Historical perspective on Karenia brevis red tide research in the Gulf of Mexico

Research on Karenia brevis blooms in the Gulf of Mexico started with the 1946–1947 red tide along the Florida west coast. Early research was on the organism itself, its tolerances and requirements, and the environment in which it lived and grew. Control of blooms, as a management option, was pursued in the 1950s with little success. However, in the 1960s–1970s, new regulation of shellfish growing areas was a public health management success. Research on K. brevis blooms followed funding cycles and was sporadic until the late 1990s when the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) and the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) funded the Ecology and Oceanography of Harmful Algal Blooms (ECOHAB) and NOAA Monitoring and Event Response of Harmful Algal Blooms (MERHAB) programs. These particular funding programs, augmented by State of Florida appropriations, provided the opportunity to study K. brevis blooms on different temporal-spatial scales and consequently advanced the science. This review looks at historical research results in the light of today's advances.     

Prevention and control of Karenia brevis blooms

With the recurrent and potentially severe impacts of Karenia brevis blooms in the Gulf of Mexico, new management approaches have been examined to potentially prevent and control these blooms. This paper summarizes past and present research and strategies for the prevention and control of K. brevis blooms. Prevention presumes a certain level of understanding about the cause or causes of these blooms. This may not yet be available, however, for K. brevis in the Gulf of Mexico. Some efforts to synthesize the current understanding of bloom dynamics for the region were recommended. The earliest attempts to control K. brevis blooms in the field used copper sulfate minerals seeded from ships and crop-dusting planes. Although effective for short term applications, the method was abandoned as it provided only temporary relief at a high cost with unknown collateral damage to the ecosystem. Results from chemical screenings and ozone treatments were also presented. Algicidal bacteria have shown some promise in controlling K. brevis in laboratory experiments, either through direct contact or release of algicidal compounds. Finally, the state of the research into the use of natural clays was presented, beginning with laboratory and mesocosm tests, to larger-scale experiments and flume studies. Several impacts studies were reviewed. While much progress has been made in examining control methods in recent years, more research in the field is needed to fully evaluate the efficacy and impacts of these strategies. Furthermore, the social and human dimensions of this potentially controversial area of research may have to be explored more fully to gauge the receptiveness of the public to these management approaches.     

Monitoring,management, and mitigation of Karenia blooms in the eastern Gulf of Mexico

Annual blooms of the toxic dinoflagellate Karenia brevis in the eastern Gulf of Mexico represent one of the most predictable global harmful algal bloom (HAB) events, yet remain amongst the most difficult HABs to effectively monitor for human and environmental health. Monitoring of Karenia blooms is necessary for a variety of precautionary, management and predictive purposes. These include the protection of public health from exposure to aerosolized brevetoxins and the consumption of toxic shellfish, the protection and management of environmental resources, the prevention of bloom associated economic losses, and the evaluation of long term ecosystem trends and for potential future bloom forecasting and prediction purposes. The multipurpose nature of Karenia monitoring, the large areas over which blooms occur, the large range of Karenia cell concentrations (from 5 × 10³ cells L^?1 to >1 × 10⁶ cells L^?1) over which multiple bloom impacts are possible, and limitations in resources and knowledge of bloom ecology have complicated K. brevis monitoring, mitigation and management strategies. Historically, K. brevis blooms were informally and intermittently monitored on an event response basis in Florida, usually in the later bloom stages after impacts (e.g. fish kills, marine mammal mortalities, respiratory irritation) were noted and when resources were available. Monitoring of different K. brevis bloom stages remains the most practical method for predicting human health impacts and is currently accomplished by the state of Florida via direct microscopic counts of water samples from a state coordinated volunteer HAB monitoring program. K. brevis cell concentrations are mapped weekly and disseminated to stakeholders via e-mail, web and toll-free phone numbers and provided to Florida Department of Agriculture and Consumer Services (FDACS) for management of both recreational and commercial shellfish beds in Florida and to the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) for validation of the NOAA Gulf of Mexico HAB bulletin for provision to environmental managers. Many challenges remain for effective monitoring and management of Karenia blooms, however, including incorporating impact specific monitoring for the diverse array of potential human and environmental impacts associated with blooms, timely detection of offshore bloom initiation, sampling of the large geographic extent of blooms which often covers multiple state boundaries, and the involvement of multiple Karenia species other than K. brevis (several of which have yet to be isolated and described) with unknown toxin profiles. The implementation and integration of a diverse array of optical, molecular and hybrid Karenia detection technologies currently under development into appropriate regulatory and non-regulatory monitoring formats represents a further unique challenge.     

