/DTX2) and domoic acid responsible for paralytic shellfish poisoning (PSP), diarrheic shellfish poisoning (DSP) and amnesic shellfish poisoning (ASP), respectively. Biotoxins were detected mainly in samples from Spain and Ireland. France and Norway appeared to have the lowest number of toxic samples. Both the multitoxin SPR biosensor and the RNA microarray were more sensitive at detecting toxic HABs than standard light microscopy phytoplankton monitoring. Correlations between each of the detection methods were performed with the overall agreement, based on statistical 2 × 2 comparison tables, between each testing platform ranging between 32% and 74% for all three toxin families illustrating that one individual testing method may not be an ideal solution. An efficient early warning monitoring system for the detection of toxic HABs could therefore be achieved by combining both the multitoxin SPR biosensor and RNA microarray.     

Toxin profiles of natural populations and cultures ofAlexandrium minutum Halim from Galician (Spain) coastal waters

The toxin profiles of three isolates and natural populations of the PSP agentAlexandrium minutum from several Galician rías (NW Spain) was obtained by HPLC. The toxin content of cultures ofA. minutum is dominated by GTX4 (80–90%) and GTX4 (10–15%) with small amounts of GTX3 and GTX2 (less than 3% of each); similar results were obtained for natural populations ofAlexandrium from three different Galician rías, where a mixture ofA. lusitanicum Balech andA. minutum can occur. Important quantitative differences were found between the three isolates, one being highly and two weakly toxic. The results obtained from these isolates and natural populations ofAlexandrium were very similar to those obtained from HPLC analyses of mussels intoxicated during a PSP outbreak in Ría de Ares (Rías Altas) in 1984, confirming thatA. minutum (previously identified asGonyaulax tamarensis Lebour andAlexandrium lusitanicum) was the PSP agent during the toxic outbreak in May 1984. Toxin profiles obtained from natural populations during different PSP outbreaks in different rías and from cultures are fairly consistent and suggest that at least from the toxin point of view,A. lusitanicum andA. minutum are identical, and that the toxin profile ofA. minutum from Galicia can be used as a biochemical marker.     

Monoclonal antibody against the surface of Alexandrium minutum used in a whole-cell ELISA

Harmful algal blooms represent a major threat to marine production, and particularly to shellfish farming. Alexandrium minutum, which causes paralytic shellfish poisoning, is occurring with increasing frequency along European coasts. Current regulatory methods to analyze environmental samples are tedious and time consuming because they require taxonomists and involve animal experiments. New rapid detection methods, such as immunoassays, are needed to ensure a fast alert system and for field studies of algal ecodynamics. Rat monoclonal antibodies were raised and selected for their ability to specifically recognize a surface antigen for the A. minutum strain AM89BM from the Bay of Morlaix, France. A whole-cell ELISA was designed, leading to the selection of one AMI6 mAb that was selected for its performance in a large set of immunochemical formats. Moreover, AMI6 mAb displayed no detectable cross-reactivity with most algae found in similar biotopes, particularly those which might be mistaken during a conventional light microscope counting Heterocapsa triquetra, Scrippsiella trochoidea, Karenia mikimotoi, and two strains of Alexandrium tamarense, either toxic or not. Using colloidal gold conjugates on immunodecorated cells, we used electron microscopy to show that AMI6 mAb targets an exposed antigen at the surface of A. minutum. It was noted that this antibody could work with many preparations of A. minutum cells, i.e. fresh, frozen or dried cells. The detection limit in the whole-cell ELISA was found to be 10 cells per well. This assay displayed sensitivity and specificity when used for the analysis of natural seawater samples. A large set of immunochemical formats, using either AMI6 mAb or related antibodies from this series, could be further envisaged for designing environmental biosensors.     