Vertical migration of Karenia brevis in the northeastern Gulf of Mexico observed from glider measurements

The toxic marine dinoflagellate, Karenia brevis (the species responsible for most of red tides or harmful algal blooms in the Gulf of Mexico), is known to be able to swim vertically to adapt to the light and nutrient environments, nearly all such observations have been made through controlled experiments using cultures. Here, using continuous 3-dimensional measurements by an ocean glider across a K. brevis bloom in the northeastern Gulf of Mexico between 1 and 8 August 2014, we show the vertical migration behavior of K. brevis. Within the bloom where K. brevis concentration is between 100,000 and 1,000,000 cells L⁻¹, the stratified water shows a two-layer system with the depth of pycnocline ranging between 14–20 m and salinity and temperature in the surface layer being <34.8 and >28 °C, respectively. The bottom layer shows the salinity of >36 and temperature of <26 °C. The low salinity is apparently due to coastal runoff, as the top layer also shows high amount of colored dissolved organic matter (CDOM). Within the top layer, chlorophyll-a fluorescence shows clear diel changes in the vertical structure, an indication of K. brevis vertical migration at a mean speed of 0.5–1 m h⁻¹. The upward migration appears to start at sunrise at a depth of 8–10 m, while the downward migration appears to start at sunset (or when surface light approaches 0) at a depth of ∼2 m. These vertical migrations are believed to be a result of the need of K. brevis cells for light and nutrients in a stable, stratified, and CDOM-rich environment.     

Zooplankton community composition and copepod grazing on the West Florida Shelf in relation to blooms of Karenia brevis

Blooms of the toxin producing dinoflagellate Karenia brevis occur routinely on the West Florida Shelf of the Gulf of Mexico. Nutrient supplies are thought to play a large role in the formation and maintenance of these blooms. The role of top-down control has been less well studied, but grazing, or the lack thereof, on these toxic species may also enhance the formation of large biomass blooms in this region. Zooplankton community structure and copepod species composition were analyzed from samples collected on the West Florida Shelf (WFS) during a NOAA funded ECOHAB regional Karenia Nutrient Dynamics project during October 2007–2010. In 2008 there was no statistical difference in the abundance of zooplankton at bloom and non-bloom stations, however in 2009 there was a statistically significant difference (p < 0.05) between the abundance of zooplankton at stations with Karenia present. To investigate copepod ingestion rates in relation to K. brevis, shipboard and laboratory experiments of the single label method of ¹⁴C labeled phytoplankton culture, and time course ingestion experiments with isolated copepods were performed. Calculated ingestion rates suggest that the copepod species Centropages velificatus, and Acartia tonsa ingested K. brevis, however rates were variable among collection sites and K. brevis strains. Parvocalanus crassirostris did not ingest K. brevis in any of the experiments.     

No difference found in ribosomal DNA sequences from physiologically diverse clones of Karenia brevis (Dinophyceae) from the Gulf of Mexico

Maximum growth rate and toxin content were significantly differentamong five strains of Karenia brevis isolated from Texas andFlorida when grown under identical culture conditions. Sequenceanalysis of the 18S rRNA gene and internal transcribed spacer(ITS) regions revealed, however, that all five strains wereidentical. Consequently, a clear genetic basis for physiologicalvariability among various geographical isolates of K. brevisfrom the Gulf of Mexico could not be assessed using these geneticmarkers. Both the ITS and 18S rRNA regions may be useful inspecies-specific probe selection. At the intra-specific level,however, an alternative marker will be needed to assess thediversity among K. brevis populations in the Gulf of Mexico.     

Detection of Karenia brevis blooms on the west Florida shelf using in situ backscattering and fluorescence data

Using shipboard data collected from the central west Florida shelf (WFS) between 2000 and 2001, an optical classification algorithm was developed to differentiate toxic Karenia brevis blooms (>10⁴ cells l⁻¹) from other waters (including non-blooms and blooms of other phytoplankton species). The identification of K. brevis blooms is based on two criteria: (1) chlorophyll a concentration ≥1.5 mg m⁻³ and (2) chlorophyll-specific particulate backscattering at 550 nm ≤ 0.0045 m² mg⁻¹. The classification criteria yielded an overall accuracy of 99% in identifying both K. brevis blooms and other waters from 194 cruise stations. The algorithm was validated using an independent dataset collected from both the central and south WFS between 2005 and 2006. After excluding data from estuarine and post-hurricane turbid waters, an overall accuracy of 94% was achieved with 86% of all K. brevis bloom data points identified successfully. Satisfactory algorithm performance (88% overall accuracy) was also achieved when using underway chlorophyll fluorescence and backscattering data collected during a repeated alongshore transect between Tampa Bay and Florida Bay in 2005 and 2006. These results suggest that it may be possible to use presently available, commercial optical backscattering instrumentation on autonomous platforms (e.g. moorings, gliders, and AUVs) for rapid and timely detection and monitoring of K. brevis blooms on the WFS.     

Elevated nutrient inputs to marshes differentially impact carbon and nitrogen cycling in two northern Gulf of Mexico saltmarsh plants

Peatlands have accumulated vast quantities of organic carbon over thousands of years but it is unclear how these sensitive ecosystems will respond to future climate change. If emissions of methane from peatlands increase, then they may contribute increasingly towards climatic warming due to the higher greenhouse warming potential of this gas. We investigated the radiocarbon concentration of methane emissions from a temperate bog over 1.5 years, which we supported with measurements of the surface flux of methane and carbon dioxide. The radiocarbon content of methane emissions varied greatly, from modern (i.e. fixed from the atmosphere within recent decades) to ~ 1400 years BP. Flux rates of methane were spatially and temporally highly variable. A vegetation clipping experiment showed that plants had a great influence on the carbon isotope composition and flux of methane emitted from the peat surface, consistent with earlier studies showing the key role of plants in peatland methane emissions. When plants were absent, emission rates were 70–94% lower and the radiocarbon age of methane emissions was much younger and less variable. Our radiocarbon measurements show that at this peatland, plant-associated methane emissions contain carbon originally fixed from the atmosphere up to hundreds of years earlier, consistent with a contribution from plant mediated transport of methane sourced from sub-surface layers.

     

Localization of polyketide synthase encoding genes to the toxic dinoflagellate Karenia brevis

Karenia brevis is a toxic marine dinoflagellate endemic to the Gulf of Mexico. Blooms of this harmful alga cause fish kills, marine mammal mortalities and neurotoxic shellfish poisonings. These harmful effects are attributed to a suite of polyketide secondary metabolites known as the brevetoxins. The carbon framework of all polyketides is assembled by a polyketide synthase (PKS). Previously, PKS encoding genes were amplified from K. brevis culture and their similarity to a PKS gene from the closely related protist, Cryptosporidium parvum, suggested that these genes originate from the dinoflagellate. However, K. brevis has not been grown axenically. The associated bacteria might be the source of the toxins or the PKS genes. Herein we report the localization of PKS encoding genes by a combination of flow cytometry/PCR and fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH). Two genes localized exclusively to K. brevis cells while a third localized to both K. brevis and associated bacteria. While these genes have not yet been linked to toxin production, the work describes the first definitive evidence of resident PKS genes in any dinoflagellate.     