Surface Plasmon Resonance Biosensor for Detection of Bacillus anthracis, the Causative Agent of Anthrax from Soil Samples Targeting Protective Antigen

Bacillus anthracis, the causative agent of anthrax is one of the most important biological warfare agents. In this study, surface plasmon resonance (SPR) technology was used for indirect detection of B. anthracis by detecting protective antigen (PA), a common toxin produced by all live B. anthracis bacteria. For development of biosensor, a monoclonal antibody raised against B. anthracis PA was immobilized on carboxymethyldextran modified gold chip and its interaction with PA was characterized in situ by SPR and electrochemical impedance spectroscopy. By using kinetic evaluation software, K_D (equilibrium constant) and B_max (maximum binding capacity of analyte) were found to be 20 fM and 18.74, respectively. The change in Gibb’s free energy (∆G = −78.04 kJ/mol) confirmed the spontaneous interaction between antigen and antibody. The assay could detect 12 fM purified PA. When anthrax spores spiked soil samples were enriched, PA produced in the sample containing even a single spore of B. anthracis could be detected by SPR. PA being produced only by the vegetative cells of B. anthracis, confirms indirectly the presence of B. anthracis in the samples. The proposed method can be a very useful tool for screening and confirmation of anthrax suspected environmental samples during a bio-warfare like situation.     

Development of a Real-Time PCR Assay for Rapid Detection and Quantification of Alexandrium minutum (a Dinoflagellate)

The marine dinoflagellate genus Alexandrium includes a number of species which produce neurotoxins responsible for paralytic shellfish poisoning (PSP), which in humans may cause muscular paralysis, neurological symptoms, and, in extreme cases, death. A. minutum is the most widespread toxic PSP species in the western Mediterranean basin. The monitoring of coastal waters for the presence of harmful algae also normally involves microscopic examinations of phytoplankton populations. These procedures are time consuming and require a great deal of taxonomic experience, thus limiting the number of specimens that can be analyzed. Because of the genetic diversity of different genera and species, molecular tools may also help to detect the presence of target microorganisms in marine field samples. In this study, we developed a real-time PCR-based assay for rapid detection of all toxic species of the Alexandrium genus in both fixative-preserved environmental samples and cultures. Moreover, we developed a real-time quantitative PCR assay for the quantification of A. minutum cells in seawater samples. Alexandrium genus-specific primers were designed on the 5.8S rDNA region. Primer specificity was confirmed by using BLAST and by amplification of a representative sample of the DNA of other dinoflagellates and diatoms. Using a standard curve constructed with a plasmid containing the ITS1-5.8S-ITS2 A. minutum sequence and cultured A. minutum cells, we determined the absolute number of 5.8S rDNA copies per cell. Consequently, after quantification of 5.8S rDNA copies in samples containing A. minutum cells, we were also able to estimate the number of cells. Several fixed A. minutum bloom sea samples from Arenys Harbor (Catalan Coast, Spain) were analyzed using this method, and quantification results were compared with standard microscopy counting methods. The two methods gave comparable results, confirming that real-time PCR could be a valid, fast alternative procedure for the detection and quantification of target phytoplankton species during coastal water monitoring.     

Characterization of Nontoxic and Toxin-Producing Strains of Alexandrium minutum (Dinophyceae) in Irish Coastal Waters

A comparative analysis of the morphology, toxin composition, and ribosomal DNA (rDNA) sequences was performed on a suite of clonal cultures of the potentially toxic dinoflagellate Alexandrium minutum Halim. These were established from resting cysts or vegetative cells isolated from sediment and water samples taken from the south and west coasts of Ireland. Results revealed that strains were indistinguishable, both morphologically and through the sequencing of the D1-D2 domain of the large subunit and the ITS1-5.8S-ITS2 regions of the rDNA. High-performance liquid chromatography fluorescence detection analysis, however, showed that only strains derived from retentive inlets on the southern Irish coast synthesized paralytic shellfish poisoning (PSP) toxins (GTX2 and GTX3), whereas all strains of A. minutum isolated from the west coast were nontoxic. Toxin analysis of net hauls, taken when A. minutum vegetative cells were in the water column, revealed no PSP toxins in samples from Killary Harbor (western coast), whereas GTX2 and GTX3 were detected in samples from Cork Harbor (southern coast). These results confirm the identity of A. minutum as the most probable causative organism for historical occurrences of contamination of shellfish with PSP toxins in Cork Harbor. Finally, random amplification of polymorphic DNA was carried out to determine the degree of polymorphism among strains. The analysis showed that all toxic strains from Cork Harbor clustered together and that a separate cluster grouped all nontoxic strains from the western coast.     