Nitrogen uptake and regeneration (ammonium regeneration,nitrification and photoproduction) in waters of the West Florida Shelf prone to blooms of Karenia brevis

The West Florida Shelf (WFS) encompasses a range of environments from inshore estuarine to offshore oligotrophic waters, which are frequently the site of large and persistent blooms of the toxic dinoflagellate, Karenia brevis. The goals of this study were to characterize the nitrogen (N) nutrition of plankton across the range of environmental conditions on the WFS, to quantify the percentage of the plankton N demand met through in situ N regeneration, and to determine whether planktonic N nutrition changes when high concentrations of Karenia are present. In the fall of 2007, 2008, and 2009 we measured ambient nutrient concentrations and used stable isotope techniques to measure rates of primary production and uptake rates of inorganic N (ammonium, NH₄⁺, and nitrate, NO₃⁻), and organic N and carbon (C; urea and amino acids, AA) in estuarine, coastal, and offshore waters, as well as coastal sites with Karenia blooms present. In parallel, we also measured rates of in situ N regeneration – NH₄⁺ regeneration, nitrification, and photoproduction of NH₄⁺, nitrite and AA. Based on microscope observations, ancillary measurements, and previous monitoring history, Karenia blooms sampled represented three bloom stages – initiation in 2008, maintenance in 2007, and late maintenance/stationary phase in 2009. Nutrient concentrations were highest at estuarine sampling sites and lowest at offshore sites. Uptake of NH₄⁺ and NO₃⁻ provided the largest contribution to N nutrition at all sites. At the non-Karenia sites, in situ rates of NH₄⁺ regeneration and nitrification were generally sufficient to supply these substrates equal to the rates at which they were taken up. At Karenia sites, NO₃⁻ was the most important N substrate during the initiation phase, while NH₄⁺ was the most important N form used during bloom maintenance and stationary phases. Rates of NH₄⁺ regeneration were high but insufficient (85 ± 36% of uptake) to support the measured NH₄⁺ uptake at all the Karenia sites although nitrification rates far exceeded uptake rates of NO₃⁻. Taken together our results support the “no smoking gun” nutrient hypothesis that there is no single nutrient source or strategy that can explain Karenia's frequent dominance in the waters where it occurs. Consistent with other papers in this volume, our results indicate that Karenia can utilize an array of inorganic and organic N forms from a number of N sources.     

Satellite remote sensing of harmful algal blooms: A new multi-algorithm method for detecting the Florida Red Tide (Karenia brevis)

In a continuing effort to develop suitable methods for the surveillance of Harmful Algal Blooms (HABs) of Karenia brevis using satellite radiometers, a new multi-algorithm method was developed to explore whether improvements in the remote sensing detection of the Florida Red Tide was possible. A Hybrid Scheme was introduced that sequentially applies the optimized versions of two pre-existing satellite-based algorithms: an Empirical Approach (using water-leaving radiance as a function of chlorophyll concentration) and a Bio-optical Technique (using particulate backscatter along with chlorophyll concentration). The long-term evaluation of the new multi-algorithm method was performed using a multi-year MODIS dataset (2002 to 2006; during the boreal Summer-Fall periods - July to December) along the Central West Florida Shelf between 25.75°N and 28.25°N. Algorithm validation was done with in situ measurements of the abundances of K. brevis; cell counts ≥1.5×10(4) cells l(-1) defined a detectable HAB. Encouraging statistical results were derived when either or both algorithms correctly flagged known samples. The majority of the valid match-ups were correctly identified (~80% of both HABs and non-blooming conditions) and few false negatives or false positives were produced (~20% of each). Additionally, most of the HAB-positive identifications in the satellite data were indeed HAB samples (positive predictive value: ~70%) and those classified as HAB-negative were almost all non-bloom cases (negative predictive value: ~86%). These results demonstrate an excellent detection capability, on average ~10% more accurate than the individual algorithms used separately. Thus, the new Hybrid Scheme could become a powerful tool for environmental monitoring of K. brevis blooms, with valuable consequences including leading to the more rapid and efficient use of ships to make in situ measurements of HABs.     

Long-term increase in Karenia brevis abundance along the Southwest Florida Coast

Data collected along the southwest coast of Florida between Tampa Bay and Sanibel Island on the abundance of the toxic dinoflagellate Karenia brevis from 1954 to 2002 were examined for spatial and temporal patterns. K. brevis was found to be approximately 20-fold more abundant within 5 km of the shoreline than 20–30 km offshore. Overall, K. brevis was approximately 13–18-fold more abundant in 1994–2002 than in 1954–1963. In 1954–1963, K. brevis occurred primarily in the fall months. In 1994–2002, it was more abundant not only in the fall, but also in the winter and spring months. It is hypothesized that greater nutrient availability in the ecosystem is the most likely cause of this increase in K. brevis biomass, and the large increase in the human population and its activities in South Florida over the past half century is a major factor.     

Microsatellite DNA markers for population genetic studies in the dinoflagellate Karenia brevis

Nine nuclear‐encoded microsatellites from an enriched genomic DNA library of the HAB (harmful algal bloom) dinoflagellate Karenia brevis were isolated and characterized. The microsatellites include five perfect (three dinucleotide and two trinucleotide) and four imperfect (two dinucleotide and two trinucleotide) repeat motifs. Gene (haplotype) diversity ranged from 0.153 to 0.750 among a sample of 13 isolates; the number of alleles among the isolates ranged from two to six and pairwise tests of genotypic disequilibria were nonsignificant. The microsatellites developed in this study will provide insight into the genetic diversity of this HAB species and tools that may prove useful in predicting source populations and physiological parameters of individual K. brevis blooms.     

Monitoring of the toxic dinoflagellate Karenia brevis using gyroxanthin-based detection methods

The threat to human health and fisheries resources due to blooms of the toxic dinoflagellate Karenia brevis has lead to widespread public concern and calls for continuous monitoring of coastal waters for this organism. Here, a rapid and sensitive photopigment-based monitoring approach is described that incorporates refinements to standard filtration and analytical methods. This method uses the biomarker pigment gyroxanthin-diester contained in cells of some gymnodiniod species including K. brevis. Investigations of the retention efficiencies of five filter types for gyroxanthin from natural blooms of K. brevis showed no significant differences between GF/F, GF/C, 934-AH, GF/A or GF/D filters. Retention efficiencies were generally greater than 98% of cells added, indicating that the larger nominal pore size filters may be used safely for sample collection, reducing overall filtration times for large volumes of water. Simulated bloom experiments using cultures of K. brevis added to unfiltered water from Galveston Bay showed that retention of gyroxanthin on GF/D filters was significantly lower than on other filter types. There were significant interactions (p < 0.01) between filter type and cell density for the variables gyroxanthin, gyroxanthin chl a^–1 and gyroxanthin cell^–1, suggesting that the performance of the different filter types was dependent on cell density. Retention efficiencies for the simulated blooms ranged between >99% of cells retained and <30% of cells retained (greatest losses were for the GF/D filters). Combined results of natural and simulated blooms indicated that GF/C, 934-AH or GF/A filters gave the best retention efficiency with the fastest filtration times. Sample processing times were also improved by modifying the flow gradients in an existing HPLC protocol allowing the analysis of 106 samples in 24 h. The resulting protocol is suitable for incorporation into routine water quality monitoring programs, and would greatly facilitate the early detection and tracking of K. brevis blooms in coastal waters.     

Economic analysis as a basis for large-scale nitrogen control decisions: reducing nitrogen loads to the Gulf of Mexico

Economic analysis can be a guide to determining the level of actions taken to reduce nitrogen (N) losses and reduce environmental risk in a cost-effective manner while also allowing consideration of relative costs of controls to various groups. The biophysical science of N control, especially from nonpoint sources such as agriculture, is not certain. Widespread precise data do not exist for a river basin (or often even for a watershed) that couples management practices and other actions to reduce nonpoint N losses with specific delivery from the basin. The causal relationships are clouded by other factors influencing N flows, such as weather, temperature, and soil characteristics. Even when the science is certain, economic analysis has its own sets of uncertainties and simplifying economic assumptions. The economic analysis of the National Hypoxia Assessment provides an example of economic analysis based on less than complete scientific information that can still provide guidance to policy makers about the economic consequences of alternative approaches. One critical value to policy makers comes from bounding the economic magnitude of the consequences of alternative actions. Another value is the identification of impacts outside the sphere of initial concerns. Such analysis can successfully assess relative impacts of different degrees of control of N losses within the basin as well as outside the basin. It can demonstrate the extent to which costs of control of any one action increase with the intensity of application of control.     