Harmful phytoplankton diversity and dynamics in an upwelling region (Sagres,SW Portugal) revealed by ribosomal RNA microarray combined with microscopy

The study region in Sagres, SW Portugal, is subject to natural eutrophication of coastal waters by wind-driven upwelling, which stimulates high primary productivity facilitating the recent economic expansion of bivalve aquaculture in the region. However, this economic activity is threatened by harmful algal blooms (HAB) caused by the diatoms Pseudo-nitzschia spp., Dinophysis spp. and other HAB dinoflagellates, all of which can produce toxins, that can induce Amnesic Shellfish Poisoning (ASP), Diarrhetic Shellfish Poisoning (DSP) and Paralytic Shellfish Poisoning (PSP). This study couples traditional microscopy with 18S/28S rRNA microarray to improve the detection of HAB species and investigates the relation between HAB and the specific oceanographic conditions in the region. Good agreement was obtained between microscopy and microarray data for diatoms of genus Pseudo-nitzschia and dinoflagellates Dinophysis spp., Gymnodinium catenatum and raphidophyte Heterosigma akashiwo, with less effective results for Prorocentrum. Microarray provided detection of flagellates Prymnesium spp., Pseudochattonella spp., Chloromorum toxicum and the important HAB dinoflagellates of the genera Alexandrium and Azadinium, with the latter being one of the first records from the study region. Seasonality and upwelling induced by northerly winds were found to be the driving forces of HAB development, with Pseudo-nitzschia spp. causing the risk of ASP during spring and summer upwelling season, and dinoflagellates causing the risk of DSP and PSP during upwelling relaxation, mainly in summer and autumn. The findings were in agreement with the results from toxicity monitoring of shellfish by the Portuguese Institute for Sea and Atmosphere and confirm the suitability of the RNA microarray method for HABs detection and aquaculture management applications.     

Toxin composition variations in cultures of Alexandrium species isolated from the coastal waters of southern China

The composition of the paralytic shellfish toxins (PSTs) of five Alexandrium tamarense strains isolated from the coastal waters of southern China and one Alexandrium minutum strain from Taiwan Island were investigated. A. tamarense CI01 and A. tamarense Dapeng predominantly produced C2 toxin (over 90%) with trace amounts of C1 toxin (C1), gonyautoxin-2 (GTX2) and GTX3; two strains of A. tamarense HK9301 maintained in different locations produced C1-4 toxins and GTX1, 4, 5 and 6; no PSTs were found in A. tamarense NEW, while A. minutum TW produced only GTX1-4. The toxin compositions of cultured A. tamarense strains did not vary as much during different growth phases as did the toxin composition of A. minutum TW. The toxin compositions of A. tamarense HK9301-1 did not change significantly under different salinity, light intensity, and nitrate and phosphate levels in the culture medium, although the toxin productivity varied expectably. Another strain HK9301-2 maintained in a different location produced much less toxins with a considerably different toxin composition. Under similar culture maintenance conditions for 3 years, the toxin profiles of A. tamarense HK9301-1 did not change as much as did A. tamarense CI01. Our results indicate that toxin compositions of the dinoflagellate strains are strain-specific and are subject to influence by nutritional and environmental conditions but not as much by the growth phase. Use of toxin composition in identifying a toxigenic strain requires special caution.     

Serum antibody screening by surface plasmon resonance using a natural glycan microarray

A surface plasmon resonance (SPR) based natural glycan microarray was developed for screening of interactions between glycans and carbohydrate-binding proteins (CBPs). The microarray contained 144 glycan samples and allowed the real-time and simultaneous screening for recognition by CBPs without the need of fluorescent labeling. Glycans were released from their natural source and coupled by reductive amination with the fluorescent labels 2-aminobenzamide (2AB) or anthranilic acid (AA) followed by high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) fractionation making use of the fluorescent tag. The released and labeled glycans, in addition to fluorescently labeled synthetic glycans and (neo)glycoproteins, were printed on an epoxide-activated chip at fmol amounts. This resulted in covalent immobilization, with the epoxide groups forming covalent bonds to the secondary amine groups present on the fluorescent glycoconjugates. The generated SPR glycan array presented a subset of the glycan repertoire of the human parasite Schistosoma mansoni. In order to demonstrate the usefulness of the array in the simultaneous detection of glycan-specific serum antibodies, the anti-glycan antibody profiles from sera of S. mansoni-infected individuals as well as from non-endemic uninfected controls were recorded. The SPR screening was sensitive for differences between infection sera and control sera, and revealed antibody titers and antibody classes (IgG or IgM). All SPR analyses were performed with a single SPR array chip, which required regeneration and blocking of the chip before the application of a serum sample. Our results indicate that SPR-based arrays constructed from glycans of natural or synthetic origin, pure or as mixture, can be used for determining serum antibody profiles as possible markers for the infection status of an individual.     

Microfluidic On-chip Capture-cycloaddition Reaction to Reversibly Immobilize Small Molecules or Multi-component Structures for Biosensor Applications

Methods for rapid surface immobilization of bioactive small molecules with control over orientation and immobilization density are highly desirable for biosensor and microarray applications. In this Study, we use a highly efficient covalent bioorthogonal [4+2] cycloaddition reaction between trans-cyclooctene (TCO) and 1,2,4,5-tetrazine (Tz) to enable the microfluidic immobilization of TCO/Tz-derivatized molecules. We monitor the process in real-time under continuous flow conditions using surface plasmon resonance (SPR). To enable reversible immobilization and extend the experimental range of the sensor surface, we combine a non-covalent antigen-antibody capture component with the cycloaddition reaction. By alternately presenting TCO or Tz moieties to the sensor surface, multiple capture-cycloaddition processes are now possible on one sensor surface for on-chip assembly and interaction studies of a variety of multi-component structures. We illustrate this method with two different immobilization experiments on a biosensor chip; a small molecule, AP1497 that binds FK506-binding protein 12 (FKBP12); and the same small molecule as part of an immobilized and in situ-functionalized nanoparticle.     

A review of the global distribution of Alexandrium minutum (Dinophyceae) and comments on ecology and associated paralytic shellfish toxin profiles,with a focus on Northern Europe

Alexandrium minutum is a globally distributed harmful algal bloom species with many strains that are known to produce paralytic shellfish toxins (PSTs) and consequently represent a concern to human and ecosystem health. This review highlights that A. minutum typically occurs in sheltered locations, with cell growth occurring during periods of stable water conditions. Sediment characteristics are important in the persistence of this species within a location, with fine sediments providing cyst deposits for ongoing inoculation to the water column. Toxic strains of A. minutum do not produce a consistent toxin profile, different populations produce a range of PSTs in differing quantities. Novel cluster analysis of published A. minutum toxin profiles indicates five PST profile clusters globally. Some clusters are grouped geographically (Northern Europe) while others are widely spread. Isolates from Taiwan have a range of toxin profile clusters and this area appears to have the most diverse set of PST producing A. minutum populations. These toxin profiles indicate that within the United Kingdom there are two populations of A. minutum grouping with strains from Northern France and Southern Ireland. There is a degree of interconnectivity in this region due to oceanic circulation and a high level of shipping and recreational boating. Further research into the interrelationships between the A. minutum populations in this global region would be of value.     