Assessing the impact of shellfish harvesting area closures on neurotoxic shellfish poisoning (NSP) incidence during red tide (Karenia brevis) blooms

Neurotoxic shellfish poisoning (NSP) is caused by the consumption of molluscan shellfish meat contaminated with brevetoxins produced by the dinoflagellate, Karenia brevis (K. brevis). During a prolonged and intermittent K. brevis bloom starting in 2005 lasting through early 2007 in the Gulf of Mexico off southwest Florida coast, there were 24 confirmed cases of NSP linked to the consumption of clams recreationally harvested in, or in close proximity to, regulated shellfish harvesting areas; these shellfish beds had already been officially closed to harvesting due to the presence of the K. brevis bloom. The majority of NSP cases (78%) were in “visitors,” either non-Florida residents or Florida residents living outside the county of harvest. The number of confirmed NSP cases was likely an underestimate of the actual number of cases.Current management strategy appears to be effective in limiting the number of NSP cases associated with shellfish harvested commercially during red tide events. In contrast, public notification that shellfish beds are closed to harvest, due to red tides or pathogens, is not reaching all recreational shellfish harvesters and consumers, particularly visitors from outside the county or state. The constantly changing closure status of shellfish harvesting areas in combination with overlooked notifications may lead to an apparent disregard of harvesting restrictions. It is important, therefore, to provide the general public, including visitors and those with language barriers, with improved access to up-to-date information concerning the daily openings and closings of shellfish harvesting areas. Furthermore, the risks of consuming potentially toxic shellfish should be disseminated more broadly.     

Sublethal effects of the toxic dinoflagellate Karenia brevis on marine copepod behavior

Apart from grazing interactions, little is known regarding thesublethal effects of Karenia brevis cells on copepod behavior.We conducted grazing and mortality experiments with K. breviscells and brevetoxins (PbTx-2), establishing routes of toxicityfor the copepods Acartia tonsa, Temora turbinata and Centropagestypicus. Subsequent behavioral experiments determined whethercopepod swimming and photobehavior, both behaviors involvedin predator avoidance, were impaired at sublethal K. brevisand PbTx-2 levels. Copepods variably grazed toxic K. brevisand non-toxic Prorocentrum minimum at bloom concentrations.Although copepods accumulated brevetoxins, significant mortalitywas only observed in T. turbinata at the highest test concentration(1 x 10⁷ K. brevis cells L^–1). Acartia tonsa exhibitedminimal sublethal behavioral effects. However, there were significanteffects on the swimming and photobehavior of T. turbinata andC. typicus at the lowest sublethal concentrations tested (0.15µg PbTx-2 L^–1, 1 x 10⁵ K. brevis cells L^–1).Although physiological incapacitation may have altered copepodbehavior, starvation likely played a major role as well. Thesedata suggest that sublethal effects of K. brevis and brevetoxinon copepod behavior occur and predicting the role of zooplanktongrazers in trophic transfer of algal toxins requires knowledgeof species-specific sublethal effects.     

Chimeric plastid proteome in the Florida "red tide" dinoflagellate Karenia brevis

Current understanding of the plastid proteome comes almost exclusively from studies of plants and red algae. The proteome in these taxa has a relatively simple origin via integration of proteins from a single cyanobacterial primary endosymbiont and the host. However, the most successful algae in marine environments are the chlorophyll c-containing chromalveolates such as diatoms and dinoflagellates that contain a plastid of red algal origin derived via secondary or tertiary endosymbiosis. Virtually nothing is known about the plastid proteome in these taxa. We analyzed expressed sequence tag data from the toxic "Florida red tide" dinoflagellate Karenia brevis that has undergone a tertiary plastid endosymbiosis. Comparative analyses identified 30 nuclear-encoded plastid-targeted proteins in this chromalveolate that originated via endosymbiotic or horizontal gene transfer (HGT) from multiple different sources. We identify a fundamental divide between plant/red algal and chromalveolate plastid proteomes that reflects a history of mixotrophy in the latter group resulting in a highly chimeric proteome. Loss of phagocytosis in the "red" and "green" clades effectively froze their proteomes, whereas chromalveolate lineages retain the ability to engulf prey allowing them to continually recruit new, potentially adaptive genes through subsequent endosymbioses and HGT. One of these genes is an electron transfer protein (plastocyanin) of green algal origin in K. brevis that likely allows this species to thrive under conditions of iron depletion.