Improved screening of microcystin genes and toxins in blue-green algal dietary supplements with PCR and a surface plasmon resonance biosensor

Microcystins (MCs) comprise a group of cyclic heptapeptide toxins that share a common backbone and have two variable l-amino acids that yield at least 21 known analogs of varying potency. These hepatotoxins and potential tumor promoters are produced by certain cyanobacteria, including Microcystis aeruginosa. The cyanobacterium M. aeruginosa blooms in freshwater lakes and can potentially co-occur with other species such as Aphanizomenon flos-aquae, which is targeted and harvested for the production of dietary supplements known as blue-green algae (BGA). BGA supplements are currently marketed in the U.S. and internationally as a product that may elevate mood, increase energy, and alleviate attention deficit hyperactivity disorder. However, the potential for BGA dietary supplements to be contaminated with MCs is of concern, and there are currently no validated methods for detection of MCs in these products. This research focused on establishing screening methods for toxic Microcystis and MCs in BGA supplements. A DNA-based method employing polymerase chain reaction (PCR) was used as a prescreening tool to evaluate the dietary supplements and to detect the presence of toxin genes (i.e., presence of toxic Microcystis). A rapid, sensitive surface plasmon resonance (SPR) biosensor, directed towards recognition of all MC forms, was also developed and validated. This improved SPR biosensor incorporates a commercial Adda-group antibody (Ab) that has the capacity for broader recognition of MCs than previously developed sensors for BGA supplements that rely solely on an arginine-reactive Ab and can quantitate MC levels down to 0.24 ng/mL (equivalent to 0.24 μg per gram of BGA supplement) in less than 10 min. Such a rapid, quantitative screening method may allow for further surveillance of BGA products to assist risk assessment efforts, establishment of regulatory guidance levels, and response to potential consumer complaints related to BGA products. The PCR technique and SPR biosensor may be used in concert as prescreening and screening tools, respectively or individually, thereby limiting the number of samples that must be evaluated with confirmatory methods.     

Toxigenic algae and associated phycotoxins in two coastal embayments in the Ebro Delta (NW Mediterranean)

Harmful Algal Bloom (HAB) surveillance is complicated by high diversity of species and associated phycotoxins. Such species-level information on taxonomic affiliations and on cell abundance and toxin content is, however, crucial for effective monitoring, especially of aquaculture and fisheries areas. The aim addressed in this study was to determine putative HAB taxa and related phycotoxins in plankton from aquaculture sites in the Ebro Delta, NW Mediterranean. The comparative geographical distribution of potentially harmful plankton taxa was established by weekly field sampling throughout the water column during late spring–early summer over two years at key stations in Alfacs and Fangar embayments within the Ebro Delta. Core results included not only confirmed identification of HAB taxa that are common for the time period and geographical area, but also provided evidence of potentially new taxa. At least 25 HAB taxa were identified to species level, and an additional six genera were confirmed, by morphological criteria under light microscopy and/or by molecular genetics approaches involving qPCR and next generation DNA pyrosequencing. In particular, new insights were gained by the inclusion of molecular techniques, which focused attention on the HAB genera Alexandrium, Karlodinium, and Pseudo-nitzschia. Noteworthy is the discovery of Azadinium sp., a potentially new HAB species for this area, and Gymnodinium catenatum or Gymnodinium impudicum by means of light microscopy. In addition, significant amounts of the neurotoxin domoic acid (DA) were found for the first time in phytoplankton samples in the Ebro Delta. While the presence of the known DA-producing diatom genus Pseudo-nitzschia was confirmed in corresponding samples, the maximal toxin concentration did not coincide with highest cell abundances of the genus and the responsible species could not be identified. Combined findings of microscopic and molecular detection approaches underline the need for a synoptic strategy for HAB monitoring, which integrates the respective advantages and compensates for limitations of individual methods.     

Development of a qualitative PCR method for the Alexandrium spp. (Dinophyceae) detection in contaminated mussels (Mytilus galloprovincialis)

Paralytic shellfish poisoning (PSP) is a syndrome caused by the consumption of shellfish contaminated with neurotoxins produced by organisms of the marine dinoflagellate genus Alexandrium. A. minutum is the most widespread species responsible for PSP in the Western Mediterranean basin. The standard monitoring of shellfish farms for the presence of harmful algae and related toxins usually requires the microscopic examination of phytoplankton populations, bioassays and toxin determination by HPLC. These procedures are time-consuming and require remarkable experience, thus limiting the number of specimens that can be analyzed by a single laboratory unit. Molecular biology techniques may be helpful in the detection of target microorganisms in field samples. In this study, we developed a qualitative PCR assay for the rapid detection of all potentially toxic species belonging to the Alexandrium genus and specifically A. minutum, in contaminated mussels. Alexandrium genus-specific primers were designed to target the 5.8S rDNA region, while an A. minutum species-specific primer was designed to bind in the ITS1 region. The assay was validated using several fixed seawater samples from the Mediterranean basin, which were analyzed using PCR along with standard microscopy procedures. The assay provided a rapid method for monitoring the presence of Alexandrium spp. in mussel tissues, as well as in seawater samples. The results showed that PCR is a valid, rapid alternative procedure for the detection of target phytoplankton species either in seawater or directly in mussels, where microalgae can accumulate.     

Growth- and nutrient-dependent gene expression in the toxigenic marine dinoflagellate Alexandrium minutum

The toxigenic marine dinoflagellate Alexandrium minutum forms toxic blooms causing paralytic shellfish poisoning (PSP), primarily in coastal waters, throughout the world. We examined effects on physiology and gene expression patterns associated with growth and nutrient starvation in a toxic strain of A. minutum. Bloom-relevant factors, including growth rate, intracellular toxin content, allelochemical activity and nutrient status were investigated in A. minutum cultures grown under different environmental regimes. Allelochemical activity of A. minutum cultures, quantified with a cryptomonad Rhodomonas bioassay, increased with age but was independent of nutrient status.The phenotypic data were integrated and compared with gene expression in cell samples taken at selected points along the growth curve. We observed 489 genes consistently differentially expressed between exponentially growing and growth-limited cultures. The expression pattern of stationary-phase cultures was characterized by conspicuous down-regulation of translation-associated genes, up-regulation of sequences involved in intracellular signalling and some indications of increased activity of selfish genetic elements such as transposons. Treatment-specific patterns included five genes regulated in parallel in all nutrient-limited cultures. The conspicuous decrease in photosynthetic performance identified in N-starved cultures was paralleled by down-regulation of chloroplast-associated genes.The particular gene expression patterns we identified as specifically linked with exponential growth, cessation of growth or nutrient limitation may be suitable biomarkers for indicating the beginning of growth limitation in field- or mesocosm studies.     

A large molecular size fraction of riverine high molecular weight dissolved organic matter (HMW DOM) stimulates growth of the harmful dinoflagellate Alexandrium minutum

An increase in the concentration of riverine dissolved organic matter (DOM) has been observed during the last decades, and this material can stimulate marine plankton in coastal waters with significant freshwater input. We studied the effect of two size fractions of riverine high molecular weight dissolved organic matter (HMW DOM), isolated with tangential ultrafiltration, on the harmful dinoflagellate Alexandrium minutum and a natural isolate of marine bacteria under laboratory conditions. Both A. minutum and bacteria grew significantly better with the low MW DOM compared to both the high MW DOM fraction and controls (no DOM additions). This experiment demonstrates that the harmful algae A. minutum and bacteria benefit from larger molecules of river HMW DOM, and highlights the potential of A. minutum to utilize organic nitrogen from large DOM molecules. This ability may enhance their likelihood of success in estuaries/costal waters with a humic rich freshwater input, especially when the relative amount of large molecules within DOM is more pronounced.